Except EDGE who's probably unhappy. For context, someone commented something about Red Raptor (I don't remember what it was but I think it was positive) on the EDGE channel and then EDGE came in and called Red Raptor a transphobe for no particular reason.
@@tirefish Unfortunately, TH-cam doesn't allow for link posting, but there are some screen grabs of some comments that he's made, along with alluding to it in a few of his videos, and following a few infamous right wing politicians on Twitter.
@@Carlos-bz5ooNo it is not. Sounds like you didn't even watch the video. It has _some_ inaccuracies, but very few compared to most paleo-docs, and extremely few for it's time.
@@yissibiiyte That's because this person doesn't cover the inaccuracies in the video for some reason. Here's some choicy ones: - Dimorphodon is depicted as an aerial insectivore. In reality it could barely fly nd hunted on the ground. - Tapejara (which should be Tupandactylus really) is depicted as seabird like when in reality it foraged on fruits and plants - Darwinopterus is depicted as an aerial hunter when it hunted small insects in real life. Among many, MANY others
@@Carlos-bz5oo all of those points reflect recent developments that the documentary can not be blamed for not knowing at the time. Tupandactylus species were only split off from tapejara after this came out. Hawking behaviour for darwinopterus was originally believed before it was adjusted into a terrestrial insectivore. Same goes for dimorphodon.
@@yissibiiyte All of the things I cited were discovered roughly two to four years before (an entire DECADE in the case of Tupandactylus). Please do research before defending inaccurate works
Ah yes Rodan. The Largest Pterosaur to ever live. Loved this doc tho, I remember watching it a while ago and seein Quetz being bumped up to 50 ft was craaazy xD
When I think of my favourite Pterosaur designs in media, I think of; Prehistoric Planet’s Azhdarchids Primeval’s Pteranodon Walking with Dinosaurs’ Tropeognathus I would also put in there Flying Monsters’ Tapajara, that to me is the canon Tapajara.
Yeah I’ve noticed Attenborough doesn’t seem to like calling birds dinosaurs. Even in Prehistoric Planet he weirdly said “there are dinosaurs here too” implying that the birds weren’t dinosaurs. Maybe because he thought about them as separate most of his life and at his age it’s hard to break habits
Well I mean they're still not dinosaurs by most ways people use the word dinosaur Most average people use "dinosaur" as a paraphyletic grouping that excludes birds incorrectly that is but they still do it anyways
@@kitchengun1175 But Attenborough is a world renowned nature expert and really shouldn’t be making laymen mistakes. When an authoritative documentary screws up it’s verbiage it confuses the audience
I think the reason why Dimorphodon has those skin skirts disconnected from the tail is because if you look closely those skirts are really close to the floor when there on the ground, so if it was attached to the tail then that would mean Dimorphodon would have dragged its tail, and that shit is unexceptionable in a twenty first century documentary starring sorta kinda dinosaurs, so the animators might have given them that to not have Kangaroo Dimorphodon’s
Glad to see this series back, but I'm a bit surprised you didn't mention one of my biggest annoyances with this particular doc: the Darwinopterus segment where it's hunting Anchiornis. Mark Witton covered this a while back, but basically wukongopterids like Darwinopterus are a lot smaller than shown here and don't fit as being bird-of-prey-like hunters.
So glad you covered up this cool documentary. Hey, do you think one day you could review two of the Dino Lab documentaries, Last Day of the Dinosaurs, Prehistoric Assassins, and maybe even Dinosaurs: The Final Day with David Attenborough? If you ever check them out that is.
emm... Red Raptor Writes did review for Prehistoric Planet 2 but I still wait for Last Day of the Dinosaurs where we got ugly Quetzalcoatlus and copy of T.rex from JP franchise but with changes
I am happy to see this one get covered. Not only does the subject matter of the documentary make it a stand-out, but I also saw an ad for it in an old Nat Geo kids magazine when I was young, but never was exposed to the actual movie itself. So its great to see it get some focus.
I kinda want to see Rick look at the river monsters episode where Jeremy looks at prehistoric fish. It may not be as long as a dedicated Dino doc, but there is still some interesting stuff in there
16:37 If anything, it was the exact opposite. Pterosaurs largely kept birds small. Like how mammals were largely kept small by the non-avian dinosaurs. Both had their exceptions, but for the most part, birds and mammals were the underdogs to the pterosaurs and non-avian dinosaurs. It was only after the KPG that mammals and avian dinosaurs were able to dominate the land and sky respectively.
I remember watching this documentary multiple times at my city’s museum, they had a huge dome imax screen (considered one of the best imax screens in the world btw☝️🤓) in the theater where they played various documentaries, so you could imagine how impressive it looked. They would announce they were showing it from time to time and I was always there to watch it.
Love your videos, some of the best Prehistoric content on TH-cam. You should do an accuracy review of Ark and the Darkness, lol. I'm sure you'd have a fun time with that one.
Another Attenborough documentary I recommend is Lost Worlds Vanished Lives from the 80s, basically about the workings of palaeontology in general. You'll need to add back the outdated section. P.S. if you review movies again, please do an accuracy review of The Lost World 1925 or the Rite of Spring segment from Fantasia. I'd love to see what balance you strike with these.
You should have a look at the Minecraft mod “prehistoric nature” it has over 800 prehistoric animals from the pre-cambrian all the way to the Jurassic at the moment the Jurassic is still being worked on so yea but they are going until the present day the creatures are as accurate as they can be within the restrictions of Minecraft dand they will update animals and there models if new research comes out on them with noticeable differences
While you’re at it, you can also look at the Fossils and Archeology Revival mod, which is about bringing back prehistoric plants and animals, as well as discovering ancient human artifacts.
I hope he will one day do a review on Dinosaur with Stephen Fry, I know you reacted to it but I hope you do a review and where it belongs in the F tier category and I also hope you do a review on Amazing Dinoworld 2
It’s so obvious that the Jurassic World staff googled Dimorphodon, and this guy was the first thing that showed up and they went, yeah alright whatever.
Seeing as we are on the topic of Pterosaurs; I’m sad to say, but for every high there must be a low. I introduced to you; Sky Monsters a National Geographic documentary on Pterosaurs that came out in 2005.
For some reason when I saw this in theaters, it came out in 2012 and I have to say it’s a really good documentary film out one day I can get it on Blu-ray or DVD. By the way, this isn’t the first National Geographic Terrace or documentary. There’s a documentary called sky monsters they came out back in 2005 has some inaccuracies here and there but I still enjoyed it as a kid.
Chatterjee also thought that quetzalcoatlus ran on its hind limbs to gain speed for take off. Former professor of kinetic called him Chattering Chatterjee
Fun Fact @RedRaptorWrites a recent study suggests that feathers might be ancestral to Archosauria as a whole as the study used genetics to transform the scales of Crocodilians into primitive feathers.
Not sure if you meant to say that quetz has the dimensions of biplanes, because biplanes are a type of plane that has two pairs of wings stacked on top of each other
Could you review "David Attenborough's Natural History Museum Alive"? I saw it on Netflix way back when and thought it was good. That documentary is what taught me about the New Zealand moa.
Hey Red Raptor I would love if you could review Animal Armageddon from 2009! That series had some real whacky animal designs that I think would be hilarious to hear you tear apart. Also curious how much of the accuracy it holds up
22:14 I would revise that tier list in the accuracy rankings a lot. Have Prehistoric Planet at 1 or slightly below Titanoboa, knock Walking with Beasts to C- and March of the Dinosaurs to D, knock The Truth about Killer Dinos down to B+, knock Chased by Sea Monsters and Walking with Monsters both down below Life on our Planet, and put Dinosaur Revolution higher than The Truth about Killer Dinos. No objections with the Fs, they deserve it.
Great video! Amazing information about pterosaurs. I was confused by the pronunciation of tapejara’s name, especially after hearing they’re from Brazil. But the name isn’t portuguese, it comes from a language related to guarani. If anyone knows the pronunciation of this language, could you let me know how to pronounce this name(I know the name was pronounced correctly in English)
there is another paleo documentary made by National Geographic that covers pterosaurs that I remember seeing (albiet much more clearly than this one) called "Flying Sky Monsters", yes that is a similar title lmao
there is another national geographic pterosaur documentary from 2006 could sky monsters if you are interested in knowing and doing a future Accuracy review
I thought one of the hypothesis as to why pterosaur diversity is lower during the late cretaceous is that the juvenile Azdharchids would have outcompeted the other pterosaurs. Does this claim have merit or has it been rejected?
One Dino Doc that I've found in a list is Dinotasia. I haven't seen it, or I just don't remember it with all the ones I've seen. An interesting one that I've seen is Dinosaur 13, about the discovery of the T-Rex Sue. Not one for a review, just a very interesting documentary.
My only personal criticism of pp quetzalcoatlus mobbing the tyrannosaurus would simply to have a more than two to drive it off. I just feel tyrannosaurus would stand its ground against just two like how it takes a good number of hyena to drive a lion off a kill rather than just one or two
Dimorphodon is a sadly inherently ugly critter Also I do wonder why none of the gliding reptiles of the Triassic never evolved flight but the pterosaurs did
Oh another negative you forgot to bring up is portraying Tapejarids as Seagoing when it's generally believed they were frugivorous and lived further inland due to their beak anatomy being more similar to birds like hornbills and parrots
When the world needed him the most, he returned
Except EDGE who's probably unhappy.
For context, someone commented something about Red Raptor (I don't remember what it was but I think it was positive) on the EDGE channel and then EDGE came in and called Red Raptor a transphobe for no particular reason.
@@theangrysuchomimus5163 Unfortunately, there's from truth to that....
Screen grabs of his comments are on Twitter.
@@theangrysuchomimus5163 Unfortunately, there's some truth to that.....
@@michaeldeak5727 Explain
@@tirefish Unfortunately, TH-cam doesn't allow for link posting, but there are some screen grabs of some comments that he's made, along with alluding to it in a few of his videos, and following a few infamous right wing politicians on Twitter.
Flying Monsters is peak. The pterosaurs finally get their well deserved documentary.
Shame its rife with inaccuracies
@@Carlos-bz5ooNo it is not. Sounds like you didn't even watch the video.
It has _some_ inaccuracies, but very few compared to most paleo-docs, and extremely few for it's time.
@@yissibiiyte That's because this person doesn't cover the inaccuracies in the video for some reason. Here's some choicy ones:
- Dimorphodon is depicted as an aerial insectivore. In reality it could barely fly nd hunted on the ground.
- Tapejara (which should be Tupandactylus really) is depicted as seabird like when in reality it foraged on fruits and plants
- Darwinopterus is depicted as an aerial hunter when it hunted small insects in real life.
Among many, MANY others
@@Carlos-bz5oo all of those points reflect recent developments that the documentary can not be blamed for not knowing at the time.
Tupandactylus species were only split off from tapejara after this came out. Hawking behaviour for darwinopterus was originally believed before it was adjusted into a terrestrial insectivore. Same goes for dimorphodon.
@@yissibiiyte All of the things I cited were discovered roughly two to four years before (an entire DECADE in the case of Tupandactylus). Please do research before defending inaccurate works
Ah yes Rodan. The Largest Pterosaur to ever live. Loved this doc tho, I remember watching it a while ago and seein Quetz being bumped up to 50 ft was craaazy xD
Hey Jimbo. Nice to see you commenting on other people's vjdeos. Glad to see you're not CONSTANTLY overworking yourself❤
20:39 glad to see Rodan get a mention in a pterosaur documentary review
When I think of my favourite Pterosaur designs in media, I think of;
Prehistoric Planet’s Azhdarchids
Primeval’s Pteranodon
Walking with Dinosaurs’ Tropeognathus
I would also put in there Flying Monsters’ Tapajara, that to me is the canon Tapajara.
The Child-snatching Barbarydactylus was also pretty cool
It’s about time we got a pterosaur documentary on this channel.
Yesss I’ve been waiting for another one of these reviews! I binged all of the other ones earlier this year and was craving more
Yeah I’ve noticed Attenborough doesn’t seem to like calling birds dinosaurs. Even in Prehistoric Planet he weirdly said “there are dinosaurs here too” implying that the birds weren’t dinosaurs. Maybe because he thought about them as separate most of his life and at his age it’s hard to break habits
Well I mean they're still not dinosaurs by most ways people use the word dinosaur
Most average people use "dinosaur" as a paraphyletic grouping that excludes birds
incorrectly that is but they still do it anyways
@@kitchengun1175 But Attenborough is a world renowned nature expert and really shouldn’t be making laymen mistakes. When an authoritative documentary screws up it’s verbiage it confuses the audience
@@LoudmouthReviews no one's perfect ; even David Attenborough
I think the reason why Dimorphodon has those skin skirts disconnected from the tail is because if you look closely those skirts are really close to the floor when there on the ground, so if it was attached to the tail then that would mean Dimorphodon would have dragged its tail, and that shit is unexceptionable in a twenty first century documentary starring sorta kinda dinosaurs, so the animators might have given them that to not have Kangaroo Dimorphodon’s
Glad to see this series back, but I'm a bit surprised you didn't mention one of my biggest annoyances with this particular doc: the Darwinopterus segment where it's hunting Anchiornis. Mark Witton covered this a while back, but basically wukongopterids like Darwinopterus are a lot smaller than shown here and don't fit as being bird-of-prey-like hunters.
So glad you covered up this cool documentary. Hey, do you think one day you could review two of the Dino Lab documentaries, Last Day of the Dinosaurs, Prehistoric Assassins, and maybe even Dinosaurs: The Final Day with David Attenborough? If you ever check them out that is.
emm... Red Raptor Writes did review for Prehistoric Planet 2 but I still wait for Last Day of the Dinosaurs where we got ugly Quetzalcoatlus and copy of T.rex from JP franchise but with changes
I am happy to see this one get covered. Not only does the subject matter of the documentary make it a stand-out, but I also saw an ad for it in an old Nat Geo kids magazine when I was young, but never was exposed to the actual movie itself. So its great to see it get some focus.
8:52 The Tapejara here remind me of the Sail People from All Tomorrows.
emm... it could be Tupandactylus imperator because it had that large crest + it was probably inspiration for creators
Finally red raptor writes return for another prehistoric doc is Flying monsters 3D documentary from David Attenborough and about Pterosaurs
W collaboration fr, W narrator and W production company.
Bro just had the best come back
I kinda want to see Rick look at the river monsters episode where Jeremy looks at prehistoric fish. It may not be as long as a dedicated Dino doc, but there is still some interesting stuff in there
16:37
If anything, it was the exact opposite.
Pterosaurs largely kept birds small.
Like how mammals were largely kept small by the non-avian dinosaurs.
Both had their exceptions, but for the most part, birds and mammals were the underdogs to the pterosaurs and non-avian dinosaurs.
It was only after the KPG that mammals and avian dinosaurs were able to dominate the land and sky respectively.
You mean to say that the Pterosaur's wings don't extend from the fourth finger to the flanks but instead, it extends from the fourth finger to ankle?
Could you please review natural history museum alive it was one of my favorites
also love your content, keep it up
Me on sister's wedding: 🤡
Me when new dino doc review: 🗿
I remember watching this documentary multiple times at my city’s museum, they had a huge dome imax screen (considered one of the best imax screens in the world btw☝️🤓) in the theater where they played various documentaries, so you could imagine how impressive it looked. They would announce they were showing it from time to time and I was always there to watch it.
This documentary furthered my interest in pterosaurs. Glad it’s getting talked about.
Love your videos, some of the best Prehistoric content on TH-cam. You should do an accuracy review of Ark and the Darkness, lol. I'm sure you'd have a fun time with that one.
Babe! Wake up Red Raptor Writes posted a new video!
Man i wish Pterosaurs survived the kpg.
Finally a post i needed this so much 🔥🔥🔥🙏🙏🙏
Another Attenborough documentary I recommend is Lost Worlds Vanished Lives from the 80s, basically about the workings of palaeontology in general. You'll need to add back the outdated section. P.S. if you review movies again, please do an accuracy review of The Lost World 1925 or the Rite of Spring segment from Fantasia. I'd love to see what balance you strike with these.
I think Dimorphdon flew just like a bat with hyper active wing flapping.
The legend returns!
You should have a look at the Minecraft mod “prehistoric nature” it has over 800 prehistoric animals from the pre-cambrian all the way to the Jurassic at the moment the Jurassic is still being worked on so yea but they are going until the present day the creatures are as accurate as they can be within the restrictions of Minecraft dand they will update animals and there models if new research comes out on them with noticeable differences
While you’re at it, you can also look at the Fossils and Archeology Revival mod, which is about bringing back prehistoric plants and animals, as well as discovering ancient human artifacts.
@@storiesimprovelives775it's a good mod but nowhere near as comprehensive as prehistoric nature
@@budget-cloaker True, Prehistoric Nature has some strengths over Fossils and Archeology, but I still really like both of them.
I hope he will one day do a review on Dinosaur with Stephen Fry, I know you reacted to it but I hope you do a review and where it belongs in the F tier category and I also hope you do a review on Amazing Dinoworld 2
The most accurate depiction of pterosaurs I've ever seen
Have you seen David Attenborough’s Natural History Museum Alive? The way he presents the fossils reminds of that.
It’s so obvious that the Jurassic World staff googled Dimorphodon, and this guy was the first thing that showed up and they went, yeah alright whatever.
Seeing as we are on the topic of Pterosaurs; I’m sad to say, but for every high there must be a low.
I introduced to you; Sky Monsters a National Geographic documentary on Pterosaurs that came out in 2005.
David Attenborough in documentary’s in the last 10 years insert pictures of him me: you haven’t aged a day
For some reason when I saw this in theaters, it came out in 2012 and I have to say it’s a really good documentary film out one day I can get it on Blu-ray or DVD. By the way, this isn’t the first National Geographic Terrace or documentary. There’s a documentary called sky monsters they came out back in 2005 has some inaccuracies here and there but I still enjoyed it as a kid.
Pteranodon deserves its own documentary
Chatterjee also thought that quetzalcoatlus ran on its hind limbs to gain speed for take off. Former professor of kinetic called him Chattering Chatterjee
12:10 I miss the old days when Dimorphodon was portrayed as a puffin and not a weird, big-headed flying rat.
This is awesome. Maybe the next Dino doc could be Final day of the Dinosaurs by David Attenboughro. Maybe Dinosaurs with steven Fry, immediately F----
This documentary is what made me interested in pterosaurs
So this is where Jurassic World got their idea for the Dimorphodon design.
I love pterosaurs so much! Such weird and beautiful animals
Damn, I forgot about this channel
*Shame on me*
I remember watching this documentary film in New York at the American Museum of Natural History.
awesome video
you should do an accuracy review on "When Dinosaurs Ruled" (1999)
You need to do Jeff Corwin's Giant Monsters. It's not great accuracy wise.
Fun Fact @RedRaptorWrites a recent study suggests that feathers might be ancestral to Archosauria as a whole as the study used genetics to transform the scales of Crocodilians into primitive feathers.
the study NEVER suggested that archosauria was ancestrally feathered, it just discovered that feathers, were derived scales
@@miguelisaurusbruh1158 Ah ok
@@miguelisaurusbruh1158 Wasn't that already known? Even before the study, feathers were more often than not thought to be modified scales.
@@theangrysuchomimus5163 yes, but in the study they actually genetically modified scales into weird pseudofeathers, honestly amazing
@@KadenSlinker it'd be cool tho
After extinction, dinosaurs have returned (nah just my boy red raptor )
Another Doc to add to the watch list!
If you want to see an old dino doc I would recommend Dinosaur! Narrated by Christopher Reeve, or PBS The Dinosaurs!
I remember going to the website for this one and I love the music that plays when you're on it but I don't know what the music's name.
Very good review. Maybe do "When Crocs Ate Dinosaurs" next?
Animal Armageddon for next documentary?
Not sure if you meant to say that quetz has the dimensions of biplanes, because biplanes are a type of plane that has two pairs of wings stacked on top of each other
Watch the Channel 4 documentary series "Extinct" or Land of lost monsters/monsters we met next.
Will you do an Australian paleo-documentary “Megafauna: What Killed Australia’s Giants?” review next time?
Been meaning to watch this documentary
Could you review "David Attenborough's Natural History Museum Alive"? I saw it on Netflix way back when and thought it was good.
That documentary is what taught me about the New Zealand moa.
Where can I watch this documentary? It sounds very good!!
I think you can still find it on TH-cam.
Dailymotion too
Let’s go bros back
Yes once metric is used to get to the moon I'll accept it (maybe)
Hey Red Raptor I would love if you could review Animal Armageddon from 2009! That series had some real whacky animal designs that I think would be hilarious to hear you tear apart. Also curious how much of the accuracy it holds up
50 Feet Long Wingspan? That makes the JWD Quetzalcoatlus Blush
22:14 I would revise that tier list in the accuracy rankings a lot. Have Prehistoric Planet at 1 or slightly below Titanoboa, knock Walking with Beasts to C- and March of the Dinosaurs to D, knock The Truth about Killer Dinos down to B+, knock Chased by Sea Monsters and Walking with Monsters both down below Life on our Planet, and put Dinosaur Revolution higher than The Truth about Killer Dinos. No objections with the Fs, they deserve it.
Kinda wished this was a spinoff of Sea Monsters a Prehistoric Adventure
Pterosaurs aka birds but with more teeth and beak variation
Great video! Amazing information about pterosaurs. I was confused by the pronunciation of tapejara’s name, especially after hearing they’re from Brazil. But the name isn’t portuguese, it comes from a language related to guarani. If anyone knows the pronunciation of this language, could you let me know how to pronounce this name(I know the name was pronounced correctly in English)
there is another paleo documentary made by National Geographic that covers pterosaurs that I remember seeing (albiet much more clearly than this one) called "Flying Sky Monsters", yes that is a similar title lmao
there is another national geographic pterosaur documentary from 2006 could sky monsters if you are interested in knowing and doing a future Accuracy review
Hi there I’m making a book about prehistoric animals so I need some ideas for pterosaurs ideas I already did hatzegopteryx and quetzacloatlus
Could you one day do The Last Day of the Dinosaurs from 2010? I remember watching that film a lot.
Love the video! Would you ever do a review of “Dinosaur Apocalypse” by the BBC?
YES MY FAV PTERO DOC! LETS FLAPPING GO!!!!
I'm surprised you didn't mention the Tapejaras being depicted living in Coastal Enviromnents (its a negative)
I thought one of the hypothesis as to why pterosaur diversity is lower during the late cretaceous is that the juvenile Azdharchids would have outcompeted the other pterosaurs. Does this claim have merit or has it been rejected?
On that, I would have to do more research. I'm not sure where that idea stands right now.
One Dino Doc that I've found in a list is Dinotasia. I haven't seen it, or I just don't remember it with all the ones I've seen.
An interesting one that I've seen is Dinosaur 13, about the discovery of the T-Rex Sue. Not one for a review, just a very interesting documentary.
Gotta find this gem and watch it !
The Quetzalcoatlus Design in This Documentary is Decent, though the Crest looks a Little Wonky
what about chaos theory and cc season 5
I disagree with pterosaurs not being monsters, monster is a relative term, anything can be a monster if viewed from the correct lense of perspective
Like a cat to a canary
@@fablelost2642 yes you get it
15:40 Literally shows arboreal evolutionary trajectory after saying arboreal pathway is incorrect.
Can you try to review dinosaur apocalypse?
20:46 this is probably wrong but what about arambourgiria or would that be the tallest
My only personal criticism of pp quetzalcoatlus mobbing the tyrannosaurus would simply to have a more than two to drive it off. I just feel tyrannosaurus would stand its ground against just two like how it takes a good number of hyena to drive a lion off a kill rather than just one or two
21:32 Avatar 2011 defeat theme meme
will you make video on this documentary that no one knows its called Prehistoric Dallas
I thought _Teleocrater_ was a dinosauromorph. Was it reclassified?
Red Raptor you can do this with the series prehistoric 2009 please
Ayo anybody remember the cringy documentary "Tyrannosaurus Sex"? RRW should do that one next lol
Dimorphodon is a sadly inherently ugly critter
Also I do wonder why none of the gliding reptiles of the Triassic never evolved flight but the pterosaurs did
Let's go
Do Monsters We Met next.
Man do trex autopsy plz 🦖🔪
Next review suggestion:Dinosaurs of Antarctica
Oh another negative you forgot to bring up is portraying Tapejarids as Seagoing when it's generally believed they were frugivorous and lived further inland due to their beak anatomy being more similar to birds like hornbills and parrots
Please do a review of Dinosaur with Stephen Fry
8:26 just a small thing in true is tupandactlyus