if you are as talented as he and has done everything for this group /company 14 years..(just turned 24 last month) yet mistreated / lack of support by your company ,wouldn't you choose to leave? His company didn't protect him and sabotage his career when the news broke out, any sensible people would did the same as he. I am happy he is free .
he was definitely neglected by fantagio but i think the things that have happened even in the past few days have really shown that he had no desire to leave astro as a group, even if he left fantagio. first and foremost the members never unfollowed each other on social media, which is usually the first thing that happens in this situation. then a few days ago, obros posted a picture of him on instagram in which they mentioned he "loves astro more than anything." in both of his recent public appearances (seoul fashion week and music bank) he is very clearly wearing his astro friendship ring, and when he performed with haww on music bank he was wearing his aroha in-ear. i'm not holding out hope that he'll ever rejoin astro but do think he's trying to tell people that leaving the group, at least, wasn't what he wanted.
EunWoo is just a pretty face, he doesn’t have any real talent. All he can do is model. They were jealous of Moon Bin bc he was full of talent and was the main focal point of Astro. There is no Astro without Bin!!!
@@michelleketelsen4996 I agree .. if they had promoted Moonbin, rocky and MJ more, Astro would have been more popular since they would come out with more good songs and good visual dancing. I am new to Astro but while watching their videos and MVs I never knew rocky was such a good dancer because he was always at the back. Only after reading Aroha’s comments did I come to know he was an excellent dancer. They could have promoted him and MJ more.
He also was not treated or promoted well by fantagio, he did not get many schedules or exposure, and a lot of the things he did, by himself, jinjin too, they both didn't get a lot of activities and would be composing and writing songs instead
another example is that last year for his birthday live, unlike the rest of the group, he was at his studio not at the company building with decorations displayed by the staff, which i always thought was a bit odd
I totally support Rocky's decision! He's too talented and will succeed in whatever he decides to do! I wish Moonbin had done the same and had had proper time to rest and take care of his health, including mental health. He deserved all the best. He worked really hard for the group and consequently for the agency. After watching several videos of the group, IMHO Moonbin was the glue that kept them together. He was warm, friendly, always hugging and comforting another member, always not afraid to express his feelings (like when he wrote on his cell phone that he loved EW or when he, on stage, shouted to EW and the other members that he loved them). It's hard for me to think they will ever be able to get together again, except, of course, for some contractual reasons. Rest in Awesome, Moonbin! Way to go, Rocky! You both did great!!
I predict after Moonbin departure each member of Astro will be quitting, one of the reason Moonbin got into depression is due to Fantagio, so many years with them and he didn’t see a future I’m so sorry he didn’t choose to do as Rocky. I wish all the other guys do the same, move on. Also to me the number one reason they should leave Astro is that Moonbin is a very very hard act to follow sorry guys he was the light of the group.
Totally agree, Moonbin was the soul of Astro , his charm , his charisma, his talent, my dear Moonbin , wish he had leave in 2019 , he will still alive today . Fantagio destroyed him 😢
The guys would be able to move Astro forward if Fantagio didn't continue to insist on promoting Eun Woo as a priority. The way Fantagio acts doesn't help the 4 of them spend time together to create music and dance. Fantagio is dismantling Astro.
I will miss rocky, he was the reason why I stanned astro. But I will continue to support him and the ot5. I hope whatever he does in the future works out for him! I will be watching.
There is definitely a fault of fantagio , they were the one who always gave attention to more popular members than the less popular ones. They won't even promote Astro properly as a group. There are many problematic things in fantagio's management. I hope rocky gets to live the life he always wanted to and prosper in life.!!!♡♡♡
Fantagio never promoted them well as a group. A lot of people say that the company's focus is only on cha eunwoo but NO. the company doesn't even promote him well. With the amount of talent and kind of a band astro is, it could have been extremely popular internationally if promoted well. Best wishes for him and astro. Aroha and pebble forever. Wish he gets to do all he wants to.. the company doesn't deserve him and his talent Anyways
I have no problem with Rocky being in a relationship. Why should this be kept secret, I disagree. I'm a huge fan of the whole group and when they're in love it's only beautiful. Beautiful songs can come out of that, so as far as I'm concerned, they only grow from that. As Aroha, I stand behind the boys no matter what they do. I agree that Fantagio keeps making mistakes. .I hope they will listen more to Astro and the Arohas. I am from the Netherlands and here too we are fans of ASTRO.
Honestly, Rocky always had the most passion for Astro, and I 100% believe he wanted to stay with them as a group but simply couldn't keep working under Fantagio - they've treated him so poorly over the years (no promotions/mishandling his dating announcement/not letting him perform for long periods of time/giving waaaay more attention to the BinSan subunit), and he and Binnie have been in the company longer than ALL the staff (including the CEO), so I bet he feels like there's nobody in charge who's fighting his corner. Some idols are allowed to leave a label but still promote with the group, but Fantagio stated that wasn't possible in their explanation for his leaving, which is why I think working with Astro under a different company was maybe Rocky's original plan. Not to mention Fantagio have just begun promotions for their new 8-member boygroup. That will be their main focus going forward, with Astro probably only getting subunit/individual schedules. Fantagio has always sucked at promoting more than one group at a time (see what happened to HelloVenus after WekiMeki debuted). Rocky was already getting almost no attention/promotion from FanMu before Lun8, so he probably realised that the company were going to keep on ignoring him. And he's a performer, he thrives on the stage/being active in the industry. Hopefully his new label will allow him the creative freedom that Fantagio didn't. I'm going to miss OT6 with all my heart, but I can't wait to see Rocky soar into success under better management. 💜
Yes, Rocky is doing great for his career. He wants to shine himself but about his personal life why should another people's are interfering . It's his personal life and also if any person may be fall in love it's not a crime, if they are in contract with entertainment industry it's industries problem not astros. So don't troll any of them in astro members and in real life.
Rocky has to do what's Best for him and has to show his füll Potential!!❤❤❤The very true Fans always standing his Ground and his Decisions!!God bless him🙏🏻😊
Mi humilde opinión es que todos tenían u potencial pero el baile lo llevaba moombin y roki basto ver la union binie y sanha y donde estaban los aplausos, mombin dio más q recibió,❤❤❤
in my opinion this is definitely on fantagio. the company itself isn't really known for their kpop groups, and it's even worse since they never seem to promote their group(s) and help them gain spotlight. no hate to cha eun woo, he is incredibly successful and honestly might be the reason why astro has so many fans. i hope fantagio starts supporting their groups more and providing them with the resources to succeed. as sad as I am that rocky left, I hope he finds something that makes him happy and actually takes advantage of his talents.
I don't give a damn about that dating issue, that is supposed to be a part of his PRIVATE LIFE. PARK MINHYUK is a real all-rounder, versatile, multi-talented, ACE! I am so proud I STAN the best idol, I love him more when he decides not to renew his contract, that is a very BRAVE ACT, getting out of your comfort zone, is not an easy decision to make. MAKE IT OR NOT, I guess he won't regret all the decisions he did, at least he did try everything! HE IS SO BRAVE, IM SO PROUD OF HIM. So let's wait and see, it is not going to be an easy journey since there are some arohas who left him, but no need to worry he got his PEBBLES NO MATTER WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN! I will support and stay for him as long as he is happy.
These guys are all amazingly talented and it is sad that their management company does not appreciate them and stand by them. In addition, what is it anyone's business as to their dating. Why should any of the idols not be able to date. I also think that the fans make it tough also. They seem to have negative opinions about dating and, honestly, it should be none of their business. They do not own them. They all have personal lives and that should be respected.
💚💜 It will be heartbreaking not to see them all together as a grp anymore. Let's be thankful these *crack🤪heads* as a grp left a huge impression in our memories! I will follow and support their careers till death, whether together *or* separate. They took my (our) heart from the beginning, in every way! No turning back from that! We all knew *ASTRO* was just their beginning and their youth. We all know that they have so much more to give to their professions in music, acting, modeling and etc. We're so fortunate they were OT6💜ASTRO, so let's keep supporting our extended family of 6 where ever life leads them, together, separate, in public, private or even retired forever! *LOL, Let's keep our hope up that one of them will marry us too!*
He did his best as a rapper, although he always wanted to sing. it was already obvious from some time ago he wanted to compose and be much more involved in the production process as well as to become a singer (quite obvious with Let's breathe album). If one followed Rocky closely one could see how much he needed to express his identity through whatever he did and had a larger vision than other ASTRO members (while Jinjin thought I’d be nice to make the 20th place in Melon Chart, Rocky said “Why not the first?” Thats how confident he was about ASTRO’s talent). They were never gonna let him be a soloist at Fantagio, other wise he would have stayed. There were obviously some conversations between Fantagio and Rocky before he took the final decision to leave. He was clearly not satisfied with what they offered (could be a money issue also). I truly admire his self confidence, how he realizes his worth and chooses his own wellbeing before others. There’s nothing wrong with wanting to create his own content, people with low self esteem will always criticize self confident people. He would still be at Fantagio if they had given him what he wanted. It's only their loss, tho, not ours :) AROHA will always be happy to see our boys shine. I know he will be well recognized and much more successful in the near future. This is just the begining. LUCKY ROCKY!!! EVERYBODY WILL KNOW YOUR NAME!
When an artist leaves the company that sponsored them. It's obvious that the company's expectations and obligations are highly demanding and have No! consideration for the artist as a human. I say good on him for leaving.
Sad but yes I think best decision for him. I don't think the Company handled them as individuals well & for now he can pass on his skills to his brothers Group "'HAWW' as they start their journey. As Choreography Coach, he already has been so valuable for them & also as a Company Member. I hope this gives him the opportunities & freedom to use all his talents. Congratulations Pebble King, you always will be part of our Universe 👏💜💯🍀⭐
ASTRO lacks support by Fantagio and is unfair. With their talents they deserve to be treated well and be given attention as a group. We will always be Arohas in the Philippines, so please Fantagio, give them the treatment they so deserve.
For sure! If Fantagio hadn't neglected Rocky/failed to promote his activities these past two years, he definitely would have stayed. I'm glad that BinSan at least got a tour, but it should've been both subunits. :(
That's a sad reality of kpop industry. Some of the companies do not have moral support and fair treatment if not to one of the members of the group, the whole group do not have the chance to showcase themselves, to shine and make their career skyrocketting. These are the reasons why some of them are leaving the group or company or worst, disbandment might happen to a kpop group.
I support every of his decisions and wish the best for him 🥺 even tho I'll miss him with ot5 but I am happy that he's free from that company and I'll always support them whether individually or as a group, and for me they will always be 6 💜
Rocky has amazing talents and skill in different areas of the entertainment industry that can take him in so many directions. I hope to see him soon, but whole and rested. I'm sure he has his personal reasons, i just hope he is ok especially after an unexpected loss of a friend and group mate and has not posted on any social media how he is.
We don't know both sides of the story. As for Cha Eun Woo, he works very hard for everything and always proves that he does it very well. 40% of Fantagio's earnings is from Cha Eun Woo (fact). Eunwoo promotes the group very well. Without knowing Eunwoo from his dramas, I would never know about Astro. Rocky is old enough to make his decisions. Whatever it may be, good luck to him.
Just because cha eunwoo gives the highest earrings for fantagio does NOT in fact mean he works the hardest.All of the idols under fantagio work hard to promote themselves and their company. Your ignorant and selfish for thinking adding the fact you would only know Astro because of eunwoo is a slap to the face to the other members who work just as hard as him to try to promote their group. The only thing helping eunwoo is his looks he lacks in performance and vocal wise he’s just a visual for the group everyone’s in that group has the talent but is shaded by eunwoos visuals it ain’t fair that this industry is based on ugly looking fans who look up to good looking people like their gods you guys need to touch some grass and live life outside a screen.
to sum up this useless and speculative video: you don't even know Rocky. otherwise they would know that he never had support from either the company or the fandom. When he needed it most, he only received criticism and judgments about his life. Speculating that he left because of his EW career is ridiculous. Even now that he's gone some people don't respect his decision. He doesn't deserve the life he led at that company, those who follow him always knew that his departure was going to happen. He left because he wasn't valued, simple as that. Just do not see who does not want .
this makes the most sense. reasons are simple. You simply leave because you know you deserver better, whether it's for money or value/promotion/respect
I don't know what to say. But it's Rocky's decision. He just wants a solo career out of the group & the company. I admit, i really want to know why he decided to left the group after his happy memories with Astro. It's his personal life we're talking about. He decided it on his own. I'm shocked when he left the group to be honest but i had no right to interfere his persistent. Rocky is the most funniest guy in the group for me especially when his former group tease him to EunWoo. I truly respect Rocky. ❤❤❤
Looking at his recent schedules and sns appearances it looks more like Fantagio didn't let him be in the group if he left the agency hence why the leaving the agency and staying in the group thing didn't work. Even in the articles after the 4 renewing Fantagio already hinted about exclusivity to their agency influencing what will happen to the group. It's also unsure to what extend Fantagio even made an effort to keep him after completely mismanaging the controversy.
Fantagio certainly has a lot to answer for - their vague responses and calls for no speculation surrounding their artists - in my opinion, clearly points to their guilt…deeply disappointed in the lack of accountability from Fantagio….even Moonbin when asked - what year he would like to go back to and he’s says - the year before joining the company….that alone speaks volumes! I would like to see a statement from Fantagio, where they admit the error of their ways and outline the changes they will make to better support their artists!! #accountability
@@TheAnuc For one, Fantagio mainly handles actors, which why they are so bad at promoting their idol groups. For another, I'm not sure he is-- I vaguely remember hearing or reading that he said he only stayed with the company for ASTRO, though I could be misinformed.
@@aubreycutler659 if that was so, then they shouldn’t have renewed their contract end of last year. After a few months moonbin left the world permanently.. Eunwoo was influential enough to change their agents to represent them and he could convinced other members to leave with him when they got the opportunity to leave. I am sure everyone would have gladly left Fantagio with him. Either F have offered more money and convinced Eunwoo to continue with them. This was a bad choice made by the members. Rocky made a wise choice to leave and now his new solo album looks so good. Obros, I heard are very good with promoting idols.
Rocky's too talented to be just a background for other, not so talented, members of the group who were chosen by Fantagio to be promoted because of their face or height. It's a pity Moonbin didn't do the same when he had a chance, and didn't start his solo career too. He was forced by Fantagio to nurse and teach Sanha and to make him the star instead of to shine himself. And Rocky will be all right, with all his talents and having Obros on his side. Now I'll support him even more.
I too felt the same. Since sanha was with them Since young, Moonbin truly loved him.. sanha was the one who was with him till the end. I believe they met the previous day befor he passed away. Though I like all Astro members, I find cha eun woo the weakest but he was projected the most. Rocky was shown as though he is crazy abt eun woo in all the video, which at least to me looked fake and silly. I’m rocky also must hv felt.
@@TheAnucMoonbin died in his appartment alone, his manager found his body after Bin had missed some rehearsals on that day. Nobody was with him till the end.
@@TheAnucMoonbin loved all his members. He was with Rocky the longest, since they were 11-12 y.o. They were trained to perform together, their chemistry on a stage was perfect, dancing they were as one. But some years ago Fantagio decided to promote Sanha because of his age and height, so since 2020 they used Bin's skills and talent mainly to teach Sanha and to make him the star instead of to shine himself like Bin deserved.
@@jee2004a yes, I know .. what I meant was sanha was in touch with him since they were again Going to do a concert after a few days. Not that he was physically present in moonbin’s place. I am very new to k-pop and am quite foreign to that kind of music. First time I came to know about K-pop was in September recently when moonbin’s ting ting tang dance with sanha popped on my TH-cam timeline. He was so good and so impressive that I started looking at him. I was shocked to learn he died in April … then I got very much interested and started watching Astro other videos .. so I don’t know the talks about them in Korea.. But I found while watching their shows and other programs that it was rocky and moonbin who were all rounders and somehow rocky was not exposed well. I am talking as someone who is just new to Astro and watching their old videos. Now I am watching BTS and can make out how much they are promoted by their agency.. If rocky was with BTS, he would have been a superstar.. in fact Astro members individually are better and I would say eun woo is even more good looking than V. But some how Fantagio did not promote them nor gave them songs which will be on international level. MJ is so good both in singing and entertaining. I watched Astro zone and how much I laughed. MJ brought me out of depression.. I am thankful to him for that. But I am not so much entertained by BTS videos. That’s why I feel bad as to how Astro group members lost.. in the end moonbin left this world at such a young age now.. Rocky has left the group. Eun woo is not giving enough time. I don’t think the Astro can survive for long..
@@jee2004a that’s the sad part that Moonbin Was used by Fantagio and must have got frustrated. I also read somewhere that he wanted and the subunit with rocky but instead he was given sanha . Sanha is also very good. I like him.. but moonbin and rocky would have been dynamic. One rapper and one singer and both excellent dancers .. it would have been like competition. I also read that Moonbin didn’t want to renew the contract but was forced by Eunwoo. Whatever, he is left the world which is very sad.
It was obvious to some fans that everything in Astro was all about chaun eun woo. and other members didn't get half the attention eun woo got yet he's not the best dancer or the best singer. I think binnie felt it as well as I read somewhere there was a lot of rivalry going on between members where they felt ignored. I was a big fan of Rocky and Moonbin and Rockys letter to binnie after his death says it all.Since Moonbins gone Eunwoo is now Korea's ambassador for travel and has attended many events but the other members seem to have gone off the radar..Binnie was a big loss to Astro and it proved how everyone loved him. Pity he didn't get the attention when he was alive just how popular he was. This is my opinion noone else's.
I think many people agree with you. thank you for saying this. Eunwoo is very handsome and is a great model - but so was Moonbin. But Eunwoo is an ok dancer and so/so singer. It boggles my mind that he now has a solo singing career. Just goes to show you how much good looks will get you in this world. Fantagio wasted Moonbin's talent -and Rocky's as well as other members. Such a shame.
I don’t believe that he took his own life impossible. He hasn’t been feeling well lately . Either way though he will be incredibly missed. He was extremely talented
I just pray right now EVERYONE gives ROCKY, ASTRO MEMBERS, BILLIE MEMBERS, MOONBIN RIH AND MOON SUA CAN BE KEPT PROTECTED, REST, AND BE GIVEN PEACE/EMOTIONAL HEALING WITH ONLY SUPPORTIVE PEOPLE ALWAYS AROUND THEM ALL.
Don't you think that moonbin didn't die he quit astro same as rocky because the company wasn't treating astro or other idols very well and to keep on Thier good reputation they just said he died also there's no proofs that he died even the funeral was private also autopsy results were very early usually it takes 3 or 4 days to get revealed 🤔
Thank you for saying this. EW is very good looking and models very well. I don't know about his acting talent. But in the group he was the weakest dancer and singer. I can't believe he is going to have a solo singing career. Just goes to show you how far good looks will take you. I wish they had all left Astro. They are popular enough and young enough that they could have continued their careers on their terms.
Fantagio decided to promote their money maker, Cha. Rocky being a superior talent compared to average Dong Min found it unfair. Toxic Cha and his forever envy for his group members especially Rocky, forced the agency to choose him or Rocky. They perhaps quietly settled with Rocky to leave. It’s common for talented people lose opportunities to those who do everything management asks them to because they are branded as ‘handsome’. It’s somehow sad for dong Min! Imagine, you work so hard every day to be in news, social media, shows, awards, and mediocre dramas, because all you got to sell is your face! Let’s hope he won’t become the victim of a scandal with some bimbo actor/singer/idiol or an addict. Rocky find your path of life. Remember, it was a fun fantasy adventure that came to an end. Now find a happy real life! Perhaps a college degree, produce dance performances, and even write a book about your life as an idiol. 👍😍❣️
Whatever the reasons why rocky left astro it is his decisions. and who knows maybe theres a more opportunity outside. Inspite of all that i will support rocky and astro of course im forever aroha
I DON'T THINK SHE WAS INTERESTED IN DATING AND HAS DENIED THE RELATIONSHIP BECAUSE IT WAS HER EARLY YEARS IN HER ACTING CAREER, I THINK THEY BROKE UP AS OF NOW 2024 BECAUSE THEY WERE NO RECENT UPDATES ABOUT THEM UNLIKE OTHER KPOP COUPLES.
He has lots of talents and I love him for his hard work.. it's his crucial time of his career, he should have kept his relationship at lowkey like how she did... Anyways..happened is happened. Astro is not gonna be the same. Rohas are not happy abt it but need to accept this change. Sadly..! It's his life after all..!!
The statement of confirmation came from Fantagio not him. We don't really know if he ever wanted it to be public especially considering he probably would protect his girlfriend too so he would go along with her statement.
@perfect pmh yes the statement was from the company. But he dint hide tat he was dating . He was open abt it. His korean fans spotted them many times n finally brought it to the media.. poor guy.. anyways no point in crying over the spilled milk. He has chosen his path to go ways from Astro. Let him shine ✨️
@dimplesara she was only spotted at the musical just as other of his friends. i wouldn't particularly say going to a public show like other of his colleagues did is being public. Who brought it to attention in the end were not his fans as they respected his privacy but anti fans who were trying for a while to find a reason to create a scandal around him. Yeah, he deserves to shine after what the company and anti fans ruined for him and what happened happened, but that doesn't mean we need to judge the process when many of the things people claimed were never confirmed.
Music company & Solo is good. He also need a good management team, manager and team dancer. Many solo artist can't find the financial means to maintain the staff long term and an Endowment Fund is needed. Its not easy and many solo artist can't survive just drop out for good.
The Korean courts have ruled that Artists' agencies have no business questioning nor interpreting negatively any artist personal love life. So it is none of their business if he is dating. They should have either referred the person asking to him or stated flatly they should mind their own business. They should let their lawyers answer that question only, in case he has to sue the person asking about his love life. Agencies are not allowed to interfere in your love life, because of the Korean Courts ruling on slave contracts..
I never thought when thinking of Astro of Eunwoo NEVER I ONLY thought of Moonbin. He was the star, amazing visual and talent. Moonbin Sanha was a 3 yr step before Moonbin going Solo in 2024 after 2023 tour. Moonbin even said to Sanha, “after the last tour they’re going to be able to do whatever they want”. Moonbin did NOT suicide himself. His body just cut him short because his heart was damaged and he was over trained. Fantagio is probably covering it up because they don’t want the blame for not taking him to hospital, and cancelling the tour and finding out deep of Moonbin’s condition. I think Fantagio paid off the corrupt police coroner to say it was suicide. There is no way Moonbin would have ever stranded Sanha or left his brothers, no way he was too loyal to Astro. RIP my beautiful star ⭐️ I think of you everyday of what you were still going to show us and it kills 💔 me. Moonbin where are you now, please come back 😢💔😭🌙🌸💔😭 No One can come close to your beauty and talent NO ONE.
Eu não queria que os meninos se separassem Isso me deixa tão triste isso É de partir o coração que cada um deles Seja feliz na sua carreira solo acompanhar cada um deles amo o grupo astro❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
What we can conclude from this video: K-Stats knows absolutely nothing about Rocky, Astro, or the inner workings of Fantagio, but decided to drag EW's career into it (like Rocky isn't the biggest Eunwoo supporter of all time). Don't make videos if you aren't going to do the research!
IF ROCKY LEFT ASTRO I WILL NOT STAN THAT GROUP ANYMORE PLUS HE IS MY BIAS AND I REALLY LOVE ALL THE MEMBERS SO MUCH BUT ILL BE SAD IF ROCKY ISNT THERE😭😭😭
@@santok1741 Who u talking to about "just go away" cause u dont understand I started to stan Astro because of Rocky and I really Love the group but without Rocky ima cry😪
This literally explained nothing. Just pure speculation. And youre wrong, not all think about CEW when talking about ASTRO. He is really known in other aspects of his career, but doesnt really shine in the group. Moonbin eas my bias ever since they debut, and i always thought he deserved so much more tha what the company gave him. That might be the case with Rocky too.
Its my thought only : it's because Jinjin will join military (enlisting) next year, so he didn't have a lot of choice to do, and his better option is renew the contract.. in the other hand, Rocky has another option, he still have 4 years ahead before enlist in military, and he should choose the best option for his career and himself... He choose not to stay with fantail, for the shake of his future.. I wish fanta allow Rocky stay in astro (but out from fanta) but I think fanta didn't give that option to Rocky.. Soo..
This video homes some judgemental toxic comments, nothing about Rocky, Astro or inner workings of Fantagio, but, decided to drag EW career into it.🔸The members need time to heal, we don’t want to lose another member.▫️Negativity has a ripple effect, it affects everyone.▫️With so much dissatisfied comments, it opens up the channel for those who don’t like an idols, artist to target them, and they have no filter they write anything.▫️It would be great if more fans, could comment on their bias, without making unkind comments on other members or idols. They are all human beings🔺In our own way can we protect all idols, be kind, they need us. 🙏🏼🌎🩷thank you.
I think some ppl need to realise that this is his life. Not in the sense that he can do whatever he wants (which he can) but I mean that this is life and he can’t be out here making decisions for the sake of the other boys careers (although it sounds harsh), he needs to think about his survival and happiness and so should the others…I mean fanmu clearly picks their favs kmttt I’ll be honest I took a step back from K-pop for some years and I heard he left and I thought it was very selfish but honestly even if it is so be it. Sometimes those decisions need to made especially when you consider the circumstances, the company has not treated him well and he’s really done his part to try and make himself a name and the last few years you can see it. and I never deeped it but OMDS 7 years and they have not managed to make a name for themselves!!! Sure they definitely got recognised but the growth was so small…I expected none of them to continue tbf. Not to say they were a failure cause they were not but, fanmu can’t offer them much…
How is it very selfish? He's given 14 years of his life to a company who have consistently ignored/neglected him artistically and failed to promote any of his solo activities for the past 2 years (even though his acting roles won AWARDS), and they gave a full tour to BinSan's subunit but not Rocky and JinJin's. And now Fantagio have debuted another 8-member boygroup (which has been in the works for the past 18 months), so it's clear they wouldn't have been paying any more attention to Rocky if he stayed there. I think he wanted to stay with Astro, but under new management (like other idols have done), but Fantagio clarified in their statement that this was not allowed, and that's why he had to leave the group. And what do you mean they "have not managed to make a name for themselves"? Astro consistently have high sales with every new album, and are a HUGE success in across Asia. Just because they didn't boom in the US doesn't mean they aren't well-known.
Guy's it not all that glamorous. Sanda stole Eunwoo away from Bin. The company had Eunwoo to speak Bin about renew of contract after making him in the mid of preparing the sub unit come back. They had him trap after he worked so hard preparing for the come back and knows that Eunwoo his weakness. Eunwoo promise he will stay by him but bin only realised he was trick into signing after the company made him work nonstop throughout 2022 to cover the company money issue in2021. He only realised he was trick that he was just a tool used by Sanda, Eunwoo and the company on Eunwoo birthday. When he was made to post a video of Binwoo almost kiss on Eunwoo birthday saying the four of them actually celebrate Eunwoo birthday but it was a lie. The ideal of the video was actually from Sanda as shown in the video. Bin only learnt about Eunwoo tricking him with the contract on Eunwoo birthday. To use Binwoo to cover up his current lover Sanda. Sanda drove a distance and surprise Eunwoo who was having a meal with staff from filming. There fans asked where's is Bin because if Sanda shown up impossible Bin not around. So they have Bin upload the video created by Sanda to lie to their fans. The Video which Sanda wanted wasn't recorded on Eunwoo birthday but actually on Sanda birthday. Another clear evidence was when Eunwoo say he bought food because Bin say he haven't eat but it was an excuse. When Bin tried to greet him he avoid Bin touch by showing him the food he bought but when Sanda reached out his hand to greet he immediately reached out and touched his hand the same hand he rejected Bin. On 18.3.23 , Diffusion sub unit Korea concert Eunwoo suprise his lover by suddenly appearing to their concert even without makeup. Just a facemask. He hug Moonbin in a brotherly manner but with Sanda even though with a facemask he kiss Sanda shoulder while hugging him. You can find it on TH-cam. The difference is so different from day and night. I would say this is damn cruel for Moonbin when both of them know he still have feelings for Eunwoo that's why he trust him and signed the contract. After that he started acting a little different like broken not only inside but also shown during his concerts. He tried to endure for his fans. You could see his Twitters after that. His last concert he pretty much had it Even though his love for the stage, mentally exhausted, physical and mentally with all the mind game going on and still have to interact with Sanha and the others like nothing happens because of the contract but he still gave his best as much as possible for his fans. He gave whatever energy he could specially to the song desire which was written personally by him for his love (Eunwoo). They made him work nonstop in 2022 with little break but Sanha got to rest and enjoyed life even when the company was suffering loss by end of 2022 because his Eunwoo lover. 😢 A cruel world we live in. They don't deserve Bin love. Eunwoo letter of apology after Bin passing is just crap. Sanda even wrote his letter of appearing weak in front of Bin. When he knows that what Bin actually Bin means was to ask him to stop playing victim to attract Eunwoo attention because only by playing victim can he appear defenceless and needs Eunwoo protection knowing very well Eunwoo doesn't allow Bin to call him hyung. In other words, have Eunwoo spoilt him by playing the younger and victim card. After a period it became a habit of Eunwoo doting on Sanda. Sanda will always look out if Bin and Eunwoo had any interaction even if each of them stations at one end of the corner and would appear unhappy if binwoo seems happy. He either interrupted their conversation or appeared unhappy. Then you will see Eunwoo approaching him with pda. All this while Bin was suffering from backlash. The company tried to limit his popularity during the all night era by making him accept a gay role in 2019 knowing very well gay are not acceptable generally in South Korea. As the higher ups prefer Sanda even though the CEO kept changing they wants the audience to focus on Eunwoo and Sanda but they didn't expect Moonbin would go into hiatus for health reasons from the backlash of playing a gay role while he was still recovering from the previous backlash from Eunwoo jealous fans and Eunwoo haters who took it out on Moonbin. They thought Moonbin would continue with activities for the group and get Sanda the original popularity they planned. They never expected Moonbin going into hiatus would make Astro failed to get their first win. Moonbin distanced himself from Eunwoo due to public views. So much hate on him and backlash. Sanda took this as an opportunity over the years. It was very clear when the company not only allowed the skinship of Sanda and Eunwoo in public but also in MV. While Moonbin was in the process of healing so Moonbin tried to take comfort with MJ and Seungkwan because no one was there for him very 😞 he never stop loving Eunwoo.
@@zioluv I even provided you with evidences, you too lazy to search than you asked if self directing. That's why cause of people like you. His no longer with us due to neglecting especially by people around him for so long. His company did career sabotage choices on him since 2019. When he was supposed to be shining since than. His bond by his contract what can he say when they already tried to control so much on him. Even when his fan tried to stood up for him during Vlive. Staff pretending to be fan in chat signal him to stop them. He can only follow orders and repeat what the staff wants. How he must have felt knowing that even his fans trying to defend him is something Astro PR also wants to control. A very sad life he lives. That's why he even asked running man Kim Jong-kook for advice on what he should do on his day off that he always felt lost. If you only follow what the company is trying to sell to the public and not Moonbin life for who he is than don't bother asking why he passed away. Afterall, the ones left in the company barely mistreated so there's nothing left to talk about. Like Moonbin mentioned before he is that guy. Members asked what that guy. Moonbin say Moonbin is Moonbin
I love Eun Woo, he led me to start loving Astro too, especially Moonbin, I believe all of them has their own fair share of talents. Ive watched almost all of their vlogs and all I see is a brotherly love. what I just read, cant be true. I love Moonbin and I have big respect for him, he is such a talented person, same goes with the rest of the members..
Rocky DOES want to be with Astro, he made that quite clear (he even kept the star in his IG profile, and wears his Astro friendship ring out in public at all times). But he clearly just couldn't stay under that awful company after the way they've treated them - Fantagio even clarified in their statement that he wasn't allowed to continue as a member of the group under a different label/company/contract (which suggests this is what Rocky initially wanted), and therefore he had to leave the group. Fantagio have been mistreating him for over a year now, it's no surprise he needed to get out of there. And Astro will always be OT6 at heart - even the boys said in their last stage together (where they already would've known Rocky was leaving) "please support each of us, even in our individual projects" - they still love Rocky, and he clearly loves them, but his mental health has to come first. Don't you think the rest of Astro 100% supports that decision too, since they love him? They've been together for so many years (11+ years in Binnie's case), that sort of friendship/love doesn't end because of Fantagio's contract stipulations. Just wait until Rocky's a soloist, I guarantee he'll be doing collabs with the Astro members all the time. 💜
@@_Eunoia_I am new to Astro.. but looking at all their videos, I always wonder why Rocky was made to swoon and act like he was crazy for eun woo especially in the years 2020-22. Earlier they we all like friends. It was very awkward to watch his talk like he was crazy abt eun woo and eun woo was like ok and very benevolent.. I feel rocky should not have done that .. also compared to sanha, he got less importance..
@@TheAnuc Rocky was always very supportive of Eunwoo, I'm not sure what you mean by him "being made to swoon and act like he was crazy for Eunwoo"? Their relationship seemed close right from the start, they'd already been together for 2 years before debut. Their trainee-day videos/iTeen content shows how close they all were. Rocky has always been a little awkward around other idols because he seems naturally shy/introverted, but with Astro he was a lot more energetic and outgoing because he seemed comfortable to be himself.
@@aroo7924 1) Liking your own very recent comment on a year-old thread is a bit embarrassing hon. 2) Please clarify who you mean by "they" and "he", your question is incredibly vague.
His change came from a long time ago, he did not talk to his fans, he had no interest in communicating even before his relationship. He did not enter private platforms, his mind was no longer with ASTRO and he left them without caring about the group's projects and the Lack of a member who is in the military service was selfish, he is talented but he only cared about his comfort
Your fandom is the most selfish and vile out their and you out of all people trying to blame him ? please start having some shame. None of you cared to keep a track of his work nor cared to know about his updates. None of you cared to listen to what he said time to time. Your fandom continued bullying him for posting so much on sns , not posting much on sns , helping in doing parts of other members in concert, talking about other members , for being introduced with his designated position on a show and so much more. I am glad he is free from that hell now. and free from you. Good riddance. He don't have to constantly hear the stupid excuse of "he didn't give his all" for you to have an excuse to hate on him while he always gave his most . also he is not responsible for other members they are individual artists too lol
Well somebody doesn't even watch rocky closely 🤷. He only cared about his own comfort? Rocky's been selfless ever since. If you're really watching him closely, he doesn't miss the chance to express his gratitude to fans and show care for his group.
Funny you say that considering he was the member with the most VLIVEs and only stopped being extremely active when he had 3 drama at the same time then had to manage still being part of all ASTRO activity including overseas schedules and while preparing for a musical. This statement was never made about other members who prepared for things like musicals and went IA that time or who some members that have big scale projects then don't join group schedules for the meantime. What he did is far from comfort, it was overworking himself and still with the little time he has he did came on VLIVE and did drop a post once in a while. It's really just a prejudiced perspective, who already wants to see him negatively from the get go.
he was not the only one who "do not enter private platforms". he was also busy with his own projects like musical but of course, you forgot or didn't know about it, right? aside from the mistreatment from the company, i believe he also left because of how some "fans" LIKE YOU, especially from korea and japan, just doesn't care about him and wanted him out. 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
if you are as talented as he and has done everything for this group /company 14 years..(just turned 24 last month) yet mistreated / lack of support by your company ,wouldn't you choose to leave? His company didn't protect him and sabotage his career when the news broke out, any sensible people would did the same as he. I am happy he is free .
Agree! He was neglected by Fantagio..he is old enough to make decisions that will benefits him in the coming future.
he was definitely neglected by fantagio but i think the things that have happened even in the past few days have really shown that he had no desire to leave astro as a group, even if he left fantagio. first and foremost the members never unfollowed each other on social media, which is usually the first thing that happens in this situation. then a few days ago, obros posted a picture of him on instagram in which they mentioned he "loves astro more than anything." in both of his recent public appearances (seoul fashion week and music bank) he is very clearly wearing his astro friendship ring, and when he performed with haww on music bank he was wearing his aroha in-ear. i'm not holding out hope that he'll ever rejoin astro but do think he's trying to tell people that leaving the group, at least, wasn't what he wanted.
Yesyes! Fabtagio only pushed eunwoo, that's not the members fault but the company
EunWoo is just a pretty face, he doesn’t have any real talent. All he can do is model. They were jealous of Moon Bin bc he was full of talent and was the main focal point of Astro. There is no Astro without Bin!!!
@@michelleketelsen4996 I agree .. if they had promoted Moonbin, rocky and MJ more, Astro would have been more popular since they would come out with more good songs and good visual dancing. I am new to Astro but while watching their videos and MVs I never knew rocky was such a good dancer because he was always at the back. Only after reading Aroha’s comments did I come to know he was an excellent dancer. They could have promoted him and MJ more.
He also was not treated or promoted well by fantagio, he did not get many schedules or exposure, and a lot of the things he did, by himself, jinjin too, they both didn't get a lot of activities and would be composing and writing songs instead
Exactly it fell so bad of him
very very true 👍
another example is that last year for his birthday live, unlike the rest of the group, he was at his studio not at the company building with decorations displayed by the staff, which i always thought was a bit odd
How i wish jin jin will out in fantagio.. because he didnt give opportunity to shine..
Its just always eunwoo and moonbin then sanha the other 3 members are totally unknown if youre not an astro fan
I totally support Rocky's decision! He's too talented and will succeed in whatever he decides to do! I wish Moonbin had done the same and had had proper time to rest and take care of his health, including mental health. He deserved all the best. He worked really hard for the group and consequently for the agency. After watching several videos of the group, IMHO Moonbin was the glue that kept them together. He was warm, friendly, always hugging and comforting another member, always not afraid to express his feelings (like when he wrote on his cell phone that he loved EW or when he, on stage, shouted to EW and the other members that he loved them). It's hard for me to think they will ever be able to get together again, except, of course, for some contractual reasons. Rest in Awesome, Moonbin! Way to go, Rocky! You both did great!!
I predict after Moonbin departure each member of Astro will be quitting, one of the reason Moonbin got into depression is due to Fantagio, so many years with them and he didn’t see a future I’m so sorry he didn’t choose to do as Rocky. I wish all the other guys do the same, move on. Also to me the number one reason they should leave Astro is that Moonbin is a very very hard act to follow sorry guys he was the light of the group.
Agreed 💜💜💜 moon bin
Totally agree, Moonbin was the soul of Astro , his charm , his charisma, his talent, my dear Moonbin , wish he had leave in 2019 , he will still alive today . Fantagio destroyed him 😢
The guys would be able to move Astro forward if Fantagio didn't continue to insist on promoting Eun Woo as a priority. The way Fantagio acts doesn't help the 4 of them spend time together to create music and dance. Fantagio is dismantling Astro.
Moonbin was the main star and no one could compete with any part of him he had everything. 😭💔😪🌙🌸
Fentegio je dokrajčio Moonbina .Sreća pa nije Rokiya .I Moonbin je trebao napustiti Fentegio.Roky pametna odluka❤
I will miss rocky, he was the reason why I stanned astro. But I will continue to support him and the ot5. I hope whatever he does in the future works out for him! I will be watching.
We lost in total 2 today :((
Its OT4 now
There is definitely a fault of fantagio , they were the one who always gave attention to more popular members than the less popular ones. They won't even promote Astro properly as a group. There are many problematic things in fantagio's management.
I hope rocky gets to live the life he always wanted to and prosper in life.!!!♡♡♡
Fantagio never promoted them well as a group. A lot of people say that the company's focus is only on cha eunwoo but NO. the company doesn't even promote him well.
With the amount of talent and kind of a band astro is, it could have been extremely popular internationally if promoted well.
Best wishes for him and astro. Aroha and pebble forever. Wish he gets to do all he wants to.. the company doesn't deserve him and his talent Anyways
What’s pebble?
@@janexnie6309 oh... rocky's fans are called pebbles 😅
honestly, the whole group should have left fantagio...
Rocky as an actor I really impressed he got 3 trophy as best actors he is very talented and I admired him very much
I have no problem with Rocky being in a relationship. Why should this be kept secret, I disagree. I'm a huge fan of the whole group and when they're in love it's only beautiful. Beautiful songs can come out of that, so as far as I'm concerned, they only grow from that. As Aroha, I stand behind the boys no matter what they do. I agree that Fantagio keeps making mistakes.
.I hope they will listen more to Astro and the Arohas. I am from the Netherlands and here too we are fans of ASTRO.
Honestly, Rocky always had the most passion for Astro, and I 100% believe he wanted to stay with them as a group but simply couldn't keep working under Fantagio - they've treated him so poorly over the years (no promotions/mishandling his dating announcement/not letting him perform for long periods of time/giving waaaay more attention to the BinSan subunit), and he and Binnie have been in the company longer than ALL the staff (including the CEO), so I bet he feels like there's nobody in charge who's fighting his corner. Some idols are allowed to leave a label but still promote with the group, but Fantagio stated that wasn't possible in their explanation for his leaving, which is why I think working with Astro under a different company was maybe Rocky's original plan.
Not to mention Fantagio have just begun promotions for their new 8-member boygroup. That will be their main focus going forward, with Astro probably only getting subunit/individual schedules. Fantagio has always sucked at promoting more than one group at a time (see what happened to HelloVenus after WekiMeki debuted). Rocky was already getting almost no attention/promotion from FanMu before Lun8, so he probably realised that the company were going to keep on ignoring him. And he's a performer, he thrives on the stage/being active in the industry. Hopefully his new label will allow him the creative freedom that Fantagio didn't.
I'm going to miss OT6 with all my heart, but I can't wait to see Rocky soar into success under better management. 💜
Rocky does well dancing, singing, acting and rapping. I wish him success in all his work!❤
Yes, Rocky is doing great for his career. He wants to shine himself but about his personal life why should another people's are interfering . It's his personal life and also if any person may be fall in love it's not a crime, if they are in contract with entertainment industry it's industries problem not astros. So don't troll any of them in astro members and in real life.
Rocky has to do what's Best for him and has to show his füll Potential!!❤❤❤The very true Fans always standing his Ground and his Decisions!!God bless him🙏🏻😊
Mi humilde opinión es que todos tenían u potencial pero el baile lo llevaba moombin y roki basto ver la union binie y sanha y donde estaban los aplausos, mombin dio más q recibió,❤❤❤
here after the moonbin news... 🙏
😢
in my opinion this is definitely on fantagio. the company itself isn't really known for their kpop groups, and it's even worse since they never seem to promote their group(s) and help them gain spotlight. no hate to cha eun woo, he is incredibly successful and honestly might be the reason why astro has so many fans. i hope fantagio starts supporting their groups more and providing them with the resources to succeed. as sad as I am that rocky left, I hope he finds something that makes him happy and actually takes advantage of his talents.
I don't give a damn about that dating issue, that is supposed to be a part of his PRIVATE LIFE. PARK MINHYUK is a real all-rounder, versatile, multi-talented, ACE! I am so proud I STAN the best idol, I love him more when he decides not to renew his contract, that is a very BRAVE ACT, getting out of your comfort zone, is not an easy decision to make. MAKE IT OR NOT, I guess he won't regret all the decisions he did, at least he did try everything! HE IS SO BRAVE, IM SO PROUD OF HIM. So let's wait and see, it is not going to be an easy journey since there are some arohas who left him, but no need to worry he got his PEBBLES NO MATTER WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN! I will support and stay for him as long as he is happy.
Preach!
These guys are all amazingly talented and it is sad that their management company does not appreciate them and stand by them. In addition, what is it anyone's business as to their dating. Why should any of the idols not be able to date. I also think that the fans make it tough also. They seem to have negative opinions about dating and, honestly, it should be none of their business. They do not own them. They all have personal lives and that should be respected.
his decision is fine
as long as we can see him on stage again.. i’m not ready to just never see him ever again
That's why we need to support him and ask others to subscribe to his channel on this platform.
💚💜 It will be heartbreaking not to see them all together as a grp anymore. Let's be thankful these *crack🤪heads* as a grp left a huge impression in our memories! I will follow and support their careers till death, whether together *or* separate. They took my (our) heart from the beginning, in every way! No turning back from that! We all knew *ASTRO* was just their beginning and their youth. We all know that they have so much more to give to their professions in music, acting, modeling and etc. We're so fortunate they were OT6💜ASTRO, so let's keep supporting our extended family of 6 where ever life leads them, together, separate, in public, private or even retired forever! *LOL, Let's keep our hope up that one of them will marry us too!*
💚💜 And to add to that, their military conscriptions as well!
Yes we were actually that they were ot6 Astro and those memories should be cherished remembering moonbin in them RIP ❤❤❤
You made the right choice, I wish you much success!! Fighting 💪💪💪.I love you❤❤
All I hope for Astro by going through this they still stay friends and same with Ikon and Monsta X.
He did his best as a rapper, although he always wanted to sing. it was already obvious from some time ago he wanted to compose and be much more involved in the production process as well as to become a singer (quite obvious with Let's breathe album). If one followed Rocky closely one could see how much he needed to express his identity through whatever he did and had a larger vision than other ASTRO members (while Jinjin thought I’d be nice to make the 20th place in Melon Chart, Rocky said “Why not the first?” Thats how confident he was about ASTRO’s talent).
They were never gonna let him be a soloist at Fantagio, other wise he would have stayed. There were obviously some conversations between Fantagio and Rocky before he took the final decision to leave. He was clearly not satisfied with what they offered (could be a money issue also). I truly admire his self confidence, how he realizes his worth and chooses his own wellbeing before others. There’s nothing wrong with wanting to create his own content, people with low self esteem will always criticize self confident people.
He would still be at Fantagio if they had given him what he wanted. It's only their loss, tho, not ours :) AROHA will always be happy to see our boys shine. I know he will be well recognized and much more successful in the near future. This is just the begining.
LUCKY ROCKY!!! EVERYBODY WILL KNOW YOUR NAME!
When an artist leaves the company that sponsored them. It's obvious that the company's expectations and obligations are highly demanding and have No! consideration for the artist as a human.
I say good on him for leaving.
You can see that Rocky for the other members of Astro he is part of the team when they go together in Jinjin performans. All this is Fantagio fault.
Sad but yes I think best decision for him. I don't think the Company handled them as individuals well & for now he can pass on his skills to his brothers Group "'HAWW' as they start their journey. As Choreography Coach, he already has been so valuable for them & also as a Company Member. I hope this gives him the opportunities & freedom to use all his talents. Congratulations Pebble King, you always will be part of our Universe 👏💜💯🍀⭐
ASTRO lacks support by Fantagio and is unfair. With their talents they deserve to be treated well and be given attention as a group. We will always be Arohas in the Philippines, so please Fantagio, give them the treatment they so deserve.
For sure! If Fantagio hadn't neglected Rocky/failed to promote his activities these past two years, he definitely would have stayed. I'm glad that BinSan at least got a tour, but it should've been both subunits. :(
That's a sad reality of kpop industry. Some of the companies do not have moral support and fair treatment if not to one of the members of the group, the whole group do not have the chance to showcase themselves, to shine and make their career skyrocketting. These are the reasons why some of them are leaving the group or company or worst, disbandment might happen to a kpop group.
agree,ya sad😪
I support every of his decisions and wish the best for him 🥺 even tho I'll miss him with ot5 but I am happy that he's free from that company and I'll always support them whether individually or as a group, and for me they will always be 6 💜
Rocky has amazing talents and skill in different areas of the entertainment industry that can take him in so many directions. I hope to see him soon, but whole and rested. I'm sure he has his personal reasons, i just hope he is ok especially after an unexpected loss of a friend and group mate and has not posted on any social media how he is.
We don't know both sides of the story. As for Cha Eun Woo, he works very hard for everything and always proves that he does it very well. 40% of Fantagio's earnings is from Cha Eun Woo (fact). Eunwoo promotes the group very well. Without knowing Eunwoo from his dramas, I would never know about Astro. Rocky is old enough to make his decisions. Whatever it may be, good luck to him.
Also Ong Seongwu is the second most earning entertainer for Fantagio
I totally agree on u
Just because cha eunwoo gives the highest earrings for fantagio does NOT in fact mean he works the hardest.All of the idols under fantagio work hard to promote themselves and their company. Your ignorant and selfish for thinking adding the fact you would only know Astro because of eunwoo is a slap to the face to the other members who work just as hard as him to try to promote their group. The only thing helping eunwoo is his looks he lacks in performance and vocal wise he’s just a visual for the group everyone’s in that group has the talent but is shaded by eunwoos visuals it ain’t fair that this industry is based on ugly looking fans who look up to good looking people like their gods you guys need to touch some grass and live life outside a screen.
to sum up this useless and speculative video: you don't even know Rocky. otherwise they would know that he never had support from either the company or the fandom. When he needed it most, he only received criticism and judgments about his life. Speculating that he left because of his EW career is ridiculous. Even now that he's gone some people don't respect his decision. He doesn't deserve the life he led at that company, those who follow him always knew that his departure was going to happen. He left because he wasn't valued, simple as that. Just do not see who does not want .
this makes the most sense. reasons are simple. You simply leave because you know you deserver better, whether it's for money or value/promotion/respect
Im here because of moonbin 😪😪🥺
I don't know what to say. But it's Rocky's decision. He just wants a solo career out of the group & the company. I admit, i really want to know why he decided to left the group after his happy memories with Astro. It's his personal life we're talking about. He decided it on his own. I'm shocked when he left the group to be honest but i had no right to interfere his persistent. Rocky is the most funniest guy in the group for me especially when his former group tease him to EunWoo. I truly respect Rocky. ❤❤❤
Don't leave Rocky please You Best member ever i even sub Astor
Looking at his recent schedules and sns appearances it looks more like Fantagio didn't let him be in the group if he left the agency hence why the leaving the agency and staying in the group thing didn't work. Even in the articles after the 4 renewing Fantagio already hinted about exclusivity to their agency influencing what will happen to the group. It's also unsure to what extend Fantagio even made an effort to keep him after completely mismanaging the controversy.
Fantagio certainly has a lot to answer for - their vague responses and calls for no speculation surrounding their artists - in my opinion, clearly points to their guilt…deeply disappointed in the lack of accountability from Fantagio….even Moonbin when asked - what year he would like to go back to and he’s says - the year before joining the company….that alone speaks volumes!
I would like to see a statement from Fantagio, where they admit the error of their ways and outline the changes they will make to better support their artists!! #accountability
How come eun woo is so happy with fantagio if they are treated very badly ..
@@TheAnuc For one, Fantagio mainly handles actors, which why they are so bad at promoting their idol groups. For another, I'm not sure he is-- I vaguely remember hearing or reading that he said he only stayed with the company for ASTRO, though I could be misinformed.
@@aubreycutler659 if that was so, then they shouldn’t have renewed their contract end of last year. After a few months moonbin left the world permanently.. Eunwoo was influential enough to change their agents to represent them and he could convinced other members to leave with him when they got the opportunity to leave. I am sure everyone would have gladly left Fantagio with him. Either F have offered more money and convinced Eunwoo to continue with them. This was a bad choice made by the members. Rocky made a wise choice to leave and now his new solo album looks so good. Obros, I heard are very good with promoting idols.
Rocky's too talented to be just a background for other, not so talented, members of the group who were chosen by Fantagio to be promoted because of their face or height.
It's a pity Moonbin didn't do the same when he had a chance, and didn't start his solo career too. He was forced by Fantagio to nurse and teach Sanha and to make him the star instead of to shine himself.
And Rocky will be all right, with all his talents and having Obros on his side. Now I'll support him even more.
I too felt the same. Since sanha was with them Since young, Moonbin truly loved him.. sanha was the one who was with him till the end. I believe they met the previous day befor he passed away. Though I like all Astro members, I find cha eun woo the weakest but he was projected the most. Rocky was shown as though he is crazy abt eun woo in all the video, which at least to me looked fake and silly. I’m rocky also must hv felt.
@@TheAnucMoonbin died in his appartment alone, his manager found his body after Bin had missed some rehearsals on that day. Nobody was with him till the end.
@@TheAnucMoonbin loved all his members. He was with Rocky the longest, since they were 11-12 y.o. They were trained to perform together, their chemistry on a stage was perfect, dancing they were as one. But some years ago Fantagio decided to promote Sanha because of his age and height, so since 2020 they used Bin's skills and talent mainly to teach Sanha and to make him the star instead of to shine himself like Bin deserved.
@@jee2004a yes, I know .. what I meant was sanha was in touch with him since they were again Going to do a concert after a few days. Not that he was physically present in moonbin’s place. I am very new to k-pop and am quite foreign to that kind of music. First time I came to know about K-pop was in September recently when moonbin’s ting ting tang dance with sanha popped on my TH-cam timeline. He was so good and so impressive that I started looking at him. I was shocked to learn he died in April … then I got very much interested and started watching Astro other videos .. so I don’t know the talks about them in Korea.. But I found while watching their shows and other programs that it was rocky and moonbin who were all rounders and somehow rocky was not exposed well. I am talking as someone who is just new to Astro and watching their old videos. Now I am watching BTS and can make out how much they are promoted by their agency.. If rocky was with BTS, he would have been a superstar.. in fact Astro members individually are better and I would say eun woo is even more good looking than V. But some how Fantagio did not promote them nor gave them songs which will be on international level. MJ is so good both in singing and entertaining. I watched Astro zone and how much I laughed. MJ brought me out of depression.. I am thankful to him for that. But I am not so much entertained by BTS videos. That’s why I feel bad as to how Astro group members lost.. in the end moonbin left this world at such a young age now.. Rocky has left the group. Eun woo is not giving enough time. I don’t think the Astro can survive for long..
@@jee2004a that’s the sad part that Moonbin Was used by Fantagio and must have got frustrated. I also read somewhere that he wanted and the subunit with rocky but instead he was given sanha . Sanha is also very good. I like him.. but moonbin and rocky would have been dynamic. One rapper and one singer and both excellent dancers .. it would have been like competition. I also read that Moonbin didn’t want to renew the contract but was forced by Eunwoo. Whatever, he is left the world which is very sad.
I get it that he wants a career of his own but I wish he still could join them occasionally to make albums. 🤗🥰
It was obvious to some fans that everything in Astro was all about chaun eun woo. and other members didn't get half the attention eun woo got
yet he's not the best dancer or the best
singer. I think binnie felt it as well as I read somewhere there was a lot of rivalry going on between members where they felt ignored. I was a big fan of Rocky and Moonbin and Rockys letter to binnie after his death says it all.Since Moonbins gone Eunwoo is now Korea's ambassador for travel and has attended many events but the other members seem to have
gone off the radar..Binnie was a big loss to Astro and it proved how everyone loved him. Pity he didn't get the attention when he was alive just how popular he was. This is my opinion noone else's.
I think many people agree with you. thank you for saying this. Eunwoo is very handsome and is a great model - but so was Moonbin. But Eunwoo is an ok dancer and so/so singer. It boggles my mind that he now has a solo singing career. Just goes to show you how much good looks will get you in this world.
Fantagio wasted Moonbin's talent -and Rocky's as well as other members. Such a shame.
I don't agree the first thing I noticed in Astro was their show To be continued and all their sense of humors
I don’t believe that he took his own life impossible. He hasn’t been feeling well lately . Either way though he will be incredibly missed. He was extremely talented
rocky is alive
Ha fatto bene a lasciare fantagio, se anche Moonbin l'avesse fatto.... sarebbe ancora tra noi😢
I just pray right now EVERYONE gives ROCKY, ASTRO MEMBERS, BILLIE MEMBERS, MOONBIN RIH AND MOON SUA CAN BE KEPT PROTECTED, REST, AND BE GIVEN PEACE/EMOTIONAL HEALING WITH ONLY SUPPORTIVE PEOPLE ALWAYS AROUND THEM ALL.
Don't you think that moonbin didn't die he quit astro same as rocky because the company wasn't treating astro or other idols very well and to keep on Thier good reputation they just said he died also there's no proofs that he died even the funeral was private also autopsy results were very early usually it takes 3 or 4 days to get revealed 🤔
He is a Star,he is so talented,he is calm 😍 we shall follow u Rocky 💪 whenever you go and support you unconditionally ❤
Moobin😣😭
Heartbreaking...
.. 😢
I think rocky chose the right decision to leave the company coz he is deserved more .
I think in Astro group only eunwo they treat good
Thank you for saying this. EW is very good looking and models very well. I don't know about his acting talent. But in the group he was the weakest dancer and singer. I can't believe he is going to have a solo singing career. Just goes to show you how far good looks will take you.
I wish they had all left Astro. They are popular enough and young enough that they could have continued their careers on their terms.
I agree based on their talents they could be more famous than bst
IT is his decision respect that And it is his live ❤
Fantagio decided to promote their money maker, Cha. Rocky being a superior talent compared to average Dong Min found it unfair. Toxic Cha and his forever envy for his group members especially Rocky, forced the agency to choose him or Rocky. They perhaps quietly settled with Rocky to leave. It’s common for talented people lose opportunities to those who do everything management asks them to because they are branded as ‘handsome’. It’s somehow sad for dong
Min!
Imagine, you work so hard every day to be in news, social media, shows, awards, and mediocre dramas, because all you got to sell is your face! Let’s hope he won’t become the victim of a scandal with some bimbo actor/singer/idiol or an addict.
Rocky find your path of life. Remember, it was a fun fantasy adventure that came to an end. Now find a happy real life! Perhaps a college degree, produce dance performances, and even write a book about your life as an idiol. 👍😍❣️
Rocky you are very talented
I stanned them years ago...I'm here again but what I'm listening right now!??
Whatever the reasons why rocky left astro it is his decisions. and who knows maybe theres a more opportunity outside. Inspite of all that i will support rocky and astro of course im forever aroha
I'm not blaming his gf.. she was smart enough to deny it through her agency n concentrate on her career..!
So, you blame fantagio yes? Ok! We agree 👏🏼
I DON'T THINK SHE WAS INTERESTED IN DATING AND HAS DENIED THE RELATIONSHIP BECAUSE IT WAS HER EARLY YEARS IN HER ACTING CAREER, I THINK THEY BROKE UP AS OF NOW 2024 BECAUSE THEY WERE NO RECENT UPDATES ABOUT THEM UNLIKE OTHER KPOP COUPLES.
He has lots of talents and I love him for his hard work.. it's his crucial time of his career, he should have kept his relationship at lowkey like how she did... Anyways..happened is happened. Astro is not gonna be the same. Rohas are not happy abt it but need to accept this change. Sadly..! It's his life after all..!!
The statement of confirmation came from Fantagio not him. We don't really know if he ever wanted it to be public especially considering he probably would protect his girlfriend too so he would go along with her statement.
@perfect pmh yes the statement was from the company. But he dint hide tat he was dating . He was open abt it. His korean fans spotted them many times n finally brought it to the media.. poor guy.. anyways no point in crying over the spilled milk. He has chosen his path to go ways from Astro. Let him shine ✨️
@dimplesara she was only spotted at the musical just as other of his friends. i wouldn't particularly say going to a public show like other of his colleagues did is being public. Who brought it to attention in the end were not his fans as they respected his privacy but anti fans who were trying for a while to find a reason to create a scandal around him. Yeah, he deserves to shine after what the company and anti fans ruined for him and what happened happened, but that doesn't mean we need to judge the process when many of the things people claimed were never confirmed.
Music company & Solo is good. He also need a good management team, manager and team dancer. Many solo artist can't find the financial means to maintain the staff long term and an Endowment Fund is needed. Its not easy and many solo artist can't survive just drop out for good.
Astro Rocky meu lindo gatinho❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🕺🕺🎤🎤🎤🎧🎧🎧🎧
The Korean courts have ruled that Artists' agencies have no business questioning nor interpreting negatively any artist personal love life. So it is none of their business if he is dating. They should have either referred the person asking to him or stated flatly they should mind their own business. They should let their lawyers answer that question only, in case he has to sue the person asking about his love life. Agencies are not allowed to interfere in your love life, because of the Korean Courts ruling on slave contracts..
I never thought when thinking of Astro of Eunwoo NEVER I ONLY thought of Moonbin. He was the star, amazing visual and talent. Moonbin Sanha was a 3 yr step before Moonbin going Solo in 2024 after 2023 tour. Moonbin even said to Sanha, “after the last tour they’re going to be able to do whatever they want”. Moonbin did NOT suicide himself. His body just cut him short because his heart was damaged and he was over trained. Fantagio is probably covering it up because they don’t want the blame for not taking him to hospital, and cancelling the tour and finding out deep of Moonbin’s condition. I think Fantagio paid off the corrupt police coroner to say it was suicide. There is no way Moonbin would have ever stranded Sanha or left his brothers, no way he was too loyal to Astro. RIP my beautiful star ⭐️ I think of you everyday of what you were still going to show us and it kills 💔 me. Moonbin where are you now, please come back 😢💔😭🌙🌸💔😭 No One can come close to your beauty and talent NO ONE.
Eu não queria que os meninos se separassem Isso me deixa tão triste isso É de partir o coração que cada um deles Seja feliz na sua carreira solo acompanhar cada um deles amo o grupo astro❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
He did make a good choice to leave the company to do some acting tv shows
noooooo I can’t believe that my bias is not in the group anymore he chose not to renew his contract
I thought you could give at least a few possible reasons for his leaving. But you chose the most delusional of them. I'm so disappointed
Rock please back na ❤❤❤❤❤
Todo o grupo deveria ter saído dessa fantasio,tenho certeza que não ficariam sem ninguém por muito tempo.
I am not giving any opinions here but I clicked because I was intrigued as to what new story is being presented as real reasons.
What we can conclude from this video: K-Stats knows absolutely nothing about Rocky, Astro, or the inner workings of Fantagio, but decided to drag EW's career into it (like Rocky isn't the biggest Eunwoo supporter of all time). Don't make videos if you aren't going to do the research!
IF ROCKY LEFT ASTRO I WILL NOT STAN THAT GROUP ANYMORE PLUS HE IS MY BIAS AND I REALLY LOVE ALL THE MEMBERS SO MUCH BUT ILL BE SAD IF ROCKY ISNT THERE😭😭😭
He left in feb 2023. Both, the company and group.
@@rebecaqtv9118 He is the reasoned I stanned Astro
@@mamastubbs-ts6td im so sorry 😔
But im sure he will comeback to us as an independent artist. Park Minhyuk 🫶🏼
Just go away... Astro will be bigger than ever with 5 boys who love each other and want to keep the group.
@@santok1741 Who u talking to about "just go away" cause u dont understand I started to stan Astro because of Rocky and I really Love the group but without Rocky ima cry😪
Are you sure?
He left.
I understand this video. But whhyy?
Ahh, now 5 member
I miss him 😭😭😭.
no idea
Ftgio made it clear in december that those not in the company couldnt be in the group. He left the company so he had to leave the group, too.
I don't know why but i still got hope that...he can work with cha eunwoo on a series or a nice song!! Looking forward to that!
I find cha-eun woo very aloof with the members in personal life except with sanha.
This literally explained nothing. Just pure speculation. And youre wrong, not all think about CEW when talking about ASTRO. He is really known in other aspects of his career, but doesnt really shine in the group. Moonbin eas my bias ever since they debut, and i always thought he deserved so much more tha what the company gave him. That might be the case with Rocky too.
Why everyone talks about Astro just for what happened recently about Bin, before now one now who Astro was, I’m Aroha and so sad everybody talks now🥲
I'm more surprised jinjin resigned because astro as a group has been shafted to promote moonbin x sanha and solo eunwoo.
Its my thought only : it's because Jinjin will join military (enlisting) next year, so he didn't have a lot of choice to do, and his better option is renew the contract.. in the other hand, Rocky has another option, he still have 4 years ahead before enlist in military, and he should choose the best option for his career and himself... He choose not to stay with fantail, for the shake of his future.. I wish fanta allow Rocky stay in astro (but out from fanta) but I think fanta didn't give that option to Rocky.. Soo..
Jinjin cast in musical "Dream High".
The problem is the fans. Sorry
I’ve just started checking out Astro. Mainly for Moonbin! Are he and San Ho striking
out on their own or as a sub unit?
Bin and Sanha are an Astro's sub-unit
Moonbin passed away😭😭😭😭
@@haneakarim So heartbreaking.....
Coming here after moonbins death 😢
This video homes some judgemental toxic comments, nothing about Rocky, Astro or inner workings of Fantagio, but, decided to drag EW career into it.🔸The members need time to heal, we don’t want to lose another member.▫️Negativity has a ripple effect, it affects everyone.▫️With so much dissatisfied comments, it opens up the channel for those who don’t like an idols, artist to target them, and they have no filter they write anything.▫️It would be great if more fans, could comment on their bias, without making unkind comments on other members or idols. They are all human beings🔺In our own way can we protect all idols, be kind, they need us. 🙏🏼🌎🩷thank you.
People please stop to be mean
I think some ppl need to realise that this is his life. Not in the sense that he can do whatever he wants (which he can) but I mean that this is life and he can’t be out here making decisions for the sake of the other boys careers (although it sounds harsh), he needs to think about his survival and happiness and so should the others…I mean fanmu clearly picks their favs kmttt
I’ll be honest I took a step back from K-pop for some years and I heard he left and I thought it was very selfish but honestly even if it is so be it. Sometimes those decisions need to made especially when you consider the circumstances, the company has not treated him well and he’s really done his part to try and make himself a name and the last few years you can see it.
and I never deeped it but OMDS 7 years and they have not managed to make a name for themselves!!! Sure they definitely got recognised but the growth was so small…I expected none of them to continue tbf. Not to say they were a failure cause they were not but, fanmu can’t offer them much…
How is it very selfish? He's given 14 years of his life to a company who have consistently ignored/neglected him artistically and failed to promote any of his solo activities for the past 2 years (even though his acting roles won AWARDS), and they gave a full tour to BinSan's subunit but not Rocky and JinJin's. And now Fantagio have debuted another 8-member boygroup (which has been in the works for the past 18 months), so it's clear they wouldn't have been paying any more attention to Rocky if he stayed there. I think he wanted to stay with Astro, but under new management (like other idols have done), but Fantagio clarified in their statement that this was not allowed, and that's why he had to leave the group.
And what do you mean they "have not managed to make a name for themselves"? Astro consistently have high sales with every new album, and are a HUGE success in across Asia. Just because they didn't boom in the US doesn't mean they aren't well-known.
Guy's it not all that glamorous.
Sanda stole Eunwoo away from Bin.
The company had Eunwoo to speak Bin about renew of contract after making him in the mid of preparing the sub unit come back. They had him trap after he worked so hard preparing for the come back and knows that Eunwoo his weakness. Eunwoo promise he will stay by him but bin only realised he was trick into signing after the company made him work nonstop throughout 2022 to cover the company money issue in2021.
He only realised he was trick that he was just a tool used by Sanda, Eunwoo and the company on Eunwoo birthday. When he was made to post a video of Binwoo almost kiss on Eunwoo birthday saying the four of them actually celebrate Eunwoo birthday but it was a lie.
The ideal of the video was actually from Sanda as shown in the video. Bin only learnt about Eunwoo tricking him with the contract on Eunwoo birthday. To use Binwoo to cover up his current lover Sanda. Sanda drove a distance and surprise Eunwoo who was having a meal with staff from filming. There fans asked where's is Bin because if Sanda shown up impossible Bin not around. So they have Bin upload the video created by Sanda to lie to their fans. The Video which Sanda wanted wasn't recorded on Eunwoo birthday but actually on Sanda birthday.
Another clear evidence was when Eunwoo say he bought food because Bin say he haven't eat but it was an excuse. When Bin tried to greet him he avoid Bin touch by showing him the food he bought but when Sanda reached out his hand to greet he immediately reached out and touched his hand the same hand he rejected Bin.
On 18.3.23 , Diffusion sub unit Korea concert Eunwoo suprise his lover by suddenly appearing to their concert even without makeup. Just a facemask. He hug Moonbin in a brotherly manner but with Sanda even though with a facemask he kiss Sanda shoulder while hugging him. You can find it on TH-cam. The difference is so different from day and night. I would say this is damn cruel for Moonbin when both of them know he still have feelings for Eunwoo that's why he trust him and signed the contract. After that he started acting a little different like broken not only inside but also shown during his concerts. He tried to endure for his fans. You could see his Twitters after that. His last concert he pretty much had it
Even though his love for the stage, mentally exhausted, physical and mentally with all the mind game going on and still have to interact with Sanha and the others like nothing happens because of the contract but he still gave his best as much as possible for his fans. He gave whatever energy he could specially to the song desire which was written personally by him for his love (Eunwoo).
They made him work nonstop in 2022 with little break but Sanha got to rest and enjoyed life even when the company was suffering loss by end of 2022 because his Eunwoo lover. 😢 A cruel world we live in. They don't deserve Bin love. Eunwoo letter of apology after Bin passing is just crap.
Sanda even wrote his letter of appearing weak in front of Bin. When he knows that what Bin actually Bin means was to ask him to stop playing victim to attract Eunwoo attention because only by playing victim can he appear defenceless and needs Eunwoo protection knowing very well Eunwoo doesn't allow Bin to call him hyung. In other words, have Eunwoo spoilt him by playing the younger and victim card. After a period it became a habit of Eunwoo doting on Sanda. Sanda will always look out if Bin and Eunwoo had any interaction even if each of them stations at one end of the corner and would appear unhappy if binwoo seems happy. He either interrupted their conversation or appeared unhappy. Then you will see Eunwoo approaching him with pda. All this while Bin was suffering from backlash.
The company tried to limit his popularity during the all night era by making him accept a gay role in 2019 knowing very well gay are not acceptable generally in South Korea. As the higher ups prefer Sanda even though the CEO kept changing they wants the audience to focus on Eunwoo and Sanda but they didn't expect Moonbin would go into hiatus for health reasons from the backlash of playing a gay role while he was still recovering from the previous backlash from Eunwoo jealous fans and Eunwoo haters who took it out on Moonbin.
They thought Moonbin would continue with activities for the group and get Sanda the original popularity they planned.
They never expected Moonbin going into hiatus would make Astro failed to get their first win.
Moonbin distanced himself from Eunwoo due to public views. So much hate on him and backlash. Sanda took this as an opportunity over the years. It was very clear when the company not only allowed the skinship of Sanda and Eunwoo in public but also in MV. While Moonbin was in the process of healing so Moonbin tried to take comfort with MJ and Seungkwan because no one was there for him very 😞 he never stop loving Eunwoo.
What is this
???
Are you self directing and acting all this in your head?? Come on!
@@zioluv I even provided you with evidences, you too lazy to search than you asked if self directing. That's why cause of people like you. His no longer with us due to neglecting especially by people around him for so long.
His company did career sabotage choices on him since 2019. When he was supposed to be shining since than. His bond by his contract what can he say when they already tried to control so much on him. Even when his fan tried to stood up for him during Vlive. Staff pretending to be fan in chat signal him to stop them. He can only follow orders and repeat what the staff wants. How he must have felt knowing that even his fans trying to defend him is something Astro PR also wants to control. A very sad life he lives. That's why he even asked running man Kim Jong-kook for advice on what he should do on his day off that he always felt lost. If you only follow what the company is trying to sell to the public and not Moonbin life for who he is than don't bother asking why he passed away. Afterall, the ones left in the company barely mistreated so there's nothing left to talk about. Like Moonbin mentioned before he is that guy. Members asked what that guy. Moonbin say Moonbin is Moonbin
I love Eun Woo, he led me to start loving Astro too, especially Moonbin, I believe all of them has their own fair share of talents. Ive watched almost all of their vlogs and all I see is a brotherly love. what I just read, cant be true. I love Moonbin and I have big respect for him, he is such a talented person, same goes with the rest of the members..
So park Bo yeon is rocky girlfriend?
Yes
@@nehakedar2618 shocked
@@nehakedar2618 How do you know that?
@@nehakedar2618 wow,are you a psychic or a stalker 🤔
No
Cha eun woo and friends
Jang wonyoung and friends
Got7 ❤
Is Rocky still dating that girl or have they broken up?
If he don't want with Astro just let him go. Now,, Astro is 5 boys who love each other and want to keep the group.
Rocky DOES want to be with Astro, he made that quite clear (he even kept the star in his IG profile, and wears his Astro friendship ring out in public at all times). But he clearly just couldn't stay under that awful company after the way they've treated them - Fantagio even clarified in their statement that he wasn't allowed to continue as a member of the group under a different label/company/contract (which suggests this is what Rocky initially wanted), and therefore he had to leave the group. Fantagio have been mistreating him for over a year now, it's no surprise he needed to get out of there. And Astro will always be OT6 at heart - even the boys said in their last stage together (where they already would've known Rocky was leaving) "please support each of us, even in our individual projects" - they still love Rocky, and he clearly loves them, but his mental health has to come first. Don't you think the rest of Astro 100% supports that decision too, since they love him? They've been together for so many years (11+ years in Binnie's case), that sort of friendship/love doesn't end because of Fantagio's contract stipulations. Just wait until Rocky's a soloist, I guarantee he'll be doing collabs with the Astro members all the time. 💜
@@_Eunoia_I am new to Astro.. but looking at all their videos, I always wonder why Rocky was made to swoon and act like he was crazy for eun woo especially in the years 2020-22. Earlier they we all like friends. It was very awkward to watch his talk like he was crazy abt eun woo and eun woo was like ok and very benevolent.. I feel rocky should not have done that .. also compared to sanha, he got less importance..
@@TheAnuc Rocky was always very supportive of Eunwoo, I'm not sure what you mean by him "being made to swoon and act like he was crazy for Eunwoo"? Their relationship seemed close right from the start, they'd already been together for 2 years before debut. Their trainee-day videos/iTeen content shows how close they all were. Rocky has always been a little awkward around other idols because he seems naturally shy/introverted, but with Astro he was a lot more energetic and outgoing because he seemed comfortable to be himself.
@@_Eunoia_Can you say which was that stage or video name that they mention about supporting him
@@aroo7924 1) Liking your own very recent comment on a year-old thread is a bit embarrassing hon. 2) Please clarify who you mean by "they" and "he", your question is incredibly vague.
I dont like Rocky, is like dont feel confident to him
His change came from a long time ago, he did not talk to his fans, he had no interest in communicating even before his relationship. He did not enter private platforms, his mind was no longer with ASTRO and he left them without caring about the group's projects and the Lack of a member who is in the military service was selfish, he is talented but he only cared about his comfort
i agree
Your fandom is the most selfish and vile out their and you out of all people trying to blame him ? please start having some shame. None of you cared to keep a track of his work nor cared to know about his updates. None of you cared to listen to what he said time to time. Your fandom continued bullying him for posting so much on sns , not posting much on sns , helping in doing parts of other members in concert, talking about other members , for being introduced with his designated position on a show and so much more. I am glad he is free from that hell now. and free from you. Good riddance. He don't have to constantly hear the stupid excuse of "he didn't give his all" for you to have an excuse to hate on him while he always gave his most . also he is not responsible for other members they are individual artists too lol
Well somebody doesn't even watch rocky closely 🤷. He only cared about his own comfort? Rocky's been selfless ever since. If you're really watching him closely, he doesn't miss the chance to express his gratitude to fans and show care for his group.
Funny you say that considering he was the member with the most VLIVEs and only stopped being extremely active when he had 3 drama at the same time then had to manage still being part of all ASTRO activity including overseas schedules and while preparing for a musical. This statement was never made about other members who prepared for things like musicals and went IA that time or who some members that have big scale projects then don't join group schedules for the meantime. What he did is far from comfort, it was overworking himself and still with the little time he has he did came on VLIVE and did drop a post once in a while. It's really just a prejudiced perspective, who already wants to see him negatively from the get go.
he was not the only one who "do not enter private platforms". he was also busy with his own projects like musical but of course, you forgot or didn't know about it, right?
aside from the mistreatment from the company, i believe he also left because of how some "fans" LIKE YOU, especially from korea and japan, just doesn't care about him and wanted him out. 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
Πολύ καλά έκανε και έφυγε αν το έκανε αυτό και ο Moonbini ίσως να ζουσε τώρα 😢😭
Ο Rocky γλυτωσε προς το παρόν.