If someone says to me..."I have something to tell you, I'll tell you later" Ah, No! tell me now. So I can not even begin to fathom what families go through when their child disappears or is found murdered & 30 years later you get your answer. And so many have been missing year after year after year with absolutely no answer, family members pass away without ever knowing what happened. Just heartbreaking what not only the victim goes through, but then the legacy of heartbreak to the surviving family members.
I’m the same way you are and I hate surprises. It would probably literally drive me crazy if something happened to one of my loved ones and there was never any justice or answers. Even if the person that hurt my loved one was caught and put in prison I’d still struggle with knowing they are alive watching tv / reading / playing cards etc after hurting my loved one especially if they had killed my loved one. I’d struggle with wanting to get my justice personally so something like an unsolved murder of a loved one of mine would bother me to no end. I’m not a violent person I’ve never hurt any innocent person but I’m extremely protective over my family especially the females so like I said if someone hurt them I’m the type of person that would feel like a failure and extremely upset I’d want justice at my hands.
Heartbreaking. As a parent, I don't know of anything that could be worse than this. The narrators voice is extremely soothing, despite the horrendous content. Very clear and easy to understand.
I completely agree with you about our wonderful narrator. I found this podcast in October and binge listened to it for 2 months. Been caught up since December. ❤❤❤❤@@ConnorEverything1997
I’ve fallen asleep to him because of how soothing his voice is despite the content. And i agree, having a 7 year old daughter and son this is my worst fear.
Okay okay look, I get thinking something like that note might be a prank, but if you think it’s one of your older sons friends, you might want to follow up on that, because that would be a pretty deranged “prank”
@@BrenMurphy1He’s not been doing those on recent episodes, probably due to the constant bellyaching from people like you, and I worry that the Casefile team will continue to deny themselves even this meager ad revenue and barely be compensated at all for all the time/effort/care they put into researching/writing/producing these podcasts. Assuming this is their full-time career, hard to see how that new model (catering to lazy critics who don’t understand how to use youtube’s fast forward function) would be sustainable for long.
@@EllenLeah-pv2ywI agree 100% casefile is the most respectful and best researched presented ect IMO. Also that guy who commented @BrenMurphy1 makes videos on anger management and mindfulness funny he can't follow his own garbage he spews 😂
i can’t imagine being the son who thought it was his dad and reported him only for it NOT to be him… what would that relationship be like at that point 😬
Some rando tried to kidnap me from Southtown Mall in the late 80s. Thankfully my mom was paying close attention that day. I often wonder if it was the same guy.
My heart breaks for Sarah who was terrified of this happening to her, just for her nightmare to be realized. At only 7 years old, she must've been petrified beyond belief. RIP to both those innocent children who had their lives ripped away. 🕊️
It's crazy that mother thought her daughter getting a used condom and a letter telling her he gonna kidnap and kill her as something not serious terrible mother
8-9 is the norm for 3rd grade. Most kids start 1st grade when they are 6 yrs old. 2nd grade is 7-8 years old so 3rd grade would be 8-9 years old. I was 8 in the 3rd grade.
@@daytonasayswhat9333This narrator is 1000% certainly not AI. Listen to some older episodes in which he does jovial ad reads and talks about the Casefile team’s experiences researching/conducting interviews for some of their Spotify-exclusive podcasts. He does have a slightly stylized (slower, unerringly clear) way in which he reads these Casefile scripts, one which he’s refined over the years, but I can’t even imagine mistaking it for AI. I can tell that you haven’t listened to many older episodes of this podcast, and I’m envious of that tbh. Wish I weren’t all caught up on these, especially since no other true crime podcast I’ve found even begins to measure up to this one.
My girlfriend lived in Grabill, IN at the time. Not a likely place for such a tragedy, the town was at least half-Amish. The 7-11 had hitching posts for the horses and buggies out front! 😅. Not making this up.
Did law enforcement pat themselves on the back for solving this, like they always do when it was actually someone else so solved this? Edit: as soon as i finished typing that, yep, they did. Gave themselves awards and everything. But it was the genealogists who solved it, not law enforcement. But they love taking credit for nothing other than doing their jobs, even when they didn't actually solve it.
When I was 10 years old in 1971 I had to look after 4 younger siblings ages ranging from twins who were 6, 5 and 3. We had to go out and not come back until dinner time, then after dinner, back out again until teatime. Not just hang about outside our home but somewhere at least where it would take half hour to get home . I was responsible for them all, and if any of them ran off home I Wouk’s be responsible for that and get a good hiding ..all the while I would be abused and SA by my father ..
Until we have lived thru this we can’t say what we would have or not have done. Hindsight is very much 20/20. I’m just glad they found her body quickly. It would be maddening to not know what happened to your kids for decades. Might never know. All of this national center for missing children age progression photos as the child has been missing from one big growth to the next. I remember Natalee Holloways mama to this day begging for information. I remember Kyron Horman. Maura Murray. They are all still missing.
@@jamesb.9155 still, that’s what happened, what are you going to do about it now, after so many years. It took years to find him, stop trying to blame people.
I like these your cases for sleeping. But when I’m awake it’s a piss off I don’t get to see his face or what she looked liked, or what Sarah looked like.
Memorial Day is in May, not March (in America anyway). Just wanted to say that (the very beginning of the video incorrectly says March). Stories like this are so awful, scary, and heartbreaking. How anyone can harm a child is beyond me.
This has nothing to do with God. God's will was never for things like this to occur. However, original sin and free will was the introduction of evil into the world, of which Satan is the prince. At no point ever did The Lord promise anyone an easy life free of grief and pain. This sort of thing is NOT God's will, and dismissing the concept of the existence of The Lord simply because life isn't Candy Land is about as Reddit as it gets.
To think… if he lives until he is 100 years old he will get out… very very unlikely but not impossible. Why couldnt they have just given him life in prison?
I find it amusing evrry time i hear a true crime podcaster warns the listener that they may be triggered by the violent content & may need to talk to a therapist about it. IT'S TRUE CRIME! Maybe they should watch cartoons or a cooking show instead lol
If anything, hearing about the prevalence of evil in the world is an encouragement for people to become reclusive themselves. As people get increasingly selfish, greedy, lustful and violence prone, I don't blame anyone for keeping a healthy distance from others.
@@doesitmatter9085 exactly so. i've realised that the 'system' is protecting or turning a blind eye to so many criminals that it's just not worth the hassle of meeting o.k. people and then finding out they are otherwise.
Why would a mother read a letter like that and take it as a joke?? WTF??!!!!????
I was thinking THE SAME
Because she is a terrible mother
and especially with a used condom most definitely wtf?
That's what I came to say.
Some people just shouldn’t be parents
This murderer lived too long without being caught.
Yes very much so
If someone says to me..."I have something to tell you, I'll tell you later" Ah, No! tell me now. So I can not even begin to fathom what families go through when their child disappears or is found murdered & 30 years later you get your answer. And so many have been missing year after year after year with absolutely no answer, family members pass away without ever knowing what happened. Just heartbreaking what not only the victim goes through, but then the legacy of heartbreak to the surviving family members.
I’m the same way you are and I hate surprises.
It would probably literally drive me crazy if something happened to one of my loved ones and there was never any justice or answers.
Even if the person that hurt my loved one was caught and put in prison I’d still struggle with knowing they are alive watching tv / reading / playing cards etc after hurting my loved one especially if they had killed my loved one. I’d struggle with wanting to get my justice personally so something like an unsolved murder of a loved one of mine would bother me to no end.
I’m not a violent person I’ve never hurt any innocent person but I’m extremely protective over my family especially the females so like I said if someone hurt them I’m the type of person that would feel like a failure and extremely upset I’d want justice at my hands.
Heartbreaking. As a parent, I don't know of anything that could be worse than this. The narrators voice is extremely soothing, despite the horrendous content. Very clear and easy to understand.
Welcome to casefile. It is the single best true crime podcast and there are 281 more cases to listen to
I completely agree with you about our wonderful narrator. I found this podcast in October and binge listened to it for 2 months. Been caught up since December. ❤❤❤❤@@ConnorEverything1997
I’ve fallen asleep to him because of how soothing his voice is despite the content. And i agree, having a 7 year old daughter and son this is my worst fear.
@@jodikennedy2141 I have often, much to my chagrin, fallen asleep to his voice.
It’s the Australian accent ❤ I’m from Australia
Okay okay look, I get thinking something like that note might be a prank, but if you think it’s one of your older sons friends, you might want to follow up on that, because that would be a pretty deranged “prank”
Very deranged! That's waaaay to close to home since those friends have most likely been in the house AND interacted with the her daughter.
@@msvmac9361 exactly!
Agreed. I was thinking the same.. you'd definitely want to know who had that mind set, thinking it was funny.. around your family.
i'm sorry how the absolute fuck does a used condom, bomb threat and murderer identification come off as a joke, omfg!
Correction, SICK JOKE. it was a sick joke to a t.
Someone with a veeeeery low opinion of their son's friends?
Exactly
Yeees...wow!!!! 🤢😵
@@FrogsForBreakfast 🎯 Right...an under the basement level opinion!
I'm addicted to this channel ❣️ The quality of the story format is definitely one of the best. Really this is my favorite true crime channel.
I'm beginning to really dig this channel also.
Great to see your subscription numbers slowly rising. One of the best true crime podcasts out there. Thanks.
Those midstream ads are exploitative. Too long and inauthentic. Hard pass.
@@BrenMurphy1He’s not been doing those on recent episodes, probably due to the constant bellyaching from people like you, and I worry that the Casefile team will continue to deny themselves even this meager ad revenue and barely be compensated at all for all the time/effort/care they put into researching/writing/producing these podcasts. Assuming this is their full-time career, hard to see how that new model (catering to lazy critics who don’t understand how to use youtube’s fast forward function) would be sustainable for long.
@@EllenLeah-pv2ywI agree 100% casefile is the most respectful and best researched presented ect IMO. Also that guy who commented @BrenMurphy1 makes videos on anger management and mindfulness funny he can't follow his own garbage he spews 😂
@@BrenMurphy1 calm down boy.
i can’t imagine being the son who thought it was his dad and reported him only for it NOT to be him… what would that relationship be like at that point 😬
Why would he his dad was a sicko either way
As a Fort Wayne native born in 82 I’ve heard so much about all of these stories. Crazy stuff
Some rando tried to kidnap me from Southtown Mall in the late 80s. Thankfully my mom was paying close attention that day. I often wonder if it was the same guy.
@@cheekyrabbit holy crap!!!!
Anything you'd like to add that's not in the video? I'm from Indianapolis, I'd never heard much about this case until recently, so I'm curious.
@@Tangleduponblue I think it was covered quite well honestly. Definitely a scary time to be a kid.
@@xplamason1029 Cool. Thanks!
RIP April Tinsley.
That poor little girl.
This is a very disturbing crime, praying for the victims families and friends. Also, praying for the victims, may their souls rest in peace.
Excellent documentary. God rest little April and I’m thinking of her family.
My heart breaks for Sarah who was terrified of this happening to her, just for her nightmare to be realized. At only 7 years old, she must've been petrified beyond belief. RIP to both those innocent children who had their lives ripped away. 🕊️
This is one of the first cases that genealogical DNA was used.
Im really glad that you're finally getting more subscribers you deserve it. One of the best podcasts on true crime on TH-cam. 💯👍🇺🇸
It's crazy that mother thought her daughter getting a used condom and a letter telling her he gonna kidnap and kill her as something not serious terrible mother
This is rough. At least it was solved, which is something, but damn, this is rough.
Many thanks Casefile ♥️
Why the hell would the mother not immediately report that letter anyway? Damn…..some parents just really are airheads
Brilliant storytelling. Best true crime podcast, for sure
Emily’s mother Crystal seemed incredibly naive, even if she hadn’t heard of April Tinsley. Some “sick joke”.
Creepy note? Sure, that alone might be a cruel prank. But a note and a USED CONDOM???? Excuse me, ma'am, but wtf? I would be flipping out.
Yes, ma'am, we would all touch it, hold it, then discuss it with friends....Unbelievable.
She and her kid were kind of off. 8 in the 3rd grade says a lot.
8-9 is the norm for 3rd grade. Most kids start 1st grade when they are 6 yrs old. 2nd grade is 7-8 years old so 3rd grade would be 8-9 years old. I was 8 in the 3rd grade.
@@learobinson4450yeah I was confused about that comment too. 8 is the age for 3rd grade.
Thank you for sharing this story ❤.
If this is the case I think it is I have been trying to find it since I remember hearing about it as a kid
Is it?
@Habanero_Chi yes!
I wonder if April was the only one.Somehow i dont think so
Agreed 💯
Rest in paradise april ❤️ sorry this cruel deprived person done such horrible things to you 😢
Excellent presentation!
BEST CHANNEL EVER!!
NOBODY DOES IT LIKE C A S E F I L E
I listen to these ones during daytime to get the story and again at night to put me right to sleep. Soothing voice. Thank you Casefiles ❤️
Pretty sure it’s AI.
@@daytonasayswhat9333 ? Al who?? ... Jk..😁
@@daytonasayswhat9333This narrator is 1000% certainly not AI. Listen to some older episodes in which he does jovial ad reads and talks about the Casefile team’s experiences researching/conducting interviews for some of their Spotify-exclusive podcasts. He does have a slightly stylized (slower, unerringly clear) way in which he reads these Casefile scripts, one which he’s refined over the years, but I can’t even imagine mistaking it for AI. I can tell that you haven’t listened to many older episodes of this podcast, and I’m envious of that tbh. Wish I weren’t all caught up on these, especially since no other true crime podcast I’ve found even begins to measure up to this one.
@@EllenLeah-pv2yw OK, fair enough. But he’s definitely using some type of autotune or voice modulator voice modification thing.
Not sure I could fall asleep to a story this horrific….just saying
My girlfriend lived in Grabill, IN at the time. Not a likely place for such a tragedy, the town was at least half-Amish. The 7-11 had hitching posts for the horses and buggies out front! 😅. Not making this up.
It's still very much an Amish town.
Did law enforcement pat themselves on the back for solving this, like they always do when it was actually someone else so solved this?
Edit: as soon as i finished typing that, yep, they did. Gave themselves awards and everything. But it was the genealogists who solved it, not law enforcement. But they love taking credit for nothing other than doing their jobs, even when they didn't actually solve it.
Thanks Matey 👍
Good to see the subs have grown over the past week..
In the 1960s, I wasn't allowed to walk to a friend's house around the corner even up to 11 years old.
When I was 10 years old in 1971 I had to look after 4 younger siblings ages ranging from twins who were 6, 5 and 3. We had to go out and not come back until dinner time, then after dinner, back out again until teatime. Not just hang about outside our home but somewhere at least where it would take half hour to get home . I was responsible for them all, and if any of them ran off home I Wouk’s be responsible for that and get a good hiding ..all the while I would be abused and SA by my father ..
Wow! I watch lots of this kind of stuff, and this was very well done! Thanks!
It took a community member to tell the mother to take this to the police!!
I’m just at the start and that blew me away!
This happened in my home town
love this channel. Best crime content
When you work Walmart overnight shift, listening to this 😮
Sorry Mate , when in Bali on holiday and listening to CF 👍😉
What about it?
@@Maligroot weak . I'm out in SF holiday eryday
I think just working at Walmart is scary, from what I’ve seen online shorts, then you listen to this as well 😮😮
@@robyn7287 overnights are pretty tame, at least at my store anyway
Until we have lived thru this we can’t say what we would have or not have done. Hindsight is very much 20/20. I’m just glad they found her body quickly. It would be maddening to not know what happened to your kids for decades. Might never know. All of this national center for missing children age progression photos as the child has been missing from one big growth to the next. I remember Natalee Holloways mama to this day begging for information. I remember Kyron Horman. Maura Murray. They are all still missing.
Very sad astounding case justice came very late your presentation style is amazing ❤
I lived there during this. I remember.
Why didn't Crystal take the evidence from her daughter's bike to the police?
Because she didn’t know it was evidence at that time and even if she did it wouldn’t have resolved anything.
@@annegiorgio5602 Still . . . That's what you do!
@@jamesb.9155 still, that’s what happened, what are you going to do about it now, after so many years. It took years to find him, stop trying to blame people.
@@annegiorgio5602you don't know that
@@alysononoahu8702 neither do you, testing of the semen did not result in anything until years later when they got a familial match
Memorial Day weekend in March in Indiana…. Pretty interesting.
So many cases mention a missing shoe…
And a pink bike.
@@hilarywallace3007 and a victim
They fly off when the child is picked up or if the child kicks etc
Many shoes are knocked off during a car accident fyi
Since when is Memorial Day in March?
Release???😡😡😡😡
I think that's a ridiculous bill.
The killer wrote that way so the police would understand it.
😂😂
Never let my children walk anywhere alone in the 1980’s
I like these your cases for sleeping. But when I’m awake it’s a piss off I don’t get to see his face or what she looked liked, or what Sarah looked like.
RIP girls
Oh nooo....I feel so bad for Sarah. She was so scared of being killed by the person who killed April and that's exactly what happened to her. Ugh.
I remember April Tinsley, but who is Sarah Barka? Grew up and still live where this happened never heard of a Sarah Barka being another child victim.
Sorry but I can’t take this case seriously with the narration. It’s so deadpan and robotic and I’m pretty sure I’m listening to AI.
Definitely not AI
Yeah it sounded like AI to me too…?
Memorial Day is in May, not March (in America anyway). Just wanted to say that (the very beginning of the video incorrectly says March).
Stories like this are so awful, scary, and heartbreaking. How anyone can harm a child is beyond me.
I cannot reconcile events like this with the concept of a benevolent god. The loss that poor family must feel is unimaginable.
This has nothing to do with God. God's will was never for things like this to occur. However, original sin and free will was the introduction of evil into the world, of which Satan is the prince. At no point ever did The Lord promise anyone an easy life free of grief and pain. This sort of thing is NOT God's will, and dismissing the concept of the existence of The Lord simply because life isn't Candy Land is about as Reddit as it gets.
Ain’t no, “god,” Broski. Just try to push on through and leave that chilly thought behind.
@@daytonasayswhat9333 there's most definitely a God.
@@doesitmatter9085 and he is a sadistic asshole
The killer lived within walking distance or a short drive from the barn.
I called it, he'd still live nearby laying low like in the Delphi case.
To think… if he lives until he is 100 years old he will get out… very very unlikely but not impossible. Why couldnt they have just given him life in prison?
Why don't u have videos? And photos ? To at least put a face to the people? Why
It's a podcast
That's crazy! I didn't know Sears sold such things.
That's really the comment your gonna leave 😮
Damn you get lots of clicks from me before i remember there are no visuals lol
I never thought Moose did it.
I have to stop listening to these cases. 😔
Best AI Narrator on TH-cam.
Is this AI?
@@WouldntULikeToKnow.No, absolutely and extremely obviously not
Sounds like a real Australian man, so it probably is. Hate AI.
It isn't AI. This podcast stems from a time even before AI narration was decent.
@@jamesb.9155not AI
Morning world have a sunny day this sunday 😎😎🙏🙏👊👍✌🇬🇧
I find it amusing evrry time i hear a true crime podcaster warns the listener that they may be triggered by the violent content & may need to talk to a therapist about it. IT'S TRUE CRIME! Maybe they should watch cartoons or a cooking show instead lol
Well told. Beware of recluses.
Heeeeeeeey!!!!!
i'm reclusive - thanks for avoiding me!
Hey I resemble that.
If anything, hearing about the prevalence of evil in the world is an encouragement for people to become reclusive themselves. As people get increasingly selfish, greedy, lustful and violence prone, I don't blame anyone for keeping a healthy distance from others.
@@doesitmatter9085 exactly so. i've realised that the 'system' is protecting or turning a blind eye to so many criminals that it's just not worth the hassle of meeting o.k. people and then finding out they are otherwise.
❤❤❤
Love all these but Ai voice over isn't 💯
First! Wow!
I tried to be first❤❤❤❤
Ooops I got 2nd 😂😂😂😂Thought I'd be first❤❤❤❤
What a stupid thing to be concerned about
@@SpicyTexan64 he is a sissy
grow tf up..
Really your comment shows your none existing compassion and sorrow for this poor little girl and her family 😞
Holy shit this was scary well done😮