Manual all day. The only time a manual sucks is in traffic. Get em while you can because it’s only a matter of time before we’re all forced to drive gay electric vehicles 🙄
Automatic are for people that don't know how to drive. For example two of the same Automatic cars on a drag race get the same result. The only difference is the reaction time on the green light. Do the same with cars in a manual, you will get two different results. It's the driver that shows its true values in the individual that is driving it.
Very opinionated commentary; but I respect that. Excellent video compared to 95% of the others I've seen. I'm an old school 4wheeler dude; and almost all the 4 wheel trucks and jeeps that I rode before were manuals. They give more torque and control when off-road and that's the main thing. No such thing as great gas mileage in a 4x4 or V8 or any truck for that matter. Forgot to mention, 4.30 gears in the manual vs 3.90 gears in the auto. I own a 4x4 TRD Off-Road 2022 Lunar Rock manual and I love it!
@@chadhaire1711 Absolutely nothing awkward about a manual transmission in traffic, for a competent and experienced driver. Automatics take all the fun out of driving.
A 6-speed manual transmission Toyota Tacoma will last you almost forever as long as, you keep up with your oil changes and all of the other things when needed. Common sense. The Tacoma with a time tested 6 speed manual is a well proven vehicle that will always take good care of you. I know. I had one that lasted me 12 years. It is ever so true that the body will rot out long before the engine and drive train ever will, and you can always bet on that one. Loads of fun to drive even on a bad day for sure. Enjoy.
The automatic lasts just as long as the manual----latter is just too much hassle to drive and has no advantage in reliability, acceleration, or fuel economy. But it is good they offer it for those who want to suffer...
@@chadhaire1711 LOL ! I have nothing at all against the automatic transmission however, my only concern is the younger generation missing out on the pleasure and enjoyment of the standard manual transmission. Us gear jammers enjoy the fun of it. Others could care less and that's ok with me. Have a great day.
@@stephenfranciszielski6309 Manual tranny works fine on Mazda MX-5 Miata, BMW turbo, and Ford V-8 Mustang GT......but the one in this truck is horrible--a pain to use.
Manual Tacoma has a better gear ratio than Auto. You can install 33s without having to spend almost $3k in regearing to 5:29 or 4:88s when you install 33s or 35s on an auto. You can also avoid the annoying gear searching that some auto tacomas encounter. The gear searching can be resolved with a Tune. I'm at sea level, and mostly do hwy driving (limited city) and I average just over 20 mpg.
@@barbecuetechtips6024 i agree that most Tacomas will never even see a dirt road, much less the Rubicon trail. But lots of folks will mount larger tires just because these rigs look so much better on 33s and 35s. I think they should come stock with 33s and properly geared for them too.
The guy who has 220k reviews noted the automatic gear adjustments to shifting has problems to automatics rather than manual transmissions. He was favoring manual rather than automatic. I'm not sure if that is true. What I do know is this. I have owned only 2 vehicles in the past 30 years. 16 with a 1986 long bed 4 cyl. and 14 with my current 2006 tacoma access cab 4 cyl. I love manual and these trucks run a long time. However, my kids are growing up and I need more room for the rear seating. It is getting close to the time to upgrade to another truck, preferably a 6 cyl. manual like yours. But if I cannot get it, I clearly know how to modify a truck from my happy 2006 tacoma.
Manual is better overall and the clutch replacements are subjective as is gas mileage depends on the driver. Ok review but I know more about the Tacoma than most so in this instance you missed the Mark on some items like it has a clutch cancel start feature specifically for off road. I’ve drove both and own a manual the automatic hunts for gears and barely downshifts without flooring it. Keep it coming though. Steering comment was spot on Toyota steering racks are not very tight but allows for ease off-road with stock tires.
@@chadhaire1711 Why not a Rebel then? Or a lightning? Those racetruck enough? Trucks are not for speed or mpg. That's a neat trick modern marketing has played on the midwits. Convinced they can purchase a truck that's as fast as a sports car, handles like a luxury sedan and gets the gas milage of a compact car. They want to purchase this truck for less money than a modern street bike costs as well.
@@triple6758 When you are driving and climbing this truck from 1,200 feet elevation to 7,000 feet, and maxing out power with a strained engine at 80 mph with your foot on the floor, and getting only 15 mpg, it is time to switch from this manual to an automatic. There are many vehicles that work great with a manual gearbox, this is NOT it. Has NO advantage over the auto gearbox at all. NONE. If you want a manual get the four banger.
For all the reasons automatics have the advantage, I bought a TRD off road 4x4 with v6 auto. It was a complete dog and was never in the right gear. It made me feel unsafe when trying to merge or turn left across oncoming traffic. It would stay in the high gear with no power and take forever to downshift. By the time you did drop it was too much forcing you to slam the brakes. I couldn’t get used to it in two years and never once saw 19 mpg on the highway. On paper the auto is better but if you don’t tow and want better real world performance, get the manual. I just need a pickup that is a little fun off road and last a long time. For the cost savings of the manual, you can buy a few clutches and enjoy your purchase more. I go off road for work and never used the multi terrain select, so that is a waste of money also.
I got a 23 tacoma v6 4wd auto. I tuned it with OTT at 6k miles. It drives great now. When you step on the gas it goes, holds gear if you stay on the gas, and moves the power to the low end. I had gas mileage improvement to. I was getting 24+ on the highway doing 80-85mph. Since I switched to 33" 6ply tires though it went down some expectedly.
Hi Chad, awesome video, very good data! But wanted to mention you can't add mileage and divide by 2 to get "average MPG.". Correct formula is 1 / ((1/A + 1/B) / 2). Basically, you have to convert it to "gallons per mile" (i.e. fuel burn rate per distance) and then average the gallons-per-mile numbers and then convert it back to miles-per-gallon. Averaging 14.5 and 19.4 gives 16.95, but that's not the actual MPG. Let's say each leg was 20 miles (actual number doesn't really matter). On the way up, you used 20/14.5 gallons, i.e. 1.38 gallons. On the way down, you used (20/19.4 gallons, i.e., 1.03 gallons). So the total trip used 2.41 gallons. 40 miles / 2.41 gallons is actually only 16.6 MPG. Not that far off in this case, but my old truck used to get 8 MPG going up a steep freeway, and 70 MPG on the way down. Needless to say it did not average 39 MPG. :D (Correct average for 8MPG and 70MPG is 14.35).
You are correct but in this case, you are reading into this too much. I have had this conversation before...yes I realize that taking a 10 mpg and 20 mpg, and dividing by 2 will ONLY give a real 15 mpg if both trips are the same mileage, will not if the miles on each trip was different. All I am saying is that by dividing the uphill and downhill and dividing by 2, that is the mileage you should expect on level ground. And I have found that formula is pretty accurate.
How's the JBL sound system? Worth it over the non TRD Pro models? And overall, is the TRD Pro worth it vs just like Sport (I am in Canada) with upgrading things to it?
@@rj12345rj Hi, so I looked it up and you are right indeed, the manual pro does NOT come with JBL sound system, it just says 7 speakers, but the automatic PRO does come with the JBL sound system. That is weird, and unfortunate!
Dont these Toyotas still have old power steering pumps versus the new fancy ones everyone else has switched over to? They last a LOT longer from what I hear
That chevy make for great drag cars, when built correctly. Had a buddy back in the day with a Vaga wagon that ran 10s in the early 80s and was a street car. 10s ain't fast by today's standards, but it was mighty fast back in the 80s.
I test drove a 2021 Tacoma trd pro manual and hated it. It had no power, first gear was useless, rear drum brakes, 55k with markup. Not for me, I bought an extended cab raptor 2018 and it’s a dream
Manual all day. The only time a manual sucks is in traffic. Get em while you can because it’s only a matter of time before we’re all forced to drive gay electric vehicles 🙄
What is so good about a manual? Seems they are outdated with modern automatics being so efficient.
Automatic are for people that don't know how to drive. For example two of the same Automatic cars on a drag race get the same result. The only difference is the reaction time on the green light. Do the same with cars in a manual, you will get two different results. It's the driver that shows its true values in the individual that is driving it.
The manual is better I get better MPG than what it’s rated for. 22-24 MPG on the freeway.
Very opinionated commentary; but I respect that. Excellent video compared to 95% of the others I've seen. I'm an old school 4wheeler dude; and almost all the 4 wheel trucks and jeeps that I rode before were manuals. They give more torque and control when off-road and that's the main thing. No such thing as great gas mileage in a 4x4 or V8 or any truck for that matter. Forgot to mention, 4.30 gears in the manual vs 3.90 gears in the auto. I own a 4x4 TRD Off-Road 2022 Lunar Rock manual and I love it!
some vehicles work with a manual....this truck is not it for me..
I can’t imagine having a truck with an automatic. A truck is a tool for work and play, an automatic is made for a tool to drive
yep lets all get the manual and get a truck that's slower, uses more gas, awkward to drive in traffic, and costs more to maintain....
@@chadhaire1711 Absolutely nothing awkward about a manual transmission in traffic, for a competent and experienced driver. Automatics take all the fun out of driving.
@@terryhutchinson9094 You obviously have not driven the clunky manual shifter in the Tacoma.....very obvious
A 6-speed manual transmission Toyota Tacoma will last you almost forever as long as, you keep up with your oil changes and all of the other things when needed. Common sense. The Tacoma with a time tested 6 speed manual is a well proven vehicle that will always take good care of you. I know. I had one that lasted me 12 years. It is ever so true that the body will rot out long before the engine and drive train ever will, and you can always bet on that one. Loads of fun to drive even on a bad day for sure. Enjoy.
The automatic lasts just as long as the manual----latter is just too much hassle to drive and has no advantage in reliability, acceleration, or fuel economy. But it is good they offer it for those who want to suffer...
@@chadhaire1711 LOL ! I have nothing at all against the automatic transmission however, my only concern is the younger generation missing out on the pleasure and enjoyment of the standard manual transmission. Us gear jammers enjoy the fun of it. Others could care less and that's ok with me. Have a great day.
@@stephenfranciszielski6309 Manual tranny works fine on Mazda MX-5 Miata, BMW turbo, and Ford V-8 Mustang GT......but the one in this truck is horrible--a pain to use.
@@chadhaire1711 You can simply have it your way. Have a great day.
My petite little wife only drives a manual transmission. Must be because she grew up in a single father home.
Manual Tacoma has a better gear ratio than Auto. You can install 33s without having to spend almost $3k in regearing to 5:29 or 4:88s when you install 33s or 35s on an auto.
You can also avoid the annoying gear searching that some auto tacomas encounter. The gear searching can be resolved with a Tune.
I'm at sea level, and mostly do hwy driving (limited city) and I average just over 20 mpg.
Yeah, but who actually needs 33s or 35's offroad? Maybe if I was doing the Rubicon or something. For 99% of people it would be a waste!
@@barbecuetechtips6024 i agree that most Tacomas will never even see a dirt road, much less the Rubicon trail.
But lots of folks will mount larger tires just because these rigs look so much better on 33s and 35s. I think they should come stock with 33s and properly geared for them too.
@@Do-UR-Research2749 I prefer stock steel wheels on them
I have 33s on a stock 13 Tacoma. Much more comfortable on road. You don't feel any imperfections. With the manual tranny, it's the perfect combo
Manual just for fun!
The guy who has 220k reviews noted the automatic gear adjustments to shifting has problems to automatics rather than manual transmissions. He was favoring manual rather than automatic. I'm not sure if that is true. What I do know is this. I have owned only 2 vehicles in the past 30 years. 16 with a 1986 long bed 4 cyl. and 14 with my current 2006 tacoma access cab 4 cyl. I love manual and these trucks run a long time. However, my kids are growing up and I need more room for the rear seating. It is getting close to the time to upgrade to another truck, preferably a 6 cyl. manual like yours. But if I cannot get it, I clearly know how to modify a truck from my happy 2006 tacoma.
Manual is better overall and the clutch replacements are subjective as is gas mileage depends on the driver. Ok review but I know more about the Tacoma than most so in this instance you missed the Mark on some items like it has a clutch cancel start feature specifically for off road. I’ve drove both and own a manual the automatic hunts for gears and barely downshifts without flooring it. Keep it coming though. Steering comment was spot on Toyota steering racks are not very tight but allows for ease off-road with stock tires.
Thorough and outstanding review as usual. Thank you.
I guess I should tell my 1994 Toyota 4X4 sitting in the driveway that it needs 2 clutches put in before I can drive it again.
Simplicity..love it! Own 2!
Only truck that even offers a manual. Arguments for or against a standard transmission is akin to arguing over color. Preference. That's all it is.
This manual is slower, no more reliable, and uses more fuel.....fine if you want a truck that is slower, no more reliable, and uses more fuel.
@@chadhaire1711 Why not a Rebel then? Or a lightning? Those racetruck enough? Trucks are not for speed or mpg. That's a neat trick modern marketing has played on the midwits. Convinced they can purchase a truck that's as fast as a sports car, handles like a luxury sedan and gets the gas milage of a compact car. They want to purchase this truck for less money than a modern street bike costs as well.
@@triple6758 When you are driving and climbing this truck from 1,200 feet elevation to 7,000 feet, and maxing out power with a strained engine at 80 mph with your foot on the floor, and getting only 15 mpg, it is time to switch from this manual to an automatic. There are many vehicles that work great with a manual gearbox, this is NOT it. Has NO advantage over the auto gearbox at all. NONE. If you want a manual get the four banger.
@@chadhaire1711 You're right Chad. However out of 26 vehicles I've owned the only ones I would buy over were the ones with the manual tranny.
@@Z3V5B0 your right arm must be getting a good workout
For all the reasons automatics have the advantage, I bought a TRD off road 4x4 with v6 auto. It was a complete dog and was never in the right gear. It made me feel unsafe when trying to merge or turn left across oncoming traffic. It would stay in the high gear with no power and take forever to downshift. By the time you did drop it was too much forcing you to slam the brakes. I couldn’t get used to it in two years and never once saw 19 mpg on the highway. On paper the auto is better but if you don’t tow and want better real world performance, get the manual. I just need a pickup that is a little fun off road and last a long time. For the cost savings of the manual, you can buy a few clutches and enjoy your purchase more. I go off road for work and never used the multi terrain select, so that is a waste of money also.
well that is why it is good Toyota offers the manual-----but not for me.
I got a 23 tacoma v6 4wd auto. I tuned it with OTT at 6k miles. It drives great now. When you step on the gas it goes, holds gear if you stay on the gas, and moves the power to the low end. I had gas mileage improvement to. I was getting 24+ on the highway doing 80-85mph. Since I switched to 33" 6ply tires though it went down some expectedly.
Hi Chad, awesome video, very good data! But wanted to mention you can't add mileage and divide by 2 to get "average MPG.". Correct formula is 1 / ((1/A + 1/B) / 2). Basically, you have to convert it to "gallons per mile" (i.e. fuel burn rate per distance) and then average the gallons-per-mile numbers and then convert it back to miles-per-gallon.
Averaging 14.5 and 19.4 gives 16.95, but that's not the actual MPG.
Let's say each leg was 20 miles (actual number doesn't really matter). On the way up, you used 20/14.5 gallons, i.e. 1.38 gallons. On the way down, you used (20/19.4 gallons, i.e., 1.03 gallons). So the total trip used 2.41 gallons. 40 miles / 2.41 gallons is actually only 16.6 MPG.
Not that far off in this case, but my old truck used to get 8 MPG going up a steep freeway, and 70 MPG on the way down. Needless to say it did not average 39 MPG. :D (Correct average for 8MPG and 70MPG is 14.35).
You are correct but in this case, you are reading into this too much. I have had this conversation before...yes I realize that taking a 10 mpg and 20 mpg, and dividing by 2 will ONLY give a real 15 mpg if both trips are the same mileage, will not if the miles on each trip was different. All I am saying is that by dividing the uphill and downhill and dividing by 2, that is the mileage you should expect on level ground. And I have found that formula is pretty accurate.
That’s what I learned to drive in Chevy Vega.
Its a Chevy Monza, same drivetrain as Vega but a worse car
Thank you for showing the RPM at 75 in 6th gear ! Gees nobody else who has done a manual review did this !!!!
I will get you a deal on the Monza!
@@chadhaire1711 Huh?
Better than my Si at least...
Any rattle noise from the transmission while clutch is in or in neutral? Heard this is a common problem with M/T
no
@@chadhaire1711 Thanks
The bird said "Go for the Manual, Go for the Manual!" But I wouldn't in this configuration, maybe in a sport sedan or coupe
How's the JBL sound system? Worth it over the non TRD Pro models? And overall, is the TRD Pro worth it vs just like Sport (I am in Canada) with upgrading things to it?
I think the Canada ones are different
The 6MT TRD Pro does not come with the JBL system, where the auto does. Not sure why, but I can confirm my ‘22 6MT TRD Pro Tacoma does not have it
@@rj12345rj that's weird, maybe the Canadian Pro 6spd manual version is different because I thought for sure it says it includes JBL sound system
@@dexedr1ne maybe. If you do confirm please let me know, thanks
@@rj12345rj Hi, so I looked it up and you are right indeed, the manual pro does NOT come with JBL sound system, it just says 7 speakers, but the automatic PRO does come with the JBL sound system. That is weird, and unfortunate!
Dont these Toyotas still have old power steering pumps versus the new fancy ones everyone else has switched over to? They last a LOT longer from what I hear
everything is electric now
My 2022 Tacoma has hydraulic steering
All the big "You Tubers" will finally be out with reviews on the new Genesis GV70 on Monday. Probably the most anticipated vehicle out there now.
Terrible mileage. Dated truck but will run forever. Get a loaded Ridgeline for less $$ unless heavy off-roading is in order.
Unibody truck 💩
And a temporary spare tire? I'll pass and get the Tacoma instead.
Ridgeline does not offer a 6 speed manual or the same off-road capability. Been looking, but that is a deal breaker.
Can’t clutch kick a auto
can't stall on a steep hill with an auto....
@@chadhaire1711 very difficult to stall in 1st and 4lo don’t even have to give it gas
@@jeremys1496 no its not
@@chadhaire1711 auto is perfect for you then! I’m in your head rent free lol everyone can have a opinion
@@jeremys1496 Yep..even when they are wrong.....
That chevy make for great drag cars, when built correctly.
Had a buddy back in the day with a Vaga wagon that ran 10s in the early 80s and was a street car. 10s ain't fast by today's standards, but it was mighty fast back in the 80s.
I test drove a 2021 Tacoma trd pro manual and hated it. It had no power, first gear was useless, rear drum brakes, 55k with markup. Not for me, I bought an extended cab raptor 2018 and it’s a dream
The main reason people in a truck would want a manual transmission is so they can tell everyone they have a manual transmissions.
Makes a good anti-theft deterrent (only if the suspect doesn't know how to drive a stick)
The majority of people cant drive one anyways so yeah......
Yeah ok Holmes
I never owned an automatic car, its so boring to drive automatic transmission
The main reason people in a truck would want an automatic transmission is because they have low testosterone levels and bitch tits
Thanks Chad. I have to agree. Automatic is the way to go. Days of me pushing a clutch are long over.