Agree to disagree on most of those ig. Bedard had one of the best true rookie seasons of the past 25 years and has all the hype to be the best player in his generation. Slafkovsky ain’t getting an A for a good half year but I think he can hit that tier in a year if he builds on his performance this season.
what do you mean he's only played 60 games? that's what we're judging him off of...? why are you judging him off anything other then what he's done so far in the time and games he's played...?
As a Habs fan I can see Slafkovsky becoming a very high A tier/low S tier player once the team gets good, he's got that fire in him to win it and definitely looking like a better choice then Shane Wright.
I get the pushback for sure. He has been a consistently good goalie with a few great seasons but like I said, I don’t think there is really any significant stretch of time where I would confidently say that he is top-3 or even top-5.
He’s been pretty mid aside from the last year or so. I’d maybe bump him up to B tbh but I don’t think C is egregious for what he’s shown over the vast majority of his career.
@@ridethepine89 pretty mid??? He might be one of the best two way forwards in hockey. It’s not often valued but his defensive prowess is soemthing to behold.
I feel stammer in S is crazy everyone else up there is miles ahead
Prime Stamkos was a superstar and he won two rockets. Even now in his mid-30’s he’s an above P/GP guy and is money in the bank for 40 goals.
You just can't put Bedard in the S tier right now... wait a couple years. Right now I would say he's like B or A.
Rick getting the D tier right off the rip is a tough scene, but it's an accurate spot
Yeah it sucks!! He had a legitimately good year or two and I think had he not had the injury issues he would have been higher.
@@ridethepine89 also getting KO'd by brent johnson probably didn't help
Stammer A
Nuge A
Auston A
Bedard A(S is wild he only play 60 games call down lil bro)
Slafgoatsky must be A with the second part of season he got
Agree to disagree on most of those ig. Bedard had one of the best true rookie seasons of the past 25 years and has all the hype to be the best player in his generation. Slafkovsky ain’t getting an A for a good half year but I think he can hit that tier in a year if he builds on his performance this season.
what do you mean he's only played 60 games? that's what we're judging him off of...? why are you judging him off anything other then what he's done so far in the time and games he's played...?
Slag in low B’s?
As a Habs fan I can see Slafkovsky becoming a very high A tier/low S tier player once the team gets good, he's got that fire in him to win it and definitely looking like a better choice then Shane Wright.
Fleury has won at every level... give him some love GD
As a Panthers fan I feel like youre too generous to Ekblad
Im a huge Ekky guy too
It might be because I’m a Leafs fan and have never seen a good RHD lol
Nuge at C is crazy. He’s arguably the best two way forward in the game. Good defence + good offence.
Barkov is a much better two way forward.
@@tylerslenk8243Well ya he is a captain for a reason. But still, C?
Bro fleury A is a mess
Put him S
I get the pushback for sure. He has been a consistently good goalie with a few great seasons but like I said, I don’t think there is really any significant stretch of time where I would confidently say that he is top-3 or even top-5.
Stammer is an A
Nuge at C😭😭😭😭
Cooked ranking
He’s been pretty mid aside from the last year or so. I’d maybe bump him up to B tbh but I don’t think C is egregious for what he’s shown over the vast majority of his career.
@@ridethepine89 pretty mid??? He might be one of the best two way forwards in hockey. It’s not often valued but his defensive prowess is soemthing to behold.
One of these S tiers is not like the others, one of these S tiers just doesn't belong.