The reason Bears fans should be panicking isn't Caleb Williams... It's how efficiently Fields has been playing in Pittsburgh. After a while, you have to wonder how much is on the QB, and how much is a decades-long institutional problem in Chicago.
As a certified Baker Mayfield defender, it’s been equal parts satisfying and sad watching the Browns implode. I get Baker was kind of volatile there, but he was (and still is) an obviously solid QB. Then they drop him only to throw 9 digits at Chester the Molester just to watch him waddle around on field and get demolished. Brilliant management boys, well done.
And throw shade at Mayfield too saying they needed an adult at the position. Browns brass throwing their QB under the bus. Their QB that brought them out of mediocrity for their first winning season in how long and had the city getting behind him. AND he wanted to be there!! Then they publicly try to humiliate him while saying it’s okay to give a predator THE bag because the guys wife gave him the okay for all women. That’s about the most Browns maneuver of all-time. Feel bad for their fans. If they had kept building with Mayfield they could’ve gone places.
Don't forget how hard they slammed the door on Baker on the way out too, "need an adult at the position" and refusing to cut him in favor of a trade to the literal worst team the NFL. It has been equally sad and satisfying watching them implode this year, but I can never help but wonder how it would have went if they just kept on Mayfield and kept building. He was on his 5th year option when he was dealt. Even if he ended up the 15th best QB in the league they'd be a top 5 team easily with all the extra parts they could have afforded, and if he flopped moving on would have been low to no risk.
Everybody rags on the trubisky over mahomes pick but i guarantee you mahomes would be out of the league by now if he was drafted by chicago lol. We cant develop offensive talent if our franchise depended on it.
@@jaycurry5593no, the argument is not the Chiefs make players better (which is debatable of course), the argument is that the Bears make high potential players worse.. and hey, it seems very true
one of the worst part about watching people slam rookie quarterbacks, (who are maybe the most system dependent when theyre young) is understanding that going somewhere with a bad headcoach, bad o coordinator, or bad quarterbacks coach, can be nails in the coffin for someone's career without them actually ever having a real chance. As well, Rogers/Brady and others have talked about how crazy it is that so many quarterbacks are expected to start rookie year. Makes sense to let them learn under 1-2 veterans for a year or two. Unfortunately that didnt pan our for Mason Rudolph in pitsburgh but. It's a good formula still
Anthony Richardson can make plays that 99% of QBs can’t make. But he also can’t make plays that 99% of QBs can make. Getting the fundamentals right in terms of passing and running needs to be his biggest priority
@@MJ-mi9qcsaw him play in college. He sucks. He looked good at times when you're fast & athletic against walk ons' he'll look alot better than he really is.
Panic is for when the situation is still in a position where the final outcome is yet to be determined. We already KNOW the Dolphins are fucked. Tua would be on this list at #1 if we were talking about the "back injury" game from a few years ago.
@@InchonDMYou dont "know" anything. Its a situation in limbo and it is absolutely panic enducing for the Fins (and fans) who've just paid him fortunes.. Why on earth would they be in the mood to roll over and accept their fate as determined?? Foolish.
All I heard all offseason was how Caleb Williams was a star and how the Bears were gonna win the division and make the playoffs. So no, Bears fans shouldn't panic. You deserve it.
Watson has zero excuse - in Houston he had a terrible o-line and he still balled out up until 2019 - ever since Covid and the masseuse scandals he's just a shell of his former self man
As a Colts fan I legit get post game clarity every damn week. Richardson does not play great, and during the last 2 weeks, I've literally been the biggest Joe Flacco supporter. But after the games I think about it and I'm here for the ride. Richardson has so much damn potential, LIKE a LOT. But his inability to throw accurately on short passes kills us. I still look forward every week to see the casual bomb pass, though, and I am still excited for this season. I think I'll give AR this whole season, and I'll start being extremely critical next year.
As a Colts fan. The Joe Flacco supporters are the ones that piss me off the most. No reason to be pissed at a dude who’s played 20 games since high school. There is no fucking reason to ever play Joe Flacco, just so what, we can go 9-8 or 8-9 and either miss the playoffs or lose in the first round. AR needs time and development and as fans we need patience. If we suck this year, well damn we get a high pick and our hopeful franchise QB actually played and learned. There shouldn’t even be a reason to be critical until we have a real playoff line up. Unless Ballard addresses the secondary before next season than I wouldn’t be too critical of Rich cause the team wouldn’t be competitive anyway. Sorry for the rant lol
Honestly as a Titans fan, Richardson just needs to learn throwing with touch and how to read a zone. Dude is still very raw. He can still turn it around for y'all.
@@ImmatureLight I’ll pray for you brother cause lord Levis is…something lol. He can pass but poor man has some horrible decision making. If Peter and Latham develop and your O-Line becomes good again and can protect Levis. You might have something, but I wouldn’t be shocked if you draft a guy this year
@zandermartin3445 That why I said "post game clarity" haha. I totally agree with you though, I'm here for AR. I want this man to succeed so fucking bad.
Putting in another vet would be the death of us. Might get us to the playoffs, but what about next year? We'll be cooked. Let AR develop, take it as a learning year. We didn't spend the bank on big free agents, we're not in a rush. I say let the team develop, we have young CBs too showing great promise (I see you Jaylon Jones). We'll be aight in a couple of years
I like to imagine Lawrence can be good, if not great, but that door is closing quickly if Jacksonville doesn't do *something* with the coaching staff. His confidence is getting killed out there and you can see it on a weekly basis, something has changed negatively big time within the team and it shows across the entire roster, not just him. There's no reason this team should be playing this poorly when it's arguably a better roster than the roster they had during their late 2022 and early 2023 seasons.
Definitely agree with Bryce Young. He had a fantastic line in college but was also taking 5-6 step drops just to see what he was throwing at. You can't get away with that in the NFL
Carson Palmer was at worst "good" and carried a pretty mid Cardinals team to playoffs. And Sam Darnold this year is certainly not mediocre or dogshit, I think we've proven Darnold's issues were the teams he was on.
@@joeking433 Which is insane tbh. Look at recent(-ish) successful rookie QBs. Sure, C.J. Stroud went and balled out, but he came into a solid team in Texas and was already the most mature QB of the draft. But Jordan Love? Sat behind Aaron Rodgers. Patrick Mahomes sat behind Alex Smith for 16 games. Lamar Jackson played in week 1 but it was in relief of Joe Flacco, who started 10 games before going down with a hip injury. The original plan for Josh Allen was to sit him behind Nathan Peterman but Peterman was so atrocious that he was benched before the first week was over. It wasn't intentional, but even JJ McCarthy is doing the same thing. I'd be willing to bet that he'll be better next year than Caleb Williams has been through three weeks. Meanwhile the Panthers will go out here and draft Bryce Young #1 overall and start him immediately for what? Literally all of these great QBs sit for a while to learn. C.J. Stroud and Josh Allen are the exceptions among the exceptions.
I can’t think of a worse contract situation in the history of the NFL than Watson’s. He’s a bad QB and a creep. I think the browns organization kinda had this coming after they screwed over the only good starting QB they’ve ever had and signed a deal with the devil.
Ironically I think Watson's signing was good for Cleveland. They have spent decades making horrible choices at QB and flushing it away at the first sign of trouble. The rest of the team was loaded, and for once there was never an idea that there would be a new starter next week or next year. And they have played better these last few years for it. Now you'd hope going forward you pick a vet or mid round QB to ride out the team and use the cap money and picks to boost the rest of the team.
As a browns fan who’s first jersey as a little kid was Tim Couch’s as well and who’s dad still talks about the fumble, god does is hurt to hear the honesty 😂 you gained a sub
As a Gators and Colts fan I’m not panicking yet about AR *yet* Coming out of University of Florida that early I had my concerns because we all knew he wasn’t ready for the nfl at all. The main reason why I’m still not panicking is that his ac joint injury basically wiped any potential progression he could have had as a rookie. He also needs to slow down and take whatever the Defense gives him
Coaching, offensive line, wide receivers, bad running game, offensive coordinator There are many factors that the QB can’t control but directly affect the way he is valued.
How has Richardson 'regressed' when he didn't even play last year and he was never good in college? He's always been a project with great athletic ability. He's shown nothing in his entire football lifetime that he can even be a 60% completiong percentage passer. The only reason he hasn't flamed out as fast as Bryce Young is because he was injured all of last year
Being a Quarterback in the NFL is super tough. You get a lot of the blame, but people don’t see what is going on behind closed doors that merges into performance. Just watching Chicagos offensive line alone tells me that Caleb has either left the wrong impression on his team and/or organization or he hasn’t take care of the people that will take care of him. Because I think at times his line doesn’t even give him any effort to protect him. He doesn’t get much time to throw and gets sacked and hurried a lot. That is not a recipe for success for any quarterback and before long his confidence will be deflated and he’ll be off the roster in 2-3 seasons.
This is the first time in...10 years? I expect my Broncos to be lambasted here, but Bo Nix seems to be exactly where Sean wants him to be as a rookie headi g into week 4. So many Broncos fans are panicking but hes doing just fine!🎉
I think Coaching, organization, and culture play a huge factor, a la Alex Smith, Geno Smith, Sam Darnold (maybe). But time will tell if this is true. By the time those guys got to an “ok” level they had had a lot of time in the NFL to develop, and a lot of different coaching staffs.
Caleb Williams is just in a cursed place. Same for Bryce Young. Trevor Lawerence might actually be ruined, or his potential permanently truncated. I’ve never been high on Richardson. He’s a classic project QB, raw and toolsy, who they threw immediately into the fire. They’re going to ruin him at this rate. The same is true to a lesser degree of Levis and more obviously Young. Daniel Jones is a solid backup who had the misfortune to be drafted in a prime spot by a mess of a franchise. The Gropist flailing and failing restores some small part of my faith in the universe.
@warlordofbritannia bruh why is TLaw ruined after two bad games? He was really good against Miami and was awesome last year before the injuries and especially in 2022 but no two bad games means he's not good anymore. The bias against him is insane man.
Nah, Bryce just sucks. Andy did fine with the same weapons and Carolina's o-line is really good. The media is just straight up lying about the Panthers.
Young is already gone and Williams will be by next year. If you’re small you have to have exceptional ability and those two just don’t. Williams might make it as a backup somewhere. Baker is an anomaly.
I think Tlaw would cook in a competently designed offense. Last year before he suffered that injury he was the 5th highest graded QB per PFF, and he was great the year before that as well. He has not played well this year but I don't know how much that is on him when the offense itself is a total mess. Deshaun Watson I don't even know if we can call it panic at this point, he just fucking stinks and has for the last few years. And Bryce as well, loved the guy coming out of college but it's clear he just doesn't have it. Last season he was in an awful situation but Carolina actually surrounded him with pieces and he's played even worse this year. I think he's broken.
@rthraitor TLaw was good against Miami and BAD against Cleveland and especially Buffalo (with some good plays here and there). Just hope he can get out of this slump. But ofc because of two really bad games people are saying he sucks now.
@@ledgnr197gaming5 tbh people have wrongly been saying he sucks since the start of last year so they are just waiting to jump on him for any reason lol. They love to hate on anyone that was called generational lol
@rthraitor THANK YOU SOMEONE ELSE GETS IT. There is a clear bias against him, which I get I guess. If I hear one more person compare him to Daniel Jones I'm gonna lose it
@@ledgnr197gaming5 yeah not a single gm is ever taking DJ over Trevor ever lmfao. It’s just lazy box score watching people, shows most people just care about fantasy rather than actually engaging with the sport. And you’ve already got people dumping on Caleb because a few people called him generatinal
The reason why a backup/mid QB might look better and get wins at Pitt is because Pitt has a culture where the QB is not the center fix/cure, but just an important piece of a larger puzzle. Teams that draft a QB in hopes it will fix something are bad because that QB is not a piece of the puzzle, but rather forced to be the glue to hold it all together. Fields is working because he is not trying to be the hero.
As a panther fan since Steve Smith popped a kick return in his rookie season, I can say pretty definitively that Carolina has to be a bottom five QB development franchise. They were blessed with a random solid starter for years in Jake Delhomme and obviously the absolute franchise leader that was Cam. If you look at the other QB's they've had its a joke, I mean look at Baker last year and Darnold so far this year. Not to say that Bryce isn't going be a bad NFL quarterback but I can't give up on him knowing the rep of the panthers and how poorly they develop talent. I hope he sits behind Andy all year, like he should have LAST YEAR
The recency and hindsight bias with TLaw is crazy to me from some fans. He played elite football for a lot of last year and the second half of 2022 but bc of two big stinkers (he even played well against Miami) all of a sudden he sucks and is not gonna be worth the contract. And yes he was bad the last two games even when the situation was fine on some plays, but his situation is way worse than people think. Defense is not playing well at all, O-Line is horrible and he clearly does not trust them, and the play calling and play design is atrocious In this offense. I think this is a slump that will be fixed by improving the O-line and cleaning out the coaching staff. People just forget how well he has played since his second season but COMPLETELY forget that bc of the contract. People want any reason to hate on him, it's ridiculous.
I think elite is a bit of a stretch. Good football, definitely. I would not go as far as to say elite. And is it all on him? No. Most of it isn't on him. This team fucking sucks. The defense has regressed, the offense is stagnant with bad playcalling, they still want to have this ridiculous hope that Evan Engram and Christan Kirk are some elite receivers. And Davis has been a bust for them. But at the same time, when is enough enough? He looked terrible in 2021. Looked bad to start 2022. It looked bad to end 2023, and looks terrible to start 2024. Is it all on him? No. But you are paying him 270 MILLION DOLLARS. You'd hope he'd make a bit more of something out of nothing. Especially as a number 1 overall pick. Tom Brady made his career out of playing with mediocre pass catchers. Patrick Mahomes just won the Superbowl with Marquez Valdez Scantling and Kadarius Toney. I'm sorry but honestly what the fuck is the difference at this point between Trevor Lawrence and Mac Jones? You want to talk about recency and hindsight bias, if Trevor Lawrence was named John Smith he isn't getting a 5 year extension and more than likely is looking for a new team. But because he is Trevor Lawrence and was a god in college, we need to hold out insane hope that he's going to make this massive leap. When? When is it coming? Please tell me. Cause honestly you could give him Tyreek Hill and Justin Jefferson and I'm not sure how much is going to change. How is he any different than Tua? Or Brock Purdy? Or Jared Goff? Or any of these middle of the road quarterbacks.
Bruh. He’s trash. Accept it. We were told he was the future face of the NFL and Daniel jones had better numbers. Tlaw is a bust and will be a career backup in 3-4 years.
I think with Richardson you can’t teach what he can do which is launch a ball over the moon. But I think you can help him with his short game and decision making.
As a new york giants fan i think giants are gonna use dj as a bridge to the new qb in this draft (hopefully cam ward) but i think he will still start next year so they can have their rookie watch first i dont want to ruin a qb like everyone else
The biggest problem the bears fans have are over hyping every single QB they get. Just take a breath and hope for something good but those rookie qbs that have a great season are rare.
The 2022 performance against the Chargers was more of an indictment on Brandon Staley than it was a good performance for T Law. He’s been mid to downright bad for most of his career with a few elite/teasing moments to keep fans roped in.
To be fair to Williams he has way worse coaching. If Daniels had to play for Flus and the OC he'd also look like he was unsure and unready. Same with Mahomes. If he was in Chicago he'd never have any success and bust out totally since he was developed very well under Reid.
Tennessee sticking by Levis is a red flag. It's one thing to throw picks as a young player, but Levis makes decisions that high schoolers know better on. I feel like the message is to NOT jump at QBs in the draft. Draft the best player available, OR build your interior and then expand to skill guys. Look at Vikings with Darnold. The guy is now balling out because Minnesota has a real team.
Levis hasn't even played 14 games. The games he's played have been behind a bottom 2 offensive line. I'd be more alarmed at Richardson and Lawrence tbh.
5:28 I don’t think removing one game to make DJ look better is the right way to look at it. By that logic, remove 2/4 games. Then remove 3/5 if he continues to be terrible. That’s ridiculous. No - he should be graded out of 100% like everybody else. If we’re going to remove on game, then is he 100% legit if we’re counting 66 or 75% of his games? Sure. But who counts like that?
Guys like Will Levis, if you fix the bone head moments, which is very likely to happen since it's his 4th week into his career, then you have a far less terrible looking rookie start. And most rookies don't start great, like Mahomes first games. He wasn't a world beater and he also didn't get thrown right into the fire like a lot of these rookie QBs are. It is so, so hard to know how a QB will do because it can depend so much on the factors outside of their own talent.
When bears want to a draft a qb and they're sure they have their man, they should have someone in the organization whose only job is to switch the names and draft the other guy. Might be better.
The Colts showed me that they shouldn't be putting all that pressure on AR5 by only letting him throw the ball 4 times in the 4th quarter against Chicago... We're going run the ball alot and use AR5 sparingly to elevate the pressure off him
Smart… or rather average intelligence Colts fans aren’t panicking just yet with AR (injuries aside). We understand this is essentially his rookie season and he was literally drafted with the thought of “this is a project QB”. (AKA be patient with him) Why would you start packing 4 games into what is more or less a rookie season? Now if we’re including injury concerns in the discussion… having some amount of panic is more understandable.
NFL teams thinking Bama is a QB factory under Nick Saban has been the greatest fleece. Young and injury prone Tua is the antithesis of this. So glad Jalen Hurts got out when he did. It going to be interesting what Jalen Milroe can do vs Georgia.
You’re absolutely correct on Watson. Browns fans defending him is looking more and more like Stockholm syndrome every day. WE GET THE OLINE IS HURT, WE GET THE RUN GAME IS WEAK. It’s like you said, he is simply not good enough to be worth the trade, and that is going to mean that this window has been sealed shut for the Browns.
One of my favorite hobbies over the past few years has been to anger hopefuls and memers alike by arguing that Daniel Jones is mid. Glad to see I'm not alone.
Also my fever dream is to see the Pats get Will Levis (Coach Mayo, it has to happen) and see them trot out the Dollarback formation of the future with him, Brissett, Maye, and Milton in the same backfield. Someone has to do this in Madden at least. Milton in that formation would be a hoot as the tailback. Dude's built like Cam Newton, and, given his preseason performance, when I heard that he claimed to be able to throw the ball 95 yards, I believed that.
so you anger people that say Jones is good by saying Jones is mid? Not sure what you are saying. Going into week 6 Jones is 11th in QB and 12th in passing yards.
After the Cowboys vs. Giants game, it’s clear that Daniel Jones isn’t the issue. That offensive line is just terrible. 281 yards in a loss where Dak had less yards on 2 TD’s is all you needed to see.
@myaheadhurts2 and he still looks raw. He has had 1.25 seasons of development at the NFL level and hasn't shown much better trait. Overall Trevor Lawerence, Daniel Jones, and Watson all have better stats than him. The only excuse is his "potential" which is funny because potential means nothing if you can't develop. Look at Toney lol
I think Richardson deserves to be a little higher. His lack of progress in improving his accuracy is deeply concerning. We keep saying "If he clicks" but the guys decision making does not resemble that of a second year NFL quarterback. He seems to play with a "Fuck it, we ball" mentality where hes tossing the ball out there with a prayer. For a team with the offensive weapons set like the Colts, there are a lot of Quarterbacks that would would make them into a winning team, or at least a much stronger offense. Richardson is running out of excuses IMO. He at least needs to be higher than Daniel Jones, who is at least making the Giants offense watchable, and getting the ball to his receivers on plays that I honestly don't think Richardson would make.
I think they know they're in a situation where they're heavily invested in Young just from the draft piucks trade to get him. They say him at just week 2 so he can use this season to sit behind a veteran QB like he should have done his rookie season. So they put him out there to see if he could handle it, he couldn't, so they're sitting him behind a veteran QB like every other young QB that's succeeded. Peterson isn't stupid and it's VERY OBVIOUS that trotting a QB out his rookie season is a recipe for disaster. CJ Stroud is a very very very rare anamoly.
Why are these rookies being rushed out onto the field in their first year? Doesn't anyone train their QBs any more? The greatest QBs had a year or two or three on the bench before they started. Even if a QB has a good first year, they often regress, and that's not an emergency! This short attention span analysis is not good for anyone. A college QB cannot be expected to do well in the NFL.
watching justin fields lead the steelers to a 3-0 record is amazing. just more proof that it’s not all on the bears qb’s. they have horrible personnel to pair with rookie qbs. probably the worst situation for a rookie qb in the league
"Lead". He's looked good, but the steelers defense has only allowed 26 points in 3 games. Most recent game was his best, but he's put up good numbers before and then stumbled like the Packers game at the end of last year.
I think it is early to judge if Fields is a top QB. Pittsburgh is only asking him not to lose the game, their D will keep them in any game. Remember, Trubisky stank it up in Chicago, and then stank it up in Pittsburgh. J Fields is off to a good start and I wish him well, but it is a long season.
How is Tua not on, let alone near or at the top of the list? The fins JUST paid a guy who literally can not ever get hit or it tanks their year, and can’t beat good teams when healthy.
Liked the video, but I don't know why you would cherry pick with Jones. That's his entire issue, at times he looks competent, then other times he looks like child who wandered onto the field. If he could avoid the bad streaks he'd be pretty ok...but he can't.
The only reason why Williams has any trouble is the way he was sold as a finished product. The Bears illustrate that “weapons” don’t matter if the offensive line isn’t addressed. If Daniels keeps putting himself in position to get lit up he will be RG4. Slide, go out of bonds please. I don’t want to see history repeat. Richardson is a high school QB. Levis definitely isn’t worth running Vrabel out of town. Dude needs to learn a sack isn’t the worst thing in the world
A coach really needs to understand the players they end up with. To see Sam Darnold rise from the dead and look like a hero in purple is a perfect example of players ending up in a system the coaches can't make work. Peyton Manning had 2 back to back 3-13 seasons before going 13-3 in his 3rd season. PS. I've seen many Browns fans go through some stuff. I was a Colts fan for decades before I moved to KC in 07. Ya'lls ownership sucks as hard as suck can suck. I'm glad Baker Mayfield escaped. Flacco looked comfy in a Colts uniform. WTF is the C suite doing?
5:08 - "if you take out the bad games he's good". Cherry-picking simply doesn't provide a compelling narrative or any insightful analysis, it's just a slippery slope.
any week three analysis is going to have small sample bias. But if he looks good in 2 of three games., that's a reason not to panic. A more fair comparison would be to toss out 1 bad game from all the QBs. and see where he rates.
Anyone who is hyperventilating about Lawrence is not watching jags games. The guy has no o-line and the play calling is leaning on the run game. Like how is this guy supposed to succeed under these conditions
If the DL isn't expecting passes, play action should be effective. Sure the total yardage might not be wonderful, but his passer rating should be fine.
if the bears had taken mahomes he would have sucked and probably would have been out of the nfl by now. the qb gets a lot of credit/blame but really the coaching and team have WAY more to do with the results than the qb's talent.
If you couldn’t see their colors, young and Watson look the same, the way they play. Less than desirable footwork, uncomfortable in the offense.. like they look like the same person.
The reason Bears fans should be panicking isn't Caleb Williams... It's how efficiently Fields has been playing in Pittsburgh. After a while, you have to wonder how much is on the QB, and how much is a decades-long institutional problem in Chicago.
There's nothing to wonder. After decades, you can't blame coaches and players.
When its ALWAYS the same teams busting on first pick QBs, do you REALLY think its the QBs at that point?
You act as though thw Steelers are scoring more points than the Bears did with Fields....
@@SanguineMalcontent They're WINNING. Fields is doing everything he needs to, managing the game and not turning the ball over.
As a lifelong Bears fan, I’m not panicking. Why? I’ve been through this 5+ times. Same old same old, nothing new, life as usual.
As a certified Baker Mayfield defender, it’s been equal parts satisfying and sad watching the Browns implode. I get Baker was kind of volatile there, but he was (and still is) an obviously solid QB. Then they drop him only to throw 9 digits at Chester the Molester just to watch him waddle around on field and get demolished. Brilliant management boys, well done.
And throw shade at Mayfield too saying they needed an adult at the position. Browns brass throwing their QB under the bus. Their QB that brought them out of mediocrity for their first winning season in how long and had the city getting behind him. AND he wanted to be there!! Then they publicly try to humiliate him while saying it’s okay to give a predator THE bag because the guys wife gave him the okay for all women. That’s about the most Browns maneuver of all-time. Feel bad for their fans. If they had kept building with Mayfield they could’ve gone places.
Don't forget how hard they slammed the door on Baker on the way out too, "need an adult at the position" and refusing to cut him in favor of a trade to the literal worst team the NFL. It has been equally sad and satisfying watching them implode this year, but I can never help but wonder how it would have went if they just kept on Mayfield and kept building. He was on his 5th year option when he was dealt. Even if he ended up the 15th best QB in the league they'd be a top 5 team easily with all the extra parts they could have afforded, and if he flopped moving on would have been low to no risk.
@@Lurrkiing ... how it would have gone* if they just had* kept Mayfield
DA bRoWnS
#factoryofsadness and I'm dusting off the paper bag
Everybody rags on the trubisky over mahomes pick but i guarantee you mahomes would be out of the league by now if he was drafted by chicago lol. We cant develop offensive talent if our franchise depended on it.
By your logic, Trubisky would be a 3 time champion and MVP if he went to the Chiefs. 😂😂😂
@@jaycurry5593no, the argument is not the Chiefs make players better (which is debatable of course), the argument is that the Bears make high potential players worse.. and hey, it seems very true
your franchise sort of does depend on it
one of the worst part about watching people slam rookie quarterbacks, (who are maybe the most system dependent when theyre young) is understanding that going somewhere with a bad headcoach, bad o coordinator, or bad quarterbacks coach, can be nails in the coffin for someone's career without them actually ever having a real chance. As well, Rogers/Brady and others have talked about how crazy it is that so many quarterbacks are expected to start rookie year. Makes sense to let them learn under 1-2 veterans for a year or two. Unfortunately that didnt pan our for Mason Rudolph in pitsburgh but. It's a good formula still
... if he had* been* drafted
“everybody wants their guy to be THE guy, but sometimes he’s just a guy.” is a perfect quote
Anthony Richardson can make plays that 99% of QBs can’t make. But he also can’t make plays that 99% of QBs can make. Getting the fundamentals right in terms of passing and running needs to be his biggest priority
But if he does… oh boy. He’s gonna be special
You stole this quote
@@MJ-mi9qcbut if he don’t he going to be out of the league pretty quick just being a great athlete don’t make you a nfl qb
That’s a dumb quote. He’s horrible
@@MJ-mi9qcsaw him play in college. He sucks. He looked good at times when you're fast & athletic against walk ons' he'll look alot better than he really is.
How are the Dolphins not on this list? QB panic is pretty much their game plan for the rest of the season.
Panic is for when the situation is still in a position where the final outcome is yet to be determined.
We already KNOW the Dolphins are fucked. Tua would be on this list at #1 if we were talking about the "back injury" game from a few years ago.
Nooo kidding
@@InchonDMYou dont "know" anything. Its a situation in limbo and it is absolutely panic enducing for the Fins (and fans) who've just paid him fortunes..
Why on earth would they be in the mood to roll over and accept their fate as determined?? Foolish.
All I heard all offseason was how Caleb Williams was a star and how the Bears were gonna win the division and make the playoffs. So no, Bears fans shouldn't panic. You deserve it.
what were you saying
Watson has zero excuse - in Houston he had a terrible o-line and he still balled out up until 2019 - ever since Covid and the masseuse scandals he's just a shell of his former self man
As a Colts fan I legit get post game clarity every damn week. Richardson does not play great, and during the last 2 weeks, I've literally been the biggest Joe Flacco supporter. But after the games I think about it and I'm here for the ride. Richardson has so much damn potential, LIKE a LOT. But his inability to throw accurately on short passes kills us. I still look forward every week to see the casual bomb pass, though, and I am still excited for this season. I think I'll give AR this whole season, and I'll start being extremely critical next year.
As a Colts fan. The Joe Flacco supporters are the ones that piss me off the most. No reason to be pissed at a dude who’s played 20 games since high school. There is no fucking reason to ever play Joe Flacco, just so what, we can go 9-8 or 8-9 and either miss the playoffs or lose in the first round. AR needs time and development and as fans we need patience. If we suck this year, well damn we get a high pick and our hopeful franchise QB actually played and learned. There shouldn’t even be a reason to be critical until we have a real playoff line up. Unless Ballard addresses the secondary before next season than I wouldn’t be too critical of Rich cause the team wouldn’t be competitive anyway. Sorry for the rant lol
Honestly as a Titans fan, Richardson just needs to learn throwing with touch and how to read a zone. Dude is still very raw. He can still turn it around for y'all.
@@ImmatureLight I’ll pray for you brother cause lord Levis is…something lol. He can pass but poor man has some horrible decision making. If Peter and Latham develop and your O-Line becomes good again and can protect Levis. You might have something, but I wouldn’t be shocked if you draft a guy this year
@zandermartin3445 That why I said "post game clarity" haha. I totally agree with you though, I'm here for AR. I want this man to succeed so fucking bad.
Putting in another vet would be the death of us. Might get us to the playoffs, but what about next year? We'll be cooked. Let AR develop, take it as a learning year. We didn't spend the bank on big free agents, we're not in a rush. I say let the team develop, we have young CBs too showing great promise (I see you Jaylon Jones). We'll be aight in a couple of years
Trevor Lawrence regressed under Doug Pederson just like Carson Wentz did.
good solid writing and narrating, you have it.
The Jaguars were dumb enough to extend his contract when could have simply made him prove his worth!
He is horrible,,,good in college,,sucks in nfl
I like to imagine Lawrence can be good, if not great, but that door is closing quickly if Jacksonville doesn't do *something* with the coaching staff. His confidence is getting killed out there and you can see it on a weekly basis, something has changed negatively big time within the team and it shows across the entire roster, not just him. There's no reason this team should be playing this poorly when it's arguably a better roster than the roster they had during their late 2022 and early 2023 seasons.
Definitely agree with Bryce Young. He had a fantastic line in college but was also taking 5-6 step drops just to see what he was throwing at. You can't get away with that in the NFL
Thumbnail with 3 afc south QBs 💀 Watson could be honorary Texans QB that sucks too
I thought the south was gonna be great this year lmao
The teams are great. But there's not much you can do when every QB is doing worse than last year.
Watson is Brown, not a Texan!!
@@ozkarin07 h o n o r a r y
@@thatonewriter8043 but the teams aren't great lol
USC quarterbacks are either mediocre or dogshit in the NFL. Never changes
Carson Palmer was at worst "good" and carried a pretty mid Cardinals team to playoffs. And Sam Darnold this year is certainly not mediocre or dogshit, I think we've proven Darnold's issues were the teams he was on.
@@wicklebeeCarson Palmer resurgence in 2016 was crazy. Lowkey should’ve won mvp
Sam Darnold out to prove you wrong this year
Darnold
@@geoffreyrisley15Nah. He had a great season but definitely not MVP over Cam. Even lost to Cam in the NFC Championship game.
Tim Couch being your first favorite player and you still liking football let alone the browns is nothing short of a mircale 😂 im sorry.
I am always surprised how many NFL teams hang the future of the franchise on a rookie QB.
That’s because they’re all looking for a Burrow/Stroud/Mahomes type turnaround.
Rookie QB contracts also allow GMs to build out rosters during the 5 year window
@@chopsnz88this is the answer
@@joeking433 Which is insane tbh. Look at recent(-ish) successful rookie QBs. Sure, C.J. Stroud went and balled out, but he came into a solid team in Texas and was already the most mature QB of the draft. But Jordan Love? Sat behind Aaron Rodgers. Patrick Mahomes sat behind Alex Smith for 16 games. Lamar Jackson played in week 1 but it was in relief of Joe Flacco, who started 10 games before going down with a hip injury. The original plan for Josh Allen was to sit him behind Nathan Peterman but Peterman was so atrocious that he was benched before the first week was over. It wasn't intentional, but even JJ McCarthy is doing the same thing. I'd be willing to bet that he'll be better next year than Caleb Williams has been through three weeks.
Meanwhile the Panthers will go out here and draft Bryce Young #1 overall and start him immediately for what? Literally all of these great QBs sit for a while to learn. C.J. Stroud and Josh Allen are the exceptions among the exceptions.
I can’t think of a worse contract situation in the history of the NFL than Watson’s. He’s a bad QB and a creep. I think the browns organization kinda had this coming after they screwed over the only good starting QB they’ve ever had and signed a deal with the devil.
Ironically I think Watson's signing was good for Cleveland. They have spent decades making horrible choices at QB and flushing it away at the first sign of trouble. The rest of the team was loaded, and for once there was never an idea that there would be a new starter next week or next year. And they have played better these last few years for it. Now you'd hope going forward you pick a vet or mid round QB to ride out the team and use the cap money and picks to boost the rest of the team.
As a Steelers fan. I love these kinds of videos. We have Future Fields now 👍🖤💛
As a browns fan who’s first jersey as a little kid was Tim Couch’s as well and who’s dad still talks about the fumble, god does is hurt to hear the honesty 😂 you gained a sub
... a fan whose* first jersey was / whose* dad still talks (who's = who is)
@@einundsiebenziger5488 thank you sir, well actually not really since you had to edit your own comment 😂 seem like a real fuckin nancy
Good video. I don't know why you're under 10k subs, you seem like a channel with a big cult following. Hope to see you grow in the future.
As a colts fan, I scream every play. Sometimes good scream, but a lot of bad so far. But thrilling nevertheless!
As a Gators and Colts fan I’m not panicking yet about AR *yet* Coming out of University of Florida that early I had my concerns because we all knew he wasn’t ready for the nfl at all. The main reason why I’m still not panicking is that his ac joint injury basically wiped any potential progression he could have had as a rookie. He also needs to slow down and take whatever the Defense gives him
I enjoyed watching Tim Couch through his Kentucky career. I still have a recruiting magazine downstairs with him in it. Good old days!
I’ve never ever been so happy to be a commanders fan
Coaching, offensive line, wide receivers, bad running game, offensive coordinator
There are many factors that the QB can’t control but directly affect the way he is valued.
How has Richardson 'regressed' when he didn't even play last year and he was never good in college? He's always been a project with great athletic ability. He's shown nothing in his entire football lifetime that he can even be a 60% completiong percentage passer. The only reason he hasn't flamed out as fast as Bryce Young is because he was injured all of last year
Being a Quarterback in the NFL is super tough. You get a lot of the blame, but people don’t see what is going on behind closed doors that merges into performance.
Just watching Chicagos offensive line alone tells me that Caleb has either left the wrong impression on his team and/or organization or he hasn’t take care of the people that will take care of him.
Because I think at times his line doesn’t even give him any effort to protect him. He doesn’t get much time to throw and gets sacked and hurried a lot. That is not a recipe for success for any quarterback and before long his confidence will be deflated and he’ll be off the roster in 2-3 seasons.
This is the first time in...10 years? I expect my Broncos to be lambasted here, but Bo Nix seems to be exactly where Sean wants him to be as a rookie headi g into week 4. So many Broncos fans are panicking but hes doing just fine!🎉
I think Coaching, organization, and culture play a huge factor, a la Alex Smith, Geno Smith, Sam Darnold (maybe).
But time will tell if this is true. By the time those guys got to an “ok” level they had had a lot of time in the NFL to develop, and a lot of different coaching staffs.
Are you also of the opinion water is wet and the sky is blue?
Caleb Williams is just in a cursed place. Same for Bryce Young.
Trevor Lawerence might actually be ruined, or his potential permanently truncated.
I’ve never been high on Richardson. He’s a classic project QB, raw and toolsy, who they threw immediately into the fire. They’re going to ruin him at this rate. The same is true to a lesser degree of Levis and more obviously Young.
Daniel Jones is a solid backup who had the misfortune to be drafted in a prime spot by a mess of a franchise.
The Gropist flailing and failing restores some small part of my faith in the universe.
@warlordofbritannia bruh why is TLaw ruined after two bad games? He was really good against Miami and was awesome last year before the injuries and especially in 2022 but no two bad games means he's not good anymore. The bias against him is insane man.
Nah, Bryce just sucks. Andy did fine with the same weapons and Carolina's o-line is really good. The media is just straight up lying about the Panthers.
Young is already gone and Williams will be by next year. If you’re small you have to have exceptional ability and those two just don’t. Williams might make it as a backup somewhere. Baker is an anomaly.
caleb already breaking franchise records, yall love to hate
I think Tlaw would cook in a competently designed offense. Last year before he suffered that injury he was the 5th highest graded QB per PFF, and he was great the year before that as well. He has not played well this year but I don't know how much that is on him when the offense itself is a total mess. Deshaun Watson I don't even know if we can call it panic at this point, he just fucking stinks and has for the last few years. And Bryce as well, loved the guy coming out of college but it's clear he just doesn't have it. Last season he was in an awful situation but Carolina actually surrounded him with pieces and he's played even worse this year. I think he's broken.
@rthraitor TLaw was good against Miami and BAD against Cleveland and especially Buffalo (with some good plays here and there). Just hope he can get out of this slump. But ofc because of two really bad games people are saying he sucks now.
@@ledgnr197gaming5 tbh people have wrongly been saying he sucks since the start of last year so they are just waiting to jump on him for any reason lol. They love to hate on anyone that was called generational lol
@rthraitor THANK YOU SOMEONE ELSE GETS IT. There is a clear bias against him, which I get I guess. If I hear one more person compare him to Daniel Jones I'm gonna lose it
@@ledgnr197gaming5 yeah not a single gm is ever taking DJ over Trevor ever lmfao. It’s just lazy box score watching people, shows most people just care about fantasy rather than actually engaging with the sport. And you’ve already got people dumping on Caleb because a few people called him generatinal
@@rthraitor Box score watchers have made football discourse so exhausting
1:45 there is a 2 year age gap if yr
as a fellow browns fan, not an overreaction at all.
The reason why a backup/mid QB might look better and get wins at Pitt is because Pitt has a culture where the QB is not the center fix/cure, but just an important piece of a larger puzzle. Teams that draft a QB in hopes it will fix something are bad because that QB is not a piece of the puzzle, but rather forced to be the glue to hold it all together. Fields is working because he is not trying to be the hero.
How are the dolphins not number 1 or at least on this list? Tua situation is definitely panic level especially with their backup currently.
Yeah no Giants fans should panic. They’re paying Jones WAY TOO MUCH to be that mid/awful.
Jones is paid like a mid QB but now producing like a high-mid QB.
12th in yards, 11th in QBR going into week 6.
Then you have andy dalton throwing for 300+ and 3 tds
As a panther fan since Steve Smith popped a kick return in his rookie season, I can say pretty definitively that Carolina has to be a bottom five QB development franchise. They were blessed with a random solid starter for years in Jake Delhomme and obviously the absolute franchise leader that was Cam. If you look at the other QB's they've had its a joke, I mean look at Baker last year and Darnold so far this year. Not to say that Bryce isn't going be a bad NFL quarterback but I can't give up on him knowing the rep of the panthers and how poorly they develop talent. I hope he sits behind Andy all year, like he should have LAST YEAR
The recency and hindsight bias with TLaw is crazy to me from some fans. He played elite football for a lot of last year and the second half of 2022 but bc of two big stinkers (he even played well against Miami) all of a sudden he sucks and is not gonna be worth the contract. And yes he was bad the last two games even when the situation was fine on some plays, but his situation is way worse than people think. Defense is not playing well at all, O-Line is horrible and he clearly does not trust them, and the play calling and play design is atrocious In this offense. I think this is a slump that will be fixed by improving the O-line and cleaning out the coaching staff. People just forget how well he has played since his second season but COMPLETELY forget that bc of the contract. People want any reason to hate on him, it's ridiculous.
His stats are compatible to Daniel jones and he gets paid more … he’s mid and being paid like a top dog
I think elite is a bit of a stretch. Good football, definitely. I would not go as far as to say elite. And is it all on him? No. Most of it isn't on him. This team fucking sucks. The defense has regressed, the offense is stagnant with bad playcalling, they still want to have this ridiculous hope that Evan Engram and Christan Kirk are some elite receivers. And Davis has been a bust for them. But at the same time, when is enough enough? He looked terrible in 2021. Looked bad to start 2022. It looked bad to end 2023, and looks terrible to start 2024. Is it all on him? No. But you are paying him 270 MILLION DOLLARS. You'd hope he'd make a bit more of something out of nothing. Especially as a number 1 overall pick. Tom Brady made his career out of playing with mediocre pass catchers. Patrick Mahomes just won the Superbowl with Marquez Valdez Scantling and Kadarius Toney. I'm sorry but honestly what the fuck is the difference at this point between Trevor Lawrence and Mac Jones? You want to talk about recency and hindsight bias, if Trevor Lawrence was named John Smith he isn't getting a 5 year extension and more than likely is looking for a new team. But because he is Trevor Lawrence and was a god in college, we need to hold out insane hope that he's going to make this massive leap. When? When is it coming? Please tell me. Cause honestly you could give him Tyreek Hill and Justin Jefferson and I'm not sure how much is going to change. How is he any different than Tua? Or Brock Purdy? Or Jared Goff? Or any of these middle of the road quarterbacks.
@@jcore0981yeah his best games were far from elite. But he's been at best a top 12-15 QB.
Bruh. He’s trash. Accept it. We were told he was the future face of the NFL and Daniel jones had better numbers.
Tlaw is a bust and will be a career backup in 3-4 years.
T law is overrated trash 🚮
I think with Richardson you can’t teach what he can do which is launch a ball over the moon. But I think you can help him with his short game and decision making.
As a new york giants fan i think giants are gonna use dj as a bridge to the new qb in this draft (hopefully cam ward) but i think he will still start next year so they can have their rookie watch first i dont want to ruin a qb like everyone else
The biggest problem the bears fans have are over hyping every single QB they get. Just take a breath and hope for something good but those rookie qbs that have a great season are rare.
These aren’t panic rankings these are cope rankings
Caleb just showed improvement in a win against the Rams, I think he'll be okay so long as he stays healthy.
The 2022 performance against the Chargers was more of an indictment on Brandon Staley than it was a good performance for T Law. He’s been mid to downright bad for most of his career with a few elite/teasing moments to keep fans roped in.
To be fair to Williams he has way worse coaching. If Daniels had to play for Flus and the OC he'd also look like he was unsure and unready. Same with Mahomes. If he was in Chicago he'd never have any success and bust out totally since he was developed very well under Reid.
Tennessee sticking by Levis is a red flag. It's one thing to throw picks as a young player, but Levis makes decisions that high schoolers know better on. I feel like the message is to NOT jump at QBs in the draft. Draft the best player available, OR build your interior and then expand to skill guys. Look at Vikings with Darnold. The guy is now balling out because Minnesota has a real team.
Levis hasn't even played 14 games. The games he's played have been behind a bottom 2 offensive line. I'd be more alarmed at Richardson and Lawrence tbh.
It just looks bad right now because he took a loss to the QB (Malik Willis) that the Titans passed on for him.
More alarmed at Richardson who is 3 years younger and has played like 20 games since high school?
Exactly his bias is showing HARD rn.
5:28 I don’t think removing one game to make DJ look better is the right way to look at it. By that logic, remove 2/4 games. Then remove 3/5 if he continues to be terrible. That’s ridiculous.
No - he should be graded out of 100% like everybody else. If we’re going to remove on game, then is he 100% legit if we’re counting 66 or 75% of his games? Sure. But who counts like that?
You know those expansion Browns teams were bad when a fan's favorite player was Tim Couch
Should’ve talked about Bo Nix
That clip of the Browns fan laughing at NY and Daniel Jones is so funny knowing the Giants beat them.😂
Guys like Will Levis, if you fix the bone head moments, which is very likely to happen since it's his 4th week into his career, then you have a far less terrible looking rookie start. And most rookies don't start great, like Mahomes first games. He wasn't a world beater and he also didn't get thrown right into the fire like a lot of these rookie QBs are. It is so, so hard to know how a QB will do because it can depend so much on the factors outside of their own talent.
Daniel Jones and Trevor Lawrence also have the same record in the playoffs, 1-1 😭🙏
to be fair, Trevor Lawrence is suffering from The Terrible Towel Curse.
So many bad numbers that are worse than what Zach Wilson was doing behind a historically bad o-line. Hope to see Zach starting again soon.
Teams just feel it’s best to get a QB out playing early where they can evaluate him and only lose rookie money if they decide to get rid of him.
When bears want to a draft a qb and they're sure they have their man, they should have someone in the organization whose only job is to switch the names and draft the other guy. Might be better.
Jayden Daniels has a Teddy Bridgewater feel. Great talent but soooo skinny. I don't think he'll last.
I wouldn’t say that had been the whole Watson story so far this season. There’s been some other stuff.
The Colts showed me that they shouldn't be putting all that pressure on AR5 by only letting him throw the ball 4 times in the 4th quarter against Chicago... We're going run the ball alot and use AR5 sparingly to elevate the pressure off him
I was wondering if Hurts would be on here, if he's not, does that mean I don't have to panic?
Just traded a 1st and McCarthy for Daniels since Tlaw has had such a low floor he’s looking more like my qb3 in dynasty
Trevor Lawrence would shine on a better team.
How is fields not included. Need someone to tell me how to feel about him. PLEASE
Smart… or rather average intelligence Colts fans aren’t panicking just yet with AR (injuries aside). We understand this is essentially his rookie season and he was literally drafted with the thought of “this is a project QB”. (AKA be patient with him) Why would you start packing 4 games into what is more or less a rookie season? Now if we’re including injury concerns in the discussion… having some amount of panic is more understandable.
300 yard, 35 point back to back games, 3 win streak and on a bye week 7 Chicago and Caleb aren't worried
@@ellislegato2238 Yeah, I think Chicago is going to be very happy with Caleb Williams.
@@footballdoesntmatter even if he squeeks out 3-4 more wins that's better than fields ever did in Chicago since Bagent won a couple last season
NFL teams thinking Bama is a QB factory under Nick Saban has been the greatest fleece. Young and injury prone Tua is the antithesis of this. So glad Jalen Hurts got out when he did. It going to be interesting what Jalen Milroe can do vs Georgia.
You’re absolutely correct on Watson. Browns fans defending him is looking more and more like Stockholm syndrome every day. WE GET THE OLINE IS HURT, WE GET THE RUN GAME IS WEAK. It’s like you said, he is simply not good enough to be worth the trade, and that is going to mean that this window has been sealed shut for the Browns.
One of my favorite hobbies over the past few years has been to anger hopefuls and memers alike by arguing that Daniel Jones is mid. Glad to see I'm not alone.
Also my fever dream is to see the Pats get Will Levis (Coach Mayo, it has to happen) and see them trot out the Dollarback formation of the future with him, Brissett, Maye, and Milton in the same backfield. Someone has to do this in Madden at least. Milton in that formation would be a hoot as the tailback. Dude's built like Cam Newton, and, given his preseason performance, when I heard that he claimed to be able to throw the ball 95 yards, I believed that.
so you anger people that say Jones is good by saying Jones is mid? Not sure what you are saying.
Going into week 6 Jones is 11th in QB and 12th in passing yards.
Just a month ago everyone was saying celab williams was special and was gonna be the best qb of all time .
I never understood the trevor lawrence hype from the very beginning. I've always told everyone he sucks.
where is bo nix? like ik he looked good last week but id like to know what you think about him.
I mean we've seen that T Law is clearly a great QB, the problem is in coaching tbh
Blows my mind that Lawrence got a pay day like that
After the Cowboys vs. Giants game, it’s clear that Daniel Jones isn’t the issue. That offensive line is just terrible. 281 yards in a loss where Dak had less yards on 2 TD’s is all you needed to see.
Richardson should probably be higher... he is bad... like awful bad
he's not awful, not yet lol
Joe Flacco went there for a reason
He's only heading into his eighth career start.
He's played like. 7 games.
@myaheadhurts2 and he still looks raw. He has had 1.25 seasons of development at the NFL level and hasn't shown much better trait. Overall Trevor Lawerence, Daniel Jones, and Watson all have better stats than him. The only excuse is his "potential" which is funny because potential means nothing if you can't develop. Look at Toney lol
I think Richardson deserves to be a little higher. His lack of progress in improving his accuracy is deeply concerning. We keep saying "If he clicks" but the guys decision making does not resemble that of a second year NFL quarterback. He seems to play with a "Fuck it, we ball" mentality where hes tossing the ball out there with a prayer. For a team with the offensive weapons set like the Colts, there are a lot of Quarterbacks that would would make them into a winning team, or at least a much stronger offense. Richardson is running out of excuses IMO. He at least needs to be higher than Daniel Jones, who is at least making the Giants offense watchable, and getting the ball to his receivers on plays that I honestly don't think Richardson would make.
Titans fans get ready for the Rudolph chants. He can save your season
Andy Dalton wasn’t brought in as a starter. Big difference between Zack Wilson and Aaron Rodgers situation.
I think they know they're in a situation where they're heavily invested in Young just from the draft piucks trade to get him. They say him at just week 2 so he can use this season to sit behind a veteran QB like he should have done his rookie season. So they put him out there to see if he could handle it, he couldn't, so they're sitting him behind a veteran QB like every other young QB that's succeeded. Peterson isn't stupid and it's VERY OBVIOUS that trotting a QB out his rookie season is a recipe for disaster. CJ Stroud is a very very very rare anamoly.
Why are these rookies being rushed out onto the field in their first year? Doesn't anyone train their QBs any more? The greatest QBs had a year or two or three on the bench before they started. Even if a QB has a good first year, they often regress, and that's not an emergency! This short attention span analysis is not good for anyone. A college QB cannot be expected to do well in the NFL.
What about Tua in Miami?
watching justin fields lead the steelers to a 3-0 record is amazing. just more proof that it’s not all on the bears qb’s. they have horrible personnel to pair with rookie qbs. probably the worst situation for a rookie qb in the league
@@rickysoup they CANT develop QBs, never could
"Lead". He's looked good, but the steelers defense has only allowed 26 points in 3 games. Most recent game was his best, but he's put up good numbers before and then stumbled like the Packers game at the end of last year.
Better this year!
I think it is early to judge if Fields is a top QB. Pittsburgh is only asking him not to lose the game, their D will keep them in any game. Remember, Trubisky stank it up in Chicago, and then stank it up in Pittsburgh. J Fields is off to a good start and I wish him well, but it is a long season.
Malik nabers is stuntin on the league rn
How is Tua not on, let alone near or at the top of the list? The fins JUST paid a guy who literally can not ever get hit or it tanks their year, and can’t beat good teams when healthy.
Liked the video, but I don't know why you would cherry pick with Jones. That's his entire issue, at times he looks competent, then other times he looks like child who wandered onto the field. If he could avoid the bad streaks he'd be pretty ok...but he can't.
The only reason why Williams has any trouble is the way he was sold as a finished product. The Bears illustrate that “weapons” don’t matter if the offensive line isn’t addressed.
If Daniels keeps putting himself in position to get lit up he will be RG4. Slide, go out of bonds please. I don’t want to see history repeat.
Richardson is a high school QB.
Levis definitely isn’t worth running Vrabel out of town. Dude needs to learn a sack isn’t the worst thing in the world
A coach really needs to understand the players they end up with. To see Sam Darnold rise from the dead and look like a hero in purple is a perfect example of players ending up in a system the coaches can't make work. Peyton Manning had 2 back to back 3-13 seasons before going 13-3 in his 3rd season.
PS. I've seen many Browns fans go through some stuff. I was a Colts fan for decades before I moved to KC in 07. Ya'lls ownership sucks as hard as suck can suck. I'm glad Baker Mayfield escaped. Flacco looked comfy in a Colts uniform. WTF is the C suite doing?
5:08 - "if you take out the bad games he's good". Cherry-picking simply doesn't provide a compelling narrative or any insightful analysis, it's just a slippery slope.
any week three analysis is going to have small sample bias. But if he looks good in 2 of three games., that's a reason not to panic. A more fair comparison would be to toss out 1 bad game from all the QBs. and see where he rates.
Did I miss Bo Nix?
Anyone who is hyperventilating about Lawrence is not watching jags games. The guy has no o-line and the play calling is leaning on the run game. Like how is this guy supposed to succeed under these conditions
If the DL isn't expecting passes, play action should be effective. Sure the total yardage might not be wonderful, but his passer rating should be fine.
Not Russell Wilson levels bad?? At least the Broncos traded for a weirdo QB and not a WEIRDO QB
How can someone regress off of a 2 and a half game sample. AR was never good
Purdy is the guy yeah lot of guys throwing under 300 yds & many ints.
if the bears had taken mahomes he would have sucked and probably would have been out of the nfl by now. the qb gets a lot of credit/blame but really the coaching and team have WAY more to do with the results than the qb's talent.
Stop watching because you have ads run every 2 mins
If you couldn’t see their colors, young and Watson look the same, the way they play. Less than desirable footwork, uncomfortable in the offense.. like they look like the same person.