Rain is one of those songs you don’t find very spectacular when you hear it for the first time. But as you go the more and more into the depth of the Beatles catalogue, you realise how special and crazy good that song is. AND ITS ONLY A B-SIDE
Liam Gallagher who’s obsessed with Lennon, calling his first kid Lennon, called the band Rain, and on Wonderwall (a Harrison reference) used the same lights in the sunglasses affect. Noel changed it to Oasis after a swimming pool in Swindon to not be too obviously Beatle inspired.
For my money, Strawberry Fields Forever backed with Penny Lane is the greatest single ever released. Both Lennon and McCartney wrote songs remembering their youths and early days in Liverpool. Lennon's SFF is much more the "dream", and I've heard it described as an unsure conversation with himself (listen to the indecisiveness of the lyrics), as if he's remembering earlier days, but isn't quite sure it is real or not. McCartney's PL is much more concrete, remembering specific people and places from Liverpool in a happier, more secure frame of mind. Both are squarely "psychedlic" with their word play and choice of instrumentation. You are right Caroline, they are entering a phase where they are quite literally willing to try anything in their songs. And let's not forget George Martin's contributions in scoring the awesome string and horn sections. Great songs, great reaction!
@@ansc6472 Listen to the chord structure, minor on the chorus, lots of changes in mode and key. Sure compared to Strawbery Fields Forever, it isn't, but it has a dreamlike quality. Remember, SFF's dreamlike attributes have a lot to do with the changing tape speed to match keys. Both highlight the difference between the two writers and how much they complimented each other.
@@Dude0000 I also seem to remember that the original concept for "In My Life" was about memories of Liverpool, like a proto-Strawberry Fields. So it seems this idea was ruminating within them for quite a while.
Paul and John were unstoppable in this time period. The Strawberry Fields Forever / Penny Lane single is generally considered to be one of the best singles of all time.
It is sobering and sad (as a 68 year old) to know full well that there will be people for whom "single" has no meaning. I am now reminiscing on orange label CBS singles, Pye's pink Kinks' singles and labels like Track, Immediate and Deram and many others that haven't existed for years. Happy days :-)
And yet back in the day the number one song of the year for 1967 on the Billboard charts was "To Sir, With Love" by Lulu. "Penny Lane" ranked number 55 for the year. Great as the Beatles were (are), it's interesting to contextualize their songs in the incredible outpouring of pop songs of the mid to late 60's. Anyone with a radio back then was overwhelmed by the incessant cavalcade of hits from both sides of the pond.
correct. Strawberry Fields is probably the single greatest song the Beatles made. And that's saying something since almost everything after Help! was genius.
@@ToneSherpa yes it is certainly among the very best but it is a studio invention and the Beatles could not reproduce it live, they were just not good enough!
@@g2tennis that's where you're mistaken... Pink Floyd has the immensely complex composition opener to their 1st album called "Astronomy Domine" and, yes, they were able to perform it live... there's even footage here on youtube (with impressive sound quality for the time too) So it just goes to prove that yes, it was humanly possible to reach that level of craftmanship in a musical instrument (and band)
Paul McCartney's bass line in "RAIN" is mindblowing - he single-handedly brought the bass guitar to the center of the stage with that 1966 track. Playing in a high-G octive was a bit unusual at the time and it alone inspired me to pick up a bass guitar and learn to play it. Thank you, Mr. McCartney, from the countless number of young musicians you've encouraged.
Yep, he really knew what to do with the bass to elevate every song. He could have been a guitarist but I’m glad he was a bassist, he was innovative as hell.
@@thesilvershining Note that he learned from The Beach Boys 'Pet Sounds' regarding mixing the bass more up front and more melodic. Good Vibrations from The Beach Boys is the template for McCartney's new approach to bass and piano style on Penny Lane which became very evident in Sgt Pepper and With A Little Help From My Friends.
This is a John song, what about praising John great songwriting and Ringo‘s drumming. You McCartney bass people Think that every song becomes a masterpiece when Paul plays his bass without recognizing the other members of the group, shame.
Pop suggests super popular mainstream things like Backstreet Boys, Steps, Vengaboys, Britney etc. who obviously, while good enough in context, are not the Beatles
@@SnabbKassa different types of pop. Radio pop is not the same as the pop the Beatles and the Kinks etc made. And then there's pop as in not classical (and often also distinct from folk).
For my money, Rain is the better track but not as commercially accessible as Paperback Writer. It was going to be the next single till Paul came in with Paperback Writer - an excellent song, but Rain has so much more texture and the lyrics (Caroline, please try to focus a bit more on their lyrics) are subtle with irony and as others have said, drum and bass are awesome. But then I have to admit I am more of John than a Paul fan!
@@andrewdoubtfire4700 it's a shame that advances in electronics have made things like the Mellotron obsolete. I'm sure there are YT videos about it, it's one of those contraptions that are impressive that they work at all, and it had an utterly distinctive sound.
@@andrewdoubtfire4700 It's effectively the first sampler ever made, a keyboard that plays back a pre-recorded tape loop for each key pressed. Register is not the right word to describe it, it would come with different banks of pre-recorded tape loops, in this case a flute.
Rain pointed forward - Strawberry Fields is the point where everyone realized that the Beatles transcended the realm of pop acts to the level of actual artists.
Rain was the first song with reverse vocals. I love it. Strawberry Fields is a great great masterpiece. So Penny Lane is. Strawberry Fields is for me one of the best songs ever written.
SFF is indeed one of the finest, if not the finest, pop song ever written. I don't like lists or rankings in things that cannot, and should not, try to be judged and ranked, but SFF is so transcendent that it really does merit the blue ribbon. It is simply that good.
@@Neal_Schier You can't really say which is the finest song of theirs because they wrote so many flawless songs. My favorites change on a daily basis...lol
@@MICKEYISLOWD There is obviously no objective metric to say that SFF is better than Hey Jude or Something. But as Caroline points out, the ARRANGEMENT of SFF is "better" - more creative - than with any other Beatles song. They use all the instrument families., and they use them well. Give some credit to George Martin's scoring. As arrangements go, SFF and "Good Vibrations" would have to be the top two pop songs of all time. Brian Wilson used up a ton of studio time recording the latter.
Caroline I was 16 when "Rain and "Paperback writer" came out and I remember thinking what can be better than this? And then it happened with "Strawberry fields forever" and "Penny lane"!! There was a big promo at the time and I was really looking forward to the next Beatles single which in my opinion is the best single ever!! From "I want to hold your hand" and "She loves you" to "Strawberry fields forever" and "Penny lane" in less than 3 years is remarkable!! I'm really thankful for growing up in such incredible times!!
@@jwt208 I would never denigrate John's ability, but the backward tape loops are Pauls. Done upstairs in the attic of his flat in the Ashers I believe.
The most brilliant part about Strawberry Fields is how it was stitched together from two different takes recorded in two different keys by slowing the tape down. You can hear the cut when John sings "going to" and the percussion comes in.
@@SM-dt1pr Technically, it is, like ADT, an innovation that came about from the demands of the creative genii of the Beatles. A lot of bands wanted to do things the Beatles did at this time. The Beatles had the best engineer and producer around to make what they wanted work. Listen to John's acoustic demo. It's good but not that interesting. The mix of artistic reach and engineering genius is what makes them great. As with Tomorrow Never Knows. How many bands wanted to do that but didn't have the talented crew behind them? We will never know.
The delight on your face as you listen is making my day! John Lennon said years later in his interview for "Playboy" magazine that the lyric, "No one I think is in my tree/I mean it must be high or low" referred to a feeling that nagged him his entire life, that he was either a genius, so much brighter than everyone around him (a common thought among bright school boys), or that he was insane or going insane, he was so out of step with everyone around him.
I'd say "Penny Lane" just makes me happy. As I got older "Rain" is extraordinary. The drum and bass lines are just incredible. I do love "Strawberry Fields", too.
@@dout0rm942 No, there’s change in speed of both the vocals and the backing track - one moved slower, the other faster. There’s a great TH-cam clip of the making of “Rain”. Only about 10 minutes long, and fascinating.
Strawberry Fields Forever/Penny Lane is absolute peak Beatles and probably the most important pair of songs they ever did, really showing off the different strengths of Lennon's (more abstract, nonsensical, inward-looking) and McCartney's (more melodic, emotional, outward-looking) styles. As much as I'm usually a Paul man of the two, to me, Strawberry Fields is the single greatest Lennon song and possibly even the best Beatles song altogether: it taps into something universal and almost unspeakable that lives inside everyone, a sort of twinned "certainty of my uncertainty." There's a reason its lyrics are so broadly quoted, and it's sonically breathtaking, too.
Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields were Paul and John, respectively, reflecting on their boyhoods in Liverpool. They’re real places. Strawberry Fields was a technical marvel in its time. They hobbled together two different takes with different tempos, instrumentations, and keys, and literally adjusted the electric power sources of their equipment to speed up and slow the takes to make them match. You can hear the edit point at like 0:59. Also check out the music videos of the two songs the Beatles channel. Iconic!
I was just about to comment this LOL. I had a surround system stereo in the 1990s. I could almost isolate the background vocals. So many layers to Their music!! Take care!!
In response to your question about which song drew us in more, you have to travel back in time to the 1960's...this was a time when there was no social media, no internet, only radio and TV. Music wasn't at our beck and call unless we were lucky enough to have a friend who had the 45's or the album of the band you wanted to hear or we were lucky enough to buy them ourselves. So you must understand that when new music came out you had to wait until it was played on the radio to hear it and if you liked a new song enough you found a way to buy the record or find a friend who bought it to hear it, it made for a different listening experience than kids have today. So when you bought a new record you played it over and over again till you knew all the words and could sing along with it. Now as to The Beatles, those of us who were lucky enough to grow up with them first heard their music as young teenagers and as we grew older each year, The Beatles musically grew right along with us...that's why we never outgrew them. And as they developed more sophisticated musically we started looking more and more for the inner meanings to the songs. Each new song, each new album was a revelation. If you think about it The Beatles changed the publics record buying habit from buying 45's to buying albums...before The Beatles most recording artists put out albums with one or two hit singles on them and the rest of the album was just kind of crappy filler songs to fill out the album. The Beatles from the very beginning put out albums that you wanted to listen to from beginning to end...very little filler songs. And as the years passed Beatle albums became works of art...they were pushing all the boundaries of what a band could do and what the public would accept. They changed music forever and the effects are still felt to this day. Before The Beatles it was all one hit wonders by singers and groups controlled by the record companies...The Beatles broke that bond and freed all after them to pursue their own musical visions. They gave the listening world a gift which we never can repay. So to ask us to say which Beatles song grabbed us the most when we first heard it is kinda a moot point because every new Beatles song grabbed us and became our favorite Beatle song until they released a new record. Honestly when you look back at The Beatles full catalogue it's amazing that they put out so many great songs in so short a time...truly amazing. I just really want to thank you for letting me see The Beatles again through your young eyes and ears and to again experience what it was like to hear these wonderful songs for the first time again.
This is the best answer I’ve read to the question of which one of these songs impacted us the most. This is basically how I feel. They ALL impacted me greatly and each one has been a joy to hear.
Just wanted to say that I’m 61 and watching someone with musical knowledge discover the brilliance of The Beatles in 2021 is such a joy. Getting to know this music was some of my best memories. I was 14 in 74 when I really got into them and the journey has continued ever since. (McCartney III is amazing) .
Can’t believe you don’t like “Rain”; fantastic recording. “Strawberry Fields Forever” is one of my all time favorite songs. A truly revolutionary recording.
Rain is great.. but as far as Beatles stuff goes, it's a bit meandering and sloppy. It's not a tight written perfectly executed pop song like some of there other stuff. some might consider the sloppiness a benefit though. and I'm inclined to agree depending on my mood. love the backwards stuff as well.
I wouldn't be surprised if you found you started liking "Rain" more the more you heard it. I find myself singing it to myself from time to time, even if I hadn't heard it for a very long time.
I love Rain, one of my favorites, but if someone doesn't love it immediately, I wouldn't expect that to change, really..... All I can say is that it signaled the start of the Beatles wanting to get seriously philosophical and revolutionary. Like, not just a fun diversion anymore - he says "can you hear me? can you hear me? I can show you..."
The bass and drums on “Rain” are amazing, and the way Paul and Ringo are working together on that like they’re reading each other’s minds the whole time.
Not King Lear, but Edward Lear who was a big influence on John Lennon's two books he wrote in 1964 and 1965 " A Spaniard in the Works" and " In His Own Write".
I live on Penny Lane and not much has changed, the barbershop etc is still there... And although it's very cold here today I'm looking out at very beautiful 'blue suburban skies'! Love from Liverpool x
Strawberry Fields Forever is one of the greatest songs of all time. It took its name from the Salvation Army home near John when he was growing up. It's still there now, helping people, and you can visit.
Penny Lane is written in two keys. The verses are in Bmaj and the chorus is in Amaj which means there is a downward whole step modulation happening on the lyric 'Meanwhile Back'. This mod happens 6 times seamlessly throughout the song and nobody notices it. Then there is an upward mod on the final chorus which is easy to hear. The song sounds simple however it is so beautifully crafted and very cleverly written. This is one of the reasons why The Beatles are so dammed good. The sophistication is always there to serve the song, unlike what came after The Beatles during the prog rock era where everyone was trying to dazzle the listener with complex lines and time signatures just to appear masterful when in fact anyone can write a song just so people can say 'wow...that's so complex'. Penny Lane is a 'perfect' song and writing perfect songs is about as difficult a task as one can imagine.
Strawberry fields is one of my favourite songs of all time. The intro with Mccartney playing the melotron sets the dream like quality of the song before it takes you on fantasy journey through Lennon's mind. Simply superb 👌
"Rain" is the one that really grabbed my attention when I was a teenager, and after hearing it with these other three here it still stands above them to me
When they made Strawberry Fields Forever, Jhon and Ringo were 26 years old, Paul 24 and George a mere 23 (practically a kid). Really blows the mind what they were able to accomplish at such a young age and all the instruments and studio experimentation they dived into with George Martin's help. Add to that the fact that there was zero previous history in the 60's of pop artists doing these innovative things such as using classical instruments with backwards or slowed down tapes. It's truly marvelous.
The amount of genius that was packed in that band was just staggering. After The Beatles both of Ringo and George had very fine careers on their own. Ringo had some very good singles (my favorite was Photograph) and George Harrison had probably the best Beatles solo album when he made All Things Must Pass. They were all brilliant artists and their music meant a lot to me growing up, and it still does. Every time I put it on it sounds just as good as it did when I 1st heard it. It never wears out
@@doriskray1430 I really wonder what the Beatles fans thought about the Pink Floyd song "Astronomy Domine" when it came out in 1967... because to me it remains as one of the most impressive things I ever heard
@@doriskray1430 California-centric writing about cars as a theme established by Chuck Berry. It was "The Beatles" who woke him to the reality that there is a world beyond California and wealth. Listen to the chauvinist "California Girls" -- then hear the contrasting -- it CRUSHES "The Beach Boys" harmonies -- "Back in the U.S.S.R."
The flutes in Strawberry Fields are actually a Mellotron, a precursor to the synthesizer that used a whole rack full of strips of recorded tape that play samples of various instruments, all controlled by a keyboard.
Almost basically an analog sampling synthesizer no less! The early electronic instruments are fascinating. I would have loved to have played an ondes Martenot at some point.
There’s an amazing video on WHY Penny Lane’s chord progression is literally mind blowing. Yeah Strawberry Fields is on the first listen more interesting but as a composition Penny Lane is so damn good. Also, as many people have pointed out, these two songs stand as counterpoints to each other. Both Lennon and McCartney wrote these songs about their upbringing. Also, it’s a perfect representation of their songwriting philosophies and really where they begin to really diverge from each other.
They were all along competing with each other for the "A"-side and first track on the LP. So they weren't "diverging"; they were simply more individually distinctive. One actually sees that throughout their career. McCartney sings, "I have to admit it's getting better," and Lennon responds, "It can't get no worse"". It's who they were together.
Rain would not make my top 100 Beatles songs. Yet it's your favorite. What sets the Beatles apart is the depth of their catalogue. Two different people could make a top 40 and not have a single sing in common. And every one of those 80 songs would be number 1 on someone's list, somewhere. What other band could that ever be said of?
Rain had a hard rock edge to it that was pretty new to the Beatles bag of tricks at that time (and has been mentioned backward vocals on the fade out). For some reason Rain rewards repeated listening. Paperback Writer with its cascading harmonies toward the end (and the Frere Jaques bit!) is a classic pop song. Penny Lane is a jaunty happy sound which does the Motown thing of sounding happy but having sad elements in the lyrics. Strawberry Fields Forever was - at the time it was released - a very new listening experience and fascinated everyone who heard it. When DJ Kenny Everett (at that time out on the pirate radio ship Radio London) first got a promo copy of it, he played it, on-air, six times in succession because he was so blown away by it! Strawberry Fields is the most interesting of these, but Rain is the one I go back to the most - but I'm not sure I could say why. All four would be in my Beatles top 10 though.
Rain is more about the bass and drums than it is about the melody. For me, anyway. That could be why Caroline mentioned that the melody didn't grab her.
I guess you can't really say The Beatles are known for any one sonic signature. They're known for changing music as we know it. From how it's written to how it's consumed and who it's consumed by to how it's produced and how it's recorded
@@thomast8539 I really wonder what the Beatles fans thought about the Pink Floyd song "Astronomy Domine" when it came out in 1967... because to me it remains as one of the most impressive things I ever heard
When the single came out, I was not yet 10 and I fell in love with Paperback Writer's clever/funny lyrics & driving tempo. But when I re-listened to the Beatles catalog as an adult it was Rain that blew me away. My first thought was what demon possessed Ringo and can we have some more? My second thought was, my god! Are they using the bass as the LEAD guitar on this song? Still one of my top 5 Beatles tracks.
I'm 29 so my experience is different then most of the commenters. But I love all these songs but hands down Strawberry Fields is one of if not the most important song in my musical life. When I first heard it as a young teen it really struck me and opened my eyes to what music could be. Penny Lane is a wonderful nostalgic masterpiece that's much more accessible than Strawberry Fields yet still has that psychedelic overtone. Paperback Writer is a fun example of middle Beatles song crafting And I love Rain. Some of Ringo's best drumming there. Literally every time it rains hard that song gets stuck in my head.
I really wonder what the Beatles fans thought about the Pink Floyd song "Astronomy Domine" when it came out in 1967... because to me it remains as one of the most impressive things I ever heard
Strawberry Fields was my favourite of the four back when they were released, but Rain still blows me away because that is Ringo's best drumming performance on a record, in my books. Every fill is different.
Strawberry Fields Forever, definitely. I heard John's haunting voice say "Living is easy with eyes closed, misunderstanding all you see. It's getting hard to be someone, but it all works out, it doesn't matter much to me": the arrangement is so delicate, so elegant; the imagery crystal clear. I wept when I heard it.
When it 1st came out, Strawberry Fields was mind-blowing. "Nothing is real." Nobody had ever put a line like that in "rock." ("You're making me feel like I've never been born?") SF was an orphanage where John chilled a lot growing up. Paul lived close to Penny Lane. They were both writing abt their childhoods in Liverpool. Both records were Double A sides. Read a ton more. And Ringo was so phenomenal I've decided lately they could not have been what they were without them
What if Paul hung around Strawberry Fields instead of John? What if John was more emotionally attached to Penny Lane than Paul was? Two VERY different songs would have been produced and I WANT TO HEAR THEM (LOL)
It is said that there is a world before The Beatles and a world after the Beatles... One could say that music today is what it is because of The Beatles.
Well that doesn't speak well for the Beatles considering the rather dismal state of current pop music. But you could say all music stems from Bach and Beethoven as well.
I was floored, stopped in my tracks, when 1st heard Strawberry Fields. I immediately exclaimed to my Mom. “That’s it. The Beatles will go down in history.” I was 14. It has remained my favorite Beatles song.
When I first heard it, I really didn't find it much attractive(half the reason is that I didn't really care about the lyrics at the time). But there was something special in that song which really made me think about it at times. Then I started to listen to it frequently and the more I listened to it the more it revealed. In this track Lennon is at the utmost level of his songwriting brilliance. It's a shame he was never satisfied with the way track turned out.
I heard "Rain" once as a very young boy, probably on the car radio as my family was driving between our home in northern Minnesota and my grandparents' farm in South Dakota. I didn't hear "Rain" again until I was a young adult, but that single snatch of music would come back to me from time to time. But my imagination had to fill in all I hadn't heard that one time, or couldn't remember accurately. Over the years the song became something called "Green" in my imagination with a different set of lyrics. When I finally heard "Rain" again, in its entirety, it purged my childhood memory and, for the life of me, I can't recall anything of the pastiche I invented.
Wonderfully explained. Pre-internet/pre-apps something vague but impactful could sear into your memory. Years would go by. You’d wonder if the mystery would ever be solved - how much was real, how much did I fill in the blanks from the fog. Then one day, maybe decades later ... an omg moment and it’s all unlocked. Been there.
It could be the favorite Beatles song we each pick DOES bring back a certain memory of where we were at the time. Or even the weather of a certain feeling, memory or season. For me: Rubber Soul/Christmas…SgtPep/summer vacation….She Loves You/pig tails & bubble gum.
Rain is my fav Beatles tune since 1966 when I played it at 13 for my friends on a sunny/rainy scottish afternoon. This tune may likely grow inside your brain !!!!
I have been a huge Beatles fan for decades and whenever I am asked which of their songs is my favorite (even though there are so many, really) I always say "Penny Lane". The reasons are that it is, in my opinion, the perfect pop song: it has a superb melody, great evocative storytelling lyrics based on an actual "lane" in Liverpool (which I have been fortunate to visit !), a fantastic arrangement and production and of course an outstanding lead vocal from Paul McCartney. It's so enjoyable to watch someone young like you, and obviously gifted with a great ear, discover the Beatles music. It's easy to understand how they were truly instrumental (and vocal... pardon the pun) in shaping and innovating popular music. Keep on enjoying the Fabs !
In Penny Lane, when the chorus of the fireman starts, Paul sings "In his pocket is a portrait of the queen". This is a reference to a British coin. They loved to throw little things like that in their songs.
@@piaraskelly1038 Mabee, not from that source synecdoche is a poetic device where you use a part to represent the whole or the whole to describe the part. So it's possible they both used the same device without reference to each other.
Do we want to tell her what the "full of fish and finger pie" line in Penny Lane is all about? (hint: kind of the equivalent to the American line "getting to third base")
@@penfold7455 I read about that years ago, probably in the Hunter Davies biography. And was gong to keep my mouth shut...but now that you bring it up...🤣...today, watch Paul try to deny it in some interview lol
George Martin was actually the seventh Beatle. Stu Suttcliffe was the fifth and Brian Epstein was the sixth and Billy Preston was the eighth. No, Pete Best doesn't count.
@@TheSpikehere I expect that there were whispers that Martin was the hidden hand. As a kid, I found it hard to believe that the Beatles wrote all their songs. I suspected that they were ghost written. It just seems so incredible that such an accomplished act was more than an act. That it was a creative force. Before the Beatles, performers mostly were puppets on a string.
"Rain" was a hard track to come by when I started listening to the Beatles, and when I eventually heard it, I loved it. It's a great pop song, but it's also has a unique, trippy vibe because of how it plays with time. And the harmonies are great.
And it seems they are vocally replicating the sitar sound here. They are droning the vowel in "rain" by repeating it to stretch the word: rai, ai, ai, ai, ain. It's like a sitar droning an A note. And it mirrors what they are doing by slowing down the track slightly; stretching it out. Just a really cool little pop song
I didn't really care for Rain at first and I also thought it just sounded off. But it's one of those songs that gets better and better literally every single time you listen to it. It's become my favorite Beatles song to just listen to, and I think it's their most solid song overall.
Nice to see and hear your enthusiasm, interest, analysis, curiosity, fascination, surprises, smiles, emotion and joy from this music. As for my own reaction, Penny Lane hit me strongest when I was a 13 year old in 1967 and it's still a brilliant piece of joyfullness, but Strawberry Fields is, by far, my favourite of these 4 songs nowadays, partly through an understanding of it's musical complexity and originality.
By common agreement, "Rain" features the finest drumming of Ringo Starr's career. Even he said he couldn't imagine where it came from, and he could never capture the same spirit again.
Let’s not forget it is only 3 years from She Loves You and I Want to Hold Your Hand. The amount of progression stylistically is astonishing. Most bands never change styles or very little in their entire career. The Beatles completely reinvented themselves. For me Strawberry Fields Forever followed by Rain are my favorites out of the four. John’s voice and lyrics connect with me on a deep level. The dreamlike quality of both are very comforting. Cazza you put a very big smile on my face this morning. Happy Thanksgiving!
Loved and still love all four of these songs. As great I feel that they all are, Strawberry Fields ... no, they are all very different and all fantastic. Why can't we just enjoy them instead of comparing them and saying a song or an album is the best ever. It just raises expectations for someone hearing it for the first time to a point where they may be disappointed. Enjoy it for what it is and was. Your reaction, Caroline, to Strawberry Fields Forever was priceless. I love seeing you light up when you hear something you really like.
"Strawberry fields" wrote by John about his memories of an orphanat he used to get in its yard to let his imagination go. "Penny Lane" is the about memories Paul's answer to John's song. Greetings from Mexico.
Also to your question, it was strawberry fields that drew me in. It’s a quintessential John Lennon song. No one writes like Lennon. he writes songs as if you’re hearing him think. “I think er no I mean er yes but it’s all wrong. That is I think I disagree” listening to that was delightful. Playful and honest. It’s a bitter sweet song once you sink into it. After a couple replays the weight of it begins to settle. This is an absolutely personal song. It actually brings tears to my eyes. “Living is easy with eyes closed. Misunderstanding all you see.” It’s all magic. For me the lyrics are perfect. Add on top of that an absolutely blow out performance by Mr. George Martin and you get a teary, fun and unique thrash through John Lennon’s psyche. Also the acoustic version (demo) on the anthology is tragic.
@@perhapsxarb7226 yes it is, a quick Google search will tell you this. Check all the lyric books. *But it's all wrong* talks about what John *knows is all wrong* , hence the, *I think I know, I mean* -- implying ego death, LSD psychedelia stuff. The *er no, er yes* you seem to think it is, is just nonsense and that is more akin to Walrus than Strawberry Fields
From the simplistic 'Love Me Do' to 'Strawberry Fields'...how far they'd come musically in 5 short years.......absolutely astounding isn't it Caroline?
Their career was astonishing at all: in september 1962 they released 'love me do' as a relative unknown band and one year later they played a concert in front of the british royals.
I'm so happy you listened to Strawberry and Penny Lane before Sgt. Pepper. It's so cool you got to sort of replicate how audiences were introduced to the music The Beatles were working on during that era. Can't wait for the next one as Sgt. Peppers was the first album I can remember listening to as a kid!
When they made the song Rain they slowed down the music tracks a little and sped up the vocal track a little. That's why it has a kind of hypnotic effect.
Yup at this stage John was into any new studio effects that George Martin could come up with to change his voice. That enthusiasm was waning after the White album, and by the time of recording' Let it be' Lennon didn't want any kind of studio tricks at all, and was openly rude and dismissive to Martin about this kind of production contribution. Martin only agreed to do the following 'Abbey Road' album if he was allowed to produce it the way he had previously collaborated with them.
Strawberry Fields Forever has always been a favourite of mine although I do love all of their music! It was a magical time growing up with them and witnessing the black & white world we were born into suddenly turn into full on colour!!! It's great to watch your reactions to them! You are a wonderful person and that comes through in your reactions! Thank you! Peace and Love forever!
Rain is my fav Beatles song ever. I love everything about it and it was the song that got me to take notice of the Beatles. It's the perfect middle ground between who the Beatles were and who they would become.
All four of these tracks are fantastic. All four of them will be listened to and admired for generations to come. This cannot be said for most pop music of today.
Strawberry Field is a musical revolution on it’s own. One of the best songs of all time. Still amazes me. And not just because of the groundbreaking production and arrangement. It is still amazing played with one ukulele.
I didn't remember hearing Rain as a kid so Strawberry Fields Forever really hit me. All of the Beatles were still alive and making their own music by the time I started to develop my personal musical taste. I have, and always will, gravitate toward John. There's a dark honesty in his presentation of his lyrics that is usually backed by a more somber tone. Because of that, Rain has been my second favorite Beatles song behind Tomorrow Never Knows. I sing Strawberry Fields in karaoke and I play lightly through the first two times through the chorus, but I put a dark emphasis on "Nothing is real", later in the song. I feel the song needs that emphasis. I love your videos in general, but can't get enough of your Beatles reactions. Honest and in the moment, the way it should be. Thanks!!
"Strawberry Fields Forever" blew our minds when it came out. The LP was alive with thought-provoking, along with fun lyrics and sounds. Thanks for sharing. You Rock!!
Minor corrections: Strawberry Fields didn't take off when the single was first released, barely cracking the BIllboard Top 10 in the U.S. The flip side (Penny Lane) made #1 because it got more radio airplay. Also, it was a single only, not on any album at the time, although later released on the U.S. Magical Mystery Tour album.
@Dave Pollison I meant to say, "The Lp that it was on..." Thanks for pointing it out. Also, I and the people I hung out with didn't generally listen to Top Ten Radio Stations. Plus, my older brother bought anything, Beatles, as soon as it was released. Their were quite a few groups we listened to that weren't getting a lot or any of Top Ten's attention. We mostly listened to local collage stations that could play "heavier" music and didn't have time restraints on the length of songs. There was usually one night a week where they would play full LPs. Thanks again for helping me with my reply 😃
As a lifelong fan of The Beatles, (some 50+ years now) it gives me goosebumps to see someone listen to them for the first time. It gives me the chance to hear songs I've heard 1000 times or more for the first time again. Thank you so much. I love all four of these tracks but "Strawberry Fields" is my favorite song of these four. It's the one that makes you think the most. But I love them all.
Strawberry Fields blew my mind when I heard it on the radio as a young teenager. "What was THAT?!" As you say, quite different from regular pop tunes, both then and now. Producer George Martin had a substantial effect on the Beatles use of instrumental variety, in terms of translating what they were after into specific musical arrangements.
In answering the last question, I think when I was young, I loved Penny Lane most of the four. I also loved Paperback Writer for it's more rock and roll sound. As I got older, I came to appreciate Strawberry Fields more and it may have been one Lennon's best songs of the later years of the group. I always thought that Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane contrasted against each other very well...Strawberry Fields always felt more moody and melacholy, while Penny Lane was more upbeat. For some friends, I just recently rated my favorite five Beatles songs from their later years and Strawberry Fields was my number 4 (behind While My Guitar Gently Weeps, Something, and Come Together). But everyone's tastes are different and there are so many great ones to choose between. Thank you again for these videos!
One of the genius of Penny lane is this: In the chorus, while the vocals go up, the music goes down. This creates a not 100% joy but a wistful nostalgia, which is the point of the song. This is not an original thought, but an observation made by Howard Goodall in his Beatles episode of his music documentary series.
@@youngbloodk Agree 100%, wait till the end, and then find out what an orchestral composer think of the Beatles contributions, and who they find themselves sharing the accolades with.
The Beatles’ use of classical instruments in their music inspired me to listen to the great composers like Bach, Brahms, Beethoven, Mozart and others. They definitely were instrumental in helping me expand my musical tastes beyond rock n roll. And that’s yet another reason why I love this band. They were never conventional, but were always branching out and experimenting.
Compare that unwillingness to be tied to one particular sound or style to today's bands and even individual singers. I asked my dear wife about Adele, who she loves. Do All her songs sort of sound the same?? "Well, yes, sort of !!"
@@scottski51 I couldn’t agree with you more. My kids often tell me that they wished they grew up in the time of the Beatles. They find today’s music so boring.
Most people do not know that Paul McCartney has written and recorded five classical music albums within the last 30 years: Liverpool Oratorio (1991), Standing Stone (1997), Working Classical (1999), Ecce Cor Meum (2006), Ocean's Kingdom (2011).
@@daddyguerrero Think "safe" is another word that could be used for today's pop music...Beatles were real catchy pop & ultra edgy experimental all at the same time, simply because they were extremely talented and got bored easily with doing the thing musically over and over again....who could or would try to pull that off again....Will never happen!....and I never say "never"....but in this case, "that will never happen again"....Beatles forever!
@@Bipbop66 This could have happened to the Beatles, as well. Had they been successful in their Decca audition, they would never have connected with George Martin. Instead, they would have been under the control of pop producers and A&R men. The pressure would have been to create songs that had certain proven tempos and other elements. They would not have gotten the education that George Martin, a classical music producer who heard their potential, provided. He took them to the symphony, where they heard all those instruments. That wouldn't have happened at Decca.
You're authentic, intelligent, and very entertaining. I appreciate your true joy at the first time hearing this. I was born in June 1964. My brother Steve was 8 and just bought his first Beatles album. I had no choice but to hear it. That was the greatest no choice for me.
Your reaction to "Strawberry Fields" was beautiful. Can you believe it was their first single NOT to get to number one?! :P Welcome to 1967 Beatles, welcome to the middle period! Goodbye moptops! And if you like The Beatles playing with any instrument they like.....you will be loving the rest of your Beatles journey!/ Oh my gosh, your ideas of what "Paperback Writer" is about cracked me up so much! / I love the bass triplets on the last chorus of "Rain". The way the bass was recorded for this single was revolutionary; after this, you started to hear a lot more bass on everyone's records./ ALL of your comments were spot-on in this video.
Paul McCartney’s bass playing becomes transcendent for the rest of The Beatles’ career. Rain is the first song in which his bass really comes to the fore. It was starting to become more important on Rubber Soul but Revolver is where he really takes off and it just keeps getting better.
I've been a Beatles fan for my whole life (pretty much) as my parents were teenagers during the sixties and so my childhood involved hearing a lot of their music (although, I came to find out, it was predominantly focused on their early years). It wasn't until I was like 15/16 when I went from a passive fan to an active one when I first heard their experimental/psychedelic phase (Revolver, Sgt Pepper, Magical Mystery Tour) and was instantly obsessed. Needless to say, I am a massive Beatles nerd, however, I'm not educated in terms of the technical musical side but more the lore, history, and lyrics (I'm a writer so lyrics and feel/sound draw me in). Strawberry Fields Forever is my favourite song of all time (other than 'I Am The Walrus' from Magical Mystery Tour so I'm looking forward to your reaction to that album). It is such a mysterious, dreamy, unique sounding song, how it changes from mellow at the beginning to sinister with the brass and cellos, the stumbling lyrics about Lennon's own confused childhood thoughts, the elaborate layered instruments, the studio effects, etc. I personally love 'Rain' as Paul's bassline is insane, it's arguably Ringo's best drumming performance, the Indian-influenced sound of the chorus, the Indian-summer feel of the song (juxtaposed comedically with Lennon's ruminations on British summers i.e. sunshine and heat constantly interrupted with rain, and how this is compared to the strangeness of changing moods - particularly when on certain substances). It is refreshing to see a musical analysis of these songs and albums from a new listener that is educated in the technical side of music, although I would be interested if you looked into the lyrics more (but that's just me). Love your videos, keep up the good work, and sorry for this essay lmao
Your essay really resonates with me--I agree with your musings, from the first sentence to the last (I 'm just a couple years younger than your parents).
Wow, your story is just about the same as mine. I was born in 1968, and I listened to my parent's record collection from a very young age. I sometimes regret that I heard Sgt. Pepper for the first time around the age of roughly 7 or 8, before I was able to comprehend what a revolution that album was. Not having any other baseline, I simply thought all music was this good. Revolver? The same. Abbey Road? I mean, come on! Magical Mystery Tour (US version)? What a trip for a young, eight-year old mind. I often tell my dad that the reason I have such strong musical instincts is because his own taste in music was so great... so much Beatles in his record collection. I became a professional musician (mostly as a composer of classical music and theater music) because of The Beatles...and my dad's record collection.
I'm enjoying your reaction to Strawberry Fields. When it was released in 1967, it blew minds all over the map. Many didn't like it and radio stations banned it. I'm glad to see that it resonates with someone of your age. People are finally catching up to it. Recommend the compelling recordings on Beatles Anthology Two that showcase the evolution of "Strawberry Field's" development.
Strawberry Fields Forever is the song that impacted me the most, not only put of these four songs, but out of all their songs. It just makes me feel such a specific way, it's a mix of insecurity, a dreamy feeling and just a general sense of taking you somewhere else far away from wherever you might be and whatever you might be experiencing, like a lot of music, it's an escape, but it let's you escape into this magical and mysterious world, and there are so many layers to the instrumentation as well, and that adds a feeling of depth, where you truly feel like you're there in strawberry fields.
I feel the same way about the song, but you've expressed it so well. And it's so personal, one really feels like one is riding along in John's train of thought.
Rain is one of those songs you don’t find very spectacular when you hear it for the first time. But as you go the more and more into the depth of the Beatles catalogue, you realise how special and crazy good that song is. AND ITS ONLY A B-SIDE
Wasn't it also the first record ever that used some backwards vocals?
Rain blew me away on first hearing!
It’s one of the first songs I learned to play on guitar… It must’ve been… 1976
Paul"s bass is just phenomenal on Rain.
Liam Gallagher who’s obsessed with Lennon, calling his first kid Lennon, called the band Rain, and on Wonderwall (a Harrison reference) used the same lights in the sunglasses affect. Noel changed it to Oasis after a swimming pool in Swindon to not be too obviously Beatle inspired.
For my money, Strawberry Fields Forever backed with Penny Lane is the greatest single ever released. Both Lennon and McCartney wrote songs remembering their youths and early days in Liverpool. Lennon's SFF is much more the "dream", and I've heard it described as an unsure conversation with himself (listen to the indecisiveness of the lyrics), as if he's remembering earlier days, but isn't quite sure it is real or not. McCartney's PL is much more concrete, remembering specific people and places from Liverpool in a happier, more secure frame of mind. Both are squarely "psychedlic" with their word play and choice of instrumentation. You are right Caroline, they are entering a phase where they are quite literally willing to try anything in their songs. And let's not forget George Martin's contributions in scoring the awesome string and horn sections. Great songs, great reaction!
If I remember rightly, it was the first two songs of an abandoned project album about Liverpool.
I agree that it's the best single ever.
Penny lane is not psychedelic compared to Strawberry Fields Forever
@@ansc6472 Listen to the chord structure, minor on the chorus, lots of changes in mode and key. Sure compared to Strawbery Fields Forever, it isn't, but it has a dreamlike quality. Remember, SFF's dreamlike attributes have a lot to do with the changing tape speed to match keys. Both highlight the difference between the two writers and how much they complimented each other.
@@Dude0000 I also seem to remember that the original concept for "In My Life" was about memories of Liverpool, like a proto-Strawberry Fields. So it seems this idea was ruminating within them for quite a while.
‘Rain’ is one of my favorite Beatles songs. It’s also one of the best examples of great bass and drum playing ever.
It's amazing how Penny Lane makes me feel nostalgic towards a place I've never been. Such a wonderful song!
Paul and John were unstoppable in this time period. The Strawberry Fields Forever / Penny Lane single is generally considered to be one of the best singles of all time.
By whom? The Beach Boys' God Only Knows/Wouldn't It Be Nice double A-side is also often mentioned in that regard.
It is sobering and sad (as a 68 year old) to know full well that there will be people for whom "single" has no meaning.
I am now reminiscing on orange label CBS singles, Pye's pink Kinks' singles and labels like Track, Immediate and Deram and many others that haven't existed for years. Happy days :-)
@@thetragicyouth By whom? (Just a joke. I'm not really asking.)
@@thetragicyouth the operative word being "one"...
And yet back in the day the number one song of the year for 1967 on the Billboard charts was "To Sir, With Love" by Lulu. "Penny Lane" ranked number 55 for the year. Great as the Beatles were (are), it's interesting to contextualize their songs in the incredible outpouring of pop songs of the mid to late 60's. Anyone with a radio back then was overwhelmed by the incessant cavalcade of hits from both sides of the pond.
Strawberry Fields Forever is a timeless masterpiece.
Both
correct. Strawberry Fields is probably the single greatest song the Beatles made. And that's saying something since almost everything after Help! was genius.
@@ToneSherpa yes it is certainly among the very best but it is a studio invention and the Beatles could not reproduce it live, they were just not good enough!
@@pmoran7971 not about being good enough, it is impossible to reproduce it live because of how it was edited
@@g2tennis that's where you're mistaken... Pink Floyd has the immensely complex composition opener to their 1st album called "Astronomy Domine" and, yes, they were able to perform it live... there's even footage here on youtube (with impressive sound quality for the time too) So it just goes to prove that yes, it was humanly possible to reach that level of craftmanship in a musical instrument (and band)
Paul McCartney's bass line in "RAIN" is mindblowing - he single-handedly brought the bass guitar to the center of the stage with that 1966 track. Playing in a high-G octive was a bit unusual at the time and it alone inspired me to pick up a bass guitar and learn to play it. Thank you, Mr. McCartney, from the countless number of young musicians you've encouraged.
And that is just ONE of his great bass lines!
Yep, he really knew what to do with the bass to elevate every song. He could have been a guitarist but I’m glad he was a bassist, he was innovative as hell.
@@thesilvershining Note that he learned from The Beach Boys 'Pet Sounds' regarding mixing the bass more up front and more melodic. Good Vibrations from The Beach Boys is the template for McCartney's new approach to bass and piano style on Penny Lane which became very evident in Sgt Pepper and With A Little Help From My Friends.
And also some of Ringo's best work.
This is a John song, what about praising John great songwriting and Ringo‘s drumming. You McCartney bass people Think that every song becomes a masterpiece when Paul plays his bass without recognizing the other members of the group, shame.
I don’t understand why people don’t like you calling them “pop songs.”
They’re the most brilliant pop songs ever written!
Pop suggests super popular mainstream things like Backstreet Boys, Steps, Vengaboys, Britney etc. who obviously, while good enough in context, are not the Beatles
@@SnabbKassa different types of pop. Radio pop is not the same as the pop the Beatles and the Kinks etc made. And then there's pop as in not classical (and often also distinct from folk).
yeah it's pop music. in every sense of the word. not just because it's popular but because it's in the style of pop songs of the era.
Might be a British thing. Townsend and Clapton referred to their music as pop constantly.
@@bfish89ryuhayabusa i would consider the beatles and the kinks more of rock than pop
Rain is, for my money, Ringo's finest performance.
He said so himself
Absolutely.
Maybe Paul's on the bass too.
For my money, Rain is the better track but not as commercially accessible as Paperback Writer. It was going to be the next single till Paul came in with Paperback Writer - an excellent song, but Rain has so much more texture and the lyrics (Caroline, please try to focus a bit more on their lyrics) are subtle with irony and as others have said, drum and bass are awesome. But then I have to admit I am more of John than a Paul fan!
100%
In "Strawberry Fields" the woodwinds are made with Mellotron on flutes register.
I wish I was smart enough to have the faintest idea as to what you are talking about
Simultaneously peaceful and haunting
@@andrewdoubtfire4700 it's a shame that advances in electronics have made things like the Mellotron obsolete. I'm sure there are YT videos about it, it's one of those contraptions that are impressive that they work at all, and it had an utterly distinctive sound.
@@andrewdoubtfire4700 It's effectively the first sampler ever made, a keyboard that plays back a pre-recorded tape loop for each key pressed. Register is not the right word to describe it, it would come with different banks of pre-recorded tape loops, in this case a flute.
@@tomwaite5127 Those mellotron flutes have a haunting sound.
You can't not love Strawberry Feilds. It's just not possible. It's a masterpiece.
it is their best song and lyrically Lennons best too
Rain pointed forward - Strawberry Fields is the point where everyone realized that the Beatles transcended the realm of pop acts to the level of actual artists.
"I'm Only Sleeping" pointed to "Rain" pointed to "Strawberry Fields Forever".
Rain was the first song with reverse vocals. I love it. Strawberry Fields is a great great masterpiece. So Penny Lane is. Strawberry Fields is for me one of the best songs ever written.
SFF is indeed one of the finest, if not the finest, pop song ever written.
I don't like lists or rankings in things that cannot, and should not, try to be judged and ranked, but SFF is so transcendent that it really does merit the blue ribbon. It is simply that good.
@@Neal_Schier You can't really say which is the finest song of theirs because they wrote so many flawless songs. My favorites change on a daily basis...lol
@@MICKEYISLOWD There is obviously no objective metric to say that SFF is better than Hey Jude or Something. But as Caroline points out, the ARRANGEMENT of SFF is
"better" - more creative - than with any other Beatles song. They use all the instrument families., and they use them well. Give some credit to George Martin's scoring.
As arrangements go, SFF and "Good Vibrations" would have to be the top two pop songs of all time. Brian Wilson used up a ton of studio time recording the latter.
Tomorrow Never Knows wasn't first?
@@MrKeychange Rain was released on may 30, 1966 and Tomorrow never knows august 5, 1966.
All four are great Beatles songs, but there is something extra special/magical about Strawberry Fields Forever.
Caroline I was 16 when "Rain and "Paperback writer" came out and I remember thinking what can be better than this? And then it happened with "Strawberry fields forever" and "Penny lane"!! There was a big promo at the time and I was really looking forward to the next Beatles single which in my opinion is the best single ever!! From "I want to hold your hand" and "She loves you" to "Strawberry fields forever" and "Penny lane" in less than 3 years is remarkable!! I'm really thankful for growing up in such incredible times!!
Don't you think Caroline is remarkable for 70 ! Michael ? 🤡
No I being inebriated misread that - back to bed ! 🎱
And one never knew, couldn't guess, what the next record would be like.
@@jnagarya519 The whole point of the the journey they took us on. What's next / You knew it would be good .. the future's looking good.
Both Paul and Ringo (drums and bass) are absolute BEASTS on Rain. One of my favorites.
Probably the first 'pop' song where the bass and drums are the 'lead' instruments and the rhythm and lead are the backing.
And, Ringo's drumming on Strawberry Fields Forever is pure brilliance.
@@jwt208 I would never denigrate John's ability, but the backward tape loops are Pauls. Done upstairs in the attic of his flat in the Ashers I believe.
@@jwt208 The tape loops were all done by Paul at home and brought in. The 'seagull' shriek at the beginning is Paul laughing backwards.
@@NigelT57 They were all involved with the tape loops and backwards tapes.
The most brilliant part about Strawberry Fields is how it was stitched together from two different takes recorded in two different keys by slowing the tape down. You can hear the cut when John sings "going to" and the percussion comes in.
When John suggested this the engineers thought he'd finally lost it, but it worked perfectly.
@@mikeknowles5848 That John guy, kinda had good ideas !:)
With respect, that's an interesting fact, but it's not "the most brilliant part..."
@@SM-dt1pr Technically, it is, like ADT, an innovation that came about from the demands of the creative genii of the Beatles. A lot of bands wanted to do things the Beatles did at this time. The Beatles had the best engineer and producer around to make what they wanted work. Listen to John's acoustic demo. It's good but not that interesting. The mix of artistic reach and engineering genius is what makes them great. As with Tomorrow Never Knows. How many bands wanted to do that but didn't have the talented crew behind them? We will never know.
Yes, David Bennet has a brilliant video on it
The delight on your face as you listen is making my day!
John Lennon said years later in his interview for "Playboy" magazine that the lyric, "No one I think is in my tree/I mean it must be high or low" referred to a feeling that nagged him his entire life, that he was either a genius, so much brighter than everyone around him (a common thought among bright school boys), or that he was insane or going insane, he was so out of step with everyone around him.
Yeah but he couldn't do mundane practical things like dive a car.
He almost died (along with Yoko) when he tried.
@@skarath Same tbh
I'd say "Penny Lane" just makes me happy. As I got older "Rain" is extraordinary. The drum and bass lines are just incredible. I do love "Strawberry Fields", too.
In Rain they slowed down the bass?
In an interview, Ringo said he'd never been as busy in a song, before or after, as in "Rain".
@@lawrencefeldman7744 no, that the speed paul recorded in. The only slowed down thing are John's vocals I think.
@@dout0rm942 No, there’s change in speed of both the vocals and the backing track - one moved slower, the other faster. There’s a great TH-cam clip of the making of “Rain”. Only about 10 minutes long, and fascinating.
Strawberry Fields Forever/Penny Lane is absolute peak Beatles and probably the most important pair of songs they ever did, really showing off the different strengths of Lennon's (more abstract, nonsensical, inward-looking) and McCartney's (more melodic, emotional, outward-looking) styles. As much as I'm usually a Paul man of the two, to me, Strawberry Fields is the single greatest Lennon song and possibly even the best Beatles song altogether: it taps into something universal and almost unspeakable that lives inside everyone, a sort of twinned "certainty of my uncertainty." There's a reason its lyrics are so broadly quoted, and it's sonically breathtaking, too.
Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields were Paul and John, respectively, reflecting on their boyhoods in Liverpool. They’re real places. Strawberry Fields was a technical marvel in its time. They hobbled together two different takes with different tempos, instrumentations, and keys, and literally adjusted the electric power sources of their equipment to speed up and slow the takes to make them match. You can hear the edit point at like 0:59. Also check out the music videos of the two songs the Beatles channel. Iconic!
TH-cam has stupidly moved your time to a timestamp of the video. Good luck fixing that.
I prefer the song Penny Lane, but Strawberry Fields has my favorite music video ever made, so it all balances out.
Just a side note, on Paperback Writer John and George’s backing vocals are the French words “Frere Jacques.”
Sounds like they're singing "Sarah Jackman" by Allen Sherman
I was just about to comment this LOL. I had a surround system stereo in the 1990s. I could almost isolate the background vocals. So many layers to Their music!! Take care!!
And the cymbals were designed to sound like a pencil scratching on paper.
I was hoping she would pick up on that.
Not just the words Frere Jacques, but the exact melody of that children's rhyme.
In response to your question about which song drew us in more, you have to travel back in time to the 1960's...this was a time when there was no social media, no internet, only radio and TV. Music wasn't at our beck and call unless we were lucky enough to have a friend who had the 45's or the album of the band you wanted to hear or we were lucky enough to buy them ourselves. So you must understand that when new music came out you had to wait until it was played on the radio to hear it and if you liked a new song enough you found a way to buy the record or find a friend who bought it to hear it, it made for a different listening experience than kids have today. So when you bought a new record you played it over and over again till you knew all the words and could sing along with it. Now as to The Beatles, those of us who were lucky enough to grow up with them first heard their music as young teenagers and as we grew older each year, The Beatles musically grew right along with us...that's why we never outgrew them. And as they developed more sophisticated musically we started looking more and more for the inner meanings to the songs. Each new song, each new album was a revelation. If you think about it The Beatles changed the publics record buying habit from buying 45's to buying albums...before The Beatles most recording artists put out albums with one or two hit singles on them and the rest of the album was just kind of crappy filler songs to fill out the album. The Beatles from the very beginning put out albums that you wanted to listen to from beginning to end...very little filler songs. And as the years passed Beatle albums became works of art...they were pushing all the boundaries of what a band could do and what the public would accept. They changed music forever and the effects are still felt to this day. Before The Beatles it was all one hit wonders by singers and groups controlled by the record companies...The Beatles broke that bond and freed all after them to pursue their own musical visions. They gave the listening world a gift which we never can repay. So to ask us to say which Beatles song grabbed us the most when we first heard it is kinda a moot point because every new Beatles song grabbed us and became our favorite Beatle song until they released a new record. Honestly when you look back at The Beatles full catalogue it's amazing that they put out so many great songs in so short a time...truly amazing. I just really want to thank you for letting me see The Beatles again through your young eyes and ears and to again experience what it was like to hear these wonderful songs for the first time again.
This is the best answer I’ve read to the question of which one of these songs impacted us the most. This is basically how I feel. They ALL impacted me greatly and each one has been a joy to hear.
Just wanted to say that I’m 61 and watching someone with musical knowledge discover the brilliance of The Beatles in 2021 is such a joy. Getting to know this music was some of my best memories. I was 14 in 74 when I really got into them and the journey has continued ever since. (McCartney III is amazing) .
Rain is one of my favorite Beatles songs and sadly it is overlooked a lot, so thanks for reacting to it!
Keep ROCKIN’ Caroline…
Sgt.Pepper is waiting.
Sgt. Peppers forever!
Can’t believe you don’t like “Rain”; fantastic recording.
“Strawberry Fields Forever” is one of my all time favorite songs. A truly revolutionary recording.
"Rain" is great.
“Rain” is all about the backwards recording.
It might too abstract for her.
Rain is great.. but as far as Beatles stuff goes, it's a bit meandering and sloppy. It's not a tight written perfectly executed pop song like some of there other stuff.
some might consider the sloppiness a benefit though. and I'm inclined to agree depending on my mood. love the backwards stuff as well.
@@ToneSherpa “Sloppy”? “Meandering”? You either don’t know what those words mean or you’ve never heard the song before. Absolute nonsense.
I've listened to these songs a million times over the years and never have I had so much fun watching someone listening to them for the first time.
I wouldn't be surprised if you found you started liking "Rain" more the more you heard it. I find myself singing it to myself from time to time, even if I hadn't heard it for a very long time.
All 4 songs are great. You can't make me choose. You are not the boss of me.
I wouldn't be surprised if she didn't. I still don't like it, and I've tried. Cool recording tricks, but the foundation of the song is still weak.
I love Rain, one of my favorites, but if someone doesn't love it immediately, I wouldn't expect that to change, really.....
All I can say is that it signaled the start of the Beatles wanting to get seriously philosophical and revolutionary. Like, not just a fun diversion anymore - he says "can you hear me? can you hear me? I can show you..."
@@jaredbond7908 I originally didn’t like Rain. Now I think it’s quite good.
The bass and drums on “Rain” are amazing, and the way Paul and Ringo are working together on that like they’re reading each other’s minds the whole time.
Not King Lear, but Edward Lear who was a big influence on John Lennon's two books he wrote in 1964 and 1965 " A Spaniard in the Works" and " In His Own Write".
Yep! Edward Lear and Lewis Carroll were big influences. Note "I am the Walrus" - very Alice!
I live on Penny Lane and not much has changed, the barbershop etc is still there... And although it's very cold here today I'm looking out at very beautiful 'blue suburban skies'! Love from Liverpool x
Strawberry Fields Forever is one of the greatest songs of all time. It took its name from the Salvation Army home near John when he was growing up. It's still there now, helping people, and you can visit.
They have a website, with photos, etc.
Nach meinem Wissen war es ein Waisenhaus...
Penny Lane is written in two keys. The verses are in Bmaj and the chorus is in Amaj which means there is a downward whole step modulation happening on the lyric 'Meanwhile Back'. This mod happens 6 times seamlessly throughout the song and nobody notices it. Then there is an upward mod on the final chorus which is easy to hear. The song sounds simple however it is so beautifully crafted and very cleverly written. This is one of the reasons why The Beatles are so dammed good. The sophistication is always there to serve the song, unlike what came after The Beatles during the prog rock era where everyone was trying to dazzle the listener with complex lines and time signatures just to appear masterful when in fact anyone can write a song just so people can say 'wow...that's so complex'. Penny Lane is a 'perfect' song and writing perfect songs is about as difficult a task as one can imagine.
Strawberry fields is one of my favourite songs of all time. The intro with Mccartney playing the melotron sets the dream like quality of the song before it takes you on fantasy journey through Lennon's mind. Simply superb 👌
"Rain" is the one that really grabbed my attention when I was a teenager, and after hearing it with these other three here it still stands above them to me
When they made Strawberry Fields Forever, Jhon and Ringo were 26 years old, Paul 24 and George a mere 23 (practically a kid). Really blows the mind what they were able to accomplish at such a young age and all the instruments and studio experimentation they dived into with George Martin's help. Add to that the fact that there was zero previous history in the 60's of pop artists doing these innovative things such as using classical instruments with backwards or slowed down tapes. It's truly marvelous.
I don’t know. We have to consider Brian Wilson.
The amount of genius that was packed in that band was just staggering. After The Beatles both of Ringo and George had very fine careers on their own. Ringo had some very good singles (my favorite was Photograph) and George Harrison had probably the best Beatles solo album when he made All Things Must Pass.
They were all brilliant artists and their music meant a lot to me growing up, and it still does. Every time I put it on it sounds just as good as it did when I 1st heard it. It never wears out
@@jerrytroyanna5090 and don't forget "Give Peace a Chance", that's prior to the solo
@@doriskray1430 I really wonder what the Beatles fans thought about the Pink Floyd song "Astronomy Domine" when it came out in 1967... because to me it remains as one of the most impressive things I ever heard
@@doriskray1430 California-centric writing about cars as a theme established by Chuck Berry. It was "The Beatles" who woke him to the reality that there is a world beyond California and wealth. Listen to the chauvinist "California Girls" -- then hear the contrasting -- it CRUSHES "The Beach Boys" harmonies -- "Back in the U.S.S.R."
Rain is Ringo's favorite drumming of all of his.
The flutes in Strawberry Fields are actually a Mellotron, a precursor to the synthesizer that used a whole rack full of strips of recorded tape that play samples of various instruments, all controlled by a keyboard.
And The Moody Blues used it a great deal.
On the mellotron, the note could only sustained based on the length of the tapes.
Almost basically an analog sampling synthesizer no less!
The early electronic instruments are fascinating. I would have loved to have played an ondes Martenot at some point.
There’s an amazing video on WHY Penny Lane’s chord progression is literally mind blowing.
Yeah Strawberry Fields is on the first listen more interesting but as a composition Penny Lane is so damn good.
Also, as many people have pointed out, these two songs stand as counterpoints to each other. Both Lennon and McCartney wrote these songs about their upbringing.
Also, it’s a perfect representation of their songwriting philosophies and really where they begin to really diverge from each other.
Literally?
@@jerryeberts3726 don’t be that guy. We’ve been using “literally” as figuratively since the days of Mark Twain. Don’t be pedantic.
@@DongusMcBongus ... pedantic at times, but you are lazy. Strive for conciseness without sacrificing clarity.
They were all along competing with each other for the "A"-side and first track on the LP. So they weren't "diverging"; they were simply more individually distinctive. One actually sees that throughout their career. McCartney sings, "I have to admit it's getting better," and Lennon responds, "It can't get no worse"". It's who they were together.
@@DongusMcBongus he might be sincerely asking if it was mind blowing how do u know?
Rain is absolutely my favorite Beatles tune. Great lyrics, great vocal performances, great guitar, great bass, great drums. GREAT SONG
Rain would not make my top 100 Beatles songs. Yet it's your favorite. What sets the Beatles apart is the depth of their catalogue. Two different people could make a top 40 and not have a single sing in common. And every one of those 80 songs would be number 1 on someone's list, somewhere. What other band could that ever be said of?
Agreed
Rain had a hard rock edge to it that was pretty new to the Beatles bag of tricks at that time (and has been mentioned backward vocals on the fade out). For some reason Rain rewards repeated listening. Paperback Writer with its cascading harmonies toward the end (and the Frere Jaques bit!) is a classic pop song. Penny Lane is a jaunty happy sound which does the Motown thing of sounding happy but having sad elements in the lyrics. Strawberry Fields Forever was - at the time it was released - a very new listening experience and fascinated everyone who heard it. When DJ Kenny Everett (at that time out on the pirate radio ship Radio London) first got a promo copy of it, he played it, on-air, six times in succession because he was so blown away by it!
Strawberry Fields is the most interesting of these, but Rain is the one I go back to the most - but I'm not sure I could say why. All four would be in my Beatles top 10 though.
I think it's the rhythm section on Rain that does this. It's my favorite bass & drum performance of their catalog.
Rain was also not overplayed on the radio like the rest, so you got to discover it for yourself.
Rain is more about the bass and drums than it is about the melody. For me, anyway. That could be why Caroline mentioned that the melody didn't grab her.
Rain is the most uderestimated song from them. I think it's one of their best songs, really.
I agree with you concerning "Rain."
I guess you can't really say The Beatles are known for any one sonic signature. They're known for changing music as we know it. From how it's written to how it's consumed and who it's consumed by to how it's produced and how it's recorded
And how it is performed live...or not.
@@jnielsen1956 true
@@thomast8539 I really wonder what the Beatles fans thought about the Pink Floyd song "Astronomy Domine" when it came out in 1967... because to me it remains as one of the most impressive things I ever heard
@@FeelingShred YAWN.
Strawberry Fields Forever is an unbelievably amazing song and gets me somewhere deep down every time, I love it!
Strawberry Fields Forever is one of favorite songs ever. Perfect.
The bassline in rain is probably my favorite McCartney bassline. Such a smooth and groovy sound
When the single came out, I was not yet 10 and I fell in love with Paperback Writer's clever/funny lyrics & driving tempo. But when I re-listened to the Beatles catalog as an adult it was Rain that blew me away. My first thought was what demon possessed Ringo and can we have some more? My second thought was, my god! Are they using the bass as the LEAD guitar on this song? Still one of my top 5 Beatles tracks.
I'm 29 so my experience is different then most of the commenters. But I love all these songs but hands down Strawberry Fields is one of if not the most important song in my musical life. When I first heard it as a young teen it really struck me and opened my eyes to what music could be.
Penny Lane is a wonderful nostalgic masterpiece that's much more accessible than Strawberry Fields yet still has that psychedelic overtone.
Paperback Writer is a fun example of middle Beatles song crafting
And I love Rain. Some of Ringo's best drumming there. Literally every time it rains hard that song gets stuck in my head.
Similarly, every time it *stops* raining I get Here Come the Sun stuck in my head.
Ah! The soundtrack of our lives.
I love it when young people enjoy The Beatles. Every time I see somebody in their twenties wearing a Beatles shirt, I always stop and talk to them
I really wonder what the Beatles fans thought about the Pink Floyd song "Astronomy Domine" when it came out in 1967... because to me it remains as one of the most impressive things I ever heard
Strawberry Fields was my favourite of the four back when they were released, but Rain still blows me away because that is Ringo's best drumming performance on a record, in my books. Every fill is different.
Strawberry Fields Forever, definitely. I heard John's haunting voice say "Living is easy with eyes closed, misunderstanding all you see. It's getting hard to be someone, but it all works out, it doesn't matter much to me": the arrangement is so delicate, so elegant; the imagery crystal clear. I wept when I heard it.
When it 1st came out, Strawberry Fields was mind-blowing. "Nothing is real." Nobody had ever put a line like that in "rock." ("You're making me feel like I've never been born?") SF was an orphanage where John chilled a lot growing up. Paul lived close to Penny Lane. They were both writing abt their childhoods in Liverpool. Both records were Double A sides. Read a ton more. And Ringo was so phenomenal I've decided lately they could not have been what they were without them
Amen to what you said about Ringo! I agree!
Paul lived close to Penny Lane but John literaly lived in Penny Lane - it's not only a street but a district in Liverpool.
The line in parentheses is from "She said she said" correct? Just curious.
@@budmcnew7763 Yes
What if Paul hung around Strawberry Fields instead of John? What if John was more emotionally attached to Penny Lane than Paul was? Two VERY different songs would have been produced and I WANT TO HEAR THEM (LOL)
Literally my favorite beatles' songs. Especially Rain. So pumped for the documentary.
It is said that there is a world before The Beatles and a world after the Beatles... One could say that music today is what it is because of The Beatles.
Well that doesn't speak well for the Beatles considering the rather dismal state of current pop music. But you could say all music stems from Bach and Beethoven as well.
If I had to pick two records for the island it would be Handel's Messiah and The White Album. Best sacred and best secular. Never get tired of either
@@jacksonmorganfroghin4815 "the rather dismal state of current pop music" LOL you're right!
I was floored, stopped in my tracks, when 1st heard Strawberry Fields. I immediately exclaimed to my Mom. “That’s it. The Beatles will go down in history.” I was 14. It has remained my favorite Beatles song.
A masterpiece. 👌
When I first heard it, I really didn't find it much attractive(half the reason is that I didn't really care about the lyrics at the time). But there was something special in that song which really made me think about it at times. Then I started to listen to it frequently and the more I listened to it the more it revealed. In this track Lennon is at the utmost level of his songwriting brilliance. It's a shame he was never satisfied with the way track turned out.
@@ashith1297 A work of art is always a failure in the view of the artist because it never achieves the ideal.
I heard "Rain" once as a very young boy, probably on the car radio as my family was driving between our home in northern Minnesota and my grandparents' farm in South Dakota. I didn't hear "Rain" again until I was a young adult, but that single snatch of music would come back to me from time to time. But my imagination had to fill in all I hadn't heard that one time, or couldn't remember accurately. Over the years the song became something called "Green" in my imagination with a different set of lyrics. When I finally heard "Rain" again, in its entirety, it purged my childhood memory and, for the life of me, I can't recall anything of the pastiche I invented.
Wonderfully explained. Pre-internet/pre-apps something vague but impactful could sear into your memory. Years would go by. You’d wonder if the mystery would ever be solved - how much was real, how much did I fill in the blanks from the fog. Then one day, maybe decades later ... an omg moment and it’s all unlocked. Been there.
It could be the favorite Beatles song we each pick DOES bring back a certain memory of where we were at the time. Or even the weather of a certain feeling, memory or season. For me: Rubber Soul/Christmas…SgtPep/summer vacation….She Loves You/pig tails & bubble gum.
I’m amazed by Strawberry Fields everytime I hear it
Your comment made me think of: "Maybe I'm amazed at the way you help me sing my song"
Rain is my fav Beatles tune since 1966 when I played it at 13 for my friends on a sunny/rainy scottish afternoon. This tune may likely grow inside your brain !!!!
I have been a huge Beatles fan for decades and whenever I am asked which of their songs is my favorite (even though there are so many, really) I always say "Penny Lane". The reasons are that it is, in my opinion, the perfect pop song: it has a superb melody, great evocative storytelling lyrics based on an actual "lane" in Liverpool (which I have been fortunate to visit !), a fantastic arrangement and production and of course an outstanding lead vocal from Paul McCartney. It's so enjoyable to watch someone young like you, and obviously gifted with a great ear, discover the Beatles music. It's easy to understand how they were truly instrumental (and vocal... pardon the pun) in shaping and innovating popular music. Keep on enjoying the Fabs !
In Penny Lane, when the chorus of the fireman starts, Paul sings "In his pocket is a portrait of the queen". This is a reference to a British coin. They loved to throw little things like that in their songs.
They all did this (Ringo may have had help bless him). It's why even now, their lyrics can be dissected.
"Pulled out the Queen, smiling, beguiling", The Jam's Down in the Tubestation at Midnight. So that's where Weller got that!
@@piaraskelly1038 Mabee, not from that source synecdoche is a poetic device where you use a part to represent the whole or the whole to describe the part. So it's possible they both used the same device without reference to each other.
Do we want to tell her what the "full of fish and finger pie" line in Penny Lane is all about? (hint: kind of the equivalent to the American line "getting to third base")
@@penfold7455 I read about that years ago, probably in the Hunter Davies biography. And was gong to keep my mouth shut...but now that you bring it up...🤣...today, watch Paul try to deny it in some interview lol
Once again, the hand of the fifth Beatle is heard. John owns a lot to George Martin for crystalizing his acid trips into music and studio wizardry.
Geoff Emerick should't be forgoten.
Everyone of them is The Beatles, including that guy on the French horn. They're all - The Beatles.
George Martin was actually the seventh Beatle. Stu Suttcliffe was the fifth and Brian Epstein was the sixth and Billy Preston was the eighth. No, Pete Best doesn't count.
@@TheSpikehere I expect that there were whispers that Martin was the hidden hand. As a kid, I found it hard to believe that the Beatles wrote all their songs. I suspected that they were ghost written. It just seems so incredible that such an accomplished act was more than an act. That it was a creative force. Before the Beatles, performers mostly were puppets on a string.
@@TheSpikehere I see that now, though I still find it hard to believe. Guess you are trying to be provocative.
“I didn’t expect that,” said everyone who heard the Beatles since forever.
"Rain" was a hard track to come by when I started listening to the Beatles, and when I eventually heard it, I loved it. It's a great pop song, but it's also has a unique, trippy vibe because of how it plays with time. And the harmonies are great.
And it seems they are vocally replicating the sitar sound here. They are droning the vowel in "rain" by repeating it to stretch the word: rai, ai, ai, ai, ain. It's like a sitar droning an A note. And it mirrors what they are doing by slowing down the track slightly; stretching it out. Just a really cool little pop song
The weather's fine
Rain is one of the best song of all time
I love the song, too! I hope with a few more listens she's able to appreciate it a little more.
Yup!
I didn't really care for Rain at first and I also thought it just sounded off. But it's one of those songs that gets better and better literally every single time you listen to it. It's become my favorite Beatles song to just listen to, and I think it's their most solid song overall.
It never got better with me anyway. It’s sheer Oasis, and I simply don't like Oasis. But to each his own, of course.
@@Zholobov1 You mean that Oasis is sheer Beatles, since they were a big influence on the former.
I agree with you. It took awhile for it to grow on me too. Ringo, for his part, feels that he did some of his best drumming on this track.
Me too!
@@Zholobov1 You got it backward, mate.
If push comes to shove, Strawberry Fields is my favorite song of all my hundreds of favorite songs. I've loved it since it was first released.
Nice to see and hear your enthusiasm, interest, analysis, curiosity, fascination, surprises, smiles, emotion and joy from this music.
As for my own reaction, Penny Lane hit me strongest when I was a 13 year old in 1967 and it's still a brilliant piece of joyfullness, but Strawberry Fields is, by far, my favourite of these 4 songs nowadays, partly through an understanding of it's musical complexity and originality.
Ooh, a secret late-night video release! I'll take it!
I also wanted to say finding your channel has reignited my interest in The Beatles' music.
By common agreement, "Rain" features the finest drumming of Ringo Starr's career. Even he said he couldn't imagine where it came from, and he could never capture the same spirit again.
Let’s not forget it is only 3 years from She Loves You and I Want to Hold Your Hand. The amount of progression stylistically is astonishing. Most bands never change styles or very little in their entire career. The Beatles completely reinvented themselves. For me Strawberry Fields Forever followed by Rain are my favorites out of the four. John’s voice and lyrics connect with me on a deep level. The dreamlike quality of both are very comforting. Cazza you put a very big smile on my face this morning. Happy Thanksgiving!
It's like going from the Wright Brothers to the Starship Enterprise.
Loved and still love all four of these songs. As great I feel that they all are, Strawberry Fields ... no, they are all very different and all fantastic. Why can't we just enjoy them instead of comparing them and saying a song or an album is the best ever. It just raises expectations for someone hearing it for the first time to a point where they may be disappointed. Enjoy it for what it is and was. Your reaction, Caroline, to Strawberry Fields Forever was priceless. I love seeing you light up when you hear something you really like.
"Strawberry fields" wrote by John about his memories of an orphanat he used to get in its yard to let his imagination go. "Penny Lane" is the about memories Paul's answer to John's song. Greetings from Mexico.
Also to your question, it was strawberry fields that drew me in. It’s a quintessential John Lennon song. No one writes like Lennon. he writes songs as if you’re hearing him think. “I think er no I mean er yes but it’s all wrong. That is I think I disagree” listening to that was delightful. Playful and honest. It’s a bitter sweet song once you sink into it. After a couple replays the weight of it begins to settle. This is an absolutely personal song. It actually brings tears to my eyes. “Living is easy with eyes closed. Misunderstanding all you see.” It’s all magic. For me the lyrics are perfect. Add on top of that an absolutely blow out performance by Mr. George Martin and you get a teary, fun and unique thrash through John Lennon’s psyche. Also the acoustic version (demo) on the anthology is tragic.
The acoustic version of SFF on the Anthology album is one of the most beautiful things i have ever heard. Honestly
Great comment, but it's *I think I know, I mean er- yes but it's all wrong*
@@jk4675 It's not "I think I know", it's probably either "I think, er, no" or "I think a 'no', a mean a 'yes' ".
@@perhapsxarb7226 yes it is, a quick Google search will tell you this. Check all the lyric books. *But it's all wrong* talks about what John *knows is all wrong* , hence the,
*I think I know, I mean* -- implying ego death, LSD psychedelia stuff. The *er no, er yes* you seem to think it is, is just nonsense and that is more akin to Walrus than Strawberry Fields
Rain is an incredible song. It's one of my favorites
Rain is a fantastic song..great drumming...
glad you didn't skip these! 🙂
From the simplistic 'Love Me Do' to 'Strawberry Fields'...how far they'd come musically in 5 short years.......absolutely astounding isn't it Caroline?
This can't be said enough for someone discovering their journey. The Beatles' evolution is head-spinningly fast in the best way possible.
It's actually only 4 years and change. Love Me Do was recorded in Sept '62, and recording of Strawberry Fields started in Nov '66.
Their career was astonishing at all: in september 1962 they released 'love me do' as a relative unknown band and one year later they played a concert in front of the british royals.
Rain and Strawberry Fields are John's voice at its most mesmerizing.
"Strawberry Fields Forever" is my favourite of those four songs.
I'm so happy you listened to Strawberry and Penny Lane before Sgt. Pepper. It's so cool you got to sort of replicate how audiences were introduced to the music The Beatles were working on during that era. Can't wait for the next one as Sgt. Peppers was the first album I can remember listening to as a kid!
When they made the song Rain they slowed down the music tracks a little and sped up the vocal track a little.
That's why it has a kind of hypnotic effect.
Yup at this stage John was into any new studio effects that George Martin could come up with to change his voice. That enthusiasm was waning after the White album, and by the time of recording' Let it be' Lennon didn't want any kind of studio tricks at all, and was openly rude and dismissive to Martin about this kind of production contribution. Martin only agreed to do the following 'Abbey Road' album if he was allowed to produce it the way he had previously collaborated with them.
Strawberry Fields Forever has always been a favourite of mine although I do love all of their music! It was a magical time growing up with them and witnessing the black & white world we were born into suddenly turn into full on colour!!! It's great to watch your reactions to them! You are a wonderful person and that comes through in your reactions! Thank you! Peace and Love forever!
Rain is my fav Beatles song ever. I love everything about it and it was the song that got me to take notice of the Beatles. It's the perfect middle ground between who the Beatles were and who they would become.
All four of these tracks are fantastic. All four of them will be listened to and admired for generations to come. This cannot be said for most pop music of today.
Strawberry Field is a musical revolution on it’s own. One of the best songs of all time. Still amazes me. And not just because of the groundbreaking production and arrangement. It is still amazing played with one ukulele.
Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields Forever is the holy grial of any single release
I didn't remember hearing Rain as a kid so Strawberry Fields Forever really hit me. All of the Beatles were still alive and making their own music by the time I started to develop my personal musical taste. I have, and always will, gravitate toward John. There's a dark honesty in his presentation of his lyrics that is usually backed by a more somber tone. Because of that, Rain has been my second favorite Beatles song behind Tomorrow Never Knows. I sing Strawberry Fields in karaoke and I play lightly through the first two times through the chorus, but I put a dark emphasis on "Nothing is real", later in the song. I feel the song needs that emphasis. I love your videos in general, but can't get enough of your Beatles reactions. Honest and in the moment, the way it should be. Thanks!!
"Strawberry Fields Forever" blew our minds when it came out. The LP was alive with thought-provoking, along with fun lyrics and sounds. Thanks for sharing. You Rock!!
Minor corrections: Strawberry Fields didn't take off when the single was first released, barely cracking the BIllboard Top 10 in the U.S. The flip side (Penny Lane) made #1 because it got more radio airplay. Also, it was a single only, not on any album at the time, although later released on the U.S. Magical Mystery Tour album.
@Dave Pollison
I meant to say, "The Lp that it was on..." Thanks for pointing it out. Also, I and the people I hung out with didn't generally listen to Top Ten Radio Stations. Plus, my older brother bought anything, Beatles, as soon as it was released. Their were quite a few groups we listened to that weren't getting a lot or any of Top Ten's attention. We mostly listened to local collage stations that could play "heavier" music and didn't have time restraints on the length of songs. There was usually one night a week where they would play full LPs. Thanks again for helping me with my reply 😃
As a lifelong fan of The Beatles, (some 50+ years now) it gives me goosebumps to see someone listen to them for the first time. It gives me the chance to hear songs I've heard 1000 times or more for the first time again. Thank you so much. I love all four of these tracks but "Strawberry Fields" is my favorite song of these four. It's the one that makes you think the most. But I love them all.
Strawberry Fields blew my mind when I heard it on the radio as a young teenager. "What was THAT?!" As you say, quite different from regular pop tunes, both then and now. Producer George Martin had a substantial effect on the Beatles use of instrumental variety, in terms of translating what they were after into specific musical arrangements.
You're emotional and analytical at the same time and I love it.
Strawberry Fields is just amazing.
That is all.
In answering the last question, I think when I was young, I loved Penny Lane most of the four. I also loved Paperback Writer for it's more rock and roll sound. As I got older, I came to appreciate Strawberry Fields more and it may have been one Lennon's best songs of the later years of the group. I always thought that Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane contrasted against each other very well...Strawberry Fields always felt more moody and melacholy, while Penny Lane was more upbeat. For some friends, I just recently rated my favorite five Beatles songs from their later years and Strawberry Fields was my number 4 (behind While My Guitar Gently Weeps, Something, and Come Together). But everyone's tastes are different and there are so many great ones to choose between. Thank you again for these videos!
Speaking of Something/Come Together, this double sided 45 was like Strawberry/Penny. The different styles of Harrison, Lennon, McCartney.
Strawberry Fields Forever is timeless. What an incredible piece of music and art.
As a lifelong Beatles fan, it's so cool to watch someone listen and react to Strawberry Fields for the first time
One of the genius of Penny lane is this:
In the chorus, while the vocals go up, the music goes down. This creates a not 100% joy but a wistful nostalgia, which is the point of the song.
This is not an original thought, but an observation made by Howard Goodall in his Beatles episode of his music documentary series.
Howard Godall on the Beatles is also worth a reaction!
That was a really good documentary, but better watched after listening to all of the albums.
@@youngbloodk Agree 100%, wait till the end, and then find out what an orchestral composer think of the Beatles contributions, and who they find themselves sharing the accolades with.
@@youngbloodk Agreed.
Wikipedia has an excellent section on what makes Penny Lane so special from a musical point of view.
The Beatles’ use of classical instruments in their music inspired me to listen to the great composers like Bach, Brahms, Beethoven, Mozart and others. They definitely were instrumental in helping me expand my musical tastes beyond rock n roll. And that’s yet another reason why I love this band. They were never conventional, but were always branching out and experimenting.
Compare that unwillingness to be tied to one particular sound or style to today's bands and even individual singers. I asked my dear wife about Adele, who she loves. Do All her songs sort of sound the same?? "Well, yes, sort of !!"
@@scottski51 I couldn’t agree with you more. My kids often tell me that they wished they grew up in the time of the Beatles. They find today’s music so boring.
Most people do not know that Paul McCartney has written and recorded five classical music albums within the last 30 years: Liverpool Oratorio (1991), Standing Stone (1997), Working Classical (1999), Ecce Cor Meum (2006), Ocean's Kingdom (2011).
@@daddyguerrero Think "safe" is another word that could be used for today's pop music...Beatles were real catchy pop & ultra edgy experimental all at the same time, simply because they were extremely talented and got bored easily with doing the thing musically over and over again....who could or would try to pull that off again....Will never happen!....and I never say "never"....but in this case, "that will never happen again"....Beatles forever!
@@Bipbop66 This could have happened to the Beatles, as well. Had they been successful in their Decca audition, they would never have connected with George Martin. Instead, they would have been under the control of pop producers and A&R men. The pressure would have been to create songs that had certain proven tempos and other elements. They would not have gotten the education that George Martin, a classical music producer who heard their potential, provided. He took them to the symphony, where they heard all those instruments. That wouldn't have happened at Decca.
Strawberry fields is One of those songs that when it came out, nobody had heard anything like it.
And nobody has heard anything like it since! 😌
I believe 'the Walrus' was recorded around the same time w/ a similar vibe
You're authentic, intelligent, and very entertaining. I appreciate your true joy at the first time hearing this. I was born in June 1964. My brother Steve was 8 and just bought his first Beatles album. I had no choice but to hear it. That was the greatest no choice for me.
Your reaction to "Strawberry Fields" was beautiful. Can you believe it was their first single NOT to get to number one?! :P Welcome to 1967 Beatles, welcome to the middle period! Goodbye moptops! And if you like The Beatles playing with any instrument they like.....you will be loving the rest of your Beatles journey!/ Oh my gosh, your ideas of what "Paperback Writer" is about cracked me up so much! / I love the bass triplets on the last chorus of "Rain". The way the bass was recorded for this single was revolutionary; after this, you started to hear a lot more bass on everyone's records./ ALL of your comments were spot-on in this video.
Paul McCartney’s bass playing becomes transcendent for the rest of The Beatles’ career. Rain is the first song in which his bass really comes to the fore. It was starting to become more important on Rubber Soul but Revolver is where he really takes off and it just keeps getting better.
I've been a Beatles fan for my whole life (pretty much) as my parents were teenagers during the sixties and so my childhood involved hearing a lot of their music (although, I came to find out, it was predominantly focused on their early years). It wasn't until I was like 15/16 when I went from a passive fan to an active one when I first heard their experimental/psychedelic phase (Revolver, Sgt Pepper, Magical Mystery Tour) and was instantly obsessed. Needless to say, I am a massive Beatles nerd, however, I'm not educated in terms of the technical musical side but more the lore, history, and lyrics (I'm a writer so lyrics and feel/sound draw me in). Strawberry Fields Forever is my favourite song of all time (other than 'I Am The Walrus' from Magical Mystery Tour so I'm looking forward to your reaction to that album). It is such a mysterious, dreamy, unique sounding song, how it changes from mellow at the beginning to sinister with the brass and cellos, the stumbling lyrics about Lennon's own confused childhood thoughts, the elaborate layered instruments, the studio effects, etc. I personally love 'Rain' as Paul's bassline is insane, it's arguably Ringo's best drumming performance, the Indian-influenced sound of the chorus, the Indian-summer feel of the song (juxtaposed comedically with Lennon's ruminations on British summers i.e. sunshine and heat constantly interrupted with rain, and how this is compared to the strangeness of changing moods - particularly when on certain substances). It is refreshing to see a musical analysis of these songs and albums from a new listener that is educated in the technical side of music, although I would be interested if you looked into the lyrics more (but that's just me). Love your videos, keep up the good work, and sorry for this essay lmao
You need to hear 'Across The Universe' for the lyrics.
''Pools Of Sorrow-Waves Of Joy' need I say more?
@@MICKEYISLOWD Its coming bro...You may see some reference to that on "Get Back" tonight.
@@Bipbop66 You can stream the first part of “Get Back” right now, you know.
Your essay really resonates with me--I agree with your musings, from the first sentence to the last (I 'm just a couple years younger than your parents).
Wow, your story is just about the same as mine. I was born in 1968, and I listened to my parent's record collection from a very young age. I sometimes regret that I heard Sgt. Pepper for the first time around the age of roughly 7 or 8, before I was able to comprehend what a revolution that album was. Not having any other baseline, I simply thought all music was this good. Revolver? The same. Abbey Road? I mean, come on! Magical Mystery Tour (US version)? What a trip for a young, eight-year old mind. I often tell my dad that the reason I have such strong musical instincts is because his own taste in music was so great... so much Beatles in his record collection. I became a professional musician (mostly as a composer of classical music and theater music) because of The Beatles...and my dad's record collection.
I'm enjoying your reaction to Strawberry Fields. When it was released in 1967, it blew minds all over the map. Many didn't like it and radio stations banned it. I'm glad to see that it resonates with someone of your age. People are finally catching up to it. Recommend the compelling recordings on Beatles Anthology Two that showcase the evolution of "Strawberry Field's" development.
Strawberry Fields Forever is the song that impacted me the most, not only put of these four songs, but out of all their songs. It just makes me feel such a specific way, it's a mix of insecurity, a dreamy feeling and just a general sense of taking you somewhere else far away from wherever you might be and whatever you might be experiencing, like a lot of music, it's an escape, but it let's you escape into this magical and mysterious world, and there are so many layers to the instrumentation as well, and that adds a feeling of depth, where you truly feel like you're there in strawberry fields.
Lennon's lyrics were very poetic. They were very imaginative
I feel the same way about the song, but you've expressed it so well. And it's so personal, one really feels like one is riding along in John's train of thought.