Who danced each move in Dumdi Dumdi best?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ส.ค. 2020
- This is not an official analysis or dance rank. It is just be zooming in on those I feel did a great job with the move. It is to appreciate when everyone did it well and catch details that may have been missed earlier.
My Blackpink version of this seems to have gotten a lot of negative feedback over the past few days. I wonder if some popular Blink referenced it as bad. I got some rude responses. Please be positive and respectful even if you disagree. I really do look at every single person and explain why I picked the one I did. I would be happy to discuss w you all in a friendly way.
Here is what the distribution ultimately was:
Soojin = 53s
Yuqi = 50s
Minnie = 46s
Soyeon = 45s
Shuhua = 15s
Miyeon = 12s
Here is my overall observation:
Soojin is a spectacular dancer. Even when she isn’t the best, she’s very high. Every move is well timed, given the right energy, and looks beautiful. I’d basically just move off of her when she isn’t doing anything special or messed up a bit. The one thing is that she isn’t very charismatic in this dance practice and misses moments to show off and add a little extra to the moves like most other girls do.
Yuqi gives this dance a lot of energy and it really suits her. I think she is great with her lower body and general groove. However she sometimes looks kind of clumsy in her moves or isn’t as aware of her body orientation or arm placement.
Minnie is very notably great with upper body movements but usually inaccurate with her footwork. There are many times she makes awkward steps compared to everyone else. However, when she is able to get the feet, she usually looks the best. I feel she sells this groovy style overall hence why she stands out in the choreo and Uh Oh's choreo
Soyeon is clearly a good dancer. Overall, she usually does every move one of the best, but not the best. However, her musicality and attitude is always great.
Shuhua has really good musicality and awareness of her posture. She also underdances a lot. Sidenote, think her live stages are worse compared to this dance practice, likely due to her short skirted outfits. Shuhua is most comfortable here and this is the best I’ve seen her dance Dumdi Dumdi.
Miyeon really doesn’t do badly at all in this dance. I’m surprised she wasn’t able to snag more moments. She is someone who knows how to hold her body, particularly her hips. However, I think her weakness would be these fast and specific moves which she misses details on hence why this dance doesn’t make her shine.
"Miyeon" - I like her hair flip
lol me
It was a good flip!
Lmaoo
Minnie' s sudden improvement shooketh me this comeback
IKR! unlike others, i used to think minnie was the, how to say it? “less stronger” (cause no one is weak) dancer in (G)I-DLE. I got soooo impressed this comeback and I love it so much 💖
@@Luis1521angel I think she just didn't really tried her best in dancing before and also she had been working out lately and now she has the strongest body which helps in dancing too... If you watched their reality show she showed her skills and capability
@Yrla Maria then you have no eyes....
@Yrla Maria um you should not express your opinion when you obviously know nothing about what you're talking about.... Cause you are saying wrong things
@Yrla Maria but you said wrong things... If she doesn't dance well at all then she wouldn't debut plus many people admitted that her dancing improved a lot so I think your opinion was mainly to hate on her
times each was the focus
soojin: 12
soyeon: 9
minnie: 11
miyeon: 4
yuqi: 13
shuhua: 5
Wow you really payed attention-✨
:o unlike me :>
Yuqi-9
minnie’s dancing is so underrated
At first I thought minnie is a main dancer
Mmm actually I'm a Minnie bias but it was never underrated but this comeback people really noticed her fast improvement which it great
주노Juno it kinda was, they always said soojin, soyeons and yuqis dance was the best while minnie should also be in that list
@shadi you don't have to say it all the time yk
@@patrickdominguez6974 qqqqqqq
Things I learned from this video:
- Minnie should be on the dance line
- Soojin is the main dancer for a reason
- Yuqi go bounce bounce bounce
YES
Minnie is like Jihyo from twice, They can dance like a main dancer even though they're not part of the dance line.
@Kpop Jjang Lovers Yuju
@Kpop Jjang Lovers Rose'
@@mxchamii6708 Rosé it's actually Lead dancer so
@@stanbtsforaclearskin But AT TIMES when they are doing the same dance Rose dances like Lisa
0:23 is owned by Minnie ❤️❤️
Ikr!
Minnie improved a lot
Soojin and Soyeon ver consistent
Yuqi gains more confidence although she's already confident
Miyeon is back as main vocalist she's not meant to be a dancer but now she's a part of a girl group well she did very well
Let's talk about Shuhua a Lead Dancer potential her moves are very clean and controlled, I think she will only improve her timing, that's her weakness in becoming a lead dancer of idle.
Anyway, 💚💚💚
Leader dancer? I think minnie dances better to be in this position, shuhua needs to gain more confidence to execute the moves
At latata i thought shuhua is part of the dance line haha
@@leticialemos1133 for me it is because Minnie tends to overdance. Whole Shuhua tends to underdance. They're both good but I see more Shuhua to have more potential.
@@leticialemos1133 No one gonna gain confidence if you talk like that lol
miyeon is also good at dance but in this song she has more vocal part focus so her dance ability doesnt showed in this cb
Minnie coming for the lead/main dancer position
She really improved~
@Mateo Koceku Yes,but she knocked me out in this cb
@Mateo Koceku ain't she the 4th
@@justkma659 I think she's the 4th actually she can easily be the 3rd of she focuses more on dancing
@@juno1765 I'm sorry but she can't surpass yuqi now she should have trained more to be in that position. But she improve though
yuqi remains undefeated as queen of bounce. miyeon and shuhua on point. soojin taking the stage. soyeon and minnie main dancer material. we stan
Minnie was highlighted so many times only neverlands ignore her talent
I like Yuqi's bounces, looks like she's enjoying that.
Same
Minnie is a great dancer, love u queen Minnie
Minnie and Yuqi✨🔥❤️👍🏻👑
minnie dancing legend
i think a lot of things in this dance are stylistic choices
I agree! I like it. There are lots of little details and the members all dance quite differently
im telling you yuqi is really bouncy when she danced that it made her 10× more cuter *^*
I'm so proud of shuhua she improved so much since debut!
shuhua miyeon and minnie improved a lot
So proud of much miyeon and shuhua improved in their dancing😭💕
Um Minnie? Helooo?
I think soyeon did a great job in dumdi dumdi she's in #3 place for me
1 yuqi
2 soojin
3 soyeon
Yeah totally. As you can see she's only 1 second behind Minnie in my vid, that's less that one whole move. Soyeon always does one of the best!
I actually like yuqi best too!!!!
But, I will put soyeon second and soojin fourth after Minnie, because yes,soojin is a good dancer,but she sort of has a sexy vibe which is not really suitable for Dumdi Dumdi but is perfect Senorita. But whatever I respect your choice.
You don't rank a dancer based on their style but based on their technique . Soojin is far better than yuqi and soyeon she just has energy. There are so many good dancers who doesn't put much energy like Lisa yooa chungha Mina etc.
Hey everyone! I'm working on making a How Would SNSD Sing for the new ITZY and Dreamcatcher albums now! As well as a theory video for BOCA
I was about to ask will you make boca theory so i came here but i am happy you are making it
It would be better if you add a conclusion about the choreography of the members at the end of these kind of videos. I really like your videos 💪
everyone looks pretty much the same while doing the same choreo but Soojin during the whistle part looks SO FRICKIN FLIRTY I LOVE THIS WOMEN
soojin is my loveeee
Minnie💖
1:34 Yas she really killed that part when I watch her in MCountDown fancam tho😍 she really improved alot and I hope everyone will appreciate her in dancing, even tho she's not a main/lead/sub dancer😅 of the group.
Dance ranking
Soojin
Soyeon
Yuqi
Minnie
Shuhua and miyeon
Yes I'd agree. But, as we can see, it depends the choreo and sometimes even the move!
How Would Soshi Sing? yes, in omg i think miyeon dance better
In the dance practice video, Yuqi danced really great but in stages she really looked stiff, but maybe because of wardrobe. Soojin really owned the chorus.
I hope this gets more views! I'm really interested what others have to say
Edit: I just read your description and this makes me interested in your videos more. I'll support you ❤️
I appreciate that a lot! Feel free to share your own opinion too. My word isn't law and i love to discuss these things
Can you do Feel Special, Fancy and More And More
I already have More and More and Feel Special on my channel! I try to do current dances but if an older one really catches my eye I'll go back and do it. Fancy is definitely a contender. Thanks for suggesting
I’m so glad I clicked on this video bc I haven’t heard the song in a while and forgot how much I love Miyeon’s voice in the chorus. Also Yuqi’s bounces are everything
Ok but why no one talking about my girl yuqi she slayed this comeback her vocalsss and her dance amazing as always ✨❤️
0:31 look how my soyeon does her "glitched file" dance! Her way is perfect!
3:00 - 3:08 should be soojin her hips are more flowy and the angle in the "flute" dance steps are perfect
Yuqi's bouncy energy in the second pre-chorus is everything
My eyes trying to read the reasoning and watch them ↖️↙️↗️↙️⬇️↙️↗️↙️↖️⬇️↙️⬅️⬇️➡️⬇️👁👄👁
why is the quality like this? 😭
Sorry. It's because I have to zoom in a lot to get each member. Some videos of mine are better when the members are closer to the front or when I can get individual fancams (which I would only do for like 5 or less members now if at all)
@How Would Soshi Sing?
it’s okay! i was just wondering because like you said, the quality’s looked better in some of your other videos & it’s a bit more difficult to see the moves clearly. thanks for your response
I really want Minnie's shoes
Minnie 💗
Thanked god I found your channel! I like ypur opinions a lot!!
3:20 RIP soojin's knees
love ur vids 👍
Soojin and Shuhua queens ♡
Yuqi main dancer lezzz get it
It’s Yuqi for me
Before this, I’ve never noticed how great and fast Miyeon’s footwork is....!! 1:35
Do SSOTS of Izone!!💕
Every time I see Soojin in thr screen I can’t help but cry. I will forever be an OT6 but I will still support them despite of what happened
For me...everyone danced best.......i love them all....😊😊😊
this is the proof yuqi is lead dance
ugh minnie and shuhua improve 💗
Color me surprised. Even though my bias is Miyeon I didn't expect her to get nearly as many focuses as she did! 😅
I really liked it ,it even helped me in correcting my dance moves thx for the informative content...... BTW can u do a video like this on everglow dun dun pls.
Love this song 😍😍😍😍😍😍
Yuqi stood out the most and I think was the best. Minnie also improved alog
I'm honestly in love with your channel, I've been watching your videos all through the day, since I only today found your channel! 🥺❤ Thank you so much for the work. I have a lil question as well. How do you differenciate moves that are "part of the choreography" from moves that are part of someone's style? Like, say the head nods where you stated that Soojin was the only one to remember. Do you compare it to the other chorus or do you find fancams and stages and also look at the dance there?
minnie my baby
I don't know why I did this but I counted who got the most moves "best"
1. Yuqi (13 moves)
2. Soojin (12 moves)
3. Minnie (10 moves)
4. Shuhua (5 moves)
5. Miyeon (5 moves)
6. Soyeon (4 moves)
Hopefully I counted correctly!
Minnie’s intro shall forever remain iconic
look how minnie shook us this comeback
Miyeon dancing has always improved since Uh Oh and yes main vocal slay
minnies dance movements are so smooth
Sorry my file glitched here is a nice observation of soyeon movements
ENDING FAIRY BEST HAIR CHO D B
Our main dancer is the best 😍
I will be never land after this video
Minnie is sooooo underrated dancer.
I think she should be in the dance line.
Just my opinion though
Could you do a Tomboy video? 😅❤
Can you do Hwaa?
Can i request? Can you do gfriend apple?
Minnie can be a lead dancer.
Oh wow i just watch a different who danced the best by a dancer you both list is very different :o
Ahhaha the floor girl
Dumdi dumdi dance really suit with yuqi and minnie
Soojin my dancing queen. Sorry not sorry girllsss
I loveee yuqi’s bounces omg
can u secret story of the swan by izone and any svt song
youve got to be kidding me 😭
Minnie's hip dance
For me as a dancer
1. Soojin ( obviously no doubt)
2. Yuqi ( she's good)
3. Soyeon ( can actually be a lead dancer if she tries)
4. Minnie( she has energy but she makes some mistakes time to time ) / Miyeon ( the exact opposite of Minnie she doesn't have much energy but her moves are correct mostly and smooth)
5 shuhua ( sorry but she has a long way to go, shes just an below average dancer with good stamina and high energy)
Shuhua is offbeat sometimes on stage, usually a bit too early
i am a new neverland this dumdi dumdi era, and istg i thought minnie was part of the dance line 😳
I meaaan look at that yuqi bounce it makes me happy too?? hshahshhaha
minnie marry ne
in conclusion minnie should be lead. position
after dumdi dumdi era I'd say the dance ranking is like this:
1. Soojin
2. Soyeon
3. Minnie/Yuqi
4. Minnie/Yuqi
5. Shuhua
6. Miyeon
with 3rd and 4th place it's hard to say because minnie's improvement is crazy but i'm not sure if she's better than yuqi. personally I prefer minnie's dancing, but I don't want to be called biased or something.
also, I think that dance positions should be like this:
Main dancer - Soojin
Lead dancers - Soyeon, Minnie, Yuqi
All
secret story of the swan izone please
when yuqi bounces, she looks like she's enjoying the choreography lol
Please gfriend apple and Dreamcatcher BOCA
actually it doesn't matter. they are not meant to dance in a same robotic way, because their concept has always been members individuality and they are staying true to that.
honestly can we just agree that all members of gidle at this point could be in the dance line
Yuqi = 12
Soojin = 12
Minnie = 11
Soyeon = 9
Shuhua = 5
Miyeon = 4
I’m sorry but I can’t with soojins bangs-
miyeon is crying lol
Are you sure you're a professional dancer . Cause in the chorus in the dumdi dumdi part no one did the body roll except soojin and miyeon a little bit but you pointed yuqi and Minnie who did it worst , they didn't even actually do any chest rolls.
This choreo looks more like a TikTok dance than an actual song....
Maybe but they said it was not
Btw they are not the ones who cheographed
What group is this?
(G)I-DLE
I’m not a fan of Gidle but Is Minnie the main dancer or Soyeon?
Soojin is the main dancer, Soyeon is the former lead dancer (but more experts rank her at 2nd place), and Yuqi the lead dancer since debut. Minnie is easily the best dancer out the dance line
Idk why Soyeon got removed from her dance position, she deserves it so much. Maybe because she has already too many positions? Or maybe the sites I check are not that accurate
are you a dancer?
Miyeon: am i a joke to you?
So Minnie being a main vocalist is the second best dancer.......