I have seen the film of “The Message” but I never heard anything about our Beloved Prophet’s voice being used at all in the film. Maybe it was edited out afterwards but I watched it as a new Muslim a few months after reverting but now after reading deep into the Sunnah of our Beloved Prophet ﷺ I see that there is no need for a film to be made at all, we can see the beauty of his character all throughout the his (ﷺ) Sunnah. May Allah Azzawajal keep us firm upon following the Quran and the Sunnah of our Beloved Prophet Muhammad ﷺ strictly in the understanding of the first 3 pious generations.
I'm not a Muslim but I love reading about Medieval History. The Muslim led Andalucía was founded by a descendant of the Umayyad caliphate (Sunni) in the late 700. The Fatimid Caliphate (Shia) started more than 100 years later in 909 and far from Spain.
@@sidelladan3792 truth? You know what the truth is? The truth is Fatima (SA) died unhappy with Abu Bakr because he didn’t give her her share of right from the property of Fadak. Written in sahih bukhari. Wallahi, those who upset the Ahlul Bayt (AS), upset the Prophet (SAW) & Allah (SWT).
This is the way of Ahlusunnah to have a civil debate. Love brother Shamsi. Indeed its a red line how they can even portray and attribute any voice to Rasul Allah ﷺ . His ﷺ shimail is enough to for any believer to feel His ﷺ presence.
❤ ❤❤ big love for brother shamsi I am from Pakistan we love Beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUH more than our self we can not become momin untill we love Nabi Kareem more than our self and all our family
SURAH 2:134 - That was a community that had already gone before. For them is what they earned and for you is what you have earned. And you will not be accountable for what they have done.
Walahi Ali would cry if anyone praised him over Abu Bakar, the companions of the prophet(peace and blessings be upon him) loved each other and they loved Abu Bakar greatly after the prophet of Allah. And it is part of our religion to love them and ask Allah to forgive us and them. May Allah guide us all, ameen.
@@mjkk6205 how will this benefit you! Allah already promised forgiveness to them. And all commanded us to ask forgiveness from Allah for ourselves and those who Proceeded us in faith. Allah didn’t say look for their mistakes. And you can’t BLEIVE how much help Abu Bakar provided to the Prophet SAWS. STOP IT! Walahi leave your hatred for the prophet’s companions. And even more the prophet promised paradise to Abu Bakar. Who are you and I to every say anything displeasing about Abu Bakar. And why would it matter even if he drank before Islam, a lot of the companions used to do un-Islamic things before Islam, but don’t you know that Allah forgives All the sins done before your acceptance of Islam. And even after excepting Islam, Allah is still the most forgiving! May Allah guide us, ameen.
I won’t say anything bad about Abu Bakr, and I even respect my Sunni brothers. But the Prophet gave Valiyat to Mowla Ali. Of course we will always until we die praise Imam Ali AS over Abu Bakr. Mo Deen is not a proper representatives for Shias, he dresses like a middle schooler.
10:38 It’s too sad to see what Shias is doing to tell us that Imam Ali radei Allah anh mentioned in the Quran. Alhammdulillah that Quran is protected by millions of Muslims so people like this guy can’t just say whatever he wants to say.
So you love the khaleefa not appointed by the prophet and hated by the daughter of the prophet when she died? Are you crazy? You love him because you’re blind.
@@yourmomshouse8993 Are you insane... Prophet( swaws) commanded Abu bakr( rd) to lead the prayers while he was ill... Abu bakr( rd) was the imam of Ali ibn talib( rd) .... Abu bakr( rd) never hated the prophet( swaws) daughter... you been seeking knowledge from the shia 👿....
@@yourmomshouse8993 Ali(ra) is reported to have said in shia book: و إنا لنرى أبا بكر أحق بها - أي بالخلافة - إنه لصاحب الغار. و إنا لنعرف سنه. و لقد أمرنا رسول الله صلى الله عليه و سلم بالصلاة خلفه و هو حي )))). نهج البلاغة، تحقيق العالم الشيعي الشريف الرضي 1 / 132 Ali(ra) said: “And we see Abu Bakr more fit to receive it (Caliphate) For he is Sahib Al Ghar (Mentioned in the Quran as the second of Two whom Allah is their third) and we know his age and the Prophet PBUH had ordered us to pray Behind him when he was Alive”. (Nahjul Balagha, Tahqeeq Allamah Shareef el Redah 1/132).
@@yourmomshouse8993 Ali said: “If I didn’t feel that he (Abu Bakr) deserved to rule, I would have not allowed him to do so.” (Sharh Nahj al Balagha by Ibn Abi al Hadeed vol.2 pg.45)
My brothers, the Messenger of God..He is the rank and rank of the Messenger of God, rather he is the master of the elite of the five messengers..Prophecy is the stage of the beginning and the end..The Prophet is a follower of the one before him and he is Jesus.
We really need to start building bridges with the shia community. Start speaking with kindness. Id imagine shias are sincere in their beliefs and only seek the truth as are the sunnis. We really need to get this idea that we can not speak to each other because of what happened 1300 years ago. We should really come together and talk as brothers and trade knowledge instead of slandering each other
When someone is cursing your own mother and the companions of the prophets ! How do you imagine being kind to them !? They have fed this hatred since their childhood ! Yet alhamdulelah we have many dua at that go and debates with the shias , they are the ones thats run away always ! Yet they call themselves ahl albayt followers !
@@MrCaprice90 Exactly. Many shia have been to speaker's corner and they were very rude and insulting. They are taught to insult and show anger when their arguments start falling apart.
@@MrCaprice90 So if Muawiyah cursed Imam Ali (AS), Hazrat Bibi Fatima Zehra (SA) PBUH and HF didn't speak to Abu Bakr, is that bad. Bro, bro, bro there's so many proof like cmon man.
@@HiHi-ek1dd Thats your problem you just only hear and don’t go and search, give me a 1 sahih hadith about moaiah cursing ali straight and forward I will wait
The funny thing was... All Muslim Including sayidina abu bakr mandatory to recite shlawat when perform shalat That the shalawat recites was include sayidina Ali, sayidah fatimah along with sayidina hasan and sayidina Husain No scholar in all sect of islam... Exclude ahli kisa and ahli mubahalah as ahlul bayt Allohuma sholi ala sayidina muhammad Wa ala *aali sayidina muhammad* So... Do you understand that fact??
Asalam ma laykum in these blessed days may allah bless and ease the sufferings of the ummah and may allah unite the ummah upon the quran and sunnah and may allah have mercy on all those that have passed away before us and may Allah have mercy on us when we pass away and may allah cure all those that have a sickness and a disability and may allah grant them a cure that leaves no aliment and may allah protect the muslims from hellfire and from the fitnah of dajjal and may allah answer all our prayers ameen
Bro I’m a Sunni, and I actually get upset for the Shia community when this guy debates on their behalf. Like please bring someone learned. How can you not correctly recite a verse from the Quran (which by the way, is supposed to be the IMPLICIT reference to Ali RA - which it is not)… like if the Ayah is that important for the Shiie school of thought, it should roll of his tongue. I’m sorry but the guy is a joke and I’m trying to be as nice as possible…. Shamsi needs to debate someone a little more… qualified?
@@exhilitydraws3417 I mean there needs to be some type of benefit to the discussion. That can't happen when one of the parties is either ignorant or insincere.
Shamsi said "There are 2 Tabari, One Shia source and one Sunni source". This is true and Farid showed books from both of them. they have the same name. If anyone is interested then let me know and I will try to find the video of Farid. the video is either about the Battle of Jamal, the killing of Usman or the karbala.
Al-Bukhari reported that, Aisha narrated that the Prophet (S) ordered Abu Bakr to lead the prayer, but later the Prophet decided to go to mosque and he went in front of Abu Bakr and led the prayer instead of Abu Bakr. Here is the tradition of al-Bukhari as claimed by Aisha: Sahih al-Bukhari Tradition: 1.680 Narrated Aisha: When the Prophet, became ill in his fatal illness, Someone came to inform him about the prayer, and the Prophet told him to tell Abu Bakr to lead the people in the prayer. I said, "Abu Bakr is a soft-hearted man and if he stands for the prayer in your place, he would weep and would not be able to recite the Qur’an.”The Prophet said, "Tell Abu Bakr to lead the prayer.”I said the same as before. He (repeated the same order and) on the third or the fourth time he said, "You are the companions of Joseph. Tell Abu Bakr to lead the prayer.”So Abu Bakr led the prayer and meanwhile the Prophet felt better and came out with the help of two men; as if I see him just now dragging his feet on the ground. When Abu Bakr saw him, he tried to retreat but the Prophet beckoned him to carry on. Abu Bakr retreated a bit and the Prophet sat on his (left) side. Abu Bakr was repeating the Takbir (Allahu Akbar) of Allah’s Apostle for the people to hear. The fact, however, is that the Prophet never ordered Abu Bakr to lead the prayer. This can be proven by the following reasons: 1. Based on the above Tradition, if the Prophet was the one who ordered Abu Bakr to lead the prayer, then why he later went to mosque and lead the prayer by himself? (Based on other traditions, the Prophet even pushed Abu Bakr away with his hand). Why such humiliation toward Abu Bakr? This proves that once the Prophet realized the plot of Aisha, he became very angry and with all his illness, he decided to go to mosque to prevent what others now claim!!! Remember What Aisha said in the above tradition: "The Prophet came out (to lead the prayer) with the help of two men; as if I see him just now dragging his feet on the ground.”This shows that the condition of the Prophet was severe, yet he was so angry at the plot of Aisha and the implication of leading the prayer by Abu Bakr that he decided to stop it at any cost. 2. All Muslims agree that the Prophet had ordered Abu Bakr and Umar to join the camp led by Usamah Ibn Zaid, and as such they should have been outside Medina where the camp was located. Then, the existence of Abu Bakr and Umar and others inside Medina was illegal and was against the order of the Prophet (S). How can, then, the Prophet order Abu Bakr to lead the prayer inside Medina while he was supposed to be outside Medina with the direct order of the Prophet?! The Messenger of Allah said: "May the curse of Allah be upon those who turn away from the army of Usamah”and he ordered the army to be dispatched immediately, and ordered all Helpers and all Immigrants except ‘Ali to leave Medina. But some companions disobeyed and complained about the leadership of Usamah (See Sahih al-Bukhari, Arabic-English version, Tradition #5.552, 5.744 and 5.745) and they delayed in joining the camp, and finally returned to Medina, in order to prepare themselves for discussion about successorship as soon as the Messenger of Allah passes away. Aisha further claimed that the Prophet (S) expired while he was resting on her chest. This claim contradicts the narrations transmitted and recorded by others. In the tradition reported by Imam ‘Ali as recorded by Ibn Sa’d who named consecutive sources up to Imam ‘Ali, we read: ‘Ali said: "In the last moments of his life, the Messenger of Allah said: ‘Call me my brother.’ So I approached him. He asked me to get nearer to him and I got quite close to him. He leaned on me and continued resting on my chest and speaking to me till his spittle fell on me and the Messenger of Allah breathed his last." Sunni references: • al-Tabaqat, by Ibn Sa’d, v2, part 2, p51, in the Chapter entitled "The Prophet demised in ‘Ali’s lap" • Kanz al-Ummal, by al-Muttaqi al-Hindi, v1, p392
Ali RA is not mentioned in the Quran. Please be careful. He is of high importance in our deen but he is not mentioned in the book of Allah. Our Shia brothers and sisters must learn the truth and follow the nabi pubh and the Quran. Full stop.
you need to read Quran first to find His name, if you need more let me know otherwise check your DNA please! both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 67 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida has been revealed on Ghadir day and for the sake of Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship (walaya) Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 249 Verse 9 in Chapter An-Nisa urges everyone to obey Imam Ali (A.S) and the other Imams (A.S) Sunni: Shavahed Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 202 according to Verse 3 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida, one’s faith is completed by accepting Ghadir and Imam Ali’s (A.S) successorship Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 211 both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 7 in Chapter al-Bayyina is about Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship and that he is the best benefactor Sunni: Dur al-Manthur, verse interpretation that both Shiites and Sunnis agree Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Ra’d introduce Imam Ali (A.S) as the best guide and director for Muslims Sunni: Musnad Ahmad, Chapter 2, Hadith 990 Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Anbiya suggests Imam Ali and other Imams (A.S) the meaning of “those who reminisce (possess) the Message Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, verse interpretation that both Shiites and Sunnis believe Imam Ali (A.S) possesses full insight of the Holy Quran according to Verse 43 in Chapter Al-Ra’d Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 400 “holding fast by the rope Allah (S.W.T) has stretched for you” in Verse 103 in Chapter Al-i-Imran means grasping on belief in Imam Ali’s and other Imam’s (A.S) guardianship Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 168 that both Shiites and Sunnis have identically narrated the famous hadith “Whoever I am his master, this Ali is his master Sunni: Musnad Ahmad Hanbal, Chapter 39, P 297, Hadith 18497
I think one of the Shiah Tabari wrote “Dala'il al-Imama” The Sunni Tabari (Muhammad ibn Jarir ibn Yazid) wrote “Tafsir al-Tabari” Easy to check which Tabari the Hadith is from
The most solid reason why Muslim don't allow film painting of a prophet "walamyakullahuu kufuwan ahad"and nothing is like him,same for beloved prophet for whole we are here to mentally glorifying thinking about prophet ,you know every sunnah is to glorify Allah means thought about holy prophet how he did yes you can change,and at any mood the most thrilling and beautiful face you imagine you can say even that is not his glimpse but its from him the holy prophet of Allah
I still don't understand why anyone is giving the the time of the day to Mo Deen..seriously why do these dawah guys give him any platform to these Jahil...!!!! When he comes to you just turn your back to this arrogant individual...he is a hypocrite of the highest level...
The thing is you know if someone in a majlis said while talking a priest said Mohammad a guy,in a rude way a ottoman soldier listened he punished the whole listener and than that place was made harram even to sow sead where that majlis was standing for seven years hearing any disrespect even talking that anything of heaven is more beautiful than sweat fragrance of rasool Allah saw is,blasphemy
Subhanallah , brother we both need to learn our religion better … is this from Quran and sunnah? … May Allah guide us to the straight path and make it soft and gentle happy and healthy upon us and our families ameen
Muhammad: Im the city of knowledge and Ali is the gate. Muhammad: Quran is with Ali and Ali is with Quran Muhammad: For who I am the leader, Ali is your leader. Sunni Islam- finished
According to who, you ?! You ignorant, the basics of Arabic language was put by Imam Ali AS originally and you call his followers ignorant of the language! I swear the youngest non-Arabic one of his followers knows more in the Arabic language than your whole bunch of fake wahhabi scholars nowadays!
@Mohammed Ali these debates take us away from focusing on the real issues and gives Shamzi The opportunity to dominate the debate and avoid discussing the real issues. The lady of Heaven film was irrelevant to this discussion.
There is only one name mentioned in the Qur'an except all the prophets and that is if zaid bin harisa (33:37) These Shias are completely blinded in their own terminology
Harun to Musa? harun died before Musa, and Yusha was after Musa. So look at the context of the saying and when and why it was said. Jeez guys, basic research will take you out of the fold of shiasm!
According to Christ, the father is the one true god (John 17:3). Christ spoke Aramaic, go look up what god is in Christs language. And put this verse together
@@Spark12429 when did I say otherwise. I am a Sunni and I have studied shia sect for a number of years. He is a clown. A clown doesn’t spit such rubbish as he has. If you are supporting him you an even bigger clown.
@@ferhattahar7372 see how Moo Deen interact with other muslim debaters within years.. how about when he debate with Mohamad Hijab?? Remember what Mohamad Hijab told him?? Unless you're Shia fanatics
Shamsi listen that movie I watched that movie the main producer failed the first time second time an English and Canadian producer they restart and complete that movie! They non Muslim who that make it "but the writer he's a Muslim person!"
both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 67 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida has been revealed on Ghadir day and for the sake of Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship (walaya) Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 249 Verse 9 in Chapter An-Nisa urges everyone to obey Imam Ali (A.S) and the other Imams (A.S) Sunni: Shavahed Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 202 according to Verse 3 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida, one’s faith is completed by accepting Ghadir and Imam Ali’s (A.S) successorship Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 211 both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 7 in Chapter al-Bayyina is about Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship and that he is the best benefactor Sunni: Dur al-Manthur, verse interpretation that both Shiites and Sunnis agree Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Ra’d introduce Imam Ali (A.S) as the best guide and director for Muslims Sunni: Musnad Ahmad, Chapter 2, Hadith 990 Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Anbiya suggests Imam Ali and other Imams (A.S) the meaning of “those who reminisce (possess) the Message Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, verse interpretation that both Shiites and Sunnis believe Imam Ali (A.S) possesses full insight of the Holy Quran according to Verse 43 in Chapter Al-Ra’d Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 400 “holding fast by the rope Allah (S.W.T) has stretched for you” in Verse 103 in Chapter Al-i-Imran means grasping on belief in Imam Ali’s and other Imam’s (A.S) guardianship Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 168 that both Shiites and Sunnis have identically narrated the famous hadith “Whoever I am his master, this Ali is his master Sunni: Musnad Ahmad Hanbal, Chapter 39, P 297, Hadith 18497 Make sure to confirm books i have read are from Sunni Fiqah if you need more let me know will give you more of those lets follow Quran
In my opinion I use my current knowledge and say that in the end of the day Abu baker and Ali the son in law of Mohamed, died more than a 1000 years ago , and Allah specified us not to be in any sects, I don't understand why we are fighing about something and people who are not here anymore , Islam is islam and our prophet is Mohamad and all of the prophets , it does not matter if anyone is an offspring from them as that does not mean they should be the leaders as they could be totaly evil or sinners like Noah's son and also I am not saying that everyone should accept what i say but consider it. politics from 1400 years ago lead to the cold war between Suadia and Iran and the deaths of many people.
That's exactly what sunah is why fighting over such a thing if someone was bad let allah deal with him we don't curse anyone . But the thing is the shia's re always mentioning that .
Disagreeing and arguing about religion is good thing as it means the religion is alive in our community. Religions that do not have disagreements and arguing going on in them are dead religions such as old pagan cults: nobody even cares about them anyomer. The problem is when arguments about theology go outside the realm of scholarship and academics, and are taken by laymen to the street, thus causing social tensions and fragmenting the society. Making it a fertile soil for political sectarianism and conflicts.
We could collaborate financially and militarily, while leaving our theological differences to be handled by scholars and academic debates on Television. Muslims, sunni or shia, have proven that they could coexist with LGBT, christian, atheis, jewish and secular peoples in the West under liberal irreligious laws. SO why wouldnt we coexist between different sects of Islam that have much more in common than in the West, under agreed upon basic fundamental islamic principles?
Salam, does Bukhari and others not say, Fatima died angry with AbuBakr? Is this not a Sahih hadith? Also, does Bukhari not state: Rasulillah said whoever angers Fatima (a.s) angers me. Even if you want to believe this is about imam Ali (a.s), you can't deny Fatima died angry with AbuBakr and not Ali. How do you explain this? It's also a fact that no one knows where Fatima (a.s) was buried (except imam Ali (a.s)), as requested by Fatima (a.s). On the day of judgement we will face Rasulillah (S), who's side will you be on, Fatima (a.s) or AbuBakr? Do you think Rasulillah (S) will take sides with AbuBakr? Will you dissociate yourself from the people who angered Fatima? Please explain your point of view. I would like to learn.
1. Tell us the whole story. Why was Fatimah radiallahu anha angry? Do Prophets leave behind wealth as inheritance? Who was right, Abu Bakr (who heard and narrated that Prophets don't leave behind wealth) or Fatimah radiallahu anhuma? 2. Ali radiallahu anh gave bay'a to those who angered Fatimah, so according to your logic Ali has a problem with Allah now. 3. Abu Bakr radiallahu anh was the only sahabi who was named sahabi in the Quran 4. Allah praised ALL the muhajireen and ansaar. You base your whole religion on a handful of events in history. Where is your religion in Quran, show me a clear cut verse?
I have nothing but respect for my Sunni brothers and sisters (those moderate ones) even if some Wahabis Sunnis claim Shia are kuffar and are killing them in cold blood .We have to look thoroughly at the virtues of Imam Ali compared to the two Khalifa's. what Imam Ali gave to to the Islamic religion from victories in the battlefield and wisdom , equality and justice throughout his time .why where the two not present in the prophets burial why did Fatima die upset towards the two Khalifa's, these questions need to be researched and answered with all honesty and dignity .
If you really have nothing but respect, why don't you quote the hadith in which Fatima was angry at Ali himself. Al-Bukhaari and Muslim narrated that al-Miswar ibn Makhramah said: ‘Ali proposed to the daughter of Abu Jahl. When Faatimah heard of that she came to the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and said to him: Your people are saying that you do not get angry for the sake of your daughters, and ‘Ali is going to marry the daughter of Abu Jahl. The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) stood up and I heard him when he recited the shahaadah, then he said: “I gave a daughter of mine in marriage to Abu’l-‘Aas ibn al-Rabee’, and when he spoke he told me the truth. Faatimah bint Muhammad is a part of me, and I do not like for her to be hurt. By Allaah, the daughter of the Messenger of Allaah and the daughter of the enemy of Allaah will not be joined together as wives of one man.” So ‘Ali abandoned that proposal. So basically, it was ALI himself who hurt her and caused her to be andry, and he was the reason why the prophet said that, so why don't you accuse Ali of angering Allah? Also, Fatima got angry at Abu bakr because he decided to follow the ruling of the prophet pbuh himself about his inheritance, so are you gonna tell me that Abu Bakr should have disobeyed the messenger of God to make Fatima happy ?
@@osumanaaa9982 t The first hadith (tradition) in ‘Elal al-Sharaye’ is regarding a person who lied to Lady Fatima Zahra about Ali seeking the hand of Abul Jahl’s daughter for marriage. In reality, there was no such incident and the false news about Ali bin Abi Talib (as) was spread by his (as) enemies who wanted to create discord between Fatima and Ali, peace be upon them.(therefore its a false hadeeth )The alleged story of Ali bin Abi Talib (as) intending to marry Abu Jahl’s daughter is not conforming the facts and realities in history because Abu Jahl’s daughter resided in Makkah whereas Ali (as) had married Fatima (sa) in Medina and were living there. The fact is that this hadith had been fabricated by the opponents in order to steer public mind from the caliphs to Ali (as). They wanted to direct naïve masses’ attention to Ali (as) rather than to the sufferings and pains which Fatima (sa) received at the hands of the caliphs.
@@osumanaaa9982 The Prophet (s) said, “Fatima is part of me - what saddens her saddens me, and what pleases her pleases me.”Al-Sunan Al-Kubra, v. 7, p. 64, the chapter on what will transpire on the Day of Judgement; Muntakhab Kenz Al-Omal, in the margins of Al-Musnad, v. 5, p. 96. your argument is false
@@hman3966 You're making a claim without substantiating it. If you're gonna label the hadith as fabrication, you need to have at least proofs. If you're gonna only accept the narrations that suit you and reject those that refute you, then that's double standards. Also you seem to be using Ali's achievements as a proof for something, but let's not forget he's not the only one who has done things for the sake of Allah. Abu bakr faced the apostates and compiled the Quran, Umar conquered Jerusalem and Uthman standardized the Quran. We love Ali too, maybe in a more appropriate way than you guys do.
Then stop lying about them, because the one who is doing the killing of the sunnah are the shiite in Syria and Iraq, the shite live unharmed in Saudi Arabia where the wahabis you are claiming killed you reign.
Shamsi was not allowed to watch lady of heaven its haram to watch a movie that is not based on true islam, but he clearly admits that he watched that movie! Tell me i am wrong... He says he did not watch it but if you rewind the video 1min he talks about the movie asif he had seen it , than instantly corrects himself because he know its haram, than he says a brother said it 2 me :) wallahi Shamsi watched that movie
I have seen the film of “The Message” but I never heard anything about our Beloved Prophet’s voice being used at all in the film. Maybe it was edited out afterwards but I watched it as a new Muslim a few months after reverting but now after reading deep into the Sunnah of our Beloved Prophet ﷺ I see that there is no need for a film to be made at all, we can see the beauty of his character all throughout the his (ﷺ) Sunnah. May Allah Azzawajal keep us firm upon following the Quran and the Sunnah of our Beloved Prophet Muhammad ﷺ strictly in the understanding of the first 3 pious generations.
I'm not a Muslim but I love reading about Medieval History. The Muslim led Andalucía was founded by a descendant of the Umayyad caliphate (Sunni) in the late 700. The Fatimid Caliphate (Shia) started more than 100 years later in 909 and far from Spain.
You get your history from Wikipedia
@@MOHAMMED-qw5ug Nope, not from Wikipedia..
Yes! I didn't appreciate this history when I was in secondary school...now I find it so interesting
@@helenteacher2615 shia always get angry when they hear the truth 🤣
@@sidelladan3792 truth? You know what the truth is? The truth is Fatima (SA) died unhappy with Abu Bakr because he didn’t give her her share of right from the property of Fadak. Written in sahih bukhari. Wallahi, those who upset the Ahlul Bayt (AS), upset the Prophet (SAW) & Allah (SWT).
This is the way of Ahlusunnah to have a civil debate. Love brother Shamsi. Indeed its a red line how they can even portray and attribute any voice to Rasul Allah ﷺ . His ﷺ shimail is enough to for any believer to feel His ﷺ presence.
May Allah reward brother Shamsi for his heart work 🙌🏻
❤ ❤❤ big love for brother shamsi I am from Pakistan we love Beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUH more than our self we can not become momin untill we love Nabi Kareem more than our self and all our family
Masha'allah
Masha'Allah
My God protect you
Very nice video
Thank you
Jazakum Allah khier
Mashallah shamsi has aloooots of information about anything and any book. May Allah protect him.
SURAH 2:134 - That was a community that had already gone before. For them is what they earned and for you is what you have earned. And you will not be accountable for what they have done.
Christians: "no thats not right, anyone could be punished for others sin"
Walahi Ali would cry if anyone praised him over Abu Bakar, the companions of the prophet(peace and blessings be upon him) loved each other and they loved Abu Bakar greatly after the prophet of Allah. And it is part of our religion to love them and ask Allah to forgive us and them. May Allah guide us all, ameen.
Bro Abu bakr used to get drunk, imam ali never drank
@@mjkk6205 how will this benefit you! Allah already promised forgiveness to them. And all commanded us to ask forgiveness from Allah for ourselves and those who Proceeded us in faith. Allah didn’t say look for their mistakes. And you can’t BLEIVE how much help Abu Bakar provided to the Prophet SAWS. STOP IT! Walahi leave your hatred for the prophet’s companions. And even more the prophet promised paradise to Abu Bakar. Who are you and I to every say anything displeasing about Abu Bakar. And why would it matter even if he drank before Islam, a lot of the companions used to do un-Islamic things before Islam, but don’t you know that Allah forgives All the sins done before your acceptance of Islam. And even after excepting Islam, Allah is still the most forgiving! May Allah guide us, ameen.
@@mjkk6205 we have reports that Ali r.a drank and lead prayer
I won’t say anything bad about Abu Bakr, and I even respect my Sunni brothers. But the Prophet gave Valiyat to Mowla Ali. Of course we will always until we die praise Imam Ali AS over Abu Bakr. Mo Deen is not a proper representatives for Shias, he dresses like a middle schooler.
@@edanisgreat5118 I don't F with Ali I respect Mo Deen
May Allah guide us all to the right path 🙏
May Allah guide all the shia to the right way to follow the Qur'an and sunnah.
(قَالَ هَٰذَا صِرَاطٌ عَلَيَّ مُسْتَقِيمٌ)
اختلفت القرّاء في قراءة قوله ( قَالَ هَذَا صِرَاطٌ عَلَيَّ مُسْتَقِيمٌ ) فقرأه عامَّة قراء الحجاز والمدينة والكوفة والبصرة ( هَذَا صِرَاطٌ عَلَيَّ مُسْتَقِيمٌ ) بمعنى: هذا طريق إليّ مستقيم.
No matter what mo deen is a good respectful guy .
May Allah bless the brother shamsi
10:38
It’s too sad to see what Shias is doing to tell us that Imam Ali radei Allah anh mentioned in the Quran. Alhammdulillah that Quran is protected by millions of Muslims so people like this guy can’t just say whatever he wants to say.
Lmao this guy is single handedly destroying the shia's image, Do your own research about Shiite beliefs instead of looking at these clowns
The guy with a glove saying whatever comes to his mind honestly
Abu Bakr our khaleefa ❤❤❤
So you love the khaleefa not appointed by the prophet and hated by the daughter of the prophet when she died? Are you crazy? You love him because you’re blind.
@@yourmomshouse8993 Are you insane... Prophet( swaws) commanded Abu bakr( rd) to lead the prayers while he was ill... Abu bakr( rd) was the imam of Ali ibn talib( rd) .... Abu bakr( rd) never hated the prophet( swaws) daughter... you been seeking knowledge from the shia 👿....
@@yourmomshouse8993
Ali(ra) is reported to have said in shia book:
و إنا لنرى أبا بكر أحق بها - أي بالخلافة - إنه لصاحب الغار. و إنا لنعرف سنه. و لقد أمرنا رسول الله صلى الله عليه و سلم بالصلاة خلفه و هو حي )))). نهج البلاغة، تحقيق العالم الشيعي الشريف الرضي 1 / 132
Ali(ra) said: “And we see Abu Bakr more fit to receive it (Caliphate) For he is Sahib Al Ghar (Mentioned in the Quran as the second of Two whom Allah is their third) and we know his age and the Prophet PBUH had ordered us to pray Behind him when he was Alive”. (Nahjul Balagha, Tahqeeq Allamah Shareef el Redah 1/132).
@@yourmomshouse8993 Ali said: “If I didn’t feel that he (Abu Bakr) deserved to rule, I would have not allowed him to do so.” (Sharh Nahj al Balagha by Ibn Abi al Hadeed vol.2 pg.45)
@@Spark12429 have you read sermon 3 called shaqshaqia? Read that then we can have a valid discussion.
Brother Shamsi
Please don't west your time may Allah bless and guide the other brother
He really said nta m9wd 😂
My brothers, the Messenger of God..He is the rank and rank of the Messenger of God, rather he is the master of the elite of the five messengers..Prophecy is the stage of the beginning and the end..The Prophet is a follower of the one before him and he is Jesus.
We really need to start building bridges with the shia community. Start speaking with kindness. Id imagine shias are sincere in their beliefs and only seek the truth as are the sunnis. We really need to get this idea that we can not speak to each other because of what happened 1300 years ago. We should really come together and talk as brothers and trade knowledge instead of slandering each other
When someone is cursing your own mother and the companions of the prophets ! How do you imagine being kind to them !? They have fed this hatred since their childhood !
Yet alhamdulelah we have many dua at that go and debates with the shias , they are the ones thats run away always ! Yet they call themselves ahl albayt followers !
@@MrCaprice90 Exactly. Many shia have been to speaker's corner and they were very rude and insulting. They are taught to insult and show anger when their arguments start falling apart.
@@MrCaprice90 So if Muawiyah cursed Imam Ali (AS), Hazrat Bibi Fatima Zehra (SA) PBUH and HF didn't speak to Abu Bakr, is that bad. Bro, bro, bro there's so many proof like cmon man.
@@osumanaaa9982 Bro...
@@HiHi-ek1dd
Thats your problem you just only hear and don’t go and search, give me a 1 sahih hadith about moaiah cursing ali straight and forward
I will wait
Abu baker sadeeq is the number one
The funny thing was...
All Muslim
Including sayidina abu bakr
mandatory to recite shlawat when perform shalat
That the shalawat recites was include sayidina Ali, sayidah fatimah along with sayidina hasan and sayidina Husain
No scholar in all sect of islam... Exclude ahli kisa and ahli mubahalah as ahlul bayt
Allohuma sholi ala sayidina muhammad
Wa ala *aali sayidina muhammad*
So...
Do you understand that fact??
"Go back to where china" hahahahaahaa
Asalam ma laykum in these blessed days may allah bless and ease the sufferings of the ummah and may allah unite the ummah upon the quran and sunnah and may allah have mercy on all those that have passed away before us and may Allah have mercy on us when we pass away and may allah cure all those that have a sickness and a disability and may allah grant them a cure that leaves no aliment and may allah protect the muslims from hellfire and from the fitnah of dajjal and may allah answer all our prayers ameen
Bro I’m a Sunni, and I actually get upset for the Shia community when this guy debates on their behalf. Like please bring someone learned. How can you not correctly recite a verse from the Quran (which by the way, is supposed to be the IMPLICIT reference to Ali RA - which it is not)… like if the Ayah is that important for the Shiie school of thought, it should roll of his tongue. I’m sorry but the guy is a joke and I’m trying to be as nice as possible…. Shamsi needs to debate someone a little more… qualified?
Respect to you for seperating the man from the madheb
@@exhilitydraws3417 I mean there needs to be some type of benefit to the discussion. That can't happen when one of the parties is either ignorant or insincere.
@@exhilitydraws3417 It ain't a madhap, it's a different religion
@@SS-ho8jx how? There's always different interpretation to life enjoy the differences
@@8heavyhchamp8 The message is one and it's clear
Shamsi said "There are 2 Tabari, One Shia source and one Sunni source". This is true and Farid showed books from both of them. they have the same name.
If anyone is interested then let me know and I will try to find the video of Farid. the video is either about the Battle of Jamal, the killing of Usman or the karbala.
Shams don't let no one talk
ya Ali CANNOT madad
یا الله امدد لنا منك....
Ya Ali asks for madad
@@osamamanan2723 huh?
@@zahirkhan-yq3gr he asks for help. You dont get it?😂
@@osamamanan2723 yes He used to asks for help what u r trying to say here??
Al-Bukhari reported that, Aisha narrated that the Prophet (S) ordered Abu Bakr to lead the prayer, but later the Prophet decided to go to mosque and he went in front of Abu Bakr and led the prayer instead of Abu Bakr. Here is the tradition of al-Bukhari as claimed by Aisha:
Sahih al-Bukhari Tradition: 1.680
Narrated Aisha:
When the Prophet, became ill in his fatal illness, Someone came to inform him about the prayer, and the Prophet told him to tell Abu Bakr to lead the people in the prayer. I said, "Abu Bakr is a soft-hearted man and if he stands for the prayer in your place, he would weep and would not be able to recite the Qur’an.”The Prophet said, "Tell Abu Bakr to lead the prayer.”I said the same as before.
He (repeated the same order and) on the third or the fourth time he said, "You are the companions of Joseph. Tell Abu Bakr to lead the prayer.”So Abu Bakr led the prayer and meanwhile the Prophet felt better and came out with the help of two men; as if I see him just now dragging his feet on the ground. When Abu Bakr saw him, he tried to retreat but the Prophet beckoned him to carry on. Abu Bakr retreated a bit and the Prophet sat on his (left) side. Abu Bakr was repeating the Takbir (Allahu Akbar) of Allah’s Apostle for the people to hear.
The fact, however, is that the Prophet never ordered Abu Bakr to lead the prayer. This can be proven by the following reasons:
1. Based on the above Tradition, if the Prophet was the one who ordered Abu Bakr to lead the prayer, then why he later went to mosque and lead the prayer by himself? (Based on other traditions, the Prophet even pushed Abu Bakr away with his hand). Why such humiliation toward Abu Bakr?
This proves that once the Prophet realized the plot of Aisha, he became very angry and with all his illness, he decided to go to mosque to prevent what others now claim!!! Remember What Aisha said in the above tradition: "The Prophet came out (to lead the prayer) with the help of two men; as if I see him just now dragging his feet on the ground.”This shows that the condition of the Prophet was severe, yet he was so angry at the plot of Aisha and the implication of leading the prayer by Abu Bakr that he decided to stop it at any cost.
2. All Muslims agree that the Prophet had ordered Abu Bakr and Umar to join the camp led by Usamah Ibn Zaid, and as such they should have been outside Medina where the camp was located. Then, the existence of Abu Bakr and Umar and others inside Medina was illegal and was against the order of the Prophet (S). How can, then, the Prophet order Abu Bakr to lead the prayer inside Medina while he was supposed to be outside Medina with the direct order of the Prophet?!
The Messenger of Allah said: "May the curse of Allah be upon those who turn away from the army of Usamah”and he ordered the army to be dispatched immediately, and ordered all Helpers and all Immigrants except ‘Ali to leave Medina. But some companions disobeyed and complained about the leadership of Usamah (See Sahih al-Bukhari, Arabic-English version, Tradition #5.552, 5.744 and 5.745) and they delayed in joining the camp, and finally returned to Medina, in order to prepare themselves for discussion about successorship as soon as the Messenger of Allah passes away.
Aisha further claimed that the Prophet (S) expired while he was resting on her chest. This claim contradicts the narrations transmitted and recorded by others. In the tradition reported by Imam ‘Ali as recorded by Ibn Sa’d who named consecutive sources up to Imam ‘Ali, we read:
‘Ali said: "In the last moments of his life, the Messenger of Allah said: ‘Call me my brother.’ So I approached him. He asked me to get nearer to him and I got quite close to him. He leaned on me and continued resting on my chest and speaking to me till his spittle fell on me and the Messenger of Allah breathed his last."
Sunni references:
• al-Tabaqat, by Ibn Sa’d, v2, part 2, p51, in the Chapter entitled "The Prophet demised in ‘Ali’s lap"
• Kanz al-Ummal, by al-Muttaqi al-Hindi, v1, p392
Jamal laughed at shamsi telling modeen to come to his arabic classes 😂
What is the name of the movie of the prophet brother shamsi..
my brother shamsi cames the park to speak only, it seems its difficult for him to listen
Ali RA is not mentioned in the Quran. Please be careful. He is of high importance in our deen but he is not mentioned in the book of Allah. Our Shia brothers and sisters must learn the truth and follow the nabi pubh and the Quran. Full stop.
Imam Ali is mentioned in the Quran. Calm down pal
@@bicmanflame3455 no he is not and again you are a Shia so ofc you would say that. Sorry to wake you up from your dream but he is not.
you need to read Quran first to find His name, if you need more let me know otherwise check your DNA please!
both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 67 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida has been revealed on Ghadir day and for the sake of Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship (walaya)
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 249
Verse 9 in Chapter An-Nisa urges everyone to obey Imam Ali (A.S) and the other Imams (A.S)
Sunni: Shavahed Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 202
according to Verse 3 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida, one’s faith is completed by accepting Ghadir and Imam Ali’s (A.S) successorship
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 211
both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 7 in Chapter al-Bayyina is about Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship and that he is the best benefactor
Sunni: Dur al-Manthur, verse interpretation
that both Shiites and Sunnis agree Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Ra’d introduce Imam Ali (A.S) as the best guide and director for Muslims
Sunni: Musnad Ahmad, Chapter 2, Hadith 990
Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Anbiya suggests Imam Ali and other Imams (A.S) the meaning of “those who reminisce (possess) the Message
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, verse interpretation
that both Shiites and Sunnis believe Imam Ali (A.S) possesses full insight of the Holy Quran according to Verse 43 in Chapter Al-Ra’d
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 400
“holding fast by the rope Allah (S.W.T) has stretched for you” in Verse 103 in Chapter Al-i-Imran means grasping on belief in Imam Ali’s and other Imam’s (A.S) guardianship
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 168
that both Shiites and Sunnis have identically narrated the famous hadith “Whoever I am his master, this Ali is his master
Sunni: Musnad Ahmad Hanbal, Chapter 39, P 297, Hadith 18497
@@bicmanflame3455 oh man, do we seriously still try to sell this ? It’s time to moooove on.
@@bicmanflame3455 bruh, WAKE UP
علَى + ي (المتكلم) = علَيَّ
Not
عَلِيّ
Don't let these doubts get to you.
Go and study, surely knowledge will protect you.
I think one of the Shiah Tabari wrote “Dala'il al-Imama”
The Sunni Tabari (Muhammad ibn Jarir ibn Yazid) wrote “Tafsir al-Tabari”
Easy to check which Tabari the Hadith is from
whos the other tabari?
Tareekh e tabari@@ltagames01
This is what syeh hassan ibn farhan al maliky said
Shia have no logic, even claiming that they are reasonable man...
What movie are you guys talking about that they used the prophet voice on a computer?
Don't waste your time brother shamsi with these shia fools
As an Arab, I notesed all of the Shiaah debates are based on false understanding of the Arabic Language and most of them don't uderstand it at all.
Quran 49:11
@@ahmedneworld1938because they have their own scholars and interpretations
Labaik allah humma la baik! I AM HERE OH ALLAH I Am here!
He should have put the recitation of the Ayah and the case is closed.
The most solid reason why Muslim don't allow film painting of a prophet "walamyakullahuu kufuwan ahad"and nothing is like him,same for beloved prophet for whole we are here to mentally glorifying thinking about prophet ,you know every sunnah is to glorify Allah means thought about holy prophet how he did yes you can change,and at any mood the most thrilling and beautiful face you imagine you can say even that is not his glimpse but its from him the holy prophet of Allah
Respect to Shamsi for walking away cos he could really embarrass modeen to the point where he cant show his face in speakers corner
Br Shamsi at his best
Im tryna ge that black hat the brothers wearing who knows where i can get wun?
Allah-u-akbar.
This guy is Moroccan love Morocco
He is Algerian akh
I still don't understand why anyone is giving the the time of the day to Mo Deen..seriously why do these dawah guys give him any platform to these Jahil...!!!! When he comes to you just turn your back to this arrogant individual...he is a hypocrite of the highest level...
Are they friends now, I don't think I've seen either of these brothers have a friendly conversation
is Mo deen okay? brothers face looked zapped in the video? jeez bro
Yeh he looks ill
The thing is you know if someone in a majlis said while talking a priest said Mohammad a guy,in a rude way a ottoman soldier listened he punished the whole listener and than that place was made harram even to sow sead where that majlis was standing for seven years hearing any disrespect even talking that anything of heaven is more beautiful than sweat fragrance of rasool Allah saw is,blasphemy
Subhanallah , brother we both need to learn our religion better … is this from Quran and sunnah? … May Allah guide us to the straight path and make it soft and gentle happy and healthy upon us and our families ameen
ٱلَّذِينَ إِذَآ أَصَٰبَتْهُم مُّصِيبَةٌ قَالُوٓاْ إِنَّا لِلَّهِ وَإِنَّآ إِلَيْهِ رَٰجِعُونَ
This is the first time I have seen MO is very quiet . May Allah swt guide him towards right path .
Muhammad: Im the city of knowledge and Ali is the gate.
Muhammad: Quran is with Ali and Ali is with Quran
Muhammad: For who I am the leader, Ali is your leader.
Sunni Islam- finished
As an Arab, I notesed all of the Shiaah debates are based on false understanding of the Arabic Language and most of them don't uderstand it at all.
So true. May Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ guide them all. Ameen
According to who, you ?! You ignorant, the basics of Arabic language was put by Imam Ali AS originally and you call his followers ignorant of the language! I swear the youngest non-Arabic one of his followers knows more in the Arabic language than your whole bunch of fake wahhabi scholars nowadays!
Shamsi treating Shia better than he treats the Muslims.
What movie were they talking about?
Does anyone else think that face-underwear is also an affront to Muhammad(saw) 🤔
How can these guys argue with each other when they have their own hadiths?
Please doa that i be forgiven from allah and i be discharge from home
Shamsi should've stayed and exposed Mo Deen further, he had him by the short and curly's
@Mohammed Ali these debates take us away from focusing on the real issues and gives Shamzi The opportunity to dominate the debate and avoid discussing the real issues. The lady of Heaven film was irrelevant to this discussion.
bro some of this Chiaa boys are going wild against suna followers .i hope they now see that we r not the enemy
Rabi yahdeena
There is only one name mentioned in the Qur'an except all the prophets and that is if zaid bin harisa (33:37)
These Shias are completely blinded in their own terminology
Of course Imam Ali is the successor of the Prophet
As an Arab, I notesed all of the Shiaah debates are based on false understanding of the Arabic Language and most of them don't uderstand it at all.
As are Abu Bakr, Omar and Uthman
@@shakibhussain6931 And Ali 😅
@@ahmedneworld1938 Of course Ali too. They are the rightly guided Caliphs
Of course, he's the first successor of the prophet peace be upon them both.
Did he really say Imam Abu Hanifah r.h was weak in hadith?
Harun to Musa? harun died before Musa, and Yusha was after Musa. So look at the context of the saying and when and why it was said. Jeez guys, basic research will take you out of the fold of shiasm!
And Harun a.s was a prophet. So r they trying to say that Ali r.a is a prophet as well?
He really added stuff to the Quran 😳 what in the hell is going on???
Christ is Lord!
under the god🤔
According to Christ, the father is the one true god (John 17:3). Christ spoke Aramaic, go look up what god is in Christs language. And put this verse together
Modeen. Please take of your gangstermask (Lol)
Honestly I just watch mo deen videos not to learn or for the dash.. I just watch it for the entertainment
I’m not sure why brother Shamsi even gives this kinghar time of the day. He is a clown. Feel sorry for the people that have to call him thier son.
@@Spark12429 when did I say otherwise. I am a Sunni and I have studied shia sect for a number of years. He is a clown. A clown doesn’t spit such rubbish as he has. If you are supporting him you an even bigger clown.
@@Spark12429 so him ridiculing our mother Aisha ra is speaking the truth? Y
I doubt this guy will ever leave his batil way .
the movies are great thanks god they did that i hope they do more movies like that Allahuakbar
Why some shia Muslims as I noticed when they come to debate they cover their, I saw some videos
How dare mo deen Talk about Quran that way, اعوذ بالله، may Allah guide him
قال هذا صراط عليا مستقيم
Its not that their cereberal activity is de generated. Its just that they are cursed for ever...
What's with that thumbnail brother? Fear Allah
Ali was the foremost , no doubt .
Nta m9ouwad ga3 😂😭 shamsi knows what time it is
This film is haram or noo Omer R.A
No aisha appointed abu bakr to lead prayer and the prophet came and removed him
modeen be tripping
Wasn’t Abu bakr supposed to go with Osama’s army?
Moo Deen?? Sorry to say,he didn't bring any posivity in Islam..more to negative impact..
And you ?? What did you bring for the comments
@@ferhattahar7372 see how Moo Deen interact with other muslim debaters within years.. how about when he debate with Mohamad Hijab?? Remember what Mohamad Hijab told him?? Unless you're Shia fanatics
Shamsi listen that movie I watched that movie the main producer failed the first time second time an English and Canadian producer they restart and complete that movie! They non Muslim who that make it "but the writer he's a Muslim person!"
I like the narrative to debate shia only from the Quran.
both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 67 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida has been revealed on Ghadir day and for the sake of Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship (walaya)
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 249
Verse 9 in Chapter An-Nisa urges everyone to obey Imam Ali (A.S) and the other Imams (A.S)
Sunni: Shavahed Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 202
according to Verse 3 in Chapter Al-Ma’ida, one’s faith is completed by accepting Ghadir and Imam Ali’s (A.S) successorship
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, Hadith 211
both Shiites and Sunnis believe Verse 7 in Chapter al-Bayyina is about Imam Ali’s (A.S) guardianship and that he is the best benefactor
Sunni: Dur al-Manthur, verse interpretation
that both Shiites and Sunnis agree Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Ra’d introduce Imam Ali (A.S) as the best guide and director for Muslims
Sunni: Musnad Ahmad, Chapter 2, Hadith 990
Verse 7 in Chapter Al-Anbiya suggests Imam Ali and other Imams (A.S) the meaning of “those who reminisce (possess) the Message
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, verse interpretation
that both Shiites and Sunnis believe Imam Ali (A.S) possesses full insight of the Holy Quran according to Verse 43 in Chapter Al-Ra’d
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 400
“holding fast by the rope Allah (S.W.T) has stretched for you” in Verse 103 in Chapter Al-i-Imran means grasping on belief in Imam Ali’s and other Imam’s (A.S) guardianship
Sunni: Shavahed at-Tanzil, Vol. 1, P 168
that both Shiites and Sunnis have identically narrated the famous hadith “Whoever I am his master, this Ali is his master
Sunni: Musnad Ahmad Hanbal, Chapter 39, P 297, Hadith 18497
Make sure to confirm books i have read are from Sunni Fiqah if you need more let me know will give you more of those lets follow Quran
While this No Deen is obviously a mushrik, قال هذا صراط عليٌّ مستقيم is read by Ya'qub al-Hadrami........
10:30 😮😮😮😮
Why this Shia is dressed like a Teletubbie?
In my opinion I use my current knowledge and say that in the end of the day Abu baker and Ali the son in law of Mohamed, died more than a 1000 years ago , and Allah specified us not to be in any sects, I don't understand why we are fighing about something and people who are not here anymore , Islam is islam and our prophet is Mohamad and all of the prophets , it does not matter if anyone is an offspring from them as that does not mean they should be the leaders as they could be totaly evil or sinners like Noah's son and also I am not saying that everyone should accept what i say but consider it. politics from 1400 years ago lead to the cold war between Suadia and Iran and the deaths of many people.
That's exactly what sunah is why fighting over such a thing if someone was bad let allah deal with him we don't curse anyone . But the thing is the shia's re always mentioning that .
Disagreeing and arguing about religion is good thing as it means the religion is alive in our community. Religions that do not have disagreements and arguing going on in them are dead religions such as old pagan cults: nobody even cares about them anyomer.
The problem is when arguments about theology go outside the realm of scholarship and academics, and are taken by laymen to the street, thus causing social tensions and fragmenting the society. Making it a fertile soil for political sectarianism and conflicts.
We could collaborate financially and militarily, while leaving our theological differences to be handled by scholars and academic debates on Television.
Muslims, sunni or shia, have proven that they could coexist with LGBT, christian, atheis, jewish and secular peoples in the West under liberal irreligious laws. SO why wouldnt we coexist between different sects of Islam that have much more in common than in the West, under agreed upon basic fundamental islamic principles?
Salam, does Bukhari and others not say, Fatima died angry with AbuBakr? Is this not a Sahih hadith? Also, does Bukhari not state: Rasulillah said whoever angers Fatima (a.s) angers me. Even if you want to believe this is about imam Ali (a.s), you can't deny Fatima died angry with AbuBakr and not Ali. How do you explain this? It's also a fact that no one knows where Fatima (a.s) was buried (except imam Ali (a.s)), as requested by Fatima (a.s). On the day of judgement we will face Rasulillah (S), who's side will you be on, Fatima (a.s) or AbuBakr? Do you think Rasulillah (S) will take sides with AbuBakr? Will you dissociate yourself from the people who angered Fatima? Please explain your point of view. I would like to learn.
1. Tell us the whole story. Why was Fatimah radiallahu anha angry? Do Prophets leave behind wealth as inheritance? Who was right, Abu Bakr (who heard and narrated that Prophets don't leave behind wealth) or Fatimah radiallahu anhuma?
2. Ali radiallahu anh gave bay'a to those who angered Fatimah, so according to your logic Ali has a problem with Allah now.
3. Abu Bakr radiallahu anh was the only sahabi who was named sahabi in the Quran
4. Allah praised ALL the muhajireen and ansaar. You base your whole religion on a handful of events in history. Where is your religion in Quran, show me a clear cut verse?
Hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhjhhj عليه today is something else
No english
No arabic .......
bro wallah i got shocked how fool he is like ik he is a stupid but not like this الله يعافيه ولا يبتلينا
@@theo4084 امين.
may allah guide him and guide us all
I have nothing but respect for my Sunni brothers and sisters (those moderate ones) even if some Wahabis Sunnis claim Shia are kuffar and are killing them in cold blood .We have to look thoroughly at the virtues of Imam Ali compared to the two Khalifa's. what Imam Ali gave to to the Islamic religion from victories in the battlefield and wisdom , equality and justice throughout his time .why where the two not present in the prophets burial why did Fatima die upset towards the two Khalifa's, these questions need to be researched and answered with all honesty and dignity .
If you really have nothing but respect, why don't you quote the hadith in which Fatima was angry at Ali himself. Al-Bukhaari and Muslim narrated that al-Miswar ibn Makhramah said: ‘Ali proposed to the daughter of Abu Jahl. When Faatimah heard of that she came to the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and said to him: Your people are saying that you do not get angry for the sake of your daughters, and ‘Ali is going to marry the daughter of Abu Jahl. The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) stood up and I heard him when he recited the shahaadah, then he said: “I gave a daughter of mine in marriage to Abu’l-‘Aas ibn al-Rabee’, and when he spoke he told me the truth. Faatimah bint Muhammad is a part of me, and I do not like for her to be hurt. By Allaah, the daughter of the Messenger of Allaah and the daughter of the enemy of Allaah will not be joined together as wives of one man.” So ‘Ali abandoned that proposal.
So basically, it was ALI himself who hurt her and caused her to be andry, and he was the reason why the prophet said that, so why don't you accuse Ali of angering Allah?
Also, Fatima got angry at Abu bakr because he decided to follow the ruling of the prophet pbuh himself about his inheritance, so are you gonna tell me that Abu Bakr should have disobeyed the messenger of God to make Fatima happy ?
@@osumanaaa9982 t The first hadith (tradition) in ‘Elal al-Sharaye’ is regarding a person who lied to Lady Fatima Zahra about Ali seeking the hand of Abul Jahl’s daughter for marriage. In reality, there was no such incident and the false news about Ali bin Abi Talib (as) was spread by his (as) enemies who wanted to create discord between Fatima and Ali, peace be upon them.(therefore its a false hadeeth )The alleged story of Ali bin Abi Talib (as) intending to marry Abu Jahl’s daughter is not conforming the facts and realities in history because Abu Jahl’s daughter resided in Makkah whereas Ali (as) had married Fatima (sa) in Medina and were living there. The fact is that this hadith had been fabricated by the opponents in order to steer public mind from the caliphs to Ali (as). They wanted to direct naïve masses’ attention to Ali (as) rather than to the sufferings and pains which Fatima (sa) received at the hands of the caliphs.
@@osumanaaa9982 The Prophet (s) said, “Fatima is part of me - what saddens her saddens me, and what pleases her pleases me.”Al-Sunan Al-Kubra, v. 7, p. 64, the chapter on what will transpire on the Day of Judgement; Muntakhab Kenz Al-Omal, in the margins of Al-Musnad, v. 5, p. 96.
your argument is false
@@hman3966 You're making a claim without substantiating it. If you're gonna label the hadith as fabrication, you need to have at least proofs. If you're gonna only accept the narrations that suit you and reject those that refute you, then that's double standards. Also you seem to be using Ali's achievements as a proof for something, but let's not forget he's not the only one who has done things for the sake of Allah. Abu bakr faced the apostates and compiled the Quran, Umar conquered Jerusalem and Uthman standardized the Quran. We love Ali too, maybe in a more appropriate way than you guys do.
Then stop lying about them, because the one who is doing the killing of the sunnah are the shiite in Syria and Iraq, the shite live unharmed in Saudi Arabia where the wahabis you are claiming killed you reign.
Elon Musk is trying to send us to Mars and ya’ll keep fighting about this still?
Shut up
6:30 lol
Let mo talk
Imam jafar Al sadik was the teacher were all the other mathahib
Divided and conquer tactics
إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ فَرَّقُوا۟ دِينَهُمْ وَكَانُوا۟ شِيَعًۭا لَّسْتَ مِنْهُمْ فِى شَىْءٍ ۚ إِنَّمَآ أَمْرُهُمْ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ ثُمَّ يُنَبِّئُهُم بِمَا كَانُوا۟ يَفْعَلُونَ
Shamsi was not allowed to watch lady of heaven its haram to watch a movie that is not based on true islam, but he clearly admits that he watched that movie! Tell me i am wrong...
He says he did not watch it but if you rewind the video 1min he talks about the movie asif he had seen it , than instantly corrects himself because he know its haram, than he says a brother said it 2 me :) wallahi Shamsi watched that movie
That's all you concluded from the whole video?