That the thing, zhuge liang know that Guan Yu will let cao cao go, if they kill cao cao there, wu will see shu as their main enemies, and shu at the time doesnt have base nor strength against wu, so kongming sent Yunchang to this task knowing that he will let mengde go
in the end, cao cao various achievements saved himself. both zhuge liang and zhou yu didnt dare to kill cao cao in fear of wei retaliation. guan yu also let cao cao leave after he heard cao cao talking jutsu.
Guan yu choose cao cao against his loyalty to liu bei ang zhuge liang . It’s very clear on the situation. It just show that guan yu have seen kindness on cao cao . So he spare the life of cao cao without hesitation .
Zhuge Liang purposely choosed Guan Yu for that reason so Cao Cao doesn't get killed by Liu Bei army and Guan Yu paid off Cao Cao kindness, very smart move.
@@gunawanputera6443 correct. If Cao Cao got killed, Wei will be on civil war cuz Cao Cao got many children as ambitious as him (just like Yuan family case). After capturing Xuchang and freeing the emperor, Wu will definitly turn against Shu and they will eventually perish since Shu still haven't reach their peak yet. In short yes, Wu will be victorious if Cao Cao got killed at that time.
@@auladit5700 also the remenant on wei will attack shu because they the one killed cao cao, shu will have to fight 2 front, wu just crush shu, and waited civil war to happend and then attack wei, remember when cao pi become prince of wei, cao zhen immedietly planing to rebel, only because of sima yi that he surrender
@@gunawanputera6443 not cao zhen, it's cao zhang, cao pi brother. After chi bi, Wu actually gain the most advantages here. It's a shame they can't utilized that properly and let the shu grow lol 🤣. Shu have to wait until they capture both Hanzhong and Jingzhou to gain advantage from both Wu and Wei. Well, at least Guan Yu managed to screw it 🤭
@@auladit5700 oh yea i always mixed up cao zhen and cao zhang, yeah they become overproud of their winnings (i mean yeah that really almost no way wei gonna win even in today standard), so they underestimate wei power when attacking jing and lost to zhuge liang plot, so do you know whose plan in red cliff battle? I read some source that zhou yu plan it, but there also some theories about zhuge liang who plan it, but he just saying that zhou yu plan it so wu will help them
The Lu Su, is same Lu Su in movie, Zhu Ge Liang and Liu Bei already know guan yu can't kill cao cao early, and in end caocao death in harsh, because many he friend who fough Dong Zhou gone awsy
because they know cao cao rather die than being captured, especially by Liu Bei who he always thing the inferior one. He might not commit suicide but do all he could do to avoid that
If I Zhuge, I will not place Guan Yu in the last ambush, knowing that Guan's loyalty, to make him unguilty I will place another general after Guan Yu to capture or kill Cao (so we will not let Guan smear his hands with Cao's blood for his loyal bonds)
then you would have failed, Zhuge Liang purposely choose Guan Yu for that reason so Cao Cao doesn't get killed by Liu Bei army, and wei retaliation doesn't come down hard on shu, which allowed for the balance of the 3 kingdoms and also allowed for time for shu to gain strength
Kinda feel for Cao Cao here, he barely gets away with his life, the guan yu encounter or not, cao cao needed to survive in order to revitalize Wei for the next leg of the race. Otherwise, Wu and Shu wouldve prolly fought to their deaths with each other.
The TV is based on the Novel, but the Novel is not named "Three Kingdoms" , is actually named "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness - 三国演义". The key concept is to show that each of the three kingdoms had their righteousness, so they became more success than other states and pollical leaders. Previously, Cao Cao can kill Guan Yu but he didn't because of his righteousness (loving heroes); same thing, Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao here but let him go because of Cao's previous righteousness to him and his own righteousness (thanksgiving and payback), which is just Guan's difference from Lu Bu even though Lu Bu is stronger than Guan Yu. So Guan Yu became a hero and Mars/battle god, but Lu Bu is only a warrior. Righteousness is the key culture of Chinese. If Guan Yu killed Cao Cao here, Guan Yu would have no any difference than most other ordinary warriors and he cannot become the god in Chinese Temples. Understand this, you will understand why Trump is so foolish in the trade war. Trump is threatening every country by his power, which is against Righteousness. CCP has no choice but fight back; otherwise, CCP will be overthrew like Chinese did to Qing Dynasty Government and Old Chinese Government (now in Taiwan). Guan Yu preferred to be killed but never surrender to any power and threatening; in contrast, he save Cao Cao's life when he became weak, poor and begging to him. Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao but let him go because of his begging, his poor situation and his previous righteousness to Guan, this is a greater Righteousness than Cao Cao gave him before. So, Guan won Cao in this regard. Otherwise, if Cao Cao save Guan previous but Guan killed Cao now, Cao will loss in righteousness. Guan's this character has made almost all Chinese worship him and his righteousness in Guan's Temples, which is called: 义气千秋 - righteousness for thousands years, which means Righteousness For Ever. Trump should read the Novel of "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness" 三国演义 before starting his war and before threatening other countries by the imperialism way
The TV is based on the Novel, but the Novel is not named "Three Kingdoms" , is actually named "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness - 三国演义". The key concept is to show that each of the three kingdoms had their righteousness, so they became more success than other states and pollical leaders. Previously, Cao Cao can kill Guan Yu but he didn't because of his righteousness (loving heroes); same thing, Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao here but let him go because of Cao's previous righteousness to him and his own righteousness (thanksgiving and payback), which is just Guan's difference from Lu Bu even though Lu Bu is stronger than Guan Yu. So Guan Yu became a hero and Mars/battle god, but Lu Bu is only a warrior. Righteousness is the key culture of Chinese. If Guan Yu killed Cao Cao here, Guan Yu would have no any difference than most other ordinary warriors and he cannot become the god in Chinese Temples. Understand this, you will understand why Trump is so foolish in the trade war. Trump is threatening every country by his power, which is against Righteousness. CCP has no choice but fight back; otherwise, CCP will be overthrew like Chinese did to Qing Dynasty Government and Old Chinese Government (now in Taiwan). Guan Yu preferred to be killed but never surrender to any power and threatening; in contrast, he save Cao Cao's life when he became weak, poor and begging to him. Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao but let him go because of his begging, his poor situation and his previous righteousness to Guan, this is a greater Righteousness than Cao Cao gave him before. So, Guan won Cao in this regard. Otherwise, if Cao Cao save Guan previous but Guan killed Cao now, GUAN will loss in righteousness and Cao will win. Guan's this character has made almost all Chinese worship him and his righteousness in Guan's Temples, which is called: 义气千秋 - righteousness for thousands years, which means Righteousness For Ever. Trump should read the Novel of "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness" 三国演义 before starting his war and before threatening other countries by the imperialism way
By common sense logic : if Guan Yu killed Cao Cao at Huarong Pass, Wei would view Shu as their arch enemy thay should be burn to ash, and it will surely happen because Shu at that time have no land they can call their own and Wu will just let them destroy each other. The point is nobody dare to kill Cao Cao because Wei with their masive and terrifying force still infront of their door.
@@henryhenry6051I thought you were cooking for a moment, then you put modern politics into it with a foolish presumption that your side of history is righteous, which is a presumption that should never be taken.
Even Cao Cao knew he had to give his head. Do not disobey miliary rules. But Guan yu is a fool. Not sure if it is loyalty. Cao Cao brought Guan Yu loyalty, it was not earned.
Everyone’s complaining Guan let cao cao go but cao cao lived because everyone was trying to get someone else to kill him.
That the thing, zhuge liang know that Guan Yu will let cao cao go, if they kill cao cao there, wu will see shu as their main enemies, and shu at the time doesnt have base nor strength against wu, so kongming sent Yunchang to this task knowing that he will let mengde go
in the end, cao cao various achievements saved himself.
both zhuge liang and zhou yu didnt dare to kill cao cao in fear of wei retaliation.
guan yu also let cao cao leave after he heard cao cao talking jutsu.
Guan yu choose cao cao against his loyalty to liu bei ang zhuge liang . It’s very clear on the situation. It just show that guan yu have seen kindness on cao cao . So he spare the life of cao cao without hesitation .
Zhuge Liang purposely choosed Guan Yu for that reason so Cao Cao doesn't get killed by Liu Bei army and Guan Yu paid off Cao Cao kindness, very smart move.
Lu Su's reaction the entire episode 🤣
Lol.. he couldn't believe he was getting played so sillily..
12:21 🤣
Zhu geliang is so smart，He didnt wanna kill caocao，at least not yet.
Cause he know if they kill cao cao, wu will turn to shu and attack them, and in that stage shu is not strong enough to take on wu
@@gunawanputera6443 correct. If Cao Cao got killed, Wei will be on civil war cuz Cao Cao got many children as ambitious as him (just like Yuan family case). After capturing Xuchang and freeing the emperor, Wu will definitly turn against Shu and they will eventually perish since Shu still haven't reach their peak yet. In short yes, Wu will be victorious if Cao Cao got killed at that time.
@@auladit5700 also the remenant on wei will attack shu because they the one killed cao cao, shu will have to fight 2 front, wu just crush shu, and waited civil war to happend and then attack wei, remember when cao pi become prince of wei, cao zhen immedietly planing to rebel, only because of sima yi that he surrender
@@gunawanputera6443 not cao zhen, it's cao zhang, cao pi brother. After chi bi, Wu actually gain the most advantages here. It's a shame they can't utilized that properly and let the shu grow lol 🤣. Shu have to wait until they capture both Hanzhong and Jingzhou to gain advantage from both Wu and Wei. Well, at least Guan Yu managed to screw it 🤭
@@auladit5700 oh yea i always mixed up cao zhen and cao zhang, yeah they become overproud of their winnings (i mean yeah that really almost no way wei gonna win even in today standard), so they underestimate wei power when attacking jing and lost to zhuge liang plot, so do you know whose plan in red cliff battle? I read some source that zhou yu plan it, but there also some theories about zhuge liang who plan it, but he just saying that zhou yu plan it so wu will help them
He didn't help, but pardon'ed him. He still had kindness debt to repay.
The Lu Su, is same Lu Su in movie, Zhu Ge Liang and Liu Bei already know guan yu can't kill cao cao early, and in end caocao death in harsh, because many he friend who fough Dong Zhou gone awsy
Why don't shu use cao cao as hostage? Then marched to the capital
because they know cao cao rather die than being captured, especially by Liu Bei who he always thing the inferior one. He might not commit suicide but do all he could do to avoid that
no different between the capture and killing. The result is same that wei will engage with shu and wu take the advantages.
Because this event did not happen in real history, Cao Cao simply fled from the battle of Red Cliff.
Because it is nonsense. Don't over analyze this. This is fictional.
there is a saying 士可杀不可辱. it is a widely known fact that commanders will commit suicide than become a captive
To the uploader....ILOVE YOU
Letting CAOCAO go is a pretty mature political move!
If I Zhuge, I will not place Guan Yu in the last ambush, knowing that Guan's loyalty, to make him unguilty I will place another general after Guan Yu to capture or kill Cao (so we will not let Guan smear his hands with Cao's blood for his loyal bonds)
then you would have failed, Zhuge Liang purposely choose Guan Yu for that reason so Cao Cao doesn't get killed by Liu Bei army, and wei retaliation doesn't come down hard on shu, which allowed for the balance of the 3 kingdoms and also allowed for time for shu to gain strength
Kinda feel for Cao Cao here, he barely gets away with his life, the guan yu encounter or not, cao cao needed to survive in order to revitalize Wei for the next leg of the race. Otherwise, Wu and Shu wouldve prolly fought to their deaths with each other.
Should have put bandit Cao into house arrest.
Enjoy Watching.
So did guan Yu actually help let cao cao escape in history?
Nope, this never happened.
Well Historically, and this whole period is probably fictional anyway, no Cao Cao simply escaped and no one helped him do it.
@@kensebego199 Iirc Cao Cao wasn't even present on Red Cliffs. He just got news about the lost battle and retreated.
給個二爺我 要啥給啥
感人
我智在天下 你想要荊州給你 在我司馬手上拿荊州無異于挑戰
Zhang fei huh 2 times in a row
曹操的演员是徐晓东吗？
徐你妈
國之強在人才也 我司馬一個能打萬人？那是扯淡要人才 曹操就大氣所以手下能將眾多
Guan Yu...Guan Yu... why?????
The TV is based on the Novel, but the Novel is not named "Three Kingdoms" , is actually named "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness - 三国演义". The key concept is to show that each of the three kingdoms had their righteousness, so they became more success than other states and pollical leaders. Previously, Cao Cao can kill Guan Yu but he didn't because of his righteousness (loving heroes); same thing, Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao here but let him go because of Cao's previous righteousness to him and his own righteousness (thanksgiving and payback), which is just Guan's difference from Lu Bu even though Lu Bu is stronger than Guan Yu. So Guan Yu became a hero and Mars/battle god, but Lu Bu is only a warrior.
Righteousness is the key culture of Chinese. If Guan Yu killed Cao Cao here, Guan Yu would have no any difference than most other ordinary warriors and he cannot become the god in Chinese Temples.
Understand this, you will understand why Trump is so foolish in the trade war. Trump is threatening every country by his power, which is against Righteousness. CCP has no choice but fight back; otherwise, CCP will be overthrew like Chinese did to Qing Dynasty Government and Old Chinese Government (now in Taiwan). Guan Yu preferred to be killed but never surrender to any power and threatening; in contrast, he save Cao Cao's life when he became weak, poor and begging to him. Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao but let him go because of his begging, his poor situation and his previous righteousness to Guan, this is a greater Righteousness than Cao Cao gave him before. So, Guan won Cao in this regard. Otherwise, if Cao Cao save Guan previous but Guan killed Cao now, Cao will loss in righteousness. Guan's this character has made almost all Chinese worship him and his righteousness in Guan's Temples, which is called: 义气千秋 - righteousness for thousands years, which means Righteousness For Ever.
Trump should read the Novel of "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness" 三国演义 before starting his war and before threatening other countries by the imperialism way
The TV is based on the Novel, but the Novel is not named "Three Kingdoms" , is actually named "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness - 三国演义". The key concept is to show that each of the three kingdoms had their righteousness, so they became more success than other states and pollical leaders. Previously, Cao Cao can kill Guan Yu but he didn't because of his righteousness (loving heroes); same thing, Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao here but let him go because of Cao's previous righteousness to him and his own righteousness (thanksgiving and payback), which is just Guan's difference from Lu Bu even though Lu Bu is stronger than Guan Yu. So Guan Yu became a hero and Mars/battle god, but Lu Bu is only a warrior.
Righteousness is the key culture of Chinese. If Guan Yu killed Cao Cao here, Guan Yu would have no any difference than most other ordinary warriors and he cannot become the god in Chinese Temples.
Understand this, you will understand why Trump is so foolish in the trade war. Trump is threatening every country by his power, which is against Righteousness. CCP has no choice but fight back; otherwise, CCP will be overthrew like Chinese did to Qing Dynasty Government and Old Chinese Government (now in Taiwan). Guan Yu preferred to be killed but never surrender to any power and threatening; in contrast, he save Cao Cao's life when he became weak, poor and begging to him. Guan Yu can kill Cao Cao but let him go because of his begging, his poor situation and his previous righteousness to Guan, this is a greater Righteousness than Cao Cao gave him before. So, Guan won Cao in this regard. Otherwise, if Cao Cao save Guan previous but Guan killed Cao now, GUAN will loss in righteousness and Cao will win. Guan's this character has made almost all Chinese worship him and his righteousness in Guan's Temples, which is called: 义气千秋 - righteousness for thousands years, which means Righteousness For Ever.
Trump should read the Novel of "Three Kingdoms Showing Righteousness" 三国演义 before starting his war and before threatening other countries by the imperialism way
By common sense logic : if Guan Yu killed Cao Cao at Huarong Pass, Wei would view Shu as their arch enemy thay should be burn to ash, and it will surely happen because Shu at that time have no land they can call their own and Wu will just let them destroy each other.
The point is nobody dare to kill Cao Cao because Wei with their masive and terrifying force still infront of their door.
@@henryhenry6051I thought you were cooking for a moment, then you put modern politics into it with a foolish presumption that your side of history is righteous, which is a presumption that should never be taken.
No, CaoCao died from illness.
Even Cao Cao knew he had to give his head. Do not disobey miliary rules. But Guan yu is a fool. Not sure if it is loyalty. Cao Cao brought Guan Yu loyalty, it was not earned.
Because you don't understand Eastern culture.
so the fact Guan Yu kill cao cao???
No, it's fiction.