Fix - Duplicate / Alternate page with proper CANONICAL tag [SOLVED]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ต.ค. 2023
- Correct way to fix - Alternate page with proper CANONICAL tag & Duplicate Google chose different canonical than user.
We're going to discuss a common issue in Google Search Console - Alternate Page Errors - and how to resolve them using proper canonical tags."
What is an Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user error ?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
When 2 different pages very similar content then you see this error in google search console and google will index only one url in that case.
What is an Duplicate page with proper canonical tag error ?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
When 2 different pages have exact same content then google decides that which page to index in search engine.
Common pages face this issue
-------------------------------------------------
1) AMP / mobile pages
2) Woocommerce pages, wordpress action links
3) Multilingual pages
Code for robots.txt
Disallow: /*(enter here the pattern you see in search console report)
Conclusion
----------------------------
"To fix canonical tag issues, assess your pages,
1) use the removal tool, and
2) implement robots.txt rules where needed."
like, subscribe, and comment for further assistance.
Thank you for watching and we'll see you in the next video!"
Links to videos mentioned in this Tutorial
====================================
Rankmath Step by Step Tutorial
• Rank Math SEO plugin S...
Search Console Full Tutorial
• Complete Google Search...
Solve GSC (Google Search console) Errors
• Google Search Console
Credits : www.flaticon.com/free-icons/s..." title="stupid icons Stupid icons created by Smashicons - Flaticon
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @letscreateyourwebsite
#googlesearchconsole #seo #google
![Fix : Discovered - Currently not Indexed | Crawled - Currently not Indexed [SOLVED]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tGoBfN5RB_g/mqdefault.jpg)
![Fix : Discovered - Currently not Indexed | Crawled - Currently not Indexed [SOLVED]](/img/tr.png)
🚩 All Search Console Issues Solution -- th-cam.com/play/PLNMMOUlW_zxtJ0CpEAaCcK6fz1EctLhGW.html&si=IEgU-GF9DQ4jnF8H
🚩 Rank Math Dedicated Video / Best Settings -- th-cam.com/video/naqRvQ_a3Ak/w-d-xo.html
🚩 Google Search console Complete Guide -- th-cam.com/video/01NYa01j-1Y/w-d-xo.html
🚩 Index and Rank your Website -- th-cam.com/video/tySXGs3jYxs/w-d-xo.html
🚩🚩SUPPORT SMALL CREATORS BY SUBSCRIBING: 15000 WEBSITE LEARNERS COMMUNITY🔥🔥🔥🔥 Let's Do it !!!!
(Try some new video to see my journey on youtube and let me know if I improved 😇🙏 )
Comment to show your support, And also if you are stuck somewhere don't hesitate to comment. I answer all the comments on my channel.
Absolutely incredible video! From start to finish, I was completely captivated. Thank you for sharing such amazing content with us. I've never subscribed to any channel before, but yours deserves millions of subscribers, and I'm proud to be one of them. Can't wait to see more from your channel
Thank you very much for such a nice comment. it really boost the moral. 1 million is not far. Soon it will reach there. Thanks for subscribing to the channel , I really appreciate that!
I was looking for a tutorial like this for months. Thank you for saving time
Glad I could help! thanks for taking your time to comment and giving your feedback. Hope you checked other videos on search console errors and SEO. Welcome to the channel again 😇❤🔥
This was really helpful for me.. I watched alot of videos on resolving the technical errors.. by far this has made me understand on resolving the Duplicate page with proper canonical tag error! Thankyou!
You are most welcome, really happy to know that my video helped you so much. thanks for taking your time to comment on the channel.
You deserve at least 3 million subscribers. Keep it up, bro!
Thanks so nice of you to say. thanks for the support bro ❤
Awesome video! Given this a go on my new shopify website. So fingers crossed!
Best of luck! I am sure you will get the results. Just need to wait a lof for google to update the daya. It might take months sometimes.
Very Good Effort Brother, Keep the Bars Higher by creating such informative videos, Really Appreciated 🎉
I have also subscribed to your channel now.
Thanks for your support brother ❤
Thanks for explaining clearly. Since I use a Wix site, some of the aspects of WordPress could make me not understand from the tech perspective. If you can cover relevant aspects from Wix users' perspective, it will be highly good. Anyhow, you explain well. I already subscribed to you and let's follow your videos.
Glad it was helpful! Yes somethings cannot be related to wix but I will try to clear the general concepts so that they can be applied to any kind of websites. Thank you for subscribing that means a slot. and future I will try to make a video on WIX issues. Have a great rest of the year. :)
YOu have solved complex issues. Your video is really awesome.
Glad to hear that, very happy about your experience. please share the video in your social media to help channel grow. I will really appreciate that!
finally!!! a super useful video!!! thank you!!!
You are most welcome. thanks for taking your time to comment and interacting with me :)
This is an interesting and educative video. Be blessed.
Really happy to hear that, thank you very much for your comment. Stay blessed ❤
This is a fantastic presentation. Let me ask, I have 7 different shoes to display and each has 5 different images showing various views. The descriptions are the same except for one place in the description where the color is mentioned. They have different SKUs. I am having this on WordPress and the reason for not using variation products is to be able to present the five different images for each. The title of the page reads Kamsy blazing shoe white, Kamsy blazing shoe red, etc. Am I likely to get flagged by Google for duplicate pages?
Hello Dear, thanks for the comment. So you do not need to worry about that in that case. Google understand how product variation works and if you are using product variations then there is no issue for the products. If you are adding separate product for different colors then it can be issue. Rest don't worry about it too much,it is totally normal.
the best thing would be to look at search console report and see which urls are showing there. Don't forget to check other search console video, i am sure they will surely help you with your website SEO.
Your video is really awesome. LOVE YOU BRO
Thank you so much brother😀 thanks for your comment , happy that you get value out of the videos 😇❤
I wish I could give your great videos more than a million likes.
Thanks brother , your 1 Like is worth million. Happy to have such great supporters. You can always share the channel on your social media and tell your friends about it, that will be really helpful
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE Certainly I will !
Thank you So MUCH for Solving my problem
You are most welcome, happy to help :)
Hi thanks for the infos. I just have the same problem with Alternate... for my Blogger website though there are 2 different pages with different content. So there is no way to index the second page??
Hello Dear, happy to help. So if you have 2 pages with different content then check which is the google chosen canonical for the pages, if those pages are both on your website and content is different then you can use request indexing option to tell google that it is a faux detect. Also check if the canonical tag of one page is not making the canonical to the other pages, they should have the self canonical tag in both of the pages.
i have a lot of these "errors" in my GSC. It is too much work to fix them individually. Is it worth fixing ? Do they affect SEO negatively ?
super helpful! thank you! Where would I find the pages tab in GA4?
Thanks for your comment, so this is something you find in GSC - Google search console not in GA ;)
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE ah thank you!
you're most welcome!
bro please make video about "Crawled - currently not indexed" I Really Love Your Way of Explaining, Love You Bro
You know what, I am working on that video and that will be released very soon, Love you 200 Brother!
my search console is showing some different website's URL is indexed instead of mine with error "Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user" and that website have copied my whole website. how to resolve this. kindly help
I have an issue with alternate pages having proper canonical tags that show 'amp' and 'noamp=mobile.' As you mentioned, it is okay because I use an amp plugin, so there's nothing to be done about that. However, the total number of pages with alternate page canonicals is 34K, but I can only see 1K in the search console. Why is that?
so it seems you might have pages listed outside your sitemap. Check if the pages are there - generate by plugins, orders, data strings etc. 1 am sure 34k pages are the pages with the next pages numbers, variations etc. Watch other videos on series to understand the whole concept about the indexing and management of the pages. there are 5-6 videos but after watching all your queries will be resolved.
Is there any reason to disallow these for duplicate pages instead of just ignoring them? I assume there is no actual change in GSC besides it just not showing these anymore
hello, so depends what kind of pages are those. if they are content pages and needs to eb indexed then we need to see that why it is sayign duplicate. if there are some pages which should not be included like theme code pages or non essential urls then if is good to disallow then. that will be save your crawl budget. Rest if the pages are not important then you can always ignore those pages!
What about in case of using hreflang? Google won't index the page with for eg en_gb version of the same product page..what can be done in this situation? Both the product pages are exactly the same only url has en_gb and we want that product to be visible across multiple countries. Any info on this is appreciated. Thank you!
Hello, okay so I can understand that it can be very complicated. but google is right at it's logic. Why the url's are same? I know most of the websites make a page for example /contact/ in english and /de/contact/ for dutch. What I think it should be done.
1) Change the translation page url to the local language for example de/kontakt/
2) Add the local title and meta description different from the other translation and try to make it unique.
3) Ensure that the content on your language pages is unique and substantially different. Avoid duplicating large blocks of content across multiple versions. Each language or regional page should provide unique and relevant information.
Try to make the different language page as unique as possible. Use a different image, heading . more of less headings.
Thank you for your reply!@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE We have implemeted Translate Press plugin which automatically adds en_gb etc country codes in the url but my challenge is these pages are not getting indexed. We want our products to be shown in other countries and hreflang tag helps with that hence we implemented TranslatePress. Any insight on this?
did you tried testing the url dierctly and live status, sometimes pages are indexed but shows not indexed. It is really hard to give you exact info without seesin all the backend and pages.
well explained!
happy that you liked it and it was easy to understand :)
Good video Bro! ☝️🔥🔥🔥
Google should do something with the Google console, because it produces too many errors and wastes time.If we make money, they make money too!They should be more motivated
Thanks brother, agree google needs a lot of improvement at identifying pages and showing the reports 🔥🔥
can we disallow robot to index ?m=1 also?
A video will come soon on this topic. I added this into the list. Keep an eye on the channel!
*HELLO SIR THANKS FOR THE GREAT ILLUSTRATION. I HAVE A QUESTION DO I REALLY NEED AN AMP PLUGIN ON MY WEBSITE, IT IS DESIGNED TO BE MOBILE RESPONSIVE ALREADY?*
Hello Dear, Don't use any amp plugin. it does worse than it bring the benefit. Watch my other videos to increase the website speed , because amp is good for website loading on mobile devices, but if your website is fast then you don't need amp. Hope I answered your question 😇❤
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE thanks very much
If we leave those urls in there and they are no longer on our website, does it affect our other website ranking in a negative way?
Hello, So if those urls are not longer on website and you have not related urls then do not worry about it. Either request for removal or wait for few weeks upto few months and google will remove those from their database.
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE Yes I understand but is that going to affect our website from ranking because we are not providing accurate information ?
I get this message when testing my blogger url URL will be indexed only if certain conditions are met...
And when i try to request indexing then it shows - Alternative page with proper canonical tag... And Crawled - currently not indexed...
hello, so it means that another page is choose as a canonical url. try to find out if the other page has the same content like this oen, if not then check in settings that if the forced canonical tag is applied. end of the day it's on google then which page it shoes to chose as canonical and index on search engine. Watch the video again and you will understand the issue. give more details so that i can investigate it further
Hii I have many URLs on my website that has ?version=1.0 at the end
These are in Alternate Page with Proper canonical tags
What can be done for these?
Hello, so you need to see where they are coming from. Seems they are some version management of pages. Try to find the plugin/ theme is creating those and disable them from there . hit on the cause of the issue to have right solution.
can i allow something to crawl like [swcfpc=1]because my 134 pages showing this issue and all have different content.kindly need a little guidance
hello Sara, so it is little complicate to say something without looking at actual report. More details will be helpful.
In alternate page with proper canonical tag i have a error "?noamp=mobile". How to rectify it..either modify robots txt file or something else
hello, so AMP is outdated and not very useful. Just switch site without AMP and then wait for few weeks those url's will be gone. Don't worry about this issue too much!
Hi there I 301 redirected my default wp site page to a new page I just created. the new page has its own canonical url and did rank on google for a few weeks but now it has the alternative page error. I don't have any errors relating to the urls in the video. Should I just submit for indexing again? I don't want to ignore it because my page is not ranking at all now.
t sounds like you might be encountering an issue with your 301 redirect or the way Google is interpreting it. Here are some steps to troubleshoot and fix the "alternative page error" you're seeing:
1. Verify the 301 Redirect:
Double-check that the 301 redirect is set up correctly and points to the exact URL of your new page. There shouldn't be any typos or extra characters.
You can use a website like www.whynopadlock.com/ to test the 301 redirect and see if it's functioning properly.
2. Check for Redirect Chains:
Avoid redirect chains where one page redirects to another, which redirects to another, and so on. This can confuse search engines. Ensure the 301 redirect goes directly from your old default WordPress page to the new target page.
3. Inspect the New Page in Search Console:
Use Google Search Console (search.google.com/search-console/about) to inspect the new page specifically. Look for any crawl errors or indexing issues related to the new URL.
4. Consider the "Alternative Page" Interpretation:
The "alternative page error" might not necessarily mean Google has indexed another page instead. It could be interpreting your 301 redirect in a way that suggests there's an alternative version of the content available.
While resubmitting for indexing can't hurt, it might not be the solution here.
Recommendations:
Fix the 301 Redirect: If you find any issues with the redirect setup, correct them immediately.
Disavow Conflicting Redirects (if applicable): If there were previous redirects for the same URL, you might need to disavow them in Search Console to prevent confusion.
Monitor Indexing Status: Keep an eye on your new page's indexing status in Search Console. It might take some time for Google to re-crawl and understand the 301 redirect properly.
Consider a Canonical Tag (Optional): You can add a canonical tag to your new page pointing to itself. This reinforces that this is the primary version of the content. However, since you already have a 301 redirect, this might not be strictly necessary.
Now after submitting it for indexing it has changed to "Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user". Any suggestions on how to overcome this?
see in the report that which is the canonical chosen by the google and then you will know why that is the preferred one.
Please how can we fix Discovery, -
Sitemaps
No referring sitemaps detected error on GSC
provide more details dear on this topic
If I do redirect 301 to me new website and It show Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user. how to fix it ? if my old website has good seo result
no you are saying to google with 301 redirect that this is the new url. Google understand that.
Hello very good video. But, what for those URL that I wan to be on Google and said alternative page with... I don't have duplicated page and Miss, Google say again again Alternative page., What can I do? Thank you
aha, that's what you think. check if the content on the pages is very similar like header , footer is same on all pages and then the main content is very small . that can be the case. If you are confident that you have enough unique content on the pages then , go on a mark as fix the pages and submit to google to reconsider.
How long does it take to take effect once you disallow the pages? I have done it few days ago and still have over 4k errors. All pages i am trying to disallow have something like ?pr_prod_strat and they are duplicates created as of result of the variants i suppose. Do you know why haven't the errors cleared?
Disallowing pages through robots.
txt doesn't guarantee immediate removal from search results. Here's a breakdown of the timeline:
Cache Refresh: Search engines like Google cache the robots.txt file, typically for a day or so. So, it might take a day or two for Google to recognize your recent changes.
Crawling and Re-indexing: Even after recognizing the changes, Google needs to recrawl the disallowed pages and re-process them based on your instructions. This crawling process can take time, especially for large websites.
So, a few days is a normal timeframe to see the effects of your robots.txt changes.
However, there could be reasons why you're still seeing errors:
Large Number of URLs: With 4k URLs, it might take Google longer to recrawl and update its index.
Previously Indexed Pages: If these pages were previously indexed, Google might consider them valuable and keep them in the index for a while despite the robots.txt disallow.
Here are some suggestions:
Monitor Robots.txt: Use tools like Google Search Console to monitor if Google is recognizing your robots.txt directives.
Wait for Recrawling: Give it more time, especially if you have a large website.
Consider Removal Request: If it's urgent, explore submitting a removal request through Google Search Console for the specific URLs you want to be removed faster. This is separate from robots.txt and might expedite the process.
As for the duplicate pages with "?pr_prod_strat" parameter, robots.txt can handle these. You can use wildcards in your disallow directive to block all URLs containing that parameter.
For example, a directive like Disallow: /*?pr_prod_strat would disallow all URLs containing "?pr_prod_strat".
Hi, I am facing the page duplication and page not found error which impact on the analytics.
when i click on this error then i am seeing there are 4k URLs and these are of the duplicate products URLs. i am deleting all these duplicate products manually from the website and keep the original one.
And on this error i am seeing there are 2k URLs. What should i do to resolve this error.
First error with 4k URLs
Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user
Second error with 2k URLs
Not found (404)
hello dear, I understand that you are having this issues in bulk. but I need more information about urls. Also if you watch the videos again in the playlist you will get the idea that how to deal with them.
Rest give me more data about the patters if these urls so that I can help you better!
awesome man
Glad you enjoyed it
Hi.. regarding the amp= issue, is it no need to add a 301 redirect for those urls before removeing it?
No, you generally don't need to add a 301 redirect for URLs with the amp= parameter before removing it. Here's why:
AMP URLs are separate: AMP pages are considered separate versions of your original web pages. They have different URLs with the amp= parameter.
Focus on canonical: The important factor for SEO is the canonical URL, which points to the main version of your webpage (the one without amp=). Ensure your canonical URLs correctly reference the non-AMP versions.
Google handles AMP removal: When you remove the AMP version of a page, Google will eventually stop indexing it. There's no need for an additional redirect on your end.
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE same for no_amp=mobile too??
yes , for all amp pages.
yes, for any amp pages;
Brother, this line ”/?attribute” must be ”Disallow: /*?attribute_pa” or ”Disallow: /?attribute_pa”? My robots starts like this:
User-agent: Googlebot
Disallow:
User-agent: Googlebot-Image
Disallow:
User-agent: *
Brother, the correct syntax for disallowing URLs with the parameter "?attribute_pa" in your robots.txt file would be either:
Disallow: /*?attribute_pa
OR
Disallow: /?attribute_pa
Both of these lines would effectively instruct search engine crawlers not to index URLs containing the parameter "?attribute_pa". Make sure to choose the one that aligns with your specific URL structure and requirements.
Google is saying for my website is "Alternate page with proper CANONICAL" for www. and when I check/test it in Search Console, it says User-declared canonical: (my domain) without www. So if I check my site without www is indexed and everything well, when I test with www, it says CANONICAL. How can I fix it? Thanks
hello it seems that there is a issue with choosing the canonical url. here are few things to
1) make sure your website is set up to redirect on www urls properly.
2) start rankmath / yoast seo wizard again and make sure you have added the www if asked anywhere.
Usually it happens when you use both versions of site www and without it. Again everything in GSC are not errors, but they are there to guide about your website. It might take few weeks/ months to see the updated info in GSC
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE I fixed by using elementor and creating homepage with adding www domain as canonical in yoast
@@toti_key thanks for letting us know what you did!
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE thank you for your reply and trying help me
Love you all ❤
What is amp? How do I know If I have or have not used amp? I have over 2k indexing issues.
Amp is accelerated mobile pages, if you are using an amp plugin then you might have this issue with amp, if not then there is nothing to worry about amp. Sometimes themes provide AMP option , check if that is enabled there. What are those 2k issue ? Did you see my easy, small and informative playlist to get rid of all of your search console errors.
th-cam.com/video/ea_zwInwIBc/w-d-xo.html
Hi, for the pages with query string, I can't find robots.txt in cpanel. How do I go about to solve it?
Hello, when you login inside file manager.. Check show hidden files. If you still cannot see the robots. Txt file that means there is no robots. Txt file.. So should create one youself.
Bro iam facing video Indexing issue can please make a video on this
& Crawl budget also
Bro, i created video on that topic last week. You did not saw ? Here you go the link to that video th-cam.com/video/XgxE2RDrtP0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=bRJI6A3ERHU2Hrhv
well done
thanks brother ❤
Hi, how do I fox alternate page with proper canonical tag that end in pr_seq=uniform?
Hello Dear, add this as blocked in roboots.Txt watch this video here to understand this th-cam.com/video/v4gxB3ldfmg/w-d-xo.htmlsi=nJvH7327dI1OSaMH&list=PLNMMOUlW_zxs8Gcts1c01PsIs-2emMZSD
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE Thanks so much
@@faithokezie8413 you're most welcome dear :)
I have problem with "more than one meta description"
can you provide more details please, this is not sufficient to understand the issue and tell you a solution?
Sir, in WordPress, the auto-update column does not show on the Plugin page. Sir, please suggest a solution to resolve the problem. Waiting for your reply.
Hello Dear, check to ensure that define(‘AUTOMATIC_UPDATER_DISABLED’, true); is not set in wp-config.php
do you have special sosial media account for answering quastion?
TH-cam is the only place, I spend so much time here that I don't have anymore time to manage another platform. Sorry dear. You can ask your question here.
hi sir i am facing Alternate page with proper canonical tag issue but i tried to solve still i did not get any result can you please me
Hello Dear, what method you applied from the video to solve the alternate page with proper canonical tag issue ?
All my pages are attachments what can I do?
what do you mean by attachments ? are they images .. can you explain more in detail.
Thanks I lost 90% of my blog traffic, I suspect its duplicates amp which I changed the plugin.
You are most welcome dear, i replied about amp on your other comment in detail :)
How solve this issue in blogger blogspot?
hello, so blogger does not give many options to manage SEO on your blog that is why people move to wordpress, but to avoid this issues make sure you do not have same content on 2 blogger posts/pages. that is the best way to avoid this error on blogger
Does anyone know how to fix pr_seq=uniform?
this will be shown in the error fir discovered/craweled not index - right ? if yes try to find out which plugin is doing that and exclude that from the site map. if it is not in the site map then add the code in robots.txt to stop google crawling that . let me know more details
thank you so much for your info， but your accent is difficult to understand
Sorry to hear that, I am working on slower and better delivery!
@@LetsCreateYourWEBSITE thankl you always
Bhai hindi mai. Bana leta
hindi sab log nahi bolte bharat me, english ek common language hai bharat aur poori duniya ki. waise ek hindi wala channel bhi hai , agar hindi videos me intrested ho to us channel ko check out kar sakte ho, ye raha link www.youtube.com/@FreeWebDevAcademy
Thank you again for a great video. I have stripped the category bases (through rankmath) but decided to change this want to see the category base. However now google is giving the " chose a different canonical" amd indexing the previous versin without the category base. Is there a solution to fixing these to have google index the ones with category bases? (i.e. url/post is chosen however I want url/category/post/ to be indexed) Many thanks..
hello, this error does not comes because of striping the category base, check in the report which is chosen as canonical. then analyze those pages and see if they have similar content.
All my 800 pages on this error has ?pr_prod HOWEVER there is no / before this, so do i input disallow without the /
hello just use the string ?pr_prod to disallow it. also you can test your tobots.txt file after making that change by this tool technicalseo.com/tools/robots-txt/
Should I do this /*?pr_prod
Ok so I have 3000 various ones with this at the end ref_pid=2837579628608&pr_seq=uniform Do you do something about it? It just keeps increasing thanks for ant suggestions.
Check if your site is hacked , I have few videos on the website security. this is not normal when the url are keep getting increasing. Watch my wordfence and antimalware tutorial.
Thanks a lot for your video it helps me a lot i have page with this ending in url /?lang=de/ and changed to /de/ is this true to add this Disallow: /*?lang=*
hello, No do not disallow the language tag. Watch my recent video on language SEO I have covered this topic in so much detail. You will know the correct strategy.
🚩 All Search Console Issues Solution -- th-cam.com/play/PLNMMOUlW_zxtJ0CpEAaCcK6fz1EctLhGW.html&si=IEgU-GF9DQ4jnF8H
🚩 Rank Math Dedicated Video / Best Settings -- th-cam.com/video/naqRvQ_a3Ak/w-d-xo.html
🚩 Google Search console Complete Guide -- th-cam.com/video/01NYa01j-1Y/w-d-xo.html
🚩 Index and Rank your Website -- th-cam.com/video/tySXGs3jYxs/w-d-xo.html
🚩🚩SUPPORT SMALL CREATORS BY SUBSCRIBING: 15000 WEBSITE LEARNERS COMMUNITY🔥🔥🔥🔥 Let's Do it !!!!
(Try some new video to see my journey on youtube and let me know if I improved 😇🙏 )
Comment to show your support, And also if you are stuck somewhere don't hesitate to comment. I answer all the comments on my channel.