🌹❤🌹❤🌹❤VIELEN DANK, Herr Pau NG 🌹🎹🎻 AUSGEZEICHNET GROSSARTIGE Werk 💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹🎹🎻👑🇩🇪👑🎉🎉Alles Gute zum Geburtstag Johann Philipp Kirnberger🎁🎂🥂🍾🌹💐🌹💐🌹❤Dankeschön 🌹 Ich wünsche dir den besten Tage, Liebe, Glück und Viel Spaß ❤ GÖTTLICH Musik ...🍃🕊 💙 🕊
Listening to this music one can hear why it was thought to be by JS Bach who’s keyboard output was scattered over Europe and thought to be his, when so many impressionists were using his style right through the 1770’s and many later composers still preferred the high baroque to the new classical being there was still a market for it ❤
very impressive Johann Philipp Kirnberger is a disciple of J.S. Bach, and like sinfonìa in D major and this harpsichord concerto in C minor, his life is pre-classical, but still retains the characteristics of baroque. I think he is a rare composer who was born in 1719 and has a completely different taste from his contemporaries L. Mozart.
Wow, this is such amazing work. Composers almost always get all the credit but here are amazing musicians who have spent most of their lives honing their skill, their art, using instruments of remarkable craftsmanship working as one being to perform this great music. I am so deeply touched. Perhaps partly because my pickup broke down and my dog ran away and my girlfriend thinks i am one of those cheese balls that nobody eats at one of those fancy-dress parties where everyone stares at paintings that look like a child with the hiccups painted them because i love this awesome music.
Richard Castro. Lo felicito por su fina prosa y por la elegancia de su expresión. Ud es un maestro en el hablar y nuevamente lo felicito. Saludos desde Ciudad de México.
In the space for description of the video it's given: " previously attributed to Johann Sebastian Bach".If a music is attributed to be composed by a great maestro such as JSBach we can imagine the quality of the music.No matter whether Kirnberger was equal to the stature of JSBach as a composer this music is of fine quality and was really magnificent! It soothed my soul.Gracias.Ciao.
To be honest there were too many critiques from his contemporaries as much as I read. In fact, this concerto may easily be mismatched with an average CPE Bach work that means Kirnberger got inspired by CPE, without adding any particulat original idea, but still putting together a decent piece of music as a follower. I would not use the word "uninspired" that is way too severe, imho. What puzzles me is how on the earth this concerto may have been attributed to JS Bach whose style (even to an amateur like me, hence not at all an expert musicologist) is rather easily distinguished vs the style of his "most akin" sons (CPE & WF)
The manuscript frontpiece has an entry with "Del Sign. Joh. Seb. Bach". It seems the attribution was made in the Kirnberger times. But by our "Bach" trained ears, it clearly has a CPE (or WF) Bach inspiration. I wonder if it was written by Kirnbeger himself as a high admirer of JS Bach. Who knows but honestly looks like the same caligraphy...
@@Reciclassicat I find this concert closer to old barocque style with only a hint of the style of C.P.E. Bach that has a specific outstanding personality; more conservative the 1 movement more "half XVII century" the second
@@andreagriseri7656 While listening to the first movement, I thought exactly the same thing. It visits keys in an arch: c-Eb-g-Eb-c. We would not expect the second visit to E-flat by 1770 (making the secondary key too stable). However, it DOES have the later innovation of the cadential 6/4 announcing the cadenza.
🌹❤🌹❤🌹❤VIELEN DANK, Herr Pau NG 🌹🎹🎻 AUSGEZEICHNET GROSSARTIGE Werk 💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹🎹🎻👑🇩🇪👑🎉🎉Alles Gute zum Geburtstag Johann Philipp Kirnberger🎁🎂🥂🍾🌹💐🌹💐🌹❤Dankeschön 🌹 Ich wünsche dir den besten Tage, Liebe, Glück und Viel Spaß ❤ GÖTTLICH Musik ...🍃🕊 💙 🕊
Listening to this music one can hear why it was thought to be by JS Bach who’s keyboard output was scattered over Europe and thought to be his, when so many impressionists were using his style right through the 1770’s and many later composers still preferred the high baroque to the new classical being there was still a market for it ❤
MAGNIFICENT music, played 'like we love it', with the enchanting sound of the harpsichord, and superbly interpreted. Merci!
Soft and harmonic sounds like these, make my soul to travel through the serenity and beauty of life...
very impressive
Johann Philipp Kirnberger is a disciple of J.S. Bach, and like sinfonìa in D major and this harpsichord concerto in C minor, his life is pre-classical, but still retains the characteristics of baroque.
I think he is a rare composer who was born in 1719 and has a completely different taste from his contemporaries L. Mozart.
Sparkly and beautifully played keyboard part much thanks
The wonderfulness of this footage and music is full of impression and admiration
Merci beaucoup de me permettre de connaître ce ravissant concerto que
j' apprécié autant par sa composition que par sa talentueuse interprétation !
I'm amazed, Pau, that you are so often able to post a work on the composer's birthday. It's a nice birthday present for them!
😄🎉🥂
Gorgeous piece, stunning performance!🌹🌹🌹
Wow, this is such amazing work. Composers almost always get all the credit but here are amazing musicians who have spent most of their lives honing their skill, their art, using instruments of remarkable craftsmanship working as one being to perform this great music. I am so deeply touched. Perhaps partly because my pickup broke down and my dog ran away and my girlfriend thinks i am one of those cheese balls that nobody eats at one of those fancy-dress parties where everyone stares at paintings that look like a child with the hiccups painted them because i love this awesome music.
Que maravilha é o cembalo 😍❤️
De dónde sacaste está fina gema? Cosas así me llenan de tal alegría que olvido los avatares de un cubano para sortear el día.
Me alegro que te guste! Un tesoro sin duda!
Richard Castro.
Lo felicito por su fina prosa y por la elegancia de su expresión.
Ud es un maestro en el hablar y nuevamente lo felicito.
Saludos desde Ciudad de México.
Raúl Franco, México lindo y querido!
That harpsichord sounds like a Challis, a nice bit of muscle in the tone.
Primitive or not I still enjoyed this composition. ❤
In the space for description of the video it's given: " previously attributed to Johann Sebastian Bach".If a music is attributed to be composed by a great maestro such as JSBach we can imagine the quality of the music.No matter whether Kirnberger was equal to the stature of JSBach as a composer this music is of fine quality and was really magnificent! It soothed my soul.Gracias.Ciao.
To be honest there were too many critiques from his contemporaries as much as I read.
In fact, this concerto may easily be mismatched with an average CPE Bach work that means Kirnberger got inspired by CPE, without adding any particulat original idea, but still putting together a decent piece of music as a follower. I would not use the word "uninspired" that is way too severe, imho.
What puzzles me is how on the earth this concerto may have been attributed to JS Bach whose style (even to an amateur like me, hence not at all an expert musicologist) is rather easily distinguished vs the style of his "most akin" sons (CPE & WF)
The manuscript frontpiece has an entry with "Del Sign. Joh. Seb. Bach". It seems the attribution was made in the Kirnberger times. But by our "Bach" trained ears, it clearly has a CPE (or WF) Bach inspiration. I wonder if it was written by Kirnbeger himself as a high admirer of JS Bach. Who knows but honestly looks like the same caligraphy...
@@Reciclassicat sometimes I would like to have a time machine to resolve these intriguing "musical cold cases" 😄
@@Reciclassicat I find this concert closer to old barocque style with only a hint of the style of C.P.E. Bach that has a specific outstanding personality; more conservative the 1 movement more "half XVII century" the second
@@andreagriseri7656 While listening to the first movement, I thought exactly the same thing. It visits keys in an arch: c-Eb-g-Eb-c. We would not expect the second visit to E-flat by 1770 (making the secondary key too stable). However, it DOES have the later innovation of the cadential 6/4 announcing the cadenza.
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Sehr edel! J. S. Bach ist spürbar.
Nice harpsichord, but the rest is soo terribly romantic :((
Feels rather primitive for 1770?
The Berlin school of music took a singular (and apparently "primitive") way even when music was fastly evolving into the new trends.