Many comments have asked why Singapore is not included in the list. It's true that Singapore is a very wealthy and highly modernized country. However, basically we consider Singapore to be a country, so it hasn't been put in the ranking of cities.
@@MistySchultz-q9r "It seems to be due to differences in statistical criteria. While I'm not sure about the source of the original comment, there was similar data from a study conducted in Japan, but some other sources showed different values as well."
Thank you (arigato) we also love and respect japan, i hope that i would be able to visit japan in future 😊 😀 🙇♂️ japan is one of the dream city of mine and many indians too!🇯🇵🤝🇮🇳
@@PTDawiriyyun you should have done a thorough research before comment 🙂, btw seoul is already there in the list, and if you have gone through Chongqing it's the biggest city in terms of municipality area as well as population in 2024 , and Guangzhou is also bigger than any more metropolitan cities, and can't say anything about Singapore though
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day). Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
More and more foreigners are choosing to travel to China and explore. The cities in China amaze me, and in the future, China will become even more developed.
Yeah I've lived in a few cities around the world but I don't think I ever want to leave Suzhou now that I'm here. It's so beautiful and clean and people are all friendly. If you get bored you can go to Nanjing or Hangzhou in about an hour on the train or to Shanghai in 20 mins. I love this city.
China's gdp is more than india offcourse it's main city will have more gdp then richest State of india "maharashtra" like how mumbai city alone is comparable to pakistan, Bangladesh, sri Lanka etc like that
According to what you said, the per capita GDP of both Seoul and Tokyo exceeds $100,000. The data you obtained is likely the GDP of the Seoul metropolitan area and the Greater Tokyo Area, which include surrounding cities.
@@SAARZ-Moors Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day). Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
@@panli-z4mwell well that's something strong hate towards Mumbai . U must be from a very high end city but let us enjoy our cities, Mumbai maybe not on par with the other cities in terms of infra but it's still the fastest developing among them ( excluding the chinese ofcourse) so all we are proud of how much it has changed since 1990s as it was nothing but slum back then but it has been improving
Tokyo has been the best city in the world not only Asia since Edo period in terms of Population and Economic size. But, in the coming decades, China will have several cities which could counter Tokyo. Incredible😮
China is currently experiencing a bubble collapse due to Xi Jinping, a war criminal in Chinese history, so China no longer has the power to carry it out.
The population of Tokyo is 9.85 million. The 37 million people refers to the metropolitan area, not the city area. And, when viewed as a metropolitan area, the GDP is the highest in the world.
Actually, 14 million. We Japanese say"Tokyo", we consider "Tokyo-to" not only 23 districts in Tokyo. If you ignore other port of Tokyo, many people living in Musashino-shi and so on will be angry, they also have great buildings and companies.
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day). Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day). Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
Bruh only dharavi and slum is not mumbai according western media and stuff gdp of mumbai is $380 billion gdp ppp is $410 or more gdp per capita is $23,000 yeah it lacks infrastructure and cleanliness but still mumbai had some good infrastructure in some areas like bkc, marine drive and all......south mumbai
@@tanishdk6450 Bullshit, Indians need to have basic logic and open their eyes to the world. Mumbai has a nominal GDP of $380bn? i.e. Mumbai is almost catching up or not far behind Seoul/Guangzhou/Shenzhen/Beijing/Shanghai with roughly the same population? May I ask what are the noteworthy industries or businesses in Mumbai? How does Mumbai support a nominal GDP of $380bn, when Mumbai's per capita GDP is close to ten times India's per capita GDP? It is said that millions of people live in slums in Mumbai, more than a million people live in Dharavi slums alone, how do all these Mumbaikars generate a GDP close to the above cities? by shitting? According to chatgpt, the GDP per capita of Seoul, South Korea's top city in 2023 will be $38,189, only slightly higher than South Korea's GDP per capita of $33,100, and the GDP per capita of Shanghai, China's top city in 2023 will be $26,943, or about twice China's GDP per capita of US$13,000. Mumbai's GDP per capita is a whopping $23,000, nearly 10 times India's GDP per capita of $2,480? Suzhou, behind Mumbai, was once China's largest industrial city (now second only to Shenzhen), with a total industrial output value above the scale (it is a traditional practice in China to count only enterprises with an annual main business income of 20 million yuan (US$2.74 million) and above, and exclude small enterprises from the statistics) of more than 4.4 trillion yuan (US$602.87 billion). What does Mumbai compare with Suzhou? Mumbai is not in the same league as the cities on the list in terms of urbanisation or industrial prowess or number of companies, you Indians need to have some logic and get out and about (of course, most of the people commenting here probably lack the appropriate economic power).
In 2014, the Make in India campaign was touted as the game-changer that would transform India into a manufacturing superpower. Promises were made of millions of new jobs, a booming economy, and reduced imports. Fast forward to 2024, and the reality looks starkly different. In today’s video, we discuss the harsh truth behind Make in India: Why the initiative failed to live up to expectations. Despite a massive push to attract foreign investment and create jobs, India still finds itself struggling with outdated infrastructure, a sluggish manufacturing sector, and a massive trade deficit. We’ll break down the numbers that tell the real story, from India’s stagnant GDP contribution from manufacturing to the failed promise of job creation. What happened to all those ambitious targets set by the government? Why is India still unable to make the leap to self-sufficiency despite its vast resources?We’ll also look at the key factors that have held India back, including red tape, environmental regulations, and the lack of a skilled workforce. All these factors combined paint a picture of a country stuck in the past, unable to move forward as a global manufacturing hub. If you're wondering why India hasn’t become the industrial giant it was supposed to be, or if you want to understand the real impact of Make in India, this video is for you.th-cam.com/video/RuV5GBCgghw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=obmXRNLfT9GgAF7a🧔
Tbh Hong Kong isn’t a cities which got carried away a lot by the Chinese Development,It is more different then the others like shenzhu,so I think it shouldn’t matter what country it belong tbh
Anyone who has been to Suzhou and Mumbai will know - Mumbai is nowhere near as rich as Suzhou, in terms of urban quality, living standards, and industrial output 😂 Nice try Indian folks.
Suzhou, because it is an ancient city, cannot be too densely populated with buildings and industries. Suzhou's buildings and industries are largely dispersed in the rest of the area and not in the main city. Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day). Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
That's correct, but if Incheon and Gyeonggi Province are included to form the Seoul metropolitan area, it would rank second, just behind the Greater Tokyo Area, with a GDP exceeding $1 trillion.
Almost Chinese city is so large. For example, Shanghai is ten times larger than Seoul or Tokyo. Therefore Chinese city have higher GDP than other city when comparing single city .
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_GDP 그게 아니고, 중국인이 본인 셀프로 자기 마음대로 만든건가보네요 예를들어 중국 상하이 베이징 이런거는 그 자체가 한국의 서울 경제권 부산 경제권, 일본의 오사카 경제권 도쿄 경제권과 인구나 면적이 동렬의 단위이기 때문에 그렇게 경제권 순위로 당연히 도쿄 - 서울 - 오사카 - 상하이 - 베이징 이런 순인거고.. 일본도 한국도 환율이 50%이상 절하되어 있기 때문에 외교정책에 따라 환율조정으로 1.5배 더 높아질수 있습니다.
Mumbai must be 9 th in the world not Asia. Taiwan no longer in it because many ammo there. Singapore doesn't deserve in it😂😂😂😂😂 Congratulations for Tokyo city of capital
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day). Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day). Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
The nominal gdp of Seoul and its metropolitan area, with a population of 26 million, is close to $1T and currently has the world's 6th largest city too, comparable to Paris. But what makes you think it's only $360 billion and only ranked 8th in Asia? LOL
@@清渏 It is based on gdp including the metropolitan area, which Tokyo dare to include too, and in fact, Seoul ranked 4th 10 years ago, and is still 6th, comparable to Paris now. In the case of China, where gdp per capita is so low, it is regrettable that Shanghai and Beijing cannot be included in the top 20 level even if similar data on the metropolitan area are brought. 😹🤣😜
The one who are not happy or agree with the list are seriously fools or lack knowledge you guys are not getting the content at all. Mock it once you yourself are sure of what you saying the video is fully correct even google show the particular cities if you search it
The size of the city in Tokyo is extraordinary.
It's a miracle city.
Many comments have asked why Singapore is not included in the list. It's true that Singapore is a very wealthy and highly modernized country. However, basically we consider Singapore to be a country, so it hasn't been put in the ranking of cities.
It's a city state, so it is both a country and a city.
Weird logic
2024년 세계 도시 경제 규모 순위(30위 내, 권역별 )
2위 도쿄 $2080B
4위 서울 $1216B
12위 오사카 $699B
13위 상하이 $663B
16위 베이징 $618B
20위 싱가포르 $515B
23위 선전 $455B
28위 광저우 $405B
이거 한국 사람들이 직접 순위를 매긴 건가요? 꽤 겸손하네요. 서울이 도쿄 다음에 있네요. 그런데 여러분의 형제 도시 평양은요? 3위에 있어야 하지 않을까요?
@@MistySchultz-q9r "It seems to be due to differences in statistical criteria. While I'm not sure about the source of the original comment, there was similar data from a study conducted in Japan, but some other sources showed different values as well."
@@MistySchultz-q9r"경제규모순위"
@@MistySchultz-q9r 도쿄인구가 3700만이란 것 부터 에러요
@@MistySchultz-q9r혹시 민주당지지자임?
I have a very good impression of Indian people who travel to Tokyo because they are well mannered and so friendly.
Thanks, we respect Japan and Japanese people too.
🇮🇳❤️🇯🇵
The first time I saw people cut in line was an Indian, actually an Indian family with kids. Very low.
Thank you (arigato) we also love and respect japan, i hope that i would be able to visit japan in future 😊 😀 🙇♂️ japan is one of the dream city of mine and many indians too!🇯🇵🤝🇮🇳
因为他们都是印度的高种姓接受过良好教育 像那种低种姓则恰恰相反
東京の地平線まで伸びる住宅地とビルのライトアップは最高
hk is better
@@fifot-uw7bu
香港もいいけど 地平線まで広がる大都会東京と比べるのは失礼
規模が違う
東京は他の都市とは違って、超高層ビルが多いとかではなく地平線まで広がる感じが良いんですよね
@@fifot-uw7bu物にも色々な見方、魅力があるのにそうやって優劣つけるのやめろよ
@@アルカディア_28126 そうね～
Mumbai & Tokyo are the exceptions , it seems like China is dominating the whole world 😅 unbelievable what a growth China have done
Seoul
@@AndrewManook I missed it sorry 😐
Singapura dilupakan, atau Osaka yang lebih besar dr kota kota china spt congqing Guangzhou, atau jakarta yang lebih besar dari Mumbai secara GDP 😂😂😂
@@PTDawiriyyun you should have done a thorough research before comment 🙂, btw seoul is already there in the list, and if you have gone through Chongqing it's the biggest city in terms of municipality area as well as population in 2024 , and Guangzhou is also bigger than any more metropolitan cities, and can't say anything about Singapore though
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day).
Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
More and more foreigners are choosing to travel to China and explore. The cities in China amaze me, and in the future, China will become even more developed.
@@gdmit-i6j true
Yeah I've lived in a few cities around the world but I don't think I ever want to leave Suzhou now that I'm here. It's so beautiful and clean and people are all friendly. If you get bored you can go to Nanjing or Hangzhou in about an hour on the train or to Shanghai in 20 mins. I love this city.
Top 11
Cagayan de Oro city
Philippines
Missy bon bon Cafe
Jiuygggy
Shanghai city has a GDP that is greater than that of the entire STATE of Maharashtra
And Maharashtra's GDP is greater than whole of pakistan 💩
Most people outside of India haven't even heard of Maharashtra
China's gdp is more than india offcourse it's main city will have more gdp then richest State of india "maharashtra" like how mumbai city alone is comparable to pakistan, Bangladesh, sri Lanka etc like that
中国の都市は夜景が凄すぎる。
特に深圳や重慶は未来都市感あって好き
深圳のプロジェクションマッピングみたいなやつかっこいい
重庆一般，深圳不错
中国のビル群にはかなわない
めちゃ分かる
@@mikeyL-os5cf 草，怎么还拉踩起来了
日本は、地震が多いため上層ビルをあまり建てられません。
そのため、東京は大都市が広い面積で広がっています
東京が広範囲に広がってる理由の大半は、純粋に日本に平野が少ないからだと思います。
国土の7割が山なのに1.2億人もいるからな
そもそも高層ビルは地震で倒れたことないからね(これからも絶対にないとは言えないが)。地震への安全だけいうなら高い方が地震の周期成分と建物の固有周期がズレるから、むしろ高い方が良いのです。同様の理由で五重塔も地震で倒れたことはない。もちろん、風では倒壊しているし、超高層でも同じ課題はありますけどね。ただそれは世界でも同様で。
@@yn3760 いや、
高層ビルの免震機構って結構大変なんですよ
台湾にある台北101が有名な例で、建物をしならせながら揺れを吸収するには、多くの費用やスペースを犠牲にしてしまいます
東京には航空法のせいで高さの制限があるから、スーパートールを建てられないんだよ。
日本の大阪は、何位なのでしょうか？ 日本人として気になります。
実際は6位くらいじゃなかったっけ
@otimponametarouそこまで高くない気がするけど、まあ上位なのは間違いない
GDPだと東京とソウルに次いでアジア3位
大阪GDP在中国只能排第第六😂😂😂并且很快被超越@@dainhukn7115
Look at the GDP data in the video. Tokyo, Shanghai, Beijing,....,Seoul, Mumbai, Suzhou
Tokyo has a gdp of approx 2 trillion USD. And Seoul is 2nd in Asia not 8th as mentioned here.
According to what you said, the per capita GDP of both Seoul and Tokyo exceeds $100,000. The data you obtained is likely the GDP of the Seoul metropolitan area and the Greater Tokyo Area, which include surrounding cities.
首尔在中国只能排第四
@陈陈烁宇 高了，单纯按gdp算的话只能排第6或第7位。
По ВВП Токио на 1 месте в мире , а Сеул на 4 месте в мире,опережая Шанхай и Пекин.😂
As a Japanese person, I'm proud that Tokyo is number one, but I also love other cities because they're cool.
Haters are crying after seeing just one city from India 😂 cry more
Are you a Pakistani bot?
東京だけ都市の範囲はでかいんよな。それだけでなくそれを囲うように神奈川、千葉、埼玉の都市圏が東京寄りになってるから合わせたらその規模はもっと大きい。
Tokyo dominated in the world ❤
미친놈 착각은😢
@@아낙수나문-i6o그러니깐요ㅋㅋ 일본애들은 항상 큰웃음을준다..
この中だと北京と東京(地元)にしか行ったことない。他のとこも行ってみたいなぁ〜、特に上海
I like how it uses GDP PPP for Mumbai but GDP Nominal for everyone else
Typical Indians way of distorting statistic to brag about India.
Mumbai GDP PPP is 400 billion
@@SAARZ-Moors Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day).
Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
@@panli-z4mwell well that's something strong hate towards Mumbai . U must be from a very high end city but let us enjoy our cities, Mumbai maybe not on par with the other cities in terms of infra but it's still the fastest developing among them ( excluding the chinese ofcourse) so all we are proud of how much it has changed since 1990s as it was nothing but slum back then but it has been improving
You are watch again carefully. Every information is for all
Data kurang akurat...
1 tokyo
2 seoul
3 osaka
4 shanghai
5 beijing
6 Shenzhen/taipe
7 guangzou/congqing/
8 hongkong/singapore/nagoya
9 jakarta/ mumbai/
@@PTDawiriyyun jakarta? Mumbai? Well they have the same thing in common but should not be in this list 😅
@@YoungMaster-g6qJakarta juga jauh Lebih baik dari Mumbai
Ketikamu penuh kebencian
@@YoungMaster-g6q jakarta>mumbai
Tokyo has been the best city in the world not only Asia since Edo period in terms of Population and Economic size. But, in the coming decades, China will have several cities which could counter Tokyo. Incredible😮
China is currently experiencing a bubble collapse due to Xi Jinping, a war criminal in Chinese history, so China no longer has the power to carry it out.
曰本人同士が英語で会話するな
掘るぞ
The population of Tokyo is 9.85 million. The 37 million people refers to the metropolitan area, not the city area. And, when viewed as a metropolitan area, the GDP is the highest in the world.
Actually, 14 million. We Japanese say"Tokyo", we consider "Tokyo-to" not only 23 districts in Tokyo. If you ignore other port of Tokyo, many people living in Musashino-shi and so on will be angry, they also have great buildings and companies.
@@Uptodate-knowledge多摩地方の人が23区に引っ越す際も東京へ引っ越すって言うらしいですね。
@@Uptodate-knowledge 東京住みです。"東京"や"東京都"は23区外の多摩地区も含みます。23区内であることを表す場合は都内、23区外であることを表す場合は都下というように分けられます。ただ、23区外でも東京の中であれば都内と言うことがあるのでよくわかりません！
@@user-lc1ms3vz9t
生まれ育ち東京ですけど、そんなの一回も聞いたことないです
@Uptodate-knowledge 武蔵野市在住だけど、別に怒んないぞw
孟买的gdp只有大概1000-1200亿美元😂，不足其他城市的三分之一怎么也上榜了？孟买的数据是ppp而不是gdp.
印度人排名你期待什么😅
@@雅君墨客-i9zbetter than you fake gdp😂
无论是gdp还是ppp他根本就上不了，除去孟买，下一个应该是新加坡
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day).
Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
Mumbai's gdp is $368 billion dollars and gdp ppp is more than $400 gdp per capita is $24,000 billion did you even researched about this ?
5:08 This is Incheon, not Seoul.
..Beautiful..from❇️..🇧🇩....💖..
当然了，虽然我们数量多，但是东京是当之无愧的亚洲第一城（如果真的算作城市的话，我记得东京应该算作一个都市圈）❤
就是东京都市圈东京占据日本我记得好大部分GDP。
东京都市圈，东京占据日本很大一部分GDP，不过GDP计算方法还有GDP组成各国都不同，中国往往忽略非常大往非常小计算。
@@是去苦多 东京都1400万人，gdp大概7000多亿美元。他说的3700万人是东京都市圈，类似于京津冀，或者长三角珠三角这样的概念。
@@雅君墨客-i9z 有一半了
@@hyjcxyz 了解了
东京我认为不错，但是它给我一个很奇怪的感觉，它更像非常多的城市建筑堆叠在一起，而不是一个看起来很整体的大都市，很难形容这是什么感觉🤔
我认为这是东京或者说日本城市的魅力所在，和国内千篇一律的高层小区住宅，日本大多数是独栋住宅，每一栋都很有个性，作为城市景观我更喜欢日本。
中国は建物豪華だけど機能してるビルがどれだけあるのか
観光地は人は集まるが写真撮るだけで周辺の店に金を落とさない
そんなあなたに「グンちゃんの中国歩き」ってチャンネルがオススメ。
中国のどの都市もイルミネーションめっちゃ綺麗❤近未来感を感じる
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day).
Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
Tondat ghe
Bruh only dharavi and slum is not mumbai according western media and stuff gdp of mumbai is $380 billion gdp ppp is $410 or more gdp per capita is $23,000 yeah it lacks infrastructure and cleanliness but still mumbai had some good infrastructure in some areas like bkc, marine drive and all......south mumbai
@@tanishdk6450 Bullshit, Indians need to have basic logic and open their eyes to the world.
Mumbai has a nominal GDP of $380bn? i.e. Mumbai is almost catching up or not far behind Seoul/Guangzhou/Shenzhen/Beijing/Shanghai with roughly the same population? May I ask what are the noteworthy industries or businesses in Mumbai? How does Mumbai support a nominal GDP of $380bn, when Mumbai's per capita GDP is close to ten times India's per capita GDP? It is said that millions of people live in slums in Mumbai, more than a million people live in Dharavi slums alone, how do all these Mumbaikars generate a GDP close to the above cities? by shitting?
According to chatgpt, the GDP per capita of Seoul, South Korea's top city in 2023 will be $38,189, only slightly higher than South Korea's GDP per capita of $33,100, and the GDP per capita of Shanghai, China's top city in 2023 will be $26,943, or about twice China's GDP per capita of US$13,000. Mumbai's GDP per capita is a whopping $23,000, nearly 10 times India's GDP per capita of $2,480?
Suzhou, behind Mumbai, was once China's largest industrial city (now second only to Shenzhen), with a total industrial output value above the scale (it is a traditional practice in China to count only enterprises with an annual main business income of 20 million yuan (US$2.74 million) and above, and exclude small enterprises from the statistics) of more than 4.4 trillion yuan (US$602.87 billion). What does Mumbai compare with Suzhou?
Mumbai is not in the same league as the cities on the list in terms of urbanisation or industrial prowess or number of companies, you Indians need to have some logic and get out and about (of course, most of the people commenting here probably lack the appropriate economic power).
私は、東京に行きたいです。
比起上海深圳香港這種滿地高樓大廈的城市......
說實話，蘇州或南京這種古色古香一些的地方，不管旅遊或生活都會更舒適。
你是不是对南京有误解啊，南京的摩天大楼全球排名19 ，比首尔都多，紫金山上远望一大片的高层建筑
@@simonjp873 南京比起其他城市人文氣息要重很多，說實話，我去玩的時候沒有感覺到香港上海那種高樓帶來的壓迫感🥲
Tokyo is still the No. 1 city in Asia, in terms of wealth, science, education, etc. Still a long way for China to go.
日本跟韓國會被中國擊潰，這在不久的未來會發生
当然 我们也就研发了六代机 日本有什么？科技？哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈
@@iank41住みやすさでは東京。
@@髙岡史幸日本有什么科技领域比中国强？ 航天？武器研发？机器人？ai？我不明白他说的比中国科技先进是指哪里？请告诉我
@@iank41宝批龙😂
Your video was very well made.👍
Tokyo is best city ❤
德里才是
@@zhongguono1 nice joke
@@zhongguono1 CCP bot crying
Mumbai❤
近年の東京はほんとに治安が悪い
何故かって、
海外客が荒らしまくり、特にあの国
東京じゃないけど、奈良の鹿がアメリカで炎上してるけど なんであんな温厚な鹿が頭突きしたかってあの国の観光者が色々マナーを守らないで雑に扱ったせいで人間不信になっちゃったんだよ。
ほんとに辞めてくれもう
In 2014, the Make in India campaign was touted as the game-changer that would transform India into a manufacturing superpower. Promises were made of millions of new jobs, a booming economy, and reduced imports. Fast forward to 2024, and the reality looks starkly different.
In today’s video, we discuss the harsh truth behind Make in India: Why the initiative failed to live up to expectations. Despite a massive push to attract foreign investment and create jobs, India still finds itself struggling with outdated infrastructure, a sluggish manufacturing sector, and a massive trade deficit.
We’ll break down the numbers that tell the real story, from India’s stagnant GDP contribution from manufacturing to the failed promise of job creation. What happened to all those ambitious targets set by the government? Why is India still unable to make the leap to self-sufficiency despite its vast resources?We’ll also look at the key factors that have held India back, including red tape, environmental regulations, and the lack of a skilled workforce. All these factors combined paint a picture of a country stuck in the past, unable to move forward as a global manufacturing hub.
If you're wondering why India hasn’t become the industrial giant it was supposed to be, or if you want to understand the real impact of Make in India, this video is for you.th-cam.com/video/RuV5GBCgghw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=obmXRNLfT9GgAF7a🧔
Tokyo is another level
Tbh Hong Kong isn’t a cities which got carried away a lot by the Chinese Development,It is more different then the others like shenzhu,so I think it shouldn’t matter what country it belong tbh
Wow china seems incredible 🎉🎉
❤china.
But USA worst
nah....Not imcredible like Tokyo Japan...The Cyberpunk city
日本にも高層建造物もっと欲しいけど、地震が…😢
依据我的搜索东京已经有了173座摩天大楼🐮🍺
TOKYO IS THE RICHEST CITY IN OUR PLANET
只是曾经
@@dkq-o7p赞同
日本人が必死に働いて高い税金納めてるおかげなの忘れないで下さい。
アメリカには敵わんよ
今も世界一だよ。
でも中国みたいに大規模の都市を分散させた方が防衛では有利だよ。
日本は東京がやられたら日本そのものが終わる。
세계 도시 종합력 랭킹(일본모리기념재단. 2024.12.10)
평가항목:경제, 연구개발, 문화교류, 거주, 환경, 교통 등 (1800점 만점)
1.런던 1655.4
2.뉴욕 1505.8
3.도쿄 1445.4
4.파리 1423.0
5.싱가포르 1291.3
6.서울 1193.3
7.암스테르담 1185.4
8.두바이 1177.7
9.베를린 1171.5
10.마드리드 1153.2
11.상하이 1144.0
ㆍ
ㆍ
16.베이징 1111.0
ㆍ
18.홍콩 1101.8
ㆍ
ㆍ
30.타이페이 1009.3
韩国人别刷这种无意义的排名了，还有很多排名，你刷不完的
Suzhou is out of my expectation.For China,I think only Beijing,Shanghai or Shenzhen would be involved.
東京は確かに上海や北京、ソウルなどを超える大都市だけど人口3700万人は東京「都市圏」じゃない？
東京で3700万はいないよ
神奈川、千葉埼玉合わせてるから
Anyone who has been to Suzhou and Mumbai will know - Mumbai is nowhere near as rich as Suzhou, in terms of urban quality, living standards, and industrial output 😂 Nice try Indian folks.
I know 😂
第10名的苏州看起来比第9名的孟买漂亮多了
Suzhou, because it is an ancient city, cannot be too densely populated with buildings and industries. Suzhou's buildings and industries are largely dispersed in the rest of the area and not in the main city.
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day).
Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
Mumbai more diverse than suzhou is beautiful in nature and cultural
@@DileepD-xj6ptdirty 😂
@@Grrzyyyes your country 😂😂😂
But nobody wanna live in china 😂 most peopls wanna live in Japan or Korea.
Seoul is top8…? Is this right?
That's correct, but if Incheon and Gyeonggi Province are included to form the Seoul metropolitan area, it would rank second, just behind the Greater Tokyo Area, with a GDP exceeding $1 trillion.
@ oh i see.. im korean but i guess u know it better then me. Thanks for the info
I think that's limited to Seoul. In terms of the metropolitan area, including Incheon and Gyeonggi-do, the ranking will rise further.
Almost Chinese city is so large.
For example, Shanghai is ten times larger than Seoul or Tokyo.
Therefore Chinese city have higher GDP than other city when comparing single city .
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_GDP
그게 아니고, 중국인이 본인 셀프로 자기 마음대로 만든건가보네요
예를들어 중국 상하이 베이징 이런거는 그 자체가 한국의 서울 경제권 부산 경제권, 일본의 오사카 경제권 도쿄 경제권과 인구나 면적이 동렬의 단위이기 때문에
그렇게 경제권 순위로 당연히 도쿄 - 서울 - 오사카 - 상하이 - 베이징 이런 순인거고.. 일본도 한국도 환율이 50%이상 절하되어 있기 때문에 외교정책에 따라 환율조정으로 1.5배 더 높아질수 있습니다.
Japan and Singapore. Just it.
서을 8위 맞아요??
Mumbai should be removed from this list, and replaced with Singapore.
True if you have been to Mumbai
@@bial3436you ever been Mumbai?
Jealous 😂😂
Country and city mein difference hota hai lol😂😂😂
I love Tokyo，because tokyo hot😅
東京は神！
I love Tokyo the most.
Mumbai is emerging city ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Indian made this video by replacing Singapore with Mumbai
China bukan hanya asia tapi seluruh dunia.
Kota paling modern menurut gua 🎉
Jepang lebih modern....lebih canggihm..China sampah...ngak ada kualitas....China sekarang maju karna dibantu ama teknologi Jepang
@@RX-78-z7c抱歉，我實在想不出日本有什麼技術能幫助其他人
@RX-78-z7c wkwkwkwk yakin lu, bukannya teknologi Jepang lebih ke Amerika ya bukan China.
Ingat China itu negara yang mandiri 😂
Broo sekarang aj pengusaha" besar pada inves ke china😂
@@zanimanay6442 日本が高度経済成長期に中国に投資してやったこと忘れるな
独立国✗ 孤立国○w
서울 왤케 낮냐....
기준이 다른건지 순위가 좀 이상함
*GO INDIA*
孟买就不该在这个榜单里面，新加坡，吉隆坡，大阪都比孟买好
Jealous 😂
@ just look down at you India
印度有什么嫉妒的？😂😂😂@@Mr_premkumar_26
外网的氛围比b站好多了😅
令人难绷🤣
罕见太多了😆
蚌
Tokyo looks the best
중국은 빌딩은 높지만 시민들의 노상방뇨" 거리에 똥사는여자" 침뱉는시민" 쓰레기투척 불결한화장실에 싫어요! 일본은 깨끗한거리 청결한화장실 위생적음식 고풍스런 목조주택이 너무 아름답고 이뻐요!
别造谣
如果你觉得你说的是真的，请你拿出证据给我看，要不然就是空口无凭，贬低别人并不能提高自己。
去过中国吗你就叫😅看点儿西方媒体给脑子看没了？😅
The only thing I can say is,you shouldn't go to Europe.
小国寡民，魑魅魍魉，何足道哉
Taipei City？
孟買都可以入選了，這影片基本沒任何參考價值
@@kkkuo82167 台北才250万人口，不过一千亿GDP，这里排名是按GDP的总量
East Asia=Japan, China and Korea
不，東亞只有中國，韓國跟日本屬於美國（美洲）
@ Only Gyeongsang Do(Homeland of Chun Du Hwan, Martial Law)
@@JENJREQWNJEQ hong kong Macau belongs to uk
I love Chongqing!!!!!!!!
Mumbai must be 9 th in the world not Asia.
Taiwan no longer in it because many ammo there.
Singapore doesn't deserve in it😂😂😂😂😂
Congratulations for Tokyo city of capital
ありがとうございます。
😂😂😂😂😂India worst country on the earth
大阪ないんや...
悲しい
大都市圏単位で見れば大阪のGDPはアジアのTOP5に入るから安心して
そりゃそうでしょ（笑）
で、中国の主要都市とソウルなどを抑えて東京がアジアのナンバーワン。
納得のランキングです。
大阪市は狭いからね...
大阪が小さいっていうのは地図上に線を引いただけの行政的な区切りの話であって、都市っていう社会的な視点で見ると京阪神大都市圏はGDPでアジア3位かつ世界7位の巨大経済圏やで。
そもそも行政的な区切りで見ると東京より重慶の方が人口は多い。
東京は経済都市圏が一都六県だけど大阪は京都神戸が別都市圏扱いされる場合もあるしね
No Singapore?
深圳の夜はカッコよすぎる
日本で大昔からの古い都市は東京や京都より大阪が歴史がはるかに長いです、日本には封印された歴史が数多くあります。
MUMBAI FANS ASSEMBLE HERE ❤❤
love tokyo
Where is the singapore
シンガポールはどこだ？？🤔
東京はアジアいちだな
All Cities here are cool and nice besides one. Munbai? U kidding? Kuala Lumpur and Singapore City are wayyyyyyyy moreeeeeeeeee qualify than Munbai.
Mumbai ❤ . Many more indian cities are coming up. Way to go
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day).
Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
We have best 5 cities in Asia
どうでもええわ。京都の方が東京より日本らしいし、大都会より何も無い大自然の方が美しい。
Singapore and Taipei should be on the list
Population of Taipei only 2.5M
Tôi là người Việt Nam, hiện tại tôi 21 tuổi, hi vọng đến khi tôi chết Saigon sẽ lọt vào top 20 😂
This list is just not correct, I am 100% sure that in top10 is Osaka,Dubai,Singapur and Taipei,
Mumbi looks the worst
Mumbai is clearly not in the same league as the other cities on the list. It is nonsense that Mumbai can be on par with Seoul when one country has a GDP per capita of over $30,000 and the other has a GDP per capita of under $3,000, with the same or even less population (most of whom live in slums and work for a few dollars a day).
Indians love to play the GDP PPP trick. The data shows that the total nominal GDP of the city of Mumbai (including urban and suburban areas, hereinafter referred to as ‘Mumbai’) in the financial year 2022-23 translates into US$ 89,158 million. And this figure may also be overestimated as Mumbai does not have any industry worth mentioning.
@@panli-z4mwhy don’t you save your Nabi and Allah and read you book 1000 times a day😂😂
Saya berdoa semoga asia seperti eropa bisa rukun antar negara tetangganya👍🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
중국에서 가장 GDP per capita가 높은 상해도 서울보다 낮은데,
선전, 광저우, 충칭 같은 중국 도시들이 서울보다 rich하다고? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
웃고 간다.
TOKYO IS MOST POWERFULL CITY IN ASIA!!!
日本には大阪や名古屋、福岡といった大都市もある事を忘れずに
你说的这几个在中国还能在找出10个出来
@@上帝的中指
大阪は総合的に重慶や成都よりは都市規模が大きいと考えています
@@都市比較スティーブ成都、武汉、南京、天津、杭州、西安、青岛、长沙、郑州、厦门。你先把这10个干赢了我们再聊下10个城市
你说这些城市在中国二三线都排不上号😅
你们东京能排上也就算东京圈还有GDP各国算法和组成不同，中国往往样小很多产业都没有计算，要想真比较可以从生产端和消费端结合，生产多少东西还有消费多少东西。
The nominal gdp of Seoul and its metropolitan area, with a population of 26 million, is close to $1T and currently has the world's 6th largest city too, comparable to Paris.
But what makes you think it's only $360 billion and only ranked 8th in Asia? LOL
首尔接近一万亿美元你真敢说？😂纽约大约 1 1000 多亿美元
@@清渏 It is based on gdp including the metropolitan area, which Tokyo dare to include too, and in fact, Seoul ranked 4th 10 years ago, and is still 6th, comparable to Paris now. In the case of China, where gdp per capita is so low, it is regrettable that Shanghai and Beijing cannot be included in the top 20 level even if similar data on the metropolitan area are brought. 😹🤣😜
@haz 抱歉 中国城市 GDP 并没有像东京那样计算都市区范围 GDP ，如果是按照你说那样计算😂，不知道甩开首尔几条街，还有你说首尔两千万多人口哪来数据？不是才 980 多万人口？🤔
ochinchin🤝
首尔有一半的韩国人口？ 韩国人口才五千万
I love Tokyo one day I visit my Anime world 💖🇮🇳
中国はこの20年くらいに建ったビルが多そうですね
Why isn’t Singapore on the list? They’re pushing trillion soon
Each and every city looked Fabulous except Mumbai 😂😂😂
Which city from you country is in this list?
@@abigmonkey Mr idiot, I am an Indian 😂😂😂
@@abigmonkey Forget about top 10 , Mumbai can't even be placed in top 20😂
@@abigmonkey I am an Indian 😂
Cry about it..
草，看到这个我第一反应就是我苏州能不能挤进前十名，刚好第十名就是苏州，真巧啊
The one who are not happy or agree with the list are seriously fools or lack knowledge you guys are not getting the content at all. Mock it once you yourself are sure of what you saying the video is fully correct even google show the particular cities if you search it
Where's Dhaka???
africa
🤣🤣🤣
the video is vastly good and the Music in between is harrible.
Why is there Mumbai? The development level of any second tier city in China will be better than it
Jealous 😂
Cry chinese bot 😂😂
@Mr_p印度人要笑死我remkumar_26 😂😂😂
@@Mr_premkumar_26 为什么要嫉妒一个只有一个城市上榜的国家？你们的逻辑我很不理解
@@水蛭o Then let that one city be there why many people in comment section crying over this one city !?
東京もやがて1位から落ちる日が来るんだろうな……
Singapore
日本が1番だろ🇯🇵