First reaction to BTS - Butter at Global Citizen Live 2021
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- BTS is a global phenomenon, yet this is my first time watching them perform. I wanted to react to their new song with Coldplay, but then I figured I'd rather make my first time all about BTS. So here it is, my first reaction to BTS performing Butter at Global Citizen Live 2021.
Watch to see what I think. Spoiler alert: Army, I get you!
By the way. When I checked out the BTS Wikipedia page, I learned that they're also known as the Bangtan Boys. I thought that they used the acronym for Behind The Scenes, but it stands for the Korean expression "Bangtan Sonyeondan", meaning "bulletproof boy scouts". BTS was formed in 2010, and then debuted in 2013. They are 7 members, and their names are: Jin, Suga, J-Hope, RM, Jimin, V and Jungkook.
Here's the link to the full performance: • BTS Performs 'Butter' ...
And here's some info about Global Citizen Live 2021 from their own TH-cam channel: "Global Citizen Live calls for action to halt climate change and for wealthy countries to deliver on the $100B climate pledge.." Read more in the video description in the link above.
Hope you enjoy :)
Xx Hege
---
I use a VPN for protecting my information online, and love that it also allows me to browse other countries' selections on streaming platforms. Get NordVPN here: go.nordvpn.net...
This is an affiliate link and I may make a commission if you purchase NordVPN's services, however, the price for you is the same, so we both win.
---
DISCLAIMER: I do not own the rights to the song Butter by BTS, nor to the performance shown in the video. This is simply a fan reaction for entertainment and educational purposes, covering a recent performance of Butter by BTS. No copyright infringement is intended. To my understanding the use of copyrighted material in this video falls under "Fair Use":
"Under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship and research."
#hegeofficial #btsbutter
--------------------
For covers by me: • Cover songs by Hege
Check out my original music on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NsEhAu
And come say hi on Instagram: bit.ly/2uA1VEt
or on my Facebook Page: / hegepop
I am also on BuyMeACoffee if you'd like to support me further - www.buymeacoff...
They are not just performers. They are producers, songwriters, composers. They all have experience in writing music. 3 rappers are credited almost in all their songs as songwriters. And one of them (SUGA) works as producer with other artists, including western ones such as Halsey and Coldplay
You can watch their Tiny Desk performance to clearly see their live vocals
I love that! ☺️ Thank you for the info, and for watching. Appreciate it!
@@HegeOfficial SUGAS Coldplay song is premering tonight
@@HegeOfficial their cover of "I'll be missing you" on the BBC 1 live lounge is also good :)
@@HegeOfficial suga also got a call from Samsung to remake "Over the Horizon"
@@HegeOfficial I want you to listen their Korean songs like paradise, tomorrow, love myself, epiphany, mikrokosmos, blue and grey, etc and read the lyrics..pls💜💜🙏
BTS always sings live. We know this because sometimes their voice cracks, they make mistakes. And they even abruptly stop singing randomly, to prove that they sing live. Even when they are dancing while singing, you can hear their voices shake slightly( they've been trained for years to sing and dance intensely at the same time). The mics are sensitive enough to hear their clothing move and their feet stomp( in more intense performances of course). Sometimes, members are ill, and they compensate by letting other vocalists support them and they admit it to their audience.
Butter is easy for them choreography-wise. BTS is known to do flips and other acrobatics, performances are very energetic and fluid.
here before editing was my wrong text about BTS and lip syncing.
@@RasaAkstiniene
They do however sing live in the pre-recordings. They don't just dance to a voice track.
I KNOW that I've posted here a text about lip syncing which was based on wrong knowledge. Because a person who was in the shows told me below in the comments that in pre-recorded versions in KBS BTS sing live, all I have to do is to accept I was wrong about KBS shows (that made me glad not gonna lie)
@@RasaAkstiniene
I mean that they obviously can't broadcast real time performances to all over the world. Yes, they have a backing track but they do sing live on top of it. In PTD I did notice for example an unused mic (V) at one point but the volume of the backing track was audibly lower in comparison.
@@imajinallthepurple It varies and we've recently seen that they do several takes for their recent "live" performances and that they are edited. Like their Jimmy Fallon, Grammy's and so on. It's all live, yet with several takes and editing. On stage it's live, but during their online concerts it was both. For example in some of the Dimple performances from 5th muster you can see both Jimin and Tae lip syncing which means the two others probably also did. The only thing this shows is that the public has become too used to pitch perfect performances. Fortunately they do still sing live during concerts as you could hear all the guy being a bit off at times during this weekends concert.
Their tiny desk performance is a great place to hear them live, or BTS festa 2021 medley live room.
personally bts medley fest live and their mtv unplugged or a full concert live is a better option. cuz tiny desk had a bit of autotune. still they always make sure to do it all live.
@@jamais_vu3 I agreee, I never really liked it when people would suggest the tiny desk for their first live performance. I just think that there's better lives
@@edwardsdreams Same! Their festa performance is so much better!
@@Laya-Rose yeahh or even just their concerts
If you're confused as to why it 'sounded live' it's because it is. They don't lipsync. In fact, they're horrible at it. They do sometimes have a backingtrack as it can be hard to constantly sing and dance but they have been trained to do it. I mean they're musicians and performers. It's their job to be good at it. Glad you enjoyed it hope to see more reactions from you :)
I find it kinda amusing how bad they actually are at lipsyncing.
@@atinybangtan they are actually not bad at lipsyncing. they have not one and not two pre-recorded performances and it is NORMAL. but as well they can sing live, they do it at their concerts at least always ;)
They’ve lypsynced on Korean music shows before but very rarely. This one one was live through she just seems very confused. She talked about them training to be picked “to go up to the sky” and I have no idea what she meant by that either.
@@marigam to succeed and be the highest level of talent and abilities to perform. The sky has no limit.
Most people will get very mad in comments about them definitely singing live, because it's hard to believe how great they are doing it. But I think there is something important to understand before accusing people who are giving it a doubt about live vocals: even when singing live, there is always a backing track and the difference between backing track recorded vocals and live vocals change in every live performance.
When I became ARMY I was also a bit confused, how do they sing so well while dancing, but after a few months of listening to their album recordings and then live performances my ears started picking up what is live and what isn't. Even being a musician myself I took some time until I could really recognize where there is a track playing in live performances and where are their live voices, because in the after production everything is blended very nicely. Now I can clearly hear all the live vocals and I can assure that they sing all the main melodies and even some adlips live. Only instrumental and some harmonies are always left for the backing track.
During the songs that have an extremely difficult choreography (like ON or Fire, Butter is pretty easy compared to those), they might turn up the main recorded melodies too up to 30-50%, but they still always sing on top of it, never lip sync. Some concerts, TV shows or award shows actually have their requirements of how much they can rely on the backing track and how much the mics are on, but they're always always on. It also helps knowing the original track really well, so when it's live, my ears instantly pick up little differences, especially in rap parts or during challenging choreo parts where we can hear a slight trembling of the voice or necklaces jingling near the mic :)
Their live performances on MTV Unplugged are very very toned down, I think you'd really like them! My favorite is Blue&Grey, their original song from the album BE 💜
Not to mention, most are not good at lip syncing. Especially RM. They do this and sound good live. She needs to see the official Butter mv to see what it sounds like in a studio recording. She can also watch all the live songs on the awards shows to see they can do this all live
No I totally agree. I have seen newer kpop groups use a backing track in a low volume to support their live singing. And that is totally fine since they are new and have a long way to go. Bts has reached to a level of perfection that they don’t need any track at this point. And when they use it , it’s pretty easy to tell like in Jimin’s serendipity chorus since it was absolutely impossible to sing with those dance moves.
I am really skeptical it was a pre recorded performance, however, if you want to want to listen more, you could watch the 2021 BTS festa room live :-) It's a fast paced medley of some of their hits and b-sides released through the years :-)
just read the description and I already like you just for googling bts and finding out some basic info and their names! most people are always like "I don't know where they're from, their names or what BTS stands for, tell me in the comments" so thanks :)
they always do sing live but they have a backtrack for the parts where the dance moves wouldn't allow good enough breath control. if you like dancing, I'd love to see your reaction to "ON", "Black Swan" or "Blood, Sweat & Tears" :)
Thank you so much for that ☺️ Most people don’t read the description, so I appreciate you reading.
And that makes all the sense in the world that they’d use stems for the more physically challenging parts, I wish more people would understand and accept that with these big productions.
It’s a great band, and I can’t wait to check out more of their performances and musicianship in general.
Thank you so much for the recommendations ☺️✨
@@HegeOfficial thank YOU for actually doing some research and taking them serious instead of doing cheap "kpop" or "boyband" jokes. I'm sure since you're a musician yourself it comes with the territory but it's just really nice to see such a genuine and open person like you :)
I think a lot of people (and that includes some army) don't know the difference between a backtrack and 100% playback and so feelings can get hurt by misunderstanding :)
looking forward to you discovering more of their music and artistry :D
@@lela1002 Can you explain the difference?
@@amberpearce710 playback is when you let the recording play and you just lipsync to it, so no live singing involved at all. a backtrack is mostly a reduced version of the recording (so not every line is on there but some select ones or some adlibs/harmonies) that's played as a support for the singer's live vocals (with bts it's also at a lower volume so you can hear pretty easily which part is sung live and which part comes from the track) 😄
@@HegeOfficial always read the lyrics it is important in bts songs... especially their Korean songs...
If you dive deeper into bts you'll be an army once you know them well about their history, personalities, music, etc.
Watch An introduction to 7 members of bangtan by Ida s
The dance sequence in the bridge/instrumental part blew me away. Watched it over and over while editing!
I'd love to see BTS live!
Their LA 4-nights concert at SOFI stadium (80,000 capacity stadium) sold out before they even went on sale.
I assure you that what you watched is a tip of iceberg. You should check out other performances as well!!
“ON - Live on Jimmy Fallon”
“Black Swan , IDOL, Butter - Live Jimmy Fallon show
And much more!!
Check out their Music Videos (on TH-cam): 1.Blood Sweat and Tear
2. DNA
3. Fake Love
4. ON
5. Black Swan
You can start from these and eventually you will find yourself becoming an ARMY lol 😆
Oh one more thing - Make sure you turn on English Subtitles when you watch their MVs - when you read their lyrics you will appreciate them even more 😊
If you want to know about bts please watch An introduction to 7 members of bangtan by Ida s
This is bts introduction by x Celeste
The most beautiful life goes on story of bts by Asian theory (2021)
Always read the lyrics if you listen their Korean songs or when you watch their mv always turn on cc
Hobi killed that just wait till you see 3J unit of BTS dancing to Megan Stallion rap on their Butter collab
In fact, one of even the things that makes me upset about people is that they say that they are "bad singers" or they "suck at singing", when they do not take consideration that they are literally jumping, panting, doing this vigorous dancing, while singing this good! Usually, artists when they do "sing and dance at the same time", only dance during the dance breaks and then stop dancing to sing or vice versa, but they are literally doing exactly.
I'm a professional casting and talent person and I have never heard that they suck at singing.
@@smartgirlsmartgirl6555 thank you for saying that cause it reminds us twitter is not the whole world. Other groups’ or acts’ fans always act like BTS can’t hold a note on that app. these men are so talented and anyone with unbiased views would have no problems admitting it
I don't think some people realize the intense dance and vocal training these KPOP bands do. It's pretty unlikely that anyone would have a bad voice or they wouldn't have been picked to train and debut. Sure, there are some stragglers out there that aren't the best but mostly they are all above par. There are some idols that train for years before they debut.
Actually unlike most high profile artists, they're known for being able to do complex choreography and not letting it interfere with vocals and sound just as good live, often you can hear breathing and know it's live
If you listen to several of the performances of Butter you can clearly tell they are singing live. The variation is obvious.
In fact they are singing live, you can hear the boom when they pronounce a word that begins with p or that has a p, you hear their breaths, which is clearly a sign that they recorded the video singing live, logically it is pre-recorded because they could not go to the event and sing it right there for reasons of the situation we are in and because of their agendas, however, in fact they can sing and dance their songs live, for the same reason that they train for years for it and well they do not say that the practice makes perfect?
It can be seen a lot that they are singing live, BTS have always said that they do not want to deceive their audience for the same reason that they never do playback, and if they sing on a track that has some pre-recorded parts because in that part of the song the dance is too strong, they don't open their mouths, they let the track play to make us understand that the playback would never be used that way.
Jin himself for his presentation of Epiphany said that he learned the first part of the song on piano because he wanted to sing it with a live piano and he had been told that he could pretend that he played, but he said that he did not want to fool ARMY (fandom name) , so he learned to play the first part of the song on piano.
I just wanted to clarify that detail.
I laughed so hard when you were like "wait, why does it sound live?" lol!!
WELCOME!!! I was just strolling through TH-cam one night and I land on a video from an Award show called MAMA 2016 Live FIRE performance by BTS. Sucked me right in because they are ending a performance where it looks like someone is going the have their blood sucked. Later, I learned that performance was Blood, Sweat & Tears. Fire oh aye oh! It was like the earth was opening up as BTS rose through the floor ablazed with FIRE all around them. So, I watched...about a dozen times!!!! I couldn't get over how talented they were. I've been apart of Fandoms before but nothing like this fandom. There is real substance in this fandom. I was the same way as you, the minute I found out about ARMY, I wanted to join. Where do I join? How do I join? I fell head first down the rabbit hole and I Love every part of being a part of the fandom. I love everything about BTS. I love that they are extremely NORMAL guys but they are the biggest goofballs on the planet too. There is so much I wish I could just tell you. But my biggest Wish for you, is that you ENJOY your journey! Subscribed LAST FYI: There is a video by xceleste' called; This is BTS ARMY.
They never lipsyncing because they are bad at it. So when you see a live performance is really live, they are singing live, ok? And react to more Bts, especially live performances
don't repeat rumours :)) kbs performances for example require to be pre-recorded. and they are good at that. that doesn't mean they never sing live. they do. at their concerts for example. with such performances as this one, sometimes it is live, sometimes not. when it is live, you can hear 'p' letter explosive sound into the mic. If it doesn't exist, it is pre-recorded, with a barrier between your mouth and mic. as well, if the mics are not held in hand and members are dancing and it is live, you'll notice how they try to touch them to put them in better place to sound better. when it is not live, they just do not pay attention to mic position, sometimes it wents to the nose and they just do not care about it :)
in general, you can notice when it is live in older bts performances from Jin - there was time when he couldn't control his breathing very well. if you want to spot not live performance, watch jimin, he often takes the mic from his mouth too early :)
but it is not a big deal if they are live at particular performance or not. they proved plenty of times they are great live ;) so they can allow themselves to do pre-recorded performances too.
but this particular one I believe is 'live' performance ;) I can hear 'p' explosive sound and breathing into the mics.
This is live singing, and dancing. You can hear them being breathy towards the end and you can hear them breathing, and the popping sound in the mic. Yes, they do use backing tracks at least some of the time, but you can hear their vocals over it. They train for years to be able to do a live show, if they couldn't sing and dance live, they would not be promoted, or even be signed. BTS has worked their butts off to get where they are. They started from nothing and have reached the top. 💜
Thank you for reacting to bts, I hope you will react to more bts 💜
Oh they can sing live and dance at the same time. JK (who starts the song of) has perfect pitch and a other vocal coach said he had his own automatic auto tuning. But also the other guys are on pitch and this was live, we as army (bts fans) hear the difference . It can be that they did several takes and the sound is from on of them, but this is definitely live but bc of inmic autotuning and maybe a bit of post production it sound like this. If you look up bangtantv you can get several behind the scenes videos
Exactly!
You know having perfect pitch has little to do with singing on pitch? Singing is about how you use your vocal cords and plenty with perfect pitch can't sing well at all. For him it's just an added bonus which makes him able to for example start singing songs acapella in the right pitch. Perfect pitch doesn't automatically give you perfect control over your singing. That's a different sort of talent he's got. That's also why you can hear that Jungkook also sometimes is off pitch because that's a very common thing.
i love how you give off positive energy as a reactor :) i recommend you check out bts room live, they did a medley of some of their old songs to newer ones . thank you for checking them out :)
Thank you so much for the recommendation, and for your lovely comment ❤️ I really appreciate it
To be honest, none of the English songs of BTS does justice to their talent. I think the fact that they are new to this English Pop side, the songs and beats are more on the classic side.
I would suggest you to watch their Korean songs. They cover a lot of genres. You could watch BLACK SWAN, MIC DROP, LIFE GOES ON, FIRE, ON, SPRING DAY, DOPE, I NEED YOU, FILM OUT to get different vibe from them.
Also about controversies about auto tune and pre-recorded things, they do sing all of their songs live BUT they pre record some of the adlibs or maybe some specific lines that they want to specifically highlight. This sometimes cause confusion among people who didn't watch much of their live performance about whether or not they are singing live.
Also, BTS's songs don't get copyright strike as long as you show the Intro where it says BIGHIT ENTERTAINMENT or now BIGHIT MUSIC. And remember to turn on the Caption while watching their videos if available.
Much respect for not going into this with an inbuilt prejudice. Hoping for more amazing BTS-related content from you.
Second this.
Agree
I'm sooooo excited for their new album that they are releasing this year...
It's gonna be fire🔥
I totally agree, but god. Butter is so good. 😩
I'm sure you'll soon realize that it's a completely different league, unfairly reductive to compare BTS to n'sync. First of all what boy bands have rappers, who even dance while rapping. And, members of BTS write and produce the music. Also the level of complex choreography, and singing impeccably while dancing. Also there is no weak link in BTS, and, none of the "one member is the star" and inside competition for attention. BTS are truly inspirational for their many service-oriented leadership qualities
Wow, same thoughts here... Back in the days, I grew up fangirling with NSYNC and the BACKSTREET BOYS, and came to love them also... But watching BTS now, I personally couldn't compare them to those boybands... BTS is way way up higher... Their performance level is above and beyond greatness... Such amazing performers... I mean where can u find, dancing rappers??? And vocalists who had such amazing voices and at the same time dances to those complex choreographies, and still delivers stable vocals... That's BTS only.... Nothing compares to them... And add to the fact that they write and produce their songs, that is exceptional talent I must say...💜💜💜
Thankyou for your reaction towards our boys, can't wait to see you to get to know them more bcs their music is so wide like literally every genre you can find on their songs so keep going!!💜
Thank you so much! I really really enjoy what I’ve seen and heard so far, can’t wait to explore more ☺️❤️
Thank you for this nice reaction!! I hope you can watch other live performances of BTS to see how talented they are vocally and how amazing their songs and dance are! I'd suggest their Tiny Desk Concert (with subtitles because their lyrics are really beautiful) 💜
Also I think you might have underestimated how much of that was live but it's understandable for a first time tbh. Of course as hardcore fans (we're called A.R.M.Y!) we know the song by heart and have watched and listened to countless performances of it, as well as knowing their voices very well, and we can hear how much of it they are singing live by the way they breathe and the amount of air they use and the way their consonnants sound, but then again we might be a bit obsessed lol
Thank you so much for your kind comment :)
Yeah, I think I also could have been way more clear in the video on what I actually meant was live or not, but it was all in the moment and I got messy. I’ll do better in future videos ☺️
Would LOVE to react to some of their songs on Tiny Desk, I adore that whole concept.
Thanks again! 💜
@@HegeOfficial Don't worry about it, we can recognise a genuine reaction when we see one, and we don't mind honest and warranted questions ^^
Tbh army can be a little bit over-protective over bts sometimes: the west is only starting to know them now and everything seems sudden, but you wouldn't believe the shit they've been through over 8 years to get here. So certain questions and words kind of trigger that defenciveness, but don't be discouraged and stay honest, we understand what you mean 💜
I don't know if I understood the term "stems" but if you meant backing vocals, I can't really tell. But what I've noticed by watching their performances is that they use backing vocals but not as loud as their live voices. The backing vocals are used to harmonized with their own voices live. Or maybe to help them breathe at some point due to singing and dancing at the same time (but you can still hear them live and differentiate the backing vocals from their live vocals). Maybe you'd love to check their *Medley Concert Live* at Tokyo Dome or any other Medley is cool. I am not professional so I don't really know anything but I've heard from other reactors that some performances are heavily produced before uploading to TH-cam (not sure what they meant) but I can tell that the Medley Concert is LIVE live so you can feel like you were there.
Love your reaction! You gotta listen to BTS Festa 2021 Medley and their Tiny Desk performance. I have never heard anything like them. I just recently discovered BTS because of their recent English music releases. I had no idea. Enjoy the journey! 😉
They often upload behind the scenes videos of how they work with these special "live but not direct" performances. They make a few takes, recording the audio each time. Depending on the performance, they just make the whole song each time, or some do it by parts, when it has scenography changes (like this one). Then they use one complete take if they're satisfied or use one as the base and complement with the rest. But the audio is always "live" even if they mix and match. They use backing vocals if the song has lines with effects on it that can't be achieved live (some can) but they don't lipsync to it, just let the audio go. You can see an example on this song (around 2:24 in your video) , when Jin says "I melt your heart into" and the audio goes on with "two". Some of the "group vocals" and part of the adlibs on some songs are on the backing vocals (I'm guessing it's what you call stems?) too, as well as additional voices (mostly female voices) but most of it is live too.
female voices????
@@Adziakowa choruses/background voices by Adora, or the ones in ON?
With all the peace and love in the world:
A lot of y’all seem to be confused about what I’m saying about singing live vs. pre-recording, and I definitely was very short and messy about this in the video, so I want to clarify.
First of all - I never mean anything bad by pointing out production tools. I even say so in the video that stems are a smart choice when they’re doing physically challenging performances where singing and dancing might not be compatible.
Keep in mind that I’d never heard the original, so telling me that «you can cLeArLy hear the difference sdkdkdk» doesn’t really help.
Also, I’m talking about the group parts, not the main vocals. I wasn’t clear about that. Having 7 voices totally in pitch on each harmonic line while dancing would be challenging. Not impossible, but challenging, in a live setting if the fact is that they had one take only.
Besides, it’s totally possible to use pre-recorded versions, even of the main vocal, that differ from the studio version. Often these are mixed in a more «live-sounding way» including booms from breaths etc. A lot of artists do this, and I’m not even saying I know that’s what BTS is doing, again, this is a first reaction not an analysis.
Pre-recs can still be performed and recorded in a live setting, just not in the very moment you see on the screen. This would allow performing several takes live and using the best one, or even adding stems to the performance before publishing. So yeah.
Again, no malicious intent behind my words. All love and respect for BTS and their craft.
Hey :) I saw some of the comments and just wanted to say that obviously not all army are knowledgeable about music production & performance techniques etc (myself included) but since bts have been accused of lipsyncing a lot by Western media and people I think some of us are just very protective about hearing any kind of "accusation" in that direction and as I mentioned in my original comment I think that can just lead to misunderstandings. I don't really know what stems are either, maybe you could explain that in your next reaction? During Covid when they couldn't travel bts have done a lot of pre-recorded live shows actually (for example the BTS week on Jimmy Fallon in 2020) since the performances are broadcasted live in the US during the show and that would be like the middle of the night for them in Korea and in the behind the scenes videos we can see that they did exactly as you mentioned: they performed it live and then chose the best take to send in. I think I've actually heard this has become quite a popular method during the pandemic since a lot of performances couldn't be LIVE live.
Thank you for explaining, Lela :) It's totally understandable that fans are protective. I've also seen the other side of the internet - negative people who just label anyone and any performance "fake" or "autotuned" just because they don't like it. They create this.
I'll d my best to be as clear as possible in my videos, and maybe even make videos around vocal- and music production vocabulary to clarify.
Stems are just fragments of a recorded musical piece - it can be the drums or other instruments, backing vocals, main vocals etc. In this case I was talking about backing vocals. So stems are often used to some extent (vocal or instrumental) in live productions. They can also be used by DJs and producers to make remixes of songs etc :).
Generally, I wish people would start seeing music production and vocal processing as what they are - tools to get the sound they want :) And that processed vocals doesn't necessarily mean tuned, and that tuned isn't necessarily bad either. haha. Ok, I really need to make a video :D.
Anyway, thanks again
@@HegeOfficial yes excactly! and since they're Asian you can imagine in which direction a lot of ugly comments on the internet go...or we as fans are all labeled hysteric teenage girls who only like bts because they're "pretty boys" since obviously they couldn't have any talent or sing live because they're not ugly and can dance? 🙄😂
but I totally get that we can be overwhelming in number and I hope the comments didn't discourage you. Because I've watched some vocal coaches react to bts I knew what you were saying but it would be awesome if you made videos like that! I think most army would really like a vocabulary breakdown or even an analysis video :)
ahh cool! thanks for letting me know, I knew about backing tracks and vocals but didn't know there was kind of an umbrella term for any kind of recorded support so to say. after you get more familiar with their voices you can easily hear (in my opinion) what's them and what's backing vocals. e.g. the second time they sing "I'll melt your heart into two" (3:57) the "two" is on the backing track whereas the part before it is live vocals.
please do! :D I think the problem is the perception of those techniques in the public. because we mostly get told production/tuning etc = cheating = that person can't sing.
Thank you, you too! 💜
Keep your BTS reactions coming! They like to prove during performances they are singing live especially Suga! I live in small town Wisconsin became an ARMY years ago! I'm almost 50 and my favorite song of all time is in Korean " Mikrokosmos ". Keep going on your journey they will change your life💜
Their room live also amazing...i like your reaction...
Just so you know I have been a BTS fan for 3 years and I haven’t ever seen them do anything fully lip synced. BTS usually have the whole thing live. Keep watching them though, because they are soooooooo much fun. Borahae💜💜😁
Oh my gosh!!! I’m so excited to watch you go on this journey!! I have so many song recommendations, they have so many different sounds and genres!!
❤️❤️ can’t wait! Thank you so much for watching, and bring on the recommendations please ☺️
@@HegeOfficial personally for me, I really recommend listening to their discography in order, from their first album to their latest, it really provides so much insight and it just flows magically
Thanks for your reaction, really enjoyed! Like that you looked up some things on your own. BTS are really good whn it comes to stable live vocals, although there may some backing track for fuller sound. If you're curious, would love to see your reaction to more lives. There's Tiny Desk Home Concert, BTS Room live, Pied Piper/Dimple 5th muster, Magic Shop Live
So glad you enjoyed it ☺️ thank you so much for watching! And for your recommendations ❤️ I’m really looking forward to check out their Tiny Desk concert.
Girl they literally practice their singing while running on the treadmill, their vocals are strong af, they are not a typical artificial american boyband
I'm laughing at the confusion about BTS singing live 😂 Please continue to react to BTS and maybe some of the behind the scenes or concert performances and I am sure you'll be able to distinguish their live vocals from prerecorded 😀💕 I'd recommend watching the Permission to Dance at the UNGA performance video and thereafter the 'bangtan bomb' for the same performance, which is like a behind the scenes at the UN on their official TH-cam, BangtanTV. Don't worry about copyright strikes with BangtanTV content.
Generally, they def use BG tracks to make their voice fuller when performing intense choreo to allow them to take a breath. They also use effects on their mics, depending on the song and performance. But they always sing live for the whole song. There was no really intense choreo here tho, speaking in comparison to some previous songs like Idol or DNA... So not really a big need to rely on other means.
Anyway, hope you're not feeling overwhelmed by army being so protective over our boys. It comes from people downplaying their actual talent and hard work for so long. Please don't take it personal. Thank you for the awesome reaction and for looking up our fandom name! I hope to see more BTS content in your channel, pretty please! 💜
Thank you so much for this :)
@@HegeOfficial I am sorry to hear that. Especially since this is really an unnecessary argument to have in the first place. Hope you give them another shot, their music and talents are so diverse and their message and passion for their fans is so wholesome. I think this is a case of some Armys getting triggered based on bad experiences of reactors who are just listening to BTS for clout. I am 100% sure that's not the case and I personally would love to see you explore/ get to know BTS better.
Not sure if you have a favourite music genre or style of song you like..? I'd like to recommend something you'd really enjoy?
There are some personal favourites below:
Blood Sweat and Tears
Save Me
Best of me
(they have 'kinda' edm vibes but still very different songs. Best of me needs to be seen as a live performance, there is no music video since its a b-side song)
Airplane pt 2
(think latin but pop)
Answer : love myself
Zero o'clock (00:00) (vocal line only =no rap)
(for when you need that pickup)
If you like rap:
Outro: tear
Mic Drop
Ugh
If you just want to hear the vocals of the vocal line members:
There is 'The Truth Untold' ... This live performance is just leaving me speechless every time.
Anyway, those are just some personal favourites and of cos there are just so many BTS songs that you probably can't react to them all anyway. Either way, I'll look out for more BTS reactions 💜 have a good day
You seem really sweet!! Please keep reacting to bts I feel like you’d really like them :))
Thank you so much ☺️ and I feel like you’re totally right about me liking them.
All live, even while dancing. 💜💜💜
They were singing live here,if you clearly observe, you ll be able to hear them breathing. But yes with a low volume backing vocals to help them breathe in between those heavy moves and support their voice to be more effectively heard. There are many live performances of BTS available on youtube. When you watch those you will get to know that they actually sing live. Also they r not just performers. They also compose, produce,rap and sing while dancing. Not to forget they write their own music.
It is not pre recorded. They are not like Nsync at all they are a new generation of group and other groups should strive to that level of performance.
Hello! Based on what I know they always sing live, but they mix it very well and I believe it helps them esp when there are intricate dance moves or jumps and whatnot. I enjoyed your reaction. Can't wait for more!
i feel like bts have had pre recorded performances before but i don't think any of their recent performances are pre recorded, this one sounds pretty much live but with a bit of vocal processing on their mics and backtrack vocals
Really loved your reaction❤️❤️.... Also I believe some of them might have told you but since I didn't see any so I decided to comment..... BTS doesn't copyright as long as you show their label/intro that says bighit entertainment they have it in the start of every MV ..... Hope it helps 😁
You are so sweet ❤️ Thank you for the kind comment and copyright help! I really appreciate it. Have a beautiful day/evening/night depending on where you are :)
@@HegeOfficial you are welcome..... And thank you I'll have a nice day ☺️☺️ you also have a nice day/ night/ evening 😘😘
By the way you talked about the pre-record performances and mentioning NSYNC, I think I can tell there's differences as what means pre-record a performance in korean and in north america, It can be a cultural difference (sorry I don't know about north america but I know really well the korean way). What BTS do when they are filming this pre-recorded performances is that they dance and sing live multiple times and then they choose the best one (they have a lot of free behind the scenes of their performances so we know how they work)
Thanks for reacting to BTS! 💜 BTS always sing live on their performance except music video of course that’s why is sooo impressive! Honestly their moral song that they wrote and produced are all beautiful and meaningful are honestly way better than their English song but that’s just my opinion! ☺️ hope you can give them a chance and check out more their song 💜
I’d love to check out their songs in Korean too! ❤️ :) Hope they have subtitles. Thank you so much for watching, and for your kind comment
@@HegeOfficial they do have english subtitle! I swear love their Korean song so much more ( not that I dont like their english song) coz they wrote it them self and are more meaningful to me
Thanks for reacting to Butter. This is their second all English song that took them to Grammy. The first one was Dynamite. They are singing live. Butter just like dynamite and Permission to Dance is just a very easy choreography for BTS. They are trained to sing and dance at the same time. They don't lipsync. They use backing track when they perform live with difficult choreography but they still sing live. They won't be the biggest boy group in the world if they lipsync with just an easy choreography. LOL!
6:29 Well, it’s because it’s live xD. That was kinda funny. 🤣🤣
It’s a pre-recorded live performance. They did few takes of the same performance singing live, and then the production team used the best parts in the video. I am able to say that because they upload the behind the scenes of their performances in their BANGTANTV channel.
Thank you so much for reacting to them. You will be amazed by the versatility of the guys. 💜
They were all singing live but they was also background vocals but they were singing live while dancing
BTS was originally a Korean hip hop group. Since 2013 they have evolved into a unique genre of their own. These are all the BTS “official” music videos in reverse order of release. Does not include live or other versions.
2021-07-09 Permission To Dance
2021-05-21 Butter
2021-04-01 Film Out
2020-11-19 Life Goes On
2020-09-01 Ioniq: I'm On It
2020-08-21 Dynamite
2020-06-26 Stay Gold
2020-03-05 Black Swan
2020-02-28 ON
2020-02-21 ON (Kinetic Manifesto Film: Come Prima)
2020-01-17 Black Swan
2019-10-18 Make It Right (feat Lauv)
2019-07-02 Lights
2019-04-12 Boy With Luv feat. Halsey
2018-08-24 Idol
2018-05-18 Fake Love
2017-12-13 With Seoul
2017-11-24 Mic Drop (Steve Aoki Remix)
2017-09-18 DNA
2017-07-04 Come Back Home
2017-02-20 Not Today
2017-02-13 Spring Day
2016-10-09 Blood Sweat & Tears
2016-05-15 Save ME
2016-05-01 FIRE
2016-04-19 EPILOGUE: Young Forever
2015-11-29 Run
2015-05-23 DOPE
2015-04-29 I NEED U
2014-10-21 War of Hormone
2014-08-19 Danger
2014-04-06 Just One Day
2014-02-11 Boy In Luv
2013-07-16 We Are Bulletproof Pt2
2013-07-10 N.O
2013-06-00 No More Dream
There are often several versions of the Official" music video.
The "Ioniq: I'm On It" is a promotional song for Hyundai. But you barely notice the car because the mv & song are so good; similar style as "Film Out"
"Come Back Home" was released on July 4, 2017 as remake of Seo Taiji’s song "Come Back Home" for Seo Taiji 25th Anniversary Remake Project.
“With Seoul” is a BTS song and film highlighting Seoul as a vacation spot. The original also shows them recording it. They have also done 3 other versions, including a “short” on 2020-09-11; a beautiful drone visual of Seoul (The Four Seasons of Seoul” on 2019-12-30, & an amazing drone visual mv on 2021-01-09.
My personal favorite "other version" video is "DANGER (Mo-Blue-Mix) , featuring THANH". Thanh is an Australian-Vietnamese singer. This song has a R&B vibe with some great lyrics added by Thanh.
There are loads of their other songs including some of my favorites: “Dionysus”, “Ma City”, “Truth Untold”, ”Outro: Tear”, “House of Cards”, “Lost”, “Dimple”, “Butterfly”, etc. and their solo, rapline, vocal line, short films, comeback trailers, etc. not included.
the 3 all english songs Bts did Butter, Permission To Dance and Dynamite, this song was from bts to us Armys to cheer us up during pandemic. All off this 3 songs all went in to Billboard 100 as nr 1. right now the have 6 nr 1 and 5 nr 1 Albums at Billboard 200
Hey... Just wanted to let u know that they sing everything live.... They dance and sing at the same time.... It's so tough to believe tho but u can notice it by watching their live concerts....
Oh and bts are always live, they just use backing tracks because they have to sing and dance at the same time and some parts are hard so the backing track helps for us listeners not to hear anything when it's their turn to sing. But it's all live
I think it's bcuz you're not familiar with their voices that you were confused abt the live singing. They do use backing tracks ( don't know if it is what you called stems) and sing over this track but once you become familiar with their voices it is really easy to understand which part is the track and which part they are singing.
They sing live with a backtrack. They trained to sing on treadmills so that their voice isn’t shaky. Welcome to the Army
I loved this reaction, thank you so much for taking time to do some research
Bts write and produces there own music and their popular for there message l they talk about self love, bullying, depression, social economic problems, and more. There amazing and have saved millions of lifes and are really important in South Korea, the government have huge respect for them for a lot of reasons and the president knows that, they represent the country. Pls know that "beyond the seen" and more then what people see. Bts stands for "BangTan Soyeondan which means " bulletproof boys scouts in english.
Yes,, they are good people with good music 💜🇮🇩
You just described idol music as a whole. Nothing wrong with that. People that know the industry are usually surprised how different BTS to most (not all) of them is. There is a reason why (2019?) they once made more money than the rest of the idol industry together. They are big big. Which is why they even break Western records.
The comparison with Michael Jackson or the Beatles in some aspects is right and wrong in a lot of others. They are BTS.
Butter is easy for a reason. The biggest problem is with the English language but choreography and sound is simple... especially for them. They have dance practice videos that show some of the choreographys when you don't find live versions. A lot of their videos are very different even for Idol music. This was made for Army and pandemic struggles (it is also a light diss song) and possible because they were waiting for some decissions from others they can do nothing about. It is simple fun.
But BTS does not have a "usual" sound. They are 7 young men with different talents who each manage to shine in their own way. They have recently been made ambassadors for SK. If you are interested XCeleste has made a view introduction videos like "This is BTS" and "This is Army".
If you like it more academic bby gang mag may be to your taste. If you have lots of time "The Rise of Bangtan" is probably the best documentary out there. We also watch reactions of those but no pressure: You enjoy what you enjoy (and if you want we will explain or find you an explanation... there are some good Korean explanations for the stuff that may get lost in translation: RM is literally a genius)
You nice! Keep going! 💜
Please be careful to keep the right perspective about Michael Jackson. They are inspired by, and pay homage to Michael Jackson, not vice versa. Black culture and black artists are the originators of so much global music. Even if BTS may go on to break many more records, "the Michael Jackson's" of history need to be recognized for being originators.
@@Lovmyself I look at my formulation and can't see were I wrote That MJ was inspired by BTS. Because that would be very very wrong. I'm not sure how you read that out of that one sentence. I'm sorry that it may have come like that from a certain viewpoint.
I'm well aware that pretty much *all* *new* *music* *genres* were at *first* developed by *Black* artists. There are no ifs and buts about that fact. Have a nice day! 💜
@@ruthfischer7615 I guess my reaction was because of the words making sure to say in some instances "comparison to" Michael Jackson is wrong, as if could be a bad thing. When, anytime anyone could be compared to Michael Jackson as a performer, is the highest praise possible, especially given the status of certain performers, like MJ as originators, even of dance moves etc. So the dialogue that I was needing to point out is that comparison between an originator and the person they inspire AS IF EQUALS is not flattering to the originator, in this way, and more likely that is what should be clarified.
@@ruthfischer7615 pt2, my reaction also bc the mention of BTS breaking records of Michael Jackson and the Beatles is a common news-bite, yet the mention of those two also seems, to me, to diminish because again, as if the Beatles are on par with Michael Jackson. What can never be quantified is the contribution of those that created things, not just record sales. Even if the Beatles were incredible songwriters and perhaps raised the bar for songwriting at that time and if they may have ushered in a new sound
@@Lovmyself Now you are dimishing the Beatles... the viewpoint is important... for music history both are maybe equally important... maybe...
For *black* history only MJ is. (and I really hope that those A* that lie about him will stop from doing so)
I'm not an US American or a Korean. I can (and will) see everything from a different viewpoint than you (different history).
But if you think of "worth" with whatever color you apply the truth is BTS is also up there (they are not white, their language is mainly Korean and they are all about the message):
They are still widely ignored. Numbers is almost everything we can do so they will be heard instead of being pushed aside and belittled (the "White Paper Project" exists for a reason) . That aside the music industry of SK and the USA are obsessed with numbers. It is almost everything they see and you are right that that is very sad.
My point was that Michael Jackson is Michael Jackson and nothing can change that (he earned his place in history the hard way) but BTS is also BTS and no one else. The comparison shouldn't even be made and is made of ignorance for both. (They are not on the news at all in my country but because of Army's call against a certain radio moderator... who says he is now writing a book about it. I hate that my country still has so much to learn about the topic that they don't see how wrong he is and foreign media/artists were/are not on his side) (Sorry for rambling)
Thank you for reading and answering. 💜
Lovely reaction ❤️
Thank you
Couldn't stop myself commenting when you said its pre-recorded. Their vocal prowess and ability to dance at the same time is legendary, just watch them continously do that in their 3 hr concert live. BTS is bad at lipsynching, just watch their MV's, RM cant even do his lines right even if his life depends on it, they are bad at it. NPR, room live, mtv unplugged, bbc radio, please watch and see why they are the best band in the world. And please know, their mics is always ON.
beautiful gal, nice reaction. the more you react to BTS, the more viewers will gradually and eventually come.
They can sing and dance at the same time, their voices aren't pre-recorded. The performance might have been pre-recorded, but their voices were live, not lip-synced. They might have a backing track to add to the performance, but part of K-Pop is they have to be able to sing and dance live at the same time. Especially, because when they release a new single, and they have a come back, there is always a comeback stage with a live performance. It's looked down upon to lip sink in South Korea, and it's required of K-Pop IDOLS to sing and dance live. They can be released from their contract for lip-syncing. Please, don't compare them to Western Standards. They do many exercises, and dance practices to be able to perform (dance and sing).
You should check out their live concert performances. They sing amazing! Thank you for checking BTS. 💜💜
Es una actuación pregrabada pero con las voces en directo,puedes oír su respiración y las voces suenan diferente que en la grabación original.
BTS’ live vocals are imo better than their studio recordings.
It is live. they literally do not lip sync ever at any point in any performance. not one time.
I loved your reaction. I didn't really understand what you meant about whether or not they're singing live, but after reading what you wrote in the comment section, I think I understand better now. Honestly though, when I started with them I actually couldn't believe they sing live sometimes, because it sounded too good, but then I heard them just randomly singing behind the scenes or doing karaoke of random songs in their livestreams and I just gave up trying to determine anything 😂. I also don't really know much about music production though, so you might be a lot more succesfull 😂.
As you probably already know, BTS has 7 members.... they are a very close "family" and totally genuine.
The group has 3 rappers (RM, J-hope, & SUGA {aka Agust D} and 4 vocalists (Jungkook, Jin, V, & Jimin). The best way to get absorb each member's style is to dive into their solos, as well as the Rapline & Vocal line performances. Here are some suggestions. While some have MV'S, some are even better live (be sure to find ones that have subtitles cc's)
RM : Change ft. WALE mv ; Joke ; Seoul
J-HOPE : Airplane mv ; Outro:Ego mv ; Chicken Noodle Soup mv
Suga : Agust D self-titled mv ; Daechwita mv ; Interlude:Shadow mv
RAPLINE : Outro:Tear live at Wembley ; Ddaeng live w/ eng sub ; DDaeng live w/ end sub
Jungkook : Euphoria live ; My Time live D2 on BTS LIVE 2; Begin live
Jin : Epiphany live ; AWAKE live ; Moon live
V : Singularity mv ; Stigma live ; Inner Child live
Jimin : Serendipity live stage mix ; LIE live stage mix ; FILTER live
Vocal Line: The Truth Unknown live ; House of Cards live ; Lost Live stage mix ; Dimple live stage mix
Just for fun check out their "Ma City" live when they all just broke loose and also have the band GHOST backing them up onstage. One of my personal favorite live performances.
First, I am not a native speaker, sorry in advance if I sound "rude", I don't mean that way. Second, I just want to share with you, didn't mean to say you are wrong or what, I think you are right instead.
It's interesting to see people talk about this. In (part of) Asia kpop fandom, we talk a lot about pre-recording things. There are MR (mean only instrument no vocal at all), live AR (they will keep part of the song in the backtrack, usually it's harmony part or parts that they feel hard to sing while dancing), AR (basically the whole song that you hear in Spotify), when "pre-record" mean for the soundtrack, it means singer will record the song in the studio with breathing or record when dancing/jumping a little and make it sound LIVE, and they lip-sync during the performance, and if "pre-record" is used for the video, it means like it's not LIVE (it's a VOD).
Kpop has a really mature system doing all these soundtrack things, it's really hard to tell if the performance is real LIVE or not (I am not saying bts didn't sing live, just kpop in general, and there are still a lot of groups singing live,) the most scientific way to find out is to pull out all the soundtrack of every performance of the song, and you compare all of them and see if they are the same (or partially same), just like playing puzzle.
Please watch a live performance. It’s never shaky. They are live at this venue,
You are so nice! :-) But BTS also write, produce most of their songs :-) I am not so sure it is prerecorded XD
I just learned, and I love that ☺️ looking forward to see more of their performances and musicianship beyond BTS as well. Thank you so much for watching!
they don't lipsync tho, they are singing live they've danced to a very hard choreography and still be singing stably live. sometimes their voices cracks cuz obviously it's hard to dance and sing at the same time but most of the time they perform extremely stable that ppl often think they're lipsyncing or whatnot so there are times where bts stopped singing and you wont hear anyone singin their part to prove that they're performing live they also have these behind the scene footage from them. thank you for reacting and giving them love.
BTS have just three English songs Dynamite, Butter and Permission to dance. Other 245 songs are in Korean. Three rapper RM, Suga aka Agust D and Jhope are great songwriter, producer. from J-ARMY 🇯🇵
They were singing live you can watch another video for them live like "tiny desk performance" they were singing with a live band
I would recommend the NPR Tiny Desk Concert, The Truth Untold (live), Your Eyes Tell (live), and Film Out (live)!
The adlibs were real.💜💜💜💜
Sounds like they were, yes, and the main vocals too on their solo parts :) Regardless, BTS is a great band 💜
Tiny desk or their Festa room live would be great if you want to hear their live vocals and see them perform more 'raw'. Also, an older song of theirs, house of cards, has an incredible live performance showcasing the vocal line: th-cam.com/video/3ytjTLq87Yw/w-d-xo.html
I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT THIS ONE! 🙏💜
Thank you for your reactions.
Yes, BTS performs and sing "LIVE", just an FYI in K-pop world... they have to sing live... that's why you hear something... sometimes they would suddenly stop singing and let the fans pick-up the lyrics...
the entire live sounded live tho TT they onyl have backing vocals for certain parts where even they make it obvious by not singing that part or during very hard movements.
That was full live vocal for me tho. Great video
Thank you ☺️ I tried to clarify a bit in my pinned comment about the live/pre-rec thing. I hope people know I don’t mean to diminish anyone’s talent or legitimacy by pointing out (possible) production tools.
I think we don't listen to the same video, because I hear the voices shaking and we hear that they are singing life. I'm not angry but please listen and see the difference with the Music Video. You will directly see the difference. So in conclusion they are singing live, their voices are shaking and surprisingly they are doing both, dancing and singing, yes some can do that.
They are live performers. Even for pre-record, they sing live. That is live performance but via virtual streams due to covid pandemic. They do not do lip sync to dance.. They never settle for less, much less to convension. They are not just singers or performers, they are individual artists, rappers, composers (both lyrics and melodies), musical arrangers, writers and rewrites. Individually, they are genius at what they do as artists. 3 (RM, Suga and Jimin) of the 7 members have an IQ of geniuses (148, 132, 138, respectivsly). While, the other 4 are impecable artists no lesser than the 3 IQ Ayers. And, they are hard working group of artists. Read about them before reacting to BTS for it's disrespect to them to react to on their work without knowing them. Like watching an orchestra concert, opera or ballet, you've got to read excerpts before the show starts, right? Had you startes reacting 3-4 years ago, it will be understandable if you do not know them. But, Hello! BTS has surpassed the historical Billboard records of the Beatles. Butter is at No. 1 for 8 weeks at the Billboard Chart 100. The Army, their fandom, grows everyday by 0.01%, if not 0.1%. Now, you are not reacting to just an ordinary never heard of boy band. You are reacting to the most popular boy band in the globe. They took the Billboard Music Awards and American Music Awards by storm since 2017 and 2018 to date, respectively. They won as the BBMA Social Artist Awards 4 years in a row. BTS is 8 year old boy band. Your lack of information about them does not justify your lack of knowledge about them. Research first, ok? You said, you wont react on their vocals, yet you just said you understand "why they do pre-record performances." BTS do not play-safe, darling. They sold out full house Wembley in London and Rose Bowl Stadium in the US. Again, BTS is knowm for its hard core live performances.
Because of them, I became kinder, they cheer me up and make the world brighter 💜 pls react to thay live performances: ON, Magic Shop, Let go, Best of me, Dimple+Pied piper....
they're so good only 1 small part sounded Live 🤣
Haha I like your angle! It sounds live in the sense that I hear the pops on p’s and t’s and so on, I just assumed they were using a pre-recorded live version given this style of production and venue. At least for the backing vocals.
hi, i just watched your reaction
i hope the protective comments didn't discouraged you from reacting to the guys, i actually love your reaction, hope we can see more of it in the future (manifesting for part 2 of the Tiny Desk Home Concert)
btw, was it you singing in the outro of your video? your voice is very beautiful💜
Hi ☺️ Thank you for being here, and for being so kind. I’m really happy you liked it, and that you want the part 2 from Tiny Desk. I will try to get it filmed this weekend.
Yes, that’s me ☺️ Thank you so much! Hope you’re having a nice weekend.
@@HegeOfficial you too, take care 😊💜
Junkook love.may boy ❣️
If you want to hear a bit more of their voices you should check out their Tiny Desk Concert or live performances from the vocal line like The Truth Untold (th-cam.com/video/PGl1A3F-dEM/w-d-xo.html), House of Cards (th-cam.com/video/TX_ozc6GtmE/w-d-xo.html) or Film out (th-cam.com/video/nvbDUtrWSt0/w-d-xo.html)
They are singing live. The can sing and dance live because theyve trained hard for it. 16 hours
There’s such a lot of discussion here about whether or not they are singing live. There are situations where they can’t sing live. As far as I know they have some tracks prerecorded and they can let the backing track take over if they are doing a particular movement which makes singing difficult. Watch Jimin doing a live performance of Lie and he stops singing and let’s the track take over when he is doing the difficult dance bits. If they are wearing Britneys or using hand mics then they’re singing. You were surprised to see them rapping. You’ll find that most of their songs have rap sections. Unless they are singing solo all Seven members have their special parts in a performance and as there are three rappers in the rap line you’ll get at least three sections of rap. There are four in the vocal line with rapper, J-Hope as a sub vocalist to make five. Jungkook can also rap and so can the others if you let them loose. It’s just not their specialty. Now that you’ve heard two of their songs sung all in English it’s time to venture into the Korean ones which only have some words and phrases in English. How about trying Pied Piper or Dope?
I think it was live because JK's "breaking into your heart like thaaat" wasn't drawn out like that in to original audio. ❤❤ But I have no ears for intricate musicality so.....yea 😅
Amm.. i mean.. its not just BTS who can sing live while dancing..? I mean if u know "KPOP" kpop is a "genre" where they trained over the years just to master them singing while dancing, so at first i thought what u were talking about "pre-record" is they cut some clip and shot again which is true, but then what i understand to what u were trying to say is that they record their vocals and just played while their dancing, so that the performance will be good and no shaking voices cause obviously their dancing. But if you'll search about bts- no no no i mean KPOP you'll know that they have to trained just like what ive said just to get on what they doing rn.;)
Edit: i'd love u to react to bts "ill be missing u " cover😊
This is a nice performance but nothing compared to what they're actually able to do. Before covid they had 2-3 hours long concerts (2018-2019, 58 dates within 13 months), fanmeetings that were like mini concerts (8 dates in 2019) and at the end of the year they also did 20-40 minutes long performances for X many award ceremonies and they always sang live while dancing crazy hard choreographies. I'm not one of those that say that they never use backing tracks or autotune because that's just how it is and it's nothing bad but I saw them live two times and they're really phenomenal live performers :D would love to see you react to more of their stuff, especially concert performances or their ROOM LIVE. Thank you!
I know its hard to believe, since in the west you're use to singers using playback especially while dancing, but BTS pretty much never do that and always sing live (with a backing track ofc). You can actually tell because you can hear the pops and their breathing sometimes while the sing and dance
Sweetie, just to let you know...this was live...you are right when u said that they train. And one those things that they train on is singing live while dancing. And I do mean the while of k pop. Every group trains that way. And don't get me wrong there are preformancea where they use pre recorded track, but it's usually when they want to go full force on the preformance or the company or TV Station they are dealing with work with nothing but pre recorded tracks. But this preformance for the Gobal Citizen Concert was all live. BTS do not like using pre recorded tracks if they don't have too...
Great reaction! Please react to more BTS live. House of Cards, Magic Shop, Untold Truth, Tomorrow are just a few suggestions.
Are you gonna react to more from them I would love to see you react to more??
이쁘다
They are so good live that many mistake them singing as lip syncing.. but that’s totally live singing and dancing all together .. u r cool I love your hair ;)
you might really like their tiny desk performance!
Thanks for your Reaktion. Sorry for my mistakes. I'm from Germany. I realy love your open mind and hope that you wil react to some more Videos from them.
Gurl.... 99% of it is live
Thanks for the reaction♥️. Please check 'my universe' by Coldplay X BTS.