Our Math Journey - What worked and what did not.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Which math curriculums we have tried, which ones worked for us, and which did not. Thoughts on The Good and The Beautiful, Kate Snow Math, Life of Fred, Beauty and Truth Math, and Simply Charlotte Mason Arithmetic.
__________________________________
Let's be friends!
IG - / kindle_togetherness
Sign up for our email list & a freebie:
view.flodesk.c...
OUR WEBSITE: www.kindletoge...
COLLABS: kindletogetherness@gmail.com
📦 AMAZON SHOP - www.amazon.com...
ETSY SHOP - www.etsy.com/sh...
__________________________________
Mentioned in this video:
🌿 Charlotte Mason Arithmetic Series - simplycharlott...
🌿 Beauty & Truth Math - beautyandtruth...
🌿 Kate Snow Math - amzn.to/43pNQoR
🌿 The Good and The Beautiful Simply Math - www.goodandbea...
🌿 Life of Fred - amzn.to/43Nn9u3
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES WE USE & LOVE:
🌿 A Gentle Feast Curriculum - agentlefeast.c...
🌿 The Peaceful Press Curriculum - thepeacefulpre...
🌿 Exploring Nature With Children - payhip.com/Lyn...
🌿 Thriftbooks - www.thriftbook...
__________________________________
#homeschoolmath #simplycharlottemason #charlottemasonhomeschool #charlottemason #homeschooling #homeschoolcurriculum #kindletogetherness
THANKS FOR WATCHING!!!
___________________________________
AFFILIATE NOTICE I do get a small commission if you use the links above. It is always a NO cost to you! Thank you for supporting our channel and helping me make time away from my family count. :)
![[DRIP] ‘Love, Maybe’ PREVIEW](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/U7hwHp95m1k/mqdefault.jpg)
I love that math shows the stability, consistency, and dependability of our creator! ❤
yes!
I would love to see a more in detail video of Beauty and Truth! All your videos are so wonderful!
Thanks for the encouragement, Mary. I will try and do a specific video about B&T at some point.
Yes I would too. I'm thinking about using it for my 5th grader.
Yes please! My 2nd grader is using TGTB Level 2 after having used Level 1. But I question whether it offers enough math sense. Just wondering if I should just make a mid year switch to Beauty and Truth. But thinking about cost ... I already paid for TGTB and then B&T will cost money. (I also looked at CM Arithmetic but it looks too repetitive and I think that may not go well with my son). However those were my top 2 after looking at tons of math curriculum. So anyhow, yes please, make a video on B&T!
I’d love to see a video about beauty and truth as well! And an update on your math situation. Your videos are so informative and thorough! Also, I can’t find a single review for B&T!
I would love to hear more about those notebooks!
Hi LaDonna, check out this video where I share more: th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
I've been wanting to see some Beauty and Truth reviews! Thank you! ❤
You are so welcome! Thanks for watching.
We are really enjoying Beauty and Truth Math! I must say I am loving it the most for my 1st grader. We were so torn between it and SCM. Thank you for sharing!
They both have their merits and I agree that B&T is a great math curriculum. It’s a wonderful feeling when you find what works best for your kiddo!
Yes, I would love to see your family's notebook system!
Hi Katie! I was able to create a video about that Notebooking in Our Homeschool
th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
Your headband is adorable! I actually hand die scarves for my etsy account. I can totally see you in them.
Aw thanks! What is your Etsy? I’ll peek at them. Tbh, most of mine are cut up clothing or thrift store finds.
@@kindletogetherness TheEclecticSouk :) Im here on TH-cam as well. I will be getting back into our homeschool content soon. Been just uploading random knitting vlogs. After 3 years of homeschool the kids decided to try "real" school this past year. We have a great local private Islamic school, BUT we happily decided to go back to homeschool this year so now I'm trying to get all back into the groove. Are you still enjoying Simply Charlotte Mason Math? We were looking at singapore math but Im still open.
@@chelseyummali Sounds like you are in for a wonderful year with your family. We do still really like the SCM Arithmetic series. However, I had to make some changes for a variety of reasons this year.
@kindletogetherness hey it works until it doesn't, right? God willing, your changes serve you well.
We also love Beauty and Truth Math!!
It’s a good one!
New subscriber ! I Am in book 1 of SCM and it has been absolutely wonderful and well rounded. I see you plan to do the notebook so another vote for that from me too! Lol look forward to watching the rest of your videos!
Hi Jane! Welcome! I’m beginning Book 1 again with my 6 year old this Fall and really looking forward to it. I did create the notebooking video. Here you go: Notebooking in Our Homeschool
th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
God speaks in math, love it. Also thanks for sharing what you did about math facts that stick. I was considering it but I don't want to do a bunch of cutting out and games.
Yeah…it comes very highly recommended and the games seemed decent. It’s just not my style.
Yes, I want to see the notebooks!
Awesome! Thanks for letting me know. Here is a video about our notebooking. Notebooking in Our Homeschool
th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
I’m so excited for this video. I’ve been leaning towards simply Charlotte mason math.
It really has been a good fit for us.
Great video! I'm having the most difficult time choosing between SCM Arithmetic and Beauty & Truth Math for 2nd grade. I think SCM will be easier to implement, but I like that B&T has the visual printouts like a ten frame, number/dot charts, etc. I would like to see the inside of your children's travelers notebooks!
It is a tough choice. I’ll try and work on getting a notebook video up.
Same.. my
Kids are really behind & it was suggested to do B&T, but I can’t tell if there’s actual papers to write on inside the packet & do all of their printouts go along with a book from Strayor? Is that not too much to flip back & forth? Too expensive? Also, that one blue book that they suggest to read along with SCM… is it necessary to get and read as a parent?
Regarding beauty and truth there aren't workbook pages or pages to write on. The student has problems to work in the Strayer Upton book. It honestly wasn't super pricy.
@@Stazi24
@@Stazi24 The blue book by Ballard is not necessary. It's there to explain their philosophy so you understand why things are done a certain way. You don't write in hr Beauty & Truth printouts but use a graph paper notebook like the ones SCM sells (or just print free online). The guides and Strayer-Upton books are non-consumable. You can get the SU books as PDFs and keep them in a binder separate from the guides to minimize flipping back and forth (it's also easier to leave open than the small hardcovers).
I adore your videos, as a 1st time homeschooling mom(almost done with our 1st year..yaaaay! )I learn a ton from you! Thank you for the videos and advice. I would love to see the notebook ideas. I use math you can see. It seems to be working for us but I am always open to other options. I am curious your opinion on it good or bad.
Waaaay to gooo! What a wonderful feeling it is to wrap up the first year! You did it! Personally, I like Math-U-See and have heard great things about it. If it is working well for you and your child, I would not switch. With Math, I think staying with one curriculum is a good choice until that curriculum is not a good fit anymore.
Yes! Please show mis the notebook stuff
Hi Stazi! So fun to find you over here too! I shared more in this video Notebooking in Our Homeschool
th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
Thank you so much for your video! I have been wanting to hear about Beauty and truth. I spent so much time stressing about math and picked SCM and it’s been a good fit! We had a baby and I just knew I needed something simple to get through and desired it to be charlotte mason. We have been happy with it but I have always been curious about B&T. I had mostly not picked it because I didn’t want to take the time to print it out and figure it out. I just came across your videos and love them!
Glad it was helpful! We are big fans of SCM and have enjoyed their math series a lot.
Yes, please do a notebook video!!
I did! I did! Check it out and let me know if you have any questions, or anything to add. th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
I would love to see a journal video!
I just made one! I hope that is covers enough to be helpful. th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
Hi Sarah Ruth, fellow AGFer here.This was great. I have 5 students and we are doing 4 different Math programs! We started Teaching Textbooks before I found CM, so my oldest (9th grade/Form 3) has continued on with that. My next oldest is a 7th grade Form 3 and math just became an absolute fight every day using TT. We took a break, last year he did Life of Fred but it wasnt at his level and he basically lost the year. We're trying Khan Academy now and he absolutely loves it. What a relief. My next is solely using Life of Fred. He is NOT an average child and is highly gifted in language but I wasn't sure he'd ever be able to add and subtract even basic numbers. He goes very slowly and mulls over everything and comprehends it all since it is language based. Fascinating to me how his brain works. He's progressing but we are just going at his pace. Lil Sis is bouncing around and doing TT for now. And with my youngest I've just started the same math as you - the SCM Arithmetic by Richele. Took me five kids to find something that I like but I'm really grateful at least one kid will get a CM math education! Beauty and Truth intrigues me. I may try that for my younger daughter who is using TT right now. Thanks for a good video.
Wow! You have so much experience. I feel like I should watch TH-cam videos you share. 💕 I do love the gentleness of the SCM arithmetic as well as how thorough it is.
We had the same experience with TGTB math. I started my oldest (twins) with it and then in 3rd grade it switched to the simply math and it was instantly a no go. The lessons were so so long and dull. And through that I learned they definitely needed a more mastery based math with some review. We switched to Apologia math and it is perfect for us. A little hands on/activity, shorter workbook lessons, whole chapters on one topic with review of what was previously learned. My youngest daughter uses MWC which I’ve had to modify. The super lengthy teacher portion has bored her to literal tears BUT she loves the work book pages. So I look over the lesson and simplify it significantly and just go over what I know she needs. It has changed her attitude significantly. It’s def not ideal but so far it’s working. I’ll have to see how the rest of the year goes and see what I want to do this fall.
I’ve heard so many folks love MWC. I have their games books but it was so much prep, I gave up 🤦🏻♀️ I’m actually now using TG&TB with my youngest again. He wasn’t doing well with the Charlotte Mason Arithmetic. I’m modifying TG&TB and I have no clue if I’ll use it for long or not.
@@kindletogetherness Apologia math is much more low prep then MWC but still similar teaching methods. They do a whole chapter on one topic before they move on all while reviewing what they previously learned. It’s my favorite Math!
Great video!!! We too just made the same switch!! 📖
Happy Homeschooling!! 😊 TGTB -> SCM Arithmetic
Oh fun! I wanted badly to not switch out of TG&TB math. We really enjoyed our first years with them, but then it became an issue with the new layout, etc. I was thankful for other choices. How do you like SCM so far? Which book are you in?
This was very helpful, thank you. Do you feel transitioning from TGATB to Beauty and Truth for my 3rd and 5th graders would be easy?
It was pretty straight forward for us.
Thank you so much for sharing! Math was also a struggle for me with many tears growing up and I dont want it to be thay way for my kids. I've been on a mission to find something that works well for my oldest who is going into "8th grade" and not loving math at all. I picked up a Life of Fred and am also not sold on the idea that it is a full curriculum. I'm going to check out your other suggestions and am definitely going to grab the Charlotte Mason math for my 6yo and give it a try! I feel my 9yo is past those CM books like you said yours was, so we are actually using tgatb, but I also agree that there's a lot of busy work there. I've given myself permission to skip a lot of the extra work with him😅 I'd love to see a walk through of one of the CM lessons!
Good for you for knowing that you can skip what your kiddos don't need. I wish The Simply CM Arithmetic had book 5 ready now. It is launching this Fall. I plan to go back to it with my eldest who is 10.
@@kindletogetherness Do you know what date/month book 5 is being published for sale??
@aworkofheart_monique My son is going into 8th grade. He went through Saxon 8/7 and nearly died/very much hated math by the end. I felt terrible! We did a speedy summer by using Master Books "Principles in Mathematics" and the accompanying videos from Master Books Academy, which is used normally for 7th & 8th graders. He liked it much more. He is going to be using Jacobs Elementary Algebra with Climber Higher Math teachers that specifically teach from a Charlotte Mason perspective. Hope this helps!
@@parisbyrum8215 I only know the target is this Fall.
@@parisbyrum8215 Thank you for sharing!
I would love to see your notebook system and where you got the leather cover
I’ve got this video that covers how we notebook. Notebooking in Our Homeschool
th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
As to the leather traveler’s journals, they were a closeout in an Etsy shop for a steal 5 years ago, but I adore what Juniper Grove Journals has if you ever want something amazing quality.
Hi! Thanks for sharing your experience with math in your homeschool. This video was helpful. We are thinking of using SCM this fall for my oldest. I’m hoping it’s a good fit. Quick question- would you recommend SCM for grades1-5 and then suggest B+T series for 6-12? Do you feel it’s a nice transition from one to the other? Or would you suggest starting with B+T from the beginning?
To be entirely honest, I can't say. Due to my son being ahead of the releases of SCM arithmetic, I finally had to move to something else. It was sad for us because I certainly love that series, but I couldn't hold him back waiting on each release.
Love the notebooks
They work so well for us!
We are getting ready to start the same SCM math book after trying a few other curriculums as well. I was wondering if you had used the dvd and wether it was worth me getting?
Hello Randi, I did get it with my bundle and watched parts. I think it’s useful if you’re not wholly familiar with the CM principles for Math. I don’t think it’s absolutely necessary.
Would love to see the travelers notebooks!
I have a notebooks video up. It shares them.
I am going to circle back to SCM math with my youngest after watching this video! It was working for her and then I switched out of it for all the wrong reasons I think. On another note, I have a handful of resources, mainly enrichment from SCM but am starting AGF this year, I really like what I see. I would love to hear your thoughts on AGF vs. SCM for the core curriculum. Have you done a video on that?
I have not. I’ve only looked at SCM as a core, but never used it as a core curriculum, so I’d be uncomfortable making a whole video comparing them. I can say that part of what drew me to AGF was the 4 year history cycle (students go through each part of history 3 complete times of doing all forms with AGF).
I would love to see how you use the travelers notebooks! I really want to do this with mine but not sure how to set it up.
Hi Kathryn! I have a video up that shares some of the details on how we use them. Hope it’s helpful. Notebooking in Our Homeschool
th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
We use Rod and Staff (more traditional math) for my oldest and it has worked well. But she is more self motivated and enjoys self teaching and honestly other than check her work and the odd help, I don't do anything for her with it. That's not R&S curriculum that's just what worked for her, they have intense teacher lessons as it can be for home or school. But that didn't work with my second. Praise the Lord we found Richelle's through SCM and it has been a blessing. She just started book 4 even though she's 11. We go at her pace and it has been amazing to see my third and fourth go through it too! I'm debating when to start my 5th child in it as she just turned 5 but is sooooo eager to do some school work. We may just wait till 6 though as I did with number 4.
It’s nice having an independent kiddo! What a blessing.
Is a book #5 of simply Charlotte Mason coming out?!? Haven’t seen anything!!
I believe so, but it’s a really slow process. I wish it were faster because my upcoming 3rd grader is 2/3 the way through book 3 and will likely finish book 4 this coming year.
My hand went up when you said math gives fear and bad memories to some people 😂
For real! It is hard work overcoming our own history with a content area.
Would love to see the notebook system
Hi Abigail! Here you go. Notebooking in Our Homeschool
th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.html
Did you do the notebook setup video? If you did, I am interested.
Hey! I did. You can watch it here: th-cam.com/video/TGanl5XOLzc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=BDQ-NcdF0dV5Xv24
So I keep seeing you pop up in various online places over the years that I'm in: VIP, AGF, here.... I feel like we could be friends IRL.
I literally just responded to your dm on IG!
Would love to see a video on the note booking :)
I will do my best to put one up soon!
Me too!
Thank you for this video!! Do you print and bind your Beauty and Truth math books at home or outsource that?
I printed and bound them at home.
@kindletogetherness Is there a binding kit you would recommend? I've been wanting to get one. I do so much printing.
I like this one and have had it for 7 years. It only does 6 sheets at a time though, unless you buy the larger capacity. It can do both spiral coils and the recommended open/close spiral binding (affiliate link, fyi) www.amazon.com/dp/B00006IAS3/ref=cm_sw_r_as_gl_api_gl_i_5PQSHRWCP5SA2JF7JZ9Q?linkCode=ml2&tag=sarahruthowen-20
@kindletogetherness Thanks so much SarahRuth!
Where did you find the hardback Strayer Upton book?
I bought them from a Facebook BST
thanks so much for this video. Does SCM math have the kiddos memorize their multiplication tables or is it just an understanding of what multiplication is?
I think the goal is memorization through understanding.
oops forgot to also ask if the SCM math is mastery or more spiral like Beauty and Truth? Thanks again for your help
I believe it is mastery based.
Are there no worksheets that come with those hard covered math books ?
No. These books are Simply Charlotte Mason Arithmetic and Strayer Upton math. Neither come with worksheets.
@@kindletogetherness Thank you:)