Subhan Allah! What a humble gentleman! Probably he needs a more humble patient guy so that he may realise. May Allah s.w.t. bless both of you with His Noor (Light).
Of course he knows but the reason why he doesn't want to answer or his reluctant to answer is because he knows if I answer it I know where it's going to lead me to. You can tell by his face he knows
The argument can be improved. Instead of asking if the universe in independent, ask if the entirety of REALITY can be contingent, or whether it has to have something non contingent in it. That is Josh Rasmussen's version, and I feel its far superior
@@OriginalAndroidPhone How? Well let's assume everything around is cause and effect from dependent things without any necessary thing. One thing causes another thing and dies, that thing causes another thing and dies or stops existing in that way and this could simply be an infinite process and also exactly how reality as we know it actually works.
@@OriginalAndroidPhone Al those contingency arguments are based on personal bias from religious people with the presupposition that there is a god. It's all baseless assumption not in line with actual reality.
I am a muslim but I agree with your comment. The agnostic/athiest man seemed quite polite to me but we don't know whatever happened before the camera started. Also, he isn't answering the questions and is beating around the bush so maybe the other person got annoyed. Regardless i don't agree with the title
@@djaxx587 no, but if you are doing dawah then your focus is to bring people to islam, so making clickbaits to some extent can be beneficial. But also those clickbaits can throw some people off, so i understand your point and i agree that the titles shoulnd't be insulting
Why exactly can't the universe be eternal? Maybe i missed it but Ali said "because of infinite regress" and couldn't explain how that relates to the impossibility of an eternal universe.
@@djaxx587i think because in a chain of dependent things going backwards, it has to come about due to an independent thing outside/separate from it otherwise no dependent thing would exist in the first place. And that independent thing cannot br the universe because we know very easily that the universe is dependent.
Cool guy..calm mannered.
Subhan Allah! What a humble gentleman! Probably he needs a more humble patient guy so that he may realise.
May Allah s.w.t. bless both of you with His Noor (Light).
Assalamu alaikum wa rehmatullahi wabarkatah hu
Look how smart and strong 💪 this Muslim brother is 😧
Jesus peace be upon him is true messiah and great prophet of God....
If one reads the Quran with an open heart and mind they will find their answer.
Of course he knows but the reason why he doesn't want to answer or his reluctant to answer is because he knows if I answer it I know where it's going to lead me to. You can tell by his face he knows
The title of the video is misleading...there was no bigotry from atheist
Yes there was, his not making eye contact
The argument can be improved. Instead of asking if the universe in independent, ask if the entirety of REALITY can be contingent, or whether it has to have something non contingent in it. That is Josh Rasmussen's version, and I feel its far superior
Reality can be completely contingent.
@@bustinjieber7521 how? i'm using contingent to mean dependent on other than itself for explanation
@@OriginalAndroidPhone How? Well let's assume everything around is cause and effect from dependent things without any necessary thing. One thing causes another thing and dies, that thing causes another thing and dies or stops existing in that way and this could simply be an infinite process and also exactly how reality as we know it actually works.
@@OriginalAndroidPhone Al those contingency arguments are based on personal bias from religious people with the presupposition that there is a god. It's all baseless assumption not in line with actual reality.
Ali was impatient with this person. He was a little hangry
I don’t know
I don’t know
I don’t know
I rest my case
Is my Christian brother throwing the arrow, and then drawing the bulls eye around it?
Double reward
Clear as a bell
Why make the agnostic look bad in the video title while he was a very nice and humble guy? Shouldn't you be righteous Sam Dawah?
I am a muslim but I agree with your comment. The agnostic/athiest man seemed quite polite to me but we don't know whatever happened before the camera started. Also, he isn't answering the questions and is beating around the bush so maybe the other person got annoyed. Regardless i don't agree with the title
@@its2eezy So views are more important than rightiousness?
@@djaxx587 no, but if you are doing dawah then your focus is to bring people to islam, so making clickbaits to some extent can be beneficial. But also those clickbaits can throw some people off, so i understand your point and i agree that the titles shoulnd't be insulting
ali dawah, the great scientist who said he'll marry his 9 year old daughter to a 40 year old 😂
5 pillars of islam:
1. PEDOPHILIA (sura 65.4, Bukhari 5133)
2. MUT’AH MARRIAGE (sura 4.24)
3. HALALA MARRIAGE (sura 2.230)
4. ADULTBREASTFEEDING (Sahih Muslim 8:3425)
5. TAQIYYA (sura 16.106, 3.28, Sahih Bukhari 3:49:857)
Christian brother is not humble enough to understand what Mr.Ali is trying to convey.
Why exactly can't the universe be eternal? Maybe i missed it but Ali said "because of infinite regress" and couldn't explain how that relates to the impossibility of an eternal universe.
You can’t have the present if there’s an infinite past
@@PantheraTK Why?
@@PantheraTK If zero is the present, and every number before and after that represents a cause, why couldn't you count back or forth to infinity?
@@djaxx587i think because in a chain of dependent things going backwards, it has to come about due to an independent thing outside/separate from it otherwise no dependent thing would exist in the first place. And that independent thing cannot br the universe because we know very easily that the universe is dependent.
@@djaxx5870+0 =0 .... there would be nothing lol. A universe cannpt give birth to itself just like a mother cannot give birth to herself.
Do you exist?
I don't know.
End of conversation,my dear brother.
Change the headline bro, its misinformation, thats haram.
talking more than 5 minutes to like this one is just a waste of time.