Mental health issues which cause suicidal tendencies are way more painful than any kind of physical pain thus the result is that people can muster the will to take their own lives. I would describe it as the closest thing to the suffering of hell in this life. May Allah relieve the mental suffering of everyone who is going through this experience.
@Tom-i5 I find it interesting that when someone gets suicided (aka murdered), we are to take solace that ot was their time and God's will... but when someone commits suicide,it's entirely their fault and they in fact cut their prescribed life short.
@@Saby217Because it is they who do it! When they are murdered it is not in their hands? They didn’t decide to kill themselves, that was someone else who decided to take their life. Suicide you kill yourself. Someone else doesn’t do it. That’s why
@@Saby217 - Getting 'suicided' is getting murdered. That's not a suicide. One can be coerced or driven into suicide through hypnosis or medication, to the point that the decision is not his, but the perpetrator's. One has to make a choice to commit suicide to be deserving the entry ticket to the punishment in the afterlife. If the choice isn't the person's, then the accountability isn't his or hers. A sin is an act, and an act is by intention.
I am sorry for your loss Allah knows all, He the almighty is all encompassing saying may Allah understand his pain isn’t a befitting statement because Allah is all aware and He already knows I hope you understand what I am saying May Allah have mercy upon us all
You being with him in his pain, having empathy and still cradling love for him, is evidence of God’s forgiveness. One has to go through hell to take one’s life. I just can’t imagine that God doesn’t respect a spent human being‘s will to forever rest. I think he draws that human being to him and اليه المصير
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Whoever purposely throws himself from a mountain and kills himself, will be in the (Hell) Fire falling down into it and abiding therein perpetually forever; and whoever drinks poison and kills himself with it, he will be carrying his poison in his hand and drinking it in the (Hell) Fire wherein he will abide eternally forever; and whoever kills himself with an iron weapon, will be carrying that weapon in his hand and stabbing his `Abdomen with it in the (Hell) Fire wherein he will abide eternally forever." Al bukhari 5778.
Are you Islamic Scholar? (Alim). If not, don't quote Bukhari. Everyone of us can't rendomly pick up a hadith from Bukhari and quote. Onli islamic scholars can do it based on thorough knowledge. Little knowledge is dangerious.
I love the Lord Jesus Christ! He mediate for me with Father God! So I don't have to burn in the fire of hell for eternity! Praise the Lord Jesus for His sacrifice and His cleansing blood!
@user-ws1pp2hg2j Jesus taught you to worship One Eternal God not himself, read the Lord's prayer. Matthew 6:9-13 “This, then, is how you should pray: “ ‘Our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name, your kingdom come, your will be done, on earth as it is in heaven. Give us today our daily bread. And forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors. And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from the evil one.’ You see how it starts and ends 😊
Assalamalikum, my son had ALS. No cure for this illness. His condition was the end of life. So he wanted to go peacefully doesn't like to go on life support .He got accepted for a medicine to take and go through the state of Colorado. May Allah take him under His Mercy. Ameen
I don't think this is allowed brother, so I think it's best if you reach out to a knowledgeable imam or scholar. Also may Allah bless your son for all eternity
Suicide is a major sin , and the one who does that is faced with a warning of eternity in the Fire of Hell, where Allah will punish him with the means that he used to commit suicide.
If the suicide is due to mental illness that has had such a far-reaching impact on a person’s reason that he is not aware of what he is saying or doing, if in such a case it so happens that he killed himself, then he will not be with the sinners who have committed the major sin of suicide; rather he will be excused. That is because this person was no longer accountable due to severe mental illness that led to loss of reason.
yes one of the conditions when angels stop recording our deeds according to a hadith is when a sane person become insane. i know mental illness in islam has a lot to do with jinn, so maybe a person who is insane could be possessed by a jinn or even a child in some cases, to do a bad or evil thing. in such case they would not be held accountable.
Yes, such as those with schizophrenia, experiencing untreated psychosis, which sometimes have command auditory hallucinations which may lead them to suicide. Or those with severe emotional dysregulation like those with personality disorders or mood disorders.
“As for those who repent, believe, and do good deeds, they are the ones whose evil deeds Allah will change into good deeds. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.” (Quran 25:70) 🤍
Jundub ibn ‘Abd-Allah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “A man among those who came before you was wounded. He panicked and took a knife and cut his hand, and the bleeding did not stop until he died. Allah, may He be glorified and exalted, said: ‘My slave hastened his death; I have forbidden Paradise to him.” (Narrated by al-Bukhari (3276) and Muslim (113)
Life is a school we are told. We chose to come in this Duniya to learn - Allah's countless blessings. Yes most in poverty and ill health. Suicide is "dropping out" of learning and so a failure. The entity/ruh/soul would need to retake their learning where they left it by self harm so it appears it will be back to very similar if not worst circumstances. Mental health support for suicidal individuals. Allah's blessings
Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) narrated that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Whoever throws himself down from a mountain and kills himself will be throwing himself down in the Fire of Hell for ever and ever. Whoever drinks poison and kills himself will be sipping it in the Fire of Hell for ever and ever. Whoever kills himself with a piece of iron will have that iron in his hand, thrusting it into his belly in the Fire of Hell for ever and ever.” (Narrated by al-Bukhari (5442) and Muslim (109)
I think it probably also depends on the person's state of mind and their intent. For example, someone who commits suicide as an act of revenge (such as murder-suicides) or to escape punishment for criminal acts (such as Hitler's suicide) will surely be in hellfire. But we cannot say the same about those who are good people but not in the right frame of mind.
A person Committing Suicide is because of MENTAL BREAK DOWN ! NOBODY LIKES to DIE. EVEN TERMINALLY SICK PEOPLE HOPE & PRAY for a MIRACLE to SURVIVE ! GOD Will Embrace Such a PAINED SOUL and GUIDE IT to a BETTER PEACE & FULFILLMENT . THIS is just like ANY PARENT Would CALM and try to HEAL a SICK CHILD ! IF YOUR GOD Does NOT FORGIVE A SOUL COMMITTING SUICIDE , HE IS NOT GOD AT ALL ! WE REALLY DON'T NEED HIM .
If one commits suicide because they lost their job is different than if someone has mental health issues and is not in their right mind. In this case I've learned that they are not sane even if temporarily and Allah swt judges them with more mercy than one who doesn't have a mental health illness. Allahu alam...
According to Qur'an there is no liability on a person who has to deal with things beyond their capacity. Thats why we should pray to God to not burden us with things which qre beyond our capacity. If someone who offed himself is tested with something which was beyond their capacity, according to Qur'an there is no liability on them.
I don't remember which verse but in the Quran it's mentioned that whatever we do, whether good or bad, is on us only. No one else can interfere. Doesn't this mean we can't do anything about the deceased ones?
Please let me ask a question and please answer it but first all praise and honor to God it is in regards two people that are in a hospital and cannot survive without the help of being fed or medicine entering their bodies if they decline to do so is that suicide and also if they decline other medical treatment that would keep them alive and suffering is that suicide as for me I believe that medicine sometimes keeps us going past our appointed time with our one God I seek guidance in this Dr so if you could answer it with a bit of a program it would be great thank you and again all praise and glory to God
What if someone took a massive amount of pills and then made dua for forgivenesstill they passed out and then they died and ALLAh SWT knows the intention.
" if you avoid the grearest sins mentioned in the Quran, I will forgive the the rest of your sins and enter you into My Paradise. " Here one should know the ' the greatest sins ' mentioned in the Quran, and do not pass a quick judgement. Moreover, one should consider the status, states, and trouble of a person who tried to commit suicide, and if it was a sucssesful attempt, close friends and families should try to relive his or her immediate family. No one in their right mind attempts try such a thing, so many reasons could be behind this attempt. We hope anyone who knows someone that maybe is planning such an act, try his or her best effort to provide necessary help. As saving one life, in Allah 's SIGHT is to save a generation. May God Almighty help all his servents, in all situations, to overcome all kinds of clamities and adversities specially at these times where TRUTH, and falsehood are mingled. Thank you Dr.Alley for taking such hard topics, though probably it needs much more time than a few minutes. Best regards.
@@SoufBouchahati Humans are not infallible. They might do mistake. But Allah is infallible. Read the whole sentence if yo know Arabic. In the first part of the verse the word ’takulu’ is used to mean ‘consume/eat among yourseves’ as the word ‘taqtulu’ is used.
@@ahmfarooq1823 No, takulu means eat/consume (plural) , the word after that "baynakum" means among each other. I have a degree in classic arabic.The second part of the part is clear. There is no mention of the part "among each other". The verse is extremely clear. Or you dont know arabic or you are delibarately twisting meanings of verses and add stuff, which is extremely dangerous. By the way, you can judge on hadith only. If the hadith is classified as sahih. For example the beard and thousands of examples. Unless you are Qurani and reject hadith which I hope not
Suicide is a sin of disbelief when one commit suicide they haven given up hope of Allah . Also there’s a Hadith where someone ask the prophet Muhammad sahlahi wa salaam about a man killing himself by jumping of cliff that he will be doing this over n over in hellfire. And Allah knows best
Dear Dr. Shabir Thank you for mentioning the narration concerning prophetic warning against suicide. It states: مَن تردَّى مِن جبَلٍ فقتَلَ نفْسَه فهو في نارِ جَهنَّمَ، يتردَّى خالدًا مُخلَّدًا فيها أبدًا، ومَن تحسَّى سُمًّا فقتَلَ نفْسَه، فسُمُّه في يدِهِ، يتحسَّاه في نارِ جَهنَّمَ خالدًا مُخلَّدًا فيها أبدًا، ومَن قتَلَ نفْسَه بحَديدةٍ ثمَّ انقطَعَ عليَّ شيء، خالِدٌ يقولُ كانتْ حديدتُه في يدِه، يَجَأُ بها في بطنِه في نارِ جَهنَّمَ خالدًا مُخلَّدًا فيها أبدًا. الراوي : أبو هريرة | المحدث : الألباني | المصدر : صحيح النسائي | الصفحة أو الرقم : 1964 | خلاصة حكم المحدث : صحيح | التخريج : أخرجه البخاري (5778)، ومسلم (109)، والترمذي (2044)، والنسائي (1965) واللفظ له، وأحمد (7448) Whomever jumps from a mountain/cliff and kills themself, then they are in Jahannam (Gehinom, hellfire) falling in it for everlasting. And whomever consumes a poison and kills themself, their poison is in their hand, and they consume it in Jahannam for everlasting. And whomever kills themself with a piece of iron (ie instrument), then his piece of iron is in their hand as they oger their belly with it in Jahannam for everlasting. [Authenticated narration appearing in Al-Bukhari, Muslim, Sunan Al-Nasaei, and Musnad of Ahmad] The question is why is there such a severe punishment for suicide ? The answer comes from the Qur'an, Allah (God) says: قال الله تعالى:﴿ولا تقتلوا أنفسكم ان الله كان بكم رحيما﴾. سورة النساء آية 29 "And do not kill thyselves, Allah (God) is merciful with you" [Al-Nisaa' (Women) 29] ﴿ولا تلقوا بأيديكم إلى التهلكة وأحسنوا إن الله يحب المحسنين﴾. سورة البقرة 195 "And do not bring about thy demise and perfect thy deeds, for Allah (God) loves those that perfect their deeds" [Al-Baqarah 195] Therfore there are multiple prohibitions and warnings telling people not to commit that great sin because it represents giving up on the mercy of the Most Merciful, and taking a decision that belongs essentially to The Creator not the created. Is the person that commits suicide a disbeliever ? The answer is no, and that as well is narrated in Sahih Muslim as follows: روى مسلم في صحيحه، في: باب الدليل على أن قاتل نفسه لا يكفر حديث: «عن جابر أن الطفيل بن عمرو الدوسي أتى النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال يا رسول الله هل لك في حصن حصين ومنعة قال حصن كان لدوس في الجاهلية فأبى ذلك النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم للذي ذخر الله للأنصار فلما هاجر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم إلى المدينة هاجر إليه الطفيل بن عمرو وهاجر معه رجل من قومه فاجتووا المدينة فمرض فجزع فأخذ مشاقص له فقطع بها براجمه فشخبت يداه حتى مات فرآه الطفيل بن عمرو في منامه فرآه وهيئته حسنة ورآه مغطيا يديه فقال له ما صنع بك ربك فقال غفر لي بهجرتي إلى نبيه صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال ما لي أراك مغطيا يديك قال قيل لي لن نصلح منك ما أفسدت فقصها الطفيل على رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم اللهم وليديه فاغفر». الدعاء له. [صحيح مسلم كتاب الإيمان باب الدليل على أن قاتل نفسه لا يكفر، حديث رقم: (116)] In brief, a man had embraced Islam (submission to God) and migrated to the prophet PBUH in Madinah, then became very ill and decided to end his life to escape the pain. He injured himself and bled to his death. His friend Al-Tufail bin Amr saw his deceased friend in a vision with a pleasant appearance yet covering the hand he had injured to commit his suicide. In this vision Al-Tufail asked him "What has thy Lord done with you ?", the man answered "He forgave me by my migration to his prophet PBUH." Al-Tufail asked "Why do you cover your hand ?", the man replied "I was told, We shall not mend what you [willingly] ruined [of thy body]." Al-Tufail relayed his vision to the prophet PBUH, and the prophet PBUH said "O Allah, and his hands may Yee forgive" [Sahih Muslim, the chapter of Faith (116)] Therefore, there is hope for the person that commits suicide in the hereafter, yet it is entirely in the hands of Allah (God). It appears from the narration that a great deed is needed on the level of performing the "hijrah" (migration to the prophet), yet Allah can forgive whomever He wishes to forgive. May Allah protect us all from the great sins, ameen.
QUR'AN 23:12-14 we CREATED insan ( from root INS meaning a thing that's self awareness perception conscious) FROM sulalah ( means lineage ancestory single RNA ribosome nafsin wahida ) FROM the clay not clay itself then we made it ( rna ribosome) a nutfah ( in nucleus fluid ) inside a qararin Makin ( firm soild air tight cell walls ) the we made the nutfah( nucleus) alaqah ( mitosis @ telophase stage were it's separate genes but clinging in one cell ) then alqah into mudgha ( a 3mm turnicate larvae) then into a izaman ( large bones exoskeleton -trylobites ) then izaman lahman ( large boney flesh mamamles) covered them bone flesh mamamlian ( humanoids with clothes) the from that we created the last creation human 🤠
Yes I have also been thinking about this over and over. Although there are the cameramen around. However, staring at each other so freely this way is questionable in Islam. Or openly, it is considered haram by most Muslim scholars
**When Were the Earliest Biographies and Sayings of Jesus and Mohammed Written?** In Christianity, the earliest biographies of Jesus are the Gospels. Mark, the earliest, was written around 70 CE, just 40 years after Jesus’ crucifixion. The other Gospels-Matthew, Luke, and John-were completed between 80-100 CE, all within a century of Jesus' life. These texts were written close to the time when eyewitnesses were still alive. In Islam, the earliest biography of Mohammed is by Ibn Ishaq, written around 767 CE, over 130 years after Mohammed’s death. However, the original is lost and is known through later edits by Ibn Hisham (d. 833 CE). The sayings of Mohammed (hadith) were collected even later, with the most trusted collections (like Bukhari and Muslim) being compiled over 200 years after Mohammed’s death. **Conclusion:** The Christian Gospels were written much closer to Jesus’ time, while the Islamic biographies and sayings of Mohammed were compiled much later, primarily during the Abbasid period.
@@mentalismification Skipping straight to the Quran while ignoring the historical reliability of the sources that give it context is like trying to assemble furniture without the instruction manual-good luck with that! The Quran doesn’t explain most Islamic practices or provide the necessary historical background on its own. It heavily relies on the Hadith and Sira, which were compiled a good 200 years after Mohammed’s time, raising serious questions about their authenticity. So, if you want to cut through anything, how about we start with the inconvenient fact that the Christian Gospels were written within the lifetimes of eyewitnesses, while Islamic sources didn’t even show up until centuries later. Context matters, my friend, and it’s one thing you can’t just skip over.
@YeshuaAkbar7 I had lots to say in the past, until I read the Quran for myself. One-on-one with the Quran day after day after a small humble prayer to the Creator to lead me to the Turth. As for manuscripts, check the Birmingham manuscript. No Gospel, no Hadith comes even close. But again, my proof was not historicity. It's the transformative effect of the Quran. Nothing else convinced me in my journey towards God. Thanks for reading. May God guide us all. Peace.
@@mentalismification The Birmingham manuscript claim might sound impressive at first, but it quickly loses steam when you dig into the details. The Birmingham manuscript only contains parts of three chapters (18-20) of the Quran, and even if it dates close to Mohammed’s time, it represents a tiny fraction of the text-just 33 verses out of 6,000+. Claiming it as evidence of a fully preserved Quran is like finding a torn-out page of a novel and saying the whole book is original. Comparatively, the Christian Gospels are full, coherent narratives written within the lifetimes of eyewitnesses. Plus, we have over 5,800 Greek New Testament manuscripts, some dating as early as the 2nd century, much closer to the events they describe than the Hadith or the later Islamic biographies. Finally, if your proof “was not historicity,” then you’ve essentially admitted you’re avoiding the very foundation of any claim to truth-historical evidence. It’s easy to sidestep the issue, but doing so doesn’t magically make the facts disappear. When it comes to manuscripts and reliable history, the Christian sources still have the upper hand, no matter how much we slice it.
@@mentalismification **Timing Gaps Expose Weaknesses in Islamic Sources vs. Christian Gospels** The Christian Gospels were written much closer to Jesus' time, while Islamic biographies and hadiths were compiled much later, primarily during the Abbasid period. **Average Time Difference:** - Gospels: About 70 years after Jesus' death. - Islamic Biographies and Hadith: Around 150-200 years after Mohammed's death. This results in an average time gap of approximately 80-130 years, with Islamic texts being compiled significantly later than the Christian Gospels. The long delay between Mohammed’s life and the compilation of Islamic texts undermines their credibility, especially regarding eyewitness accounts. The Gospels were written closer to Jesus' life, making it more likely they were based on eyewitness testimony or reliable oral traditions. In contrast, Islamic sources were compiled 150-200 years after Mohammed’s death, suggesting they are based more on second-hand reports or hearsay rather than direct witnesses. The Christian Gospels thus have a stronger case for containing elements of eyewitness or near-contemporary involvement.
No one is equal in the eyes of God. There are 6 levels of hell and 6 levels of heaven. The 7 th level of heaven is reserved for prophets who are “ Chosen By God.” Every human being in this world has a different relationship with God. Whitney Houston committed suicide from a drug overdose. Currently, she is enjoying absolute paradise and is able to evolve every day. Her entire day is extremely productive which includes one hour of meditation. I don’t think it is possible to evolve in this world. Human beings seem to be going in reverse. Many of the angels have stopped charging people for suicide. This world is a sick, demented, deranged place to live.
'Do people think God cannot reassemble their bones? Yes ˹indeed˺! We are ˹most˺ capable of restoring ˹even˺ their very fingertips. But man desires to continue in sin'. - Quran 75-3,4,5.
I will not risk it. I will not tempt God, especially because it is killing a human being, which is yourself. You are playing God so it falls under murder and ungratefulness. Go to see your doctor, go get cognitive therapy, consider medication, consider a psychiatric hospital. Do exercise, eat healthy, sleep well, have a good support system and live a balanced life.
No mental gymnastics needed. Islam is a very straightforward religion that emphasises common sense and empathy towards others. People who commit suicide out of revenge (such as murder-suicides) or to escape worldy punishment (such as Hitler's suicide) are surely destined for hellfire. But we cannot say the same about those with mental health issues who are driven to suicide due to depression or hopelessness. We simply pray that Allah has mercy on those people because their intentions weren't evil, they were irrational acts of desperation.
How absurd for hadith to speak for God in his judgment. Throughout the gospels Jesus makes it clear that he is the Judge. Forget about trying to carry the burdens of your dead family members, the question is what will you do with Jesus' words and what is the state of your own soul!
The Judge is God, Jesus is no judge. He will be judged by God. As you may well know, Jesus is not God, but an estimed messenger of The Almighty Creator. Peace.
![[Live] : ONE 168 วันนี้!! "โจนาธาน vs ซุปเปอร์เล็ก"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0jIN65KgJsI/mqdefault.jpg)
Mental health issues which cause suicidal tendencies are way more painful than any kind of physical pain thus the result is that people can muster the will to take their own lives. I would describe it as the closest thing to the suffering of hell in this life. May Allah relieve the mental suffering of everyone who is going through this experience.
Amen
@Tom-i5 I find it interesting that when someone gets suicided (aka murdered), we are to take solace that ot was their time and God's will... but when someone commits suicide,it's entirely their fault and they in fact cut their prescribed life short.
@@Saby217Because it is they who do it! When they are murdered it is not in their hands? They didn’t decide to kill themselves, that was someone else who decided to take their life. Suicide you kill yourself. Someone else doesn’t do it. That’s why
@@Saby217 - Getting 'suicided' is getting murdered. That's not a suicide.
One can be coerced or driven into suicide through hypnosis or medication, to the point that the decision is not his, but the perpetrator's.
One has to make a choice to commit suicide to be deserving the entry ticket to the punishment in the afterlife. If the choice isn't the person's, then the accountability isn't his or hers.
A sin is an act, and an act is by intention.
You can't compare it. I have both and I can say the physical issue is way worse.
I am the only Muslim in my family. My uncle committed suicide when I was only 6 years old. May Allah understand his pain 😢
Ameen
INSHALLAH. ALLAH will forgive him. AMEEN.
Ameen!
I am sorry for your loss
Allah knows all, He the almighty is all encompassing
saying may Allah understand his pain isn’t a befitting statement because Allah is all aware and He already knows
I hope you understand what I am saying
May Allah have mercy upon us all
You being with him in his pain, having empathy and still cradling love for him, is evidence of God’s forgiveness. One has to go through hell to take one’s life. I just can’t imagine that God doesn’t respect a spent human being‘s will to forever rest. I think he draws that human being to him and اليه المصير
I absolutely love your videos! Thank you for sharing ❤ Alhamdulillah
May the almighty protect us from this torchure and bring ease to the Muslims suffering
YOU ARE a writer As well, I hope that you Will Write A Book On Prophet Muhammad ( PbUH)..❤
I really needed this video 🖤
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Whoever purposely throws himself from a mountain and kills himself, will be in the (Hell) Fire falling down into it and abiding therein perpetually forever; and whoever drinks poison and kills himself with it, he will be carrying his poison in his hand and drinking it in the (Hell) Fire wherein he will abide eternally forever; and whoever kills himself with an iron weapon, will be carrying that weapon in his hand and stabbing his `Abdomen with it in the (Hell) Fire wherein he will abide eternally forever."
Al bukhari 5778.
Are you Islamic Scholar? (Alim). If not, don't quote Bukhari. Everyone of us can't rendomly pick up a hadith from Bukhari and quote. Onli islamic scholars can do it based on thorough knowledge. Little knowledge is dangerious.
@@syednasir8316- so the scholars hold the power 🤔
I love the Lord Jesus Christ! He mediate for me with Father God! So I don't have to burn in the fire of hell for eternity! Praise the Lord Jesus for His sacrifice and His cleansing blood!
@@syednasir8316 Seriously 🤔!! Why can't they quote Al-Bukhari ??
@user-ws1pp2hg2j Jesus taught you to worship One Eternal God not himself, read the Lord's prayer.
Matthew 6:9-13
“This, then, is how you should pray: “ ‘Our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name, your kingdom come, your will be done, on earth as it is in heaven. Give us today our daily bread. And forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors. And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from the evil one.’
You see how it starts and ends 😊
Assalamalikum, my son had ALS. No cure for this illness. His condition was the end of life. So he wanted to go peacefully doesn't like to go on life support .He got accepted for a medicine to take and go through the state of Colorado. May Allah take him under His Mercy. Ameen
Assisted suicide and euthanasia in law and ethics in the world?
I don't think this is allowed brother, so I think it's best if you reach out to a knowledgeable imam or scholar. Also may Allah bless your son for all eternity
@@shamskhan6088 I’m sure he’s in jannah
Suicide is a big sin and it is only God's decision as to whether to forgive it or not.
I'm from the Philippines, I hope I can you Dr Shabir God willing. (I really like how you beat the crap out of D Wood)
Suicide is a major sin , and the one who does that is faced with a warning of eternity in the Fire of Hell, where Allah will punish him with the means that he used to commit suicide.
If the suicide is due to mental illness that has had such a far-reaching impact on a person’s reason that he is not aware of what he is saying or doing, if in such a case it so happens that he killed himself, then he will not be with the sinners who have committed the major sin of suicide; rather he will be excused. That is because this person was no longer accountable due to severe mental illness that led to loss of reason.
yes one of the conditions when angels stop recording our deeds according to a hadith is when a sane person become insane. i know mental illness in islam has a lot to do with jinn, so maybe a person who is insane could be possessed by a jinn or even a child in some cases, to do a bad or evil thing. in such case they would not be held accountable.
Yes, such as those with schizophrenia, experiencing untreated psychosis, which sometimes have command auditory hallucinations which may lead them to suicide. Or those with severe emotional dysregulation like those with personality disorders or mood disorders.
God gives life to man and He has the right to take it back, so suicide is a betrayal of trust
Shabir Ally I Love you for the sake of Allah. You are a Lion of Islam.
Give and forgive is forgiveness
“As for those who repent, believe, and do good deeds, they are the ones whose evil deeds Allah will change into good deeds. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.” (Quran 25:70) 🤍
Jundub ibn ‘Abd-Allah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “A man among those who came before you was wounded. He panicked and took a knife and cut his hand, and the bleeding did not stop until he died. Allah, may He be glorified and exalted, said: ‘My slave hastened his death; I have forbidden Paradise to him.” (Narrated by al-Bukhari (3276) and Muslim (113)
I really love these videos
Life is a school we are told. We chose to come in this Duniya to learn - Allah's countless blessings. Yes most in poverty and ill health.
Suicide is "dropping out" of learning and so a failure. The entity/ruh/soul would need to retake their learning where they left it by self harm so it appears it will be back to very similar if not worst circumstances.
Mental health support for suicidal individuals.
Allah's blessings
Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) narrated that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Whoever throws himself down from a mountain and kills himself will be throwing himself down in the Fire of Hell for ever and ever. Whoever drinks poison and kills himself will be sipping it in the Fire of Hell for ever and ever. Whoever kills himself with a piece of iron will have that iron in his hand, thrusting it into his belly in the Fire of Hell for ever and ever.” (Narrated by al-Bukhari (5442) and Muslim (109)
I think it probably also depends on the person's state of mind and their intent. For example, someone who commits suicide as an act of revenge (such as murder-suicides) or to escape punishment for criminal acts (such as Hitler's suicide) will surely be in hellfire. But we cannot say the same about those who are good people but not in the right frame of mind.
A person Committing
Suicide is because of
MENTAL BREAK DOWN !
NOBODY LIKES to DIE.
EVEN TERMINALLY SICK PEOPLE HOPE & PRAY for a MIRACLE to SURVIVE !
GOD Will Embrace Such a PAINED SOUL
and GUIDE IT to a BETTER PEACE & FULFILLMENT .
THIS is just like ANY PARENT Would CALM and try to HEAL a SICK CHILD !
IF YOUR GOD Does NOT FORGIVE A SOUL COMMITTING SUICIDE ,
HE IS NOT GOD AT ALL !
WE REALLY DON'T NEED HIM .
Thank you.
If one commits suicide because they lost their job is different than if someone has mental health issues and is not in their right mind. In this case I've learned that they are not sane even if temporarily and Allah swt judges them with more mercy than one who doesn't have a mental health illness. Allahu alam...
According to Qur'an there is no liability on a person who has to deal with things beyond their capacity. Thats why we should pray to God to not burden us with things which qre beyond our capacity. If someone who offed himself is tested with something which was beyond their capacity, according to Qur'an there is no liability on them.
I don't remember which verse but in the Quran it's mentioned that whatever we do, whether good or bad, is on us only. No one else can interfere. Doesn't this mean we can't do anything about the deceased ones?
Please let me ask a question and please answer it but first all praise and honor to God it is in regards two people that are in a hospital and cannot survive without the help of being fed or medicine entering their bodies if they decline to do so is that suicide and also if they decline other medical treatment that would keep them alive and suffering is that suicide as for me I believe that medicine sometimes keeps us going past our appointed time with our one God I seek guidance in this Dr so if you could answer it with a bit of a program it would be great thank you and again all praise and glory to God
Tyvm
What if someone took a massive amount of pills and then made dua for forgivenesstill they passed out and then they died and ALLAh SWT knows the intention.
" if you avoid the grearest sins mentioned in the Quran, I will forgive the
the rest of your sins and enter you into My Paradise. "
Here one should know the ' the greatest sins ' mentioned in the
Quran, and do not pass a quick judgement. Moreover, one should
consider the status, states, and trouble of a person who tried to
commit suicide, and if it was a sucssesful attempt, close friends
and families should try to relive his or her immediate family.
No one in their right mind attempts try such a thing, so many
reasons could be behind this attempt.
We hope anyone who knows someone that maybe is planning
such an act, try his or her best effort to provide necessary
help. As saving one life, in Allah 's SIGHT is to save a generation.
May God Almighty help all his servents, in all situations, to overcome all kinds of clamities and adversities specially at these
times where TRUTH, and falsehood are mingled.
Thank you Dr.Alley for taking such hard topics, though probably
it needs much more time than a few minutes.
Best regards.
Quran didn’t mention it, but the Hadith did. However we can’t judge it only depending on Hadith narratives when it’s not clear in Glorious Quran.
What are you talking about?
"And do not kill yourselves, indeed Allah is to you ever Merciful" Quran 4:29
@@SoufBouchahati The word ‘taqtulu’ means here is ‘kill among yourselves’( i.e. one another). Check the renowned translations.
@@ahmfarooq1823 no check the tafseer ibn katheer, saidi and others. Not translations. The verse is clear, the arabic is clear.
@@SoufBouchahati Humans are not infallible. They might do mistake. But Allah is infallible. Read the whole sentence if yo know Arabic. In the first part of the verse the word ’takulu’ is used to mean ‘consume/eat among yourseves’ as the word ‘taqtulu’ is used.
@@ahmfarooq1823 No, takulu means eat/consume (plural) , the word after that "baynakum" means among each other. I have a degree in classic arabic.The second part of the part is clear. There is no mention of the part "among each other". The verse is extremely clear. Or you dont know arabic or you are delibarately twisting meanings of verses and add stuff, which is extremely dangerous.
By the way, you can judge on hadith only. If the hadith is classified as sahih. For example the beard and thousands of examples. Unless you are Qurani and reject hadith which I hope not
Suicide is a sin of disbelief when one commit suicide they haven given up hope of Allah . Also there’s a Hadith where someone ask the prophet Muhammad sahlahi wa salaam about a man killing himself by jumping of cliff that he will be doing this over n over in hellfire. And Allah knows best
what happens if someone has no other hope been on antidepressaNTS FOR A LONG TIME
Why did prophet Muhammed try to commit suicide till the angel stopped him. Was that disbelief in Allah
I don't have money to donate
Dear Dr. Shabir
Thank you for mentioning the narration concerning prophetic warning against suicide. It states:
مَن تردَّى مِن جبَلٍ فقتَلَ نفْسَه فهو في نارِ جَهنَّمَ، يتردَّى خالدًا مُخلَّدًا فيها أبدًا، ومَن تحسَّى سُمًّا فقتَلَ نفْسَه، فسُمُّه في يدِهِ، يتحسَّاه في نارِ جَهنَّمَ خالدًا مُخلَّدًا فيها أبدًا، ومَن قتَلَ نفْسَه بحَديدةٍ ثمَّ انقطَعَ عليَّ شيء، خالِدٌ يقولُ كانتْ حديدتُه في يدِه، يَجَأُ بها في بطنِه في نارِ جَهنَّمَ خالدًا مُخلَّدًا فيها أبدًا.
الراوي : أبو هريرة | المحدث : الألباني | المصدر : صحيح النسائي | الصفحة أو الرقم : 1964 | خلاصة حكم المحدث : صحيح | التخريج : أخرجه البخاري (5778)، ومسلم (109)، والترمذي (2044)، والنسائي (1965) واللفظ له، وأحمد (7448)
Whomever jumps from a mountain/cliff and kills themself, then they are in Jahannam (Gehinom, hellfire) falling in it for everlasting. And whomever consumes a poison and kills themself, their poison is in their hand, and they consume it in Jahannam for everlasting. And whomever kills themself with a piece of iron (ie instrument), then his piece of iron is in their hand as they oger their belly with it in Jahannam for everlasting.
[Authenticated narration appearing in Al-Bukhari, Muslim, Sunan Al-Nasaei, and Musnad of Ahmad]
The question is why is there such a severe punishment for suicide ? The answer comes from the Qur'an, Allah (God) says:
قال الله تعالى:﴿ولا تقتلوا أنفسكم ان الله كان بكم رحيما﴾. سورة النساء آية 29
"And do not kill thyselves, Allah (God) is merciful with you" [Al-Nisaa' (Women) 29]
﴿ولا تلقوا بأيديكم إلى التهلكة وأحسنوا إن الله يحب المحسنين﴾. سورة البقرة 195
"And do not bring about thy demise and perfect thy deeds, for Allah (God) loves those that perfect their deeds" [Al-Baqarah 195]
Therfore there are multiple prohibitions and warnings telling people not to commit that great sin because it represents giving up on the mercy of the Most Merciful, and taking a decision that belongs essentially to The Creator not the created.
Is the person that commits suicide a disbeliever ? The answer is no, and that as well is narrated in Sahih Muslim as follows:
روى مسلم في صحيحه، في: باب الدليل على أن قاتل نفسه لا يكفر حديث: «عن جابر أن الطفيل بن عمرو الدوسي أتى النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال يا رسول الله هل لك في حصن حصين ومنعة قال حصن كان لدوس في الجاهلية فأبى ذلك النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم للذي ذخر الله للأنصار فلما هاجر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم إلى المدينة هاجر إليه الطفيل بن عمرو وهاجر معه رجل من قومه فاجتووا المدينة فمرض فجزع فأخذ مشاقص له فقطع بها براجمه فشخبت يداه حتى مات فرآه الطفيل بن عمرو في منامه فرآه وهيئته حسنة ورآه مغطيا يديه فقال له ما صنع بك ربك فقال غفر لي بهجرتي إلى نبيه صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال ما لي أراك مغطيا يديك قال قيل لي لن نصلح منك ما أفسدت فقصها الطفيل على رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم اللهم وليديه فاغفر». الدعاء له.
[صحيح مسلم كتاب الإيمان باب الدليل على أن قاتل نفسه لا يكفر، حديث رقم: (116)]
In brief, a man had embraced Islam (submission to God) and migrated to the prophet PBUH in Madinah, then became very ill and decided to end his life to escape the pain. He injured himself and bled to his death. His friend Al-Tufail bin Amr saw his deceased friend in a vision with a pleasant appearance yet covering the hand he had injured to commit his suicide. In this vision Al-Tufail asked him "What has thy Lord done with you ?", the man answered "He forgave me by my migration to his prophet PBUH." Al-Tufail asked "Why do you cover your hand ?", the man replied "I was told, We shall not mend what you [willingly] ruined [of thy body]."
Al-Tufail relayed his vision to the prophet PBUH, and the prophet PBUH said "O Allah, and his hands may Yee forgive" [Sahih Muslim, the chapter of Faith (116)]
Therefore, there is hope for the person that commits suicide in the hereafter, yet it is entirely in the hands of Allah (God). It appears from the narration that a great deed is needed on the level of performing the "hijrah" (migration to the prophet), yet Allah can forgive whomever He wishes to forgive.
May Allah protect us all from the great sins, ameen.
QUR'AN 23:12-14 we CREATED insan ( from root INS meaning a thing that's self awareness perception conscious) FROM sulalah ( means lineage ancestory single RNA ribosome nafsin wahida ) FROM the clay not clay itself then we made it ( rna ribosome) a nutfah ( in nucleus fluid ) inside a qararin Makin ( firm soild air tight cell walls ) the we made the nutfah( nucleus) alaqah ( mitosis @ telophase stage were it's separate genes but clinging in one cell ) then alqah into mudgha ( a 3mm turnicate larvae) then into a izaman ( large bones exoskeleton -trylobites ) then izaman lahman ( large boney flesh mamamles) covered them bone flesh mamamlian ( humanoids with clothes) the from that we created the last creation human 🤠
Isn’t it Haram to sit face to face or next to a non mehram
That's his daughter, if memory serves me correctly, so I don't believe it applies, Allahu alam
@@AngelsandWolves1 oh okay really I didn’t know thanks for telling me
Yes I have also been thinking about this over and over. Although there are the cameramen around. However, staring at each other so freely this way is questionable in Islam. Or openly, it is considered haram by most Muslim scholars
But at times I think Dr Safiya is Dr Shabir's daughter of sister... Wallahu a'alam
**When Were the Earliest Biographies and Sayings of Jesus and Mohammed Written?**
In Christianity, the earliest biographies of Jesus are the Gospels. Mark, the earliest, was written around 70 CE, just 40 years after Jesus’ crucifixion. The other Gospels-Matthew, Luke, and John-were completed between 80-100 CE, all within a century of Jesus' life. These texts were written close to the time when eyewitnesses were still alive.
In Islam, the earliest biography of Mohammed is by Ibn Ishaq, written around 767 CE, over 130 years after Mohammed’s death. However, the original is lost and is known through later edits by Ibn Hisham (d. 833 CE). The sayings of Mohammed (hadith) were collected even later, with the most trusted collections (like Bukhari and Muslim) being compiled over 200 years after Mohammed’s death.
**Conclusion:** The Christian Gospels were written much closer to Jesus’ time, while the Islamic biographies and sayings of Mohammed were compiled much later, primarily during the Abbasid period.
You can cut through all that, and go straight to the final revelation from God known as The Quran. It's your manual for salvation.
@@mentalismification Skipping straight to the Quran while ignoring the historical reliability of the sources that give it context is like trying to assemble furniture without the instruction manual-good luck with that!
The Quran doesn’t explain most Islamic practices or provide the necessary historical background on its own. It heavily relies on the Hadith and Sira, which were compiled a good 200 years after Mohammed’s time, raising serious questions about their authenticity.
So, if you want to cut through anything, how about we start with the inconvenient fact that the Christian Gospels were written within the lifetimes of eyewitnesses, while Islamic sources didn’t even show up until centuries later. Context matters, my friend, and it’s one thing you can’t just skip over.
@YeshuaAkbar7 I had lots to say in the past, until I read the Quran for myself. One-on-one with the Quran day after day after a small humble prayer to the Creator to lead me to the Turth.
As for manuscripts, check the Birmingham manuscript. No Gospel, no Hadith comes even close.
But again, my proof was not historicity. It's the transformative effect of the Quran. Nothing else convinced me in my journey towards God.
Thanks for reading. May God guide us all. Peace.
@@mentalismification The Birmingham manuscript claim might sound impressive at first, but it quickly loses steam when you dig into the details. The Birmingham manuscript only contains parts of three chapters (18-20) of the Quran, and even if it dates close to Mohammed’s time, it represents a tiny fraction of the text-just 33 verses out of 6,000+. Claiming it as evidence of a fully preserved Quran is like finding a torn-out page of a novel and saying the whole book is original.
Comparatively, the Christian Gospels are full, coherent narratives written within the lifetimes of eyewitnesses. Plus, we have over 5,800 Greek New Testament manuscripts, some dating as early as the 2nd century, much closer to the events they describe than the Hadith or the later Islamic biographies.
Finally, if your proof “was not historicity,” then you’ve essentially admitted you’re avoiding the very foundation of any claim to truth-historical evidence. It’s easy to sidestep the issue, but doing so doesn’t magically make the facts disappear. When it comes to manuscripts and reliable history, the Christian sources still have the upper hand, no matter how much we slice it.
@@mentalismification **Timing Gaps Expose Weaknesses in Islamic Sources vs. Christian Gospels**
The Christian Gospels were written much closer to Jesus' time, while Islamic biographies and hadiths were compiled much later, primarily during the Abbasid period.
**Average Time Difference:**
- Gospels: About 70 years after Jesus' death.
- Islamic Biographies and Hadith: Around 150-200 years after Mohammed's death.
This results in an average time gap of approximately 80-130 years, with Islamic texts being compiled significantly later than the Christian Gospels.
The long delay between Mohammed’s life and the compilation of Islamic texts undermines their credibility, especially regarding eyewitness accounts. The Gospels were written closer to Jesus' life, making it more likely they were based on eyewitness testimony or reliable oral traditions. In contrast, Islamic sources were compiled 150-200 years after Mohammed’s death, suggesting they are based more on second-hand reports or hearsay rather than direct witnesses.
The Christian Gospels thus have a stronger case for containing elements of eyewitness or near-contemporary involvement.
No one is equal in the eyes of God. There are 6 levels of hell and 6 levels of heaven. The 7 th level of heaven is reserved for prophets who are “ Chosen By God.” Every human being in this world has a different relationship with God. Whitney Houston committed suicide from a drug overdose. Currently, she is enjoying absolute paradise and is able to evolve every day. Her entire day is extremely productive which includes one hour of meditation. I don’t think it is possible to evolve in this world. Human beings seem to be going in reverse. Many of the angels have stopped charging people for suicide. This world is a sick, demented, deranged place to live.
What has god got to do with suicide.Everything down here is our doing not gods doing.Anyways what is everybody going to do in heaven without a body?
'Do people think God cannot reassemble their bones?
Yes ˹indeed˺! We are ˹most˺ capable of restoring ˹even˺ their very fingertips.
But man desires to continue in sin'.
- Quran 75-3,4,5.
What a dumb question!
I will not risk it. I will not tempt God, especially because it is killing a human being, which is yourself. You are playing God so it falls under murder and ungratefulness. Go to see your doctor, go get cognitive therapy, consider medication, consider a psychiatric hospital. Do exercise, eat healthy, sleep well, have a good support system and live a balanced life.
Please no forgiveness after death stop the Islamic propaganda
Poor dr Shabir - trying to make Islam palatable for the modern masses - just call a spade a spade - stop with the mental gymnastics
Dr shabir is right.
@@ahmedzahir2865 - dr shabir won gold for mental gymnastics
No mental gymnastics needed. Islam is a very straightforward religion that emphasises common sense and empathy towards others. People who commit suicide out of revenge (such as murder-suicides) or to escape worldy punishment (such as Hitler's suicide) are surely destined for hellfire. But we cannot say the same about those with mental health issues who are driven to suicide due to depression or hopelessness. We simply pray that Allah has mercy on those people because their intentions weren't evil, they were irrational acts of desperation.
How absurd for hadith to speak for God in his judgment. Throughout the gospels Jesus makes it clear that he is the Judge. Forget about trying to carry the burdens of your dead family members, the question is what will you do with Jesus' words and what is the state of your own soul!
The Judge is God, Jesus is no judge. He will be judged by God.
As you may well know, Jesus is not God, but an estimed messenger of The Almighty Creator. Peace.
Where did Jesus ever say, "I am God worship worship me" in the Bible❓ Show me those verses exactly & I will convert to Christian now❗⛪
John 5. The Son is worthy of exactly the same honour as the Father whom we worship as God. @@hoopoe3093