+TheTitaniaOfAnime ya I actually researched about that and found out that she isn't 5'7 , in fact she is 5'6 or 5'5. So before sulli left fx , she was the tallest female in SM entertainment and now that she left sooyoung is the tallest female in SM. I actually noticed that sooyoung doesn't look tall on camera , instead she looks short but ppl were like "sooyoung is 5'7 or 5'8" and I was like "no she is definately not 5'7 or 5'8" so I just assumed she is tall but she looks short in camera. But in this video u can clearly see how tall sulli is. So ya :) for now all I know is sooyoung is 5'6
+AHungryUnicorn I'm pretty sure Sooyoung is actually taller than that she might even actually be like 5"8 cos I met Jessica irl and she was around 3 inches shorter than me (I'm like 171cm so she must be around 162-163) and from pictures of her and Sooyoung it seems like their height difference was really big 3-4 inches for sure.
It's cool that F(x) is the only group wherein all are great dancers and no one among them resembles each other coz theyre all natural beauties. Seriously, they all look diff fr each other. I honestly cannot think of any girl grp!
jinlissul they dont need to debut to get surgeries tho. most of girls in this industry come from families that have money. is just to me that they dont look natural
diaphanous.sylph Luna doesn't exsist to most of the fandom. I like them all but as a Luna biassed I feel sad always reading the comments under f(x) videos. Her presence is always dissmised.
참고로 레드라이트는 세월호 이야기를 간접적으로 담은 노래입니다. 단순히 지나가는 이슈가 아니라, 장기적이고 확실한 관심이 서로에게 구원이 될 수 있다는 내용이에요. 처음 티저 나왔을 때부터 세월호 관련된 노래라는 예상이 많았고, 여러 인터뷰를 통해서 팬들은 내용을 다 알고 있었어요. 지금 돌아보니 힘들었던 설리에게 필요한 내용의 노래가 아니었을까 싶네요. 너무 그립다...
2022 today, still thinking about f(x) being a true precious gem of the Kpop music industry. Do you guys all agree that they rocks the stage and have such a breathtaking aesthetic vibes in every single performance? Honestly I still can't bear my heart with their visuals, especially that of Krystal and Sulli. They are true queens and true artists. Hard to believe that such a beautiful and talented lady (Sulli) is gone. Their beauty is just a whole another level compared to the idols of the following gens
I keep coming back to them , I belive they would be so big if they continued together and also although this is just sadly not possible Krystal and Sully would´ve made an amazing sub-unit. Sometimes it´s sad how the world take it´s turn.
@@abiiibiii I think Amber and Luna would have made an amazing sub-unit. The other girls had started branching out into acting and we're killing it! Amber and Luna have so much passion for music and were doing a lot behind the scenes. The even performed at festivals together so I would have love for SM to give them that opportunity.
I have many things to say. Amber's singing voice is amazing she should have more singing lines. Blonde Krystal needs to comeback. Sulli is probably the prettiest woman in Korea ,them legs😭. Victoria is my underrated beauty and Luna is not SM's best female vocal for nothing
마리아 I like her after She leave f(x) I usually see bad comment about her. I still like her But Now she have only a few fan:( People are hating on her Because They said that She didn't love f(x) , leave friend and about dating...
+Sam .B so her case is similar to Iu's case? (People not seeing her as the nation's little sister anymore, the controversy that chat-shire created) (not hating on either iu or Sulli, Iu is ny favorite korean solo singer and Sulli would be my bias in fx if she hadn't withdrawn from the group)
sulli is hands down one of the prettiest and cutest kpop stars, and she has an soft angel-like voice that always gets overlooked... stay strong and keep smiling sulli, these are the times you know who ur real fans are.
I am happy that sulli was in the middle before she bid f(x) goodbye. but you can clearly see here that she was sad, very sad. she is really depressed and the members knows it and cares about her. I am happy that she is now happy, bullying can really torment one's life. it can make you hide in seclusion, but she proved her haters wrong. now she is back and stronger.
Choi sulli you are a awesome singer and an actress.I like the role that u have played in" to the beautiful you" tele -drama. You are a very talented girl.
sanduni fernando I agree with you but others did not even appreciated her talent and keeps bashing for a single mistake. Bashers/Haters always finds mistakes.
yeah.. so many top comments from years ago, saying sulli's a top visual lol... i remember liking her way back after seeing her in rum pum pum, with her orange hair. she looked like a baby, it was dang cute. i wasn't really following any kpop recently so i only heard of it now...
고블린 앨범 나왔을 때 멜론 댓글창 뭐라고 도배된줄 아세요? 설리가 에프엑스 망쳐놓고 왜 노래내냐 어쩌구 욕만 있었어요 근데 설리가 떠난후엔 갑자기 다들 자기가 쓴 댓글 다 지우고 애도하죠...진짜 너무 슬펐어요 이중성이 너무 심한거같아서요..다신 이런일이 안일어났으면 좋겠네요
설리가 떠난 건 정말 안타까운 일이죠.. 탈퇴 후에 뭐만하면 욕을 먹고 그랬으니.. 그런 악플들은 싹 다 사라져야 합니다. 근데 그거와는 별개로 무대에서 무기력한 태도를 보여 팬들에게 질타를 받았던건 어쩔 수 없는 일이었다고 봐요. 솔직히 초창기와는 다르게 의욕도 없어보이고 팬들 입장에서는 설리가 아이돌 가수란 직업에 대한 책임감이 없어보였고 갑자기 탈퇴 해버리니 미운 시선이 따라다녔던건 어쩔 수 없었던거 같아요. 물론 그와 상관없이 사소한 걸로 꼬투리 잡고 욕하던 댓글들은 정말 고소당해도 할 말 없죠. 참 안타깝네요
설리탓할게 아니지 우울증이 그렇게 심했는데, 다 차치하고 그룹활동 계속했으면 급행복해지나? 자신을 포기하고 했어야 함? 사람있고 에프엑스있는거죠. 일이 이렇게 되고 보면 당시 진짜 힘들어서 더 할수없었나보다 하는 생각이 들겠구만, 언제까지 그래도 욕먹을건 욕먹어야 한다며 악플달건지? 솔직히 이미 헤어진지 4년 쯤이었을 때도, 그룹 이미지 어쩌고 하면서 설리탓하는 건 그냥 만만한 핑계거리 찾아 패는거밖엔 안 되어요. 그저 악플러면서 떳떳한척까지 하는 건 웃김. 설리가 끝에 열심히 안 했다손쳐도, 그래서 탈퇴했잖아요. 열심히 할수있는 상태가 아니니까 자기 행동 책임지고 나갔는데 뭘 더 원하는건지 모르겠음. 안 나가고 열심히 해야된다 이 답을 정해놓고 정작 개개인은 안 보고 있잖아요 고블린이 무슨 솔로앨범 타이틀이었던 것도 아니고, 배우 개그맨 여러사람들이 일회성으로 슴스테 싱글내는거. 마치 단독앨범 나온것처럼 과장해서 욕박았던 것도 웃기고. 갈라선지가 4년이나 된 사람의 활동을 사사건건 걸고 넘어질거면, 현멤버 개인활동은 어떻게 욕 안 박고 넘어갔나? 설리가 앨범을 내든말든 연기 활동을 어떻게 하든 에프엑스랑은 상관 없어졌고, 정작 상관있는건 현멤버 개인 활동인데. 그리고 설리가 탈퇴해서 에프엑스 그룹이 망한것처럼 말하는 건 다른 에프엑스멤버한테도 실례입니다. 설리 없으면 그룹이 없는거냐. 에프엑스도 연차가 있는데 그룹활동 안 나왔던 건 여러 이유가 있었겠죠. 설리탈퇴 후 안 나온것도 아니고: 4 walls 있었고요. 더 낼려면 더 냈겠죠. 슴스테 다른 멤버도 했었고 개인활동도 각자 있고 그런건 다 무시하고 설리 타켓잡는건 너무 한 것
Ever since someone else noticed that Victoria's fans never cheer when she sings, ive been noticing it nonstop and its seriously bugging me. WHERE THE FANS AT?? WHERE THE LOVE AT?? Seriously, she never gets any love. VICTORIA'S FANS UNITE!
i would totally cheer for her lol...she has A CRAPLOAD of chinese fans, shes actually the most popular fx member in china, but im not so sure abt korea
inSAMity L Victoria's popular among chinese fans because she's chinese...obviously. krystal and sulli are considered the most popular in korea, and rightly so.
저 시절로 돌아가고 싶다ㅎㅎ 좋아하는 아이돌 컴백 한다 그러면 발매 전부터 재킷 사진 확인하고 티저 확인하고 설레면서 기다렸다가 뮤비 나오면 몇번이고 돌려보고.. ㅠㅠ 지금은 왜 저런 열정이 없는지😂 누군가를 좋아하고 응원하는 열정이 얼마나 삶에 에너지를 주는건지 저땐 몰랐어..에프엑스도 응원하던 그룹중에 하나였는데 그립다..
It's her job. If she's too depressed to do her job well she shouldn't perform at all. That's like saying "I don't expect a doctor to do a good job on a surgery because the doctor is depressed." I do love Sulli and hope the best for her, but being an idol and performing well is her job regardless of her depression, and if she was feeling so depressed she couldn't perform her job well, she shouldn't have been on that stage at all.
***** that's something insensitive to say tbh? Because when you're depressed you'll not care about yourself or about anything because of it You will forget to shower and to clean from depression You'll completely shut out of the world from it So saying stuff like that is really insensitive towards her honestly and you know how sm won't let their idols rest proof number exo :)
+Twice Jeongyeon If she was too depressed and didn't perform I bet you'll be like "oh sulli didn't even put in effort" Ugh people like you can never be satisfied🙄
Also Vic!! Krystal is gorgeous too but Vic is so rare and Sulli is just the prettiest of them all in my opinion. Luna's beautiful as well and Amber's amazing so idk how to choose :P
+TheHurricaneVenus I hope she got a weapon permit for her body because it can make man die like flies. I nearly died by heart attack when I first saw her here
sulli is DROP DEAD GORGEOUS, so beautiful and i'm a girl saying this! the haters she has are just jealous little girls. seriously. she OBVIOUSLY looks pale, and in her eyes you could tell she isnt well at all! sm doesnt give a shit. i think sulli would be better off being a model. she's so tall, gorgeous, and underrated! she's always hated by jerks! -_-
i so agree with you , idk why ppl are being so judgemental but hey those ppls are born with bitch mouth so definately that wont stop ..we cant deny that fact so thats why we must live with our own perspective...but they are rly getting on my nerves with all those hateful comments , no matter what sulli do ppl are nvr going to appreciate her cuz they are just blinded .....i have so many words to say to all those haters but my words will be to cheap for their ears so i gave up long time back ...tsk ...any ways i m rly happy to see your comment
haha fans now a days are so unpredictable , they are so good with changing lanes , ergghh i m so tired with their drama's any ways the sooner they realise that their rantings wont make any difference the more better it will be for them x3
ever since i found f(x) through the taiwanese drama with calvin, i only see victoria. she is so beautiful...sooo beautiful. idk, imo, victoria is the visual. i love all the members tho. while you debate over sulli...imma stay in my lane and stan victoria.
I’m a MeU OT5 since 2011…I miss so much f(x), even if now I have MAMAMOO by my side. I feel nostalgic reading the old comments when the Kpop industry was in its golden age. I miss also and especially you Sulli, my first and precious Ultimate Bias. When you left f(x) in 2014 I would have never imagined you leaving us in 2019, after your masterpiece Goblin. I hope you are happy and free more than ever now and thanks to you I’m an Uaena today. May you Rest In Peace.
I'm a MeU since early 2014. Sulli is also my first and ultimate bias in whole K-industry. I feel the same. Her departure from the group was still bearable but when she left in 2019, I was shattered. Good to see people like you genuinely appreciating her. ❤️
because she's obviously not feeling well, but they all hate on her and bully her, saying she's untalented, when she's just not feeling well. -.- they shouldnt have a right to do that. they're not as talented as her, i will bet on that 100%
I miss f(x) so much. The ending pose at 3:28 really made me tear up from nostalgia. They really deserved the best, yet... well, I won't say because you all should know what I'm alluding to. Anyway, love one another, be kind, and be yourself. It's one of the many things I've learned from stanning a unique group like f(x).
i think the reason thats why they hate sulli is because sulli is almost a perfect person she's pretty,tall and talented they just hate her because they are jealous
I remember when I was actively following all their performances this era as a sulli bias and felt so heartbroken seeing all the hate she got this cb because of all the rumors...all the rough times hoping that she would come back...i love you so much my sweet peach angel. you deserved better and i really hope this time around people will start to consider idol's feelings before they spread hate.
That years when all of Kpop female groups were so strong. Striking visuals, real talents, and amazing personalities. Snsd, 2ne1, Sistar, Fx, after school, 4minutes, Miss A. Damn realize so many new groups now with shitty concepts and less talents and one by one those queens are disbanded. What a world
Nowadays rap is almost always about how better they are than everyone or their success. It's annoying how a group can debut with singers that are just about average and ppl will praise them but if Luna where to miss a high note she'd be hated on. Many groups can debut nowadays and became amazingly famous but the girl groups you listed didn't get it right from debut. SNSD debuted in America and Suju where also very popular Wonder Girls to yet as soon as a 3rd gen group debuts in America everyone is like they brought kpop to America or they made kpop worldwide. The kpop community needs to change.
Somita. Dalvand bp has the dancers, the rappers but not the singers. The groups above have all. Bp doesn't. The person who put up the comment is talking about when all of them where amazing.. Nowadays they're not a amazing
all of F(x) adds a different vibe Sulli adds a cute yet srong vibe Krystal adds a sexy vibe Luna gives off the tough and confident vibe Amber gives off power Victoria (my bias
![[HOT] F(x) - Red Light 에프엑스 - 레드라이트, Show Music core 20140712](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Nfncna3z8TM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[에프엑스] 레드 라이트 (f(x) - Red Light) 교차편집 (STAGE MIX)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Hk3q-wkX18E/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Show Champion] 레드벨벳 - Bad Boy (Red Velvet - Bad Boy) l EP.258](/img/n.gif)
와 썸네일 안누를수가 없네
두콩두콩 ㄹㅇ ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ 저도 썸넬때매 들옴
긍까료 개오바 너무이뻐요
ㄹㅇ.. 홀리듯 들어옴..
보고싶다 설리....
와 저렇게 심플한 옷을 입었는데도 엄청 화려하다 다들 너무 멋있음
ㅇㅈ 거의 노출없는 무채색 계열 상의에다 검정 반바지에 롱부츠인데 진짜 화려함...
비주얼과 피지컬이 다했음ㅋ 뭘입혀도 고급지게 소화함
이 댓글 보기전까지 코디가 밋밋하단 생각 한번도 못함 대박
Sam Smith 얼굴이 다들 화려하게 생겨서...
ㄹㅇ특히 크리스탈 온니...핵간지...
설리가 웃는 영상에선 좋은 얘기만 하고 싶음. 점점점 찍으면서 슬퍼만 하는 것도 고인에 대한 예의가 아니라고 생각함. 그나저나 설리 이때 정말 예쁘다 언제 봐도 레드라이트 때는 다들 리즈 찍었는데 루나랑 설리가 특히 예뻤던 것 같음
@성훈박 까는 소리 하고 있네 버러지만도 못한 게 ㅋㅋㅋ 난 예전부터 쭉 설리 팬이었으니까 딴데 가서 짖으세요
성훈박 개웃겨 닠ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
저 악플러 댓글마다 달고 다니네요 그냥 신고 사뿐히 눌러줍시다^^
성훈박 정신차리고 살아라ㅋㅋ
성훈이 여간 어떻게 지냈을지 눈에 보이노 니 댓글 하나하나에 사람 상처받고 죽어가는 건 눈에 안중에도 없노 등신아 정신 좀 차리고 인생 회개 좀 하길 바란다 제발ㅋㅋ 제 스스로를 악플러라고 깨닫지 못하고 악플을 달고 다니는 인생 틀려먹은 패배자 인생이라노
에프엑스는 볼때마다 느끼는게 설리랑 크리스탈이 확실히 존재감 쩌네
성훈박 엥 옛날부터 함수에서 진리랑 정수정 젤 존재감 오진다고 말 많이 나왔는데 인생 개꼬였네ㅋㅋ
성훈박 인생 그렇게 살지마 ㅠㅅㅠ
성훈이 ㅈㄴ 꼬였네 ㅋ
@성훈박 ㅇㅇ 안그래 ㅋ 말하는 꼬라지봐 진짜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ앞에선 아무말도 못할 딱 전형적인 학교 찐따형ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ^^
ㅇㅇ 설리 크리스탈 데뷔때부터 확실히 관심받았음 눈에 띠는 여아이돌로, 또는 이상형으로도 언급 많이 됐었고 설리는 단독 디카 광고도 있었음. 보통 꽤지날때가진 그룹으로 찍곤 하는데 설리는 개인이었음
miss you angel
Rest in peace Choi Jinri
14.10.2019
So sad
Sulli ah😭😭😭😭😭
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
😭
Sad time
썸네일에 설리미모 실화...? 저 사람이 이 세상에 없다는게 아직도 믿기지 않는다...
@성훈박 고인모독 오지네 개념부터 챙기고 댓글 달아
성훈박 어휴 이렇게 넷상에서 니 인성 보이는데 현실에선 얼마나 할지 상상감
성훈박 으..;; 말하는꼬라지하곤;;...언행에서 성훈이 인성이 보이네 ㅅㅂ
@성훈박 주변사람은 당신 이런댓글 찌그리는거 아냐?? 꼭 보여줘라
성훈박 여기저기 가서 토 달지마 보기 싫음 ㄲㅈ 위에 댓글에서도 그러더니
Sulli's visual is so breathtaking.
xCharlesx lol this likes you have is 911 xD
thanks for making me cry. rip sulli 😭😭❤️❤️
@@mae-uk8fk ...
@@mae-uk8fk ok
✨ She really did shine ✨
honestly F(x) us probably the most unique girl group out there
agree
actually i agree 100% i cant find a gg that makes more unique concepts with much quality. I just hope SM gives them a cb soom
true
the butter that Ten thought was ice cream t-ara look them up
completely agree
코디 저게 무 엇...
그냥 티에 그냥 바지 입혀놨는데
빛나는 외모가 받쳐 줌.....
예원 아마 얼굴믿고 저래 입힌듯
다들 기럭지 장난 아님..
옷이 이상한건 아닌데 너무 평범해ㅜㅜ 무대의상인데 그냥 저거 입고 밖에 돌아댕겨도 될듯ㅜㅜ
세월호 사건에 대해 얘기한 노래라 그런 거 아닐까라는 생각이 들어요 !
@@user-vk3xm5sh1c 그런 해석이 있긴 했지만 대놓고 세월호 추모곡이라고 한 것은 아닌데 확대해석 아닐까용
역시 에펙코디가 진짜 센스가있네 뭘 입혀도 태가 좋은걸 아니까 딱 기본으로 심플하게 입힘 지금봐도 촌스럽지도 않고 노래에 안어울리지도 않고 확실히 에펙이 노래나 스타일이나 앞서가는게 있음
역시 태가 나 예쁜 얼굴이니 뭘해도 어울리지
Sulli is seriously tall and gorgeous. No wonder she is an elite visual in the industry
She is 5'7 , same height as sooyoung from snsd.
+AHungryUnicorn some people say that Sooyoung isn't actually 5'7 but I have no doubts that Sulli is.
+TheTitaniaOfAnime ya I actually researched about that and found out that she isn't 5'7 , in fact she is 5'6 or 5'5.
So before sulli left fx , she was the tallest female in SM entertainment and now that she left sooyoung is the tallest female in SM. I actually noticed that sooyoung doesn't look tall on camera , instead she looks short but ppl were like "sooyoung is 5'7 or 5'8" and I was like "no she is definately not 5'7 or 5'8" so I just assumed she is tall but she looks short in camera. But in this video u can clearly see how tall sulli is.
So ya :) for now all I know is sooyoung is 5'6
+AHungryUnicorn I'm pretty sure Sooyoung is actually taller than that she might even actually be like 5"8 cos I met Jessica irl and she was around 3 inches shorter than me (I'm like 171cm so she must be around 162-163) and from pictures of her and Sooyoung it seems like their height difference was really big 3-4 inches for sure.
+AHungryUnicorn plus when you look at pictures of Sooyoung and Sulli together Sooyoung looks taller
크리스탓 진짜... 머리색 때문이 아니라 그냥 존재감 오진다 저런 머리색에 진짜 심플한 옷들만 입었는데 느낌 지대로네
와 설리는 진짜 그냥 누가봐도 아이돌이네 너무 예쁘다..
Sulli will always have one of the top positions of beauty in the kpop industry! Her visual is no joke!!!! :o
true
Nadi Zer agree! Something even her haters can't take away form her.
OF COURSE!!
its erfectly trueee
its true !!!!!
케이팝 오래 한 사람은 에프엑스 같은 그룹이 없다는 걸 알 수 있음. 다시 나올 리도 없는 그냥 완-벽한 조합임
fx needs more attention from sm really :(
Sm brings all these fantastic groups that we all love
Only for sm to lose them and break our hearts 😥
especially for luhan yes :((
Youare Kawaii yeah ):
huh?
True! They are talented. They are the only group that I love from SM 😁
Sulli.......damn.
Krystal.......damn.
Luna.......damn.
Amber.......damn.
Victoria........
DAMN!!
Lucifroggy Boostio 7
YESSSSS SHE IS SO GORGEOUS
Sulli .... *cries*
。。
sulli was literally the prettiest woman in korea
No, it's NingNing
@@JH-bb8in she isnt even korean lmao
@@sup2181 LFMAOO
@@JH-bb8in who tf is ningning?
yesss
어딘가 살아있을 것만 같아
설리랑 크리스탈 그냥 예쁜거 뿐만 아니라 뭔가 존나 간지난다 ...
ㅇㅈ
이때 진짜 루나 개리즈 .. 칼단발에 블루계열 머리 너무 찰떡
It's cool that F(x) is the only group wherein all are great dancers and no one among them resembles each other coz theyre all natural beauties. Seriously, they all look diff fr each other. I honestly cannot think of any girl grp!
+Aeighter I think most girls in twice arent natural
+Lindsay Jung I agree, like 2NE1 you can tell who is who..but BOM is nit natural at all lmao
+Loreto Hidalgo lmao have you seen their predebut? they look the same. if anything i'd say that only nayeon probably got a nose job at the very most.
jinlissul they dont need to debut to get surgeries tho. most of girls in this industry come from families that have money. is just to me that they dont look natural
Loreto Hidalgo and? what is "natural looking" to you though lmao half of them are foreigners- you can check what they look like predebut.
they are literally the most beautiful girl group in kpop
except Manber
+RebeccaBlackVirus bye
Lel... manber is my ship name for manager oppa and amber
RebeccaBlackVirus LMAO MANBER MY ASS. ITS AMBER. AND SHE'S PRETTY
ci
지금봐도 트렌디하고 화려함... 14년이 진짜 돌판 전성기같음
Is no one gonna talk about LUNA? She's slaying this look
moon goddess Luna 🌙....just look down at the comments :)
diaphanous.sylph Luna doesn't exsist to most of the fandom. I like them all but as a Luna biassed I feel sad always reading the comments under f(x) videos. Her presence is always dissmised.
Ikr
this fandom ignores luna :/
Exactly
Time for a new hair do
sulli =angel
she's so beautiful omg
...
juostine 94 now she’s an actual angel💔
This Hits different now ..
This comment is so haunting to me... 😭
페이스캠으로 5명 모두 보고싶다..진짜 레전드 찍었을 거 같아
So, I'm scrolling through the comments and I barely see anything about Amber. She looks amazing.
Amber is literally perfect
She has a nice smile!
OMG IRK
Amber is everything
+makaila artis She's life!
Fx활동때부터 설리는 나한테 여아이돌 원탑이었는데..이전에도 그랬고 앞으로도 설리같이 예쁘고 매력넘치는 아이돌은 없을거라고. 근데 그녀를 다시는 볼수없다는게 너무 안타깝다.
설리 진짜 닮고 싶어도 절대 못 따라하는 독보적 미인임..
경국지색의 끝판왕 같다
suli trully beautiful and bright. her body is perfect.
참고로 레드라이트는 세월호 이야기를 간접적으로 담은 노래입니다. 단순히 지나가는 이슈가 아니라, 장기적이고 확실한 관심이 서로에게 구원이 될 수 있다는 내용이에요. 처음 티저 나왔을 때부터 세월호 관련된 노래라는 예상이 많았고, 여러 인터뷰를 통해서 팬들은 내용을 다 알고 있었어요. 지금 돌아보니 힘들었던 설리에게 필요한 내용의 노래가 아니었을까 싶네요. 너무 그립다...
네??세월호가 더 나중에 터지지않았나..
누구피셜인가요..?
몇개월 더 뒤에 노래 나왔던걸로 기억함
갑자기 뭔 세월호요?
@@eunnnj3165 세월호 참사를 간접적으로 비판한 가사예요. (스엠오피셜)
2022 today, still thinking about f(x) being a true precious gem of the Kpop music industry. Do you guys all agree that they rocks the stage and have such a breathtaking aesthetic vibes in every single performance?
Honestly I still can't bear my heart with their visuals, especially that of Krystal and Sulli. They are true queens and true artists. Hard to believe that such a beautiful and talented lady (Sulli) is gone. Their beauty is just a whole another level compared to the idols of the following gens
I keep coming back to them , I belive they would be so big if they continued together and also although this is just sadly not possible Krystal and Sully would´ve made an amazing sub-unit. Sometimes it´s sad how the world take it´s turn.
@@abiiibiii I think Amber and Luna would have made an amazing sub-unit.
The other girls had started branching out into acting and we're killing it!
Amber and Luna have so much passion for music and were doing a lot behind the scenes.
The even performed at festivals together so I would have love for SM to give them that opportunity.
이런 그룹이 다시 나올수 있을까 아무도 도전하지 않았던 컨셉을 그렇게 찰떡같이 소화하는,,,
Eventho sulli is not here anymore, she still a star in my heart
보고싶어, 많이. 그것도 많이.
Are none of us going to talk about how Luna slayed that high note?
Elizabeth Jane THANK YOU. FINALLY
I have many things to say. Amber's singing voice is amazing she should have more singing lines. Blonde Krystal needs to comeback. Sulli is probably the prettiest woman in Korea ,them legs😭. Victoria is my underrated beauty and Luna is not SM's best female vocal for nothing
Seino Parker I love how you complimented them all 👌🏾
Say it again for the people in the back!!
I AGREE Sulli should be #1 on most beautiful faces. She is so cute but Im crying here I want to back to f(x) PLEASE PLEASEEEE
YESSS
The prettiest lady is gone 😭 😭
썸넬 설리 미쳤나봐 진짜 너무 이뻐 홀린듯이 들어옴
Who is the pne with the brown hair, red lipstick and beige shirt? SHE IS ONE OF THE MOST BEAUTIFUL CREATURES TO EVER WALK ON EARTH
+마리아 She is Sulli or choi jinri
+hello hahaha i am kinda late but do you know why everyone seems to hate her? Ive legit met no one who likes her, even a bit :(
마리아 I like her after She leave f(x)
I usually see bad comment about her.
I still like her But Now she have only a few fan:(
People are hating on her Because They said that She didn't love f(x) , leave friend and about dating...
+Sam .B so her case is similar to Iu's case? (People not seeing her as the nation's little sister anymore, the controversy that chat-shire created) (not hating on either iu or Sulli, Iu is ny favorite korean solo singer and Sulli would be my bias in fx if she hadn't withdrawn from the group)
It's Sulli
sulli is hands down one of the prettiest and cutest kpop stars, and she has an soft angel-like voice that always gets overlooked...
stay strong and keep smiling sulli, these are the times you know who ur real fans are.
JuNnO S. CoolKat we miss her 😭
설리한테 악플단 악마같은 것들
평생 불운만 따라다니길
설리님 뿐만 아니라 연예인이든 일반인이든
상대에게 상처 준 사람들은 진짜 그랬음 좋겠다..
000 0000 좀 빠져 댓글마다 초치는인간들 꼭있네;
근데 세상사가그렇진않더라 ㅠㅠ
찐구 맞아요 😢
I am happy that sulli was in the middle before she bid f(x) goodbye. but you can clearly see here that she was sad, very sad. she is really depressed and the members knows it and cares about her. I am happy that she is now happy, bullying can really torment one's life. it can make you hide in seclusion, but she proved her haters wrong. now she is back and stronger.
Right... Her solo album goblin amezing...
Now she is gone.... RIP SULLI 💔 😢
@Джен Джен 😢 😢 😢 😢 she needs help but no one can understand.. koreans always busy to criticise her...
OH MY GOD 😭
May i know why IN THAT TIME she was not happy?
Amber is so pretty, I love her
Red light was my fav era among all fx comebacks. Everyone look so beautiful. For me, Sulli is the original visual.
Choi sulli you are a awesome singer and an actress.I like the role that u have played in" to the beautiful you" tele -drama. You are a very talented girl.
sanduni fernando I agree with you but others did not even appreciated her talent and keeps bashing for a single mistake. Bashers/Haters always finds mistakes.
U are 100% correct!☺
*reading all the old comments makes me sad...*
Hella yes.
yeah.. so many top comments from years ago, saying sulli's a top visual lol...
i remember liking her way back after seeing her in rum pum pum, with her orange hair. she looked like a baby, it was dang cute. i wasn't really following any kpop recently so i only heard of it now...
f(x) is unique. All of their members are visuals, good singers and good dancers. Nobady compares to them.
고블린 앨범 나왔을 때 멜론 댓글창 뭐라고 도배된줄 아세요? 설리가 에프엑스 망쳐놓고 왜 노래내냐 어쩌구 욕만 있었어요 근데 설리가 떠난후엔 갑자기 다들 자기가 쓴 댓글 다 지우고 애도하죠...진짜 너무 슬펐어요 이중성이 너무 심한거같아서요..다신 이런일이 안일어났으면 좋겠네요
@꽃보다강민 인정...나 고블린 티저영상에서 그런댓 봤음
근데그럴수밖에없지 탈퇴한설리는 노래내주고 4년동안컴백못한에펙인데 당연히 원망스러웠지..인신공격하는 사람들이 나쁜거지 저정도 비판은 할수있다고봄 설리 물론 너무안타깝지만 진짜 에펙망친건 사실이니까...
설리가 떠난 건 정말 안타까운 일이죠.. 탈퇴 후에 뭐만하면 욕을 먹고 그랬으니.. 그런 악플들은 싹 다 사라져야 합니다. 근데 그거와는 별개로 무대에서 무기력한 태도를 보여 팬들에게 질타를 받았던건 어쩔 수 없는 일이었다고 봐요. 솔직히 초창기와는 다르게 의욕도 없어보이고 팬들 입장에서는 설리가 아이돌 가수란 직업에 대한 책임감이 없어보였고 갑자기 탈퇴 해버리니 미운 시선이 따라다녔던건 어쩔 수 없었던거 같아요. 물론 그와 상관없이 사소한 걸로 꼬투리 잡고 욕하던 댓글들은 정말 고소당해도 할 말 없죠. 참 안타깝네요
@@훙냥냥-p9v 연옌은 이미지로먹고사는직업인데 이미지 이미안좋아졌는데 당연히 팬들은 설리가 원망스러울수밖에 없죠 에펙은 안나오고 설리는 솔로곡을 내준거니까...수정이 솔로곡 내달라고 말많았는데 설리가 나오니까..물론 인신공격은진짜 나쁜거죠 그때 뭐 임신루머같은거 하지만 대중들에게 평가받는 직업이기때문입니다...팬들은 책임감없는 설리를 원망할수밖에없죠..
설리탓할게 아니지
우울증이 그렇게 심했는데, 다 차치하고 그룹활동 계속했으면 급행복해지나? 자신을 포기하고 했어야 함?
사람있고 에프엑스있는거죠. 일이 이렇게 되고 보면 당시 진짜 힘들어서 더 할수없었나보다 하는 생각이 들겠구만, 언제까지 그래도 욕먹을건 욕먹어야 한다며 악플달건지?
솔직히 이미 헤어진지 4년 쯤이었을 때도, 그룹 이미지 어쩌고 하면서 설리탓하는 건 그냥 만만한 핑계거리 찾아 패는거밖엔 안 되어요. 그저 악플러면서 떳떳한척까지 하는 건 웃김.
설리가 끝에 열심히 안 했다손쳐도, 그래서 탈퇴했잖아요. 열심히 할수있는 상태가 아니니까 자기 행동 책임지고 나갔는데 뭘 더 원하는건지 모르겠음. 안 나가고 열심히 해야된다 이 답을 정해놓고 정작 개개인은 안 보고 있잖아요
고블린이 무슨 솔로앨범 타이틀이었던 것도 아니고, 배우 개그맨 여러사람들이 일회성으로 슴스테 싱글내는거. 마치 단독앨범 나온것처럼 과장해서 욕박았던 것도 웃기고. 갈라선지가 4년이나 된 사람의 활동을 사사건건 걸고 넘어질거면, 현멤버 개인활동은 어떻게 욕 안 박고 넘어갔나? 설리가 앨범을 내든말든 연기 활동을 어떻게 하든 에프엑스랑은 상관 없어졌고, 정작 상관있는건 현멤버 개인 활동인데.
그리고 설리가 탈퇴해서 에프엑스 그룹이 망한것처럼 말하는 건 다른 에프엑스멤버한테도 실례입니다. 설리 없으면 그룹이 없는거냐.
에프엑스도 연차가 있는데 그룹활동 안 나왔던 건 여러 이유가 있었겠죠. 설리탈퇴 후 안 나온것도 아니고: 4 walls 있었고요. 더 낼려면 더 냈겠죠. 슴스테 다른 멤버도 했었고 개인활동도 각자 있고 그런건 다 무시하고 설리 타켓잡는건 너무 한 것
Wow.Sulli is rapping now like Minho.Yay! Minsul..HAHAHA.
확실히 크리스탈 진짜 대박이다 외모+피지컬+표정+음색+춤선 뭐 하나 빠지는게 없구나
세상에서 제일 밝고 예쁜 별이 됐길 바라요
Ever since someone else noticed that Victoria's fans never cheer when she sings, ive been noticing it nonstop and its seriously bugging me. WHERE THE FANS AT?? WHERE THE LOVE AT?? Seriously, she never gets any love. VICTORIA'S FANS UNITE!
i would totally cheer for her lol...she has A CRAPLOAD of chinese fans, shes actually the most popular fx member in china, but im not so sure abt korea
inSAMity L Victoria's popular among chinese fans because she's chinese...obviously. krystal and sulli are considered the most popular in korea, and rightly so.
Jamie K. She's not popular among the Korean fans obviously because she's not korean....
Oh my god I didn't even notice until I read your comment. Where all the Victoria fans at? D:
Right here i love them all equally
이제와서 힘내라고말하고싶어도 듣지못하고 대답도못듣는다고 생각하니 너무 답답하고 미안한마음이 들어서 눈물나...... .....
@@잉여-d9v 뭐래요ㅜㅜ
@@잉여-d9v 좀 지워주지...나빠
to all u people who are always hating on fx and sulli especially, why dont you just become a kpop star yourself, if u can do any better?
I know right?? She does well to me
Gonnacry?
Sulli Baby I Missed You so Much
저 시절로 돌아가고 싶다ㅎㅎ 좋아하는 아이돌 컴백 한다 그러면 발매 전부터 재킷 사진 확인하고 티저 확인하고 설레면서 기다렸다가 뮤비 나오면 몇번이고 돌려보고.. ㅠㅠ 지금은 왜 저런 열정이 없는지😂 누군가를 좋아하고 응원하는 열정이 얼마나 삶에 에너지를 주는건지 저땐 몰랐어..에프엑스도 응원하던 그룹중에 하나였는데 그립다..
I love how people expect sulli to perform well even though she was depressed and was going through a really hard time :) such a great fan
+Orne Lla from the hate
It's her job. If she's too depressed to do her job well she shouldn't perform at all. That's like saying "I don't expect a doctor to do a good job on a surgery because the doctor is depressed." I do love Sulli and hope the best for her, but being an idol and performing well is her job regardless of her depression, and if she was feeling so depressed she couldn't perform her job well, she shouldn't have been on that stage at all.
***** that's something insensitive to say tbh? Because when you're depressed you'll not care about yourself or about anything because of it
You will forget to shower and to clean from depression
You'll completely shut out of the world from it
So saying stuff like that is really insensitive towards her honestly and you know how sm won't let their idols rest proof number exo :)
+Twice Jeongyeon damn that was harsh
+Twice Jeongyeon If she was too depressed and didn't perform I bet you'll be like "oh sulli didn't even put in effort" Ugh people like you can never be satisfied🙄
How great fx is.. has 2 visual. . Krystal and sully.. they are the most gorgeous girlgroup member in kpop.. but now just Krystal
Also Vic!! Krystal is gorgeous too but Vic is so rare and Sulli is just the prettiest of them all in my opinion. Luna's beautiful as well and Amber's amazing so idk how to choose :P
Am I the only who thinks that Victoria is the prettiest in the group?
That's your opinion Tess Tran
+Tess Tran Well people prefer Krystal and sulli because of their young look but Victoria is def the prettiest in the group with Krystal 👑👑❤❤
Lol Lol
Of course, it's all opinion, but to me it was always Victoria ^_^ Second for me is Sulli.
내가 젤 좋아하는게 레드 라이트 일렉트릭쇼크 설리임 진짜 너무 너무 이쁘고 자기일 열심히 하는 프로 같고 어리지만 강하고 멋있었네 ..이제 두번 다시 못본다는게 맘아프다 ..
How can a person be as hot as Krystal? Her body is goals. Bye.
+TheHurricaneVenus I hope she got a weapon permit for her body because it can make man die like flies. I nearly died by heart attack when I first saw her here
sulli's so pretty in this comeback
이 날 설리직캠 유툽에 없나요? 너무 예뻐서 어이가 없네요
sulli is DROP DEAD GORGEOUS, so beautiful and i'm a girl saying this! the haters she has are just jealous little girls. seriously. she OBVIOUSLY looks pale, and in her eyes you could tell she isnt well at all! sm doesnt give a shit.
i think sulli would be better off being a model. she's so tall, gorgeous, and underrated! she's always hated by jerks! -_-
i so agree with you , idk why ppl are being so judgemental but hey those ppls are born with bitch mouth so definately that wont stop ..we cant deny that fact so thats why we must live with our own perspective...but they are rly getting on my nerves with all those hateful comments , no matter what sulli do ppl are nvr going to appreciate her cuz they are just blinded .....i have so many words to say to all those haters but my words will be to cheap for their ears so i gave up long time back ...tsk ...any ways i m rly happy to see your comment
no problem but honestly most sm fans are like 'oh i love you!' one day and then they are bashing their idols the next day :/
haha fans now a days are so unpredictable , they are so good with changing lanes , ergghh i m so tired with their drama's any ways the sooner they realise that their rantings wont make any difference the more better it will be for them x3
we call those fans fake. most fans nowadays dunno what the meaning of 'fake fans' are or are blind to see that they are fake themselves.
"sm doesn't give a shit." if they didn't care, they obviously wouldn't have cut their promotions short. think a bit.
I miss sulli:(
same :/
i wanted to hear her voice again and see her perform
Me too
HeyVillaseñor me too I miss her much
I miss her too
this suddenly showed up in my recommended and I can't believe it's been 6 years since this song came out. So much has changed since then...
Krystal looks really beautiful with blonde hair!
ever since i found f(x) through the taiwanese drama with calvin, i only see victoria. she is so beautiful...sooo beautiful. idk, imo, victoria is the visual. i love all the members tho. while you debate over sulli...imma stay in my lane and stan victoria.
I actually like Sulli AND Victoria they're both really attractive to me. I can't choose between them
+Park Soo Yoo you right.. debate bout sulli never come to any solution though.. keep supporting fx guys!
Shes underrated beauty, she's fierce and sexy , her looks could prolly kill
I’m a MeU OT5 since 2011…I miss so much f(x), even if now I have MAMAMOO by my side. I feel nostalgic reading the old comments when the Kpop industry was in its golden age. I miss also and especially you Sulli, my first and precious Ultimate Bias. When you left f(x) in 2014 I would have never imagined you leaving us in 2019, after your masterpiece Goblin. I hope you are happy and free more than ever now and thanks to you I’m an Uaena today. May you Rest In Peace.
I'm a MeU since early 2014. Sulli is also my first and ultimate bias in whole K-industry. I feel the same. Her departure from the group was still bearable but when she left in 2019, I was shattered. Good to see people like you genuinely appreciating her. ❤️
Sulli looks so beautiful in this performance :c
I really miss my bias :'(
I want her back, please!!!
Sulli looks so perfect in this OMG. And damn, those heels. Props to them 👏👏👏
레드라이트는 설리밖에 생각안남 넘예뽀
설리가 너무 예쁘니까 에펙스 노래가 거의 설리가 썸네일이네 설리 보고싶다
今でも本当にf(x)が恋しいです､､､。
설리 진짜 너무 예쁘다... 너무 예뻐서 육성으로 와 했네 진짜 이쁘다
F(x) is irreplaceable. Concept, visuals and talents. My Ghad I miss them
이때 설리 카메라도 잘 못보는게 이제 힘들었던게 보이네요.. 여기서도 너무 예쁘고 빛나는데.. 이때고 지금이고 이 사실을 알아줬음 좋겠네요.. 언제나 행복하길
f(x)가 너무 그리워요 나는 온 마음을 다해 이 소녀들을 사랑합니다.
설리야 편해야해 꼭.
크리스탈 최애인데 진심 너무 이쁘다... 하고 싶은거 다 해줘 언니ㅠㅠㅠ 거기다가 비디터 유튜브가 언젠간 이 곡도 댓글 읽기를 할 거 같다...
썸네일 뭐야…? 홀린듯이 들어왓음 개이쁘다 진짜
why are people hating on Sulli? anyone care to explain?
' Coz they're haters ;)
Sully es hermosa :3 envidia
because she's obviously not feeling well, but they all hate on her and bully her, saying she's untalented, when she's just not feeling well. -.- they shouldnt have a right to do that. they're not as talented as her, i will bet on that 100%
Because her boyfriend is 14 years older than her.
thats none of your fucking business or the fans. LMFAO. what the actual fuck.
Omg sulli is so pretty in this video 😻😻
우리나라 아이돌 중 가장 세련된 노래를 의미까지 담아 선보였던 유일무이한 걸그룹~
I miss f(x) so much. The ending pose at 3:28 really made me tear up from nostalgia. They really deserved the best, yet... well, I won't say because you all should know what I'm alluding to. Anyway, love one another, be kind, and be yourself. It's one of the many things I've learned from stanning a unique group like f(x).
i think the reason thats why they hate sulli is because sulli is almost a perfect person she's pretty,tall and talented they just hate her because they are jealous
Right...
정말로 다른 멤버 이목구비 뚜렷하고 너무 예뻐도 설리만 보인다..진짜 어떻게 저렇게 이쁘고 키도 크냐 성격까지 마음에 듬..최고야
I miss Sulli, and she is so gorgeous here!
Sulli has this model like vibe in her aura ..... she is tall and gorgeous one of the most beautiful visual in kpop's girl groups 😍😍😍😍😍
Sulli choi miss ur face and smile she doesn't deserve to suicide she's a strong and nice girl
Is sullli the blonde girl
@@dreampug7117 3:26 is Sulli.
@@dreampug7117 no .... She's the one with brown long hairs
Soojung killed me ! 😳
Sulli is so tall. I like tall girls
I'm short 😭 *cries in a corner* hehe^^
Jung Soo Yeon then do something! haha xDDD
Sulli is 170, Victoria is tall too she's 168
aveen sdiq I love Joy too!
+aveen sdiq I miss my girls ..Words can't even explain😢😭
本当にコンセプトもすべてすきだった😢
okay they all look gorg as usual but sulli looks like a queen here? like ok why are u so pretty?
I miss Sulli and f(5) so much!! :'( I hope she can comeback soon...
where is she?? she's ok??
Hiisabel Caarrillo Taking a break.
Issaberu' CM taking break because of choiza.
www.eatyourkimchi.com/eatyourkimchi-awards-android/ VOTE!
I remember when I was actively following all their performances this era as a sulli bias and felt so heartbroken seeing all the hate she got this cb because of all the rumors...all the rough times hoping that she would come back...i love you so much my sweet peach angel. you deserved better and i really hope this time around people will start to consider idol's feelings before they spread hate.
That years when all of Kpop female groups were so strong. Striking visuals, real talents, and amazing personalities. Snsd, 2ne1, Sistar, Fx, after school, 4minutes, Miss A. Damn realize so many new groups now with shitty concepts and less talents and one by one those queens are disbanded. What a world
Divo Galindra oh my god this is so true.
Nowadays rap is almost always about how better they are than everyone or their success. It's annoying how a group can debut with singers that are just about average and ppl will praise them but if Luna where to miss a high note she'd be hated on. Many groups can debut nowadays and became amazingly famous but the girl groups you listed didn't get it right from debut. SNSD debuted in America and Suju where also very popular Wonder Girls to yet as soon as a 3rd gen group debuts in America everyone is like they brought kpop to America or they made kpop worldwide. The kpop community needs to change.
What about blackpink they are amazing
Somita. Dalvand bp has the dancers, the rappers but not the singers. The groups above have all. Bp doesn't. The person who put up the comment is talking about when all of them where amazing.. Nowadays they're not a amazing
What you saying they can't sing 😐definitely ur need to listen to the blackpink song
Omg Sulli😍is so beautiful 😍
저 시절 설리는 진짜 개이뻤어❤ㅠㅠ 보고싶네
all of F(x) adds a different vibe
Sulli adds a cute yet srong vibe
Krystal adds a sexy vibe
Luna gives off the tough and confident vibe
Amber gives off power
Victoria (my bias