The cheers for Ningning makes me cry she deserve so much love and support and they just prove that they can sing live 💜💜🔥 plus NIGNINGS HIGNOTE DID YOU HEAR THAT
Ningning and Giselle is really popular internationally. that is no surprise. Winter may be popular in Korea but its different outside of Korea. Altough all of them are all really famous but Ningning is just different.
Ningning proving why she’s the main vocal. Look at her go with that high note! No hesitation, she just belted it out while keeping her choreo sharp right after that.
i think the reason why they were so shaky in Coachella is because they were nervous, they can sing. They are just very nervous and lack confidence which is sad since people keep hating on them making it worse when in actuality they're great vocalists and most likely would have great stage presence as well. It's all about confidence
Ningning and Gigi are best received internationally, all these korean antis think their fellowmen are the only ones who deserve recognition. So glad to hear all the cheers for the two after getting so much non-sensical hate from Korea😐
They found their ground and audience that love and giving them great appreaciation, thank you guys for showering Aespa with so much Love, They are SINGING LIVE and all of you are lucky in hearing their powerful voices👏👏💙🌟🌙🦋
Aespa slayed i hope ppl cheer them and compliments them all and dont let one member hanging like they all gave their best so let’s give them the cheer and appreciation they all deserve if u rlly love Aespa u will appreciated them all as a whole group
I'm so touched. Aespa used to debut during covid and there was no audience at all. And now many people support them and love them. Very proud of them. Love you my girls ❤️
I love all the cheers for all of the girls equally, you can really tell that they had fun. Like Gigi and Ningning doesn't deserves all the disrespect they've been received in SK.
Giselle's attitude when doing these live stages really shines! Her "I'm confident" and smiles really add to the stages, plus she seems to handle the pressure of singing live really well! Her energy is super fabulous
I AM SATISFIED ON THIS SHOWCASE!! VERY VERY MUCHH!!! I'M SATISFIED ON THE CROWD AND THE PERFORMANCE!!! OH YES! PLUS THAT THEY SANG LUCID DREAM FOR THE VERY 1ST TIME!
They are all owning this era! This choreo showcases all of them. Ningning and Giselle have improved so much. They are finding their confidence. Love this
I love all the cheers for all of the girls equally, you can really tell that they had fun. No hate but Gigi and Ningning doesn't deserves tge disrespect when they're in SK.
Winter looks so pretty, cute, and amazing as always. She's getting better every day. Her voice is so greattt, and Ningning's voice too. Good job, Aespa!!!
when winter move her head, the fireworks blast as a background and for me, IT IS MOST SATISFYING SIGHT TO BEHOLD, a reason for orhers to stop criticizing our baby winter, you know what i mean, thank you😀😀😀😊
Winter didnt really had a good stage presence. She does that always. Sure i understand that she's concentrating but if she let that go and smile in the right part, the aenergy in the room will change immediatly for sure. The crowd can enjoy the music if they see you enjoy them too or want us to enjoy. Giselle did always a good job there
@@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300 winter actually improved her stage presence A LOt, especially on this day, many non fans even complimented her about it, you’re just so bitter.
@@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300 what do u mean. she got the best stage presence here along with giselle. stage presence doesn't mean smiling lol. she's smirking and confidently dancing and singing. what else could u ask for
omg this is so wonderful!!✨ their sound is the best tune. they are looked awesome and like an ethereal angel glow that lights a star. i'm so proud of aespa!! 🥺❤️
In their Coachella performance I saw a comment about ænergy not being a good song to start, but I think that it's so powerful and fits so much with their concept that sounds perfect for the beggining to me
블랙맘바도 라이브로 했다는 증거 2:36 원터 '넌 언젠가부터 싱크아웃'이랑 '노이즈 같이 보여' 할 때 '넌'이랑 '보여' 부분에서 마이크 문제인지 음원이랑 다르게 고음 올라갈 때 살짝 흔들림. 3:35 닝닝 '위험한 장난을 쳐 매혹적이지만 널 부정할 밖에' 부분할 때 음원에서는 장난을 쳐~인데 영상에서는 장난을 쳐↗️라고 함. 그리고 자기 파트 들어가기 전에 음방이랑 다르게 안무 동작 살짝 줄여서 춤. 립싱크할 거면 안무 완벽하게 출 수 있었겠지. 근데 라이브하니까 호흡 조절하려고 동작 크기 줄인거임. 자기 파트 아닐 때는 안무도 완벽하게 소화함. 실수한 거 찾으려는 게 아니고 에스파 라이브 못한다고 너무 억까하길래 음원이랑 살짝 다른 부분 찾아봄. 이건 실수한 게 아님. 각각 다른 무대별로 느낄 수 있는 매력이지. 실력있는 에스파 자신감 가지고 이번 활동도 성공적이였으면 좋겠다.
I love it when they sing high notes amazing I wish I was in la to see them. Awe I should have come. Me screaming and just watching this video. 😇🥰😍❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ #aespa #Karina #Winter #Giselle #Ningning
Better saving energy on singing than giving all the energy to dancing while having a shakey voice. Thank you for listening and watching aespa content. Saying they lip synching is such a complement 😉😁😄
Come on guys, Aespa doesn't need to prove anything to all those haters. Let them judge, besides they will never be happy whatever Aespa does. 😊 Let's just continue supporting and loving Aespa to make the haters even more bitter. 🤣
The cheers for Ningning makes me cry she deserve so much love and support and they just prove that they can sing live 💜💜🔥 plus NIGNINGS HIGNOTE DID YOU HEAR THAT
she deserves all the best
Ningning and Giselle is really popular internationally. that is no surprise. Winter may be popular in Korea but its different outside of Korea. Altough all of them are all really famous but Ningning is just different.
Come on she is the most popular in the group Internationally
Yes i saw also in next level us showcase video they cheer so loud for ningning! So happy for her!
@@danissegomez7953 Don't compare Ning Ning and Winter but cheer purely. Ning Ning and Winter are both popular and growing
Ningning proving why she’s the main vocal. Look at her go with that high note! No hesitation, she just belted it out while keeping her choreo sharp right after that.
And we can already hear her improvement since coachella
their live vocals have already improved SO MUCH since coachella, i really hope sm lets them keep singing live for the comeback too
💯
i think the reason why they were so shaky in Coachella is because they were nervous, they can sing. They are just very nervous and lack confidence which is sad since people keep hating on them making it worse when in actuality they're great vocalists and most likely would have great stage presence as well. It's all about confidence
I hope so. However I also think it won't happen. That's SM, you know...
@@tapewoerm they just were excited
The fact that people are saying this is pre recorded is such a compliment for AESPA!! Queens😩
Ikr!
SM artists' have got nuttin' to prove... they are some of the best trained vocalists.
@@shad0wCh8ser That’s the problem. They are talented but they barely get to showcase their vocals. People don’t doubt their talent though.
@@bobbyiconic but when sm artists showcase their talent people still hating on them
this is live i can tell but their dance move become much weaker
Ningning is so fierce , I love the international crowd is hyping her
I couldn't take my eyes of NingNing, she's so cute yet fierce and that stage presence... I'll support her in everything she wants
Ningning gorgeous!!
Ningning and Gigi are best received internationally, all these korean antis think their fellowmen are the only ones who deserve recognition. So glad to hear all the cheers for the two after getting so much non-sensical hate from Korea😐
NINGSELLE HAS GOTTEN THE ATTENTION THEY DESERVE!!!!
They found their ground and audience that love and giving them great appreaciation, thank you guys for showering Aespa with so much Love, They are SINGING LIVE and all of you are lucky in hearing their powerful voices👏👏💙🌟🌙🦋
Really happy for them
Wanna see aespa sing live? Go to their show. They’re exclusive ✨
Totally agree!!
Aespa very expensive 🥲
i always told that about sm artist, they will never let their artist waste their voice in non profit event lol 😅
@@darklighter9750 Right haha Anyways, even if they argue it too many times no one can be close to SM ARTIST VOCALS.
Hahahhaha trueee 🤣🤣
You know it’s live when Ning Ning is holding her mic on her high notes!
Performing in front of a live audience must have boosted their confidence so much. they’re doing good!!!
Ningning stage presence and expression is woww
Aespa slayed i hope ppl cheer them and compliments them all and dont let one member hanging like they all gave their best so let’s give them the cheer and appreciation they all deserve if u rlly love Aespa u will appreciated them all as a whole group
I'm so touched. Aespa used to debut during covid and there was no audience at all. And now many people support them and love them. Very proud of them. Love you my girls ❤️
Yes🥺💞🙌
ningning slayed that freakin high note
Ningning did so well
Aespa did very well
Ningning Queen
I love all the cheers for all of the girls equally, you can really tell that they had fun. Like Gigi and Ningning doesn't deserves all the disrespect they've been received in SK.
Giselle's attitude when doing these live stages really shines! Her "I'm confident" and smiles really add to the stages, plus she seems to handle the pressure of singing live really well! Her energy is super fabulous
You can clearly hear their live vocals there's background but they still sang live wowwww slayyyyyy
Winter's moves are so clean and crisp it's sooooooo satisfying to watch!!!!!
Aespa they have so stable vocals
Aespa is gorgeous😭😭😭I love them
2:06 that girl shouting "oh my God look at Ningning". Me too girl me too ❤️❤️😭😭😩😩
I AM SATISFIED ON THIS SHOWCASE!! VERY VERY MUCHH!!!
I'M SATISFIED ON THE CROWD AND THE PERFORMANCE!!! OH YES!
PLUS THAT THEY SANG LUCID DREAM FOR THE VERY 1ST TIME!
Really? Gonna check lucid dream
The crowd they deserveee😭
Their singing is soo Gorgeous in a way that, I thought its Pre-recorded.
Aespa is Amazing 💞💯
It's live lol
@@anisaariyani5510 It's LIVE, yes!
winter live voice is my everything
Im an international fan and always have soft spot for NINGNING not just cuz she is my bias but she doesn't gain the recognition she deserves in SK..
They are all owning this era! This choreo showcases all of them. Ningning and Giselle have improved so much. They are finding their confidence. Love this
They sing live
I love all the cheers for all of the girls equally, you can really tell that they had fun. No hate but Gigi and Ningning doesn't deserves tge disrespect when they're in SK.
THE LIVE VOCAL IMPROVES A LOT!!!
You need to pay to see their live singing. Haha. Love them anyway
How lovely to hear them sing live!! They slayed so hard! aespa fighting
Winter looks so pretty, cute, and amazing as always. She's getting better every day. Her voice is so greattt, and Ningning's voice too.
Good job, Aespa!!!
The crowd make me feel so proud 😭❤
Queen NingNing so pretty
Can't take my eyes off of ningng..she has some unexplainable charisma..😀
giselle stage presence 💪
They singing LIVE. I SO PROUD AESPA
THEY ARE SO STABLE OMG THEY SOUND LIKE THE STUDIO VERSION!!!!
NingNing slaying hard
when winter move her head, the fireworks blast as a background and for me, IT IS MOST SATISFYING SIGHT TO BEHOLD, a reason for orhers to stop criticizing our baby winter, you know what i mean, thank you😀😀😀😊
sorry for typo, its means others
Winter didnt really had a good stage presence. She does that always. Sure i understand that she's concentrating but if she let that go and smile in the right part, the aenergy in the room will change immediatly for sure. The crowd can enjoy the music if they see you enjoy them too or want us to enjoy. Giselle did always a good job there
@@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300 winter actually
improved her stage presence A LOt, especially on this day, many non fans even complimented her about it, you’re just so bitter.
@@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300 thats just her face bruh stop forcing it and accept it
@@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300 what do u mean. she got the best stage presence here along with giselle. stage presence doesn't mean smiling lol. she's smirking and confidently dancing and singing. what else could u ask for
닝닝아...사랑해 진짜로
Me encanta el baile de karina es muy satisfactorio no tiene que bailar con fuerza para hacerlo bien ♡
Finally a live performance omg i feel like I've been waiting for this since coachella
Aespa 💚💚💚
I can tell Ningning was nervous especially at the first part of Black Mamba. But when she did her B4 belt she overcame it.
Winterr♥♥♥
My goooooooosh the best begining and entrance of æspa!!! Wow love it, WE ARE THE ÆSPA!!!!
I'm in love with this girls ♡
Stanning queens after Queens. Love to see it.
omg this is so wonderful!!✨ their sound is the best tune. they are looked awesome and like an ethereal angel glow that lights a star. i'm so proud of aespa!! 🥺❤️
NINGNING MY LOVE KEEP SLAYING
*QUEEN GISELLE STAGE PRESENCE* 👑👑👑
Sending support to them from philippines were very proud to stan them 🥰🥰🥰
I can't explain how proud I am to these girls 🥺😭😭
Im glad they're finally singing live and broo the vocals🤩🤩
GO MY GIRL NINGNING!!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Their headbang at the last part is always so satisfying like yes,,, go girls slay everything ahhh
In their Coachella performance I saw a comment about ænergy not being a good song to start, but I think that it's so powerful and fits so much with their concept that sounds perfect for the beggining to me
Ningning so slayed
4:07 THIS ENTIRE PART ONWARDS IS ACTUAL HEAVEN OML winter and ningning??? slayyyy
MY GURLIESSS SING LIVEEEEEE 😻😻😻🥰🥰
giselle looks soooo happy ❤️
Жизель с Винтер встретились взглядами и не могли удержаться от улыбки)) Как и рассказывали в интервью
Ningning high note!!!!!
omg giselle was killing it !!! lovely aespa as always
WE.ARE.THE.AESPA
that's catchy 😍😍
The performance looks amazing, and they're singing live!!! Yaas
Ningning so goodddd💕💕💕
We need an offical lightsick asap SM!
too cute winter
I'm so proud of them😭♥️
닝닝 코첼라 라이브 댓글 다 본듯... 라이브 잘하려고 엄청 애쓰는 동시에 절대 실수 안하려고 긴장한 게 눈에 보임 다들 잘했어~
More live vocals for aespa soon. I'm claiming it 🥺💜
블랙맘바도 라이브로 했다는 증거
2:36 원터 '넌 언젠가부터 싱크아웃'이랑 '노이즈 같이 보여' 할 때 '넌'이랑 '보여' 부분에서 마이크 문제인지 음원이랑 다르게 고음 올라갈 때 살짝 흔들림.
3:35 닝닝 '위험한 장난을 쳐 매혹적이지만 널 부정할 밖에' 부분할 때 음원에서는 장난을 쳐~인데 영상에서는 장난을 쳐↗️라고 함.
그리고 자기 파트 들어가기 전에 음방이랑 다르게 안무 동작 살짝 줄여서 춤. 립싱크할 거면 안무 완벽하게 출 수 있었겠지. 근데 라이브하니까 호흡 조절하려고 동작 크기 줄인거임. 자기 파트 아닐 때는 안무도 완벽하게 소화함.
실수한 거 찾으려는 게 아니고 에스파 라이브 못한다고 너무 억까하길래 음원이랑 살짝 다른 부분 찾아봄. 이건 실수한 게 아님. 각각 다른 무대별로 느낄 수 있는 매력이지. 실력있는 에스파 자신감 가지고 이번 활동도 성공적이였으면 좋겠다.
오늘 첫날이니까 라이브 잘했고.. 낼이도 라이브 기대되요
에스파가 음방때 라이브했어요 증거있고 무대 자컨무대도 미국방송 라이브했고 앵콜 라이브잘하던데 또있는데 ..
에스파 원래라이브잘함
이제 컴백나오니까 기대되요
정확하고 예리한 분석 ㅇㅇ
이 영상 보고 라이브 아니라는 인간들은 억까 아니면 완전 막귀라는거임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
오히려 보컬이 강한 친구들인데 이번 활동은 유스케 같은데 나가서 실력 제대로 보여줬으면 좋겠음
Giselle just look so happy to be here
이런 거엔 댓 없지 또..ㅋ 코첼라에선 닝닝이 긴장해서 실수했던 거구만 그 때 실수 없는 나머지 애들도 까대는 거 보고 진짜 견제 오지는 구나 생각듬 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이제 뭐로 까려나
My ningning is soooo prettyyy!
all aespa members rap in this song🔥🔥
I love it when they sing high notes amazing I wish I was in la to see them. Awe I should have come. Me screaming and just watching this video. 😇🥰😍❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ #aespa #Karina #Winter #Giselle #Ningning
I hope they will sing live in SK too bcs they sound so stable and good idk what SM is hiding
3:43 Im obsessed of how karina said "black mamba"
Ningning👑
Better saving energy on singing than giving all the energy to dancing while having a shakey voice. Thank you for listening and watching aespa content. Saying they lip synching is such a complement 😉😁😄
They’re live and they don’t even breathe heavily omg THE STABILITY QUEENS
slayning
Come on guys, Aespa doesn't need to prove anything to all those haters. Let them judge, besides they will never be happy whatever Aespa does. 😊 Let's just continue supporting and loving Aespa to make the haters even more bitter. 🤣
You are truee
I love ningning voice
에스파 너무 멋짐!!! 이모팬이 응원한다!
Gilak ning2 vocal badaaaas
QUEENS👑🔥
The California vibe ning Ning gives out wow
I love all their outfits except for NingNing but her vocals are unmatchable
Winter❤
How dare you assault everyone with winter's abs 🤣 Weez all not ready for that fit.
aespa