Yeah. And as far as I know, all girl group trainees from every agency performs this for evaluation. Or in some cases, any Soshi song. They are the girl group standard.
1) no one underestimates snsd's vocals And secondly, that's such a bad comparison cuz these girls are like 14... They haven't even developed their voices fully
The scariest part was when she shifted the girl’s hair to look at the name tag with a very serious face then she turned to her clipboard with the same expression but suddenly whipped around to smile at something or another lolol
You know the sad part of this evaluation is that some girl's got a easier parts in the song. So they can nail that part haha. Like this girl got the line from Taeyeon and others for example got hyoyeon or Yuri (for example) there is a difference you know
0:25 i'm sorry to say this but that was kinda more like a scream. Not gonna say she sang out of tune but it just sound more as if she screamed it. If you don't agree, go listen to Ailee. She's queen in this
G V Goo Eleutice lol this show is so biased. They center the good ones they like, minimize their weaknesses and let the others stand in the shadow. Bada looked as if that scream was a perfect note. Cmon, don't say she looked like "oh that was bad, we'll help u"
OKIDOKI just because YOU think that bada look impressed doesn't mean she's really saying that she sang it perfectly right. How can you know what she's thinking without talking? Lol are you a mind reader?
she just debuted a few days ago, her name is natty and she's a thai soloist. she participated in sixteen (the show that made twice) and used to be under jyp, and then went on to idol school (the show that made formis_9) as shown in this video. please support her debut as a soloist, the song is called nineteen. :D
Beam she used to be sixteen contestant. A survival shows where all twice members compete to become twice. Unluckily she was eliminated during the finale episode
It's clear for her voice that she's still young, her voice doesn't even fully matured yet...why even some comments that she's shouting. We all know that it's not a highnote. For me it's better when she do that shows that she's still trying to do the highnote instead of don't sing at all just because it's a highnote.
So funny to me how Bada sort of breezed by Nayeon in these early moments, listening to her but not really taking as much notice at first. Then they get to the performances, and Bada is literally Nayeon's fangirl for every song lol!
Natty improved, that’s all i got to say. She definitely shook me even though she didn’t made it (i think?), she still shook me! Well done natty! Im proud of you!
@Ellie〰 1.) left is already in past tense. Lefted doesn't exist. 2.)she didn't leave to join idol school, she left after sixteen and went back to Thailand with the intention of not pursuing music anymore, but eventually gave it another shot and came back to sk on 2017 and joined idol school.
Everyone talking about 0:25. Yeah it wasn’t necessarily a ‘note’ but when learning how to sing you have to see where your potential lies. She had an open throat, clear voice, nice chest/ mix voice and potential to work TO a high note with support throughout. That’s how you get better, and that why they most likely reacted impressed to the girl.
@@dreamcatcher5526 Your comment is not necessary...And plus Itzy aren't amazing vocalist but there definitely far from being bad there are just average and they are more of a dance based group than vocal.
![Idol School [아이돌학교] EP.1 - Natty(나띠 ) Cut](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WTk3lCHCEH0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[EN/JP] [‘MCD VOCAL CHALLENGE’ Girls' Generation - Into The New World] #엠카운트다운 EP.765 |Mnet 220811방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6cl0udULwEM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[C.C.] BLACKPINK ROSÉ fascinating the judges with her voice #BLACKPINK #ROSE](/img/n.gif)
이거 되게 괜찮은것 같은건 나뿐인가
프듀는 개개인의 노래실력은 잘 모르고 진짜 잘하는 애들이 묻히는 경우도 있으니까 이런식으로 한명한명 실력 다 보여주는것도 괜찮은 것 같은데..
마져마져
믿고보는 바다
맞아영
근데 저는 차라리 같은 파트만 불렀으면 실력차이가 딱 보일텐데 고음파트 걸리는 친구는 부담스러울수도 있다고 생각해요
시스템은 좋지만 실력이...
애초에 실력을 보여줘야하는 프로그램이니까 잘하는 사람들은 고음파트가 걸리는 게 자신을 보여줄 수 있으니까 유리할 수도 있을 것 같네요.
바다 코옆에서 노래불러야하는거면 정말 영광이고 긴장될텐데 다들 떨지않고 잘했네 ㄷㄷ 나라면 오들오들떨면서 노래못했을듯
Is no one gonna talk about 0:50 she was so good!
파스텔Kitty her name is nayeone she has a TH-cam channel
Violet V whats her channel
Violet V thanks
lol did anyone realize someone still sang at 1:05
파스텔Kitty not at all ?
0:10 이건 진짜 어린이다..
김은결은 저때 13살이였으니 더..
어린나이에 거길 들어 간거 보면 그래도 실력은 있었을듯 하네요
헐 중딩으로 보이는데ㄷㄷ
@@user-iq3cw9kz7z 미국이면 12살...
얘 YG들어감ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지금 연습생임
While people sometimes underestimate snsd’s vocal but this song just shows how hard it is
Yeah. And as far as I know, all girl group trainees from every agency performs this for evaluation. Or in some cases, any Soshi song. They are the girl group standard.
This song is hard and especially if u try to sing this song auditioning for sm and you don’t do it it’s Ike embarrassing
it is indeed hard to sing this song
@@hitmantae104 embrassed to death I guess
1) no one underestimates snsd's vocals
And secondly, that's such a bad comparison cuz these girls are like 14... They haven't even developed their voices fully
You cant blame them for being nervous when a legend like Bada is evaulating you.. a member of the original Girl Group..
What original girlgroup?
@@dcpurplee the legendary girl group of SMent. - S.E.S. :) They belong to the 1st generation of KPOP along with the girlgroup FinKL. :>
@@dcpurplee
The first SM girl group
The first nation's girl group
Elksie why?
Elksie don’t disrespect the legends like that.
어린애 2명은 더 배워야될듯 고음 잘하는게 아니라 소리지르는급 아닌가 일단 이 보컬 테스트 자체가 별로임 고음부분 걸리는애는 뭔죄여
악으 다 감안하고 보지 않을 가요 그리고 손 들기 전 잠깐 듣고 손 들으시니까......가수 짬에서 나오는 안목이 있을 것 같아요.....
@@user-md9zj1mz1f 믿고보는 바다
가까이 가서 발성 자체를 보는게 다른 오디션이랑 차별화 되서 좋은거 같은데요 노래를 저거 하나만 듣고 판단하는것도 아닌거 같고 저음에도 괜찮으면 기다려서 더 부르게 해주는거 같은데
박선 학생 나만 소리 되게 단단하고 발성 좋다 생각했나? 트레이너분이 좋은 표정을 하고 계시는데 우리가 판단할 문제는 아닐 듯
@@user-ij5tt6ry9m 별로여
김나연, 나띠 둘이 잘하네.
나띠는 외국인이고 어린걸 감안하면 플러스.
엥 오히려 김명지분이 김나연분 보다 훨 나은데...
G K 저도 그 분 목소리도 그렇고 더 좋은 듯
나띠 음색이 약간 바다같음
외국인 미친...
잠깐 외국 살다와서 발음이 좀 안좋은건줄 알았는데....
노래도 잘하고 춤도잘추고...
@@1iz1 사람마다 다른거 같아요
Bada is so scary i don't know why 😂😂😂
Kim Shoute i think the girl teacher is more friendly than boy teacher
Come on yo Its SES xD
The scariest part was when she shifted the girl’s hair to look at the name tag with a very serious face then she turned to her clipboard with the same expression but suddenly whipped around to smile at something or another lolol
She's like didn't sleep
they weren't really properly trained in that show
0:25 that was a scream, not a note.
Soneful Well she is a kid. So dont expecr her to hit the best high notes.
You can''t expect from a 14 year old girl to nail the high note that taeyeon is singing..
You guys are true too but she looks like...a bit weird?Like she is an idol i just didn't like this.
Ikr, and look at her satisfied face
You know the sad part of this evaluation is that some girl's got a easier parts in the song. So they can nail that part haha. Like this girl got the line from Taeyeon and others for example got hyoyeon or Yuri (for example) there is a difference you know
0:25 i'm sorry to say this but that was kinda more like a scream. Not gonna say she sang out of tune but it just sound more as if she screamed it. If you don't agree, go listen to Ailee. She's queen in this
OKIDOKI thats the purpose of training there helping her...duh
OKIDOKI lol comparing a little girls voice to a grown woman? I don't think so. She'll have time to improve.
OKIDOKI bada was actually surprised she can scream the note, not that she's good lol
G V Goo Eleutice lol this show is so biased. They center the good ones they like, minimize their weaknesses and let the others stand in the shadow. Bada looked as if that scream was a perfect note. Cmon, don't say she looked like "oh that was bad, we'll help u"
OKIDOKI just because YOU think that bada look impressed doesn't mean she's really saying that she sang it perfectly right. How can you know what she's thinking without talking? Lol are you a mind reader?
1:21 reminds me of Joy , her voice is naturally soft but has strength with training shell be amazing
Nicole Mano that isn’t soft at all 😂
@@its_arisely okay teacher
Nicole Mano how’d you know lmao
she debuted yesterday as a solo artis! her name is natty if you wanna look at her debut💓
she just debuted a few days ago, her name is natty and she's a thai soloist. she participated in sixteen (the show that made twice) and used to be under jyp, and then went on to idol school (the show that made formis_9) as shown in this video. please support her debut as a soloist, the song is called nineteen. :D
이거 거의 공개 처형같아
진짜 김나연 연습생 왜 데뷔 못함ㅠㅠㅜㅜㅠ 노래 진짜 잘하던데..
휴지 이거 투표가 조작이라서요
박선은 발성은 좋은데 조절은 못하는거같음 그러니까 륶끼가 나오고... 트레이닝 받으면 되겠지 뭐
Jang Jinyoung's disgust face though
K-POPTrash Lyrics bada was like yes and he was like no😂
Ikr 😂
K-POPTrash Lyrics where isit
At around :25 and :30
thank kiews:)
박선인가 ..? 그 학생은 고음이 아니라 소리 지르는거 같은데
@@user-xf6vx9qi2w ㅇㅈ이요
나만 소리 되게 단단하고 발성 좋다 생각했나? 트레이너분이 좋은 표정을 하고 계시는데 우리가 판단할 문제는 아닐 듯
박선 쟤 그때 보컬 2등? 했음
dyfuehd dududu 소리 되게 단단하긴 한데 좀 어려서 그런지 고음 낼 때 고함 지르는 것 같긴 함
@@user-ij5tt6ry9m ㅋㅋㅋㅋ이 말 도배하고 다니네ㅋㅋㅋ
Who’s here after Natty debuted solo with nineteen? SHE DID IT YALL!! SHE DID IT!!! so proud, been with her since sixteen, now all grown up ❤️❤️
NATTY I MISS YOU😢
Who's natty?
Beam she used to be sixteen contestant. A survival shows where all twice members compete to become twice. Unluckily she was eliminated during the finale episode
She in WM Ent. We can wait she debuted with chaeyeon soon after izone.
They rigged the show. Everythings exposed now
Don't worry she will debut soon (hopefully) jyp has plans for her so I have heard
노래 부르는데 입에 귀 귀울이고ㅋㅋ
겁나 부담스럽겠다ㅋㅋㅋ
와 나띠 노래도 잘해ㅠㅠ 심지어 외국인인데도 발음까지 정확하다ㅠ
0:25 I think it not highnote. Oh ! Jang Jinyoung' face
But she anyway got second place
I SALANG KPOP is she in fromis9
@@vincent5502 No, she only got second place for that vocal lesson
I SALANG KPOP how?! she was the worst one
@@dcpurplee how? Natty, Nayeon and many others were better-
썸네일 바다엿어.......? 개그우먼 줴훈줴훈 하시는 분인줄 알았는뎈ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 다시보니까 맞는거같아욬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
미칰ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그 개그맨 이은영님이용?
ㅋㅋ저두 그분인줄 알고 들어옴ㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ이거 보고 그 분처렴 보임
aren't that vocal trainer and bada from SM?
so is this program for SM?
Taiga Aisaka No they are just there to help them out
not SM have bad relation with Mnet?
She's not from sm since 2013. But she's still part of S.E.S
Mamau De Cat this was in 2017, sm didn’t boycott mnet back then
0:50 HER VOICE 😘
ChuXChannel na young is daebak
Giang Ngo *YES*
Giang Ngo it's nayeon
What is Love? Nayeonie lol no
What is Love? Nayeonie ohww i thought you mean nayeon from twice im sorry
Lol yeh its her
0:10 다 잘부를 줄 알았는데....
안캐럿 아마 14살아님13살 일꺼예요
저땐 6학년이었을걸요 지금은 실력이 어떨지 모르지만..
Legend song!!!! Soshi daebak!!!
+misspurpleswan Exactly, this song fitting for all new generation that is why it's called into the new world for a reason?
misspurpleswan yes
다 공정 하게 평가하든가..
고음파트 걸린사람은 뭐야...
불땽해
어차피 심사위원들은 고음이든 저음이든 노래잘부르거 못부르는건 다알수있음
오히려 고음때 걸리면 더 잘뽐내면 그것도 이득이지 않나요?
가수될려고 하는건데 걸그룹중에 고음없는 노래가 몇 된다고..
염병 못하는데 뭔 이유를 듬
? 고음 걸리는게 기회지 뭔 개소리들하고있지 ..? 아니 기회왔을때 잘해버리면 바로 증명하는건데 요즘애들 사상 존나 이상하네ㅋㅋ 어떻게든 묻어가려ᄀᆞㅛ
썸넬안보고 제목만 보다가 들어왔는데
Into the New world 라 해서 겨울왕국+알라딘인줄
앜ㅋㅋㅋ 저도욬ㅋㅋ
Glad to see Natty finally debut and to show off her vocal talent at 1:20
i'm proud to be SONE 😢👏
Fany SAME
Me too
Me too💖
Me three 😭
Me too
은결아 그냥 초관심이나 하자 너무하다
그러게요 노래보단 연기에 더 재능이 있는 것 같아요ㅠㅠㅠ
이거 투표 조작때메 안됌 ㅠㅠ
박신영 이미 저기있는 40명도 주작으로 들어갔는데 뭐ㅋㅋ
러러처헟라럴
0:25 누가봐도 고음이 아니라 소리지르는건데 이제보니까 주작티 확난다
It's clear for her voice that she's still young, her voice doesn't even fully matured yet...why even some comments that she's shouting. We all know that it's not a highnote. For me it's better when she do that shows that she's still trying to do the highnote instead of don't sing at all just because it's a highnote.
When is herin gona blow away people with her vocals
Cassie Elite EXACTLY
Cassie Elite who is herin?
so sad no one got to hear her singing itnw...
@@mzlly wait... herin was eliminated from eps 1?
Natty สู้ๆ นะ เป็นกำลังใจให้ ขอให้น้องได้เป็นนักร้องจริง ติดตามตั้งแต่ sixteen ละ เสียดายแทนน้องมากๆ รอบนี้ขอให้สมปราถนานะ 💪👏
박선고음은 좀 아닌데...저 프로그램에서 잘되면 데뷔할텐데 울림통보고 고음연습시키기엔 너무 늦지 않았나 한다..
Gotta give them credit, singing a legendary song next to a legendary singer, that pressure must be insane
So funny to me how Bada sort of breezed by Nayeon in these early moments, listening to her but not really taking as much notice at first. Then they get to the performances, and Bada is literally Nayeon's fangirl for every song lol!
김나연 음색쩐다
무슨 썸네일 바다가 잘못한 거 있어가지고 기자회견 하는 줄 알았네 ㅅㅂ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
1:35 i just love the way she smile like a mom
It's like it was hard for them to sing this song. This is SNSD song. Soshi love this song
snsd created the legend song😍proud of snsd❤
0:48 I love her voice so much 🤩 and also 1:20 SO AMAZING THEY ALL WERE those were just the best in my opinion ♥️
Muireann Thank you ! They’re so talented and natty is so adorable 💕
I'm Proud to be sone..legendary queens we love more and more until forever SNSD 😍😍😍
역시 륶끼 하드캐리 버스기사 메보 나연님 파트 너무 좋다 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ 맑고 단단하고 힘찬 음색 취저…
ウンギョルちゃん可愛い、横でガン見されながら歌えるのはすごい
Natty improved, that’s all i got to say. She definitely shook me even though she didn’t made it (i think?), she still shook me! Well done natty! Im proud of you!
팣츠파핯파라랄라샇핳핳핳하할할할라사랖핳랗라샇핳핲ㅎ하할랗샆핳핲
할랖라팔랓살할핲할랄
랓랄랄랄랄랄랄랄럵ㄹ
the third one is actually sounds so good and so beautiful
Who are the girls in 0:38, 0:48 & 1:20? They have great voices
They are Myungji-former member of Tiny G, Nayeon-former member of Berry Good and Natty-former JYP trainee.
iheart taengoo natty
iheart taengoo 1:20 natty
Natty has a great voice :O
@Ellie〰 1.) left is already in past tense. Lefted doesn't exist. 2.)she didn't leave to join idol school, she left after sixteen and went back to Thailand with the intention of not pursuing music anymore, but eventually gave it another shot and came back to sk on 2017 and joined idol school.
바다 너무 멋지다...분위기가 진짜...
When Bada be serious,..wow,..so full of charm
ナッティの歌うInto The New Worldが凄く好き
この曲のこともナッティのおかげで知って好きなったよ
0:25 she’s just screaming and jinyoung knows it while bada is like “oh yasss girllll”
Annie Nguyen yeah you obviously don’t know how hard that is
@@its_arisely but it's still screaming, not singing
黑天鹅维多利亚 no. No it isn’t. It’s called belting.
@@its_arisely belting shouldn't be that loud, right?
黑天鹅维多利亚 it’s not loud?? Did you even compare it to the other singers??
Jyp standard👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻 every shows jyp trainee so good 💜 their charming personality and talent amazing
00:10
I don't know if you know lee haeun, they are both the same age, 14.
they can't say she sings like that because of her age.
Is that Bada from S.E.S?
Neta Restya yas
Yes
I would definitely love to meet Bada and take lessons from her. She’s an icon
Being rated by a legendary girl group idol while singing the nation’s girl group song. Must be so nerve wrecking 😟😟
Yeah, true!!
나띠 목소리 진짜 매력적인들 솔로가조아ㅜㅠ
김은결님 재능티비에서 봐서 아는데 노래할 때도 말할 때 말투가 나오네..,
I like nayeon and natty's voices
the legend song
Everyone talking about 0:25. Yeah it wasn’t necessarily a ‘note’ but when learning how to sing you have to see where your potential lies. She had an open throat, clear voice, nice chest/ mix voice and potential to work TO a high note with support throughout. That’s how you get better, and that why they most likely reacted impressed to the girl.
Nope,her throat closed
Ok other reason why SNSD become a legendary nation's girl group for a reason 👑👑
SNSD your highness I'm proud of you all and PROUD TO BE A SONE 😍😘😍
I really like this segment 😍
Most of them were amazing!
SNSD's debut one of the best debut in the world
Definitely one of the greatest debut songs of all time.
@@jamesrawlins735 periodt.
legend song
hamham taro what title?
Jiwon was so supportive of her, I guess it’s because they were both in sixteen, so they just have that bond
바다 포스 ㄹㅇ 오진다..ㄷㄷ👍👍
Natty did so great, I reallly love her voice!
이 시국에 이게 또 .. 유튜브 알고리즘 정말 ••
이 영상을 몇번 보는거지 난 왜 자꾸 들어오지
나연이.. 시달할때 슬펐겠㉰.. 같이 연습했던 친구 2명이랑 고등학교 동창 1명이 있는 그룹에서 히트친 곡을 커버 했었으니까.. 참.. 빨리 데뷔했음 좋겠네
Omgahd that is so scary,,
I'll probably shaking if was at their shoes..
박선 끝나고 바다는 웃는데 딴 남자쌤은 인상 찡그림
고음이 너무 잘해서 그런거임 ㅋㅋㅋ
i like natty's voice but she have problems whit high notes
key mar Xy erm maybe because she’s more of an alto then a suprano
she's mostly a dancer so her vocals are pretty average
@@dreamcatcher5526 Your comment is not necessary...And plus Itzy aren't amazing vocalist but there definitely far from being bad there are just average and they are more of a dance based group than vocal.
@@madisonbarkley9199 look, you even agree that their vocal is not that amazing right.
@@dreamcatcher5526 though, they are average.
รอนัตตี้อยู่เด้อ เสียงมีพลัง ชิบมาก รอแค่โอกาสเนาะ นัตตี้
I would cry on the spot when someone from SM will evaluate me lmao
I would breakdown regardless of who's evaluating me 😭 I just hate how all the other contestants have to sit there and watch
김나연 처음듣는데 음색 너무이쁘고 프로같네요
다들 넘 멋있어용 ㅠ
0:29 That gesture said all. That was a scream, not a high note.
I'm the only one that has seen this video a lot of times
badaaa 😍😍
wow i like this performance . SNSD Fighting ! Legend song
Lance Mojica what name music
90년대 최고의 걸그룹 이었던 SES 메인보컬이 2000년대 최고의 걸그룹인 소녀시대의 노래로 미래의 보컬을 찾다..
i don't care about the trainees. i'm just being amazed yet feel in-loved how bada evaluate them. uwu~
고음 올라갈때 바다님 표정 무엇 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
The first one was so cutee!
I love this song
Overall. I liked Natti's voice the most. ❤
PS: Soshi is legendary. 😂❤
Which one is shoshi
@@xkyoukaa she is talking about girls generation =soshi
Jang Jinyoung legit cringed at that note. Where's the Unnie's when you need them to make him sane again?!
연습생기싸움이 날 여기로 이끌었다
anyone else came back here after nattys debut?
im glad she went solo ! natty fighting !
Natty so beautiful voice and Jiwon so cute
0:50 Her voice very good
This is so good omg I love Jo Yuri
I would shake the hell out of my legs if bada was to judge me that close