"Give a one word answer, based on YOUR EXPERIENCE." I think he happily, and maybe a tiny bit luckily, got an audience member who would "go with the flow" to one degree or another. (Either she was hearing sounds that suggested the answer, of she was covertly being asked to play along and give the answers she [quietly] heard.) Or, it is MAGIC!!! 🎩🪄🔮
Audio was playing that would direct her to think about the answers that he intended. Someone could force a different response, but having pig sounds somewhere nearby (or through the chair) that are barely noticeable make it easier to blurt out, "Pig!" since she's put on the spot for every question. Knowing that you're being fed thoughts this way, you could ruin his trick, but most of the time you would feel like you came up with the idea yourself and not attempt to change your response. It's risky magic.
Not possibly. The magicians have to disclose the method to the producers, and audience plants are not allowed. Penn’s response suggests the answers were being fed to her, but it was happening on the stage, not in advance.
Penn's hint suggests the volunteer hears questions different from those the audience hears. It is not clear exactly how this works. But I suspect, the sentences are constructed such that similar sounding words can be substituted in key places that radically alters the meanings. Through some mechanism, the volunteer hears the verbally similar phrases.
pig, rain, train, piano have characteristic sounds, and I understood these sounds are being played at the subject so softly the audience can't hear them
The paint was a special acrylic embedded with nano-technology that rearranged itself through AI into a picture to correspond with the volunteer's free choice selections...OR... Mr. Mobley's power of suggestion is subliminal and phenomenal and only truly detectable to P&T...OR...just got lucky several times in a row. Loved it. Great performance!
I'm thinking he guided her to the astral plain, which he already visited before and planted those ideas there. Several Buddhas gave him hell for littering their existential realm.
I’m thinking there were sounds fed into the monitors on the floor facing her, like a pig, rain, train, piano right before each question. If that's the case, he's playing with fire cause that's relying on the sound guy to get that just loud enough so only she hears and not anyone else... but this makes the most sense to me, as someone who's mixed lived show audio.
It’s also risky because just because she hears the sounds doesn’t mean she has to pick those answers. She could try to mess with him and pick totally opposite stuff
I thought it would be scribbled words on the board, and then it is a painting, and she gets to take it with her, so it cannot be gimmicked. If she really had a free choice of words I cannot see how this was done, no clue, other than magic.
I was ready to think maybe a nice AI image generator and rolling the dice that the result makes sense, but it looks painted and not like giant framed screen. Also this was apparently a few years ago :)
My only guess is she is hearing a different story than the audience so her answers are very obvious. Like it could like “what animal goes oink” or something like that. Not that exactly but somehow she’s hearing him ask questions that we don’t hear. Maybe the mic is getting muted.
Ok, freaky, I imagined opening the red door BEFORE he said it, and imagine walking on stars. And also I imagine the train, but more like the NY subway. My other answers were Rabbit, and Rubik’s Cube.
I saw a squirrel - a spaceship - and a video game. So the answers she stated aren’t preloaded in someone’s mind obviously. He stumped me for sure. * I forgot to say I thought rain originally. So idk, maybe there’s something subliminal in there.
Not only have I no idea how this was done but no idea on how P&T busted it???? What a great routine and a lovely touch to give the painting to the lady to keep.
Good act, part of the brilliance of this is the wording like questions that specifically say “playing with”. This way, when she says piano, no one would really expect to be playing “with” a piano rather playing a piano. probably people were imagining a yo-yo or something. It is super simple in general I’m not sure exactly which direct method was used. But if you consider each one of those items has a very quick and extremely distinct noise it makes to identify it. It’s super simple. Still really great performance.🎉
Depending on how the trick was achieved, that might have given it away. Plus, with a trick like this, even though it would be against the rules anyway, it helps convince the audience that the person being hypnotized isn't in on the trick.
I still don't get the Sam Harris thing. She said pig. I would've said squirrel, clear skies, space shuttle, Iphone and the trick wouldn't have worked. How exactly did he get her to say pig, rain, spider playing a piano?
The clue of Sam Harris is how he pronounces it the second time. He says "Sam HARRis". My guess is that they edited out Penn actually saying "Sam CHARRis" because it would have being obvious. So they edited out the 'C' sound.
The look of total bewilderment on P & T faces at 4:25 is something VERY rarely seen! It looked impossible to me, and Alyson looked stunning! I find nobody’s explanation here plausible.
@@dpersonal4187 I like Atheists and Magicians. That was ALL I addressed. I presented NO opinion beyond that. Anything else, is coming from YOUR own mind. So that's on you alone.
Nice performance! If I understand Penn's code words correctly, then he's suggesting that the ambient sound/music was priming the audience member to say those things. Am I on the right track here?
Likely much more direct. Sound only she can hear, not sure if it would be direct instructions or eg. pig noises when he asks what animal. We don't see him select the audience member, probably vetted for suggestibility/agreeability.
The best guess in the comments is that there were sounds next to the girl to make her think about specific things, but I think it would be too risky. For example, hearing the rain she could have said that the weather was foggy or cloudy.. or hearing a pig she could have said "boar" with a just a bit of fantasy.. so I'd say she had headphones with a different speech going on with different questions and he was very good at timing. Anyway nice trick, but the first time I saw this video I closed my eyes and imagined a turtle driving a spaceship on a cloudy day
Also if I were the one up there and I heard sounds i would purposely pick things that had nothing to do with them to try and screw up his trick so it’s very risky to leave it in the participants hands like that
That's exactly what I imagined too a pig driving a train in the rain and a spider playing piano on the train carriage. Amazing. She's definitely not an actor!
I think she was pre prepared .. a lot if the audience were , without realising this .. I've seen how Darren Brown can do this to a bunch of people , well ..maybe ..
Giving her the picture instead of just having the words written down is such a great touch.
Thanks :)
The question at the end really makes me think she’s not being fed answers but being fed different questions.
she was "forced" to be in it.
Wonderful performance 👍👍
"Give a one word answer, based on YOUR EXPERIENCE."
I think he happily, and maybe a tiny bit luckily, got an audience member who would "go with the flow" to one degree or another.
(Either she was hearing sounds that suggested the answer, of she was covertly being asked to play along and give the answers she [quietly] heard.)
Or, it is MAGIC!!! 🎩🪄🔮
Epic! I'm not even gonna read the comments cuz I don't want to know the secret!
I still don't get this, I was trying to play along but said mole, bus, ball
Well..anybody care to explain please?
Audio was playing that would direct her to think about the answers that he intended. Someone could force a different response, but having pig sounds somewhere nearby (or through the chair) that are barely noticeable make it easier to blurt out, "Pig!" since she's put on the spot for every question. Knowing that you're being fed thoughts this way, you could ruin his trick, but most of the time you would feel like you came up with the idea yourself and not attempt to change your response.
It's risky magic.
@@StillNight77 not how it was done.
@@jitzmaster Source: I made it up
The girl knew all the words ahead of time.
bs
That would go against the rules of the show
Not possibly. The magicians have to disclose the method to the producers, and audience plants are not allowed. Penn’s response suggests the answers were being fed to her, but it was happening on the stage, not in advance.
Penn's hint suggests the volunteer hears questions different from those the audience hears. It is not clear exactly how this works. But I suspect, the sentences are constructed such that similar sounding words can be substituted in key places that radically alters the meanings. Through some mechanism, the volunteer hears the verbally similar phrases.
Not that complicated, obviously they are actors. It's on TV almost always scripted even reality TV
@@michaellynch4670 The show does not work that way. Much like a gameshow, there are strict rules, and audience plants are not permitted.
@@fake1hotmailcom rubbish , he said he did did it earlier before the show.
@@michaellynch4670 bs sewer rat
pig, rain, train, piano have characteristic sounds, and I understood these sounds are being played at the subject so softly the audience can't hear them
Penn and teller do not seem impressed by this
Agreed haha
The paint was a special acrylic embedded with nano-technology that rearranged itself through AI into a picture to correspond with the volunteer's free choice selections...OR... Mr. Mobley's power of suggestion is subliminal and phenomenal and only truly detectable to P&T...OR...just got lucky several times in a row. Loved it. Great performance!
I'm thinking he guided her to the astral plain, which he already visited before and planted those ideas there. Several Buddhas gave him hell for littering their existential realm.
😂😂😂
@Sharpo I laughed out loud at your comment on this. Thanks for the kind words.
@@jonmobley You are a master!
I’m thinking there were sounds fed into the monitors on the floor facing her, like a pig, rain, train, piano right before each question. If that's the case, he's playing with fire cause that's relying on the sound guy to get that just loud enough so only she hears and not anyone else... but this makes the most sense to me, as someone who's mixed lived show audio.
It’s also risky because just because she hears the sounds doesn’t mean she has to pick those answers. She could try to mess with him and pick totally opposite stuff
I want that painting! It is so unexpected pretty. That girl is so lucky. It is a great conversation piece for her.
I thought it would be scribbled words on the board, and then it is a painting, and she gets to take it with her, so it cannot be gimmicked. If she really had a free choice of words I cannot see how this was done, no clue, other than magic.
Well,...we know its not magic but I'm just as stumped as you are on this one.
This is exactly what I was thinking. I thought he was typing the words during strategic moments when he was facing to the right to hide his arm.
Kind of reminds me of between the lines but this was mind blowing!
Who said she had a free choice? ;)
I was ready to think maybe a nice AI image generator and rolling the dice that the result makes sense, but it looks painted and not like giant framed screen. Also this was apparently a few years ago :)
My only guess is she is hearing a different story than the audience so her answers are very obvious. Like it could like “what animal goes oink” or something like that. Not that exactly but somehow she’s hearing him ask questions that we don’t hear. Maybe the mic is getting muted.
Sooo… No clue
the chair ! sounds are coming from the chair thru bones of guest, easy trick
you are on the moon how do you not see a rocket coming your way to take u home? 🙄🙄🙄
it would be too obvious. If the participant had ANY instructs.. it was to pick anything BUT the obvious. All choices were inane on purpose.
@@Meinstein yeah and she shouldn’t get instructions in the first place
@@bahaaalouii8844 That's show biz. And it's within the rules. She DID have free choices.
It would not have been much of a trick if she had made ordinary choices. Chipmunk, airless, rocket.. would have surpried no one.
@@Meinstein between the 4 choices the only one ordinary is to say a rocket, the others dont have an ordinary answer so your argument is not valid
The image is actually great.
Ok, freaky, I imagined opening the red door BEFORE he said it, and imagine walking on stars. And also I imagine the train, but more like the NY subway. My other answers were Rabbit, and Rubik’s Cube.
I saw a squirrel - a spaceship - and a video game. So the answers she stated aren’t preloaded in someone’s mind obviously. He stumped me for sure.
* I forgot to say I thought rain originally. So idk, maybe there’s something subliminal in there.
I also thought Rubik’s cube! But I guessed rain too!
I was thinking a chipmunk, a storm, an orange, and a Rubik’s cube
@@evantate8840 I also thought of a chipmunk
Not only have I no idea how this was done but no idea on how P&T busted it????
What a great routine and a lovely touch to give the painting to the lady to keep.
Glad you enjoyed it!
But the spider was not driving the train. Huh?
Good act, part of the brilliance of this is the wording like questions that specifically say “playing with”. This way, when she says piano, no one would really expect to be playing “with” a piano rather playing a piano. probably people were imagining a yo-yo or something. It is super simple in general I’m not sure exactly which direct method was used. But if you consider each one of those items has a very quick and extremely distinct noise it makes to identify it. It’s super simple. Still really great performance.🎉
A fun performance and also a super-lovely picture at the end!
Thanks!!
Great painting!
So smart! I love this!
Thanks!
I feel this would have been more impressive had it been Alison or Penn being hypnotised...
Depending on how the trick was achieved, that might have given it away. Plus, with a trick like this, even though it would be against the rules anyway, it helps convince the audience that the person being hypnotized isn't in on the trick.
I still don't get the Sam Harris thing. She said pig. I would've said squirrel, clear skies, space shuttle, Iphone and the trick wouldn't have worked. How exactly did he get her to say pig, rain, spider playing a piano?
The clue of Sam Harris is how he pronounces it the second time.
He says "Sam HARRis". My guess is that they edited out Penn actually saying "Sam CHARRis" because it would have being obvious. So they edited out the 'C' sound.
The look of total bewilderment on P & T faces at 4:25 is something VERY rarely seen! It looked impossible to me, and Alyson looked stunning!
I find nobody’s explanation here plausible.
I for one appreciated the shout out to Sam Harris.
You loe7ionists?
@@dpersonal4187 What?
As an Atheist and Magician myself, I AGREE! 😺👍
@@NickvonZ Sure, if you like someone promoting a state that says it's founded on a religion. He's an intellectual lightweight and a hypocrite.
@@dpersonal4187 I like Atheists and Magicians. That was ALL I addressed.
I presented NO opinion beyond that.
Anything else, is coming from YOUR own mind. So that's on you alone.
Nice performance!
If I understand Penn's code words correctly, then he's suggesting that the ambient sound/music was priming the audience member to say those things. Am I on the right track here?
no
Yes
Both
maybe
Likely much more direct. Sound only she can hear, not sure if it would be direct instructions or eg. pig noises when he asks what animal. We don't see him select the audience member, probably vetted for suggestibility/agreeability.
Risky trick as you really need a compliant audience member.
hahaha not at all. that's not the method dude.
@@_MarioNeta_ Penns code implied that. Listen to what Penn says
Genoveve is HOT!
The best guess in the comments is that there were sounds next to the girl to make her think about specific things, but I think it would be too risky. For example, hearing the rain she could have said that the weather was foggy or cloudy.. or hearing a pig she could have said "boar" with a just a bit of fantasy.. so I'd say she had headphones with a different speech going on with different questions and he was very good at timing. Anyway nice trick, but the first time I saw this video I closed my eyes and imagined a turtle driving a spaceship on a cloudy day
Also if I were the one up there and I heard sounds i would purposely pick things that had nothing to do with them to try and screw up his trick so it’s very risky to leave it in the participants hands like that
Larry, Moe, Curly.
That's exactly what I imagined too a pig driving a train in the rain and a spider playing piano on the train carriage. Amazing. She's definitely not an actor!
bs sewer rat
@@Dr.IanPlect that's what you imagined? That's because thats what you are.
@@michaellynch4670 The amoeba is muted.
Russian troll
Dumb starting the video with her already set down. Earpiece placed before.
Good guess! But I assure you that is not the method. She is chosen from the audience randomly before I’m allowed on stage. Show rules :)
These are edited for time, so they cut out the audience selection process unless it's a funny or really unique method. Or if they have time to fill.
I think she was pre prepared .. a lot if the audience were , without realising this ..
I've seen how Darren Brown can do this to a bunch of people , well ..maybe ..
the magicians cannot do any prework on the audience on Penn & Teller Fool Us, so I don't see how the audience could be prepared on beforehand...
@@manusoftar
Good point , I'd forgotten that ..
Jenavive can get it