Hello, I'm a VFX artist and I just wanted to point out something The "illumix" model of Plushtrap is not the actual model, it's all 3D renders which explains why the detail is so high and superior to the other 2. The one used in the trailer is a VFX shot with tracking on a real life scene (see Iron man armors in Marvel movies for example) I also want to point out that Steelwool's models are often lower quality because HW is a VR game before anything else and the detail on the models cannot be really high if performance must be kept, that includes the characters, effects, map etc etc all on 2K to 4K screens. Thanks for reading and have a great day or night
@@KadesKove lolbit, funtime foxy, and mangle all dont actually have confirmed genders, and i dont think they ever will, sense the gender of the characters dont actually matter.
Not to be rude but i really dont like the fnaf vr models. They changed the colors and looks of the models. They could have done WAY better in my opinion. And keep in mind THIS IS MY OPINION.
Congrats on 19.6K subs. It was legit only about a month or two ago when you were at just 5K. Big jump in a small amount. Keep up the good work, constant uploads, and I can’t wait for you to grow even bigger.
Bonnie: I agree with FreddyPopCollector Phantom Mangle: To me i like the 2 the same Nightmare Freddy: Another agreed Lolbit: I perfer scott's model (also the hook is because lolbit in fnaf world) Withered Chica: Yes another agreed Plushtrap: perfect scotts
this doesn't have anything to do with the actual models but can we just stop for a moment and laugh at the puppets movement in fnaf VR. Why did the make him so wavy and floaty? Is he a ghost? How does he constantly do the wave?
My Opinion: Mr. Bonnie: Scott’s. Steel Wool’s is blue, do I need to say more? Illumix’s is too shiny. Phantom Mangle: Hard choice but I’d have to go with Steel Wool’s. Basically the same reason as him. Nightmare Freddy: Scott’s because Steel Wool’s has yellow eyes, and the secondary color is not as bright as Scott’s. Lolbit: Is this even a question? I like Scott’s Withered Chica: Scott’s, it’s way creepier than Steel Wool’s, case closed. Plushtrap: Illumix’s, do I need to say more? More texture, has irises, that’s all I could think of. THESE ARE MY OPINION PEOPLE, thank you :)
I think the original intent was that Bonnie's color was supposed to represent a blue tone even if it really comes across as a purple tone, that's why he is represented blue in Fnaf World. The reason why he looks odd in Help Wanted is because his snout and belly are pure white wile in the original version it is a faded blue, pretty much grey.
I think Bonnie was actually supposed to be blue, since Scott has made almost every other version (most importantly Adventure (FNaF World) Bonnie) blue. Also Funko's version of Lolbit having a hook is probably due to the FNaF World version.
The original Bonnie isn’t purple, it’s just always seen under intense lighting. If you compare Scott’s behind-the-scenes image of Bonnie in the backroom it’ll be clearer why Steel Wool’s Bonnie looks the way it does.
Yay new video! Keep up the good work! My ranking: Bonnie: Steel wool Phantom mangle: Steel wool Nightmare freddy: Scott Lolbit: Steel wool Withered chica: Scott Plushtrap: Illumix
Another complaint on Steel Wool Bonnie, you can clearly see at 1:16 that they got his head shape wrong. And with Illimix, Bonnie is too purple! You can see that Steel Wool and Scott’s base color for Bonnie are closer to each other.
For me, I think all the Illumix models for the toy animatronics (including Mangle) are the best. They show the most realistic shine and they have very well modelled scratches and damage done to them, which is realistic for animatronics like the toys who are near children everyday. (Especially Mangle)
You should continue this series. It's interesting to hear what someone else think about the models. Personally, I think steel wool did the best job, then Scott Cawthon's original models and last place are AR models, i don't know why but AR models look different from the others but i can't say what exatcly
Funko gives lolbit a hock because in fnaf world she had a body and a hock and the fnaf world lolbit was the first lolbit whit a body so funko give there action figure a hock
honestly, I agree with most of your opinions, except for the bonnie. in my opinion, steel wools bonnie gives me more 'child entertainer but secretly evil' vibes more than Scott's model. but hey, good video!
Good video! Next time can you cover the rest of the withered models please? I don’t want to force you to do anything though. I’ll watch no matter what models you cover next.
Personally, I love most of the steel’s models, they really capture the feel for actual real life animatronics, but nothing can beat the originals in my opinion
you should compare fan models insted of official models since steel wool and illumix edited scotts model so you aren't really comparing anything beside the fact their edited
7.phantom bb do I even need to explain 6.phantom puppet she’s really annoying 5. Phantom golden Freddy he’s really random and cool 4.phantom chica she has a cool mechanic and is an arcade gamer 3.phantom mangle a really cool coloration 2.phantom foxy really cool and has a hard mechanic 1.phantom Freddy the best mechanic and a cool design
Thanks for doing Withered Chica. I prefer some of the details on SteelWool's model like the end of her arms having frayed pom pom strands instead of wires as well as her endo jaws having blood from the bite of 87.
In my opinion this is my favorite phantom ranking worst (I know that shadow Freddy is in fnaf 3 and we all thought it was golden but I’m still going to call him golden Freddy cause it sticks out I love shadow Freddy but he looks green in fnaf 3 which doesn’t look right in my opinion)
2:35 To correct you, Nightmare Freddy's irises are always amberish gold. But yeah, his eyes are more befitting on PC than in VR. Why did SteelWool give him black pupils? I even find his eyes rather hypnotic since they're fixed onto us in the FNAF 4 extras menu.
I need to take a moment to just say how much I appreciate this channel. I've been looking for a good fnaf channel for years. Don't get me wrong, Dawko is good and all, but he doesn't cover fnaf all the time, he mainly does fan games. But you always do fnaf, and that's what I love. I love the little things you cover. Tbh, I learn more about fnaf in your videos than I do in Dawkos because of the depth you take into fnaf. So thank you for making your channel, I love it. Additional note, I've noticed your editing skills are getting a lot better! So keep up the good work. 😌
While i was watching this i was dancing to we are the phantom you are the best fnaf youtube channel besides Dawko, game theory, and of course Markipler.
Ah yes, the four horsemen of Fnaf: Dawko Matpat Markiplier And FreddyPopCollector They all somehow manage to take different corners of the Fnaf games and make them interesting. Also, if you're interested in a similar channel to this one, you should check out Andiematronic (very good channel)
tbh across all the models I have ever seen, I've always favored the scott classics, maybe its the way scott frames them but they always had a more stylishly grim look that I favor
The models are all quite good across the board. I think the ones that can be the jankiest are the Steel Wool ones. My favorite model I think would have to be the Nightmare endo from HW. So detailed, so good! Yet barely seen..
Withered chica is cute in vr, also my fav animatronic is nightmare and I was upset af that he wasn't on vr. (yes I find nightmare and nightmare fredbear cute) but love the video!
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
Hello, I'm a VFX artist and I just wanted to point out something
The "illumix" model of Plushtrap is not the actual model, it's all 3D renders which explains why the detail is so high and superior to the other 2. The one used in the trailer is a VFX shot with tracking on a real life scene (see Iron man armors in Marvel movies for example)
I also want to point out that Steelwool's models are often lower quality because HW is a VR game before anything else and the detail on the models cannot be really high if performance must be kept, that includes the characters, effects, map etc etc all on 2K to 4K screens.
Thanks for reading and have a great day or night
What do you mean about the iron man thing?
@@mrfazmeme3565 the plushtrap is not the actual model.
plushtrap has 4 models guys DONT FORGET THE OUT OF STOCK ONE
@@TheSage1211 there isn’t a official 3D model for him.
3:30 lolbit comes from fnaf world, and she had a hook there, she also has a hook in Freddy in space 2,so I think that's why they gave her a hook
yeah, im pretty sure funko just took mostly reference for lolbit from his fnaf world version, and a little bit of sl lolbit and funtime foxy
Pretty sure Lolbit's a dude but ok-
@@KadesKove ah shit here we go again with the gender debate
@@slaybutton1692 I'm just stating my views. No need to get offended.
@@KadesKove lolbit, funtime foxy, and mangle all dont actually have confirmed genders, and i dont think they ever will, sense the gender of the characters dont actually matter.
Bonnie has a deffrent model like old and new.
* different
Chicken Nugget well yeah they do
different* and if you mean old as withered well all of them have
You know what would also be a good series: fan models vs official models
yeah that's a great idea👍👍
I love that idea
We would be here ALL DAY..
🦊🐻🐥🐸 My favorite for the have characters are foxy Freddy chica happy frog who's your favorite I like your videos
Oh damm
I just realized that your intro music is "we are the phantoms" by rotten eggplant
Did you just read my mind
X0RPH0B1AS no
I think it’s the CG5 cover but idk
Lolbit has a hook in his/her Funko figure because he/she had one in FNaF World, aka his/her ingame debut.
I really like this series! And i’m excited to see steel wool’s Security Breach models!!
Scott's Models: Original, Good.
Steel Wools: Sometimes Good, Sometimes Bad.
Illumix: Shiny, Good, Sometimes Passes beyond Scott’s.
Allumix, jk idk how to spell it
You spelled illumix correct
Illumix is correct
Thanks for telling that it was correct.
here's the catch all models are scotts either way but edited by other companies
I'm just glad there aren't instances where any of them don't even try to look similar to the original
Looks like we are getting another series!
Ah, another series that will come to an end soon enough, eh?
Personally I think the VR models are more realistic and cooler, sure they’re less like the original but they are cooler.
I think the VR models are underrated. They look pretty cool to be from a vr game
+1
have you seen the endo's when i first saw them i thought they where real
@@thewhovianhippo7103 I know, they're amazing
Not to be rude but i really dont like the fnaf vr models. They changed the colors and looks of the models. They could have done WAY better in my opinion. And keep in mind THIS IS MY OPINION.
Congrats on 19.6K subs. It was legit only about a month or two ago when you were at just 5K. Big jump in a small amount. Keep up the good work, constant uploads, and I can’t wait for you to grow even bigger.
I like Bonnie's new guitar but I still have a place for the old guitar
Bonnie: I agree with FreddyPopCollector
Phantom Mangle: To me i like the 2 the same
Nightmare Freddy: Another agreed
Lolbit: I perfer scott's model (also the hook is because lolbit in fnaf world)
Withered Chica: Yes another agreed
Plushtrap: perfect scotts
After watching every single video in your channel I noticed that the intro song is “we are the phantoms” I like that song
Clicked as soon as I saw the notification, love the videos
this doesn't have anything to do with the actual models but can we just stop for a moment and laugh at the puppets movement in fnaf VR. Why did the make him so wavy and floaty? Is he a ghost? How does he constantly do the wave?
did you forget to mention that vr plushtrap has FIVE FINGERS?!?!
19k!! Oh my gosh dude! I'm so happy that you are growing so quickly! Congrats, my guy!
Aaahahahhahaha nvm! JUST HIT 20K !!!!! IM SO HAPPY FOR YOU!!!
My Opinion:
Mr. Bonnie: Scott’s. Steel Wool’s is blue, do I need to say more? Illumix’s is too shiny.
Phantom Mangle: Hard choice but I’d have to go with Steel Wool’s. Basically the same reason as him.
Nightmare Freddy: Scott’s because Steel Wool’s has yellow eyes, and the secondary color is not as bright as Scott’s.
Lolbit: Is this even a question? I like Scott’s
Withered Chica: Scott’s, it’s way creepier than Steel Wool’s, case closed.
Plushtrap: Illumix’s, do I need to say more? More texture, has irises, that’s all I could think of.
THESE ARE MY OPINION PEOPLE, thank you :)
I has a question is there gonna be a finale of this series?
-btw I liked the first vid-
-also bonnie is blue-ish purple-
VR Bonnie be looking like the old SFM model.
Illumix plush trap looks really nice oh yeah and good job for being very nice to your fans.
amazing, you should make more
( you should also make them longer)
I think the original intent was that Bonnie's color was supposed to represent a blue tone even if it really comes across as a purple tone, that's why he is represented blue in Fnaf World. The reason why he looks odd in Help Wanted is because his snout and belly are pure white wile in the original version it is a faded blue, pretty much grey.
I think Bonnie was actually supposed to be blue, since Scott has made almost every other version (most importantly Adventure (FNaF World) Bonnie) blue.
Also Funko's version of Lolbit having a hook is probably due to the FNaF World version.
I’ve always seen Bonnie as a blueish purple color.
I'm so glad you did this! I have no joke been looking everywhere for a decent model comparison video. Keep up the good work ✊
Yoooo I’ve been waiting for this vid. I loved the last model comparisons
The original Bonnie isn’t purple, it’s just always seen under intense lighting. If you compare Scott’s behind-the-scenes image of Bonnie in the backroom it’ll be clearer why Steel Wool’s Bonnie looks the way it does.
I love the part where it said "No this doesn't count." over FNaF World. That made me laugh.
Dang this idea is so cool!
When I was little I really didnt like spring bonnies model in fnaf world.
me: YES MORRREEE
Lol ur icon I love it
@@fabianfonseca7153 lol get one
*YOU DARE CHALLENGE ME*
And funko isn't lazy you poopy butt
gotta put that "me:" _somewhere_
Fpc: why does he have a hook that's stupid
Fnaf world: *exists*
Fpc: ima pretend that didn't happen
Now all I have to do is wait for the next episode and then after that the final episode
0:15 The captions 😂😂😂😂😂😂
The reason why it has a hook is because the adventure lolbit has a hook
This Series is awesome, and I would love a part 3!
The reason why Funko lol but has a hook is because in fnaf world she/he had one
I think that original classic look WAY better. Good vid😉👍
3:35 *THAT'S ME*
Also nice video lol
All of the Funtimes made by Steel Wool when you look at them closer they just look *S C U F F E D*
Yay new video!
Keep up the good work!
My ranking:
Bonnie: Steel wool
Phantom mangle: Steel wool
Nightmare freddy: Scott
Lolbit: Steel wool
Withered chica: Scott
Plushtrap: Illumix
I’m a big fan I’ve been waiting for you to upload every time
I can agree with all of these. Expert Bonnie I prefer steel wools mainly because it has that sfm look. Other then that great choices! Keep it up!
I have been binging your videos since two days ago. Since I came across your channel I got into Dawko so thank you.
3:25 I'm pretty sure Funko gave Lolbit a hook because I'm pretty sure Lolbit in FNAF World has a hook
This, this is nice I love the AR Plushtrap
Another complaint on Steel Wool Bonnie, you can clearly see at 1:16 that they got his head shape wrong. And with Illimix, Bonnie is too purple! You can see that Steel Wool and Scott’s base color for Bonnie are closer to each other.
you derverve over 1 million and i've been thinking of making vids like you. just wanted to tell you before i do it and people get mad at me
I barely realized something
3:45
I AM STILL NOT IN FNAF AR
👁💧👄💧👁
If anyone was wondering his intro song is called "we are the phantoms" by the way great vid Freddy pop collector.
I'd like to see you cover both the marionette and nightmarionne
Love the video as always!
Nice video I agree with you on the Nightmare Freddy and Bonnie I’m excited to see the next on of these you do
They gave lolbit a hook cause in fnaf world lolbit had a hook
I love your videos every time you upload one I watch it automatically
WE need more if these awesome comparisons
For me, I think all the Illumix models for the toy animatronics (including Mangle) are the best.
They show the most realistic shine and they have very well modelled scratches and damage done to them, which is realistic for animatronics like the toys who are near children everyday. (Especially Mangle)
This series is pretty cool
I didn't realise that plushtrap has stitches until you said that he does. I thought it was just the texture of the suit
You should continue this series. It's interesting to hear what someone else think about the models. Personally, I think steel wool did the best job, then Scott Cawthon's original models and last place are AR models, i don't know why but AR models look different from the others but i can't say what exatcly
Funko gives lolbit a hock because in fnaf world she had a body and a hock and the fnaf world lolbit was the first lolbit whit a body so funko give there action figure a hock
Please credit the Triple A Fazbear Wiki for some of the renders used in your content. Thank you.
Lefty needs a new model
honestly, I agree with most of your opinions, except for the bonnie.
in my opinion, steel wools bonnie gives me more 'child entertainer but secretly evil' vibes more than Scott's model. but hey, good video!
Wow, thats the most weird way I've ever seen someone say "peaches are the best fruit"
Good video!
Next time can you cover the rest of the withered models please?
I don’t want to force you to do anything though. I’ll watch no matter what models you cover next.
I am enjoying the series, continue please. To be honest, I like Illumix's models the most
i mean, Lolbit existed before SL:CN, they were the byte vendor in FNaF World, so they had a body
Personally, I love most of the steel’s models, they really capture the feel for actual real life animatronics, but nothing can beat the originals in my opinion
you should compare fan models insted of official models since steel wool and illumix edited scotts model so you aren't really comparing anything beside the fact their edited
😎 cool (And also congrats on 20K)
Hi freddy pop collector i am a big fan of you and you talking about fnaf
7.phantom bb do I even need to explain
6.phantom puppet she’s really annoying
5. Phantom golden Freddy he’s really random and cool
4.phantom chica she has a cool mechanic and is an arcade gamer
3.phantom mangle a really cool coloration
2.phantom foxy really cool and has a hard mechanic
1.phantom Freddy the best mechanic and a cool design
In my opinion my favorite models are: Regular Bonnie, Regular Phantom Mangle, Steel wool Nightmare Freddy, Regular Lolbit, Steel wool withered Chica, and Fnaf ar Plushtrap.
Plushtrap might be shows up soon but maybe they didn't have an idea about his gameplay
A part three would be nice!
For twenty k, maybe you could play something?
Thanks for doing Withered Chica. I prefer some of the details on SteelWool's model like the end of her arms having frayed pom pom strands instead of wires as well as her endo jaws having blood from the bite of 87.
Cant believe how much your channel has been blowing up recently.
In my opinion this is my favorite phantom ranking worst (I know that shadow Freddy is in fnaf 3 and we all thought it was golden but I’m still going to call him golden Freddy cause it sticks out I love shadow Freddy but he looks green in fnaf 3 which doesn’t look right in my opinion)
2:35 To correct you, Nightmare Freddy's irises are always amberish gold. But yeah, his eyes are more befitting on PC than in VR. Why did SteelWool give him black pupils? I even find his eyes rather hypnotic since they're fixed onto us in the FNAF 4 extras menu.
Scott's original design... that stare though. O_O
It's the road to 20k LET'S GET IT BOIIIIIIS!!!
I used to think phantom mangle was made out of code. Because she is on the monitor so code would make sense and she is green and black
I can't believe this all started with a screen saying "Warning: this game contains flashing lights, loud noises, and a lot of jumpscares"
I need to take a moment to just say how much I appreciate this channel. I've been looking for a good fnaf channel for years. Don't get me wrong, Dawko is good and all, but he doesn't cover fnaf all the time, he mainly does fan games. But you always do fnaf, and that's what I love. I love the little things you cover. Tbh, I learn more about fnaf in your videos than I do in Dawkos because of the depth you take into fnaf. So thank you for making your channel, I love it.
Additional note, I've noticed your editing skills are getting a lot better! So keep up the good work. 😌
*please do a part 3*
While i was watching this i was dancing to we are the phantom you are the best fnaf youtube channel besides Dawko, game theory, and of course Markipler.
Ah yes, the four horsemen of Fnaf:
Dawko
Matpat
Markiplier
And FreddyPopCollector
They all somehow manage to take different corners of the Fnaf games and make them interesting. Also, if you're interested in a similar channel to this one, you should check out Andiematronic (very good channel)
I 100% agree on you on the Nightmare Freddy one. 👍👍
Edit: Steel Wool also doesn’t have the wires.
tbh across all the models I have ever seen, I've always favored the scott classics, maybe its the way scott frames them but they always had a more stylishly grim look that I favor
The models are all quite good across the board. I think the ones that can be the jankiest are the Steel Wool ones. My favorite model I think would have to be the Nightmare endo from HW. So detailed, so good! Yet barely seen..
Withered chica is cute in vr, also my fav animatronic is nightmare and I was upset af that he wasn't on vr. (yes I find nightmare and nightmare fredbear cute) but love the video!
I actually agree with all your picks in this video and these videos are good pls continue
Me: Chilling and Drawing
FreddyPopCollector: *Uploads*
Me: meh
Video Title: *comparing models*
Me: *I AM SPEED*
congrats on 20K subscribers :)
for withered chica: they ain't called STEELwool for nothin'!
Next do Mangle models (Scott.C, Steel Wool & Illumix)
I prefer all of Scott's models except for Phantom Foxy, I think the VR model is a lot more creative. I just don't like that it's the FNaF 1 model tho
We need a part 3
Yes yes yes and yes, amazing! :> And your totally right about this.