truck was left undestroyed ,because their main priority is storyline as the moniroy character is also using Suraksha kavach which protected the truck!!!
@@bikashkahar9390 Recommended schools to learn Visual Effects (VFX) online 1.CG Spectrum Online College of Digital 2.Arts and Animation. They offer online courses taught by top film and game artist These two places might help and try to choose your base as after effects because most companies hire after effect users. 9 Best Tools to Create High-Quality VFX 1.Autodesk. 2.Adobe After Effects. 3.FXhome HitFilm Pro. 4.Blackmagic Design Fusion Studio. 5.Blender. 6.Wondershare Filmora. 7.Foundry Nuke Studio. 8.Maxon Cinema 4D. U might also want to learn these for future benefits and internship. My best wishes for your VFX career
@@rgbedits7496 i'm a art student, mujhe -3 years ka EXP. Graphic Design and Motion Graphics mai.. bt after 12th mene koi Bachelor DEGREE nai ki hai, so please suggest me ki apne FIELD ke according mai konsi DEGREE karu jo Graduation ke level pe ho.. kuch company wale (Any B. Degree) ki demand karte hain, or wo mere pas hai ni.. Please bataiye
@@rajsolanki9271 haa vo to hai Lekin there is always a place for improvement. Kyunki kucch bhi perfect nhi hota hai. Iss movie kaa VFX apna kaam karde bas. Baaki main chiz to story pe depend karti hai.
seriously, I appreciate this kind of content creators, who justifies to what they are criticizing, who have a background and knowledge about what they are talking, unlike some other random guy who just watch a movie and comment on years of work fiction. keep it up!
As a VFX artist, I can definitely say that "POST ME DEKH LENGE" hits way too hard....And in the End, Food chain me last me jo hota he vahi marta he. Client director aur production house ki leta he, we log VFX companies pe saara blame daal dete he. As a VFX company they can't response against them bcoz agar esa kiya next time koi kaam nahi dega....Aur ye VFX companies pe aaya saara frustration aur blame VFX artist pe daal diya jata he (hum jese logo pe) , aur hum apni job bachane k liye saara gaali blame chup chaap sunte rehte he...This is reality of INDIAN VFX...Aur esa hi chalta rahega i guess bcoz sab ko apni jeb bharni he......Thanks brother I hope teri aawaaz waha tak pahuchegi.....
Started the video thinking "here goes another jealous artist" But genuinely astonished by your knowledge and understanding. Keep up the good work man. Much appreciated.
This would be more better if it was brahmastra 3 or 4. they have made it for the first time. I am also a vfx artist, so everything is not meant for picking up mistakes. be happy that Bollywood is also capable now to fight with marvel maybe after 2 or 3 years. So judging is not necessary now and enjoy the movie bro.
@@rouniktarafder5284 I am really proud of this movie!! Except for very few details jo sirf special knowldedge se hi pta chalein, the VFX are so great. The whole trailer is really awesome with the bgm, the flow, etc. This is going to be my first IMAX experience and I can't wait for it.
I don't know how the story will be and it doesn't matter at all actually coz the cg and VFX itself will take 70 percent hearts of INDIAN crowds. Now INDIA is getting ready for something big and our new superheros and the copyright one. MADE IN INDIA Tagged..
@@nerds3k true. They are trying something new. If it clicks, it'll change things for Indian cinema itself. As far as I've seen, hate comments are there but ppl are looking forward to watching this movie in theatres.
Yaa , Ryt bro.. When i'm watching the trailer of "Brahmastra".. I'm also thinking ki ye to Kunwar bhai bhi kar skte the Keep going bro.. U will be in Hollywood editing team in upcoming years ❣️❣️
Brahmastra team actually took some suggestions previously and improved from the teaser to the trailer. They are also doing it for the first time so its good to have healthy critisizm that could make it better. Afterall Ayan has waited 10 years for this to become a reality. I'm sure he'd be happy to get these suggestions that could actually improve as his end goal is to please an audience so why not take feedback and make it work as much as he can. For RRR, VFX artists broke down the detailed analysis later on and appreciated every tiny effort. I'm sure Ayan wouldn't want to fail them too and set a good bar. He wants to make it the best one yet and feedback is always good for that.
Why are you extending so much leniency? They are not doing it for charity. They should do the best else people will stay home and watch incredible vfx on ott for western shows.
@@user-yk5lv8iw8x they deserve a bit of leniency even if they do their best there would still be a difference from a far more experienced and established studios and they are the 1 St one to try to turn the wheel here in this one dimensional word aur western studios kitne bhi aachi film bana le kitni bhi diversity badha le Ghar ki baat kuch alag hi hoti hai.
I am a VFX artist myself, and i truely believe that according to bollywood standards the VFX of this film was amazing. Its the first time that we have seen such dramatic and beautiful effects in a bolly film even though their were some loopholes. Understanding the pipeline and having knowledge doesnt means that you know what it take to make such an art My friend the problems that you have shown can also be seen in alot of Marvel films as well. Dont always criticize, sometimes a praise is better
Naah its the result that matters, movie is made for kids. The vfx you say aren't too complicated either. RRR had good treat as well, and that was a proper story.
The statement "according to bollywood standards" is extremely problematic. We are supposed to hold ourselves to the best standards in the world, and not that which is mediocre.
Criticism is important factor for betterment or improvisation in any field. One should always welcome it. Anyways you also seems to be criticising... 😜
Hum advance booking karke makers ko pehle se khush nhi karenge hum toh unme se hai jo 9 ko ticket kharidenge aur maker ko surprise karenge ki 😘advance booking toh 20 cr ki hui lekin opening day collection 60 cr ka kaise aa gya...Love You Ranbir and Alia...Alia ki mehnat maine Gangubai me dekhi hai aur ranbir ki Shamshera me...Toh Brahmastra in dono mehnati actor ka combination hai...All Time Block Buster...movie ❤️ #BrahmastraSupport
I really appreciate your eye for detail. As correctly described by you, all the tiniest details cumulatively make a great shot which feels completely realistic. Even a person without any knowledge of VFX would instinctively feel something’s not right. He would not know what and where but to the brain it immediately just doesn’t feel right.
bhai aapko VFX ya 3D modeling Ka pipeline pata bhi hain, VFX industry mein jishne work nahi kiya woh VFX ki knowledge de ra hain amazing...You can Change Bollywood..Keep it up
Thank you. What I've been saying for a while now and getting hate from others for it -- the VFX lack professionalism. Im not a VFX expert myself, but like you said I can subconsciously notice something is off and I have a strong visual sense -- I realized myself a long time VFX look best in low lighting, overcast skies and from wide long shots and quick shots. Despite this very obvious trade secret, our directors use bright lightning, daylight (krissh 3, Bahubali) close ups on CGI and slow motion, making it bloody obvious it is CGI --- it just baffles me if I can notice this, how can not the director, VFX supervisor, the cinematographer? Why do they do slow motion on VFX and let the audience know it is CG -- look at the animal effects in RRR and Bahubali, remember Bahubali running over the extremely fake cows in slow motion, did rajamouli not see himself how fake it is looking. In Brahmastra all the best shots are the ones in dark lighting and all the worst shots are the ones saturated in too much bright and warm colours. The ones I hate the most and am genuinely surprised how not only did they get the OK, but Ayan chose them for his trailer --- all the yellowish shots of the brahmastra and the light coming down to earth; the yellowish shot with Alia in her boots lying on the floor with some kind of whirlwind in the background, it lacks depth of field, looks as bad as the tunak tunak video. The final shot of them running as the ground gives way also does not look good, reminds of bad CGI from 2012 movie, but even worse choice of colour . I appreciate brahmastra for upping our indian standards, but it is nowhere close to Hollywood professionalism. The same VFX artists are working on it from Hollywood, but whats lacking is the visual and aesthetic sense of Ayan himself. Compare Bhansali - he has the visual sense to produce perfect shots. He has even proved he can work with VFX in Bajirao mastaani and padmavaat. Notice he uses dark ambient lighting, practical sets and VFX seamlessly, that you dont even see the VFX.
Rrr had decent cgi animals. Like just look at the scene where the tiger is chasing bhim. Those shots are kinda reveal the cgi but the tiger's body movement while running is believable and somewhat accurate
'Harry Potter mn sare scenes overcast mn shoot kiye gaye the' Meanwhile most of the Quidditch games scenes are directly sunlit. Direct sunlight se vfx aur continuity bht challenge ho jata hn zarur. Bt yeh nahi ki cheat krke sare scenes overcast mn shoot krlo. Creative choices story ko serve karna chahiye baki technically strong artists saab kuch pulloff krlete hn (given the adequate time) PS- Points regarding the truck was absolutely OP
The irony with bollywood is that they only consider someone known to director We have so many talents like Kunwar who know what they are talking Loved the video...... great points bro rather than criticizing you showed them how it is done and exposed the post production team 😱😱
before you started the reaction, i thought lets watch the trailer first, peronsally, the trailer was so lit and awesome and vfx in it was truly impressive as compared to any india movie vfx i've seen before. i thought the trailer looks really awesome, what did he notice that wasn't good. And after watching your video , i do realize these little things that you mentioned. I gues only a vfx artist could notice these things because a simple person could not, and the example you showed at end perfectly explained what you meant. So hats off to you!!!
No doubt vfx is eye pleasing compared to other bolly movies 👍 But if we want that our bollywood improves, we need to appreciate it but at the same time we should give them suggestions to improve. ~ Thanks for this breakdown ❤️
unko suggestions doge to bolenge ki hamari movie mat drkho fir. note - no khan harmed in this comment🤣😂 #only Marvel . not interested in kachrawood. where thry don't care about there fans, then we don't care about them.
@@mayurmelge6247 bollywood has given tons of good movies. It has a huge market and even when times aren't good, other industries are picking bollywood actors not just for acting skills but also for market. Other industries know this very well. You guys only know to spread hate. Your specialty is, spreading hate before the movie releases and pass judgment on it. Marvel is also bakwaas these days. Moreover, comparing Brahmastra concept with Marvel shows your common sense.
@@mayurmelge6247 lol marvel k andhbhkt marvel khd ghtiya VFX de rha abi k tym aur ghtiya filme aur shows v ghtiya ..aur ye hamri movie mat deko wala comment kis context me ta Jake pta kr blindly hate mat faila nepotism pe bola ta ye kareena ne naki kisi khan actr ne
I am writing this comment after watching first few minutes of the vedio,and i clearly understood that this man is super knowledgeable and educating us by giving practical examples not degrading or blaming the output,and i am sure that this vedio will get minimum 4m views.
Amazing breakdown bro... The knowledge u have, must be implemented in Indian cinema.. Hope more ppl would become knowledgeable like you and actually implement it.. kudos
Looks like you were wrong. It wrong to judge a book by its cover. That scene is not badly lit up but it is actually a day scene. Film vfx supervisor did a fab job.
Talking about sun, shadows & realistic feel, there were numerous mistakes in sajay Leela Bhansali's so called "perfectly directed" movies & rajamoulis bahubali 1 & 2
This is quality content 🔥 Even in the photo manipulation, you need pictures with good lighting so it will relate to the idea or scene you creating but real artists are not getting such jobs only connections getting jobs like this, thats why bollywood will never reach close to hollywood.
Woahhh man just loved the way you did the simplification and the techniques that can be done for making the shot look much more better.... Kudos to you 🙌
I think brahamastra should hire you for vfx coz I think you are the best vfx artist i have ever seen btw love your content keep it up! ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Yr accha hai ki main kisi bhi film industry se juda kaam nahi karta hai aur isiliye main full masti ke sath movie enjoy karta hai nahi to bs movie ke errors hi nikalte rehta....
Maybe it's just me but I like the anime style VFX instead of Hollywood's realistic VFX. The more realistic VFX looking U make more boring it looks best example for me is live-action Lion King. With the huge amount of work went in the VFX its the most boring looking film I have seen in my life. One of the main reason why RRR works so well, it blends the unrealism with realism.
My reply is this. We may think realistic and refined looks boring, but it gets more respect and is classier. Compare sardar uddam to RRR, both anti colonial movies, but one is a cartoon for dumb masses the other a serious movie that can be proudly shown to anybody in the world and it will be universally appreciated for its actual filmmaking. Padmavaat and Bajirao mastaani are also called boring, but they are a class apart from Bahubali in all aspects of filmmaking, even the VFX and war scenes.
Light behind subject was brilliantly done by RRR team . I watched their videos . No one can match their level in india. For that hitting fire wood stick, they used some led bulbs on it for light reflection on body. Then there was a bomb blast so they used high power LEDs behind the subjects.
I don't know why are you not appreciate his effort behind work . After watching this video and thumbnail your just praising urself you. As artist you should respect and appreciate others work .
Bro don't worry you're a great artist and a good teacher I learn after effects from your tutorial videos I love to see your videos like how you add funny jokes and make video interesting as well so i bet you will get much better opportunity foresure.❤️❤️
Great bro. Bahuto ko dekha aur suna hai criticize krte hua but bahut kam log hote hai jo bolte hai " Ye lo, aisa karo. Look, this is better" hats off 😎
When you said post me dekh lenge I knew I am in the right place. The problem is 10 saal leke I hone power rangers banaya hai. And aj bhi Indian audience isi baat se khush ho jaati hai ki arre koshish to kar rahe hai.
Well its not supposed to look realistic. This is not a period film, its a fantasy movie. The whole purpose of a fantasy movie is to make fantastical choices when it comes to the vfx. Look at Harry Potter, LOTR, do the elements in those movies look realistic? No. Its nothing but a creative choice.
@@gampa_10_31 Yeah I agree with advancements. But do you know the budget of LOTR? It was 300 Million dollars for the entire trilogy and that too in 2001. Brahmastra's budget is nothing compared to that.
Guys let's appreciate this movie .. might be not that perfect but this is the first time Bollywood tried VFX this big... we have to support, it'll get improved by time✌️🤓...& I'm very excited to watch this😍
Its all about starting something new if u start then after it u can improve it but if u won't start what u are gonna improve so overall its all about giving a start and I am damn sure we can make it much better we all are just starting to see our golden days again.
True. In the beginning it will be difficult. If this clicks, the company will get another Oscar and for Indian cinema, the course will change and Ayan Mukherjee will become highly sought after
Agreed that it might not be upto the mark from the VFX angle but I think 300cr is a big budget and they have to not just deliver VFX but also the stories, cast and other things. Your opinion is respected but I am just elated by the idea that they have definitely tried creating something extravagant and also tried to respect our ancient history.
@@ashimdas6113 Yes like you judged the whole cinematography by a trailer. You can't comment on it unless you've seen the movie. The trailer was in snippets. You guys just learn some big words and become critics in the comment section.
@@winsomeyou1837 this is the thing with these foolish people. They spread hate, give reviews of movies, shows even before they come out or without even watching.
Bro u are great but as u find faults in brahmastra trailer in yoirs video also a blue ligh is clearly seen on your hand while the fire effect was on the other side😅😅
usa sends india to do the editing keying rotoscoping as india has low labour cost, so the budget of 1700 cr vs 300 cr is huge. and for 300 cr budget the movie has done amazing vfx.
I showed the trailer to my friend who works at Walt Disney and he was not impressed at all. He said that even the people applying for their jobs have bettern videos in their portfolio than this.
Returning here 2 years after I first saw the video, I realised just now how much I have learnt. I am so grateful for your channel, everytNice tutorialng
Brahmastra vfx work is done by DNEG who worked for most Hollywood movies including for marvel and dc. But yeah it is important to make this correct at the time of shooting.🙌
Use my Redeem code 66paknzp and get your ActionVFX free one-month Starter Subscription
"Offer ends Aug. 31st"
😃😃😃
Dekh rahe ho consistency meri :)
Thank you Bhai 😀😍
@@Itx_kunwar haa bro 🔥🔥
Bhaiya kya Aap delhi Shipt ho gye.....?
truck was left undestroyed ,because their main priority is storyline as the moniroy character is also using Suraksha kavach which protected the truck!!!
I had been in an vfx company for 11 years and I could guarantee that he had told real facts rather than criticizing. great job bro !
Sir VFX me kon sa course Lena sahi hoga please guide me 🙏🙏
@@bikashkahar9390 bsc vfx and animation
MAI BSc VFX karna chata hu ye sahi h sir or aap ke hisab se kitane me course free lag sakta h sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@bikashkahar9390 Recommended schools to learn Visual Effects (VFX) online
1.CG Spectrum Online College of Digital
2.Arts and Animation. They offer online courses taught by top film and game artist
These two places might help and try to choose your base as after effects because most companies hire after effect users.
9 Best Tools to Create High-Quality VFX
1.Autodesk.
2.Adobe After Effects.
3.FXhome HitFilm Pro.
4.Blackmagic Design Fusion Studio.
5.Blender.
6.Wondershare Filmora.
7.Foundry Nuke Studio.
8.Maxon Cinema 4D.
U might also want to learn these for future benefits and internship.
My best wishes for your VFX career
@@rgbedits7496 i'm a art student, mujhe -3 years ka EXP. Graphic Design and Motion Graphics mai.. bt after 12th mene koi Bachelor DEGREE nai ki hai,
so please suggest me ki apne FIELD ke according mai konsi DEGREE karu jo Graduation ke level pe ho..
kuch company wale (Any B. Degree) ki demand karte hain, or wo mere pas hai ni.. Please bataiye
For them to improve the vfx in brahmastra part 2, this part 1 needs to earn big.
Yes, they have to pull audience first
And I bet part 1 k VFX bhi achhe hi honge definitely 👍🙌😍and ye pakka Blockbuster movie hai
@@rajsolanki9271 haa vo to hai
Lekin there is always a place for improvement. Kyunki kucch bhi perfect nhi hota hai. Iss movie kaa VFX apna kaam karde bas. Baaki main chiz to story pe depend karti hai.
Wo Toh Nahi Hone Waalaa
@Top 10 NOT INTERESTED.
seriously, I appreciate this kind of content creators, who justifies to what they are criticizing, who have a background and knowledge about what they are talking, unlike some other random guy who just watch a movie and comment on years of work fiction. keep it up!
As a VFX artist, I can definitely say that "POST ME DEKH LENGE" hits way too hard....And in the End, Food chain me last me jo hota he vahi marta he. Client director aur production house ki leta he, we log VFX companies pe saara blame daal dete he. As a VFX company they can't response against them bcoz agar esa kiya next time koi kaam nahi dega....Aur ye VFX companies pe aaya saara frustration aur blame VFX artist pe daal diya jata he (hum jese logo pe) , aur hum apni job bachane k liye saara gaali blame chup chaap sunte rehte he...This is reality of INDIAN VFX...Aur esa hi chalta rahega i guess bcoz sab ko apni jeb bharni he......Thanks brother I hope teri aawaaz waha tak pahuchegi.....
The amount of knowledge in this video is packed very well! More of these please
After watching Adipurish trailer , this is gold !
Omg this guy needs to be appreciated,he deserves the world the way he noticed every minor details, salute!!!!!
brahmastra dekhne se behtar iss bande ko hi paise de du ticket ki. Good explanation for hungry brains like us...Keep up the good work champ.
Abey galat bola hai isne. Woh Nandi shot Day ka hi hai. Aur yeh Prime Focus ko bol raha jisne khud Marvel and Oscar winning team hai
Bro had no idea that after a few years he is going to make his own superhero film. Extremely excited to see Aarya in his Rage💖💖
Started the video thinking "here goes another jealous artist"
But genuinely astonished by your knowledge and understanding. Keep up the good work man. Much appreciated.
At least someone is there who is giving a proper explanation rather than just shitting on the hardwork of artists involved
This would be more better if it was brahmastra 3 or 4. they have made it for the first time. I am also a vfx artist, so everything is not meant for picking up mistakes. be happy that Bollywood is also capable now to fight with marvel maybe after 2 or 3 years. So judging is not necessary now and enjoy the movie bro.
@@rouniktarafder5284 I am really proud of this movie!! Except for very few details jo sirf special knowldedge se hi pta chalein, the VFX are so great. The whole trailer is really awesome with the bgm, the flow, etc. This is going to be my first IMAX experience and I can't wait for it.
I don't know how the story will be and it doesn't matter at all actually coz the cg and VFX itself will take 70 percent hearts of INDIAN crowds. Now INDIA is getting ready for something big and our new superheros and the copyright one. MADE IN INDIA Tagged..
@@rouniktarafder5284 exactly 🔥🔥
@@nerds3k true. They are trying something new. If it clicks, it'll change things for Indian cinema itself. As far as I've seen, hate comments are there but ppl are looking forward to watching this movie in theatres.
Never seen such detailed & simlified breakdown. So much of knowledge. Loved it. ❤
I am a layman on VFX but this guy is extremely talented. Hats off.!
I've sawn it today ( brahmastra ) it's really nice movie reached our expectations
Bro the company who has done vfx has won 6 oscar for their vfx
Wahi na bhai. Kuch log sikh kr apne aaap ko baap samjhte h
Wonderful work Kunwar... Your rise always inspires me... It is fantastic... Very wonderful Kunwar ❤
You don't even watch the full video and commenting this 😂
@@mahadevmahata5794 hehehe... Fuck off man... I already knew that Kunwar's video will be fantastic
Yaa , Ryt bro.. When i'm watching the trailer of "Brahmastra".. I'm also thinking ki ye to Kunwar bhai bhi kar skte the
Keep going bro.. U will be in Hollywood editing team in upcoming years ❣️❣️
Kunwar bhai kar sakte the, but aaj tak aisa kuch kiya nahi.
@@Sunny-sc5vq 😂
Waw Super Duper Vfx Sir🥰🥰🥰
Hey, If you see the movie, they show the clouds coming and the weather changes to overcast. So they took care of that.
Finally got to see an honest review on these VFX ✨🙌
Brahmastra team actually took some suggestions previously and improved from the teaser to the trailer. They are also doing it for the first time so its good to have healthy critisizm that could make it better. Afterall Ayan has waited 10 years for this to become a reality. I'm sure he'd be happy to get these suggestions that could actually improve as his end goal is to please an audience so why not take feedback and make it work as much as he can. For RRR, VFX artists broke down the detailed analysis later on and appreciated every tiny effort. I'm sure Ayan wouldn't want to fail them too and set a good bar. He wants to make it the best one yet and feedback is always good for that.
do you think its so easy to make changes in few days.. joke is on you.. this guy is just big mouth and no actual production vfx experience..
Man it shows! Just look at the new prerelease promo, it looks noticeably better.
Why are you extending so much leniency? They are not doing it for charity. They should do the best else people will stay home and watch incredible vfx on ott for western shows.
@@user-yk5lv8iw8x they deserve a bit of leniency even if they do their best there would still be a difference from a far more experienced and established studios and they are the 1 St one to try to turn the wheel here in this one dimensional word aur western studios kitne bhi aachi film bana le kitni bhi diversity badha le Ghar ki baat kuch alag hi hoti hai.
@@mohnishverma9454 Sure, Bhai. Please spent your time and money on what you choose!
Love the Way you Work on VFX
Can't wait for your video on Adipurush Visual Effects
Knowledge like this has the potential to make masterpieces.
your channel is going to create so many competent visual artists in the future, amazing work. amazing breakdown, perfectly done.
Very nicely put and explained in detail. An honest and detailed VFX reviewer like you definitely needs to appreciate. Kudos buddy.
I am a VFX artist myself, and i truely believe that according to bollywood standards the VFX of this film was amazing. Its the first time that we have seen such dramatic and beautiful effects in a bolly film even though their were some loopholes.
Understanding the pipeline and having knowledge doesnt means that you know what it take to make such an art
My friend the problems that you have shown can also be seen in alot of Marvel films as well.
Dont always criticize, sometimes a praise is better
Naah its the result that matters, movie is made for kids. The vfx you say aren't too complicated either. RRR had good treat as well, and that was a proper story.
The statement "according to bollywood standards" is extremely problematic.
We are supposed to hold ourselves to the best standards in the world, and not that which is mediocre.
Criticism is important factor for betterment or improvisation in any field. One should always welcome it. Anyways you also seems to be criticising... 😜
Hum advance booking karke makers ko pehle se khush nhi karenge hum toh unme se hai jo 9 ko ticket kharidenge aur maker ko surprise karenge ki 😘advance booking toh 20 cr ki hui lekin opening day collection 60 cr ka kaise aa gya...Love You Ranbir and Alia...Alia ki mehnat maine Gangubai me dekhi hai aur ranbir ki Shamshera me...Toh Brahmastra in dono mehnati actor ka combination hai...All Time Block Buster...movie ❤️ #BrahmastraSupport
I really appreciate your eye for detail. As correctly described by you, all the tiniest details cumulatively make a great shot which feels completely realistic. Even a person without any knowledge of VFX would instinctively feel something’s not right. He would not know what and where but to the brain it immediately just doesn’t feel right.
Loved it! ❤️
Bro please continue the REACT series, jitni knowledge aur value aap idhar provide krte ho wo kisko nhi chahiye. 🙌
Can't wait to see your work in movies too!!
i felt so sad for those who missed the last part
Only legends can understand all these, who ever worked on animation and vfx. Good explaination.
Lavde jaby koay ka review dekh.
He said hollywood level hai visuals.
bhai aapko VFX ya 3D modeling Ka pipeline pata bhi hain, VFX industry mein jishne work nahi kiya woh VFX ki knowledge de ra hain amazing...You can Change Bollywood..Keep it up
Well done bro we need artist like you who will take vfx in india to greater heights
😂😂😂😂
He had me at 10.06
This man is proving all with the practical.....bro ur just awesome
The knowledge, the information.....he is power packed
Thank you. What I've been saying for a while now and getting hate from others for it -- the VFX lack professionalism. Im not a VFX expert myself, but like you said I can subconsciously notice something is off and I have a strong visual sense -- I realized myself a long time VFX look best in low lighting, overcast skies and from wide long shots and quick shots. Despite this very obvious trade secret, our directors use bright lightning, daylight (krissh 3, Bahubali) close ups on CGI and slow motion, making it bloody obvious it is CGI --- it just baffles me if I can notice this, how can not the director, VFX supervisor, the cinematographer? Why do they do slow motion on VFX and let the audience know it is CG -- look at the animal effects in RRR and Bahubali, remember Bahubali running over the extremely fake cows in slow motion, did rajamouli not see himself how fake it is looking.
In Brahmastra all the best shots are the ones in dark lighting and all the worst shots are the ones saturated in too much bright and warm colours. The ones I hate the most and am genuinely surprised how not only did they get the OK, but Ayan chose them for his trailer --- all the yellowish shots of the brahmastra and the light coming down to earth; the yellowish shot with Alia in her boots lying on the floor with some kind of whirlwind in the background, it lacks depth of field, looks as bad as the tunak tunak video. The final shot of them running as the ground gives way also does not look good, reminds of bad CGI from 2012 movie, but even worse choice of colour .
I appreciate brahmastra for upping our indian standards, but it is nowhere close to Hollywood professionalism. The same VFX artists are working on it from Hollywood, but whats lacking is the visual and aesthetic sense of Ayan himself.
Compare Bhansali - he has the visual sense to produce perfect shots. He has even proved he can work with VFX in Bajirao mastaani and padmavaat. Notice he uses dark ambient lighting, practical sets and VFX seamlessly, that you dont even see the VFX.
Appreciate your research 👍❤️
Rrr had decent cgi animals. Like just look at the scene where the tiger is chasing bhim. Those shots are kinda reveal the cgi but the tiger's body movement while running is believable and somewhat accurate
Ya right bro
@@arnavjain9799 idk how so many movies mess it up but animating animals aren't that hard
You can easily get a reference footage of that
How do I give you 100 likes at once?
'Harry Potter mn sare scenes overcast mn shoot kiye gaye the'
Meanwhile most of the Quidditch games scenes are directly sunlit.
Direct sunlight se vfx aur continuity bht challenge ho jata hn zarur. Bt yeh nahi ki cheat krke sare scenes overcast mn shoot krlo.
Creative choices story ko serve karna chahiye baki technically strong artists saab kuch pulloff krlete hn (given the adequate time)
PS- Points regarding the truck was absolutely OP
The irony with bollywood is that they only consider someone known to director
We have so many talents like Kunwar who know what they are talking
Loved the video......
great points bro rather than criticizing you showed them how it is done and exposed the post production team 😱😱
before you started the reaction, i thought lets watch the trailer first, peronsally, the trailer was so lit and awesome and vfx in it was truly impressive as compared to any india movie vfx i've seen before.
i thought the trailer looks really awesome, what did he notice that wasn't good. And after watching your video , i do realize these little things that you mentioned. I gues only a vfx artist could notice these things because a simple person could not, and the example you showed at end perfectly explained what you meant. So hats off to you!!!
No doubt vfx is eye pleasing compared to other bolly movies 👍
But if we want that our bollywood improves, we need to appreciate it but at the same time we should give them suggestions to improve.
~ Thanks for this breakdown ❤️
As if they will listen to your suggestions.
unko suggestions doge to bolenge ki hamari movie mat drkho fir.
note - no khan harmed in this comment🤣😂
#only Marvel . not interested in kachrawood. where thry don't care about there fans, then we don't care about them.
@@mayurmelge6247 marvel ke vfx bhi ab bekaar horhe h vfx artist pe bhit workload derhe h lekin fir bhi woj audience ki nhi sunrhe
@@mayurmelge6247 bollywood has given tons of good movies. It has a huge market and even when times aren't good, other industries are picking bollywood actors not just for acting skills but also for market. Other industries know this very well. You guys only know to spread hate. Your specialty is, spreading hate before the movie releases and pass judgment on it.
Marvel is also bakwaas these days. Moreover, comparing Brahmastra concept with Marvel shows your common sense.
@@mayurmelge6247 lol marvel k andhbhkt marvel khd ghtiya VFX de rha abi k tym aur ghtiya filme aur shows v ghtiya ..aur ye hamri movie mat deko wala comment kis context me ta Jake pta kr blindly hate mat faila nepotism pe bola ta ye kareena ne naki kisi khan actr ne
I am writing this comment after watching first few minutes of the vedio,and i clearly understood that this man is super knowledgeable and educating us by giving practical examples not degrading or blaming the output,and i am sure that this vedio will get minimum 4m views.
Ty so much bro for this information
Amazing breakdown bro... The knowledge u have, must be implemented in Indian cinema.. Hope more ppl would become knowledgeable like you and actually implement it.. kudos
I smell someone's debut in Bollywood 😍😍🔥🔥🔥
Now you are hired for BRAHMASTRA - 2 definitely 🔥
😂😂😂
Looks like you were wrong. It wrong to judge a book by its cover. That scene is not badly lit up but it is actually a day scene. Film vfx supervisor did a fab job.
It's amazing that we are getting this knowledge without paying a single penny
Talking about sun, shadows & realistic feel, there were numerous mistakes in sajay Leela Bhansali's so called "perfectly directed" movies & rajamoulis bahubali 1 & 2
very well explained, totally agreed with you, our industry need to understand that planning is must and should before going for the shoot.
This is quality content 🔥
Even in the photo manipulation, you need pictures with good lighting so it will relate to the idea or scene you creating but real artists are not getting such jobs only connections getting jobs like this, thats why bollywood will never reach close to hollywood.
Red chilliesvfx n nyvfxwala is gud
@@lukhykhuthan9173 bhai brahamstra ka VFX dneg ne kiya hai jisne iss sal Oscar jita hai
R u from future ???
@@xanom0 Its a merg of prime focus which is indian company with dneg, that doesnt mean dneg team worked on this
@@xanom0 I got to know that the vfx team has won Oscars. Not 1 or 2 but 7
Woahhh man just loved the way you did the simplification and the techniques that can be done for making the shot look much more better.... Kudos to you 🙌
I think brahamastra should hire you for vfx
coz I think you are the best vfx artist i have
ever seen btw love your content keep it up!
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Yr accha hai ki main kisi bhi film industry se juda kaam nahi karta hai aur isiliye main full masti ke sath movie enjoy karta hai nahi to bs movie ke errors hi nikalte rehta....
Detailed and neat explanation 💜
Maybe it's just me but I like the anime style VFX instead of Hollywood's realistic VFX. The more realistic VFX looking U make more boring it looks best example for me is live-action Lion King. With the huge amount of work went in the VFX its the most boring looking film I have seen in my life. One of the main reason why RRR works so well, it blends the unrealism with realism.
Well said 👍
Same thinking
agree with you completely
My reply is this. We may think realistic and refined looks boring, but it gets more respect and is classier.
Compare sardar uddam to RRR, both anti colonial movies, but one is a cartoon for dumb masses the other a serious movie that can be proudly shown to anybody in the world and it will be universally appreciated for its actual filmmaking.
Padmavaat and Bajirao mastaani are also called boring, but they are a class apart from Bahubali in all aspects of filmmaking, even the VFX and war scenes.
Lion king wasn’t boring at all
Light behind subject was brilliantly done by RRR team . I watched their videos . No one can match their level in india. For that hitting fire wood stick, they used some led bulbs on it for light reflection on body. Then there was a bomb blast so they used high power LEDs behind the subjects.
I don't know why are you not appreciate his effort behind work . After watching this video and thumbnail your just praising urself you. As artist you should respect and appreciate others work .
Love You Yaar.
Love From Pakistan.
Genius.❤️
Hats off you bro... Such an interesting knowledge and information you deliver us . Keep it up 🤝🏻
Love u brother ♥️
Bro don't worry you're a great artist and a good teacher I learn after effects from your tutorial videos I love to see your videos like how you add funny jokes and make video interesting as well so i bet you will get much better opportunity foresure.❤️❤️
Your vfx which you have shown in video is fanatastic, and mindblowing sir i think bollywood should to hire you for vfx desining
Love you sir 😘😘😘
Great bro. Bahuto ko dekha aur suna hai criticize krte hua but bahut kam log hote hai jo bolte hai " Ye lo, aisa karo. Look, this is better" hats off 😎
I am in editing from 1 year doing after effects & premiere pro I must say you are very knowledgeable.
This man wants to work in Bollywood that's why he is reviewing correct so that Bollywood can take this man 😂
🙌
5:41 maybe the truck carries something important and that's why our hero needed to stop it in such a way so that those important things can be saved?
kunwar bro you inspired me a lot and i am in the process to become an animator'
When you said post me dekh lenge I knew I am in the right place. The problem is 10 saal leke I hone power rangers banaya hai. And aj bhi Indian audience isi baat se khush ho jaati hai ki arre koshish to kar rahe hai.
Sir ji aapne kya hi knowledge di with practical example mzaaa hi aagya 😘❤️😘❤️
Last scene 🔥🔥 as expected😎😎
Well its not supposed to look realistic. This is not a period film, its a fantasy movie. The whole purpose of a fantasy movie is to make fantastical choices when it comes to the vfx. Look at Harry Potter, LOTR, do the elements in those movies look realistic? No. Its nothing but a creative choice.
Harry Potter, and lotr vfx is also saturated,and one more thing is, at their time, there are no vfx advancements like now
The keyword is "realistic".. and you've no idea what you're talking about.
Bro harry potter does look realistic, its just we already knew whats real and what isn't, but in the movie everything looked real.
ofcourse it looks realistic...its just fiction..thats what he is trying to say.
@@gampa_10_31 Yeah I agree with advancements. But do you know the budget of LOTR? It was 300 Million dollars for the entire trilogy and that too in 2001. Brahmastra's budget is nothing compared to that.
9:37 you've downloaded this vfx from internet but Brahmastra creators had to create it themselves
Bhai mano ya na mano ye movie toh tatti hi hai😂😂tatti vfx 300 caror pe
@@Im_nanku11 bhai tatti to nahi hai tu nat dekhiiyo tujhe tatti lag ri hai to
bhai unhone thodi bahut mstake chodi hia yha pe ye to manna padega
ब्रह्मास्त्र The vision review . Click and watch 👇till the end. th-cam.com/users/shortswdwUGEhs6IY?feature=share
@@Im_nanku11 kon si indian movie ka vfx tujhe tatti nhi lga ?
BRO APPKA BACKGROUND MUSIC BAHUT KHATARNAK THA, AND U HAVE REALLY GOOD DEPTH IN VFX.
Marvel dekhte dekhte tum bhi last me suspense chod jate ho aur woh kafi achha lagta hai 🔥❤
Jokes on you in movie the scene was in day and by using the powers the environment goes cloudy nit night. You judged things to early.
Bhai uske kami h qki app jese log udhr nai h
The amount of efforts he puts in his video, just phenomenal. Keep it up buddy!
Nice facts....awesome job....very simple facts about shooting in overcast and night conditions not in broad daylight
The VFX team of brahmastra are 10 time Oscar winner so please don't judge them
Kitna vi ro le tujhe nhi lene wala hai vai vfxteam me😂.
Guys let's appreciate this movie .. might be not that perfect but this is the first time Bollywood tried VFX this big... we have to support, it'll get improved by time✌️🤓...& I'm very excited to watch this😍
Its all about starting something new if u start then after it u can improve it but if u won't start what u are gonna improve so overall its all about giving a start and I am damn sure we can make it much better we all are just starting to see our golden days again.
True. In the beginning it will be difficult. If this clicks, the company will get another Oscar and for Indian cinema, the course will change and Ayan Mukherjee will become highly sought after
bhai thodi dikkatt to hai par 3d me dekhne me bada mazza aya
You are Awesome, learned lots from you. Your subscriber from Nepal.
Agreed that it might not be upto the mark from the VFX angle but I think 300cr is a big budget and they have to not just deliver VFX but also the stories, cast and other things. Your opinion is respected but I am just elated by the idea that they have definitely tried creating something extravagant and also tried to respect our ancient history.
While ignoring basic cinematography
@@ashimdas6113 Yes like you judged the whole cinematography by a trailer. You can't comment on it unless you've seen the movie. The trailer was in snippets. You guys just learn some big words and become critics in the comment section.
@@winsomeyou1837 this is the thing with these foolish people. They spread hate, give reviews of movies, shows even before they come out or without even watching.
@@ashimdas6113 bhai ye word "Cinematography" kaha se seekha chapri 🤣
@@fruityloops11 keya hain gawar to he nehi teri tara para likha hu thora bohit english to ata hain
Bro u are great but as u find faults in brahmastra trailer in yoirs video also a blue ligh is clearly seen on your hand while the fire effect was on the other side😅😅
I watched the movie
It's awesome
All thr vfx are amazing
Don't try to be oversmart ki mughse krwalete
The man who had done.. Was epic
Constructive criticism is what we need.. good job
usa sends india to do the editing keying rotoscoping as india has low labour cost, so the budget of 1700 cr vs 300 cr is huge. and for 300 cr budget the movie has done amazing vfx.
I appreciate u sir .. u should keep on making VFX of ur own and let Bollywood know .. there are peoples who can make our country proud
Keep it up bro... India need more talent like you on this field. Infact you should b the one to make this film.
Salary nhi dete vfx walo ko.. chavanni athanni dete h bas. Poochh kisi se bhi.. they are highly underpaid.
I showed the trailer to my friend who works at Walt Disney and he was not impressed at all. He said that even the people applying for their jobs have bettern videos in their portfolio than this.
CW's Flash's series level VFX
Small things make you perfect..but perfection is not a small thing ...!
Returning here 2 years after I first saw the video, I realised just now how much I have learnt. I am so grateful for your channel, everytNice tutorialng
Very well explained and informative Breakdown
Brahmastra vfx work is done by DNEG who worked for most Hollywood movies including for marvel and dc.
But yeah it is important to make this correct at the time of shooting.🙌
Nope its made by redefine
@@aracturus6220 its done by dneg and redefine. both are the main vendors for this. just pause in the end and see youll fine out.
Taking out mistake is easy in others work but doing a VFX editing for first time is very difficult bro...
Phone pe dekh ke judge kr raha hai yah lavla, 5 time Oscar winning team ne kiya hai, chutiya to hai
Exactly
That's why we should not use amature VFX editor to ruien the movie ✨
@@shibanand8991 they are called sarkari vfx artists
Kuch v bol bhai brahmastra ki vfx to tatti hai 😂
This is called talent