ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- 'Pragaash' means light or illumination. Are we really showing the band members of the Kashmir's all-girl band the light, or driving them into darkness in the name of religion (Audio in Hindi)
Watch full show: khabar.ndtv.com...
This is how a discussion on TV should happen on sensitive issues lots of respect for Ravish sir . And he hasn't changed a bit 😁😄 in 2019 as well
आज पहली बार मैं ब हसीयते मुसलमान रविश जी ये कह रहा हुं के आज के दौर में उलेमा अपने पर्सनल गुस्से को कौम पर थोपते खुरान व हद्दीस का हवाला देकर
@@AfzalKhan-uw2qh
Grt.
Boht kam log hote h jo majhabi baton se upr kuch soch-samajh paate.
💞
Thanks to Ravish Kumar for Kargil war
@KERALA TIGER these were not songs.songs means poetry which makes a man lover of world and attract them toward womens. sufis had written poetry which was only to attract people and to make them love to Allah
Wah, kya sensitive issue pe discussion ho rha hai, aur ye dusro jo gyan dete firte😂.
Arnab goswami should watch and learn how to conduct a debate. Respect Ravish kumar
Exactly.
Abe panel v chillane wala h, uske yha to panel v chor h sale
Babar sale mugal ki nazayaz aulad
...tujh jaise atanwadi ke pille ki aukat nhi h advice dene ki
No need. Only pseudo seculars ,communist, Congress they like ravish .
Arnav goswami is the best reporter
proper homework for all the issues is best Quality of ravish kumar...
Totally logical debate. That's why I respect this man🙏🏻
हिंदू, यहूदी या ईसाई धर्म के बारे में बहस क्यों नहीं करते? दुनिया भर में इस्लाम धर्मका बहस क्यों है? मैं इस्लाम की प्रथा को देखकर हैरान हूँ!
@@plaintruth7503 kyu ke sab jante he ke islam hi sachha mazhab he ,islam itna achha mazhab he ke
logo ko samaj me ajaye to vo muslim ho jaye,or problem vahi he sare logo ko ke log hamare dharm ko chhod denge or islam qubul kar lenge
@@plaintruth7503 samje bro
@@lordleader5186 but agar sabhi log yahi sochne lge toh Dharam chorega kaun vaise Islam I feel is too strict , there is a need of liberalizing the practices.
There is no logic in Ravish . He used many logical fallacies . On of it was Bismillah khan is a musician .
So what .
Loved the way discussion progressed, if it was any other channel, they may have stared screaming on each other.
That Maulana clearly said that there is no room for discussion on this topic at least not on TV and Ravish ji gave up too soon.😂
Now imagine Hindu Brahmin saying the same on Ram Temple issue.. just imagine how would Ravish ji react to that? Constitution khatre mei hai, screen kala, desh bachaao... Fatwa is clearly a act of crime we don't need discussions over that. See the hypocrisy, open your eyes.
Crazy Cosco
According to u..
U support bhakts...BJP..
Uneducated pm..MODI.
Most jahil personality ever seen...
Circat
right
Hahahaha i had seen same type of debates on this channel as well but these guests were taught some etiquettes by their parents
The best part of this video is keeping respect, and dignity of others. Moreover, everyone talked relative to the topic, rather than Pakistan or hate speech 😎
No, they don't show proper respect to the mufti at all.
You people do first foolish and disrespectful things and expect to discuss with you in these things with respect....no respect to your bullshit..simple straight answer
@@aboltabol666 he is not respected person why should a jih@di be respected
Hail Md.Rafi, Bismillah Khan, AR Rahman etc. and every artist in the world.
Ar Rahman is not born muslim
@@iamray112 it doesn't matter ! he chose the path and he is Muslim
@@Nishattfatimaa. lol, but why is he still singing and composing music. It’s haram
@@icecreqlrrt8854 bro Ik it's haram but it's his choice and at the end it's Allah who choose and indeed he is the one who knows what's in everyone's heart.
@@iamray112 why did he converted?
Such a calm debate😅 koi bhauk hi nahi raha😂😂😂 other media channels take some inspiration from ravish sir😇
Correct!
@@alivingbeing6996 Absolutely agree!! I am not a Librandu by the way nor a Bhakt, just an Indian with a brain that's in the right place.
Godi Media pm
Right
Sahi kaha bhai
Ye video 2013 ka haii..
Underline it..??
Ravish ji tab bhi Deshahit me partakaritaa karte the aur aaj bhi 2019 me kar rahe hai..
Ye baat isase sabit hoti haii...
Good work Ravish Sir..
ravish Kutta gaddar
Kishor kumar ha aur tu sala desh bhakt. lolll
Kishor kumar a usse kise k certificate k zarurat nhi
HAHA HAHA yes for andh bhakts . its very true.
तो अब क्या ये प्रश्न पूछ पायेगा? अब ये नही पूछता
Oh my god such a calm debate
because its not moderated by cow-swamy of repug-lick tv
oh...so you've verified that Arnab is 'cow-swamy'..hahahahaha
Ravish kitni shanti se que puchh raha hai Mufti se , BUt Yahi Ravish and Media jab kisi Rss or vishva hindu parishad se Pucchte hai to " AAp hote kaun hai aisa bolne vale ? " aapki ki Aukat kya hai ? Because . MUllo se fatati hai ya to TRP ya so called Secularaism
vaibhav kumar REALLY GOOD.
Rajesh Radadia Bhai aisa to ravish Kumar ne Kabhi Nahi Bola jhoot mat bolo😂😂😂Maine ravish Kumar ki saari debates suni hai Kabhi bhi unhone is level p jaake panelists ki bejjati Nahi ki arnab ki tarah
Irony is that biggest muslim country in our subcontinent (Pakistan ) produces one of the best music in this region .
So true
Is there any shariat in pakistan? No
Begum Akhtar (Malik-e-ghazal) and ustad Bismillah Khan
(Best example of Ganga jamuni tehzeeb)
Pehle insan Bano phir Hindu Muslim.
Nusrat sahab ko kaise bhool skte hain.
Hindu ye sab chutiyap nahi krte.. Hindus have always been liberal towards clothing, singing, dancing, womem freedom, etc etc. Hinduo ko beech me laake "farzi secular" mat bno
First of all there is no such thing of 'Ganga Jamuna Tezheeb'
@@Cryboutet sati bhi hindu ritual tha, widow reamarige se sabse jayda katar panti hinduo ko hi takleef thi, do bahut hai ya or example dun.
Sabhi religion main defects hai.
Isle kaha tha pehle insaan bano, fir hindu muslim kar lena.
@@ssm7593 of there is no ganga jamuni tehzeeb now, people like you destroyed it.
I wanted to convert to Islam but after knowing music, dance and all good things are banned in Islam, I banned Islam from my life.
Actually u dont no Nothing about islam..... Do research and compare
Hahhah.....u don't know bro.... read Qur'an once
@@indian1492 shut up I even didnt read Quran I want to read and know the truth about ur prophet. Jo tumhare prophet ko napasand hota thaa usse wo Allah we jodkar keh dete thee Haram hai ye Hanna ye painting sabb Haram hai , shukr hai tumhare prophet be ye nahi khaa ke sans(breathing) Lena bhee Haram hai .
Other mainstream media channels should learn from Ravish sir as how to conduct a debate. Massive respect to you sir🙂
Jay shree ram
@@aarjun6839 Jai Shree Ram Bhai
Bharat mata ki jay
Vande mataram
Inklab zindabaad
रवीश कुमार इस वेरी नाइस पत्रकारिता चाहे वह हिंदू हो चाहे मुस्लिम चाहे कुछ कोई भी हो निष्पक्ष होकर बोलता है भाई
If we don't discuss each others religion then there's no point in having Multi Religious society.
उस जमाने मे चश्मा भी नहीं था। क्यों पहन रखा है?
Science aur nach gane me farq hai
@@tasleemraza5697 prophet dawood ka naam suna h
Allah ne unko music dia
Thoda dekho
@@tasleemraza5697 science ka kya bhai guitar koi science ne thodi diya vo to instrument h jo ab h
Phle sitar or ek tara the
Sir ji sangeet kyu ban he wo janane ki kosis kro islam me bs ek Allah ki ebadat krnaa he aur jo gangitkar hote he wo apni sangeet ke madhyam se khuda ki tauhin krte hai ek masuka ke liye es liye ye baate sahi nhi he hamare ulema gairjajuri batate he khair agr apko sari baate janna hi he ache se sangeet ban ke baare me to DM Kijiye jarur apko kuch acha hi sikhane aur sikhaane milega kuch aap jankari denge kuch ham naki bebuniyadi bahes
@manjeet singh galat shabdo ka upyog mt kro yr aao apko batata hu Allah aur islam kyaa he apka no. Adrrss share kro sab jankaari apko apke ghr tak pahucha kr milega mgr galat shabdo upyog mat kijiye agr koi apki izzat krta he to aap bhi kro uski izzat kyo aur rahi baat badmaashi ki ap apne baap bolte ho yaa apke elake sabhi mardo ko baap bolte ho eska jawab thoda soch kr do janab aur han detail jarur share kro apko sabhi prakar ki daut clear krne ki puri kosis krenge
Right way of debate...very good Ravish.
Aajkal Ke sabhi channel pe debate kam Faltu ki bakwas, shouting hote hain.
Lockdown me dekh rahe ravish sir is always best....Allah aapke Dil me Hidayat de Aameen
Internet is also haram , tv is also haram , then why you use loudspeaker to irritate other
Jay shree ram
@@ritamnandi7933 If you don't know Anything abt Islam, so please just clear your doubts first. These Are some common questions like Why Allah created Haram things, Why Allah gave birth to His non-believers. Quran is book Of signs, not science.
@@ritamnandi7933 This shows your lack of knowledge in each and every era. So just take some knowledge first. If you want to me to make you understand then let me know, Otherwise I am not gonna waste my words on you.:)
@@ritamnandi7933 What if I prove God exists logically.?? And heaven and hell are there?
This type of debet is a tight slap on the face of that "Nation wants to know " type people .
Also tight slap for all the women's rights
@@Leo-ki2iywhat a reply
Naushad ali, Rafi sahab, sajjad husain, Khayyam, pt. Bismilla khan, Sahir Ludhiynavi, Abeda parveen, Gulam Ali, Sarod player Amjad ali khan, javed Akhtar, Javed ali, A R Rahman , Zakir Husain...........Aur kitne naam ley.. we all love these legends.
Yeh kaisa fatwa h jismen sangeet nahin
Sangeet aur gana bajana hi to JINDAGI h guru nanak g ke sath mardana Rabab bajata tha bina band baaje singing ke shadi nahin hoti Akbar k navratanon
Men Tansen raag malhar gaa kar barish ka deta tha jungle k hiran bhi uske sangeet sunane k liye dourhe aate the dairy forming wale pashuon ko geet sunakar jaida dudh paate hain
Jslamba370
rahat fateh ali aur uska baap chhut raha hai bhai
Arre bhai sangeet khud upar wale ne hi banaya hai....................warna kisi insaan mein itna dum kaha ki woh saat suro ka invent karde?
Hinduism aur buddhism toh meditation ka source maante hai music hai
ISLAM DHARAM KI NAZAR ME WO SAB HARAM KAMAYI KAMATE HAI
Respect ravish sir ji respect and valid point from you and hillal Ahmed ,this is how a discussion or debate should happen not like how so called media does
Music is Haram in one word....
Nasheed is halal if it's without music, only Dafli can be added... Moreover the lyrics shouldn't have any shameless or nudity in it.. Only then it's halal.
میرا کینٹ بھی پڑھ لیجئے گا۔ شکریہ
Chal chutiye..
A big thing of Shame is a clean shaved man is arguing against a mufti who is dressed according to sunnat..
Ek fasiq e maulin jiska sirf naam musalmano ki tarah hai woh mufti sahab se behes kar raha hai
Music haram hai haram haai haram hai wo gaana jo instruments ke sath gaya jaata hai usko Rafi gaaye chaahe bismillaah khan gaaye wo inlogo ke gaane se jayaz hargiz nahi ho sakta
Shariat sab pe hujjat hai wo koun hai jo shariat pe hujjat ho maazAllah
Aur Nabi karimﷺ ki aamad par ek baa daff bajaya gaya lekin uske baad kahin par daff ya kisi aur musical instrument ka bajana saabit nahi balki farooq e azam radiAllahu anh ke aate hi un daff bajane wali ladkiyo ne apni dafliyo ko chhupa liya tha ye bhi riwayaat me maujood hai
Jisko kapde utaar kar naachne ka ban kare wo naache lekin apni be hayayi ko islam se na jode
This was quite an intriguing debate for Atheists.
In my POV anything that gives happiness (not harming body or peace of society) shouldn't be banned in any religion.
Depends if your present happiness wont compromise with your future one
@@darimtiyaz3093 present happiness is the only thing that matters 😌
Drinking is not harmful to others or peace of society, so that means it should not get banned?
@@hussainadnan8248 No. It shouldn't be banned. Anything being consumed within the 4 walls of someone's residence should be of no concern of the government or any other political or religious party provided it doesn't harm anyone else or peace of the society.
@@kdaahri6857 sorry but I personally think that alcohol and drugs harm our body, and consuming something that harms our body and knowing it is a sin. Such as, suicide is haram. Why? Cuz Allah created us and our beautiful lives and we have no right to end it. Only Allah does. ♥️
आज पहली बार रविश कुमार के लिए दिल में इज्जत बनी।
I am happy nobody shouted atv each other n treated each other with respect
Everything was sponsored and scripted
They might not scream but they're definitely a bunch of people who'd disintegrate society.
Koi aapki mummy ko "aunty aapki maa ka" boley toh hoga toh woh galat hi.. Ye log bhi waise hi hain
Ravish Kumar is more interested in Muslims appeasement than women's rights
@@saurabhsinghtomar9016 🤣what?
@@Cryboutet my brother, are you dreaming?
When Prophet Muhammad went from Mecca to Yathreb ( old name of Madina ) ladies of Madina sang to welcome song with Duf for prophet .
Singing is not a crime in Islam
If it is we muslim doesn't sing Azaan, Naath
Singing is very broad topic. Singing can be vulgar, it can be with music, it can be ladies doing lot of nudity. So if they sing only praising only Lord with only exception of Duff then it's allowed...
Wht about classical songs,n differnt rag or folk or traditional song ,Sufi songs
Here should be Mufti menk he could explain them more clearly
Zakir Naik Or Mufti Tariq Masood from Pakistan.MTM is the most intelligent guy ever
Hmein v log kaisi kaisi nazar se dekhte h k gaane gaati h ...halanki hmein v Islam k baare mein pata h but Kya apna shauq kuch v nhi
or nouman ali khan or shiekh yasir qadhi they are literally awesome.
i think he was under pressure. mag allah guide us all
I was going to suggest the same thing
सच यही है कि इस्लाम में संगीत मान्य नही है, दुख यह है कि ज़रूरत के हिसाब से लोग मज़हब का इस्तेमाल करते हैं, और जानकार उसे घुमा फिरा के सही भी ठहरा देते हैं।
But brother ... Time k sath sath religion ko bhi update hona chaiye ...
Islam me Sangeet Nahi ye tum dawa kaise kar sakte ho debate suno daf bazaya Gaya hai
100%
@@nipungupta5819 ab woh hm toh nahi kr skte inhe hi krna hai , Hassan nissar Saab ke zaban me - science and technology inhe rondh ke Chali jayegi.
I am a Muslim and I enjoyed watching Ravish Kumar's interview
This is your position.
U hav to tell u r Muslim. If u proud to be a Muslim. Keep u r original name.
@@mohammedzameer477 It's my original name. 😅
@@hunter_dal kiya aap bhi sangeet ko ya ravish ji ke is entrviu ko support karti he
@@rashidistudio4438 Assalamualaikum Janab. Mai Mr. Ravish aur inke chanel ko support karta hu kyuki agar Aap koi aur news channel kA debate dekhoge toh jis tarike se cheek kar aur chillakar saamne wale ki aawaz daba dete hai aur channel per aaye mehman ko baato Mai zalil Kiya jaata hai. Ravish jee ke debate Mai kabhi aap yeh nahi dekhoge. I think yeh journalism ka sahi tarika aur debate Karne ka Islam ke mutabik sahi tarika hai. Rahi baat music ki..toh daf bajana halal hai aur Mai iss view point ko support karta hu.
Bahut bahut meharbani aapki hinduo par 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Huge Respect for Anchor... Huge Respect.. Talking about discussion in a polite Manner it's much harder that anything... Other Media must learn from him...
what is worng with ... these... jahil mufties.. why don't they follow correct sharya.. of understanding the case ... n then checking hadith n Quran... before giving answers(fatwas)
if they don't know, why cannot they say .. we don't know..
sahi hi mufti ban ke baithe hi aur choti si baat ka jawab nahi de pa rahe hi
they said they don't know about the issue itself, the first speaker even said didn't listen to the girl band also, but coming for a debate without knowing what they need to talk about is useless..
Hinduism is great........Sati......pratha, bal vivah ko nikala..........government ne use legely Ban...kiya..........we change with time,we dnt leave 10K years back changing is truth....
Sati pratha and bal .vivah social ...issues the .......prr in cheezon ka koi ...zikr ni ha ....hindu scriptures ....ma
Singing song is prohibited in islam, listening music is also prohibited in islam, playing guitar, drams , also prohibited. And about rafi sahab he was a singer. He also did wrng n rest of the muslims singers thy also wrng . N even muslims actors. Thy r also doing wrng . Its not allowed in islam. Haan Singing is allowed. but with out music, n its only on praising allaha N our Prophet Mohammed . Azan is for calling to the people's to gather in one place to perform the prayer s ...for 5 times in a day .. if u want 'go n check the azan meaning s .... Singing is allowed in islam only for Naat ,hamd, only allowed for praising allaha n Prophet Mohammad . Not any other thgs ..
Drinking is also prohibited
Killing is also prohibited but you guys do eat meat and drink
So stop being a Muslim because you are not
Chutiye log
@@adityashandilya3238 drinking alcohol is prohibited... Killing innocent human is prohibited
yeh post neeche se copy ki gai hai Abhishek bhai ka thanks:- एक मुस्लिम एक बस में चढ़ा और उसने ड्राईवर से अनुरोध किया कि बस में बज रहे पाश्चात्य संगीत को तत्काल बन्द कर दे. ड्राईवर ने कारण पूछा तो उसने
कहा कि इस्लाम के अनुसार संगीत सुनना हराम है क्योकिं प्यारे नबी के समय संगीत नहीं था और विशेष रूप से पाश्चात्य संगीत तो बिलकुल नही.
ड्राईवर ने विनम्रतापूर्वक रेडियो बन्द कर दिया, बस का दरवाज़ा खोला और मुस्लिम को बस से नीचे उतर जाने का निवेदन किया. उसने कारण पूछा तो ड्राईवर ने विनम्रता से उत्तर दिया ---
"देखो भाईजान प्यारे नबी के समय कोई टेक्सी नहीं थी, कोई बस नहीं थी, कोई बम नहीं थे, हवाई जहाजों का अपहरण करने वाले नहीं थे, मस्जिद में शोरगुल मचाने वाले लाउडस्पीकर नहीं थे, कोई आत्मघाती हमले नहीं होते थे, RDX, असला, बारूद नहीं था, AK-47 नहीं थी, सर्वत्र केवल अमन और शान्ति थी अतः चुपचाप नीचे उतर जाओ और अपने गंतव्य तक पहुँचने के लिए ऊँट का इन्तजार करो...😂😂
Many thanks ravish ji for this debate. The way of discussion was clear & easy to understand. The video was not entirely uploaded so questions remain to answered from the representatives but there was one thing which is giving every answer of question. I found some solutions.
Thank you so much ravish ji & ndtv.
We need intelligent youth for our country
Hum sariyat k dayre me rehna chahiye Aalim sahab aapko salam Aapke jazba ko salam jb ye koum gumrah Hoti h to aap Humare Rehnuma bn ke Khadhe hote h
Allah bless you
See but the problem is when a muslim boys or men sings form bands , do shows no maulvi or Mufti cares to give fatwa. But when a muslim girl do the same many fatwas pour in. Why this double standard. Either you speak with equal force against things which is not permitted in Islam to both the genders or none. There are many muslim men in Kashmir who has band and sings , no one give fatwa?
No one give fatwa on corruption, against murderers, Terrorist etc which really impact others but give on singing, dress-up etc which doesn't disrupt peace in society.
Imagine India as a Islamic country. With those mufti making sanvidhan.
Well reason why i am your fan because you keep it simple and straight . and yes mera pass itna eilm nahi hai par haan har cheez par fatwa dene wale kabhi kabhi sirf islam nahi apnei faide bhi dekhte hi.
Namir Ashraf singing with music haram 98% scholer agree in these matter
Singing haram hai musalman ho QURAN padho hadees padho
@@nizamchaudhary2363 I want to ask u why.
@@DivyaSharma-kv2re islam me singing is liye haram hai jab insan koch gata hai ya sonta hai to apne banane wale ko bhol jata hai music ek aisa problam hai jo insan ki soch ko bechain karta hai real me aisa koch nahi hota islam me khabo khayalon me jina nahi hai real life me rehne wala insan right hai logon ne apne income ke liye start kiya hai music sonne se mind hang ho jata hai music me sokon nahi hai us ishwar ko jis ne hame banaya hai uske age jhokne se sokon milega
@P Sarmah thanks dear kash main hamesha QURAN padh sakta lekin dunya ke kaam bhi karna padta hai mera entertainment martail art hai songs son ke rona hasne ke liye main dunya me nahi aya ho marne ke baad apne karmon ka hisab bhi dena hai movie dekh kar log wrong track par ja rahe hain dhoka dena rape chori jhot har crime log movie dekh kar hi sikhte hain
The music or song which takes you away from Allah that is Haram.
allah is very selfish then
Luv the way this discussion is held, a healthy discussion...huge respect to Ravish for asking tough questions....and other muslim reporter giving good arguments...
Very sensible talk, they're listening to each other, respecting, calmness. Great journalism by Ravish kumar.
Ravish kr. is such a excellent & knowledgeable reporter, he can tackle the conversation very well 👍
peaceful talk show 👍
Great Ravish sir you deserve respect 😊😊😊😊😊
Allah is the most accepting ✨!! Bhagwaan hai woh. Unko toh bas apne har bache , bachi ya bachon ki khushi dekhni hai✨♥️. Unko hamaari khushi se etraaz nahi hai✨. Allah ko hamaari personal zindagi se koi problem nahi hai. Woh hamaari har baat ko nazaraandaz kar ke hamare ko khush karne ki koshish karte rehte hai. Allah ho Akbar ✨
@BHAGWAN atheist abbey sun!! IDC AND IDK WHAT GOD IS TO U!!! But for me alll gods r one and they accept me just the way Iam!! Aur sun bhai agli baar kuch bhi likhne se pehele soch liyo!! Tujhko kya pata hai ? HAR INSAAN KE LIYE FAITH AUR BHAGWAAN KA MATLAB ALAG HOTA HAI!!
@BHAGWAN atheist abbey gaali kyu de raha hai ?!! Nah toh mujhe aise insaan se kuch samjhana hai na toh use kuch samjhaana hai jo yahi nahi understand kar raha ki alag logon ke liye faith alag hai ✨
Being a Muslim girl I feel so much secured because of my islamic rules
😂😂😂😂
🤪🤪🤪
😂😂😂😂😂
phir burkha pahana chhod do...itana hi secure lagta hai to....🤪🤪🤪
@@shivamtudu5353 burqa pahn na sa hi secure lagta hai.
Yes , Duf bajana jaiyaj hai but others singing instruments bajana jaiyaj nehi hai . It is true .
Ravi sir I respect u.....u r very intelligent....but u don't select good scholar to satisfy u
Right bro
Sadie Ahmed I agree
Ravishji I respect you because you are a true person either you have by mistakenly choosen wrong person for this debate.
I request you to kindly visit deoband school (Madarasa)
and put this question to them including any other such question in your mind
I can challenge you if not your mind your heart will accept each and everything dot of Islam.
@RKA oh angrez ki aulad agaye.ok mister bhopali think what you like we dont care because we know that we are on right path given by our greatest master the creater.plenty of kings queens gone who used to deny islam and for that every single one of you disbelieving unfaithful ungrateful creatures your last place has been marked already which is HELL.
a good scholar can only be an atheist or agnostic.
Raza Khan i am hindu i will surely go to hell.
Ustaad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan
The man who made a musical revival is a Muslim.
Art is God and religion can never dominate the almighty.
Here, then, is Ambedkar on Islam:
"Hinduism is said to divide people and in contrast Islam is said to bind people together. This is only a half-truth. For Islam divides as inexorably as it binds. Islam is a close corporation and the distinction that it makes between Muslims and non-Muslims is a very real, very positive and very alienating distinction. The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity. The second defect of Islam is that it is a system of social self-government and is incompatible with local self-government, because the allegiance of a Muslim does not rest on his domicile in the country which is his but on the faith to which he belongs. To the Muslim ibi bene ibi patria [Where it is well with me, there is my country] is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin."
Bitter Truth quran says if u kill one innocent people u kill the whole humanity nd if u save one innocent people u save the whole humanity after this u don’t get this than pls don’t blame Muslims its not our fault but u are incapable to tackle the truth
Bitter Truth prophet muhammad said love your country die for your country nd follow the law of contry where u live but if the laws against the Islamic law than u can struggle for your right.not a single country in this world says raping a girl is right nd in islam punishment for rape is death.every country May have their own rule nd regulation but they cant convert lies into truth
heena parween Aiysha and Muhammad 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@Mirza GalibWhere is the proof of your allah?
Ravish Kumar.. If u want ur answers try calling mufti menk.. I hope they will clear all ur doubts
@Abhisakh Malick Islam sharia is there soo women are safe no toh tumhare rule se chalenge toh.. Shorts mai apni bheno ko ghumna... In Islam women place is very high..
And u are saying about babies lol jaise tumare kabhi bache ni hoge.. Grow up.. Atleast read about Islam.. Then question
@@reyanshmalik8999 aur tum begairat log apne soch k saath kisi k v maa behan ko jod do wah,tum apne hisab se jio aur ladkiya tumhare adesh aur tumhari gulami Kar k wah re
@@mannukumar2832 kisi ko gulam ni banate.. Ye. Soch tum andh Bhakt ki hai... Tumhari kisi chiz kisi book reality ya logical nai hai
.. Khud ki book bhi padh lega toh bhi belive ni hoga....
@@reyanshmalik8999 tu kaunsa book padhta hai batayega Jara Jo Bina Jane bhakt bol Gaya asal me tum kattarwad k numainde ho Maine Kya baat boldiya Jo tujhe Michi lagi tu 2sro k upor bol Tere pe koi na bole
@@mannukumar2832 kise manta h tu? Use jo khud ki biwi ko ni bacha sakta.. Hazar janwar ko bhagwan mante jisko khud he marte... Chuhe ko.. Aur cow kahi Mari padi rehti hai.. Elephant ko khud he circus m leke marte.. .. Sense hai kisi ki pet mai se dunia banai hai... Lol.. Ek percent toh sense wali Baat karle
Ravish sir is true secular, liberal journalist who fight against such patriarchy society. So proud of you.
And hello to those religious people, be it Islam, hindu Or any religion, throw out these regressive thought from mind. Open up ur mind and see the world, where it's going? We revolved with time,we stand up today from stone Age, and we should accept all those changes. And I don't know in which world these people wants to live. Life is beyond these quran,geeta and Bible.
totally agreed bro
Huh. When Muslim found at regressing people often mix it with religion to comment so that they don't offend or look speaking against islamic nonsense. But when it comes to Hinduism people became full on fire. This time they just forgot to mention other religion. Hypocrite moron.
Maulvi Saheb is right, there is no room for music in Islam, Islam is a very strict practice, take it or leave it
It has to change with time
Mary payra Nabi S.A.W kay paoun ke matti jaisa b koyi naii ha..
i support you sisters....
i m muslim too
You support what is haram and call yourself a Muslim ?
Suhail Raina,tere baap dada kashmiri pandit they.apne dna ko pehchaan bhai.
Beute. Probakt
Truth Unveiled aage chutiye certi dene .... islam hota na to youtube nahi chal rahe hote .... bakei chala rahe hote
Vikrant Prasad
TH-cam was invented by some muslim Bangladeshi
But it is true these mullahs are holding us back
Iam muslim hamesha main maulana se poochta rehta hoon aise kaise har cheez pe fatve de dete hai apni sonch ko islam ke naam pe logon pe thop dete hai
Islam has produced world level singers like Nusrat ji .. no question of Islam being against Music
Islam ne molvi, mufti ka dictetership hai
Naa woh log sirf direction batane ke liya hai logo ki marzi ke uper hai unko kya karna hai. Mujhe pata nahi ye itne fatve kyu dete hai unko sirf ye batana chayie ki hamari book me kya likha hai 🙄
Sir,with due respect i would like to request u to bring some knowledgeable scholar of islam to ur studio to discuss this type of islamic issue.u may bring mufi maynk,dr zakir nayak and there are many
zakin naik india se bhag gya ....usko bula rhe hai aaa nhi rha ...usko darr hai ki wo mar jyga india aty hi tujhy nhi pta kha
Zakir nayak hahahahahaha lavda mera
EMPIRE GAMING they are kafir jakir naik kafir
Yeah true
Dr. Zakir Naik sir is the best to answer all your Islamic related questions.
Aap ne bilkul sahi likhe masha allah
Dr Zakir Naik bhut jgh glat h
@@archsam7709 kisliye galat hai bata dete to sahi kay aur galat kay malum hota koi bat nahi ab bata do zara
2013 to 2019... Nothing changed.
Ravi sir alot of love and respect from Pakistan
If there is a god, these man certainly has not understands his meaning.
Not these man...It should be this man because these is plural
Kisko kisko lagta hai ki Arnab ko is debate se kuch seekh leni chahiye???
👇
Use samay Airport , Twin tower nhi the. Isare smjhe to like here
एक सार्थक बहस ।रबीश जी पहली मर्तबा मुझे लगा की आपने "अपने सिर्फ मतलब का "चुनाव नही किया ।
धन्यवाद ।
Caller tune me kon sa gana set he 😂 😂
SANJEEV KUMAR
Munni baadnam hui darling tere liye
Ye gana tha !
Saap soongh gya tha is question pr😂😂😂😂
Brother music islam mi totally haram nahi hy bolke ek istelha hy ke aisi music jo apko alha se door karre aur devil ke raste pe le jai wo galat hy like hum music sunne se attract hore alcohol se, relationship with girls or boy, etc it wrong.....but islam is update
Bus us ko samjha ne wale aur samjha ne wale chahiye......
Plz understand the point
Not read the islam in any person or molvi ...... If u want to read the read holy book and prophet SWA life......
@@naazkhan398 thanks for detail .....
Aapke jese ache logo ki bahut jarurat he.....
Music is nowhere disliked in islam , these are misconception created by people who call them selves scholar of Islam and and use sentiments to their benefits. Dawood A.s In the Books of Samuel, Dawood is a young shepherd who gains fame first as a musician, Quran also present similar description
Mufti sahab came without knowing the whole case
Invite someone having full knowledge of the case or inform him about it before calling on panel
Baqi jo haram hai wo to haram hi hai chahe puri duniya hi wahi karne lage
Sach aur jhoot mai yahi farq hai
Y
Sahi baat h puri duniya udaa do bhai tum log .
*Music is prohibited but pakistan becomes the 1st nation to watch most no of porns*
😂😂😂😂😂
infotainment channel lk
Still it is a sin..nd they are committing sins..gunaahgaar tw hr jagah hoty hn na...saari dunya shareef thodhi hy..
There is a difference between Islam and Pakistan. Not all Pakistanis are following Islam even though they are born of Muslim. Follow the religion, not the people.
Kew etna such bolta vai sab.....
@@vikramtete7461 thanks to understand. Nowadays people blaming others religion without knowing
Ravish ji,as per my knowledge on Islam, after hearing this debate,I can say, your guests couldn't reply you perfectly the question which you have asked them.
I agree to that..!!
Hinduism is the best which gives freedom to all for geet, sangeet, bhajan, Kirtan, dance, drama, theatre, entertainment etc. We have shastras on dance, and music. Goddess Saraswati plays veena, Krishna plays bansuri. Shiva does tandav dance. No point discussing this matter with Muslims.
Music is also not haram in Islam.
Nowhere in Quran mentions that music is haram
Music is haram only when it content bad words or which are anti-Islam
@Aurora Chakra I have not seen that flim buddy
Mumtaz Mannan....This idiot doesn't know anything about Quran.
According to islam any acts of shaitan which leads to immoral activities ....eventually...is haram for eg. music attracts wine and alchol, which attracts to dancing which attracts to sexual activities, so yes Music is Haram according to Quran, please read with commentary by Ib ne Taimiah rahmathullalay.
Nothing is haraam if it doesn't hurt or harm anybody, but these things are preached by some haraami's to the innocent peoples to misguide them......
Thank God I'm born as a Hindu.
Thanks a lot God.🙏
If Arnab Goswami add in the conference then? 😂😂
डिबेट मार पिटाई में बदल जाएगी ,अर्नब आ जाएंगे तो
Music is way above religion
Vo mjahb mjhab nhi hota Jo badal nhi sakta waqt k saath ...vo mjhb kis kaam ka
Ravish sir I proud of you
islam me drum allow hai lekin one side drum
hahahahah nice sarcasm
Farji 420 it's true only Dhol
Right
Islam me non Muslim ijad allow hai ki nahi..
Is THIS joke,us samaye jo bhi instruments used hota hoga, Wahi to likha melega.
What do you expect Ing, 🎸
Arnab, Ajith hanumanakkar, Rangana (kannada news anchors) should watch this debate and learn how to conduct a peaceful debate on particular issues.. respect Ravish kumar ❤️
Ravish .....simple si baat hai to interpret religion you dont need any mufti you go to any gentle common hardworking man to get it
Ravish Sir """
Main bhi Muslim hoon par Molana saheb se ye sawal kijiye ?
Islam mein Tasbeer lena mana hai
Toh aaj ke Daur me kisi cheej ka ID banana ho Tab kiya Kare...
Jamane ke sath bhi chalna jaruri hai """
🇮🇳 Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Majbori main picture banwana jaiz h a
ullu ki nasal. RASOOL ALLAH NE KAHA HE KI JAHA RAHO WAHA KE KANOON FOLLOW KARO.
Ajka....Fajar ka Azan ka time kaya he mere bhai......
@@bowwow255 ok...fir..tamil or keral me non Muslim log apni hi bahen ke beti ko shadi kartahe.....toh waha ka Muslim vi ohi karega......
@@sukchand.abusaeed kiya bakrai . kitab khol ke dekh likha kiya he.
इस्लाम धर्म में क्या सही या गलत है ये तो मै नहीं जानता, पर मुझे सूफी संगीत बेहद पसंद हैं।।।।
It is prohibited when it takes u away from your lord.....tujhme rab dikhta hai yara me kya kru....tuhi hi rab tu hi dua...etc ..only except the daf....which do not .
Discussion should be like this.
Anchor should be like this.
Some violent anchors should learn it.
NAREN DAS you mean Arnab Giswami?
First NDTV video i liked.!!!
Calm debate 👏
I think Insaniyat insan ke andar Hoti hai religious ke andar nhi
अरे भाई इस मोलवी को बता दो कि हज़रत दाऊद को अल्लाह ने पूरकशीश आवाज़ दी थी , और वें ड्रम और बांसुरी बजा कर लोगो का मनोरन्जन करते थे !
Wo kisi tarah ka musical instruments nahi bajate the bhai
Bas unki awaaz achchi thi aur us awaaz me jab wo zabur padhte the to sare parinde aur janwar bhi sunne ko aate the
SHAH_Educational Channel ** शाह ** - एजूकेशनल चेनल saboot dikha
@@sallukhan853 is shah educational channel ko ye maloom nahi hai
Ke
hadees me dawood alayhissalam ka zikr hai to usme unke awaaz ke liye jo lafz istemaal hua hai wo mizaamir hai jiska matlab flute hota hai magar usme unke awaz ko flute jaisa surila bataya gya hai aur drum ka zikr hi nahi hai
Flute aur drum bajane ki baat bible me hai bible k according wo drum aur flute bajate the
@@sallukhan853 ye bas kahi internet se padh kr aya hai aur bakwaas kar raha hai ye shah educational channel
You're saying before Mohammad
Ravish sir rocks
Oh really ❓I don't think so. sangeet ki duniya me kai mahan kalakar muslim hain , right❓❓❓
Narrow minded people are all around us. Lot of such stupid ideas are always also around
Wo musalmaan nahi h sirf unka Naam muslim hai Islam aur qraan poori tarah se music aur songs ki permission nahi deta . Aur ek baat qraan aur Islam se musalmaan hai musalman se qran aur Islam nahi 😔
@@kishanmishra1644 well said 👍
Whosoever want Sharia should be send to Afganistan under Taliban rule.
रविश , आपने पहली बार इस्लाम की ग़लत धारणा पर चोट की है । मुफ़्तियों के ग़लत फ़तवों पर सवाल उठाया है ।
बहुत बढ़िया ।
वरना अब तक तो ....
Sorry ravish kumar ji apko dr zakir naik se milna chahiye
@Mirza Galib ; bhul
Sab se pahele mai us hadees ke bare me bolna chata hoon jis ko lekar music ko Islam ka hissa samjha jata hai. Mohammed(s.a.w) Makkah se madina aaye us waqt choti si kuch ladkiye duf bajake Mohammed (s.a.w) ka welcome kare WO us waqt ki baat hai jab Islam abhi puri tarha complete nahi huwa tha. us waqt aur bhi bahoot si chize hallal thi (yane us waqt log bahot se kaam karte the lekin baad me us Ku haraam kardiya gaya Allah ki taraf se) waise hi music bhi isi me shamil hai. Aur aap Ku us ek hadees ke alawa aur koi hadees nahi mile gi jis me music ya dance kiya gaya ho ya koi sahabi ne kiya ho. Ye to sirf Islam me music Ku allow karne ke liye us hadees Ku pakad te hai.
Mufti Sahab se Jawab hi nahi Diya ja Raha:
Aurat ki har ada husn aur khubsurati hai. Usme rukhsar bhi shamil hain aur Awaz bhi shamil hai. Aurat ke husn aur zeenat ki hifazat aurat ke zimme hai.
Sangeet ka ta'alluq Dil ke sukun se hota hai aur Quran sukun ke ta'alluq se kehta hai " ala bizikrillaahi tatmainnul Qulub" means tranquility lies in zikr of Allah only.
So if you are seeking tranquility in any other things your knowledge is limited.
There are many changes in Islamic commandments but we need to see in last phase of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).
The shariat completed before the demise of prophet. Before that many changes are made. For example people used to take wine and came to masjid but later on it was prohibited.
Maulana must do homework before coming to such places.
Sahi bola
Music Islam me bilkul mana hai lekin Islam me riyat hai lekin Islam me music mana dabli aur nagara approve hai
परिवर्तन संसार का नियम है । और ये लोग जड़ हो गए हैं ।
Ravish kumar you are the best👍
This topic is awesome.
How come u feel this topic was Awesome..? Singing is HARAM IN ISLAM U shud know about it