Congratulations to LOONA for their 2nd win and FIRST win as OT12! A huge thank you to Orbits that participated in voting, let's get them their 3rd win!
Its really true when Lay said that in order to be stable in singing while dancing, you must be able to master the choreography first so it will become a natural response in your body when the music plays and you can focus on how you will sing. LOONA practices their choreography ALOT and it shows just by watching them. You can also hear it from their singing as they have a stable voice due to practicing the choreo while singing.
I really love LOONA but this is obviously prerecorded. Compared to their performance today on MCD and their cb stage on MuCore which have 100% live vocals, you can’t clearly see through their expressions that they are struggling nor a having little shake in their voices because of the intense choreography. But no matter what, yes they deserved more than two wins.
@@reverieboy its means that they're not singing live and have recorded the song without autotune and without dancing and used it in the background while performing their song, so they don't have to sing
With choreography like this, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with using a pre-recording. It doesn’t diminish their talent or hard work in any way in my opinion
@@tem7939 no lol, if you watch her fancam you could see she's having a hard time since the choreo is that hard, even if she's staying still just using her hands that doesn't mean that she can hit that note. And she's never done it live also it was a backtrack jsyk.
MR removed doesn't prove that loona ( or any artist) are singing live. And if you use common sense you can tell that they're straight up not singing certain parts that the MR removed video would lead you to believe they are.
@@rataliewhite498 I'm just informing you because kpop fans keep using mr removed for proof of live singing when they don't even know how it works. Also, stability in a pre record doesn't matter. It's a pre record they're not gonna let bad vocals go on air. I'm not hating, let's just all be on the same page with this. And let's not play dumb either you know you meant them singing live
the dance is really intense, it's a death wish if you want them to perform live. pre-recorded vocals are still live vocals and they wouldn't be idols if they couldn't sing.
This is the Best mr removed they really singing well I respect them they like Dreamcatcher because Dreamcatcher also singing live Because I am a insomnias and orbit
Can we make this very clear there is nothing wrong with things being pre-recorded. It is not safe for idols to constently sing live while dancing as it can put a lot of stress on ones vocal cords. ♡
@@dreamdr0p Darling, I'm not saying they should never do it or that you can't preform like that. However, if they were to do it at every single compation as well as music show for all of there promotions it could put them at a higher risk of having vocal problems in the near future.
K-pop idols have my mad respect. Dancing is hella hard already by breathing normally, and generally we dance only 1 min songs or less because it's actually kinda dangerous to dance more than by breaks, it all depends of the body energy and all. Some people can dance for like hours and hours, but others dances for like 30 minutes and it's already dying. Dancing makes your heart beats faster (after all, it's actually a way of exercising your body), meaning your breathing will also go faster than normal. Singing is also a very difficult thing. People tend to think that singing is just making noise with your mouth, but it's even deeper than that. When you sing, you need to manage your air to make sounds with your vocal chords. To make sounds it's to manage your air in some way to make it beautiful, it gets even harder when you want to do vibratos and other techniques, because you need to manage your air all the time. NOW TRY TO MANAGE YOUR AIR WHILE STAYING ON BALACE, BREATHING FASTER (which means you'll use more air to sing then you would normally do) AND MAKE IT BEAUTIFUL! YEAH, KINDA HARD, HUH?
I rlly love them and i think they totally deserved their win,but this is clearly pre-recorded,you can't hear a single noticeable breath or the kind of struggling face to sing the notes but last week on music bank they slayed live vocals
we are talking about loona... their choreographies are very difficult and tiring... it's impossible for anyone to sing and dance this live. they're very talented and i love them, but doing that would be very tiring..
I am not sure if they're lipsync or not but i am sure that chuu's high note at the end is not live. I'm sure because even kpop idols with very very great vocals like haechan, taeil, baekhyun, wendy, taeyeon and more can't sing such that high note with comfortable facial expression like chuu did. I love loona but maybe bbc needs to change that lipsync thing bcs it's unfair. Some kpop groups like twice, itzy etc receive hatred for having bad mr removed so i really think prerecord is unfair.
Most likely not. For instance, at 0:41, Chuu should not be able to sing the part that clearly. It would be a lot shakier than it is if this performance was really live. Also at 1:17.
Parts are def not live. Any time they're expected to roll their head or do upper body choreo at the same time as holding a note, doesnt sound like it. Poor Yves and Heejin got those a lot. Haseul didn't sing her first lines I think. But... like I dont think that means they're bad, this is normal. Modern day choreo means most bands perform like this, half live half relying on backing track. That choreo is so demanding.
I don’t see a point of those videos those performances are mainly about aesthetic aspects lip sync here is normal and should be it’s time to stop setting unreachable standard for idols try to work everyday so hard dance at the same time sing be stable etc
![[MR Removed] 210702 LOONA (이달의 소녀) - Paint the Town (PTT)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NRlgtEAevn0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removed] 210702 LOONA (이달의 소녀) - Paint the Town (PTT)](/img/tr.png)
![이달의 소녀(LOOΠΔ) - WOW, PTT (Paint The Town) [World is One 2021 CONCERT - 화제의 무대 다시보기]](/img/n.gif)
Congratulations to LOONA for their 2nd win and FIRST win as OT12! A huge thank you to Orbits that participated in voting, let's get them their 3rd win!
Its really true when Lay said that in order to be stable in singing while dancing, you must be able to master the choreography first so it will become a natural response in your body when the music plays and you can focus on how you will sing. LOONA practices their choreography ALOT and it shows just by watching them. You can also hear it from their singing as they have a stable voice due to practicing the choreo while singing.
They're soooo good!
*really
So stable!
yea
Vivi: You break it
Gowon: You make it
Vivi: You kill it
Gowon: You want it
Vivi: You own it
Gowon: You show it
Have you noticed that?
I really feel that
@@harveys.marcano9070 ikr!
Yas! I'm not a fan. But the same face keep appearing so many times. But Vivi n gowon 🥺
I really love LOONA but this is obviously prerecorded. Compared to their performance today on MCD and their cb stage on MuCore which have 100% live vocals, you can’t clearly see through their expressions that they are struggling nor a having little shake in their voices because of the intense choreography. But no matter what, yes they deserved more than two wins.
But i have a question. What is actually pre-recorded means? Im sorry im just so confused.. 😔🙏🏻
@@reverieboy It's a recording before the performance of the voices without dancing (I think that's it, maybe it's not)
@@jjepdi yep
@@reverieboy its means that they're not singing live and have recorded the song without autotune and without dancing and used it in the background while performing their song, so they don't have to sing
@HeartsForAmamiya loona can definitely sing live but the choreo is pretty demanding
With choreography like this, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with using a pre-recording. It doesn’t diminish their talent or hard work in any way in my opinion
I badly want to see chuu singing the high note live
It's impossible because the dance is so hard she'll be out of breath
@@vraiieee not really. during that part she just stays still, so she'd be able to cacth her breath. plus im pretty sure she has done it live
@@tem7939 no lol, if you watch her fancam you could see she's having a hard time since the choreo is that hard, even if she's staying still just using her hands that doesn't mean that she can hit that note. And she's never done it live also it was a backtrack jsyk.
@@vraiieee oh lmfao for some reasom i thought this comment was talking about the hi high note 😭 im really sorry for the misunderstanding
@@tem7939 HAHAHAHHA lol it's ok
HASEUL BRIDGE😩😍😍😍❤️💗❤️💗❤️💗
WTF WAS THAT BRIDGE OMG OMG OMG OMG HASEUL >> ANYONE ELSE WTF
Wow they're so stable. They deserve the win
MR removed doesn't prove that loona ( or any artist) are singing live. And if you use common sense you can tell that they're straight up not singing certain parts that the MR removed video would lead you to believe they are.
@@guntherstewart8941 so? Theyre still stable in the pre-recorded. Nobody said theyre singing live or not.
@@guntherstewart8941 cry about it
@@Alorah_ having pre recorded perfomances is nothing bad,it's better for them because the choreo is hard and they need to take of their voices
@@rataliewhite498 I'm just informing you because kpop fans keep using mr removed for proof of live singing when they don't even know how it works. Also, stability in a pre record doesn't matter. It's a pre record they're not gonna let bad vocals go on air. I'm not hating, let's just all be on the same page with this. And let's not play dumb either you know you meant them singing live
으음....mr제거 많이 들어봐서 아는데 이거 제대로 제거가 안 된것 같네요
I can replay Haseul's part of the bridge over and over again ISTG 🤩
진솔이 음색 너무 잘 들려 ㅠ 진짜 국보급
This is pre-recording though. But yesterday MCD they did live
No u can really hear them breathing loud
👏2:39 👏 haseul’s 👏bridge👏yall👏
AR인데 완전.. 제대로 해서 올려줘요..
간간히 들리는 숨소리랑 음원과 다른 발음들 보면 엠알제거 맞는듯! 달소 성장했다⚡
그런데 츄 고음부분을 보면 ar인것 같은데 아닌가요?
@@뭘봐-h4n ar로 녹음했다고 하기엔 불안정한 부분이나 춤에 따라서 호흡이 조금씩 끊기는 부분들이 들려서 사전녹음을 하진 않은 거 같고 헤이! 나 츄 고음같이 빡센 춤 추면서 소화하기 힘든 부분들만 mr을 더 키우거나 한거같네요
the dance is really intense, it's a death wish if you want them to perform live. pre-recorded vocals are still live vocals and they wouldn't be idols if they couldn't sing.
Vivi and Gowon bring the most stable ones 😭
WOW THEY'RE SO STABLE THEY MUST GET THIS 3RD WIN
anyways idk why I'm surprised... stan LOONA
OLIVIA HYE KILLED IT OMG WHAT A STABLE QUEEN EVEN MID JUMP
The chills I got when I heard Haseul during the bridge 😩
Go won is so stable with the uhuh as well as Vivi with the yea yea yea
뭐야...AR임....???
달소 많이 성장해따 앞으로도 더 올라가자
Jinsoul rainha da estabilidade- 🛐🛐
오진다...
This is the Best mr removed they really singing well I respect them they like Dreamcatcher because Dreamcatcher also singing live
Because I am a insomnias and orbit
Omg same! :D
Buddyorbitsomnia lol
Same
Buddy,orbit,insomnia * 💖❤ Holy Trinity
It's prerecorded lmao
HASEUL!! OUR ICONIC OPERA QUEEN
진솔 츄 여진 이브 다 잘 하네. 소녀들 정말 화이팅!!!
Don't forget...stan talent...
Stan loona
everyone saying its pre-recorded like its a bad thing... these girls proved numerous times how stable they are and that they can sing
They're all so stable, but JinSoul had me shook, she sounds amazing :)
2:47 츄 고음 대박!!♡♡
저긴 ar임
@@뭘봐-h4n 아 넵
i love it voice Haseul so much!!! ✨❤️
다들 너무 잘한다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Haseulll omg the bridge so good😍
Voice JINSOUL OMG LIKE ANGEL 😭💜
Can we make this very clear there is nothing wrong with things being pre-recorded. It is not safe for idols to constently sing live while dancing as it can put a lot of stress on ones vocal cords. ♡
That’s literally what they spend years training for tho lol
@@dreamdr0p It doesn't matter how long you train it's not healthy.
@@vortexwriting1026 bestie that literally makes no sense. Kpop idols are performers.
@@dreamdr0p Darling, I'm not saying they should never do it or that you can't preform like that. However, if they were to do it at every single compation as well as music show for all of there promotions it could put them at a higher risk of having vocal problems in the near future.
@@dreamdr0p Kpop idols are also humans
How stable they are 🥺🥺🥺
0:12 OMG! BEUTY VOICE AAAAAH~
my vivi..
all of their voices are so different and I love it
Jinsoul is just another level, she's a vocal machine
QUEENS
heejin stable queen
Lippie n heejin supremacy.
Parts like JinSoul and Olivia Hye should be live but the rest are pre-recorded
제거가 아예 된건 아닌듯;;
AR 안빼고 말그대로 MR만 뺀거
Loona >>>> tus favs
o ao vivo das gatas
Jinsoul💙
Ya pero que Diosas
This is pre record because when chu was singing a high note she closed her mouth while the sound was still singing
The high note is not live. And most of the song is being sung live. Only the parts thats extremely hard to sing while dancing is not live
she hates lip syncing so she does what she wants
@@loonalover9000 you make no sense
shut up
oh yes you are talking about less than 5% of the song
Love them, but are y'all sure this is live and not prerecorded?
Parts are live but not 100 percent which is really normal
you can hear it the shake in their voices get more noticeable by the second pre-chorus
it’s all prerecorded
@@chaeyoungabadbitch9743 not all of it
@@seokjinsthirdtoeonhisleftf1923 like 90%
0:43 하슬언니랑 현진언니 안 부르는 거야..?
Yeojin most underrated vocalist
Jinsouul💙💙
K-pop idols have my mad respect. Dancing is hella hard already by breathing normally, and generally we dance only 1 min songs or less because it's actually kinda dangerous to dance more than by breaks, it all depends of the body energy and all. Some people can dance for like hours and hours, but others dances for like 30 minutes and it's already dying. Dancing makes your heart beats faster (after all, it's actually a way of exercising your body), meaning your breathing will also go faster than normal.
Singing is also a very difficult thing. People tend to think that singing is just making noise with your mouth, but it's even deeper than that. When you sing, you need to manage your air to make sounds with your vocal chords. To make sounds it's to manage your air in some way to make it beautiful, it gets even harder when you want to do vibratos and other techniques, because you need to manage your air all the time.
NOW TRY TO MANAGE YOUR AIR WHILE STAYING ON BALACE, BREATHING FASTER (which means you'll use more air to sing then you would normally do) AND MAKE IT BEAUTIFUL! YEAH, KINDA HARD, HUH?
HASEUL !!
Wanna be the cookieeeeee~
I rlly love them and i think they totally deserved their win,but this is clearly pre-recorded,you can't hear a single noticeable breath or the kind of struggling face to sing the notes but last week on music bank they slayed live vocals
HASEUL SOUND SOOOOOO GOOD
HASEULLLLLLLL I LOVE YOU SO MUCH
OH WOW JINSOUL
"yeah yeah"
we are talking about loona... their choreographies are very difficult and tiring... it's impossible for anyone to sing and dance this live. they're very talented and i love them, but doing that would be very tiring..
I think some parts are pre-recorded
Because of the choreo, is hard sing while dancing this choreo
THAT HIGHNITE
they eating cd for breakfast
You break it 🤪🤪
jinsoullll
Aww🥰
I am not sure if they're lipsync or not but i am sure that chuu's high note at the end is not live. I'm sure because even kpop idols with very very great vocals like haechan, taeil, baekhyun, wendy, taeyeon and more can't sing such that high note with comfortable facial expression like chuu did. I love loona but maybe bbc needs to change that lipsync thing bcs it's unfair. Some kpop groups like twice, itzy etc receive hatred for having bad mr removed so i really think prerecord is unfair.
Her high note is not high because the dance demands too much energy. The girls sing live at parts and dont at parts that have too much movement.
The brigde, they ate…… CDS
when I saw the thumbnail I thought it was Yuna Itzy, lol my eyes🤣
i cant stop laughing at the thumbnail
There's nothing to laugh at?
Vivi now: lol 😂
is this really live? a lot of parts sound really similar to other stages that were using prerecordings
it is probably you can hear the breathing at 2:31
Most likely not. For instance, at 0:41, Chuu should not be able to sing the part that clearly. It would be a lot shakier than it is if this performance was really live. Also at 1:17.
Parts are def not live. Any time they're expected to roll their head or do upper body choreo at the same time as holding a note, doesnt sound like it. Poor Yves and Heejin got those a lot. Haseul didn't sing her first lines I think.
But... like I dont think that means they're bad, this is normal. Modern day choreo means most bands perform like this, half live half relying on backing track. That choreo is so demanding.
What do you use for your mr removed videos???
This isn't mr... this is ar
I'm new to loona and I'm curious about heejin eye color. Is it really blue??
No its a contact lens
Anyone curious about how they breathe while dancing like that....
They cant stop to breathe but it’s not recorded...
I don’t see a point of those videos those performances are mainly about aesthetic aspects lip sync here is normal and should be it’s time to stop setting unreachable standard for idols try to work everyday so hard dance at the same time sing be stable etc
omg choerry and vivi in this performance are perfection.
ok but this is pre recorded 😔😔 there are live performances to this song you should this to those ones
is this pre record?
yes
@@dearmanobal who is live singing?
@@hyellabies3013 none 😅
I love my girls but this is pre/recorded vocals😭
whats prerecording?
Pre-recording is an idol who recorded they voice (singing) before going to stage without using autotune or others.
WHO MOANED AT 2:00??????????
who?
1:58 it's not moan, it's chuu's adlib :D
No after heejin's part in chorus lol
@@g0w0n67 auw or uuh, if its, i dunno lol
엠알 제거 맞나?
They seriously have to stop
Its getting dangeous
Are they eating cds again ;)
I THOUGHT I SAW YUNA WTF
아무리 봐도 ar이네요......
중간에 숨 차는 소리 들리는 거 보니까 ar 깔고 라이브 한 듯
So gowon doesn't have more than 3 seconds of lines and decides not to sing? 😕
진짜 잘하긴하는데 제목이랑 가사가 일치하진 않는다....
모든 노래에서는 가사가 제목가 일치해야됀다는 그래야돼는 이유가없는데용