Folks, J.D does an amazing job of bringing us American history free if charge, so let's repay those who fought for our freedoms and donate to the American battlefield trust and continue to preserve our battlefields from development. It is a great organization.
I started this playlist somewhere in the middle. Started from the beginning with a topo map and was walked through the battle. Very well done series. A remarkable story well told!
The videos you post are excellent and the history given by you as to what occurred really brings the past back to life the way no book could ever hope to accomplish. Thank you once more for keeping the American Civil War history alive as I have learned so much that was never taught in school!
What makes it so much worse for Mrs. Carter and losing her 3 sons is she had lost her husband before losing 2 sons at Shiloh and then her son William at Antietam. Beyond devastating.
@@gregc.7167 I will tell you this, ole boy. SLAVERY is the Gospel of JESUS CHRIST; HE Requires you to forsake ALL for HIM. Get rid of slavery and you get rid of the ONLY WAY to Eternal Salvation. John 3.3, 33-34- Wake up ole son!
Your videos are some of the finest Civil War history materials on the web. McClellan was so ambivalent and such a coward, he could have crushed Lee at Antietam...but the fight went to Gettysburg where more blood was shed. Last time I visited Antietam, I was out in the cornfield by myself at 11:00AM. There was no one around. I heard cannon fire as clear as day and many others have reported the same thing. Antietam is haunted and one immediately feels an eerie vibe when touring the battlefield.
Gosh! What can I say? Your informative, well-presented series certainly portrays and explains the battle and also the effect on the community. Thanks! You and Eric really bring the past to life. The animated maps help because I'm also a visual learner.
Thank you for this amazing look into this battle. To be the last son to die and the one who supported his Mother had to be devastating to his family. We forget that many of these soldiers were the sole supporters of their families and when they were gone the struggles that they family went through had to be awl full.😢
@@murielsmith8922 I thought of her too. My son returned from deployment safe and unharmed ~ I am forever grateful to The Lord for that. I pray for all soldiers and their moms….I know the pain and worry too well!
As always a thoroughly professional and enlightening series. Cannot wait to see what you have in store for us on the next adventure. JD you are one of the best!
Please continue the Civil War vids, they are great! Wish they were longer since they are so great. I enjoy watching yours over Battle Field Trust with respects to them.
I truly enjoy your work and have for a long time. It has grown poignant with my recent discovery that my great great grandfather was with the 20th Massachusetts from April 1862 until he was wounded in June 1864, probably at Malvern Hill. William Gartland Company A.
Been to this battlefield. What moved me the most was the Church in the battlefield. Went inside. First thought of services it held. Imagined my minister Dad preaching there! Also thought about the wounded who lay here, some recovering, some dying. My Civil War studies began with the doctors, nurses, sick and wounded as I am a nurse.when I study a battle those things always come to mind.
Thank you for going to these battlefields and telling the stories. They really more understanding in finer details about what happened, why battles were won and lost.
Great work! , thank you from here in the UK . I’m liking all your videos on the US Civil War and battlefield tour videos . I know the basics of the US Civil War and watching your videos is really capturing my interest and imagination for the subject , thank you .
Hello from Brazil. I have always been fascinated by the American Civil War history and I am enjoying your channel very much. Congatulations. Keep up with the good work.
JD I just want to say that your videos are so much more informative than a lot of documentaries. Also, not far from me is a civil war pow camp. Camp Ford. If you are ever in East Texas around Tyler, if you have time to check it out
This series has been outstanding, as usual! You do such a good job describing the events and movements of the armies! By telling the stories of individuals who participated or were affected by the battles you show the human side of war. Thank you!
An absolute amazing series JD. I have been there but never really understood what happened. I like a few of your buddy's who do these teaching history videos but you are the best out there. Thank you for your efforts. It's really great stuff. 👍🏼😎
Great series JD!! Your videos did an outstanding job covering the battle and the battlefield. I also really enjoyed your inclusion of the South Mountain sites. They are well worth a day just to find and see all of them. Can’t wait to see what your next series subject will be. Keep up the great work!!
Really enjoyed your series on the battle of Sharpsburg...south named the battles after the nearby town where the north named most of them after the bodies of water.
Thanks JD always love the videos and can't wait for the next one. Keep up the great work and stay safe. The personal stories are always great. Thanks again.
Thank you. When I was stationed in Korea in 1990 I was able to take some time and track battles there. Every time it rained it seemed we were finding mines and mortar shells washed down the hills.
I have said it before, and I'll say it again because it's true. The quality of editing is even more amazing. I know you hate editing, but you are getting really good, my man. Congrats. This series was fantastic.
I live in Hagerstown and have been to Antietam battlefield so many times but it looks so different seeing it through your eyes. I will have to make another trip just to see the things I have seen on your videos i have missed, Thank You,
@@TheHistoryUnderground so much meat here! Very good coverage JD. I love the way you include troop movements with personal stories ~ wow! About that mom though!!! I cannot begin to imagine her pain and loss! Do you know if her sons were all on the same side of this conflict? Just curious
Being a non-American (I`m Australian)my knowledge of the Civil war was limited ...(all I knew was it was in early 1860`s,Generals I knew were Grant and Lee, and main battles were Gettysburg and Antietam) from other occasional documentaries. But with JD`s past and present civil war presentations, I`m actually soaking all this up. Being a ww1 and 2 history nut, I`m familiar with military tactics etc, so can follow JD with his description of tactics, strategies, wounds, losses, outcomes etc. good series....
Your videos explain so much, and the inclusion of personal stories make the history more real. It shows to me how God awful that war really was. There is nothing glorious in war. It is such a tragedy.
The slaughter of the Confederates at Antietam still breaks my heart every time. And to this day I find it incomprehensible that the soldiers who fought for the South are condemned in this way. It was a different time, the thinking was completely different. Most of those who fought were not even slave owners. These soldiers fought so that the South would not be patronised by the North. Monuments that stand for these soldiers, for an unimaginable bloodshed and patriotism, are destroyed and torn down. A disgrace without equal. TY JD again
Been enjoying this series JD very informative on battles I don't remember being taught in school. It's a very sad thing that the mother had to endure with losing her husband and then her son's. That reminds of the Sullivan brothers from WWII have you done a video on this???
AP Hill's attack was a Major "Hit" on the union left flank is an Understatement. Bear in mind, after they captured Harper's Ferry, paroled prisoners, had lunch, etc, the soldiers had brand new uniforms and shoes (which they haven't seen in a while) and also Captured Regimental colors. I have no doubt from a distance they looked like Federal Troops. When Hill Showed up it was the perfect attack situation for him, and baffling for Rodman because in that smoke filled haze I bet he couldn't tell who they were! Were they Union reinforcements? I've read a lot on Antietam and one word that was used a lot to describe AP Hill's flank attack: was that they "Smashed" into them. They didn't see it coming. Another Great Video, Thank you.
Thank you so much for this video . The Napoleonic style warfare would come to its end with various firearms that could be fired a lot quicker and artillery which could shoot further with the addition of newly developed shells ,so heartbreaking that so many men were lost .
There is a marathon that runs from Harpers Ferry along the canal, through most of Antietam, and to Shepherdstown. That made me appreciate how hilly Antietam is more than any other visit to the battlefield.
“Speed bumps” traversing terrain like that, with gear and that rifle wearing slick soled brogans isn’t easy. Then doing it for real with the extra weight of lead and the stress of combat. Hats off to them.
I am crippled and will never be able to go to the places you take me. Without you l would never be able to see these things. As an American history buff l havehave never heard this part of history in such detail
Thanks JD another awesome video. I really enjoy the hard work you put into each video you make. Man I love the Civil War series that you have made . Your research and study of the battlefields that goes into the videos you create are awesome!! Keep em coming buddy 👍
So good. Thank you so much! I thank God every day that I found this channel some time ago. It is one of only two channels I follow (American Battlefield Trust being the other) where I just go ahead and "like" the video before I even start it. It's a sure thing from me! Thank you!
I really enjoy your productions. All are well researched and sympathetically told. Thank you.
Folks, J.D does an amazing job of bringing us American history free if charge, so let's repay those who fought for our freedoms and donate to the American battlefield trust and continue to preserve our battlefields from development. It is a great organization.
Absolutely. Love the work that they do.
I started this playlist somewhere in the middle. Started from the beginning with a topo map and was walked through the battle. Very well done series. A remarkable story well told!
thanks! Appreciate that!
Antietam is a fascinating chapter of the CW and this series is outstanding. Thank you for producing these excellent videos!!
Thanks!
Excelent production.
Definitely one of your best series! Keep up the great work JD!
Thanks a ton!
The videos you post are excellent and the history given by you as to what occurred really brings the past back to life the way no book could ever hope to accomplish. Thank you once more for keeping the American Civil War history alive as I have learned so much that was never taught in school!
🙏🏼
Amen to that.
What makes it so much worse for Mrs. Carter and losing her 3 sons is she had lost her husband before losing 2 sons at Shiloh and then her son William at Antietam. Beyond devastating.
Awful.
I wonder what became of the poor soul. How she ever had any money to survive
No sympathy for anyone who just DO NOT MIND THEIR OWN BUSINESS!!!!!
@@pmcclaren1 awww is someone missing their slaves today?
@@gregc.7167 I will tell you this, ole boy. SLAVERY is the Gospel of JESUS CHRIST; HE Requires you to forsake ALL for HIM. Get rid of slavery and you get rid of the ONLY WAY to Eternal Salvation. John 3.3, 33-34- Wake up ole son!
Your videos are some of the finest Civil War history materials on the web. McClellan was so ambivalent and such a coward, he could have crushed Lee at Antietam...but the fight went to Gettysburg where more blood was shed. Last time I visited Antietam, I was out in the cornfield by myself at 11:00AM. There was no one around. I heard cannon fire as clear as day and many others have reported the same thing. Antietam is haunted and one immediately feels an eerie vibe when touring the battlefield.
Thank you for the kind words. Hope that the channel is doing some good.
Gosh! What can I say? Your informative, well-presented series certainly portrays and explains the battle and also the effect on the community. Thanks! You and Eric really bring the past to life. The animated maps help because I'm also a visual learner.
Appreciate that. The American Battlefield Trust really gave us all a gift with those maps.
In Hartwig's book about Antietam, he describes how the stone walls along the Hagerstown Pike played a role in the fighting near the Dunker church.
Thank you for this amazing look into this battle.
To be the last son to die and the one who supported his Mother had to be devastating to his family.
We forget that many of these soldiers were the sole supporters of their families and when they were gone the struggles that they family went through had to be awl full.😢
To me, that's one of the saddest stories on the battlefield.
@@samuraieko5408 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@samuraieko5408 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@samuraieko5408 And you, sir, are what Scots would refer to as a 'bawbag'.
Good job on the series. I know you put in a lot of time and effort. Hasn’t gone unnoticed, much appreciated!
I appreciate that. Thank you.
I am learning more and more about history every video I watch by you! It actually is concerning that they fail to cover all of this in school here!
Another chapter in the history of a great nation. Thanks a lot. Colin UK 🇬🇧
Glad you enjoyed it!
Can’t imagine losing 1 son~let alone ALL in 6 months! That poor woman! Wow!
Awful.
Sort of the basis for saving private Ryan, as I remember!
@@tomwarner2468 different war but yes….smacks of similarity! It certainly moved my heart!
This lady reminded me of Mrs. Thomas Sullivan who lost all five of her boys in WW2. The men die but the Mothers suffer the most!!
@@murielsmith8922 I thought of her too. My son returned from deployment safe and unharmed ~ I am forever grateful to The Lord for that. I pray for all soldiers and their moms….I know the pain and worry too well!
I tell ya Jd, i've really enjoyed watching this Antietam series , very descriptive. You got an awesome channel , your awesome at what you do. 🇺🇸
Thanks 🙏🏼
As always a thoroughly professional and enlightening series. Cannot wait to see what you have in store for us on the next adventure. JD you are one of the best!
Thanks! Got a few more episodes left in this series and then it's off to the Revolutionary War.
Again JD great work on the battle! I can’t thank you enough with bring us American history! Thank you very much!
Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for watching.
The accounting of events of Antietam have been a true learning experience. Great videos from both sides! Thank you
Thanks!
Excellent series on Antietam.
🙏🏼
Please continue the Civil War vids, they are great! Wish they were longer since they are so great. I enjoy watching yours over Battle Field Trust with respects to them.
This is a sad event. And great narrative of this final day of the battle. Especially a mother loosing all her sons. Thank you for sharing!
Glad you enjoyed it
What a fantastic series! Thank you so much for all the time and effort that you put into making it for us all.
👊🏻
This has been an excellent series JD, well done!
Thanks!
I truly enjoy your work and have for a long time. It has grown poignant with my recent discovery that my great great grandfather was with the 20th Massachusetts from April 1862 until he was wounded in June 1864, probably at Malvern Hill.
William Gartland Company A.
Been to this battlefield. What moved me the most was the Church in the battlefield. Went inside. First thought of services it held. Imagined my minister Dad preaching there! Also thought about the wounded who lay here, some recovering, some dying. My Civil War studies began with the doctors, nurses, sick and wounded as I am a nurse.when I study a battle those things always come to mind.
Thanks!
Wow! Thank you!
@@TheHistoryUnderground you're very welcome. A historian after my own heart.
Bro, you know your stuff. Terrific presentation.
Rest in peace to all who fought.
Here's to our republic surviving these awful days of division.
Thank you for going to these battlefields and telling the stories. They really more understanding in finer details about what happened, why battles were won and lost.
Poor Mrs. Carter. The Civil War has such long stretching consequences. Incredibly sad story. Great coverage brother. Keep it up!
Very sad story. Thanks for watching.
I truly enjoy each of your videos. So well done in every aspect. Keeping our history alive. Thank you JD!
Great work! , thank you from here in the UK . I’m liking all your videos on the US Civil War and battlefield tour videos . I know the basics of the US Civil War and watching your videos is really capturing my interest and imagination for the subject , thank you .
So glad to hear it! Thanks!
Nothing like walking the ground with an expert. Brilliant stuff.
👍🏻
Best stuff on TH-cam!
Thanks!
Hello from Brazil. I have always been fascinated by the American Civil War history and I am enjoying your channel very much. Congatulations. Keep up with the good work.
Thanks 🙏🏼
Want too travel to these site's just don'thave the ability to do so. Thanks JD for taking us tthere! You do a great job!!!
JD I just want to say that your videos are so much more informative than a lot of documentaries. Also, not far from me is a civil war pow camp. Camp Ford. If you are ever in East Texas around Tyler, if you have time to check it out
Another great series JD. I learned many new things about this battle and look forward to getting out to the battlefield soon myself
This series has been outstanding, as usual! You do such a good job describing the events and movements of the armies! By telling the stories of individuals who participated or were affected by the battles you show the human side of war. Thank you!
I’m a Canadian 🇨🇦 and I’ve been obsessed with Gettysburg civil war stuff for years I think I was there in a past life lol
The Civil War is an endless well of content to study.
These videos really bring the history to life - I think we can all now say 'I was there'.
An absolute amazing series JD. I have been there but never really understood what happened. I like a few of your buddy's who do these teaching history videos but you are the best out there. Thank you for your efforts. It's really great stuff. 👍🏼😎
Thank you. That really does mean a lot.
Great series JD!! Your videos did an outstanding job covering the battle and the battlefield. I also really enjoyed your inclusion of the South Mountain sites. They are well worth a day just to find and see all of them. Can’t wait to see what your next series subject will be. Keep up the great work!!
Thanks! Got some Revolutionary War content coming up next.
Really enjoyed your series on the battle of Sharpsburg...south named the battles after the nearby town where the north named most of them after the bodies of water.
👍🏻
I have enjoyed the Antietam Battle as well as all of the others. The Civil War is my favorite History War. Thank you for bringing this to life
Incredible video. Very well done should be used in history classes.
Thank you ... a truly amazing series your Antietam presentation is.
Outstanding educational knowledge on the battle of Antietam.
Thanks! Hope that it serves to be helpful to people.
Excellent series. Your work is appreciated. Keep traveling.
Many thanks!
Thanks JD always love the videos and can't wait for the next one. Keep up the great work and stay safe. The personal stories are always great. Thanks again.
Thank you. When I was stationed in Korea in 1990 I was able to take some time and track battles there. Every time it rained it seemed we were finding mines and mortar shells washed down the hills.
You have the best show on u-tube. Thank you!
Another really good video. Very informative. Thank you. Really like all of your videos.
Glad you like them!
Superb description of broad spectrum of action as well as the details of the actions of the battle.
I have said it before, and I'll say it again because it's true. The quality of editing is even more amazing. I know you hate editing, but you are getting really good, my man. Congrats. This series was fantastic.
Thanks!
Love the suspensful music in this JD kinda like another one of those last hurrah's to get the job done for the union side of things.
🇺🇸
I live in Hagerstown and have been to Antietam battlefield so many times but it looks so different seeing it through your eyes. I will have to make another trip just to see the things I have seen on your videos i have missed, Thank You,
Not sure if this is the final episode, but I really enjoyed this series. Great job by you, VTH, and the Battlefield Trust.
Got a few more to go before we move on to the American Revolution :)
Excellent episode…so much to go over her…..pausing this comment to watch again! Well done JD!
Thanks!
@@TheHistoryUnderground so much meat here! Very good coverage JD.
I love the way you include troop movements with personal stories ~ wow! About that mom though!!! I cannot begin to imagine her pain and loss!
Do you know if her sons were all on the same side of this conflict? Just curious
@@1psychofan - Yeah, they were all Union soldiers.
@@TheHistoryUnderground well, if there’s any comfort to be had at least they weren’t opposing each other. Still WOW! That story shook me,
Separate topic. Another fan asked me if you will make more T shirts. She wants to order some for Christmas gifts 🎁 any chance?
Being a non-American (I`m Australian)my knowledge of the Civil war was limited ...(all I knew was it was in early 1860`s,Generals I knew were Grant and Lee, and main battles were Gettysburg and Antietam) from other occasional documentaries.
But with JD`s past and present civil war presentations, I`m actually soaking all this up.
Being a ww1 and 2 history nut, I`m familiar with military tactics etc, so can follow JD with his description of tactics, strategies, wounds, losses, outcomes etc.
good series....
Thanks! I really do appreciate that.
Say, You being an Aussie y'all don't have cold Christmases do ya? Hot in the North and cold in the South. Curious from Texas...
ALWAYS real cool and well done!! Appreciate you sir!
I appreciate that!
Excellent, will revisit when new museum is opened
Can't wait to see that myself.
Thoroughly enjoyed your Antietam series. You do good work sir.
These videos are SO good. Thank you
Glad you like them!
Well-done series, as usual. Thanks!
Thanks!
Pure enjoyment! Thanks
Glad you enjoyed it!
Your videos explain so much, and the inclusion of personal stories make the history more real. It shows to me how God awful that war really was. There is nothing glorious in war. It is such a tragedy.
Just Fantastic documentary, TY ! I've been there, years ago, still so greatful to learn more from you.
The slaughter of the Confederates at Antietam still breaks my heart every time. And to this day I find it incomprehensible that the soldiers who fought for the South are condemned in this way. It was a different time, the thinking was completely different. Most of those who fought were not even slave owners. These soldiers fought so that the South would not be patronised by the North. Monuments that stand for these soldiers, for an unimaginable bloodshed and patriotism, are destroyed and torn down. A disgrace without equal. TY JD again
right on
Great series'. Sharpsburg MD is on my bucket list too once more in my life.
Amazing place.
Thx 4 all your Work in Saving this History, JD!! JJ
I absolutely love this video. Thank you for sharing & educating us.
Been enjoying this series JD very informative on battles I don't remember being taught in school. It's a very sad thing that the mother had to endure with losing her husband and then her son's. That reminds of the Sullivan brothers from WWII have you done a video on this???
Superbly well narrated
The price of War is a sad one. What a waste of men. Great episode JD thank you so much 🙏
Man I love your videos. So happy I discovered your channel
Really neat! Continue the good work!
This was definitely a fascinating series
AP Hill's attack was a Major "Hit" on the union left flank is an Understatement. Bear in mind, after they captured Harper's Ferry, paroled prisoners, had lunch, etc, the soldiers had brand new uniforms and shoes (which they haven't seen in a while) and also Captured Regimental colors. I have no doubt from a distance they looked like Federal Troops.
When Hill Showed up it was the perfect attack situation for him, and baffling for Rodman because in that smoke filled haze I bet he couldn't tell who they were! Were they Union reinforcements?
I've read a lot on Antietam and one word that was used a lot to describe AP Hill's flank attack: was that they "Smashed" into them. They didn't see it coming.
Another Great Video, Thank you.
Thanks for the added analysis. 👊🏻
@@TheHistoryUnderground Thanks! Keep up the great work.
These are wonderful bud thank you. I’m
Not able to make it to these places but I can live vicariously through you
Seeing the actual terrain gives me a better sense of the difficulties of this battle. No mountains, but lots of Hills.
Thank you so much for this video . The Napoleonic style warfare would come to its end with various firearms that could be fired a lot quicker and artillery which could shoot further with the addition of newly developed shells ,so heartbreaking that so many men were lost .
Agreed.
JD, another great video. Keep it up my friend.
Thanks 👍
Strong work as always. Thank you for all the work you do on these videos
Your game is on point for this
Appreciate that!
There is a marathon that runs from Harpers Ferry along the canal, through most of Antietam, and to Shepherdstown. That made me appreciate how hilly Antietam is more than any other visit to the battlefield.
Well done JD. We love how you try to simplify your video's. 👍 👍 👍
Thanks 👍
Love it👏👏 keep em coming
Thanks!
Great work!!
“Speed bumps” traversing terrain like that, with gear and that rifle wearing slick soled brogans isn’t easy. Then doing it for real with the extra weight of lead and the stress of combat. Hats off to them.
A great narrator
Great series! Thank you
I am crippled and will never be able to go to the places you take me. Without you l would never be able to see these things. As an American history buff l havehave never heard this part of history in such detail
Thanks JD another awesome video. I really enjoy the hard work you put into each video you make. Man I love the Civil War series that you have made . Your research and study of the battlefields that goes into the videos you create are awesome!! Keep em coming buddy 👍
Well done! TY
👊🏻
Great Job, Thank you.
So good. Thank you so much! I thank God every day that I found this channel some time ago. It is one of only two channels I follow (American Battlefield Trust being the other) where I just go ahead and "like" the video before I even start it. It's a sure thing from me! Thank you!
Love the series
Thanks!
JD good job great video thank you and sending love from United Kingdom 🇬🇧
Superb series. FYI...from the east side of the Rohrbach/Burnside bridge to the National Cemetery is approximately a walk up an 80 story building !