You can choose the panalty wich have minimum cost both of them if both cost are same then u can choose that cost which will allot maximum units... This is very esy to solve a Q...... U can easily understand by this video th-cam.com/video/4LN-46Q2bOU/w-d-xo.html
At 2:28 you said that if 2 same numbers are there in 1row then diffrence between 1st and 2nd minimum should be taken, but in NPTEL video ( th-cam.com/video/Q31jKiEXxdc/w-d-xo.html ) at 26:48 professor told that if 2elements are same then penalty must be 0. Kindly verify sir.
With all due respect to NPTEL professor. Understand the concept of penalties. It’s about finding the loss of money by picking up two best options (I.e. minimum transportation costs) and then the highest penalty I.e. highest loss is covered first with the allocation. If there are two cost cells that are same and I am putting penalties as zero that means I haven’t evaluated two lowest costs in terms of minimum and second minimum. Hence I prefer to go with min and second min
@@shershah9406 ultimately you get to find the optimal solution and that would be same for all, so IFS is not right or wrong only the quality of answer would vary marginally
@@shershah9406 ultimately you get to find the optimal solution and that would be same for all, so IFS is not right or wrong only the quality of answer would vary marginally
Tq apki aadat mjhe achchi lgi ki apne like or comnt ke liye nhi bola isliye mene khud hi kar diya i m inspire with you
How did you get 10 in x24 it should be 15
And also in x34 you got 5 how ?
thank you sir! i can do my assignment thanks to this video! i
th-cam.com/video/1wbQ-WtTmaM/w-d-xo.html
Nice explanation sir thank you
When vogel approximation method fails ? with example
Well explained sir 👏
Thanks
Very helpful
Thank you . I have one question. I was doing another problem then on the second round i got all the penalties equal to 25 how can i proceed ?
Please send the problem screenshot @ bksoam@live.com
@@bksoam thank you. I have sent it. Hope you received it
@@wengelawitbisrat8934 sent the solution
@@bksoam Thank you so much!!
Is it complete question
Thanks alot❤️💯
If the panelty get tie how should we select the amount
Any of the the penalties will work. The initial solution may differ in that case due to different selection of penalties
thank you sir
What to do when collum and row panalty are same
Mohammad Meraj Ansari u can choose to enter from any of them. The initial solution may differ but the end result will be same
You can choose the panalty wich have minimum cost both of them if both cost are same then u can choose that cost which will allot maximum units... This is very esy to solve a Q...... U can easily understand by this video
th-cam.com/video/4LN-46Q2bOU/w-d-xo.html
How to calculate zero present in row and column
that will be treated as minimum
At 2:28 you said that if 2 same numbers are there in 1row then diffrence between 1st and 2nd minimum should be taken, but in NPTEL video ( th-cam.com/video/Q31jKiEXxdc/w-d-xo.html ) at 26:48 professor told that if 2elements are same then penalty must be 0. Kindly verify sir.
With all due respect to NPTEL professor. Understand the concept of penalties. It’s about finding the loss of money by picking up two best options (I.e. minimum transportation costs) and then the highest penalty I.e. highest loss is covered first with the allocation. If there are two cost cells that are same and I am putting penalties as zero that means I haven’t evaluated two lowest costs in terms of minimum and second minimum. Hence I prefer to go with min and second min
@@bksoam sir then whom to follow? your method or NPTEL method.
@@bksoam Sir I am assistant professor of industrial engineering and operations research at BIT Mesra and i follow the same method as taught in NPTEL
@@shershah9406 ultimately you get to find the optimal solution and that would be same for all, so IFS is not right or wrong only the quality of answer would vary marginally
@@shershah9406 ultimately you get to find the optimal solution and that would be same for all, so IFS is not right or wrong only the quality of answer would vary marginally
4 agr ( -4 ) tab is question ko kese solve kr skte h..
th-cam.com/video/1wbQ-WtTmaM/w-d-xo.html
Can u send transportation problem vam method
Its VAM only
th-cam.com/video/1wbQ-WtTmaM/w-d-xo.html
Can u send lest cost method link
Look in to the channel
This language convert in hindi link send
th-cam.com/video/1wbQ-WtTmaM/w-d-xo.html
Your camera is poor please check
It's good, improve ur video quality
Kbhi ro ko nhi leta
To kbhi column ko
kamal verma u have to take maximum penalty value doesn’t matter row or column as it represents highest opportunity lost
Speak loudly
But I got the answer as 475
Could hardly understand this accent
How would i know that i should delete a row or a column?