@@quintissaviengvong2371 it was like the prime slim era where he released songs like kim and kill you plus the some things he said on real slim shady too. His edgy side didn't sit that right with critics and general public too except for the younger gen
@@mlodylube Considering that we're almost halfway through this decade it's safe to say that it will defenitely remain as one of the very best albums if not the best of the 2020s
@@butterytomatoes747 the Grammys don’t care about actually going for the most critically acclaimed. They go for popularity with good picks coming from the mainstream. Eminem was in the mainstream during those times.
Or the culture, Eminem would be unknown rapper if he was black, it's the truth, erase the image and purely listen to the music especially early on and you'll find this out when comparing him to other rappers very similar from that era the only thing that makes him stand out is his race
@@spade-night I’d have to disagree. What made him stand out was his bombastic personality and pen game. He was different and that drew a lot of attention to him once Dre gave him a chance. The culture respects him nowadays aside from those old heads and people who hated him back in the day for being white who still hate him for being white. Kendrick Lamar and Tyler, The Creator were heavily influenced by Eminem both citing him as an inspiration. You don’t have to love his catalog, but you have to admit his impact and generational status.
@@THEOsu-bu1syall the King disease were good, IWW was very good, stillmatic was also a good album, he never did albuns below average, but illmatic is just the best album of all time
Nas was actually a teenager when he made most of Illmatic, because there were some lead singles to the album and 20yo is just how old he was on the release date
Ice Cube - 16, wrote tracks for Eazy Duz It - 19, Straight Outta Compton (NWA) - 20, Amerikkka's most wanted - 21, Death Certificate - 23, The Predator
I know you stans won’t believe this but not everybody connects with the weird trailer park pill poppin horrorcore side of rap. I say that and think it’s easily his best record. It’s kinda polarizing in many ways though. Like that whole kill your mother arc he was on is weird to a large percentage of rap fans
Honestly as a musician it's pretty comforting to know that super famous musicians have made their best works in their 30s, I'm only 25 and i often get insecure about having missed some imaginary window of opportunity, but said window obviously doesnt exist. People can make incredible art at any age.
@@Jay-xl3ln except Cole’s pen is better now than it’s ever been and he’s matured significantly. Listening to 2014 FHD was cool when I was a freshman in high school. Listening to it now, it’s got a lot of angsty and corny tracks that aren’t fully fleshed out. Nothing wrong with that, but quality wise, Chance the Rapper had 10 Day and Acid Rap, both of which do what 2014 does but better.
@@SirZubo how is that a joke? By valid, I mean I wouldn't be shocked if someone gave it a 77. 75-80 is a good range for NWTS. A joke would be if I said 'Total Xanarchy is the most influential, and amazing album of all time'.
@@A-trainfan345 dawg, NWTS is a great album. Drake's second best. I may prefer Kendrick, but that doesn't mean I hate Drake(as an artist). Also, in what universe is a 75-80 a bad score?
This is why I like critics more than hip hop fans sometimes because they understand at least that Cole is mid. Even if they kinda overrate that Drake album and were too harsh on Eminem
@@senzangakhonajere1994 I am not saying he’s *terrible* he’s just fine. That’s what Ive always felt about Cole. He’s good at rhyming, and I like some of his beat choices, but I’ve never felt like he really had much to say that other rappers hadn’t said better, funnier, more poetically, yknow. It’s not really a hate, I mean mid in the truest sense here. He’s not bad, he’s just middle of the road, though I liked the off season, some of 4YEO, and no role modelz; I just find a lot of his output kinda lacking a real voice, as compared to someone like Jay Z or Kendrick who both seem to have influenced him heavily, even though I know his career kind of came around the same time as Kendrick. So I mean, he’s good sometimes really good, I just think the *average* j cole song is just not as good as all the people he gets compared to, peak hip hop etc
Well if you ask me... its like that for most legends even soke shit from Dot is gassed up way to much... to a level now where one is not allowed to say otherwise... The thing you see a making jcole mid... is what ppo were celebrating fro Dot on his last ulbum with so much heart n emotions... I'm using Kendrick coz is the one we are forced to believe has a perfect discography n what not... but overall I get your point..
@@senzangakhonajere1994 i mean I think they overrated damn, and section 80 just hasn’t aged that well to me in EVERY song, (some are great) But GKMC->TPAB is a ridiculous run
It ain't hard to tell. I excel, then prevail The mic is contacted, I attract clientele My mic check is life or death, breathin' a sniper's breath Exhale the yellow smoke of Buddha through richeous steps. Deep like shinin', sparkle like a diamond Sneak a uzi on the island in my army jacket linin' Hit the earth like a comet, invasion Nas is like the afro-centric asian: half man, half amazin' 'Cause in my physical I can express through song Delete stress like Motrin, and extend strong Drink Moet with Medusa, give her shotguns in hell From the spliff that I lift and inhale, it ain't hard to tell
Dead presidents is such a good song it was my first actual introduction to jay z other than ye and my best moment is when i was listening to the blonded radio on gta v and i heard all of dead presidents into crack rock and i just stayed there where i was with a good view and listened to the two classics
These scores are proof that critics know nothing about what they judge and their opinions are worth nothing. All they do is suck the soul out of music.
![Kanye West - On Sight [2009 Roblox Cover]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vo1-rf3l7-o/mqdefault.jpg)
Nas making that at 20 is insane, truly a genius
And he started writing it at 16
Wrote it at 16 🐐
GLAZING
@@leonconnelly5303nope, it's a 10/10 album
@@leonconnelly5303you do It lmao
joey was 17 when he made 1999
Defo his best as well
what did the critics rate it?
@@thismightbealter 76 but the community rated it 85
Doesn't matter, 1999 is amazing for a 17 year old and no doubt a really good album @@thismightbealter
@@thismightbealterits rated 76 sadly, Def 85+ without a doubt
6ix9ine jumpscare 💀
39/100 is crazy for your best album ever
i knew he was bad but never this dogshit💀
yo, are you the real jN??
real
Rat jumpscare*
"don't talk about my mums yo"
- MF DOOM
Sometimes you rhyme quick sometimes you rhyme slow
@@Kailoren37and vice versa, like a nice slice of verse pie
Hit it on the first try, villain, the worst guy
Spot hot tracks like spot a pair of fat asses
Spot hot tracks like spot a pair of fat asses, shots from the scotch out of square shot glasses
Mmlp and off season at 70 is criminal
The shit on mmlp was super controversial
Off season is in the low 90's atleast and so is mmlp
Critics don’t love J Cole.
There’s a reason for that.
@@Cabbage-editsI would put offseasons more mid to high 80s and MMLP is mid nineties fs
@@MrPolitical2 understandable, but for me, off season just sounds too good to be under 90,im deadass glazing
Everyone else 😎👍
Lil pump 😐
6ix9ine 💀
@Anthony_Or_Yesnoif your high
@@penjeshAgree lol😂
69 has a few good songs but lil pump...
+ emidnem 🤡
bot
How is Eminem only six more than Lil Pump?
Cause of controversial shit he said probably
On mmlp?
@@quintissaviengvong2371 it was like the prime slim era where he released songs like kim and kill you plus the some things he said on real slim shady too. His edgy side didn't sit that right with critics and general public too except for the younger gen
Have you heard lil pump?
@@quintissaviengvong2371 He recieved good reviews due to being new. Age has changed, modern reviewers are much more open
Cole, Denzel and especially Wayne deserve higher scores
No respectfully, nothing to ground breaking and wouldn’t be fair to sit up on top with the other albums , I’ll make a pass for Wayne tho
Em too
@@uglysegura9616sorry but denzel curry does deserve atleast a 85 for mmesyf, the best album of the 2020s so far and absolutely amazing
@@mlodylube Considering that we're almost halfway through this decade it's safe to say that it will defenitely remain as one of the very best albums if not the best of the 2020s
Denzel already Already 84 that is not a perfect album really Eminem and Drake deserve better ones as well as J. Cole and Wayne
Madvillainy only at 89 is absolutely ridicolous
It's easily in my top 3 favourite albums at the moment
Tripping off the beat kinda, dripping off the meat grinder
@@orinpatterson9993 heat niner, pimping, stripping, soft sweet minor
Professional Music Critics in the 2000s are too hard to please because of their higher standard in the artistry of music...
@@jisellesharmaignequintao5804 Ik, Y2k was goated for music (not the ice spice album)
Eminem was never loved by critics ever.
dude won so many grammys, come on
@@butterytomatoes747 the Grammys don’t care about actually going for the most critically acclaimed. They go for popularity with good picks coming from the mainstream. Eminem was in the mainstream during those times.
Deserved
Or the culture, Eminem would be unknown rapper if he was black, it's the truth, erase the image and purely listen to the music especially early on and you'll find this out when comparing him to other rappers very similar from that era the only thing that makes him stand out is his race
@@spade-night I’d have to disagree. What made him stand out was his bombastic personality and pen game. He was different and that drew a lot of attention to him once Dre gave him a chance. The culture respects him nowadays aside from those old heads and people who hated him back in the day for being white who still hate him for being white. Kendrick Lamar and Tyler, The Creator were heavily influenced by Eminem both citing him as an inspiration. You don’t have to love his catalog, but you have to admit his impact and generational status.
Imagine creating fucking ILLMATIC at age 20. GOAT no doubt.
Peaking at 20 is crazy. Nothing else he did reached Illmatic level
@@THEOsu-bu1syI liked KD3 and it was written
@@THEOsu-bu1sylisten to it was written. Also ig you could say he peaked at 20 but it’s still absolutely insane
@@THEOsu-bu1syCrazy that no rapper in the world has or will ever be on the level that Nas was on at 20…
@@THEOsu-bu1syall the King disease were good, IWW was very good, stillmatic was also a good album, he never did albuns below average, but illmatic is just the best album of all time
The off season over 2014 forest hill drive is crazy
No its not that crazy, 2014 was a bigger commercial success but its not a better album
It’s literally better in every way because forest hill drive is corny as hell
2014 FHD has not aged well. Off season is a way better version (and better reflection) of Cole.
@@justthetwoofus.I liked maybe 1 or 2 songs off of it it sounds corny to me, 2014 forest hill dr was way better
That’s the nostalgia talking. Off season his best body of work
How is the off season not even 10 points above lil pump
Lil Pump self title isn’t the worst album ever, mid to low 60s is a perfect spot
@@WilliamChiara yeah but the off season is a lot better
@@shancrd2 100%, The Off Season my favorite Cole album
I prefer FHD.
@@shancrd210 points is a lot better it’s not some ground breaking album
Nas was actually a teenager when he made most of Illmatic, because there were some lead singles to the album and 20yo is just how old he was on the release date
Damn only 89 for Madvillainy huh? I always thought it was higher.
I think he might have used the user score instead of the meta score
Lollipop still makes you feel like a ⭐️ till this day mann those 06’-08 years were the shh
Ice Cube
- 16, wrote tracks for Eazy Duz It
- 19, Straight Outta Compton (NWA)
- 20, Amerikkka's most wanted
- 21, Death Certificate
- 23, The Predator
Also dropped Lethal Injection at 24, then co-wrote the movie Friday at 25. Cube was a legend before 30
WE COULVE BEEN TOGETHER SLIM, THINK ABOUT IT 🗣🗣🔥🔥
YOU RUINED IT NOW, I HOPE YOU CAN'T SLEEP AND YOU DREAM ABOUT IT 🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
How does mmlp have a critic score of 73
Eminem said the critics wouldn't like it in the album
True @@Dev-em7ow
I know you stans won’t believe this but not everybody connects with the weird trailer park pill poppin horrorcore side of rap. I say that and think it’s easily his best record. It’s kinda polarizing in many ways though. Like that whole kill your mother arc he was on is weird to a large percentage of rap fans
@@chiarosuburekeni9325 still amazing, tho. I'm not even a stan.
You realise eminem isnt rapping a white trash style. But a detroit style. His friends are even qeirder and more horrorcore @chiarosuburekeni9325
Honestly as a musician it's pretty comforting to know that super famous musicians have made their best works in their 30s, I'm only 25 and i often get insecure about having missed some imaginary window of opportunity, but said window obviously doesnt exist. People can make incredible art at any age.
chief keef made finally rich at 17
WALKIN WITH MY BACK TO THE SUN
KEEP MY HEAD TO THE SKY
the off season as cole’s best album is fucking insane
It literally is his best album, no corny goofy ass lyrics
@@PasteurizedLettuce😂
@@PasteurizedLettucelmao the off season sucks compared to 2014
@@Jay-xl3ln except Cole’s pen is better now than it’s ever been and he’s matured significantly. Listening to 2014 FHD was cool when I was a freshman in high school. Listening to it now, it’s got a lot of angsty and corny tracks that aren’t fully fleshed out. Nothing wrong with that, but quality wise, Chance the Rapper had 10 Day and Acid Rap, both of which do what 2014 does but better.
@@PasteurizedLettucetypical white take
Shyheim (one of the most underrated rappers imo) was 13 when he made Rugged Child
Madvillainy at 89 is wild
TPAB another classic CD yuh
Melt my eyes only being an 84 is crazy
I saw some of the reviews, and they had to have been fake
to have one of the best rap albums of all time as your debut must be amazing
Nothin was the same at 77 is insane
the carter III to the off-season transition is crazy
Madvillainy at 89 is insane
Man I better be doing shit when I'm 27 😂
27 is the magic year
eminem was underated, critics just couldnt stand him just like he said in "The Real Slim Shady"
Bro tried sliding in pump 💀
Shows you how much critics can be disconnected with eminems highest score being so low
The late 20s early 30s is the prime of a rapper. Seasoned to the game more mature and confident.
TPAB is such a perfect album
cap
@@fateenergy1360 Cap. - x - = +
@@fateenergy1360You haven't listened to the album
@@ccspdhda he's prob a Drake glazer lol.
Fr 2nd listen is the best music experience ever
wayne at 80!? cole at 76!? EM AT 73!?? this is why we don’t listen to critics.
NWTS getting a 77, MMLP getting 73 both actual crimes that are death sentence worthy
NWTS getting a 77 is valid. However mmlp deserves minimum 90.
Lol good joke kid@@idkimbored139
@@idkimbored139”everything Drake makes is bad because Kendrick is better” 🤓☝️
@@SirZubo how is that a joke? By valid, I mean I wouldn't be shocked if someone gave it a 77. 75-80 is a good range for NWTS. A joke would be if I said 'Total Xanarchy is the most influential, and amazing album of all time'.
@@A-trainfan345 dawg, NWTS is a great album. Drake's second best. I may prefer Kendrick, but that doesn't mean I hate Drake(as an artist). Also, in what universe is a 75-80 a bad score?
"I like ice cream"
-MF DOOM
Who is also still waiting for "Dead Homes" from Kendrick Lamar?
The off season should be atleast a 90 maybe higher but mbdtf should be atleast high 90s only 91 is crazy low
73 for MMLP is wild
Madvillainy wasn't strictly MF DOOM. It was MF DOOM and Madlib as a group called Madvillain.
DOOM is still the rapper. Even though Madlib technically co-formed Madvillain, he's just the producer, so not really considered.
This is why I like critics more than hip hop fans sometimes because they understand at least that Cole is mid. Even if they kinda overrate that Drake album and were too harsh on Eminem
Give it a second listen... mid is like saying you have a problem or something. I understand its your opinion
@@senzangakhonajere1994 I am not saying he’s *terrible* he’s just fine. That’s what Ive always felt about Cole. He’s good at rhyming, and I like some of his beat choices, but I’ve never felt like he really had much to say that other rappers hadn’t said better, funnier, more poetically, yknow. It’s not really a hate, I mean mid in the truest sense here. He’s not bad, he’s just middle of the road, though I liked the off season, some of 4YEO, and no role modelz; I just find a lot of his output kinda lacking a real voice, as compared to someone like Jay Z or Kendrick who both seem to have influenced him heavily, even though I know his career kind of came around the same time as Kendrick. So I mean, he’s good sometimes really good, I just think the *average* j cole song is just not as good as all the people he gets compared to, peak hip hop etc
Well if you ask me... its like that for most legends even soke shit from Dot is gassed up way to much... to a level now where one is not allowed to say otherwise... The thing you see a making jcole mid... is what ppo were celebrating fro Dot on his last ulbum with so much heart n emotions...
I'm using Kendrick coz is the one we are forced to believe has a perfect discography n what not... but overall I get your point..
@@senzangakhonajere1994 i mean I think they overrated damn, and section 80 just hasn’t aged that well to me in EVERY song, (some are great)
But GKMC->TPAB is a ridiculous run
Denzel w only 84 is crazy
I almost said “eh I have a couple of years” then I saw illmatic, bro was my age.
Mmlp being a 73 is comical
it’s crazy how much the critics have downplayed eminems skill, gave tdoss a 4 and ice spice 8 🤯 these music critiques have zero credibility
Tbh both albums are 4 😂
‘critics’
Critics don’t give a score, a critic does
tdoss was ass and y2k was ass too
Eminems skill starts and ends at his ability to rap. Being able to rap doesn't mean you make good music. Em just doesn't make good music.
The LITTLE PUMP album, being 6 score below the Marshal Mathers lp and 9 behind The Off-Season, should tell you enough about critic score, lmao
They did eminem dirty
It ain't hard to tell. I excel, then prevail
The mic is contacted, I attract clientele
My mic check is life or death, breathin' a sniper's breath
Exhale the yellow smoke of Buddha through richeous steps.
Deep like shinin', sparkle like a diamond
Sneak a uzi on the island in my army jacket linin'
Hit the earth like a comet, invasion
Nas is like the afro-centric asian: half man, half amazin'
'Cause in my physical I can express through song
Delete stress like Motrin, and extend strong
Drink Moet with Medusa, give her shotguns in hell
From the spliff that I lift and inhale, it ain't hard to tell
Ems highest is 73?!?!?! Whatever these critics are taking, i want some too
Wayne only having 80 is wild af to me
Mmlp critic score is criminal
ALL CAPS jumpscared me bro
Dead presidents is such a good song it was my first actual introduction to jay z other than ye and my best moment is when i was listening to the blonded radio on gta v and i heard all of dead presidents into crack rock and i just stayed there where i was with a good view and listened to the two classics
Can't still believe that Lil Pump made his best album at 17, he is just a good rapper
Madvillany underrated
Not really its a fantastic album and often regarded as a top ten album by most rap fans
@@Burke23according to this video, it is underrated
Shut up kid mf doom the goat
For these ratings
89 is a great rating
UM TABOO IS IS HIS MOST CRITICALLY ACLAIMED ALBUM
Madvillainy only having a 89 pisses me off
Nah no way you snuck in lil pump like that 😂
rip DOOM, all caps when you spell the man’s name ✊
Iceburg boy is now Iceburg CEO
I love MF DOOM and madvillainy. Rest in peace to the villain.
25 to 27 is the best age LOL
Tha Carter 3 forever!!
No way the offseason is Cole’s best album. It’s like #5.
Ong
Literally
The J. Cole disrespect is crazy wtf
reasonable doubt over tpab is interesting im so used to seeing it topping these lists
Over Illmatic and MBDTF too
Nwts being higher than mmlp is a crime
Nas basically a teenager dropping 1 of the most classic bangers of all time 😅
Vaudeville Villain is more critically acclaimed than Madvillany
Lil pump self titled being that close to MMLP is nuts
do “is it the best one” for vultures 2 pls
TPAB at 27 is fucking insane.
Critics got offended by mmlp😭😂
Nah it’s kinda inconsistent and not conceptually great
No one is offended the music is just bad. 😭
One of the most mainstream rappers to ever exist, it feels unrealistic to act like a outcast when you can make mid albums and get trophies
Eminem show his best work
As much as we hate her fans, Thank you Taylor for giving us MBDTF
mmlp and Carter 3 got done dirty (both should score a 90+ fs
Haunted me with that Kendrick snippet
The disrespect cole face is disgusting
Chief Keef dropped Finally Rich at 17
Mac Miller dropped Blue Slide Park at 19
These scores are proof that critics know nothing about what they judge and their opinions are worth nothing. All they do is suck the soul out of music.
26 and 27 taking over this list
the shock on my face after hearing A MASTERPIECE, then it to be continued by drake 😐
The mmlp being a 73 is just ridiculous
Tf did Eminem say about animals 💀
Reasonable doubt being higher than tpab is sad
Note to self
Wait until i turn 27
a Jay Z record will always make me say, "Huh?"
MDBTF is only a 91 because Anthony Melon Fantano dragged it down out of jealousy
73 as Eminems highest score is crazy
damn, we stll got time 😭
Off season should be higher
I'm 20 and knowing nas made one of the greatest rap albums ever at my age made me feel like a bum
Madvillainy 89 critic score is criminal easily 90+
ngl critics rating carter iii over iv is surprising
they should add critics for these critics 😭
39 for 6ix9ine is really generous 💀