Everything Wrong With Songs of War Episode 1 In 10 Minutes Or Less
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- Today we take a look at Black Plasma's series.
DISCORD --} / discord
Next: TBA
Original Video: • Songs of War: Episode ...
Remember, no animation is without sin! Which animation's sins should we expose next?!
Writers:
Christina Coca: / grrawesomeness
Eo Wills: / ifthestarsgo
Editor:
Sam Kersey: / dampbagels
Outro Music:
Invisible by Declan DP / declandp
Licensing Agreement: www.declandp.in...
Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/2PiwqoQ
Music promoted by Audio Library • Invisible - Declan DP ...
Twitter: / animationsins
0:37 Animation sins: Unless you have the strength of a thousand men
Ardoni: Has the strength of 10,000 men
5:35
Animation Sin= No afticulation of their mouths.
Me= You told it before but I have to tell it this time "THIS IS MINECRAFT".
This counter argument falls flat then you realise Minecraft characters don't even move their mouths when they "talk". You can't defend them by saying "it's more accurate to Minecraft" when it isn't at all.
@@Nugcon True
@@tylerplayz8134 not true
@@VortexZero5 ye nvm ur right I changed my opinion
animation: has anything.
Animation sins: ThIs Is nOt fOrgIVaBle
Lol so true
Not really i can see alot of problems in SoW stuff and it's sometimes inaccurate
SolarDrawzThings Then Try Making Your Own Animation
THIS ANIMATION Is not the most perfect you know, Its not like it's the best Animation on earth
@@GamingWithMichael10nobody said it was
Guy: considering everything that’s happening in this scene, this wither is doing a whole lot of nothing.
Wither 1 second later: (fires a bolt hitting and killing someone)
Yeah and no one focuses on the stoopid wither any way
Sins he thinks he can just judge the story then I wanna see him do it better
Man so fucking stupid. THIS ANIMATION SINS CHANNEL SHOULD ME CALLED 'i DONT KNOW HOW TO ANIMATE
he also looks around for said someone.
@@poisoningdemons216 true
Someone:makes an animation-
Animation sins:that is a sin that cannot be forgiven
They give no mercy.
The song of war animation isn't the best animation on earth you know, Some animations have mistakes. That's why the Sin Channel was made, to give advice to fix the mistakes
@@alwaysmeepin9609 they never do, don’t they? I miss them :(
Songs of war: Is done perfectly
Animation Sins: uh um oh the walk cycles is bad! More sins!
no animations are perfect
@Lord Shags yes
who cares
i mean its an animation style so you cant really blame them.
yeah it wasnt mean to be completly minecraft
A S: That's all it for now! BYE!
Me: That is a sin for judging a famous episode on worldwide.
You’re a sin for not reading the description,
iITS HIS MOTHER FREAKING JOB
being "famous" doesn't give them a pass for criticism, despite how nitpicky and superficial it might be.
@@bayglman your a sin for not reading the script and watching the behind the scenes
Some of the sins here just compares this to real life logic while everyone knows this is Minecraft
0:24 "considering everything that's happening in this scene, that Wither is doing a whole lot of nothing."
0:29 *WITHER LITERALLY SHOOTS A BOLT*
well most people are in close quaters and wither skulls do splash damage and u don`t want to hurt your allies don`t u
Hello there
I hate him
The real question, can animation sins make a “perfect” animation? I’m not being offensive, I just wanna know because how does he know this much?
they cant and their animators
The stone floor in the Walls of Time are *meant* to be reflective as they're icy
* Says Information Dumping is a sign of a bad story *
Me: Well where’d you want them to fill them in on it?
its because he is just watching an episode ._. he could just watch the full movie
@@ethankim3555 The full series wasn't out yet. I imagine there were only 2-3 episodes released during the time this video was published
@@RandomPerson-qv9jr Yeah, after my initial hype I noticed that. Although the Songs would be very confusing without an explanation, and they might seem like generic powers without that bit of info
That's exactly what the lord of the rinds movies do lol
Him:the withers doing nothing
Wither 2 seconds later: shoots something
Animation: *has nothing wrong with it*
AnimationSins: 100 sins Take it or leave it
Everyone else : brUh
Lol
Btw who else knows Gravity Falls?
Helena Dražanová *literally everyone*
@@sunfish1997 I don't
death dash18 WTF
you are realy right
Animation: weapon being slightly in ground but so small it’s unseeable
Animation sins: this sucks
That's true
The stone is not supposed to reflect light.
Me: Theres ice on it
5:48
And its icy
He would know this if he paid any attention to the behind the scenes
Oh the stone shouldn't reflect light but the fact that there's a bagillion things in this video which go beyond basic Minecraft are okay?
Like really get a grip
Scooby Snacks isee(icy)
But the point is not to look exactly like Minecraft.
Just have the similarities of Minecraft in a dystopia.
Every songs of war fan who sees this vid:
WATCH BEHIND THE SCENES >:(
7:37 That was intentional. Each enchantment in this series has a separate active and dormant.
1: He might have been a scout, given that those Withers are pretty weak compared to everyone else in the scene.
2: Who said they do not? After all, he was an Ardoni of Old. Besides, Wither Skeletons have weaker bones, as they are under a modified Wither Effect.
3: Codswallop, as Hagrid called it.
4: Strange creatues, alright?! He literally just said it!
5: Strange creatues are strange creatues!
6: How many times must I write it?
7: I have said it twice, and referred to it once, yet I have to write it again: Strange creatues are strange creatues!!!
8-16: You know the drill.
17: You said you would add ten for all of them! Liar!
18: What is the problem?!
19-23: Get to the POINT!
24: For once, they decided to use extra high resolution.
25: Shrouded in the dark side, everything is.
26:And? Are Ardoni suddenly not allowed to rest?
27: Where? If it is the head of the bottom Nestoris (possibly Ingressus Voltaris), we see the top and back of his head.
28: They might have had several fights at the same time, the third clashing coming from one off-camera.
29: That is not even a point.
30-34: You have already counted that many times before, each time saying you would add ten or something for all of them!
35: That is more or less how people might act if insulted.
36: Because that is how disappointed people act!
37-46: Well, the ground might be naturally slippery.
47: And? It is a PRIME SONG!!!
48: Voltaris are SUPPOSED to blend into fire-like backgrounds.
49: How many times are you going to complain about floating? YOU SAID YOU WOULD ADD TEN FOR ALL OF IT!!!
50: Who said they do not? Do you know how gravity works in their home world?
51: We have been through that as well. Try finding something original?
52: Maybe the Song is a bit like Balefire from The Wheel of Time by Robert Jordan.
53: Are you a crazy hater, or are you a bot? "Bad story", seriously.
54: I am not triggered by that, wich says something. However, I am triggered by all this garbage of yours. Someone post this video on r/mildlyinfuriating.
55: Snow particles are snow particles.
56-58: As I said, snow particles are snow particles.
59: Might just be good to hide it, some people are that. Just look at Severus Snape.
60: Dark places without light sources will remain dark.
61: People recently woken up from sleep often have bad articulations.
62: Thin layer of ice on top of it.
63: That is irrelevant.
64: Giving us a better area view.
64 Again: Accio! Besides, YOU miscounted the amount of "errors", and increased from 63 to 64 twice in a row. I think that is when you use the expression hypocrite.
65: Clouds, fog, light, snow, or a combination of those.
66: That is just wrong.
67: He have fought his first proper battle in over a century, he is probably tired. Tired people might shake a bit.
68: It is snow.
69: He probably used a Mobilium Song at low strength.
70: Because nobody is wielding it, have you never watched Star Wars?
71: Will you never grow tired of this?
72: Slow motion.
73: Probably because he is wounded.
A dude checking his inventory 2:23
Animation sins has found your sin unforgivable
XDXDXDXD
LOL XD
umm no hes not the movie isn't based on actual minecraft.it wouldn't make sense for an inventory check.the story doesn't have minecraft rules it has real life rules with a minecraft texture.
@@godswillotonye6519 r/woooosh
Songs of war: Makes best Minecraft series
This guy: finds the smallest things for content
Black plasma studio: Can you do better huh
Animation sin: That's a sin
Hey, man, what’s up. How do you feel about this video a year later? Im wondering how people’s opinions have changed on a controversial things after a long stretch of time.
Me: A fan of songs of war
Also me: Finds an sin for songs of war
Me: watches cuz I’m bored
My brain: *Triggered because he didn’t pay attention to behind the scenes
Same
Yes. His Explanation makes no sense!
Yes, someone said it
@@whoknows1447 wut it just ended
no animation has no sins
One little thing, Thalleous' markings on the left arm didn't disappear, he was holding his stomach, so that the arm was turned around and from the back we saw the inside of the arm.
8:06 Um, that's not the back of his arm. That's just the side that faces the body. We all know how Minecraft rigs work here... right?
yes
Yeah, i guess they just didnt bother to texture the inside of his arm.
How many times did u watch this to find those “sins”
Hey, man, what’s up. How do you feel about this video a year later? Im wondering how people’s opinions have changed on a controversial things after a long stretch of time.
@@sovietcosmonaut2595 At first I thought this mattered but now I've realized now nitpicky AS' videos generally are
4:37 I'd have to oppose that. For something as deep as SoW, it's kind of necessary for a prologue like this to get the viewer used to the world, Songs and past events which are referred back to. David's talked about a few things like this in his behind the scenes, also explaining how the prologue was being read by Thalleous.
8:04 That's the inside of the arm, which don't have markings.
Some good finds there though, some sins just picking on their style which have been covered in previous vids, but great job.
5:53 They were going for a frozen appearance on the floor rather than pure stone.
i agree
Also considering the length of the series, this is a relatively short time
yes, thank you. this whole video has me personally triggered.
Finally somebody from black plasma can step in because of this bad video
That was one of the best animated movies I have ever seen... You need to watch the full 2 hour movie.
You're incorrect, dude. You added 30 sins only because they "were floating" 3 or 4 times
Yeah songs of war is a great animation
You are right
@@odomrandy totally agreed
@@odomrandy not completely
Its too smooth
Do u guys watch my videos
6:26 It’s not random humor. It’s a reference to Derp, a character in lot of their animations that always carrys a fish on him.
0:32 someone needs to educate This dude on how sharp things work
Also the guy is a Ardoni so he can probably spear that skeleton anyway
サイレントボイス that’s not sharp things, that’s the anatomy of an undead skeleton
Lmaooo
So how much force does it take for a spear to penetrate a skull from a far distance? I get you might say it a wither skull so it weaker but still what do you know how sharp things?
Why is this man just criticizing everything that these people worked so hard to create? He could probably add an extra 20 sins because someones breathing animation looked off.
@jason reynolds
You can just sin fucking important stuff and not
“aAhHhhH HEWoBRINE!!!!!!!!”
Thats true
Its literally the point of the video. This is literally a POSITIVE THING for the animators lmao
I mean it can be a good way of finding out any mistakes you might have not noticed
@jason reynolds $ sudo heck jason reynolds
Unofficial response from a big fan of SoW:
1: He was searching for a target, he started attacking literally 1 second later.
2: The lore states that the Ardoni are very strong.
3: Basic geography mate, those exist naturally aswell, especially when it's a "newly" formed mountain, lets say an earthquage happened 10 years ago and changed it's shape a bit. Earthquakes can be local. And the mountaing WERE terraformed, for various reasons like building the walls of time.
4: It's minecraft logic, they were trying to balance between realism and the laws of the game.
5: You got me there
6-16: Look point 4
17: How do you think they would be able to make this possible in minecraft
18: Those are ceremonial staffs more than weapons
19-23: You got a point
25: I agree
26: He probably went the wrong way
27: Uhhh... wdym
28: k
29: That's the part of the animation process, look up the "Ardoni skin tutorial" where the animator explains it.
30-34: come on, you already added enough of those for the same thing, now it's just being rude
35-36: ?
37-46: Why, there wasn't THAT much of them
47: You clearly are trying to give the best animation many strikes just so you can make drama, don't you. I don't see a problem here. I'm already tired of typing this.
Ok triggered fanboy who can't take opinions
SkilledNoob456
I agree. Blink on this animation at you’ll miss +3 hours of editing
@@rorymanley6696 ever heard of criticism?
7:36 Enchanted weapons have an active and idle state in this series, the glow dims abruptly because the sword's enchantment has just switched from active to idle.
1:50 The weapons are dope, you should’ve taken away 10 sins for those.
You dare opposed Thalleous mortal?!
Him:That does not fit in Minecraft
Couple minutes later: his facial expression didn’t change enough.
Anyone: releases an animation. Animation sins: *n o*
13 LIVES You mean Animation Sins not Cinema Sins
CamTheCoolKidYT Sentence: horrible name
@Shauna Smiddy tf do you mean "rude"?!
no animation is perfect
Thalleous: *N O.*
Soo many things you said are just exaggeration like the missing markings MAYBE cuz he was cut
animation sins just talks about the most smallest things in all of his videos
Only true songs of war fans understand that all these sins dont count
Yes
Yes since i watched the whole season 2 by megste
Ya this sh!t is crazy who notices a glitched out snow flack or the curve of the ground what you want them to be triangles that docent fit rite. And the off dissenter logo.
Yes
@@Directed2212 i dont understand, can you please explain, is the season 2 by megste made by the script, so it follows how it should be? And is Megste one of the helpers in creating the first season? So is he one of the original creators, and is the season 2 in the right script order?
At 5:54 it is supposed to be reflective. There ice on it
animation: * has poor walk cycles *
Animation sins: *That is a sin that cannot be forgiven*
True
True
True
True
poor walk cycles are bad tho
5:33 see the snow coming in the background and the lantern they put the lantern there which made some snow melt which made the stone reflected
Ik, but they look disgusting
@@alittlebitd3ad they do not
@@liuemma7175 they do...
@@alittlebitd3ad :\
@@liuemma7175 :)
The stone reflects because there is supposed to be a thin layer of ice on it.
Also the sword’s glow dims because it is not used (part of the lore).
A very good, well made animation that probably took 4 years: *Has one easily missable mistake*
Animation Sins: 80 sins, take it.
Season 1 finale is coming out today and your just ruining the series
dude the series is not perfect you should know that.its not bad its really good but its not perfect.
yas
@@godswillotonye6519 make your own
@@judepelobello3671 It's not perfect.
I agree this dude is judging someone that made hard work on this and I disliked him for that
07:34 That's because the sword can be active or inactive. That is the sword deactivating. (it is explained in the behind the scenes of episode 2 i believe)
Id like to see you make a ten episode series of animations completely from scratch! Its not that easy!
they make animation
Pfft a channel with 251k subs saying the “sins” on a channel with almost 10 millions subscribers and views
bruh
the channel has four million not 10
also the people who own the channel have almost a million subs
also just because they have more subs doesnt mean they are better
@@Something29292so the animation is bad?
EnchantedMob: releases Dream your dream and Break the cycle
AndyBTTF: releases Doki Doki forever
Animation Sins: *N O*
How old are you
Deandra Bryan WHOA THERE BUSTER
@@deandra1735 why does that matter?
@@deandra1735 I don't think that matters
@@dduck07 just because something doesnt matter doesnt mean that a question cant be answered like why someone skin is brown or why leaves are green it doesnt have to matter the point in finding something out could mean the person is just curious
3:38 I think it is specifically made that way so you see that he is literally in his element in the burning village after slaughtering so many people and 7:35 that Thalleous's sword stops glowing is due to the fact that in this animation entchanted items can be activated and deactivated, so of course it stops glowing when he hasn't equipped it
There’s always those things that people like you point out that people like me would never have noticed Great job 👍
Break the cycle when?
Yes
Yes
Yes
Doki doki forever when
Video title: Song of war
Me: Is it going to be a military march?
Animation: No
EliteAidan Productions, Songs of War is a Minecraft animation series made by Black Plasma Studios. At the time of writing this comment, the latest episode is Songs of War: Episode 7.
@@someoneontheinternet1317 Okay
Let's see you make a animation and make IT AS GOOD as SoW + post a 10min+ video every week
When hawken blocks the energy ball with the sheild but it all breaks exept the part that was actualy hit by the ball
The energy spreads on to the edges of the shield since the middle has more resistant & regularly deflects or spreads away most kinetic energy
He goes into so much detail that he even could make animation sins of a real life thing
(dont take this serious)
Now you have to do “Everything right in Songs of War SEASON 1 Full Movie”
*SNORT*
You know that when it's enchanted and it's blowing in means that it is activated but when it isn't on it doesn't glow so much
I dont know if I'm going mad but has your voice changed
It's a different narrator.
I was about to say
Like bro
@@Ranman242 what happened to the other one?
@@ImSpookd I don't know. My guess is that they hired the new narrator to allow Zach to spend more time animating his own stuff at ZAMination. But that's just my guess.
'information dumping is usually a sign of a bad story'
the second book for lord of the rings:
Animation: someone stands still
Sin Counter: OH THAT IS A SIN RIGHT THERE
3:40 The Tesseract
7:34 why is this a sin?
It was shown earlier that Thalious could activate the aura and now that he isn't holding it anymore it deactivates after a few seconds.
Also, narrator is different
Is zach okay?
@Aamn Maybe
@@ABRXZER how do u know?
4:44 "This is the opposite of good story writing" I guess he didn't like fellowship of the ring then
"10 minutes or less"
Me: 10 AND 12 SECONDS U LIAR!!??!!!
Same here
Bro doesn't know how arm rotation looks like
Thalleous' patterns on the arm didn't disappear, his arm was in a position
Cinema sins: Ruining every animation
Me:NOTHING IS PERFECT OK
NinjaGaming 152 same, I don’t even know why I watch this channel.All they do is criticize people’s hard work.
@@piggyzilla7744 . Just because they do hardwork doesn't mean they shouldn't be criticised
@@e3210-y7o the sins are stupid though
CinemaSins rants movies
I want to see him make an animation and see how bad it is also he want them to make a new run for every one of them that would be so hard 4:15
Why not make it YOURSELF then if like critisizing it so much?! Wtf is SOOO wrong with it?!!??!?!
Ikr. If he didnt criticize so much of the actual animation so... well, literally, I could take it as a joke. It's less of fun sins and more like just blatantly and rudely criticizing the work.
I dont even care if the animators dont care, I'm feeling insulted in their place.
@@dangk3405 David (director of SoW) didn't care about it since people told him that it's mainly just animation sins instead of how some part was bad and saying how this certain part of the story could be improved, yes my English is bad lmao
@@dempi7164 it's ok I'm not English too :)
*Casually drinking from my glass cup*
*Notices animation sins post a video on Songs Of War*
.... *Crushes glass cup*
Number 1: Minecraft's generation is random and in 1.18 the mountains look like that asshole.
Number 2: How about you make a Minecraft Animation yourself and have the creators of this movie rate it.
Number 3: This is a fantasy movie, meaning some stuff here are out of the ordinary.
Number 4: Its an animation, so everything isn't perfect.
Only by watching this did I realize that the Sendaris in the tournament was a younger Thalleous.
And then at the end your making his voice sound weird, and it’s almost like your making a joke out of the whole film / movie
This is the guy who complain everything when watching a movie.
Animation Sins: This animation has no sins.
Also Animation Sins: But I need views.
Animation sins,ur channel keeps me happy keep it up man :)
Tiras Conde wrong time to comment this
@@Devilsaur naw
Just to let you know: The foot sliding is in almost all of Sqaured Media’s animations.
9/10 the video should be called rap of war
agreed
why, watch the original video first
"This is the opposite of good storytelling."
SOW fans: So you have chosen.... *death*
No offense new guy but where’s Zach I miss hearing the voice I’ve been listening to for the past four years
AHEM!
1. songs of war is the best
2. Songs of war is the BEST MINECRAFT ANIMATION to exist!
3. (I apologize for 4.)
4. HOW IS THERE ANYTHING WRONG WITH THIS!!!!!? BESIDES THE FACT THAT THE NEXT SEASON ISN'T OUT YET!!!?????!!!
1:54 These are not weapons, these are the Sendar, Nestor, Kaltar and Mendor. These are staffs which are connected to the "power" of being master (even if Ingressus uses the Voltar as a weapon idk why)
Okay, now it's cancelled YOU HAPPY!!??!?!?!?
This is the first animation that got under 90 sins in this channel
They have the nicest fighting animations
5:51 bro thats ice on top of the stone
I didn’t notice a single shit. I just focused on the amazing story. 😄
the wither was not doing anything at the start but keep on looking at it and it starts attacking.
The dremora lord scene was hilarious!
It was my favourite!
Dremora lord? What?
@@Ranman242 it's from Skyrim
Oh! Thought you were referring to a scene in the episode!
@@Ranman242 thought they were at first too lmao
Black plasma studios and other fans disliked this frickin video
I thought it was going to be roasting like cinema sins, but he sinned everything ACTUALLY wrong with the series. Give him a 100 sins
Animation Sins: *Sees a pixel out of place in the distance*
Hmmm 10 sins for that one.
8:00 The markings are on the side of the arm as it's rotated to allow the bend inwards. try it on your arm, bend it inwards as in the scene and you'll see, that the inside points behind you
1 sin for skyrim addictions!
Animation sins be like: this fictional world with literal floating islands doesn’t have good physics because it enriches the story that’s a sin
5:45 cmon even I noticed that clipping on his face
Ur making this video sound like animation is Easier than it accually is (I wanna see u try to do animation) its not easy
The dude actually does animate.