THIS IS NOT REAL LIFE, IT IS ONLY THE TXT UNIVERSE STORY WRITTEN BY BIGHIT. THIS IS FICTIONAL. A lot of people are asking where the concept photos are - THEY ARE NOT ON INSTAGRAM. They are fabricated photos MADE TO LOOK LIKE SOCIAL MEDIA by BigHit for the album and can be found here (scroll down and hit "port"): ibighit.com/txt/eng/discography/detail/the_dream_chapter-eternity.php
I was making a morse code translate of the teaser from The Dream Chapter: Eternity. so if you want you can use it for a Video. Hope you have a nice day. :D
Gfriend coming back soon Also small mini theory: What if the Dytopia tree from Dreamcatchers storyline is the same tree that gives exo their powers in their storyline (Which may or may not connect also to red Velvet being connected to exo)
Hai sis... I just want to tell you, that you should to hear 'someone' voice in magic island music video, which is 10 minutes 24 second (when the train want to crash into them) and you will hear ‘someone’ voice, idk whats she say but the voice repeat 3rd times, thanks you:)
Tae Spoon Of Suga I was like w-what? Then I looked up at the profile picture and BURSTED out laughing and ending up choking in the middle of the night!
I love the transition of this music video. The choreography had so much detail and story to it and the MV itself just had two things I love, cute and dark concepts 💕
let's be real tho, even in crown the lyrics were actually really dark if you take time to analyze it, also run away. they just covered it up with fun, poppy, fresh bg music. 😂
@@chaerry5329 Thats why I love those songs so much! It's really sad but the musical arrangement and the music video makes to sound so fun until chaos happens. 😂
bighit is an entertainment industry that focuses on music for healing so its pretty frequent when they have deeper meanings in their music. so i say TRUUU
In the choreography, they touch each part that hurts them. Ears, eyes, shoulders, heart, and head. Also, in the choreo, taehyun and soobin are controlling Kai. Which could mean he's gullible. Which also goes with your theory
Earlier in the mv, Beomgyu covered Taehyun trying to suffocate him because he suspects him (or maybe Beomgyu was the liar and trying to kill Taehyun the detective to get rid of evidences and the witness) And in the choreo everyone leans toward Beomgyu and in the lyrics he said *"I resent you a lot."* And Taehyun controlled Kai and used him to replied that it's *"because you don't understand me."* And Kai seems to lose his mind because everyone is controlling him and he don't know who to believe anymore. And next is Soobin, it seems like he's telling Kai to look at him, understand him, and stay by his side (bcoz he forced kai to look at him in the Choreo) and the lyrics were *"Please stop the resentment."* And if you notice it all from the concept trailer, Soobin was saying "Save Me." Save me from this resentment, Please believe me. Why am I left alone again? Why can't you see me? And there's Yeonjun who seemed to start the fire or the resentment or the problem. Idk. So.. Who's the liar among them? I'm losing my mind too trying to understand it all to be honest.
Parts that hurts? Soobin's ears bcoz of what he heard? Taehyun's eyes because of what he saw? Beomgyu's shoulder because he don't want them to lean on him, thus destroying their friendship? (lol idk) Kai's heart because he's too softhearted? And Yeonjun's mind... Idk why AHAHA. I hope bighit explain this all or I'm gonna lose my mind soon
Kai and Yeonjun do the pinky promise sign, meaning that they're the only ones keeping the promise they made, still having fun and all, not aware of what's going on in the friend group. They're innocent and naive, as Yeonjun starts the fires and commits terrible things by mistake; every time he joins Boemgyu into having fun he ends up doing something bad. Boemgyu on the other hand makes the horns sign in the choreography: he's the traitor, corrupted by Soobin (aka the cat) into breaking the group apart, the one who breaks the promise and stays in disguise while causing problems. He's always making sure that Yeonjun follows him creating problems. _Boemgyu is the one taking everyone to Soobin's house and ringing the doorbell, he was invited by Soobin _Boemgyu wants cookies (he's the only one shown biting into one) > Yeonjun makes cookies leaving the oven turned on, causing the fire _Boemgyu starts the fruit fights (blending strawberries, throwing the first tomato and throwing jam at Taehyun) > Yeonjun goes on the table, joins the fruit fights and realizes he's taken them too far only when it's too late _Boemgyu goes on the bed > Yeonjun follows him leaving a dirty shoe mark on the sheets _Beomgyu is wearing a shirt with a smile on, he's aware and happy of the results he's achieved and is happy in the tomato mess on the floor _Boemgyu tries to kill Taehyun because he found out about what he and Soobin are really doing _Boemgyu is aware of everything, he even looks at the camera when everybody is watching TV. He's enjoying the disaster he's caused (the red screen), eating chips. Soobin (aka the cat) might have taken control over Boemgyu, the camera even focuses on his eye
paniced! gay Maybe he realized it and either joined Soobin and Beomgyu or joined Taehyuns side but wanted the viewers to keep quiet because he knew sooner or later Soobin and Bemogyu will kill Taehyun because he found out?
Any of yall notice TXT’s first 2 albums are the color of the cats eyes blue and green 😳 Edit: AND SOOBINS HAIR IS PURPLE AND THE ETERNITY ALBUM IS PURPLE AND SOOBIN IS THE MAIN CHARACTER AGGAGAGA HELP
omg okay so you guys know how in BTS save me webtoon, Jin goes to the beach when he finds out everything has went wrong? It then says he heard a voice telling him that “if he could, would he turn back time to fix everything?”. when the comic zooms out, we see a white cat. it’s the only thing with him at the beach. we never see the front of the cat though. BUT in a seokjin toy/merchandise, he’s posing with a white cat, the tail similar to the one in the comic and we see the eyes of the cat and the cat eyes are blue and green just like the one that follows TXT. so we can assume that the cat at the beach gave Jin the power to travel to different timelines, to remember the past, and dreams and etc. we can also assume that the cat is the same one that follows txt but in different colors (but same color eyes). the cat is targeting both Jin and Soobin. Jin remembers the past timelines and is the only one who has to go through the hurt and the pain of remembering them. Soobin, unknowingly can dream of the past/future timelines and is aware of the fact that he’s alone and suffering. Both Jin and Soobin are aware of the fact that they’re, in some way, separated from the group or are different. But jin tries to help every other member with their problems and come together and tries to fix everything while Soobin goes another way and just doesn’t want to be the only one suffering in the end. either way, more problems always occur. just like BTS, TXT are together in the beginning, but end up separating. The cat then finds someone in the group to target, and gives them the power to dream about different timelines, or to travel to them which ultimately leaves that person lonely/suffering which forces them to try and fix things with the others but something always goes wrong. it’s a little messy but i think that soon, we’re going to be shown individual problems each txt member is going through. Even if it’s the same cat, the targets are taking different ways to fix things. unlike BTS, i think TXT is going to try and keep targeting who they think is a liar. soon hueningkai will find out about all of that and when he does, i feel like he’d be the worst one. meaning that when he finds out there’s a liar, or suspicious person, he’d attack them the worst than any txt member. i think yeonjun is going to break from the guilt and start blaming others as well.
@@moonchxld3829 but in bts save me when he was talking with taehyung, didn't taehyung said he was having strange dreams, like yoongi trapped in side a burining fire, jungkook falling from a building,etc. he said he dream of it every night, but doesn't know remember himself in it. so i think taehyung dreams about it.. but doesn't know that it'll happen
I realized Im the nap of a star mv, they had unique characters and I think I know why. //Soobin- he has problems with hearing because that's something they can't give him. They don't listen to him. //Taehyun- has a problem with one eye because he is suspicious of soobin. Just like when a detective closes one eye to look at a magnifying glass. //Beomgyu- His shoulder has thorns showing how he is controlled by his shoulders on what to do. Brainwashed to believe Taehyun is the liar. //Hueningkai- He has wings because he is honest- he is not breaking their promise to stay together but his heart is broken because he feels alone since he's the only one with pure intentions within the friendship. //Yeonjun- He has horns believing that it's his fault this is all happening. He's the oldest after all and he broke the promise (as said in the video) Just a theory everyone probably know this already and im just mindlessly blabbering😂
Just wanted to point out, if you stop the video at 2:51, the scene where Hueningkai is looking at the ice cream but there seems to be something underneath it. Something like cake, idk. It is like saying beneath their sweet friendship underlies a dark truth. Just a thought cause that scene has been in my head for a long time
Yeaa I noticed that when I first watched the video, when watching kai looked noticeably uncomfortable with what's going on but I also noticed under the ice cream there was, what I think is, red velvet cake (great choice btw, if not for the theory, it's for the flavor lol) and I think it was chosen to match the red theme that had been going on (with the tomatoes and strawberries), maybe it also has something to do with beomgyu because of that 🤔 maybe beomgyu is starting to try to manipulate kai like he did yeonjun idk, bc there wasnt much that happened with kai, the red velvet matching the red theme which relates to beomgyu just really stuck out to me
@Lychee, Beomgyu could be seeing Taehyun trying to keep Kai innocent in all this as ruining their fun, and while being influenced by Soobin ends up resenting Taehyun for it. Kai meanwhile does see and notice that what he’s eating has red in it and still eats it. It could be him taking in all the flaws of his friends and choosing to believe in the good in them even while his heart is hurting. It’s just a thought but I could be wrong
Unrelated note: I feel like the star is the monster doll. It's their promise and friendship. Their flaws is put on the monster, their happiness is always with the monster, when Taehyun has it or Yeonjun. When the promise was made, it created a doll like a object to remind their promise. But when the star fell asleep, the doll starts to take in the boys flaws, the star and the monster doll has something connecting them and it's the promise. The monster doll is kind of like the star? What's inflicted on them goes to the monster and then the star, their promise. Their fears, flaws and weaknesses ( Soobins ears, Taehyuns eye, Heuningkais heart, Beomgyu's shoulder and Yeonjuns neck) are hurting and pulling apart the group and the promise. In can't you see me, the bear isn't there, so maybe their promise was left behind and the cat finally takes over them. (This is a copy paste of my comment on another video, I talk more about the cat in that comment so I didn't add it in this comment) Edit: You and Bookish theories should collaborate with each other! I think you can together can sew in the pieces quite nicely, both your theories sounds real when put together.
@@skrrtskrrt3337 That's true, it'd be nice if they collab on some theories tho, maybe not this theory but something else. It's a nice thought to think about since they are the two main channels( that links quite a lot of things together nicely) I watch theories on :)
In a comment, I read someone saying how “TXT” looks like the TT cry face emoji and how the ‘X’ in the middle is the cry face no being able to speak/ their words being shut/ unable to express themselves/ keeping secrets from each other. This could connect to the video’s theory on how soobin may be the one who is either the “liar”, and/or is the one who is suffering in secret because he can’t or doesn’t want to tell his friends how he feels/ them not being able to hear him because his emotions and words are silent (X). This theory is kinda crazy sorry
So that's why it called TXT. And bighit planning to do secret theory about this video That one of creating this MV and the members only knows this. And I'm like shocked
Agree but that time his not Dancing or kneeling or whatever...his not in the center like if they're singing they would be in a center....but in this choreo Yeonjun is the one who is in the center....so that means Yeonjun is the one who caused it(idk) and make Soobin and Taehyun suffer and Yeonjun face is like full of guilty and when the part Yeonjun at the end where the lyrics said "Friends don't understand me understand me any- shhh" Yeonjun part when dancing all of the members including Yeonjun are looking at Yeonjun....bro....... oof- sorry maybe I'm going to a wrong theory😅
I have a theory, but I haven’t been able to share it since I don’t have twitter, so hopefully someone will see this and think something of it. Basically, in the “who’s a liar” part of the new choreo, everyone says that soobin and taehyun are the liars. I don’t think this is true. It maybe that taehyun just isn’t crossing his fingers as much or something, but it looks more like he’s making his fingers straight, like how you would if you made a gun with your fingers. This to me immediately brought to mind the game mafia, with the promise sign (yeonjun, beomgyu, huening kai) as the civilians who are hurt and framed, the crossed fingers (soobin) as the mafia who is setting everything up, and the gun fingers (taehyun) as the police/detective, the only one who is able to tell “who’s the liar”. Another likely coincidence with the choreo is how in the first “who’s a liar” choreo, taehyun’s at the edge of the formation, unknowing of the “mafia”. During the second choreo, taehyun is next to soobin, as if he’s eliminated suspects, or even figured out that soobin is the mafia. With taehyun as the police/detective, it makes sense how he’s the one related to clue, the one picking up the clues and figuring everything out. Also, the song is “Can’t you see me”, and we know that taehyun’s thing is with his eyes, the police in the mafia game is the only one with the ability to ‘see’ everyone, coincidence maybe? Idk, random theory based on something that was probably a coincidence/accident in the choreo, but i thought it was interesting and wanted to share. Edit: i understand that taehyun is crossing his fingers, thats why i said that it was a coincidence
I have some theories too, _In the chorus it says “My heart incinerated, come and feel me feel me” I think it’s like a way of saying come and feel my pain_ _In the same part incinerated means to destroy (something, especially waste material) by burning it. So they have somehow burned the heart, maybe along with the house. Maybe as to why Hueningkai’s heart was in pain in Nap Of A Star. _Since Yeonjun is saying the line “Bad bad hope it’s just a painful dream” I think it is directed towards his guilt, to what he has done in the past music videos. He is hoping that he didn’t actually do that to his friends (TXT) in real life, hoping it is just some nightmare.
@Tom Hoang The line "bad bad hope it's just a painful dream" is sung by Soobin. The part where Yeonjun puts his hand on his face and the members lean on him is right after that, and Yeonjun sings "sad sad return me to your side again".
Oh noo it's okay!! I mean broken friendship is normal cause everyone experience it at least once in their lives :)) that's why txt is special bcs they're songs are always something you can relate to.
saw this comment under the mv that i think fits with your theory: "Yeonjun is the one who unintentionally hurts his friends without knowing until he realized what he did Taehyun is the victim who always get target at Beomgyu is the toxic friend who hurts and bring others around him down to get himself up Soobin is the one questioning the friendship and feeling left out Hueningkai is the one who tries to smile and play along even though he is damaged by their friendship"
Well, I don't know if it was supposed to be like that, but at 3:35 of the music video the light that seeps through the left window is blue and the right window has a green curtain like the cats eye's. I hope that's some how useful. It could've been the cats' "presence" as you described it, though it maybe a stretch.
Im actually waiting for this video because I know that Laina will reveal who's the liar.... I hope you will continue uncovering it.... Im imagining BIGHIT being in mess because your revealing the story hahahaha
Her: Explains the theories carefully for everyone to understand. Some 12 year-olds acting like they know everything: "They are not lying to each other!" "They won't disband" "That's not true!"
Haha... guess I've pass that age... I'm still very young but my mindset on things is quite mature so I don't think about it that way even though I'm not 12 anymore who still doesn't use their brain sometimes... no bad though intended... they just didn't know the whole story... those 12 year olds just see the theory from one perspective when there's a lot to unpack even if they were still rookies... its not even 2 years ago that they debuted and so much to unpack is both hilarious, ridiculous, and amazing...
if you watch the mv closely when they were throwing tomato’s at each other, you can see it started out as a joke and it was all fun. then the more they continue throwing the tomato’s, they get more aggressive. that can tie into what you said about it being funny at first, and then others taking is personally.
I would like to also point out how in the beginning, all the boys are shown in the aftermath of everything that happened, with everyone outside while soobin is the only one inside. Then in the end, the same scene of the boys are seen EXCEPT for soobins. Also, in the mnet comeback vcr, soobin is shown running towards a train (the same train that brings them from and to their "Magic Island") one of the boys are there to try to help him on but he doesn't make. The bridge breaks, he falls and gets left behind. Could this mean that the cat kept him in the Magic Island. Also that the ghost in the mirror isn't just a ghost, but Soobin trying to communicate to them but the boys aren't hearing him? NOT MY THEORY!!! credit: Bookish Theories. Highly suggest also checking her out, ya'll are my fav when it comes to txt theories
do you guys remember the part where yeonjun said "shhhh". I feel like that he knows about taehyun and soobin and is telling them to keep quit and not say anything because it would ruin their friendship. Or he is telling them to keep quit because he thinks/knows the cat is listening.
This is most likely just a coincidence, but Soobin's situation reminded me of something in Harry Potter. In the 5th book, Harry is lonely and suffering at the Dursleys' bc he doesn't get any information from Ron and Hermione. So he sends Hedwig to them and tells her to peck them until they give. When he sees them at Grimmauld Place, he notices that they have deep gashes on their hands from Hedwig's pecking and realizes he doesn't feel sorry at all. Idk, again, it's probably just a coincidence.
Do you know that in Magic Island MV they were talking about the practice room ghost? I think that was soobin when he was trapped in the glass and reaching out to them, but the call for help reached them in another timeline
Wawww..... I'll look for more clue... this is impressive... more and more theories comes up and in the end we as MOA will solve this all out... I'm sure about this one...
i actually thought that soobin is dead (as a symbol, like he's not rlly dead dead but kinda away from them because of something that happened) that's why the others can't see or hear him. he's in pain, away from them and he's the only one who knows who the liar is. he's suspicious of yeonjun ir taehyun and uses beomgyu to find out. kai is innocent and just don't know what's going on (OR we should think that he is, maybe he is the liar but no one is suspicious of him and his hyungs are fighting each other) or yeonjun is the one, but doesn't know about it. maybe the cat controlls him? and taehyung isn't much affected by the cat and tries to find out? and soobin can't do anything and just watches from afar in pain? OMG my head hurts... why is bighit like this??? why???
These theories literally have me on the edge of crying. Holy- My mind just exploded with info and I can’t wait to tell my friends this theory. They hate kpop and say that the songs have no meaning to it.
In maze in mirror theres a lyrics "My Weak shoulder i cant hide or open" that lyrics was sings by Taehyun and Beomgyu,My eyes was shook(bin:v) when i know there's the lyric "My Weak shoulder" because Beomgyu has a shoulder with that spiky thingy and it seemed like it hurt him,not sure why Taehyun also sing that part though. Wait i forgot Beomgyu wrote the song on training days:v
It seems like they're turning on each other or making themselves feel worse, making them also break the rule of staying together. Beomgyu believes Taehyun is the traitor, Taehyun is suspicious of Soobin, Soobin feels left out because of them, Yeonjun believes it was his fault, and Kai is starting to feel alone because of how they're acting. Hmmm...
@@adeleneeetran gosh ur right! I really thought that since this is the last dream chapter album in the series, that it would happily end in a good way, but nahhh
I just realized that Soobin is the only member during this era that does not have beads on him (Yeonjun has it on his hoodie strings, Beomgyu and Taehyun have necklaces, and Hueningkai has both a bracelet and necklace). I feel like these are glass beads, which connects to GFRIEND as well. I sort of have a theory that Soobin doesn't have glass beads because he's been taken over by the cat. I'm not too sure.
Yo dont forget SVT now 😂😂😂 Imagine BTS, TXT, GFRIEND, the upcoming new bg from I-LAND, and the new gg in 2021, coming together in one epic bighit drama.... It's the BIGHIT UNIVERSE.
So basically this is the simplified plot of the MV, which falls into their ongoing narrative: _Soobin feels left out from the group of friends and is sad, and thinks that it's unfair, so he wants the others to feel the same pain he feels by ruining their friendship _Boemgyu helps Soobin with the plan and starts playing both sides making Yeonjun join him in acts that will ruin the friendship, such as fights and the fire _Yeonjun blindly falls in the trap thinking they're all games, when in reality he's already taken them too far, ruining the whole friendship over fights that were meant to be playful but end up hurting everyone _Taehyun finds out about what's going on in the group and confronts Boemgyu, who kills him to keep him quiet _Huening Kai is naive and isn't aware of what is happening at all and still thinks they're all friends, until it's too late and the friendship is ended and everybody is suffering
@@julianabuarque8245 according to the theories that i've read, soobin is manipulating beomgyu the part in the mv where soobin pushed the glass out of the table and cuts to the scene of beomgyu falling on the bed meaning that soobin has successfully initiated his plan of brainwashing beomgyu and since taehyun is suspicious of soobin's actions, beom tried to silence taehyun by killing him so that the the chaos he and soobin made won't be revealed to the group.
In the lyrics of the song, it says “Our Scintilla bloomed underneath the starlight. Now see them burn in fire.” Scintilla means “A tiny trace or spark of a specified quality or feeling.” Just wanted to point that out.
When you watch stuff like this you don't realise how much depth there is to a storyline! Normally I just watch without a second thought but this has shown me the creativity and art of txt, thank you for this theory
In the choreo you said that when they say "who's a liar?" Soobin and Taehyun cross their fingers behind their backs while the others hold out their pinkies means that they aren't being truthful aka they are the liars. Well I was trying to pay closer attention to he choreo and noticed that when they say the first "can't you see me" of the choruses, they take slide their arms under their chin and they seem to be pointing at something. Then I noticed that they Beomgyu is the last one in the formation that they stand in and they could be pointing at him. I may be looking into this too much but maybe it means that, as you said in the video, Soobin is manipulating Beomgyu and the others catch on to Beomgyu's odd behaviour but they don't know what Soobin is doing so Soobin just keeps quiet about it. Idk let me know what you think
MJ Kpop I think so too! Also Bemogyu, if you look closely, doesn‘t do the pinky promise either. He makes horns which may mean that he‘s been possessed aka controlled (by Soobin?) Especially since Bemogyu lead txt to Soobins house, starts the fights, suffocates Taehyun and then always directly looks at the camera as if he knows what he‘s doing and wants us to keep quiet
I swear that bighit has the most complex backstories.... like just bts's,txt's backstories?? Bighit really needs to make a whole show explaining the theories..
Bts is more confusing to me... it's about psyche, the journey to the self by Carl Jung theory and the wings is definitely the hardest universe to crack up rather than txt... txt theories are much more relatable to younger people because they were still young... but bts is using something people are not that familiar with... the persona, shadow, ego, anima animus, its just too much...
Big hit really do be planning everything since the 1800s y’all this is crazy. I like how they have a concept to follow and and that it’s not just some random songs they make.
Omg, friendship is sometimes complicated. Txt reflects so many moments my 'friends' and I have been through, I guess many more people, too. I appreciate that they talk about this topic, I love this group's concepts sm, I'll stan :')
This blue notebook it appears when we unlock the hidden song "Sweat", there's a video after you clear the "mission" from Magic, and it's the Run Away scenario, the boys are entering a classroom, and I think Soobin is filming and this notebook showed up, in the cover is written "FOREVER" It gave me chills
At the end of Magical Island, when the cat runs over them in the shape of a train and among those "flashback"each of the boys touches the part of the body that refers to the teddy bear. Could this mean that when they come back to reality their worst fears return? (sorry about the english)
2:13 I just realized one thing. I've heard somewhere that there's a very slim chance where you can remember a *real* dream. And if nap of the star is a "dream MV", I can see why they don't remember the promise. It's not really related to cysm but I just wanted to share my thoughts.
I watch you since your very first video on txt. (weird hat era) And honestly, youre the best theorist when it comes to the bighit universe. Love You and my mind is once again blown!
Hybe casually making a whole literal story line for each and every group...is just so.....confusing...cuz I dont understand any groups storyline that easily🤡🤡
finding your video again 2 years later and most of the theories still stand! this was one of the first theories i had seen when i became a moa im really happy to watch it again :) see you in the name chapter
beomgyu is such an interesting character he is the 3rd youngest and 3rd oldest, his colour in the debut photos was orange. orange is the middle of red and yellow yellow is usually a colour that we use to represent happiness and peace, while red is usually a colour that we use to represent anger and chaos. in the cysm m/v, he is either seen very happy, or very not, one moment he was having fun with the strawberries, the next he’s trying to kill taehyun. him being the middle member in the age means that he’s in the hyung line and the maknae line. this could also mean that he can be both mature and cute. i think that the whole +u is actually two different stories. yeonjun supposedly broke the rules in magic island, by opening his eyes. txt is constantly relating to games, you know the board game operation? where if you touch the sides the buzzer sounds? when yeonjun opened his eyes, i think that triggered the star, as long as you close your eyes, the star stays on. when the star ‘turned off’, the witch came out pretty much straight away, the witch is like the buzzer sounding. when yeonjun found himself dead in the ruined stadium, it was literally dark and there wasn’t much colour in the scene. the witch is also very dark. but when taehyun found him, his throat was slit and purple blood was coming out of his cut. the witch and the cat are pretty much the same thing. in the scene in naos when the cat and yeonjun met, his horns gave the cat a sort of smile. what cat smiles and is purple? the cheshire cat the cheshire cat is a character in alice in wonderland, this relates to taehyun’s section in eternally, where there was supposedly a reference to the gossiping flowers. the cheshire cat has the ability to time travel, it smiles then disappears and reappears somewhere else. the whole +u is about time travel. back to there being two different stories in +u, yeonjun dies in two different ways beomgyu fights both soobin and taehyun kai is in two completely different times, one as a child and one as now soobin is in both worlds, his dream being one world and the practice room in eternally being the other but what’s taehyuns? beomgyu fights taehyun in one world, taehyun is one of the only members without stripes on their sleeve, we saw that the person had no stripes on their sleeve for a split second in eternally. taehyun’s morse code is ‘clue’, he can be seen as sort of nosy, he’s the detective, always finding out everything. taehyun wanted to know what’s in the book beomgyu has, but he got upset and his wings/spikes came out. in the choreography for cysm, taehyun is one of the liars because we can see he crosses his fingers in soobins line ‘who’s a liar?’. beomgyu and taehyun are always fighting, beomgyu always being the one who attacks first though. in another world, soobin fights beomgyu, i think this because he ends up with the same book beomgyu had been protecting. in the practice room in eternally, beomgyu films soobin a lot, only soobin, i don’t think he ever films him when he’s with the other members. soobin is also one of the liars in cysm choreo, he also crosses his fingers. i think beomgyu could know that taehyung and soobin are both liars, because with yeonjun and kai, he’s very friendly. in naos when the star goes out, you’ll see the witch come, but you will also see a butterfly flying around. beomgyu’s animal for the questioning things was a butterfly. coincidence?
Soobin- Lonely Beomgyu- Soobin is controling him(?) Taehyun- Knows what Soobins going though Yeonjun- Guilty because he started all of this Huening Kai- Just trying to have a good time (I think this is what she's saying...?)
Became a MOA just March of this year. I just heard this song last night and I'm addicted. I've watched most vids about CYSM (including performance videos, bts, award shows, and theories) and would like to share some of what I noticed. 1. Starting from 0:23 - Gyu and Yeonjun are the only two that looks kind of guilty. Kai - grieving sad Taehyun - emotionless, suspicious Soobin - looks done and gave up 2. It's already given that Soobin and Taehyun are the liars (if you base it on their crossed fingers), the reason I guess why Gyu and Yeonjun resents them. 3. The scene on the sofa when Kai took some photos, only Gyu and Yeonjun are smiling. The other two are on the floor, all serious. 4. Notice how they kill the other characters (or ended their friendship). Gyu ate the cookie and bite its "head" off - look what he did to Taehyun. He covered his head with a blanket. Yeonjun, on the other hand, is the one who used the oven to bake - fire started inside the house on the scene where he checked his hand and saw the other members. 5. There are 2 types of liar friends based on the "lips" scene. The smiling lips are not Soobins *I paused it a dozen more times to check*, the screaming one is. **More on this on #6. One lies to fool and/or manipulate (smiling) while the other one lies that he's okay eventhough he wants to be closer to his friends (screaming) *which is also based on their Eternity concept trailer. 6. Soooo... I mentioned above that the smiling lips aren't Soobins. I'm guessing it's either Taehyun or *gasp* Yeonjun. Okay, hear me out.. 6a. As mentioned on #5, a person can lie to fool and/or manipulate other people. I'm guessing Taehyun are fooling his friends into thinking he wants their company when it's clearly not (he never smiled in the video), and Yeonjun's the manipulative one letting his friends feel everythings fine when in fact he has other plans *the ssssh scene in the oven*. 6b. On the first liar line of Soobin, notice how Yeonjun peeked through. Co-incidence? Maybe. Maybe not. 6c. Some of you might ask "Why Yeonjun? His hand gesture on the liar line is a pinky swear and not a crossed finger". Well, that is true.. however, not everyone can keep their promises. Friendships are not all roses, sometimes it ends in a one big mess. You may also check the bridge lyrics. S: Bad bad hope it’s just a painful dream Y: Sad sad return me to your side again 6d. Yeonjun crying alone in the bed covered with the blanket, with his friends surrounding him. He's guilty on something he did. In the process of trying to hurt Soobin, he hurt his other friends too and lose them all. *Check YJ line again from the bridge above*. Again it could be Taehyun or Yeonjun or both - aside from Soobin, being the liar. Just curious at the end, there are only 4. Soobin is not shown. Maybe he completely cut-off his friendship with the other 4, staying inside the burning house (ashes of their friendship as per the song). This is the reality of some friendships, it's messy all around. WDYT?
4:20 - "why should it be only me who suffers" The Chaos chapter : Freeze- Ice cream - "I feel like I'm the only one that's been robbed It's unfair So everything shall be doomed" 😨😱
At 4:30 she talks about the choreo containing clues with the fingers crossed gesture so I wanted to point this out. At the end of the dance, when Yeonjun shhs the lines saying "friends don't understand me" Yeonjun, Kai and Beomgyu look up at each other, but Taehyun and Soobin, the "liars" both look down, like they feel guilty or scolded. I checked out a bunch of performances to see if it was a fluke, but they do it the same every time. It may just be an aesthetic choice for the dance, but it's something I noticed and thought it was neat, and went along well with the theory!
a little late to comment but i read the comments and with the help of some of my theory's i think that in cant you see me the cat has full control over them and that the lairs kinda know what is happening. also i feel like beomgyu is doing all this and is happy about it. but i dont think he is doing it on purpose . he might be controlled (or not). huening kai is probable the innocent one that is gullible and does not know a thing. soobin knows what is happening and is probable the cats target. were as yeonjun i think he is controled by soobin (aka maybe the cat) in to doing bad things just like what beomgyu is doing but realizes its bad a little too late. also in run away when soobin is drawing on the white baord it has multiple drawings of cats and also says forever . the baord also has a flower which you also see in eternally . you also see those tall trees in magic island and the fire. there is also that doll thing drawn on the baord. and last there is a star drawn on the baord which maybe is the star in nap of the star.
I am not good at theories. in fact congratulations I loved yours. maybe just maybe the cat was there. that smiley face made of ketchup beomgyu's shirt has one too and in the yeonjun photoshoot there is also a smiling face on his shirt. this can be random but it was something I noticed I believe that yeonjun needs help, probably beomgyu too, but mainly yeonjun and soobin, are the two who ask for "save me" in the song and in an interview (I'll leave the link and the exact moment ) asked: who was that fighting with the devil? -It was me (soobin replied) and then appears "yeonjun was captured by the devil first" idk if it helps with something kkk "we never said it anywhere else" they said. ps: sorry for any mistakes, kisses and support from Brazil th-cam.com/video/tO-DEhq2sjI/w-d-xo.html. Txt mmtg if the link doesn't works. 9:54
Why does the cookie that Beomgyu ate in Cant You See Me seems suspicious to me?? Idek anymore, my brain has exploded in this video😆 Luv your videos Laina♡♡
Bruh you don’t know how much I appreciate your channel because I’m really bad at figuring things like this out and you make staning bts and txt so much more fun for me
![TXT ETERNALLY MV EXPLAINED [TXT UNIVERSE THEORY]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QAc1rsKahm8/mqdefault.jpg)
THIS IS NOT REAL LIFE, IT IS ONLY THE TXT UNIVERSE STORY WRITTEN BY BIGHIT. THIS IS FICTIONAL.
A lot of people are asking where the concept photos are - THEY ARE NOT ON INSTAGRAM. They are fabricated photos MADE TO LOOK LIKE SOCIAL MEDIA by BigHit for the album and can be found here (scroll down and hit "port"):
ibighit.com/txt/eng/discography/detail/the_dream_chapter-eternity.php
I was making a morse code translate of the teaser from The Dream Chapter: Eternity. so if you want you can use it for a Video. Hope you have a nice day. :D
i just got it, like they're literally making a whole ass ARG out of this. at first i was confused about the instagram pictures
Gfriend coming back soon
Also small mini theory:
What if the Dytopia tree from Dreamcatchers storyline is the same tree that gives exo their powers in their storyline
(Which may or may not connect also to red Velvet being connected to exo)
is that an app? if yes what is it called?
Hai sis... I just want to tell you, that you should to hear 'someone' voice in magic island music video, which is 10 minutes 24 second (when the train want to crash into them) and you will hear ‘someone’ voice, idk whats she say but the voice repeat 3rd times, thanks you:)
Everyone is having a theory and then there's me, not understanding anything and just watching because I'm dumb. 😂
You're not alone 😂😂 many people told me theories about this 'can't you see me' mv, it gaves me more things to think about
Me too. Haha i started watching again the previous mvs. I want to understand the concept or storry but i don't know where to start. Hahaha
Lmfao same i thought im the only one😭
i feel the same way just watch their theories and just say "yae thats totally what i thought"
Omg I feel you, I tried to figure it out by myself but my head really hurts bcoz I can't connect it all 😂
bighit really be planning out everyone’s whole careers
TRUE DAT
Your profile pic gave me anxiety 😂
Tae Spoon Of Suga I was like w-what? Then I looked up at the profile picture and BURSTED out laughing and ending up choking in the middle of the night!
im gonna cry when they add i-land into the bighit universe i cant handle all of it anymoree
imagine you can hear. p0isOn apPlE
Do you also notice that their choreo is super sinister? Like literally mimicking snapping your own neck, slitting/choking your own throat, etc. O.O
I love the transition of this music video. The choreography had so much detail and story to it and the MV itself just had two things I love, cute and dark concepts 💕
let's be real tho, even in crown the lyrics were actually really dark if you take time to analyze it, also run away. they just covered it up with fun, poppy, fresh bg music. 😂
chaerry wait! crown was a horror concept all along! :0
@@chaerry5329 Thats why I love those songs so much! It's really sad but the musical arrangement and the music video makes to sound so fun until chaos happens. 😂
It could be that They are turning into puppets
it's not a Bighit music video if there is no Theories included.
Actually it’s not only bighit thing. It’s part of most kpop groups (like EXO, I think it might be interesting for you if you like theories haha).
bighit is an entertainment industry that focuses on music for healing so its pretty frequent when they have deeper meanings in their music. so i say TRUUU
@@Lottiya yeah but were talking about bighit now
I Stan Bts and what’s the problem in adding something else to conversation? XD I think theories were the main point.
@@Lottiya
Yes but it's sort of bighit thing you know? Others groups do it too but it's mostly bighit
That one dislike is from BigHit because you’re uncovering more than they expected. This video is just genius, so it has to be them!
Two now. From BigHit and one staff member 😂
@@hellothere2122 or from one of the members
@@bismuthezoid yeah
32 now from all the secrets they kept from us
Nahhhh the whole staff team
tag yourself, i’m hueningkai in this situation.. i have no idea what’s going on, i just want to eat 😂
I had been on all of their situation and the posistion that i sitting now is Soobin
M e I just want the bread
love hyunjin
I‘m stuck in all of them at once and I honestly don‘t know how I got myself into this
Im Yeonjun Im the one that started the fire . Im accident prone
I am too
In the choreography, they touch each part that hurts them. Ears, eyes, shoulders, heart, and head.
Also, in the choreo, taehyun and soobin are controlling Kai. Which could mean he's gullible. Which also goes with your theory
Also in almost every choreo soobin controls the members, in crown the chorus with the bow he moves them up. In run away where he starts the chorus
Earlier in the mv, Beomgyu covered Taehyun trying to suffocate him because he suspects him (or maybe Beomgyu was the liar and trying to kill Taehyun the detective to get rid of evidences and the witness) And in the choreo everyone leans toward Beomgyu and in the lyrics he said *"I resent you a lot."* And Taehyun controlled Kai and used him to replied that it's *"because you don't understand me."* And Kai seems to lose his mind because everyone is controlling him and he don't know who to believe anymore. And next is Soobin, it seems like he's telling Kai to look at him, understand him, and stay by his side (bcoz he forced kai to look at him in the Choreo) and the lyrics were *"Please stop the resentment."* And if you notice it all from the concept trailer, Soobin was saying "Save Me." Save me from this resentment, Please believe me. Why am I left alone again? Why can't you see me?
And there's Yeonjun who seemed to start the fire or the resentment or the problem. Idk.
So.. Who's the liar among them? I'm losing my mind too trying to understand it all to be honest.
Parts that hurts? Soobin's ears bcoz of what he heard? Taehyun's eyes because of what he saw? Beomgyu's shoulder because he don't want them to lean on him, thus destroying their friendship? (lol idk) Kai's heart because he's too softhearted? And Yeonjun's mind... Idk why AHAHA. I hope bighit explain this all or I'm gonna lose my mind soon
Katrina Cassandra Andaleon no i think yeonjun is the one with the horns
@@keila7287 my head really hurts trynna figure it all out HAHA
The people working on those MV’s need *A RAISE*
Ikr it's just masterpiece of a mv so much symbolism and depth into it it's clear they thought about hard
FR THEY'RE EVEN BETTER THAN MOVIES
Kai and Yeonjun do the pinky promise sign, meaning that they're the only ones keeping the promise they made, still having fun and all, not aware of what's going on in the friend group. They're innocent and naive, as Yeonjun starts the fires and commits terrible things by mistake; every time he joins Boemgyu into having fun he ends up doing something bad.
Boemgyu on the other hand makes the horns sign in the choreography: he's the traitor, corrupted by Soobin (aka the cat) into breaking the group apart, the one who breaks the promise and stays in disguise while causing problems. He's always making sure that Yeonjun follows him creating problems.
_Boemgyu is the one taking everyone to Soobin's house and ringing the doorbell, he was invited by Soobin
_Boemgyu wants cookies (he's the only one shown biting into one) > Yeonjun makes cookies leaving the oven turned on, causing the fire
_Boemgyu starts the fruit fights (blending strawberries, throwing the first tomato and throwing jam at Taehyun) > Yeonjun goes on the table, joins the fruit fights and realizes he's taken them too far only when it's too late
_Boemgyu goes on the bed > Yeonjun follows him leaving a dirty shoe mark on the sheets
_Beomgyu is wearing a shirt with a smile on, he's aware and happy of the results he's achieved and is happy in the tomato mess on the floor
_Boemgyu tries to kill Taehyun because he found out about what he and Soobin are really doing
_Boemgyu is aware of everything, he even looks at the camera when everybody is watching TV. He's enjoying the disaster he's caused (the red screen), eating chips.
Soobin (aka the cat) might have taken control over Boemgyu, the camera even focuses on his eye
but yeonjun broke the forth wall, he looked at the viewers through the oven signaling 'shh' as if HE also knows what's going on
Wow this is a fresh perspective.
@@ewik7928 true omg
y'all scaring me
paniced! gay
Maybe he realized it and either joined Soobin and Beomgyu or joined Taehyuns side but wanted the viewers to keep quiet because he knew sooner or later Soobin and Bemogyu will kill Taehyun because he found out?
Any of yall notice TXT’s first 2 albums are the color of the cats eyes blue and green 😳
Edit: AND SOOBINS HAIR IS PURPLE AND THE ETERNITY ALBUM IS PURPLE AND SOOBIN IS THE MAIN CHARACTER AGGAGAGA HELP
Soobin is Controlled by the cat or he is the cat 😭
I said “I’m sure soobin is the main character” when the first teaser came out. Glad someone thinks the same
OMG WAIT YOU’RE RIGHT- sis how did i not notice that
omg okay so you guys know how in BTS save me webtoon, Jin goes to the beach when he finds out everything has went wrong? It then says he heard a voice telling him that “if he could, would he turn back time to fix everything?”. when the comic zooms out, we see a white cat. it’s the only thing with him at the beach. we never see the front of the cat though.
BUT in a seokjin toy/merchandise, he’s posing with a white cat, the tail similar to the one in the comic and we see the eyes of the cat and the cat eyes are blue and green just like the one that follows TXT.
so we can assume that the cat at the beach gave Jin the power to travel to different timelines, to remember the past, and dreams and etc. we can also assume that the cat is the same one that follows txt but in different colors (but same color eyes).
the cat is targeting both Jin and Soobin. Jin remembers the past timelines and is the only one who has to go through the hurt and the pain of remembering them. Soobin, unknowingly can dream of the past/future timelines and is aware of the fact that he’s alone and suffering.
Both Jin and Soobin are aware of the fact that they’re, in some way, separated from the group or are different. But jin tries to help every other member with their problems and come together and tries to fix everything while Soobin goes another way and just doesn’t want to be the only one suffering in the end. either way, more problems always occur.
just like BTS, TXT are together in the beginning, but end up separating. The cat then finds someone in the group to target, and gives them the power to dream about different timelines, or to travel to them which ultimately leaves that person lonely/suffering which forces them to try and fix things with the others but something always goes wrong.
it’s a little messy but i think that soon, we’re going to be shown individual problems each txt member is going through. Even if it’s the same cat, the targets are taking different ways to fix things. unlike BTS, i think TXT is going to try and keep targeting who they think is a liar. soon hueningkai will find out about all of that and when he does, i feel like he’d be the worst one. meaning that when he finds out there’s a liar, or suspicious person, he’d attack them the worst than any txt member. i think yeonjun is going to break from the guilt and start blaming others as well.
@@moonchxld3829 but in bts save me when he was talking with taehyung, didn't taehyung said he was having strange dreams, like yoongi trapped in side a burining fire, jungkook falling from a building,etc. he said he dream of it every night, but doesn't know remember himself in it. so i think taehyung dreams about it.. but doesn't know that it'll happen
I realized
Im the nap of a star mv, they had unique characters and I think I know why.
//Soobin- he has problems with hearing because that's something they can't give him. They don't listen to him.
//Taehyun- has a problem with one eye because he is suspicious of soobin. Just like when a detective closes one eye to look at a magnifying glass.
//Beomgyu- His shoulder has thorns showing how he is controlled by his shoulders on what to do. Brainwashed to believe Taehyun is the liar.
//Hueningkai- He has wings because he is honest- he is not breaking their promise to stay together but his heart is broken because he feels alone since he's the only one with pure intentions within the friendship.
//Yeonjun- He has horns believing that it's his fault this is all happening. He's the oldest after all and he broke the promise (as said in the video)
Just a theory everyone probably know this already and im just mindlessly blabbering😂
No no continue you actually make great points
🥺🥺
@sjhdjshdjhs sjhdgsjajdh my friendship already turn on like this😂
But I think it is fun, right?😂😂
Wow I think I like this theory
WOAHH THIS MAKES MORE SENSE!!😭😭😭
Just wanted to point out, if you stop the video at 2:51, the scene where Hueningkai is looking at the ice cream but there seems to be something underneath it. Something like cake, idk. It is like saying beneath their sweet friendship underlies a dark truth. Just a thought cause that scene has been in my head for a long time
Wow that's an amazing theory
When?
@@blaise7700 in the actual mv
Yeaa I noticed that when I first watched the video, when watching kai looked noticeably uncomfortable with what's going on but I also noticed under the ice cream there was, what I think is, red velvet cake (great choice btw, if not for the theory, it's for the flavor lol) and I think it was chosen to match the red theme that had been going on (with the tomatoes and strawberries), maybe it also has something to do with beomgyu because of that 🤔 maybe beomgyu is starting to try to manipulate kai like he did yeonjun idk, bc there wasnt much that happened with kai, the red velvet matching the red theme which relates to beomgyu just really stuck out to me
@Lychee, Beomgyu could be seeing Taehyun trying to keep Kai innocent in all this as ruining their fun, and while being influenced by Soobin ends up resenting Taehyun for it. Kai meanwhile does see and notice that what he’s eating has red in it and still eats it. It could be him taking in all the flaws of his friends and choosing to believe in the good in them even while his heart is hurting.
It’s just a thought but I could be wrong
Unrelated note:
I feel like the star is the monster doll. It's their promise and friendship. Their flaws is put on the monster, their happiness is always with the monster, when Taehyun has it or Yeonjun. When the promise was made, it created a doll like a object to remind their promise. But when the star fell asleep, the doll starts to take in the boys flaws, the star and the monster doll has something connecting them and it's the promise. The monster doll is kind of like the star? What's inflicted on them goes to the monster and then the star, their promise. Their fears, flaws and weaknesses ( Soobins ears, Taehyuns eye, Heuningkais heart, Beomgyu's shoulder and Yeonjuns neck) are hurting and pulling apart the group and the promise.
In can't you see me, the bear isn't there, so maybe their promise was left behind and the cat finally takes over them.
(This is a copy paste of my comment on another video, I talk more about the cat in that comment so I didn't add it in this comment)
Edit: You and Bookish theories should collaborate with each other! I think you can together can sew in the pieces quite nicely, both your theories sounds real when put together.
No they dont have to collaborate because what is the excitement for the next things to happened when all the theories is out and solved
@@skrrtskrrt3337 That's true, it'd be nice if they collab on some theories tho, maybe not this theory but something else. It's a nice thought to think about since they are the two main channels( that links quite a lot of things together nicely) I watch theories on :)
@@branddransnothing NO that's not fine to my brain ☠️☠️☠️
other companies choosing concepts: cute, girl crush etc.
bighit: *makes an entire universe*
For every group they have
so true
Ok off topic but am i the only one who finds it cute when she pronounce "Hyung" dkshsjjs
She pronounces it correctly.
@@peepmcsqueak5310 i literally didn't said that she's pronouncing it wrong..?
Sameeee its so cuteee sjndh
@@lordjaissonc.riberal2000 Oh, I guess I didn’t read it correctly sorry.
In a comment, I read someone saying how
“TXT” looks like the TT cry face emoji and how the ‘X’ in the middle is the cry face no being able to speak/ their words being shut/ unable to express themselves/ keeping secrets from each other.
This could connect to the video’s theory on how soobin may be the one who is either the “liar”, and/or is the one who is suffering in secret because he can’t or doesn’t want to tell his friends how he feels/ them not being able to hear him because his emotions and words are silent (X).
This theory is kinda crazy sorry
Kim no ur right ive thought that for the longest time I just didn’t really pay much attention to it!!
TXT means tomorrow by together
_Taesthetic _ yes but maybe there's more to it than that?
I can't se letters in the name anymore lmao
So that's why it called TXT. And bighit planning to do secret theory about this video
That one of creating this MV and the members only knows this. And I'm like shocked
Soobin is lonely, right? At the end of Can’t You See Me, he is the only person who sings the last note..he ended the song alone.
Agree but that time his not Dancing or kneeling or whatever...his not in the center like if they're singing they would be in a center....but in this choreo Yeonjun is the one who is in the center....so that means Yeonjun is the one who caused it(idk) and make Soobin and Taehyun suffer and Yeonjun face is like full of guilty and when the part Yeonjun at the end where the lyrics said "Friends don't understand me understand me any- shhh" Yeonjun part when dancing all of the members including Yeonjun are looking at Yeonjun....bro....... oof- sorry maybe I'm going to a wrong theory😅
@@miwaani_4627 its not wrong... its just a bit far fetched but it still does make sense... you've got your senses working here... I'm impressed...
@@Fransisca_Athanasia haha I've never been this smart in my life😂😂
I have a theory, but I haven’t been able to share it since I don’t have twitter, so hopefully someone will see this and think something of it.
Basically, in the “who’s a liar” part of the new choreo, everyone says that soobin and taehyun are the liars. I don’t think this is true. It maybe that taehyun just isn’t crossing his fingers as much or something, but it looks more like he’s making his fingers straight, like how you would if you made a gun with your fingers.
This to me immediately brought to mind the game mafia, with the promise sign (yeonjun, beomgyu, huening kai) as the civilians who are hurt and framed, the crossed fingers (soobin) as the mafia who is setting everything up, and the gun fingers (taehyun) as the police/detective, the only one who is able to tell “who’s the liar”. Another likely coincidence with the choreo is how in the first “who’s a liar” choreo, taehyun’s at the edge of the formation, unknowing of the “mafia”. During the second choreo, taehyun is next to soobin, as if he’s eliminated suspects, or even figured out that soobin is the mafia.
With taehyun as the police/detective, it makes sense how he’s the one related to clue, the one picking up the clues and figuring everything out. Also, the song is “Can’t you see me”, and we know that taehyun’s thing is with his eyes, the police in the mafia game is the only one with the ability to ‘see’ everyone, coincidence maybe?
Idk, random theory based on something that was probably a coincidence/accident in the choreo, but i thought it was interesting and wanted to share.
Edit: i understand that taehyun is crossing his fingers, thats why i said that it was a coincidence
They confirmed taehyun and soobin were supposed to cross their fingers. He just doesnt do it right
omg i also thought he was a police investigating but then he was strangled because he knew something beomgyu didn't want him to know
poppingtxt yeah, i wasn’t sure and thought that might’ve been the case
This is genius
We have the same theory about that part of the choreo. Can't miss that.
I have some theories too,
_In the chorus it says “My heart incinerated, come and feel me feel me” I think it’s like a way of saying come and feel my pain_
_In the same part incinerated means to destroy (something, especially waste material) by burning it. So they have somehow burned the heart, maybe along with the house. Maybe as to why Hueningkai’s heart was in pain in Nap Of A Star.
_Since Yeonjun is saying the line “Bad bad hope it’s just a painful dream” I think it is directed towards his guilt, to what he has done in the past music videos. He is hoping that he didn’t actually do that to his friends (TXT) in real life, hoping it is just some nightmare.
@Tom Hoang The line "bad bad hope it's just a painful dream" is sung by Soobin. The part where Yeonjun puts his hand on his face and the members lean on him is right after that, and Yeonjun sings "sad sad return me to your side again".
This actually broke my heart because the story sounded like something that could happen in real life :,) sorry for sounding stUpiD BUT RHJFKFJFFFLKVV
Oh noo it's okay!! I mean broken friendship is normal cause everyone experience it at least once in their lives :)) that's why txt is special bcs they're songs are always something you can relate to.
@@hueningkai3001 I was confused like "iS ThiS tHe rEAL hUEniNGkAi" for a second there-
@@polyphias akasksk I'm not 😂 unless... 👀
Hueningkai 👀
Yeah I relate to it too and it's very sad :( and it happens
saw this comment under the mv that i think fits with your theory:
"Yeonjun is the one who unintentionally hurts his friends without knowing until he realized what he did
Taehyun is the victim who always get target at
Beomgyu is the toxic friend who hurts and bring others around him down to get himself up
Soobin is the one questioning the friendship and feeling left out
Hueningkai is the one who tries to smile and play along even though he is damaged by their friendship"
the other 4 members: trying to kill each other
hueningkai: idk
Well, I don't know if it was supposed to be like that, but at 3:35 of the music video the light that seeps through the left window is blue and the right window has a green curtain like the cats eye's. I hope that's some how useful. It could've been the cats' "presence" as you described it, though it maybe a stretch.
Beomgyu also have a blue and green pearl on his necklace
Im actually waiting for this video because I know that Laina will reveal who's the liar.... I hope you will continue uncovering it.... Im imagining BIGHIT being in mess because your revealing the story hahahaha
Her: Explains the theories carefully for everyone to understand.
Some 12 year-olds acting like they know everything: "They are not lying to each other!" "They won't disband" "That's not true!"
Yess 🤣 and it's a concept, or a timeline it doesn't (probably) apply to real life haha
Haha... guess I've pass that age... I'm still very young but my mindset on things is quite mature so I don't think about it that way even though I'm not 12 anymore who still doesn't use their brain sometimes... no bad though intended... they just didn't know the whole story... those 12 year olds just see the theory from one perspective when there's a lot to unpack even if they were still rookies... its not even 2 years ago that they debuted and so much to unpack is both hilarious, ridiculous, and amazing...
I'm 12 years old but I don't act like that, I agree with everything she says 😶
if you watch the mv closely when they were throwing tomato’s at each other, you can see it started out as a joke and it was all fun. then the more they continue throwing the tomato’s, they get more aggressive. that can tie into what you said about it being funny at first, and then others taking is personally.
Someone: what if we do just a normal, no hidden meanings, mv?
Bighit: jarod. 19.
I would like to also point out how in the beginning, all the boys are shown in the aftermath of everything that happened, with everyone outside while soobin is the only one inside. Then in the end, the same scene of the boys are seen EXCEPT for soobins. Also, in the mnet comeback vcr, soobin is shown running towards a train (the same train that brings them from and to their "Magic Island") one of the boys are there to try to help him on but he doesn't make. The bridge breaks, he falls and gets left behind. Could this mean that the cat kept him in the Magic Island. Also that the ghost in the mirror isn't just a ghost, but Soobin trying to communicate to them but the boys aren't hearing him? NOT MY THEORY!!! credit: Bookish Theories. Highly suggest also checking her out, ya'll are my fav when it comes to txt theories
I’m just saying...I’m French and your “Ceci n’est pas un nounours” was just too precious
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR SO LONG SKSKSKS
SORRY IT TOOK ME SO LONG!!
do you guys remember the part where yeonjun said "shhhh". I feel like that he knows about taehyun and soobin and is telling them to keep quit and not say anything because it would ruin their friendship. Or he is telling them to keep quit because he thinks/knows the cat is listening.
This is most likely just a coincidence, but Soobin's situation reminded me of something in Harry Potter. In the 5th book, Harry is lonely and suffering at the Dursleys' bc he doesn't get any information from Ron and Hermione. So he sends Hedwig to them and tells her to peck them until they give. When he sees them at Grimmauld Place, he notices that they have deep gashes on their hands from Hedwig's pecking and realizes he doesn't feel sorry at all. Idk, again, it's probably just a coincidence.
woah, as a huge hp fan, that's so smart
I didnt even have finished the video but my head Is alredy about to explode 😂👌
Do you know that in Magic Island MV they were talking about the practice room ghost? I think that was soobin when he was trapped in the glass and reaching out to them, but the call for help reached them in another timeline
watch eternally omggggg
Wawww..... I'll look for more clue... this is impressive... more and more theories comes up and in the end we as MOA will solve this all out... I'm sure about this one...
OMG I'M 6 MINUTES LATE!!!
I LOVE YOU ANYONE WHO READS THIS!!!
Edit: OMG thanks for the likes. This is the most I've ever recieved
i actually thought that soobin is dead (as a symbol, like he's not rlly dead dead but kinda away from them because of something that happened) that's why the others can't see or hear him. he's in pain, away from them and he's the only one who knows who the liar is. he's suspicious of yeonjun ir taehyun and uses beomgyu to find out.
kai is innocent and just don't know what's going on (OR we should think that he is, maybe he is the liar but no one is suspicious of him and his hyungs are fighting each other)
or yeonjun is the one, but doesn't know about it. maybe the cat controlls him? and taehyung isn't much affected by the cat and tries to find out?
and soobin can't do anything and just watches from afar in pain?
OMG my head hurts... why is bighit like this??? why???
These theories literally have me on the edge of crying. Holy-
My mind just exploded with info and I can’t wait to tell my friends this theory. They hate kpop and say that the songs have no meaning to it.
Also, in cant you see me yeonjun and soobin are the only ones who say “save me”
Hmmm then in the first chorus Hueningkai is the one that says “can’t you see me” and she also said that Hueningkai was getting lonely
Wait..why did kai say can't u see me and soobin & yeonjun say save me?
Saima Tehreem ^^^^
@@sylva.s Taehyun also said cant you see me OwO
_immy_ x
And the „Once again, I‘m left alone.“
And how Yeonjun und Hueka say „My friends don‘t understand me, no.“
11:10 i love the way you pronounce it idk why it just sounds so nice
i grew up speaking french so that might be why! (though i think i have a quebecois/canadian accent...)
@@LainaSunflower thats cool !! i only know to speak english, some spanish, and internet
ddyeeyee I’m laughing because internet is in its own category 😂
damn, sis has the same brain as Albert Einstein-
Well Albert’s brain was stolen so-good point
she be uncovering the whole damn storyline
Watch this and bookish theories and your whole perspective on the human race will change completely
In maze in mirror theres a lyrics "My Weak shoulder i cant hide or open" that lyrics was sings by Taehyun and Beomgyu,My eyes was shook(bin:v) when i know there's the lyric "My Weak shoulder" because Beomgyu has a shoulder with that spiky thingy and it seemed like it hurt him,not sure why Taehyun also sing that part though.
Wait i forgot Beomgyu wrote the song on training days:v
Literally was waiting for this so I could scream about theories or something-
It seems like they're turning on each other or making themselves feel worse, making them also break the rule of staying together. Beomgyu believes Taehyun is the traitor, Taehyun is suspicious of Soobin, Soobin feels left out because of them, Yeonjun believes it was his fault, and Kai is starting to feel alone because of how they're acting. Hmmm...
@@adeleneeetran gosh ur right! I really thought that since this is the last dream chapter album in the series, that it would happily end in a good way, but nahhh
I just realized that Soobin is the only member during this era that does not have beads on him (Yeonjun has it on his hoodie strings, Beomgyu and Taehyun have necklaces, and Hueningkai has both a bracelet and necklace). I feel like these are glass beads, which connects to GFRIEND as well. I sort of have a theory that Soobin doesn't have glass beads because he's been taken over by the cat. I'm not too sure.
bighit: how much do you want them to be so curious?
BTS, GFriend, TXT: YES!
ohmygaaaa being a bighit stan is ugh!!
Yo dont forget SVT now 😂😂😂
Imagine BTS, TXT, GFRIEND, the upcoming new bg from I-LAND, and the new gg in 2021, coming together in one epic bighit drama.... It's the BIGHIT UNIVERSE.
So basically this is the simplified plot of the MV, which falls into their ongoing narrative:
_Soobin feels left out from the group of friends and is sad, and thinks that it's unfair, so he wants the others to feel the same pain he feels by ruining their friendship
_Boemgyu helps Soobin with the plan and starts playing both sides making Yeonjun join him in acts that will ruin the friendship, such as fights and the fire
_Yeonjun blindly falls in the trap thinking they're all games, when in reality he's already taken them too far, ruining the whole friendship over fights that were meant to be playful but end up hurting everyone
_Taehyun finds out about what's going on in the group and confronts Boemgyu, who kills him to keep him quiet
_Huening Kai is naive and isn't aware of what is happening at all and still thinks they're all friends, until it's too late and the friendship is ended and everybody is suffering
Why would beomgyu kil taehyun over that
@@julianabuarque8245 according to the theories that i've read, soobin is manipulating beomgyu the part in the mv where soobin pushed the glass out of the table and cuts to the scene of beomgyu falling on the bed meaning that soobin has successfully initiated his plan of brainwashing beomgyu and since taehyun is suspicious of soobin's actions, beom tried to silence taehyun by killing him so that the the chaos he and soobin made won't be revealed to the group.
In the lyrics of the song, it says “Our Scintilla bloomed underneath the starlight. Now see them burn in fire.” Scintilla means “A tiny trace or spark of a specified quality or feeling.” Just wanted to point that out.
When you watch stuff like this you don't realise how much depth there is to a storyline! Normally I just watch without a second thought but this has shown me the creativity and art of txt, thank you for this theory
In the choreo you said that when they say "who's a liar?" Soobin and Taehyun cross their fingers behind their backs while the others hold out their pinkies means that they aren't being truthful aka they are the liars. Well I was trying to pay closer attention to he choreo and noticed that when they say the first "can't you see me" of the choruses, they take slide their arms under their chin and they seem to be pointing at something. Then I noticed that they Beomgyu is the last one in the formation that they stand in and they could be pointing at him. I may be looking into this too much but maybe it means that, as you said in the video, Soobin is manipulating Beomgyu and the others catch on to Beomgyu's odd behaviour but they don't know what Soobin is doing so Soobin just keeps quiet about it. Idk let me know what you think
MJ Kpop
I think so too!
Also Bemogyu, if you look closely, doesn‘t do the pinky promise either. He makes horns which may mean that he‘s been possessed aka controlled (by Soobin?)
Especially since Bemogyu lead txt to Soobins house, starts the fights, suffocates Taehyun and then always directly looks at the camera as if he knows what he‘s doing and wants us to keep quiet
I love the new album so much, my favorite track is fairy of shampoo, but all of the songs are great
I like how all their songs interconnect with lyrical and visual storylines. It's honestly a masterpiece.
I swear that bighit has the most complex backstories.... like just bts's,txt's backstories?? Bighit really needs to make a whole show explaining the theories..
honestly, txts storyline is already more confusing than bts’
also i think PUMA is the next MV, no theory, just cause of the trailer...
Bts is more confusing to me... it's about psyche, the journey to the self by Carl Jung theory and the wings is definitely the hardest universe to crack up rather than txt... txt theories are much more relatable to younger people because they were still young... but bts is using something people are not that familiar with... the persona, shadow, ego, anima animus, its just too much...
Big hit really do be planning everything since the 1800s y’all this is crazy. I like how they have a concept to follow and and that it’s not just some random songs they make.
I love this theory and I hope that they'll once find a way to get back together :(
and not kill each other
Omg, friendship is sometimes complicated. Txt reflects so many moments my 'friends' and I have been through, I guess many more people, too. I appreciate that they talk about this topic, I love this group's concepts sm, I'll stan :')
This blue notebook it appears when we unlock the hidden song "Sweat", there's a video after you clear the "mission" from Magic, and it's the Run Away scenario, the boys are entering a classroom, and I think Soobin is filming and this notebook showed up, in the cover is written "FOREVER" It gave me chills
At the end of Magical Island, when the cat runs over them in the shape of a train and among those "flashback"each of the boys touches the part of the body that refers to the teddy bear.
Could this mean that when they come back to reality their worst fears return?
(sorry about the english)
BigHit really has so many stories to tell
Bighit must be so smart to think of something like this. I mean... it’s an entire storyline! Whoever came up with the storyline is amazing.
YOU JUST PREDICTED THE CAT -ITS ON ETERNALLY AND MADE APPERANCE IM FREAKING OUT
2:13 I just realized one thing. I've heard somewhere that there's a very slim chance where you can remember a *real* dream. And if nap of the star is a "dream MV", I can see why they don't remember the promise. It's not really related to cysm but I just wanted to share my thoughts.
IM HERE TO SUPPORT!
I watch you since your very first video on txt. (weird hat era) And honestly, youre the best theorist when it comes to the bighit universe. Love You and my mind is once again blown!
Nedved Tom WEIRD HAT ERA. YOU JUST NAMED THAT ERA 😂😂😂😂😂
Hybe casually making a whole literal story line for each and every group...is just so.....confusing...cuz I dont understand any groups storyline that easily🤡🤡
ok but how are people that smart. like girl im just watching and enjoying their videos i never noticed anything of that-
This is just a genius theory, it really connects with every MV of theirs uwu
finding your video again 2 years later and most of the theories still stand! this was one of the first theories i had seen when i became a moa im really happy to watch it again :) see you in the name chapter
BigHit really do love making people trying to solve their theories and making them confuse
beomgyu is such an interesting character
he is the 3rd youngest and 3rd oldest, his colour in the debut photos was orange.
orange is the middle of red and yellow
yellow is usually a colour that we use to represent happiness and peace, while red is usually a colour that we use to represent anger and chaos. in the cysm m/v, he is either seen very happy, or very not, one moment he was having fun with the strawberries, the next he’s trying to kill taehyun.
him being the middle member in the age means that he’s in the hyung line and the maknae line. this could also mean that he can be both mature and cute.
i think that the whole +u is actually two different stories.
yeonjun supposedly broke the rules in magic island, by opening his eyes.
txt is constantly relating to games, you know the board game operation? where if you touch the sides the buzzer sounds? when yeonjun opened his eyes, i think that triggered the star, as long as you close your eyes, the star stays on.
when the star ‘turned off’, the witch came out pretty much straight away, the witch is like the buzzer sounding. when yeonjun found himself dead in the ruined stadium, it was literally dark and there wasn’t much colour in the scene. the witch is also very dark.
but when taehyun found him, his throat was slit and purple blood was coming out of his cut. the witch and the cat are pretty much the same thing. in the scene in naos when the cat and yeonjun met, his horns gave the cat a sort of smile. what cat smiles and is purple?
the cheshire cat
the cheshire cat is a character in alice in wonderland, this relates to taehyun’s section in eternally, where there was supposedly a reference to the gossiping flowers. the cheshire cat has the ability to time travel, it smiles then disappears and reappears somewhere else. the whole +u is about time travel.
back to there being two different stories in +u,
yeonjun dies in two different ways
beomgyu fights both soobin and taehyun
kai is in two completely different times, one as a child and one as now
soobin is in both worlds, his dream being one world and the practice room in eternally being the other
but what’s taehyuns?
beomgyu fights taehyun in one world, taehyun is one of the only members without stripes on their sleeve, we saw that the person had no stripes on their sleeve for a split second in eternally. taehyun’s morse code is ‘clue’, he can be seen as sort of nosy, he’s the detective, always finding out everything. taehyun wanted to know what’s in the book beomgyu has, but he got upset and his wings/spikes came out. in the choreography for cysm, taehyun is one of the liars because we can see he crosses his fingers in soobins line ‘who’s a liar?’. beomgyu and taehyun are always fighting, beomgyu always being the one who attacks first though.
in another world, soobin fights beomgyu, i think this because he ends up with the same book beomgyu had been protecting. in the practice room in eternally, beomgyu films soobin a lot, only soobin, i don’t think he ever films him when he’s with the other members. soobin is also one of the liars in cysm choreo, he also crosses his fingers. i think beomgyu could know that taehyung and soobin are both liars, because with yeonjun and kai, he’s very friendly.
in naos when the star goes out, you’ll see the witch come, but you will also see a butterfly flying around. beomgyu’s animal for the questioning things was a butterfly. coincidence?
IM SO HAPPY I FINALLY UNDERSTOOD A THEORY ABT THE TIMELINE THANK YOU FOR THIS I HOPE U MAKE ANOTHER ONE IF AN MV DROPS AGAIN!!!
Staying up to stream the CYSM vid and, oh look! You uploaded! Yay!
When taehyun
Eat the strawberry
Beomgyu had red light
And you didnt notice
That the only capture in the camera is
Kai,beom and yeon
Soobin- Lonely
Beomgyu- Soobin is controling him(?)
Taehyun- Knows what Soobins going though
Yeonjun- Guilty because he started all of this
Huening Kai- Just trying to have a good time
(I think this is what she's saying...?)
Why is everyone so SMART I WISH I COULD SHARE MY THEORIES TOO BUT NO ONE WILL CARE HAHAHA GOOD THING ur hear
Became a MOA just March of this year. I just heard this song last night and I'm addicted. I've watched most vids about CYSM (including performance videos, bts, award shows, and theories) and would like to share some of what I noticed.
1. Starting from 0:23 - Gyu and Yeonjun are the only two that looks kind of guilty.
Kai - grieving sad
Taehyun - emotionless, suspicious
Soobin - looks done and gave up
2. It's already given that Soobin and Taehyun are the liars (if you base it on their crossed fingers), the reason I guess why Gyu and Yeonjun resents them.
3. The scene on the sofa when Kai took some photos, only Gyu and Yeonjun are smiling. The other two are on the floor, all serious.
4. Notice how they kill the other characters (or ended their friendship). Gyu ate the cookie and bite its "head" off - look what he did to Taehyun. He covered his head with a blanket. Yeonjun, on the other hand, is the one who used the oven to bake - fire started inside the house on the scene where he checked his hand and saw the other members.
5. There are 2 types of liar friends based on the "lips" scene. The smiling lips are not Soobins *I paused it a dozen more times to check*, the screaming one is. **More on this on #6. One lies to fool and/or manipulate (smiling) while the other one lies that he's okay eventhough he wants to be closer to his friends (screaming) *which is also based on their Eternity concept trailer.
6. Soooo... I mentioned above that the smiling lips aren't Soobins. I'm guessing it's either Taehyun or *gasp* Yeonjun. Okay, hear me out..
6a. As mentioned on #5, a person can lie to fool and/or manipulate other people. I'm guessing Taehyun are fooling his friends into thinking he wants their company when it's clearly not (he never smiled in the video), and Yeonjun's the manipulative one letting his friends feel everythings fine when in fact he has other plans *the ssssh scene in the oven*.
6b. On the first liar line of Soobin, notice how Yeonjun peeked through. Co-incidence? Maybe. Maybe not.
6c. Some of you might ask "Why Yeonjun? His hand gesture on the liar line is a pinky swear and not a crossed finger". Well, that is true.. however, not everyone can keep their promises. Friendships are not all roses, sometimes it ends in a one big mess. You may also check the bridge lyrics.
S: Bad bad hope it’s just a painful dream
Y: Sad sad return me to your side again
6d. Yeonjun crying alone in the bed covered with the blanket, with his friends surrounding him. He's guilty on something he did. In the process of trying to hurt Soobin, he hurt his other friends too and lose them all. *Check YJ line again from the bridge above*.
Again it could be Taehyun or Yeonjun or both - aside from Soobin, being the liar.
Just curious at the end, there are only 4. Soobin is not shown. Maybe he completely cut-off his friendship with the other 4, staying inside the burning house (ashes of their friendship as per the song). This is the reality of some friendships, it's messy all around. WDYT?
I’VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!!
i literally kid you not i get CHILLS everytime i see this cat. it just weirds me out!
...this could be a drama guys....I'm telling you
Omg txt linking all there mvs in such a manner they have taken it to another level
I’m french and when you say the « ceci n’est pas un nounours » I was like so happy because that was so cute the way you say it. And you say it well☺️.
Finally thanks so much laina😊
4:20 - "why should it be only me who suffers"
The Chaos chapter : Freeze-
Ice cream - "I feel like I'm the only one that's been robbed
It's unfair
So everything shall be doomed"
😨😱
Bighit is really planning a whole movie out here, I never knew a song could get this deep and interesting
12:36 so I went at the txt-theanswers and I can't find that word cause I'm stupid, does anyone know?
Forever
At 4:30 she talks about the choreo containing clues with the fingers crossed gesture so I wanted to point this out. At the end of the dance, when Yeonjun shhs the lines saying "friends don't understand me" Yeonjun, Kai and Beomgyu look up at each other, but Taehyun and Soobin, the "liars" both look down, like they feel guilty or scolded. I checked out a bunch of performances to see if it was a fluke, but they do it the same every time. It may just be an aesthetic choice for the dance, but it's something I noticed and thought it was neat, and went along well with the theory!
THE QUEEN OF THEORIES IS BACK
so........ eternally..........
I was really impressed with everything you said. The difficulty is wanting to see the video and read the subtitles in Portuguese LOL !!
Brazil🇧🇷🇧🇷❤️
a little late to comment but i read the comments and with the help of some of my theory's i think that in cant you see me the cat has full control over them and that the lairs kinda know what is happening. also i feel like beomgyu is doing all this and is happy about it. but i dont think he is doing it on purpose . he might be controlled (or not). huening kai is probable the innocent one that is gullible and does not know a thing. soobin knows what is happening and is probable the cats target. were as yeonjun i think he is controled by soobin (aka maybe the cat) in to doing bad things just like what beomgyu is doing but realizes its bad a little too late. also in run away when soobin is drawing on the white baord it has multiple drawings of cats and also says forever . the baord also has a flower which you also see in eternally . you also see those tall trees in magic island and the fire. there is also that doll thing drawn on the baord. and last there is a star drawn on the baord which maybe is the star in nap of the star.
I've had multiple theory's with Can't You See Me and although none of them are similar to this one i really like this theory!
GOD you were right!!!! The next MV was Eternal and the cat DOES appear!!!!! God you are a genius. Im getting goosebumps.
If Soobin is the liar then it is all a lie! The dreams and everithing
sooo eternally is out and we are waiting queen
I am not good at theories. in fact congratulations I loved yours. maybe just maybe the cat was there. that smiley face made of ketchup beomgyu's shirt has one too and in the yeonjun photoshoot there is also a smiling face on his shirt. this can be random but it was something I noticed I believe that yeonjun needs help, probably beomgyu too, but mainly yeonjun and soobin, are the two who ask for "save me" in the song and in an interview (I'll leave the link and the exact moment ) asked: who was that fighting with the devil? -It was me (soobin replied) and then appears "yeonjun was captured by the devil first" idk if it helps with something kkk "we never said it anywhere else" they said. ps: sorry for any mistakes, kisses and support from Brazil
th-cam.com/video/tO-DEhq2sjI/w-d-xo.html.
Txt mmtg if the link doesn't works. 9:54
I'm not a MOA, but I wanted to know what was going on in "Can't you see me?" AND THIS IS INSANE, I'm in love with these theories haha
Why does the cookie that Beomgyu ate in Cant You See Me seems suspicious to me?? Idek anymore, my brain has exploded in this video😆 Luv your videos Laina♡♡
Bruh you don’t know how much I appreciate your channel because I’m really bad at figuring things like this out and you make staning bts and txt so much more fun for me
We have Puma then Eternally... my brain is hurting
Why can I relate to Kai trying to just have fun and Soobin being left out