Tommy kind of did but then he screw up when he couldn't argue back but I was surprised that Joe didn't pick that up right away, even more when she got back and forth with Tommy.
+theSUBVERSIVE Yeah but you can't really argue back with knowing you're a civilian. What else can you say besides that? Pointing fingers with a crappy reasoning is worse than just yelling that you (yourself) are a civilian. And besides, Geo argues too much to begin with. I thought it was pretty obvious that Geo was the mafia because she pointed fingers at everyone for no reason (Tommy and Tiff)
+whackedout101 but you just pointed out things to argue back at geo. You don't have to argue back about the roles, you can talk about their behavior, the things they did and how they change their mind, what I said is that you can't start pointing out something trying to make a point and then allow the other to back you off without any actual point rather than attacking you back quite defensive like she did. There are always ways to argue back, that's the point of the game, it's a matter of how good and logical you are, the roles don't matter that much at some point if you are good at it, if he knew what she was, that's all he needed.
+whackedout101 but you just pointed out things to argue back at geo. You don't have to argue back about the roles, you can talk about their behavior, the things they did and how they change their mind, what I said is that you can't start pointing out something trying to make a point and then allow the other to back you off without any actual point rather than attacking you back quite defensive like she did. There are always ways to argue back, that's the point of the game, it's a matter of how good and logical you are, the roles don't matter that much at some point if you are good at it, if he knew what she was, that's all he needed.
If they were in kindergaten. Tiff would be that girl who likes pointing fingers, and would follow her BFF everywhere Geo would be that girl who likes making best friends with someone like Tiff but would dump her every time after she loses a game Joe would be that boy who'd get A+ and 1 extra pizza slice for lunch Josh would be that boy who likes to smile creepily at the corner of the classroom, and likes to argue but has nothing good to say for his argument. Tommy would be the good boy sitting quietly on his chair... but when someone comes near him and starts accusing him for breaking the crayons, he would blow up like a grenade ! ...... SHOW 'EM BOI! Gina would be that girl who just likes going with the flow..... "YEAH! they say he creepy! so I say he creepy too!" Julia would be the teacher's sidekick
+Rex Stylus Haha this is probably my favourite Mafia comment ever! Sums everyone up really well and reminds us that they are all just people and those are their personalities, so obviously the personality of each person will creep into their playing style. And also reminds everyone in the comments that these are all just people playing a game not intentionally trying to hurt anyone. People in the comments shouldnt get so heated about their playing style its just different ways of playing the game, if they really felt anyone was ott then they would have been told and we wouldnt have seen that agian but they all really just friends. This aint high school no more, so no need for all the heated comment talk on other comments, people getting overheated when there is nothing really to argue about is how wars are started!!! So calm down!! But in this game environment they all know they are going to argue with each other and its just a game so everyone lets just watch the vid and enjoy instead of any nasty comments!!!
a great prank would be to not have any mafias then bart would just randomly killing people and the players would be so fucking pissed trying to convince everyone that they're not mafia
Tommy is right though. If you're not allowed to use previous games as proof, then basically no one here has any reason to defend themselves because no one has any proof to prove anyone is mafia. Tommy can only say that he's civilian. It does not matter what you bring to the table, the only thing that anyone could really say is just that they are civilian.
+nymx exactly. he has nothing. he can bring anything to the table. even his bullshit. will that keep him from getting selected to be on the chopping block?
The part when Joe asked Tommy why he suddenly got so heated and defensive it was so obvious that the reason was because Geo was treating him so rudely "YOu make NO sense! What do you even mean!!" But it would weird and awkward if Tommy said that the reason was because of Geo's condescending tone :/
Agreed here, too. Sure Geo is a competitive type of player, but she is always 'condescending' towards the other JK people... like for JKN she's always talking down to Julia.
not only that but she talks down to her own husband. she's constantly pointing out random things about her own man. and it's always at the most odd and random times. and you can tell by his expression how it makes him feel. she kind of puts him out there at a vulnerable time and in front of everyone. but, joe usually has barts back and is usually the one sticking up for bart. don't get me wrong I love and adore geo she's a wonderful person with a great heart, but at the end of the day she is no better than anyone else. and I really hope she starts to allow herself to grow and see how she belittles people and maybe do better with it. I understand she's very aggressive and dominating and a lot of people back down because they feel intimidated by her demeanor and sometimes loud mouth, but that's usually when you have targeted a sensitive issue in someone. geo just needs to know when to humble herself down.
Thanky you Tommy for being the Voice of reason this round, cause even though joe helped a lot, it was tommy sacrificing to take out Geo that finally sealed the deal. Tiffany was just extremely counter productive this round. she was constantly wishy washy and didnt see who was the true civilian. Once Tommy said that he knows its not her then that should have confirmed to her that he was the civilian cause the Mafia needs two civilians to die and Joe is confirmed a civilian by josh so the only ones were those 3. So if Tommy tells Tiffany that he trusts that shes not the Mafia and wouldnt vote for her then she as the civilian should have known that it was confirmed Geo then.
Why didn't they all just jump on Geo when she kept on pushing that Tiff was dead, or was supposed to be dead, for (Geo) wanting as many people as possible to die haha
+somethinrelistrange I think it was tempting for Geo to accuse Tommy first because he was quiet most of the time. She can't go against Joe because he was deemed innocent by Josh.
if geo was smart, she shouldnt Have blamed Tommy. it would have Been better to wait since Tommy was content do sacrifice himself anyways while tiff was on the chopping board
+Halikarz31 Tommy just doesnt know how to play along with people. Just cause Geo was playing the game by pointing him out, he got butthurt and wouldnt let go of it.
+Halikarz31 I don't think that Tommy was truly angry or moved inside. He was smiling after the whole deal , so I don't know why people label it as something negative. They both were competitive and emotional during the game, but they can separate between game and reality. If Tommy were to be more eloquent he would occupy just as much verbal space as Geo. But because he is more quiet people perceive him as a victim somehow. Have you guys played any competitive sports? In sports you often have to physically push your opponents and take their victory, or vice versa. But it reality it can only make your bond stronger.
+T1ger8oi the only reason tommy got angry was because the manner in which geo. was playing the game. It's one thing to be competitive and another to be rude, and she clearly was not playing the game, she found a way to disrespectful. U know why its geo fault. Think about this has tommy ever gotten angry while on jk new or party, no he is reserved most of the time. Proof that geo attitude towards playing is just way to serious.
+Zurk lol she asks him a question, he tries to answer and before he can finish his sentence she asks him another question/talks over him. She did that throughout this video. You'd have to have the patience of a freakin' monk to not get angry over that. On a side note, i think that was actually one of the tests Buddha took in order to achieve Nirvana. jk
+Bob Loblaw It's a strategy in any argument to plainly make your "opponent" look bad. Literally, if she can trigger Tommy and make him upset, he looks works and she looks better in the situation. Not to any of us, but to someone in that game, when Tommy is yelling and swearing, he looks terrible, and Geo wins unfortunately.
tiff needs to learn that outside relationships dont matter in a game. she is too scared to betray friends. geo needs to learn how to be less defensive. she made it way too obvious when she pointed at tommy w/o any proof.
yea she is too perfect with the shit she is doing and she is way too defensive with her "true facts" plus she seems butthurt so i would automatically vote for her and gina was way too quiet and acting weird so i would vote for her too probably first
Geo thinks she had a good argument but nothing she was saying made any sense, everyone freaks out when someone does the smallest thing and think there lying
Yeah when she argued with Tommy at the end, every time Tommy puts a point out she says things like, 'That doesn't make sense', 'What are you talking about'. It felt like she's just chucking lines everywhere.
I like Mafia but this particular game sounded more personal. You can defend it by saying arguing is part of the game, but it sounds like they were getting out deep-seated frustration they had with each other. Also, this video really reveals the hierarchy that exists in JK. Josh was even fanning himself because of the tension. Geo has a very strong personality and always looks to pick on those that are less dominant; she was defending her position to not reveal she was the mafia but did so in the nastiest, most belittling way - also showing her place in the hierarchy. Tommy did get angry quickly but I think anyone would when you're basically being talked down to in - of all things - a game. As usual Tiffany is under Geo's thumb and acts as her pet. This video was hard to watch but I'm glad I saw it. I realize their videos are only moments in time that we get to see so maybe they needed this game to vent, I don't know. Although, I hope they do less intense versions of Mafia for later videos and realize you don't need to pick on others and get overly defensive just to play the game correctly.
Lol this is the most eloquently put summary of the issue everyone has with this video. Why doesn't this have more likes? People keep pointing out that Geo's job as Mafia was to defend herself but they are really missing the point. Geo's hand gestures, face expressions, and phrases like "what are you talking about?" are all incredibly belittling especially towards Tommy who she clearly doesn't respect. Although I love watching this crew, I'm also very glad Tommy came to the realization that he wasn't being appreciated and left. As an extra side note, I'm also kind of wondering if Geo has anything to do with the fact that JustKiddingFilms never made an honorary video for Tommy's departure from the company... It seems incredibly odd to me that they wouldn't because Tommy has been with them for so long.
Thanks! I read a lot of the comments and just wanted to give my opinion since I felt the exact same way you do. Geo was way too aggressive and her energy was negative. I do like her and most of the JK crew members - while feeling indifferent about the rest - but I did notice this about her personality for a while. I hope Tommy left on civil terms at least. I liked him, he had an awkward but endearing quality about him. I'm glad he moved on to do his own thing though. I noticed when he was sometimes on JKN, commenters would say that Tommy didn't contribute but when he did, he was always interrupted or kind of ignored. I feel like the same thing is occurring in this video, commenters are overlooking what is really happening in the context of the video.
This is a perfect explanation! I agree with you totally, especially because AFTER the game was done, Geo was still very rude to Tiff and Tommy, like the game's done calm the fuck down.
I wish others would stand up against her so maybe she's learn to be a good sport. but that's why i love when David call's her out! David is a very good debater rather than an argumentative player, so he always defend the true side and he always has a reason. and I think Geo is one of the main reasons he won't play mafia
God damn why is geo so aggressive? I mean I love her but seriously she accuses other people of mafia and as soon as people start pointing fingers she's all like what the fuck what the fuck, geo, you're the best, but seriously? calm down and let the other jk members enjoy the game without you rambling on and accusing other people of shit.
You can't ask that kind of thing, that's simply how they are and eventually it will get like this, they won't tone it down, the max they can do is to let Geo be mafia the next time so the game can be a bit more chill... Hahahaha...
+Nhi Nguyen Her strategy in Mafia is to make everyone made or confused when she triggers people. It works great on Tommy especially, because he gets extremely frustrated and ends up fucking up his story. It's not really a good way to argue, but you need to know who you are playing, so it actually works with guys like him.
"What are you talking about" "What are you talking about" "What are you talking about" -Geo Every god damn time someone had an argument with geo. This pissed me off
If you think about it, Josh is like one of the best player through out the whole Mafia series and this match is a good example of why. Because of Josh, he manage to find out the 2 mafia early, prove that Joe was innocent, killed a Mafia and sacrifice himself for the civilian. A true team player and MVP. Good job Josh!
+Sterling Ngahuia I guess you can say its an opinion by society's standards, but by saying that i think you would just be bs'ing yourself, probably since you like Geo. The thing is, if thats not offensive, then what is? Also, why are'nt people talking about how the rest of the crew's negative attitude. That's because they are in laymans terms, being nice.
+lolitsnick Geo kicked a girl in the crotch when she was a kid. Just because she felt like doing it. The rest of the crew makes fun of her for being a Bully in school and she denies being one, but the way she treats the weakest most awkward members of this crew makes me think she is still that Crotch kicker.
It's a game, jesus. Getting defensive to pretend you're innocent in a GAME is normal lol. She smiled when she revealed herself as mafia. She wasn't pissed off. Tommy though, started throwing the F word at Geo out of anger. I'm glad he left JK.
+AmillionCookies LOL! and Gina looked at the camera and she's like "omg! they are going nuts!" written on her face. Those two were legit getting pissed lol.
tiff forgets that its a game and thinks her relationships outside the game still stand which is why she always backs up geo and apologised to gina when she voted
+awchante hahah That makes so much sense. Throughout this game Tiff is like "I know it's Geo", but then she backs up Geo by voting Tommy. I'm like why are you voting Tommy if you know it's Geo. lmao
+DXVID when joe came out and said "its these two" after confirming that gina wasn"t the cop and joe wasn't mafia, tiff was all like "its not us! I know its not geo and its definitely not me!" like gurl how you even know its not geo.
DXVID Well she can't vote Joe out. And she's not going to vote herself out. So she's obviously going to vote Geo too. I feel like if Josh hadn't revealed Joe, she would have voted Tommy and Joe. She's always trusting Geo, even when she "knows" Geo's mafia. (Her words not mine bro). lol
YOUR DUMB she is smart af if there wasnt double kill in the game which there shouldnt be then she probably would have won she is obviously smart how she convinced everyone. also tiff was so innocent about to cry and tommy was the weird awkard creeep
+Goh Jun Liang sounds like someone that's never played. and even if you have, it's NOT obvious when you're actually playing. you cant say it's obvious when youre already biased with knowing the actual roles
actually I've played mafia and town of salem all I can say is firstly, its just a game, secondly, anyone defending like that so passionately definitely smell victory thats close and thirdly, due to the amount of players here with a mafia down a civilian shouldnt feel pressured to stay alive unless you are cop or dock-tah which both died early. Gezz talking about being biased huh?
There was one person who was willing to not die, this was Geo. Tiff and tommy were both okay with dying as long as someone else dies. Now use your brains, why is geo not the one who is like I;m civilian kill me as long as you kill someone else, she was the only one not saying that. This makes her guilty. It felt so good when Geo lost
***** you say this because you know who was the mafia, cuz if u did knew all people is mafia, i think you're more dump cuz you don't have respect face to othere people, good luck :)
yeah that IS TRUE. however, like tommy said XD there's literally like just 1 round. there's only like 1-3 facts they can use. but i see her strat it's irritatingly effective to an extent. I can't say i like it. Joe's really the best mafia player
Tommy kind of pointed that out at a time that only Geo was so heated about it but then things shifted when Tommy did a poor job sustaining his argument, had he held his ground and pointed that out to Joe, the game would had ended right there. Joe was already suspicious of Geo he just wanted anything to back that up, but when Geo got even more aggressive Tommy lost a bit of his cool and she took advantage of it and then it took another 5 min to figure it out and once they eliminated Tiff as a suspect based on how indecisive she was, then It clicked for the three of them.
that guy you don't know Alright dude peace. I hope you make it into an environment where you can live happily and peacefully, and you don't need to worry about wars, gangs etc. XD
I think if the smartest person in the world was playing and gave an amazing in depth analysis of why Geo's mafia, she would still say, "You don't make any sense" and "What?!" lol
There was something Tommy could've pointed out. If Geo was so sure that Tiff was the mafia, and they already picked her off, why would she be so quick (and passionate) to accuse Tommy of being mafia *as well*? If they already picked out a mafia then it wouldn't matter who they kill off second, much less accuse them of being mafia. The only person who would *be so ready* to do such a thing would be someone with extra information that the other 3 wouldn't know, i.e. the mafia, who is trying to throw people off. Also, "I'm civilian too! What are you guys talking about? You don't make any sense." isn't a better argument than Tommy's.
+Mark Ten Also, she pretty much gave herself away when she insisted that Tiff was dead. She was the only "civilian" in the game adamant about Tiff(civilian) being dead. I mean, why would you as a civilian be so adamant about another civilian being dead? I thought Joe would have called her out on that and they would've gotten rid of Geo.
+Mark Ten "Also, 'I'm civilian too! What are you guys talking about? You don't make any sense.' isn't a better argument than Tommy's." EXACTLY!! Why didn't anyone pick up on that!? It was LITERALLY the same defense.
Mafia Game Summary: Julia - bad nurse (nurse should always save themselves in the first round because you don't know shit yet) Gina - bad mafia (why you call yourself a cop when everyone knows Josh is a cop?) Tommy - bad civilian (understandable arguments but needs to explain it better) Josh - mvp of the game (good strategy in checking on Joe (who is a decent player), sacrificed himself to accuse a mafia (correctly), could have stay longer if Julia saved herself instead in the first round) Geo - manipulative mafia (controlling the game with convincing arguments and accusations but went too far sometimes) Joe - decent mafia player (missed so many hints, could have done better? Overall decent player) Tiff - worst mafia player (horrible decision maker, accusing Josh based on laughing? Biased against Geo?)
I agree Geo and Tiff are always bad at these and always have the weirdest accusations like "Oh he wasn't looking at her after she was pronounced dead, he's Mafia"
I agree with everything except Geo's part, she didn't have convincing arguments, she just knows how to put on a face and say random shit, so it sounds convincing but in reality it isn't.
+CK Dchosen1 Julia -- Good point. Gina -- I SMILED WHEN SHE GOT CAUGHT. She really messed up. Tommy -- I think he made a valiant effort considering that Geo was going to town on him. Geo -- The only strength of Geo's game is the fact that she has a pretty good poker face... and she also just didn't listen, lmao. Her really aggressive front and headstrong attitude is why the game lasted as long as it did. Joe -- Is actually pretty good. He called out Geo at one point AND then Gina. I got so happy because I thought he was about to nail it but... everyone kind of talked themselves into a ditch. Tiff -- Needs to grow a backbone.
+Dusky ★CS:GO★ i guess that's part of her strat. when she gets cornered she's not gonna be like "okay guys, ya got me." i think outside of the game she is respected as a jk member and so when she pulls the "you make no sense" card, some of the dude's just agree with her through a subconscious bias :/ felt a little bad for Tommy, Geo lied so hard to him. Half this game was Geo arguing xD
azam987654321 Cool. Now that you figured out that i was imitating you, i can be serious, stop copying the way you write your unnecessarily cuss-filled comments... and answer your very first question: "why the fuck would you feel bad" Take this analogy for instance: If some guy goes into a basketball match... where it is the Best team in the league vs the Underdog team. And then the underdog gets absolutely Pounded (126 - 14) ... is it stupid to feel bad for the losing underdog team? Do you say, "why the fuck would you feel bad. that's how you play the fucking game. lol". How the game is played has absolutely nothing to do with why someone feels bad for that losing team. You feel bad for that team because they lost big time. And how this game is played had absolutely nothing to do with why *eXx* was feeling bad for Tommy. Geo appeared to be verbally dominating Tommy(he appeared to be losing), so *eXx* felt bad for him. *tl;dr: It's this thing called Sympathy. It's when you feel bad for someone else's misfortune (to quote the dictionary).* Maybe you're just not a very sympathetic person... but yeah. There's your answer. Be happy. And maybe if you cuss less at random strangers, people will mock you less. Byee P.S Thanks for the skype invite, but i'm ok. You take care now.
I actually liked Geo this game of mafia, she was just doing what she had to. I think she would have won if the time limit had really be enforced because despite what he himself said, it seemed like Geo had Joe on her side at the final four if he truly had to make a decision then, but the longer it went on the more time the group had to break it down.
+J Morris the thing is that joe was being dumb at the end because he wasn't able to understand why tommy wasn't mafia. when instead of trying to make them feel bad by saying to kill himself. instead he was saying that he's willing to kill himself along with the mafia to win but geo wasn't willing to which ruined the point of trying act like a civilian and be willing to kill herself as long as mafia is removed. thats her mistake
Garry Bobby Phogeson Yeah very true, I think Geo did good though by creating further chaos and just general noise by not just agreeing to it/backing off right away, so that she could gum up the works and thought processes, and I don't remember since it's been a day now (and I don't have time to rewatch,) but I feel like Tommy didn't come up with that right away, so if a more time enforced situation had been at hand who knows if Tommy would have brought that to the table quickly enough. Not saying time limits have to be a thing, since I think talking until everyone is sure on what they want to do is just as fun and valid, it just seemed weird that Bart had the timer and then didn't enforce it either, but hey this isn't like a sport or for cash, rules can be changed on the fly :P
@@takarideja7373 So pretty people can’t argue? I know a lot of pretty people who can argue. Don’t how how being pretty and not pretty have to with anything.
Geo is really cool at times, most of the time shes a bully in all videos, this isnt something you should be supporting on your channel, no offence, just advice, get nicer.
Geo pissed me off so much!! It was so clear that she was mafia cuz why would a civilian be so defensive? Also whenever Tommy or Tiff said anything against her, she would say "that doesn't even make any sense!" What kind of defense is that? Joe should have figured it out right away!!
+Meteorite 102 The same kind of defense Tommy had which was "but I'm civilian". The whole point as Mafia is to deter everyone else from killing you. So "that doesn't make any sense" actually worked well for her until Tommy killed himself to prove Geo was it.
She picks on the weakest target because she's mafia.. I bet even if josh kept his mouth shut and didn't smile she would've hopped on his ass just because she wants to play dirty and eliminate the easiest targets first, but thank god she lost that made my day
It old because watching one of their older videos you see that the players wore the exact same shit...every single one..on a previous episode..I don't think that's a coincidence
+Lizzabeth Sahagun We'd all appreciate it if you didn't curse at people over the internet. We don't even know you. And by the way, she meant that Geo gets too heated. It is just a GAME and I know after that, they'll be friends. But, it's very unpleasant for the viewers to watch 30 minutes of arguing, ruins the fun.
Geo is so obvious that she's mafia in this one. She tries her best to keep everything off of her and then got super mad when Joe mentioned how if josh isn't mafia then its Geo and tiff, Geo tried so hard to keep everything off of her to the point it's obvious.
I'm only like 5 mins into this but Josh gets called out for smiling, and then when he's something important or a civilian and he gets killed he gets blamed for being suspicious! The only time I would be worried about Josh is if he wasn't smiling and laughing lol
geo please stop. i'm sorry but you are bad at this and really really aggressive. tommy gave good points but you ignored him just like when you ignore josh. if people are nice and not aggressive it doesn't mean they're wrong or bad at the game and vice versa. and i think joe is the best at this game.
This was honestly one of their best mafia so far. It wasnt as clear cut as the other mafia games. We only knew it was Geo because we saw who the mafia was, but if you were actually playing, you would understand why Joe is confused between the 3 players at the end.
+JANE DOE yeah it's a game, and she's playing it the way it's supposed to be. If you're not playing at 100% then what's the point. And you're only saying that cause they show the roles in the beginning. If you didn't know roles, it would be so difficult to tell. You'd have suspicions but you wouldn't actually know shit
I always hear Joe and Geo say, "Be a good Civilian". I'm always confused when they say that, how do you be a good Civilian? Civilians have almost no power". If someone could tell me how to be a good Civilian that would be helpful
+RichardLovesFF Kinda brief.There is a role civilians play, they need to play in a way that doesn't make them suspicious and they have to make themselves easy to read. If they get heated, they're too emotional and are unable to calmly contribute thus sounding very mafia-like(Tommy). If they jump on accusations constantly(Tiff) w/o any reasoning they appear as a desperate mafia. Town should contribute actual ideas, the only person who invoked useful responses(somewhat) was Joe.
Honestly the mafia got lucky at the start. If Julia lived she could've saved Josh since he admitted to being cop (i think it was inevitable that he'd be on the chopping block because it's Josh right). Joe would've found Gina out, Josh would confirm that Tiff is civilian. And then gg 10 minute game.
+Impunity Joe kinda got lucky too, since the cop cleared him and he didn't need to defend himself. The only reason he went after Tiff was because the cop thought she was mafia. But yeah, props to him for calling out Geo. That was pretty sick how he figured that out.
Why are the comments so heated? They just played a fun GAME and no one actually resents each other... you have to play like that if you want to win the GAME of Mafia... that's what makes it so fun because you get to put on an act and use strategy
The comment section is intense due to the fact that the last half of the video was intense and that gets the audience watching heated which makes their comments sound heated because during the time they write their comments is when they are still in that heated state of mind... If you namine
+MyOdie But man, who the hell genuinely starts accusing people before the game has even begun tho. I love Tiff and all, but that's pretty freakin stupid man.
I don't know how they didn't spot Geo straight away. She was being so defensive!
Tommy kind of did but then he screw up when he couldn't argue back but I was surprised that Joe didn't pick that up right away, even more when she got back and forth with Tommy.
+the_MASK lmao omg 😂😂
+theSUBVERSIVE Yeah but you can't really argue back with knowing you're a civilian. What else can you say besides that? Pointing fingers with a crappy reasoning is worse than just yelling that you (yourself) are a civilian. And besides, Geo argues too much to begin with. I thought it was pretty obvious that Geo was the mafia because she pointed fingers at everyone for no reason (Tommy and Tiff)
+whackedout101 but you just pointed out things to argue back at geo. You don't have to argue back about the roles, you can talk about their behavior, the things they did and how they change their mind, what I said is that you can't start pointing out something trying to make a point and then allow the other to back you off without any actual point rather than attacking you back quite defensive like she did. There are always ways to argue back, that's the point of the game, it's a matter of how good and logical you are, the roles don't matter that much at some point if you are good at it, if he knew what she was, that's all he needed.
+whackedout101 but you just pointed out things to argue back at geo. You don't have to argue back about the roles, you can talk about their behavior, the things they did and how they change their mind, what I said is that you can't start pointing out something trying to make a point and then allow the other to back you off without any actual point rather than attacking you back quite defensive like she did. There are always ways to argue back, that's the point of the game, it's a matter of how good and logical you are, the roles don't matter that much at some point if you are good at it, if he knew what she was, that's all he needed.
And THANK THE LORD Julia talked when she did to get the game back on track.
If they were in kindergaten.
Tiff would be that girl who likes pointing fingers, and would follow her BFF everywhere
Geo would be that girl who likes making best friends with someone like Tiff but would dump her every time after she loses a game
Joe would be that boy who'd get A+ and 1 extra pizza slice for lunch
Josh would be that boy who likes to smile creepily at the corner of the classroom, and likes to argue but has nothing good to say for his argument.
Tommy would be the good boy sitting quietly on his chair... but when someone comes near him and starts accusing him for breaking the crayons, he would blow up like a grenade ! ...... SHOW 'EM BOI!
Gina would be that girl who just likes going with the flow..... "YEAH! they say he creepy! so I say he creepy too!"
Julia would be the teacher's sidekick
Love it lol
Yes!!!! Hahaha
+Rex Stylus Haha this is probably my favourite Mafia comment ever!
Sums everyone up really well and reminds us that they are all just people and those are their personalities, so obviously the personality of each person will creep into their playing style.
And also reminds everyone in the comments that these are all just people playing a game not intentionally trying to hurt anyone.
People in the comments shouldnt get so heated about their playing style its just different ways of playing the game, if they really felt anyone was ott then they would have been told and we wouldnt have seen that agian but they all really just friends.
This aint high school no more, so no need for all the heated comment talk on other comments, people getting overheated when there is nothing really to argue about is how wars are started!!! So calm down!!
But in this game environment they all know they are going to argue with each other and its just a game so everyone lets just watch the vid and enjoy instead of any nasty comments!!!
lol, funny thing is that we actually know how they were from their stories
+Rex Stylus I think Gina would be the person with the dirt on everyone. Have you seen her in other videos... she is savage >:D
a great prank would be to not have any mafias then bart would just randomly killing people and the players would be so fucking pissed trying to convince everyone that they're not mafia
THIS A GREAT IDEA!
YESSSSSSS 👏👏👏
that would be too funny
LOLOL that's genius
yes
Tommy is right though. If you're not allowed to use previous games as proof, then basically no one here has any reason to defend themselves because no one has any proof to prove anyone is mafia. Tommy can only say that he's civilian. It does not matter what you bring to the table, the only thing that anyone could really say is just that they are civilian.
Yeah but ANYONE can claim to be civilian, that doesn't mean they are
+nymx exactly. he has nothing. he can bring anything to the table. even his bullshit. will that keep him from getting selected to be on the chopping block?
Geo in the comment be like: What do you talking about?
The part when Joe asked Tommy why he suddenly got so heated and defensive it was so obvious that the reason was because Geo was treating him so rudely "YOu make NO sense! What do you even mean!!" But it would weird and awkward if Tommy said that the reason was because of Geo's condescending tone :/
Agreed here, too. Sure Geo is a competitive type of player, but she is always 'condescending' towards the other JK people... like for JKN she's always talking down to Julia.
i dead thought tommy was gonna get up and slap the shit outta geo
We can only dream.
not only that but she talks down to her own husband. she's constantly pointing out random things about her own man. and it's always at the most odd and random times. and you can tell by his expression how it makes him feel. she kind of puts him out there at a vulnerable time and in front of everyone. but, joe usually has barts back and is usually the one sticking up for bart. don't get me wrong I love and adore geo she's a wonderful person with a great heart, but at the end of the day she is no better than anyone else. and I really hope she starts to allow herself to grow and see how she belittles people and maybe do better with it. I understand she's very aggressive and dominating and a lot of people back down because they feel intimidated by her demeanor and sometimes loud mouth, but that's usually when you have targeted a sensitive issue in someone. geo just needs to know when to humble herself down.
If Geo doesn't die in the first round, she's mafia. Lol, mafia always kills her first because she argues too much, duh XD
+Michelle Yang LMAOOO On God tho Geo always dies in the first round
+Michelle Yang good point coz all other mafia games she's been in she died first round lol
+Michelle Yang I was looking for this comment hahah
true
I'm Hmong too lololololoolol #TeamHmong #TeamYang
Thanky you Tommy for being the Voice of reason this round, cause even though joe helped a lot, it was tommy sacrificing to take out Geo that finally sealed the deal. Tiffany was just extremely counter productive this round. she was constantly wishy washy and didnt see who was the true civilian. Once Tommy said that he knows its not her then that should have confirmed to her that he was the civilian cause the Mafia needs two civilians to die and Joe is confirmed a civilian by josh so the only ones were those 3. So if Tommy tells Tiffany that he trusts that shes not the Mafia and wouldnt vote for her then she as the civilian should have known that it was confirmed Geo then.
Why didn't they all just jump on Geo when she kept on pushing that Tiff was dead, or was supposed to be dead, for (Geo) wanting as many people as possible to die haha
+somethinrelistrange well, at that point they had to kill two people, so she had nothing left to do really
+somethinrelistrange I think it was tempting for Geo to accuse Tommy first because he was quiet most of the time. She can't go against Joe because he was deemed innocent by Josh.
if geo was smart, she shouldnt Have blamed Tommy. it would have Been better to wait since Tommy was content do sacrifice himself anyways while tiff was on the chopping board
+Nam Di chopping board***
TonyGotManners
ty
Geo and Tommy don't go well together. Tommy is a hothead and Geo is competitive to the point where it isn't funny for anyone even herself
I think she bullies Tommy more than Josh. But is more discreet about it.
+Halikarz31 Tommy just doesnt know how to play along with people. Just cause Geo was playing the game by pointing him out, he got butthurt and wouldnt let go of it.
+Halikarz31 I don't think that Tommy was truly angry or moved inside. He was smiling after the whole deal , so I don't know why people label it as something negative. They both were competitive and emotional during the game, but they can separate between game and reality. If Tommy were to be more eloquent he would occupy just as much verbal space as Geo. But because he is more quiet people perceive him as a victim somehow. Have you guys played any competitive sports? In sports you often have to physically push your opponents and take their victory, or vice versa. But it reality it can only make your bond stronger.
+T1ger8oi the only reason tommy got angry was because the manner in which geo. was playing the game. It's one thing to be competitive and another to be rude, and she clearly was not playing the game, she found a way to disrespectful. U know why its geo fault. Think about this has tommy ever gotten angry while on jk new or party, no he is reserved most of the time. Proof that geo attitude towards playing is just way to serious.
T1ger8oi yea ur just an idiot troll were done here.
I understand Tommy's anger, Geo talks too much
+Zurk
lol she asks him a question, he tries to answer and before he can finish his sentence she asks him another question/talks over him. She did that throughout this video. You'd have to have the patience of a freakin' monk to not get angry over that. On a side note, i think that was actually one of the tests Buddha took in order to achieve Nirvana. jk
***** lmao
+Bob Loblaw It's a strategy in any argument to plainly make your "opponent" look bad. Literally, if she can trigger Tommy and make him upset, he looks works and she looks better in the situation. Not to any of us, but to someone in that game, when Tommy is yelling and swearing, he looks terrible, and Geo wins unfortunately.
Halikarz31 You right.
Halikarz31 true, i'm still not a big fan of her though lol
Count how many times geo says "what are you talking about?"
New game take a shot every time she says what are u talking about and what the fuck?? Gets u shit faced quick
XD
Everytime she lies or anything of that nature that's her quote for fibbing lol that's her tail.
I took a sip of wine everytime she said it and ended up in hospital getting my stomach pumped.
She said it as many times as this comment got liked
tiff needs to learn that outside relationships dont matter in a game. she is too scared to betray friends.
geo needs to learn how to be less defensive. she made it way too obvious when she pointed at tommy w/o any proof.
Tommy snapped on Geo........finally she knows how it feels lol
super true
+Katriel Riley When was that? I wanna see!
23:01
Ikr so happy for him
But they still love each other lol
this video should've been named "why tommy left jk"
Damn...true!
32:36 Tommy was like "that is it. Im done with this crew"
XD DAYYYYYYUM this made my day
did he leave ?!
+moh albah yep. He has his own little thing going on, called FormulaArts. You can see for yourself if you look it up.
Geo and Gina got aggressively defensive when their accused of being a mafia. That made it too obvious. Lol
It's mostly geo who's always getting defensive asf.
yea she is too perfect with the shit she is doing and she is way too defensive with her "true facts" plus she seems butthurt so i would automatically vote for her and gina was way too quiet and acting weird so i would vote for her too probably first
I would be frustrated too... Cuz she had good proof as to why it wasnt her, and they werent believing her
Mr Pedit she didn’t have jack lmao
Yeah but joe and Josh’s reasons were stupid I love josh and joe but there reasons were absolutely stupid
Geo thinks she had a good argument but nothing she was saying made any sense, everyone freaks out when someone does the smallest thing and think there lying
+John Lake Yea she argues with emotion not logic. I wish Bart was playing, he would've took Geo on.
Yeah when she argued with Tommy at the end, every time Tommy puts a point out she says things like, 'That doesn't make sense', 'What are you talking about'. It felt like she's just chucking lines everywhere.
Yeah she didn't make any sense but her tone and the way she says her words make her believable
Ikr and she never said she was civilian until tommy said in civilian and then she said I'm civilian
+John Lake
It's just like politicians, they talk a lot but they never actually say anything.
Joe is really good at this game
Damn Julia's hair is growing fast
+DavidParody stfu
+DavidParody Love seeing your comments on all these videos :)! Keep it up fam!
+DavidParody it was a pre-recorded game. It was about 4 months ago
+DavidParody the more you're told to stfu, the more you comment. major key to success! #djkhaled
Tiff: "The whole smiling-thing was a clue."
And Geo laughing manically wasn't?
V HAS COME TO burn in hell
iiROGUEiiKAKASHIii No proof it exists.
V HAS COME TO. Your opinion doesn't matter🖕🏽
I like Mafia but this particular game sounded more personal. You can defend it by saying arguing is part of the game, but it sounds like they were getting out deep-seated frustration they had with each other. Also, this video really reveals the hierarchy that exists in JK. Josh was even fanning himself because of the tension.
Geo has a very strong personality and always looks to pick on those that are less dominant; she was defending her position to not reveal she was the mafia but did so in the nastiest, most belittling way - also showing her place in the hierarchy. Tommy did get angry quickly but I think anyone would when you're basically being talked down to in - of all things - a game. As usual Tiffany is under Geo's thumb and acts as her pet.
This video was hard to watch but I'm glad I saw it. I realize their videos are only moments in time that we get to see so maybe they needed this game to vent, I don't know. Although, I hope they do less intense versions of Mafia for later videos and realize you don't need to pick on others and get overly defensive just to play the game correctly.
Lol this is the most eloquently put summary of the issue everyone has with this video. Why doesn't this have more likes? People keep pointing out that Geo's job as Mafia was to defend herself but they are really missing the point. Geo's hand gestures, face expressions, and phrases like "what are you talking about?" are all incredibly belittling especially towards Tommy who she clearly doesn't respect. Although I love watching this crew, I'm also very glad Tommy came to the realization that he wasn't being appreciated and left. As an extra side note, I'm also kind of wondering if Geo has anything to do with the fact that JustKiddingFilms never made an honorary video for Tommy's departure from the company... It seems incredibly odd to me that they wouldn't because Tommy has been with them for so long.
Thanks! I read a lot of the comments and just wanted to give my opinion since I felt the exact same way you do. Geo was way too aggressive and her energy was negative. I do like her and most of the JK crew members - while feeling indifferent about the rest - but I did notice this about her personality for a while.
I hope Tommy left on civil terms at least. I liked him, he had an awkward but endearing quality about him. I'm glad he moved on to do his own thing though. I noticed when he was sometimes on JKN, commenters would say that Tommy didn't contribute but when he did, he was always interrupted or kind of ignored. I feel like the same thing is occurring in this video, commenters are overlooking what is really happening in the context of the video.
This is a perfect explanation! I agree with you totally, especially because AFTER the game was done, Geo was still very rude to Tiff and Tommy, like the game's done calm the fuck down.
I wish others would stand up against her so maybe she's learn to be a good sport. but that's why i love when David call's her out! David is a very good debater rather than an argumentative player, so he always defend the true side and he always has a reason. and I think Geo is one of the main reasons he won't play mafia
Yea she's simply too much. I like your explanation. It's so rude to keep saying things like, "what are you even saying?!"
God damn why is geo so aggressive? I mean I love her but seriously she accuses other people of mafia and as soon as people start pointing fingers she's all like what the fuck what the fuck, geo, you're the best, but seriously? calm down and let the other jk members enjoy the game without you rambling on and accusing other people of shit.
and pls don't be unreasonable in the next mafia
You can't ask that kind of thing, that's simply how they are and eventually it will get like this, they won't tone it down, the max they can do is to let Geo be mafia the next time so the game can be a bit more chill... Hahahaha...
Thats the whole fucking point of the game! to argue and defend yourself
+Nhi Nguyen Her strategy in Mafia is to make everyone made or confused when she triggers people. It works great on Tommy especially, because he gets extremely frustrated and ends up fucking up his story. It's not really a good way to argue, but you need to know who you are playing, so it actually works with guys like him.
Isn't that the whole game? You dumbass lmfao
Geo arguments were bad too. ''What are u talking about. Lol
exactly
Hopefully they'll remember this for other games, to just call out on when THey see those (to me) Now dumb tactics(talking about G E O.
Funny thing is tiff falls for it. Mexican connection
Spencer Summerhays na I'm Mexican, tiff is just dumb
***** lmao
LOL Geo gets so hypocritical and panicky. All her arguments are along the lines of "i know you are but what am i" she doesnt let anybody talk haha
So true
Joe is too good at this.
Ikr
This game pissed me off so much for some reason like I know arguing is part of the game but Geo was just pissing me off the entire time
I FUCKING FEEL YOU GEO WAS JUST SO UGH!!!!
+Park Jimin SO UGH!!!!!!!! RIGHT?
"What are you talking about"
"What are you talking about"
"What are you talking about"
-Geo
Every god damn time someone had an argument with geo.
This pissed me off
+Peter_Panda IKR that was her only argument
+Park Jimin like anyone else had an argument for them besides joe
The whole time, I pretended I was playing with them as a citizen, so I can pinpoint who is mafia. That way, I feel like I'm in the crew hehe(:
DANG. Geo and Tommy are scary. I'm stressed out cuz of this haha so intense
+Crystal Ko i do that sometime's
+Crystal Ko I do too :P I close my eyes at the beginning... it was really easy to tell at the end though...
+Crystal Ko HAHAh the progression of "I feel like I'm in the crew" to "I AM SO STRESSED OUT" this makes me laugh -Sean
JustKiddingParty omg... IS THIS REAL LIFE?
If you think about it, Josh is like one of the best player through out the whole Mafia series and this match is a good example of why. Because of Josh, he manage to find out the 2 mafia early, prove that Joe was innocent, killed a Mafia and sacrifice himself for the civilian. A true team player and MVP. Good job Josh!
Loll I totally agree. Josh is a boss!!! He was awesome in this video:D
I don't understand why Geo had to be so rude this whole round especially in the end to Tiff and Tommy 😑😑
Geo and tiff piss me off
+THESKITTLEBOYZ she does but it's cause she really trusts her in EVERYTHING. I hope geo doesn't betray her because that'd be some shit😳
I'm pretty sure I still dont know how to play this game.
Thanks for the thumbnail.😊😊🙃🙃
+Gina Darling #thumbnailqueen
you were so cute in this video Gina!
you were so funny the whole entire time hahah
+Gina Darling You didn't life your shirt up.. it's your fault this video won't get 8 million views
Am I The Only One Who Was So Fucking Pissed At Geo😂😂Everything She Said Made Me Angry 😭
She lost though.. Thank god lol
+KYRAN F For me Tommy pissed me off
+KYRAN F
Doesn't It Take A Lot Of Time To Write Like This? Ain't nobody got time fo' dat.
Tiff pisses me off the most.
No I think she's smart its mafia and she is smart af of how long she survived
Why is Geo making me so mad? I'm not even playing the game.
Geo: what are you talking about? 😒
Theres something about Geo that makes me hope she loses every time
I know the feeling lol
she is like a bully in this game because of her confidence is towering everyone's indecisiveness and silence, but that's why she is awesome
+HaleyFT AoT7Lam but sometimes she goes overboard and she doesn't even realize ot because of her overload of "confidence"
Nah
+ZknightA because she thinks shes better than everyone
geo talks down on people a lot to make them look dumb and her pointless arguments "valid". if I was tommy I'd be like that too lol
viv vid
If Bart wasn't the Narrator and was playing He probably would have put her in her place.
I'm laughing at how throughout the whole time Gina is looking at the camera, laughing, smiling or making surprised faces. x'D
Look at josh
+Elfman Strauss | Right??? Every time Geo swore he gave the most surprised face ever.
People keep asking "Why are the comments so heated. Did'nt you read the disclaimer?" Disclaimer or not, Geo's behaviour is offensive, thats a fact.
+Nicholai Scottman Not a offensive, hardly a fact.
+Sterling Ngahuia I guess you can say its an opinion by society's standards, but by saying that i think you would just be bs'ing yourself, probably since you like Geo. The thing is, if thats not offensive, then what is? Also, why are'nt people talking about how the rest of the crew's negative attitude. That's because they are in laymans terms, being nice.
+lolitsnick
Geo kicked a girl in the crotch when she was a kid. Just because she felt like doing it. The rest of the crew makes fun of her for being a Bully in school and she denies being one, but the way she treats the weakest most awkward members of this crew makes me think she is still that Crotch kicker.
+filayn nuhaus lmao that's mad ass that she kicked someone in their crotch 😂😂
It's a game, jesus. Getting defensive to pretend you're innocent in a GAME is normal lol. She smiled when she revealed herself as mafia. She wasn't pissed off. Tommy though, started throwing the F word at Geo out of anger. I'm glad he left JK.
ha look how scared Josh was when George and Tommy started arguing.
geo*
Lmao "George"
+AmillionCookies LOL! and Gina looked at the camera and she's like "omg! they are going nuts!" written on her face. Those two were legit getting pissed lol.
Lololol we should call her George from now on
"George" Lmao that made my day 😂
tiff forgets that its a game and thinks her relationships outside the game still stand which is why she always backs up geo and apologised to gina when she voted
+awchante
hahah That makes so much sense. Throughout this game Tiff is like "I know it's Geo", but then she backs up Geo by voting Tommy. I'm like why are you voting Tommy if you know it's Geo. lmao
+Bob Loblaw she voted for tommy AND geo, it was a double kill. tommy was just the first option
+DXVID when joe came out and said "its these two" after confirming that gina wasn"t the cop and joe wasn't mafia, tiff was all like "its not us! I know its not geo and its definitely not me!" like gurl how you even know its not geo.
DXVID Well she can't vote Joe out. And she's not going to vote herself out. So she's obviously going to vote Geo too. I feel like if Josh hadn't revealed Joe, she would have voted Tommy and Joe. She's always trusting Geo, even when she "knows" Geo's mafia. (Her words not mine bro). lol
+awchante yeah, I caught that, when Joe pointed to Geo and Tiff and said "it's these two", Geo said "why me?" Tiff said "why us?" Lol
Boy this ones hella old isn't it
I like mafia
+Gabriela Gomez i assume these were all filmed within a day or two and they just made the intros as though it has been a while.
It was made before Julia got her haircut so it's been a while since they recorded this
Julia doesn't shave is a big deal, Geo has her old body, Tommy isn't as chubby, Julia has long hair, and Joes goatee is tiny.
Why do people care about when something it's filmed if it's still new content for us regardless
when geo isnt killed in the first 2 rounds you know she is mafia
I love how serious Joe gets in Mafia, it's kinda scary.
Tommy*
+Lejames Bron Tommy is never serious 😂
+786Demigod He got serious in the end, he looked like he was pissed off at geo
Geovanna*
+Kookie Hyung The only time you'll ever see him serious XD
Geo gets so fucking aggressive oh my god.
when doesn't she
+teaarmo
did you miss Tommy arguing? He was close to punching someone
And she's mafia she's smart
Knightinvason TV so smart she lost?
YOUR DUMB she is smart af if there wasnt double kill in the game which there shouldnt be then she probably would have won she is obviously smart how she convinced everyone. also tiff was so innocent about to cry and tommy was the weird awkard creeep
It was so dam obvious the way geo defended herself!! wtf!
+Goh Jun Liang sounds like someone that's never played. and even if you have, it's NOT obvious when you're actually playing. you cant say it's obvious when youre already biased with knowing the actual roles
actually I've played mafia and town of salem all I can say is firstly, its just a game, secondly, anyone defending like that so passionately definitely smell victory thats close and thirdly, due to the amount of players here with a mafia down a civilian shouldnt feel pressured to stay alive unless you are cop or dock-tah which both died early. Gezz talking about being biased huh?
Fuck Geo
There was one person who was willing to not die, this was Geo. Tiff and tommy were both okay with dying as long as someone else dies. Now use your brains, why is geo not the one who is like I;m civilian kill me as long as you kill someone else, she was the only one not saying that. This makes her guilty. It felt so good when Geo lost
Please do mafia with Gina AND David
yes
yyyeeaa gina and david
+Caro Honest YES THEY SHOULD
***** you say this because you know who was the mafia, cuz if u did knew all people is mafia, i think you're more dump cuz you don't have respect face to othere people, good luck :)
ok, keep talking, you'll make me feel so happy :) cya
When it's Geo she says "What are you talking about?" When they accuse her lol
why isnt anyone pushing the fact that Geo is over reacting on round2 and use that as the reason to put geo in the chopping block
yeah that IS TRUE. however, like tommy said XD there's literally like just 1 round. there's only like 1-3 facts they can use. but i see her strat it's irritatingly effective to an extent. I can't say i like it.
Joe's really the best mafia player
Tommy kind of pointed that out at a time that only Geo was so heated about it but then things shifted when Tommy did a poor job sustaining his argument, had he held his ground and pointed that out to Joe, the game would had ended right there. Joe was already suspicious of Geo he just wanted anything to back that up, but when Geo got even more aggressive Tommy lost a bit of his cool and she took advantage of it and then it took another 5 min to figure it out and once they eliminated Tiff as a suspect based on how indecisive she was, then It clicked for the three of them.
that guy you don't know lmao bruh. You still shouldn't resort to violence due to frustration XD
that guy you don't know Alright dude peace. I hope you make it into an environment where you can live happily and peacefully, and you don't need to worry about wars, gangs etc. XD
I know right she was so offended that should've been a clue.
Mafia, the game that ruins friendships.
Worse than monopoly?
You should have a look at them playing Resistance lol
I think if the smartest person in the world was playing and gave an amazing in depth analysis of why Geo's mafia, she would still say, "You don't make any sense" and "What?!" lol
"What are you talllkking about"
lol Geo's cool but she always does this
"That sucksss!"
"You're not bringing anything to the table!" lol
+bob loblaw shes doing that to make the others think that the person shes arguing with look stupid
Joe's the smartest guy I know when it comes to Mafia
+Albert Ho joe, as usual, was fucking on point in this game and it was hilarious when he threw the plush. I was like "man, me too"
+Zach K Agreed!
😂😂 geo pisses me off in mafia
Like pls stfu
But like just in mafia
+Kathy Nguyen thats the point of the game to speak and defend urself, smartypants
+Arsen theworldsrooler tru tru
omg ik I wanted to punch her. But I can't. 😒
Geo takes this game really serious
She takes all games serious. Trust fam i agree .
There was something Tommy could've pointed out. If Geo was so sure that Tiff was the mafia, and they already picked her off, why would she be so quick (and passionate) to accuse Tommy of being mafia *as well*? If they already picked out a mafia then it wouldn't matter who they kill off second, much less accuse them of being mafia. The only person who would *be so ready* to do such a thing would be someone with extra information that the other 3 wouldn't know, i.e. the mafia, who is trying to throw people off.
Also, "I'm civilian too! What are you guys talking about? You don't make any sense." isn't a better argument than Tommy's.
+Mark Ten
Also, she pretty much gave herself away when she insisted that Tiff was dead. She was the only "civilian" in the game adamant about Tiff(civilian) being dead. I mean, why would you as a civilian be so adamant about another civilian being dead? I thought Joe would have called her out on that and they would've gotten rid of Geo.
+Mark Ten "Also, 'I'm civilian too! What are you guys talking about? You don't make any sense.' isn't a better argument than Tommy's."
EXACTLY!! Why didn't anyone pick up on that!? It was LITERALLY the same defense.
Mafia Game Summary:
Julia - bad nurse (nurse should always save themselves in the first round because you don't know shit yet)
Gina - bad mafia (why you call yourself a cop when everyone knows Josh is a cop?)
Tommy - bad civilian (understandable arguments but needs to explain it better)
Josh - mvp of the game (good strategy in checking on Joe (who is a decent player), sacrificed himself to accuse a mafia (correctly), could have stay longer if Julia saved herself instead in the first round)
Geo - manipulative mafia (controlling the game with convincing arguments and accusations but went too far sometimes)
Joe - decent mafia player (missed so many hints, could have done better? Overall decent player)
Tiff - worst mafia player (horrible decision maker, accusing Josh based on laughing? Biased against Geo?)
I agree
Geo and Tiff are always bad at these and always have the weirdest accusations like
"Oh he wasn't looking at her after she was pronounced dead, he's Mafia"
#UnderratedJosh that's two mafia games Josh has brought home the win in.. I love seeing him do this because they can't bully him no more
I agree with everything except Geo's part, she didn't have convincing arguments, she just knows how to put on a face and say random shit, so it sounds convincing but in reality it isn't.
+CK Dchosen1
Julia -- Good point.
Gina -- I SMILED WHEN SHE GOT CAUGHT. She really messed up.
Tommy -- I think he made a valiant effort considering that Geo was going to town on him.
Geo -- The only strength of Geo's game is the fact that she has a pretty good poker face... and she also just didn't listen, lmao. Her really aggressive front and headstrong attitude is why the game lasted as long as it did.
Joe -- Is actually pretty good. He called out Geo at one point AND then Gina. I got so happy because I thought he was about to nail it but... everyone kind of talked themselves into a ditch.
Tiff -- Needs to grow a backbone.
Das da mudda true shit
Am I the only one that likes Tommy's arguement? Was better than Geo's, when she got cornered only thing she said was "You don't even make any sense"
+Dusky ★CS:GO★ i guess that's part of her strat. when she gets cornered she's not gonna be like "okay guys, ya got me." i think outside of the game she is respected as a jk member and so when she pulls the "you make no sense" card, some of the dude's just agree with her through a subconscious bias :/ felt a little bad for Tommy, Geo lied so hard to him. Half this game was Geo arguing xD
+eXx why the fuck do you feel bad. thats how you play the fucking game lol
+azam987654321 Why the fuck not? Is there some unwritten fucking rule of this game that says viewers must not feel bad for players.?
azam987654321 Cool. Now that you figured out that i was imitating you, i can be serious, stop copying the way you write your unnecessarily cuss-filled comments... and answer your very first question: "why the fuck would you feel bad"
Take this analogy for instance: If some guy goes into a basketball match... where it is the Best team in the league vs the Underdog team. And then the underdog gets absolutely Pounded (126 - 14) ... is it stupid to feel bad for the losing underdog team? Do you say, "why the fuck would you feel bad. that's how you play the fucking game. lol".
How the game is played has absolutely nothing to do with why someone feels bad for that losing team. You feel bad for that team because they lost big time. And how this game is played had absolutely nothing to do with why *eXx* was feeling bad for Tommy. Geo appeared to be verbally dominating Tommy(he appeared to be losing), so *eXx* felt bad for him.
*tl;dr: It's this thing called Sympathy. It's when you feel bad for someone else's misfortune (to quote the dictionary).*
Maybe you're just not a very sympathetic person... but yeah.
There's your answer. Be happy. And maybe if you cuss less at random strangers, people will mock you less.
Byee
P.S Thanks for the skype invite, but i'm ok. You take care now.
filayn nuhaus i didnt read any of that. put your money where your mouth is and skype me if youre so confident and wish to continue this, idiot.
Geo gets sooo salty when she loses
I love Geo but it made me so mad with her argument like i felt so irratated lol. if I was actually in this game friendships would've had issues
just to clarify though, I love Geo a lot and I know in the game u have to do that but it was irratating. still loved it tho.
+Fawjia Yeasmin Right? She was going off on Tommy and then used the same argument as him. I love her too, but she aggravated me in this mafia game.
+Fawjia Yeasmin She always gets super personal and really upset when playing Mafia.
+Fawjia Yeasmin Yeah, she really takes the fun out of the game ugh
I took a bong hit everytime Geo said "what are you talking about" and now Geo is bald..
I actually liked Geo this game of mafia, she was just doing what she had to. I think she would have won if the time limit had really be enforced because despite what he himself said, it seemed like Geo had Joe on her side at the final four if he truly had to make a decision then, but the longer it went on the more time the group had to break it down.
+J Morris the thing is that joe was being dumb at the end because he wasn't able to understand why tommy wasn't mafia. when instead of trying to make them feel bad by saying to kill himself. instead he was saying that he's willing to kill himself along with the mafia to win but geo wasn't willing to which ruined the point of trying act like a civilian and be willing to kill herself as long as mafia is removed. thats her mistake
Garry Bobby Phogeson
Yeah very true, I think Geo did good though by creating further chaos and just general noise by not just agreeing to it/backing off right away, so that she could gum up the works and thought processes, and I don't remember since it's been a day now (and I don't have time to rewatch,) but I feel like Tommy didn't come up with that right away, so if a more time enforced situation had been at hand who knows if Tommy would have brought that to the table quickly enough. Not saying time limits have to be a thing, since I think talking until everyone is sure on what they want to do is just as fun and valid, it just seemed weird that Bart had the timer and then didn't enforce it either, but hey this isn't like a sport or for cash, rules can be changed on the fly :P
+J Morris Glad you enjoyed her, but to me, she was fucking obnoxious, loud, repetitive, and just an overall extreme drag on the game
They always target Josh
It's cause he's black
+Jeff the Slayer no its not
+C40R3 FTW lol ik. Just a joke
Jeff the Slayer well thats one fucked up joke haha!😂
damn tiff you were terrible in this game :(
+Ken Siu you know that you fall for geo's mind games, and yet you still are giving in
+Ken Siu lol "I always trust geo and she's the Mafia every them! I think I'll trust her again!" Logic.
+Elijah s Tif or Geo?
+TelicsHD she's not so bright lol
+Elijah s I agree
JOE SO MUDDA SMART!!!!
Tommy fucking sucks
+Ders JuanPablo How they would of lost if he didn't say anything?
Geo isn't a better argue-er, she's just the loudest.
Geo is prettier than u thoo
@@takarideja7373 Found someone stupider than Geo, congrats!
@@understandwithme1518 jus go FK urself
@@takarideja7373 I guess I struck a nerve lmao, my bad sorry
@@takarideja7373 So pretty people can’t argue? I know a lot of pretty people who can argue. Don’t how how being pretty and not pretty have to with anything.
tommy is so sweet. i miss him. :(
You know Geo had to fire him after this haha
Wow how old is this video? Julia with long hair wtf
+Caro Honest few months
+Karim Zniber at least 4 months
***** ya probly, from Julia's instagram it's at least 12 weeks old, I still haven't finished the video, it still very entertaining :D
+Caro Honest theyre wearing the same clothes from the last mafia so around 3-4 months
+Caro Honest she was hot there! now she looks like a chineese boy
Geo is really cool at times, most of the time shes a bully in all videos, this isnt something you should be supporting on your channel, no offence, just advice, get nicer.
geo's anthem: "dude what are you talking about"
i'd like to purposefully see Bart & Geo as mafia. That would be hella interesting to watch! lol
Bart would throw he under the bus in a heartbeat. Has done it before lol
+Mind Yours lol yeah
They were once Spies together when they played Resistance, which is kind of like Mafia.
Tiffany saying "I knew it!". No, she did not lol. She kept going back and foward.
Geo pissed me off so much!! It was so clear that she was mafia cuz why would a civilian be so defensive? Also whenever Tommy or Tiff said anything against her, she would say "that doesn't even make any sense!" What kind of defense is that? Joe should have figured it out right away!!
+Meteorite 102 its just a game.... fucking entertainment... just watch and if you dont like it dont watch!
+Meteorite 102 The same kind of defense Tommy had which was "but I'm civilian". The whole point as Mafia is to deter everyone else from killing you. So "that doesn't make any sense" actually worked well for her until Tommy killed himself to prove Geo was it.
Stop targeting Josh. He is actually pretty good at this game.
Tommy's argument was way more better than Geo's argument, all I heard Geo saying was, "What the fuck are you talking about?".
I swear Geo always riding Josh's meat like dam there are other people playing the game
XD
She picks on the weakest target because she's mafia.. I bet even if josh kept his mouth shut and didn't smile she would've hopped on his ass just because she wants to play dirty and eliminate the easiest targets first, but thank god she lost that made my day
Geo talk too much to be innocent. Btw guys it's more fun if you skip the part where they reveal the roles :)
and close your eyes at night
I've never thought of doing that, great idea.
+SkyDrawzZ thank you, you da reel #MVP for that tip
+SkyDrawzZ that's a horrible point. innocents can talk a lot too. you're only able to say that because you ALREADY know from the beginning
But then u would find out anyway when they go to sleep
Bruh Julia got goddamn long hair again, wtf
+troopuh it's an old video, like back in september or something
Ikr realy old vid
Don't forget her legs bruh! 😛
It old because watching one of their older videos you see that the players wore the exact same shit...every single one..on a previous episode..I don't think that's a coincidence
+Bea Guarin yea they prolly have alot of prerecorded videos but didn't upload it for purposes
I don't like geo any more not trying to be mean
+Nicolle Lopez I'm not gonna lie, I never liked Geo in the first place. She seems like all the games are about her.
agree
didn't you read the beginning of the video, it basically said that even if there yelling at each other they still love each other as friends. Dumbass.
+Lizzabeth Sahagun We'd all appreciate it if you didn't curse at people over the internet. We don't even know you. And by the way, she meant that Geo gets too heated. It is just a GAME and I know after that, they'll be friends. But, it's very unpleasant for the viewers to watch 30 minutes of arguing, ruins the fun.
+Lizzabeth Sahagun you seem like you have a very low IQ
NO FUCKING SHIT - Geo 12 times
"What are you talking about?" -Geo the entire video
yeah i didnt like how she kept yelling that. she was undermining the jkcrew and shutting down people with that phrase. all part of the game i guess
+Zachary Dixon "That doesn't even make any sense!" - Geo the entire video
+Zachary Dixon Her Way is super believable though cause she's so sure of herself
+Nancy Le nope, it's because she's loud
Tiff acts likes she's smart and knew it all along she didnt
She had an instinct. But she’s too indecisive and too afraid of betray her friendship, when in reality, it has nothing to do with it
Geo is so obvious that she's mafia in this one. She tries her best to keep everything off of her and then got super mad when Joe mentioned how if josh isn't mafia then its Geo and tiff, Geo tried so hard to keep everything off of her to the point it's obvious.
This was uncomfortably intense.
I'm only like 5 mins into this but Josh gets called out for smiling, and then when he's something important or a civilian and he gets killed he gets blamed for being suspicious! The only time I would be worried about Josh is if he wasn't smiling and laughing lol
+Ela Bolanos "...gets killed and blamed for being suspicious..." lol sounds very familiar, quite current events.
+Jarrell Sanchez damn
It's because geo was mafia, that gave her full reign to target the weakest person in the group (Josh).. She just plays dirty and I am so glad she lost
It's weird, I was on the towns side this game, I'm usually always on the mafias side, hmm
+Mogwei 22
You know why? Because fuck gehoe
+Chechen Wolf Haha i was on the town side too because of the same reason
Jay Jay
I was just baffled.... like... calm the fuck down, it's a game... she was so obnoxious...ughh
ITS A FUCKIN GAME MEANT TO MAKE YOU ARGUE!!!!!!
what r u talking about?
+Mogwei 22 ikr
geo please stop. i'm sorry but you are bad at this and really really aggressive. tommy gave good points but you ignored him just like when you ignore josh. if people are nice and not aggressive it doesn't mean they're wrong or bad at the game and vice versa. and i think joe is the best at this game.
fam it is a game
well obviously she going to ignore them cuase she want to win
누나 seosi army exactly. she should take it easy.
What else she going to do agree with tommy and blow up her position of being mafia
it's a dang game bro, stop being so butthurt guys
This was honestly one of their best mafia so far. It wasnt as clear cut as the other mafia games. We only knew it was Geo because we saw who the mafia was, but if you were actually playing, you would understand why Joe is confused between the 3 players at the end.
Damn Julia got Cakes......
+Andres Alcaraz But shes hideous and she doesnt shave, shes all yours.
That's rude...
But I'm hoping your joking.
+Grizzly Brah w/ long hair she's amazing and with short hair she looks cute, so either way you wrong nigga
Andres Alcaraz nigga you desperate
+Andres Alcaraz (. )( .)
Geo needs to not play this game tbh😁😁
i think my blood pressure went up from watching this
Geo stop raising your hand god damn...
+JANE DOE yeah it's a game, and she's playing it the way it's supposed to be. Shut up
+JANE DOE yeah it's a game, and she's playing it the way it's supposed to be. If you're not playing at 100% then what's the point. And you're only saying that cause they show the roles in the beginning. If you didn't know roles, it would be so difficult to tell. You'd have suspicions but you wouldn't actually know shit
+Thien Luong lol ive been scrolling through the comments, and every comment about geo ur there to defend her...
+D'zyn well there's a timer so gotta say what you gotta say quick?
22:12 look at Josh's face
+rp2114 dead
23:21
+Ash H MARKKK HES MY BIASSS
+rp2114 LOL IM DEAD XD
+rp2114 LOLOL he's like the scared kid while the parents are fighting
By the disclaimer, I can tell Josh gets severely bullied.
Ikr I was kind of like ok what did you guys do to josh this time 😂.
+Tailor Well you were wrong, Josh was the one doing the 'bullying' this time, if you could even call it that- y'all are too sensitive.
lmaoooo .
***** Why are you bullying Tiffany? LOL Bigot
Yeah they really bullied him into that lol especially lying ass Geo
When tommy was in JK
Why did he leave
He got another job.
And he's killing it
Raquel Balbas Rip Tomia
Thank god he's gone.
I always hear Joe and Geo say, "Be a good Civilian". I'm always confused when they say that, how do you be a good Civilian? Civilians have almost no power". If someone could tell me how to be a good Civilian that would be helpful
Well you clearly wouldn't be a good civilian
I guess you be a good civilian by pointing someone out, who turns out to be mafia.
People who think civilians are useless are usually the ones who can't play the role properly. Civilians use logic and observations.
+RichardLovesFF Kinda brief.There is a role civilians play, they need to play in a way that doesn't make them suspicious and they have to make themselves easy to read. If they get heated, they're too emotional and are unable to calmly contribute thus sounding very mafia-like(Tommy). If they jump on accusations constantly(Tiff) w/o any reasoning they appear as a desperate mafia. Town should contribute actual ideas, the only person who invoked useful responses(somewhat) was Joe.
+Kevin Qian Richard theres ur answer
Joe is fucking good at this game tho
Honestly the mafia got lucky at the start. If Julia lived she could've saved Josh since he admitted to being cop (i think it was inevitable that he'd be on the chopping block because it's Josh right). Joe would've found Gina out, Josh would confirm that Tiff is civilian. And then gg 10 minute game.
+Impunity Joe kinda got lucky too, since the cop cleared him and he didn't need to defend himself. The only reason he went after Tiff was because the cop thought she was mafia. But yeah, props to him for calling out Geo. That was pretty sick how he figured that out.
Haha I know
I feel bad for josh because everyone excuse him
accuses**
don't worry, everyone else is getting accused. plus they're arguing and thats how you play the game
Thats the game bro
+Anson Nguyen excuse
I know it's the game but would it be fun if you always get accuse first just because you are guy who smiles a lot
Tiff don't act like you knew it and are smart if you knew geos was why did you vote for tommy?
Hey Geo, What Are Thoooooseeeeee
+vGz Viper Those are my chanclas!
+flymike00 I've seen that vine 😂😂
The "Moses 11's"
+vGz Viper it's the jerusalem huaraches
+vGz Viper The same could be said for Josh, Are those bowling shoes???
Why are the comments so heated? They just played a fun GAME and no one actually resents each other... you have to play like that if you want to win the GAME of Mafia... that's what makes it so fun because you get to put on an act and use strategy
The comment section is intense due to the fact that the last half of the video was intense and that gets the audience watching heated which makes their comments sound heated because during the time they write their comments is when they are still in that heated state of mind... If you namine
+Joe Jiang exactly
Tiff ALWAYS accuses the wrong "'mudda" person lol
+Mikaela Francesca she's fucking stupid
+Gavin McDougall nah
+MyOdie
But man, who the hell genuinely starts accusing people before the game has even begun tho. I love Tiff and all, but that's pretty freakin stupid man.
Tommy just need to say, "geo, if I'm mafia, then would you die right now to win this game?
geo got no valid points like ever lmfaooo but ppl still belive her