@WJ-ng5dc 1. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself observed his birthday by fasting every Monday. This shows that he acknowledged the significance of his birth. Fasting on Mondays, which he explained was in gratitude for his birth, is a form of celebration, even though it may not resemble modern-day practices. 2. The significance of Friday as an Eid (celebration day) in Islam: The Prophet (peace be upon him) explained that Friday is significant because it was the day Allah created Adam and the day Adam passed away. If Friday is a celebration for the creation of Adam, how much more deserving is the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, whose status is higher than Adam, to be a day of celebration? 3. Allah instructs us in the Qur'an to celebrate His blessings and mercy: In Surah Yunus (10:58), Allah says, “Say: In the bounty of Allah and in His mercy - in that let them rejoice.” The birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is one of the greatest manifestations of Allah's mercy to mankind. Therefore, it is only fitting to celebrate his birth as a sign of gratitude. 4. Celebrating the Prophet's birth should not be seen as an innovation (bid'ah): Just because something wasn't celebrated in a formal way during the time of the Sahaba doesn't necessarily mean it is wrong. By this logic, many aspects of modern life would also be considered impermissible. New ways of expressing love for the Prophet, as long as they don't contradict Islamic principles, can be seen as valid. 5. Celebrating national independence days is widely accepted, but the Prophet’s birth is even more significant: Just as countries celebrate the day they gained independence, the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the day when the world received the greatest blessing and liberation through his message. If people celebrate independence days, why shouldn't we celebrate the birth of the one who brought spiritual independence to humanity? 6. Rejecting the celebration of the Prophet's birthday could be seen as disregarding his importance: The birth of the Prophet is a major blessing for the entire world. By refusing to celebrate it, one might be missing out on recognizing the profound significance of his coming into this world. These are some points capture the reasons why many Muslims believe celebrating the Prophet's birthday is not only permissible but also a way to express love, gratitude, and reverence for the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him).
@@_ibnmuhammad No one got cooked, the only ones getting cooked are the zios who the madkhalis try to tell us we should sign peace treaties with. Madkhalis fight other Muslims and say boycotting starbucks is haram while what happens in Gaza continues. We reject madkhalism. Enjoy the cook offs on them merkavas btw. On youm ul qiyamah may i be raised alongside Shaykh Izzaddin (of Shaam/Palestine), and may those madkhalis who continue to fight Muslims be raised with Mileikowsky the kazzab.
قال ابن القيم رحمه الله : وقال لي شيخ الإسلام رضي الله عنه - وقد جعلت أورد عليه إيراداً بعد إيرادٍ - : " لا تجعل قلبك للإيرادات والشبهات مثل السفنجة ، فيتشربها ، فلا ينضح إلا بها ، ولكن اجعله كالزجاجة المصمتة تمر الشبهات بظاهرها ، ولا تستقر فيها ، فيراها بصفائه ويدفعها بصلابته ، وإلا فإذا أشربت قلبك كل شبهة تمر عليها صار مقرا للشبهات " " مفتاح دار السعادة " ( 1 / 140 ) . ونقل الإمام الذهبي رحمه الله عن سفيان الثوري رحمه الله قولَه : " من سمع ببدعة فلا يحكها لجلسائه ، لا يلقها في قلوبهم " .
WHat absolutely boggles my mind is when the Shaykh states that the Mawlid isnt replicated, advised , suggested by the Prophet ( saws) the Sahabas and the 4 Ulimahs ; and yet after the brother accepeting this truth... he then proceeds to talk about nuonced and vagueness and nothing is clear cut. If you think its such a great idea and your doing more Ibadah He should read 4 rakahs Maghrib ! ,.. well the prophet didnt say not to do that lol , and technically it is more Ibadah. .... If any of the Sahabas where alive today,.. they would be bemused by what the muslims quarrel over !
He walked into that one 😂 A man sneezed next to Sayyidunā ‘Abd ullāh Ibn ‘Umar رضي الله عنه and said: "praise be to Allāh and peace be upon the Messenger of Allāh" Ibn ‘Umar رضي الله عنه said: “I too (other times) say; 'praise be to Allāh and peace be upon the Messenger of Allāh', but this is not what Rusūlullāh ﷺ taught us (after sneezing), rather he taught us to say: 'Praise be to Allāh in all circumstances'.” Recorded: Sunan Tirmithy, 2738 - Mustadrak Ḥākim, 4, p 265 Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ It was asked of Salmān Al Fārisy رضي الله عنه: "Your Prophet taught you everything? even what to do when using the toilet?" he replied: "Yes, he forbade us from facing the Qiblah and to clean ourselves afterwards using the right hand" Recorded: Ṣaḥīḥ Musslim, 4, 224 Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ " 'Abd ullāh ibn ‘Abbās saw Mu’āwiyah ibn Abi Sufyān رضي الله عنهم touching the two northern corners of the Ka’bah, and he told him not to do that. Mu’āwiyah said to him: “No part of the House should be ignored." Ibn ‘Abbās said: "Indeed is for you in the Messenger of Allāh an exemplar of goodness” al Aḥzāb: 21. "And I saw the Prophet ﷺ touching the two Yamany corners” Mu’āwiyah then accepted what Ibn ‘Abbās said." Recorded: Sharh Usool I'tiqad Ahl as-Sunnah wa al-Jamaa - Mussnad Aḥmad Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ Sa’īd Ibn al Musayyib رضي الله عنه saw a man praying too many optional prayers before the Fajr prayer and therefore he forbade him from doing so. The man retorted: "O Abu Muḥammad, Will Allāh punish me for praying?" Sa'īd replied: "No, but He will punish you for doing other than the Sunnah." Recorded: Mussnad Aḥmad, 188 Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ Huthayfah Ibn al Yamān رحمه الله said: "Do not perform any act of worship which was not practiced by the companions of the Prophet ﷺ because the early people did not leave anything unaddressed. so follow the way of those who were before you. Recorded: Al Ibānah Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ Sufyān ath Thawry رحمه الله said: "An innovation is dearer to Shayṭān than a sin, for one can easily repent from a sin, but an innovation is not easily repented from." Recorded: Al Muḥaddith Al Fāsil Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ A man asked Mālik bin Anas رحمه الله: "At which point do I initiate my state of Iḥrām?" he replied: "From Thul Hulayfah, where the Prophet ﷺ did so" the man retorted: "I wish to do it from the area beside the grave of the Prophet ﷺ" Mālik said: "Do not do that, for I fear that if you do so, you will be afflicted with trials" the man replied: "Why would I be afflicted with trials? All I wanted was to do it from a place which is only a few miles away from where you told me!" Mālik said upon hearing this: "What can be more serious than feeling that you performed a righteous deed that the Prophet ﷺ failed to do? I heard the words of Allāh: “So let those beware who dissent from his order lest trials strike them or a painful punishment.” an Nūr: 63 Recorded: Al Bā’ith ‘alā inkāril bid’a wal hawādith, 91 Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ This is just a snippet of the statements of the salaf...
Jazaka’Allahu khair akhi I really appreciated that you went out of your way to do this but could you give the reference please. It would make it a lot easier since I’m on my phone rn and not on a computer and I’d have to do more research just to see where it’s from
@@rickfox804 @rickfox804 1: Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2738 2: Jami` at-Tirmidhi 16 3: i couldn't find the exact one but Sahih al-Bukhari 1608 is simmilar and Sunan an-Nasa'i 2948 and Sunan an-Nasa'i 2950 give more emphasis on the Prophet's ﷺ action 4: Al-Bayhaqī, As-Sunan Al-Kubraa 2:466 5: Abu Dawud 6: not sure but i found a quotation from abdurrahman org that it can be found in Sharh Usool I'tiqaad 7: cant find anything
@WJ-ng5dc 1. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself observed his birthday by fasting every Monday. This shows that he acknowledged the significance of his birth. Fasting on Mondays, which he explained was in gratitude for his birth, is a form of celebration, even though it may not resemble modern-day practices. 2. The significance of Friday as an Eid (celebration day) in Islam: The Prophet (peace be upon him) explained that Friday is significant because it was the day Allah created Adam and the day Adam passed away. If Friday is a celebration for the creation of Adam, how much more deserving is the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, whose status is higher than Adam, to be a day of celebration? 3. Allah instructs us in the Qur'an to celebrate His blessings and mercy: In Surah Yunus (10:58), Allah says, “Say: In the bounty of Allah and in His mercy - in that let them rejoice.” The birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is one of the greatest manifestations of Allah's mercy to mankind. Therefore, it is only fitting to celebrate his birth as a sign of gratitude. 4. Celebrating the Prophet's birth should not be seen as an innovation (bid'ah): Just because something wasn't celebrated in a formal way during the time of the Sahaba doesn't necessarily mean it is wrong. By this logic, many aspects of modern life would also be considered impermissible. New ways of expressing love for the Prophet, as long as they don't contradict Islamic principles, can be seen as valid. 5. Celebrating national independence days is widely accepted, but the Prophet’s birth is even more significant: Just as countries celebrate the day they gained independence, the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the day when the world received the greatest blessing and liberation through his message. If people celebrate independence days, why shouldn't we celebrate the birth of the one who brought spiritual independence to humanity? 6. Rejecting the celebration of the Prophet's birthday could be seen as disregarding his importance: The birth of the Prophet is a major blessing for the entire world. By refusing to celebrate it, one might be missing out on recognizing the profound significance of his coming into this world. These are some points capture the reasons why many Muslims believe celebrating the Prophet's birthday is not only permissible but also a way to express love, gratitude, and reverence for the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him).
@@moizuddin6932 Fasting on Mondays means it's NOT a celebration. Because we're instructed not to fast on celebration days like Fridays or Eid days. So, instead of celebrating 12th of Rabi Ul Awal, why don't you fast on Mondays. Make it important the way the prophet (alayhi salam) made it important. Don't invent a new way.
It might be painful to hear what the Shaikh is saying but it’s the truth. We can’t pretend to love the prophet more then companions did. They are the best of example.
@@WJ-ng5dc 1. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself observed his birthday by fasting every Monday. This shows that he acknowledged the significance of his birth. Fasting on Mondays, which he explained was in gratitude for his birth, is a form of celebration, even though it may not resemble modern-day practices. 2. The significance of Friday as an Eid (celebration day) in Islam: The Prophet (peace be upon him) explained that Friday is significant because it was the day Allah created Adam and the day Adam passed away. If Friday is a celebration for the creation of Adam, how much more deserving is the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, whose status is higher than Adam, to be a day of celebration? 3. Allah instructs us in the Qur'an to celebrate His blessings and mercy: In Surah Yunus (10:58), Allah says, “Say: In the bounty of Allah and in His mercy - in that let them rejoice.” The birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is one of the greatest manifestations of Allah's mercy to mankind. Therefore, it is only fitting to celebrate his birth as a sign of gratitude. 4. Celebrating the Prophet's birth should not be seen as an innovation (bid'ah): Just because something wasn't celebrated in a formal way during the time of the Sahaba doesn't necessarily mean it is wrong. By this logic, many aspects of modern life would also be considered impermissible. New ways of expressing love for the Prophet, as long as they don't contradict Islamic principles, can be seen as valid. 5. Celebrating national independence days is widely accepted, but the Prophet’s birth is even more significant: Just as countries celebrate the day they gained independence, the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the day when the world received the greatest blessing and liberation through his message. If people celebrate independence days, why shouldn't we celebrate the birth of the one who brought spiritual independence to humanity? 6. Rejecting the celebration of the Prophet's birthday could be seen as disregarding his importance: The birth of the Prophet is a major blessing for the entire world. By refusing to celebrate it, one might be missing out on recognizing the profound significance of his coming into this world. These are some points capture the reasons why many Muslims believe celebrating the Prophet's birthday is not only permissible but also a way to express love, gratitude, and reverence for the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him).
. 😠CHALLENGE😠 . EID-MILAD-UN-NABIﷺ MANANA JAAYIZ Nahi Hai, Koyi QURAN-O-HADEES Se SABIT Kar Kay Dikhawoo😏 QURAN-O-HADEES Ka FAISILAH Hai:-👇👇👇 Kissi Bhi Cheiz Kay NA-JAAYIZ Honay Kay Liyae QURAN-O-HADEES Ki DALEEL Hona ZAROORI Hai (Yani Jisko QURAN-O-HADEES Ne NA-JAAYIZ Nahi Kaha,Woh Karna JAAYIZ Hai)👌👌👌 Lahaza,Jab QURAN-O-HADEES Ne EID-MILAD-UN-NABIﷺ MANANA NA-JAAYIZ Nahi Kaha,Ab Jo Bhi EID-MILAD-UN-NABIﷺ MANANA NA-JAAYIZ Kahay Ga,To Samijh Lijiyae, Woh SHATAAN Hai, Kyun Ki QURAN-O-HADEES Kay Khilaaf SHATAAN Hi Bool Sakhta Hai 📌📌📌
I was wondering the same thing about celebrating the prophet's birthday 'salatu as salaam' and brother Uthman Farooq answered the question quite clearly! Thank you so much.
What is so hard to understand. If you want to "celebrate" mawlid with just salawat and dzikr, Rasulullah SAW told us to do that and practice his sunnah every day. Not sanction it to a specific day. And the main teachings of the Prophet SAW has always been to worship Allah SWT, not finding obscure opinions to celebrate his birthday. You want to send peace and blessings to the prophet and his family, do it everyday as the Prophet taught us, along side every other ibadat that is waajib.
Notice how before asking about his bid'ah, he tried to embarrass Sheikh by asking him a very specific and fringe question about grammar to try and undermine his knowledge. This is something more and more common with the students of Ahlul bid'ah, and why we as students of knowledge must really strive to have strong Arabic and Quran and Usool as well as Aqeedah and fiqh
I’m not sure akhi. It seemed he came to ask the 1 question and was almost ready to leave. This act of mawlid must be ingrained in him since childhood and he knows he can’t leave it or he loses all his family this is usually the case.
I am from a city in the subcontinent where grave worship is rampant especially amongst the illiterate masses. When you try to reason with them they get emotional. The caller in this video is not too different from them. May Allah guide us all to the way of Quran, Sunnah and the Salaf.
Even chatGPT doesn't find this "nuanced" because this is what it answered me with : " The origins and observance of Mawlid developed over several centuries within Islamic culture and history. Early Islamic Period During the Prophet Muhammad's lifetime and the era of the early caliphs, the Prophet's birthday was not celebrated as a formal event. The emphasis in early Islam was on following the Prophet’s teachings and practicing his Sunnah (traditions). Development of Mawlid in the Islamic Timeline Fatimid Dynasty (10th-12th Century CE): The origins of formal Mawlid celebrations trace back to the Fatimids, a Shia dynasty ruling Egypt and parts of North Africa. They were the first to introduce public celebrations marking significant Islamic dates, including the birth of the Prophet Muhammad. However, their intent was partly political, as they aimed to strengthen their rule by encouraging public gatherings. Sunni Muslim Adoption (12th-13th Century CE): The celebration of Mawlid spread into Sunni communities, particularly in Egypt and Syria, where it took on a more widespread and devotional nature. The festival was embraced by the Ayyubid dynasty, especially under Sultan al-Malik al-Muẓaffar of Irbil (in modern-day Iraq). He is often credited with organizing grand Mawlid celebrations, with festivities that included sermons, poetry, and feasting." My humble conclusion is that celebrating 'Al Mawlid' comes from a Fatimid Shia practice that has sadly infiltrated sunni Muslims lives. But we must always go back to the roots of our deen since if the Prophet P.B.U.H himself didn't tell the sahabah to celebrate, than who are we to make these judgements and continue a wrong Shia-based practice? May Allah swt make it easy for all of us and bless Shaykh Uthman for his hard work.
@hamidaqueue5973 that's not backbiting, we are watching a video where the brother got a bit rude interrupting the sheikh, he commented on the video pointing out that the brother is disrespectful, that does not amount to backbiting but inshallah your intentions are pure as are mine. ALLAH knows best. Salam
But the fact that's when someone is disrespecting the ulemas and make them as little child who have not read all the proof from what mawlid can be not halal, its a sign of great jahiliya to says that's they have no knowledge of that. So the brother sees that instantly and change his mind about what he thinks about brother uthman...
My Sheikh Uthman is almost always on point with his Evidences Ma'Sha'Allah Alhumdullilah Allahu-Akbar. Jazakallah Khair Ustad for ahutting down the Bidati people
I have seen a mawlid celebration in a masjid where fard salah was delayed and shortened so that the congregation can have more time singing nasheeds. I try to avoid going to that masjid if possible where they made every ibadat seem so difficult, except obligatory salah which they speed though. They even have lengthy dua's after every adzan and iqamah before salah, when I am already pressed for time as I have to go to work immediately after.
Later scholars if they oppose salaf we prefer the salaf. Mawlid came from Obaidi fatimid shia sect. They used to celebrate mawlid of ashab al qisa i.e. Hassan, Hussain, Ali, Fatima and nabi A.S.
Allah and his angels send durood and Salaam on the prophet pbuh, o you who believe you too send durood and Salaam on the prophet pbuh. Allah swt most High most Merciful has clearly stated this in the holy quran, now Allah swt has not stated how much one should read nor when one should read so if one does read and send salutations durood and Salaam on the best of creation as ordered In the holy quran how on earth can this milk shaikh say that you would be punished fir something Allah swt and his angels do, These wahabi shaykhs don't realise on the day of judgement when we all run to the prophet pbuh to intercede for us do they really think by saying you will be punished for something Allah swt has ordered us to do in the quran and does himself is a direct violation of Allah's laws and commands. So brothers take heed these guys may look all knowledgeable but so is shaytaan he has a tight grip on the wahabi World, they claim to love the prophet but deny him in the same breath, Allah swt loves the prophet pbuh so much so that he told us how many obligatory prayers we should read and put a number on it told us how many months are in a year told us how many times we do tawaf during the holy seasons even told us the number of sunnah fard or nawafil to read see numbers in all types of his own worship are mentioned but when it comes to sending durood and Salaam he Allah swt never limited it to a specific number, rather it's limitless in its origin, can one imagine how many durood and salaam Allah and his angels send. Do dont be fooled b these not do learned shaykhs who try to bypass the prophet pbuh however will run to him on the day of judgement themselves
The guy is obviously trying to close his eye to the truth ..i was also doing maulid beforr but it took me years to idnetify and realise the truth that it was bidya and i had to swallow my pride and stop because loving your prophet and followung gods guidance is better than inventing things on your own which are not in the religion
Alhamdulillah the last few evidences absolute clarity! Just to add as far as I remember there is a narration of Abdullah ibn umar cursing ones who elongate the adhaan, thus proving even a nuance of change in this religion is destruction
You have done your job by making it very clear to him. Only those who want to follow ASSUNNAH will abide by it. اللهم اجعلنا من المتبعين ولا تجعلنا من المبتدعين
In malaysia and indonesia, maulid celebrated with dancing and entertainment that not related to prophet saw, this is exactly what christians doing during christmas celebration.
My question to ahlul bidah is if you celebrate mawlid to express the love for Muhammad pbuh. Why don't you celebrate mahram like the shia to express the love for ahlul bayt?
@@hamidaqueue5973 bro Their opinion is not proof.when i said proof i meant quran or hadith. Show me if prophet Muhammad pbuh or any sahaba or anyone from 4 imam or bukhari,muslim (ra) any mujtahid from 1st 3 century celebrated mawlid...
I may not agree with Shaykh Uthman on everything but this caller is very disrespectful! To try and catch someone out on Arabic grammar is very very snidey! It shows that he was trying to have a "GOTCHA" moment with Shaykh Uthman. Not only that he said he studies in Egypt. So why isn't he asking his lecturers at uni about this? He starts the call by saying he has a Masala that no one can answer and he's struggling to find and answer. Here's me thinking it's going to be a serious question 😂 It ends up being an Arabic grammar test to try and catch the Shaykh out. Wallahi what an insincere brother. I mean if you're studying in Egypt and you can't find an answer to these questions you should go back home bro
@SlaveofAllahhh totally agree people like that brother are pretty disgusting but Allah exposes them and their character while they don't even realize it bc of their arrogance.....
Assalamu Alikum. Unfortunately sounds like most Christian’s you debate with. They put up a wall and don’t want to listen with an open heart. May Allah guide us all. Ameen
Sheikh Sulayman ar Ruhayli حفظه الله said: "Ask him (i.e innovator), did the Messenger of Allah ﷺ leave off something of the religion and did not do it nor clarify it? If he says yes, then he has disbelieved. If he says no, then he has established proof against himself."
For those uninitiated in Islam : In Islam we have 3 aspects : Al-Islam (=Fiqh which is Jurisprudence), Al-Imen (=Aqidah which is Belief) and Al-Ihsan (=Spirituality) (See the hadith of "Gabriel" in Sahih Muslim) The Ulemas (scholars of Islam) diverged among those 3 aspect so the ijmah (which is the consensus) of the Ulemas (scholars) conclude to a divergence accepted, as a result ALL muslims that FOLLOW ANY OF those MADHAHIBS (Schools of Thoughts) are in the right path (Ahl Sunnah which is the people who follow the tradition of the Prophet Muhammed Peace be upon Him) 1-Fiqh = 4 Madhab, Maliki, Shaffi, Hanbali and Hanafi 2-Aqidah = 3 Madhab, Ash'ari, Maturidi and Athari 3-Ihsan = 2 Madhab, Sufi and Not Sufi For example : Imam An-Nawawi was : Fiqh : Madhab Shaffi Aqidah : Madhab Ash'ari Ihsan : Sufi Imam Ibn Tamiyyah was : Fiqh : Madhab Hanbali Aqidah : Madhab Athari Ihsan : Not Sufi Imam Ibn Ashir was : Fiqh : Madhab Maliki Aqidah : Madhab Ash'ari Ihsan : Sufi Imam Abu al-Layth al-Samarqandi was : Fiqh : Madhab Hanafite Aqidah : Madhab Maturidi Ihsan : Sufi ... ATTENTION : *The sahabas (the companions) and the tabi'ins (the followers of the companions) and taba'tabi'ins (the followers of the followers of the companions) did not thinks over that (schools of Aqidah) because they were mutashabih (ambiguous) which is accept the verse or the hadith as it is and do not says anythings more. They do not said of for example that's the Face of Allah is attribute or NOT of Allah. But when many ideologies like the Greck philosophy in Palestine & Lebanon & Egypt, the Latin philosophy in Spain, the Hindu philosophy in Inde the Christian philosophy in Egypt and the Zoroastrian philosophy in Perse begin to rise and bring a lot of muslims to misguidance and kufr. BY NECESSITY, the muslims scholars had to give answers to those questions wich concern in the majority about qadr (destiny), free-will and attributes, and as a result the Ummah and the Ijmah among the scholars conclude to 3 schools of thoughts which are all FROM the SUNNAH : Asharis, Maturidi and Atharis *The sahabas and the tabi'ins and taba'tab'ins did not thinks over that (schools of Fiqh) because they were a little bit, and they had not to do that., so each Ulemas makes their own opinions and basically their own madhab, so the people lived by that, but because of the deviant thoughts that's were going on the muslim world and the increase of the muslim community BY NECESSITY, the muslims scholars had to make madhab which Ulemas can now give interpretation and fix opinion based on holy principe wich as known today as the 4 madhahibs : Maliki, Shaffi, Hanbali and Hanafi *Many people now are ignorant and do not fully understand what Sufism is. Sufism represents above all a path towards the greatest degrees of piety, in this path several components are developed such as: asceticism, trust in Allah, renunciation of the soul, fear of Allah etc... And some write and describe their ideas in order to reach these components, understand them and apply them while others prefer to focus only on a personal path so everyone must develop "alone" (without necessarily writing methodological texts to achieve it). Today unfortunately many deviate from the path of the sunnah, and call themselves Sufis while they are not, those people are not considered Sufis in the same way as the elders like An-Nawawi or Al-Ghazali , they are just deviants and follow their passions. *The 4 legal schools, the 3 theological schools agree on 90 to 95% of the religion, they diverge on very external points, such as for example for the legal schools the position of the hands in prayer, or the one who eats or drinks during Ramadan without doing it on purpose must make up for his fast or not, etc... And the same for theological schools they differ on certain things about the attributes of Allah etc... For Sufis and non-Sufis, they just differ on how to achieve the highest degree of piety. *Throughout Islamic history, there has never been war or bloodshed over attending school. There were only debates between scholars but otherwise Muslims lived peacefully with these differences and were tolerant. *Any Muslim who are Muqqalid (wich is not being a scholar) has to follow ONE madhab in each aspect that's he wants, but it is preferable that he follows the most majority school in his country for practical reasons , and he cannot pick and choose. And for Muslim who are Mujtahid (which is being a scholar) he can choose between the madhahibs because he has the knowledge to go in dept to the argument of each madhab and being sincere in those research and the science. *Now in the last 200 years a movement in Saudi Arabi born and says that now its not correct and we should only follow what we says (the ulemas of Saudi Arabia) and then it began to born the wahabi sect who deviates from the salafs (the ancient scholars) and the right path, they are in picking opinion from all the schools (in fiqh, in aqidah in ihsan) and pick what they want to impose in the muslim community, they take the overwhelming majority of their opinions from the schools: Fiqh: Madhab Hanbali, Aqidah: Madhab Athari, Ihsan: Not Sufi, and as the hadith says they are like the khawarij (extremists) : The Prophet of Islam (peace and blessings be upon him) had said after blessing all the regions except the Najd plateau: “From the Najd will rise the horn of Satan” [Reported in the Sahih al-Bukhârî: Hadîth 558 (p 108) the book of prayer for obtaining rain in “the summary of the sahih al-bukhârî” Volume I, by Imam Zein Ed-Dine Ahmed ibn Abdul-Latif A -Zoubaidi.] The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) had said: there will come out of Najd people who only understand the exterior of the Qur'An, the meaning of the Qur'An does not reach their hearts.....This is to allude to the Khawârijthe followers of the followers of the companions [Reported by Al-Bukhari in his chapter on lost sects]
They have no problem doing what which was not commanded in the Quran and which is not shown in Hadith yet have no problem doing what is forbidden by the Quran and Hadith like taking a mortgage/loan & paying interest/ribah/sood
In India, Shias and different groups of Muslims coming out to streets on Miladunnabi blocking roads and playing songs like gangsters. This is exactly how the Hindus celebrate their festivals. May Allah SWT guide us all. Ameen
The most clear cut evidence against it is that we’re not 100% sure when the prophet was born. If it was a big thing then it wouldn’t been a discussion as to when the prophet was born. 🤷🏽♂️
Emotions need to take the back seat to facts. Our deen is clear all praise to Allah. In the prophet we have the greatest of guides peace and blessings upon him. We don't need more, there is no more to add to a perfect guidance. May Allah guide the brother its clear he is putting forth a great effort to learn, may Allah sorround him with those who will put him on a straight path and the way of the salaf, the way of the Prophet peace and blessings upon him.
@@MM-bu9ir Keep saying that you yourself as Conor in this version was definitely Asrhad 😂 Any seeing this go and see the debate Abdul Rehman v Arshad rashid simple as that
This guy says you will be punished for reading durood whilst Allah swt innallaha wa malaikitahu ya saluna alan nabi ya ayu halaazena amanu Sallu alayhi wa salimu taslima. This guy should refute what the Saudi leaders are doing if he's a real shaykh and not refute sending durood on the prophet
Mawlid is jaiz and great. There is nothing problem in pointing out a date. We dont have a problem with people not attending mawlid, but there is a standard. If its haram tell us how specifying a date is haram. Again, specifying a date is not wrong. Get me a hadith on that
Whomever Allah guides, no one can lead him astray. Whomever Allah sends astray, no one can guide him. The truest word is the Book of Allah, and the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The evilest matters in religion are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation, every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.”
17:40 What if people are gathering and remembering him in a way that is displeasing to Allah. There are certainly some forms of worship that are displeasing to Allah, such as adding or omitting rakats from fard salah. So who can then try and say that all worship is good worship? Truly a boy of his desires
If i hold gatheri g of dhikr and remembrance of holy prophet pbhu tomorrow maybenot many people would come as oppose to the specific date on which he was born that is the state of todays people where as sahaba would come everyday to see tha face of the beloved and learn about him
oh ignorant people sahabas had the blessed destiny to see and be with the beloved 24/7 but all we have are these gatherings which should be held in our hearts everyday we cannot even fathom how drenched the sahabas were in love with the prophet khalid bin walid stiched the prophets hair in his turban did that mean he understood more than khulaafa rashidun no
Why dont the Bidati people start making Azan on Eid prayer and Janaza prayer too since Azan is a vig blessing. We ONLY DO and DONT what the Prophet SAID from Evidences. Not an inch out of the ⭕
Okay I have a question when does it become an innovation does it become an innovation when you do it specifically on the 12th what about if somebody attends gatherings of commemoration throughout the entire year like every single Thursday or every single Friday when does it specifically become a biddah because of celebrating the birthday what is believed to be the best day is an innovation and there should be no problem with having gatherings of commemoration during the week for example not necessarily doing rabbi a awal
Brother Uthman Farooq is a Talib with incredible Knowledge but he is NOT a Shaikh yet. May Allah SWT bless our Dawah brethren with an abundance of khair in duniya and akhira Ameen Ya Rabb ❤
Celebration of mawlid is neither part of faith or religion. It is clearly bidah. Youll not die nor will you be questioned if you don't celebrate it. Don't waste time and money on this unfruitful act. Don't make a door for fitnah. Don't try to overperform Prophet pbuh. Trash who have yet to perfect salah should shut it and keep quiet. No grave worshipping either. Note to do well and don't act oversmart.period.
can asnyone explaine to me why these type of videos have a person inserting a video of themselfes into video literally adding zero value to it but in fact taking away from it.
Assalamu Alaikum!
Please share and spread the Dawah.
If you wish to donate: t.ly/Xpqey (PayPal). This channel isn't monetized.
@WJ-ng5dc 1. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself observed his birthday by fasting every Monday. This shows that he acknowledged the significance of his birth. Fasting on Mondays, which he explained was in gratitude for his birth, is a form of celebration, even though it may not resemble modern-day practices.
2. The significance of Friday as an Eid (celebration day) in Islam: The Prophet (peace be upon him) explained that Friday is significant because it was the day Allah created Adam and the day Adam passed away. If Friday is a celebration for the creation of Adam, how much more deserving is the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, whose status is higher than Adam, to be a day of celebration?
3. Allah instructs us in the Qur'an to celebrate His blessings and mercy: In Surah Yunus (10:58), Allah says, “Say: In the bounty of Allah and in His mercy - in that let them rejoice.” The birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is one of the greatest manifestations of Allah's mercy to mankind. Therefore, it is only fitting to celebrate his birth as a sign of gratitude.
4. Celebrating the Prophet's birth should not be seen as an innovation (bid'ah): Just because something wasn't celebrated in a formal way during the time of the Sahaba doesn't necessarily mean it is wrong. By this logic, many aspects of modern life would also be considered impermissible. New ways of expressing love for the Prophet, as long as they don't contradict Islamic principles, can be seen as valid.
5. Celebrating national independence days is widely accepted, but the Prophet’s birth is even more significant: Just as countries celebrate the day they gained independence, the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the day when the world received the greatest blessing and liberation through his message. If people celebrate independence days, why shouldn't we celebrate the birth of the one who brought spiritual independence to humanity?
6. Rejecting the celebration of the Prophet's birthday could be seen as disregarding his importance: The birth of the Prophet is a major blessing for the entire world. By refusing to celebrate it, one might be missing out on recognizing the profound significance of his coming into this world.
These are some points capture the reasons why many Muslims believe celebrating the Prophet's birthday is not only permissible but also a way to express love, gratitude, and reverence for the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him).
Amin y’a rab 🙏
he didnt cook anyone.
@@AlphaMaverick1111 he knew he was cooked that's why he needed to run
@@_ibnmuhammad No one got cooked, the only ones getting cooked are the zios who the madkhalis try to tell us we should sign peace treaties with. Madkhalis fight other Muslims and say boycotting starbucks is haram while what happens in Gaza continues. We reject madkhalism. Enjoy the cook offs on them merkavas btw. On youm ul qiyamah may i be raised alongside Shaykh Izzaddin (of Shaam/Palestine), and may those madkhalis who continue to fight Muslims be raised with Mileikowsky the kazzab.
May Allah protect us from people of bidah and keep us firm on Qu'ran & Sunnah
قال ابن القيم رحمه الله :
وقال لي شيخ الإسلام رضي الله عنه - وقد جعلت أورد عليه إيراداً بعد إيرادٍ - :
" لا تجعل قلبك للإيرادات والشبهات مثل السفنجة ، فيتشربها ، فلا ينضح إلا بها ، ولكن اجعله كالزجاجة المصمتة تمر الشبهات بظاهرها ، ولا تستقر فيها ، فيراها بصفائه ويدفعها بصلابته ، وإلا فإذا أشربت قلبك كل شبهة تمر عليها صار مقرا للشبهات "
" مفتاح دار السعادة " ( 1 / 140 ) .
ونقل الإمام الذهبي رحمه الله عن سفيان الثوري رحمه الله قولَه :
" من سمع ببدعة فلا يحكها لجلسائه ، لا يلقها في قلوبهم " .
Tasawuf is not bidah ya wahabbi
Compilation of quran good bidah by companions does that mean rasoolAllah forgot to tell us things
آمین
WHat absolutely boggles my mind is when the Shaykh states that the Mawlid isnt replicated, advised , suggested by the Prophet ( saws) the Sahabas and the 4 Ulimahs ; and yet after the brother accepeting this truth... he then proceeds to talk about nuonced and vagueness and nothing is clear cut. If you think its such a great idea and your doing more Ibadah He should read 4 rakahs Maghrib ! ,.. well the prophet didnt say not to do that lol , and technically it is more Ibadah. .... If any of the Sahabas where alive today,.. they would be bemused by what the muslims quarrel over !
Have to say akhi, this is probably the best example one could give.
The four imams never said it was haram. The four madhabs allow it. Najdi petrodollars only celebrate sword dancing with Trump.
What an explanation by Shaykh. May Allah grant him more knowledge and jannatul aa'la
He walked into that one 😂
A man sneezed next to Sayyidunā ‘Abd ullāh Ibn ‘Umar رضي الله عنه and said:
"praise be to Allāh and peace be upon the Messenger of Allāh"
Ibn ‘Umar رضي الله عنه said:
“I too (other times) say; 'praise be to Allāh and peace be upon the Messenger of Allāh',
but this is not what Rusūlullāh ﷺ taught us (after sneezing), rather he taught us to say:
'Praise be to Allāh in all circumstances'.”
Recorded: Sunan Tirmithy, 2738 - Mustadrak Ḥākim, 4, p 265
Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ
It was asked of Salmān Al Fārisy رضي الله عنه:
"Your Prophet taught you everything? even what to do when using the toilet?"
he replied:
"Yes, he forbade us from facing the Qiblah and to clean ourselves afterwards using the right hand"
Recorded: Ṣaḥīḥ Musslim, 4, 224
Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ
" 'Abd ullāh ibn ‘Abbās saw Mu’āwiyah ibn Abi Sufyān رضي الله عنهم touching the two northern corners of the Ka’bah, and he told him not to do that.
Mu’āwiyah said to him:
“No part of the House should be ignored."
Ibn ‘Abbās said:
"Indeed is for you in the Messenger of Allāh an exemplar of goodness” al Aḥzāb: 21.
"And I saw the Prophet ﷺ touching the two Yamany corners”
Mu’āwiyah then accepted what Ibn ‘Abbās said."
Recorded: Sharh Usool I'tiqad Ahl as-Sunnah wa al-Jamaa - Mussnad Aḥmad
Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ
Sa’īd Ibn al Musayyib رضي الله عنه saw a man praying too many optional prayers before the Fajr prayer and therefore he forbade him from doing so. The man retorted:
"O Abu Muḥammad, Will Allāh punish me for praying?"
Sa'īd replied:
"No, but He will punish you for doing other than the Sunnah."
Recorded: Mussnad Aḥmad, 188
Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ
Huthayfah Ibn al Yamān رحمه الله said:
"Do not perform any act of worship which was not practiced by the companions of the Prophet ﷺ because the early people did not leave anything unaddressed.
so follow the way of those who were before you.
Recorded: Al Ibānah
Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ
Sufyān ath Thawry رحمه الله said:
"An innovation is dearer to Shayṭān than a sin, for one can easily repent from a sin, but an innovation is not easily repented from."
Recorded: Al Muḥaddith Al Fāsil
Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ
A man asked Mālik bin Anas رحمه الله:
"At which point do I initiate my state of Iḥrām?"
he replied:
"From Thul Hulayfah, where the Prophet ﷺ did so"
the man retorted:
"I wish to do it from the area beside the grave of the Prophet ﷺ"
Mālik said:
"Do not do that, for I fear that if you do so, you will be afflicted with trials"
the man replied:
"Why would I be afflicted with trials? All I wanted was to do it from a place which is only a few miles away from where you told me!"
Mālik said upon hearing this:
"What can be more serious than feeling that you performed a righteous deed that the Prophet ﷺ failed to do?
I heard the words of Allāh:
“So let those beware who dissent from his order lest trials strike them or a painful punishment.” an Nūr: 63
Recorded: Al Bā’ith ‘alā inkāril bid’a wal hawādith, 91
Grade: Ṣaḥīḥ
This is just a snippet of the statements of the salaf...
Jazaka’Allahu khair akhi I really appreciated that you went out of your way to do this but could you give the reference please. It would make it a lot easier since I’m on my phone rn and not on a computer and I’d have to do more research just to see where it’s from
@@rickfox804 @rickfox804 1: Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2738
2: Jami` at-Tirmidhi 16
3: i couldn't find the exact one but Sahih al-Bukhari 1608 is simmilar and Sunan an-Nasa'i 2948 and Sunan an-Nasa'i 2950 give more emphasis on the Prophet's ﷺ action
4: Al-Bayhaqī, As-Sunan Al-Kubraa 2:466
5: Abu Dawud
6: not sure but i found a quotation from abdurrahman org that it can be found in Sharh Usool I'tiqaad
7: cant find anything
@WJ-ng5dc 1. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself observed his birthday by fasting every Monday. This shows that he acknowledged the significance of his birth. Fasting on Mondays, which he explained was in gratitude for his birth, is a form of celebration, even though it may not resemble modern-day practices.
2. The significance of Friday as an Eid (celebration day) in Islam: The Prophet (peace be upon him) explained that Friday is significant because it was the day Allah created Adam and the day Adam passed away. If Friday is a celebration for the creation of Adam, how much more deserving is the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, whose status is higher than Adam, to be a day of celebration?
3. Allah instructs us in the Qur'an to celebrate His blessings and mercy: In Surah Yunus (10:58), Allah says, “Say: In the bounty of Allah and in His mercy - in that let them rejoice.” The birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is one of the greatest manifestations of Allah's mercy to mankind. Therefore, it is only fitting to celebrate his birth as a sign of gratitude.
4. Celebrating the Prophet's birth should not be seen as an innovation (bid'ah): Just because something wasn't celebrated in a formal way during the time of the Sahaba doesn't necessarily mean it is wrong. By this logic, many aspects of modern life would also be considered impermissible. New ways of expressing love for the Prophet, as long as they don't contradict Islamic principles, can be seen as valid.
5. Celebrating national independence days is widely accepted, but the Prophet’s birth is even more significant: Just as countries celebrate the day they gained independence, the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the day when the world received the greatest blessing and liberation through his message. If people celebrate independence days, why shouldn't we celebrate the birth of the one who brought spiritual independence to humanity?
6. Rejecting the celebration of the Prophet's birthday could be seen as disregarding his importance: The birth of the Prophet is a major blessing for the entire world. By refusing to celebrate it, one might be missing out on recognizing the profound significance of his coming into this world.
These are some points capture the reasons why many Muslims believe celebrating the Prophet's birthday is not only permissible but also a way to express love, gratitude, and reverence for the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him).
@@moizuddin6932 Fasting on Mondays means it's NOT a celebration. Because we're instructed not to fast on celebration days like Fridays or Eid days. So, instead of celebrating 12th of Rabi Ul Awal, why don't you fast on Mondays. Make it important the way the prophet (alayhi salam) made it important. Don't invent a new way.
Can you compile all these statements into a pdf and post somewhere?
JazakAllahKhair
It might be painful to hear what the Shaikh is saying but it’s the truth. We can’t pretend to love the prophet more then companions did. They are the best of example.
@@WJ-ng5dc 1. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself observed his birthday by fasting every Monday. This shows that he acknowledged the significance of his birth. Fasting on Mondays, which he explained was in gratitude for his birth, is a form of celebration, even though it may not resemble modern-day practices.
2. The significance of Friday as an Eid (celebration day) in Islam: The Prophet (peace be upon him) explained that Friday is significant because it was the day Allah created Adam and the day Adam passed away. If Friday is a celebration for the creation of Adam, how much more deserving is the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, whose status is higher than Adam, to be a day of celebration?
3. Allah instructs us in the Qur'an to celebrate His blessings and mercy: In Surah Yunus (10:58), Allah says, “Say: In the bounty of Allah and in His mercy - in that let them rejoice.” The birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is one of the greatest manifestations of Allah's mercy to mankind. Therefore, it is only fitting to celebrate his birth as a sign of gratitude.
4. Celebrating the Prophet's birth should not be seen as an innovation (bid'ah): Just because something wasn't celebrated in a formal way during the time of the Sahaba doesn't necessarily mean it is wrong. By this logic, many aspects of modern life would also be considered impermissible. New ways of expressing love for the Prophet, as long as they don't contradict Islamic principles, can be seen as valid.
5. Celebrating national independence days is widely accepted, but the Prophet’s birth is even more significant: Just as countries celebrate the day they gained independence, the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the day when the world received the greatest blessing and liberation through his message. If people celebrate independence days, why shouldn't we celebrate the birth of the one who brought spiritual independence to humanity?
6. Rejecting the celebration of the Prophet's birthday could be seen as disregarding his importance: The birth of the Prophet is a major blessing for the entire world. By refusing to celebrate it, one might be missing out on recognizing the profound significance of his coming into this world.
These are some points capture the reasons why many Muslims believe celebrating the Prophet's birthday is not only permissible but also a way to express love, gratitude, and reverence for the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him).
. 😠CHALLENGE😠 .
EID-MILAD-UN-NABIﷺ MANANA JAAYIZ Nahi Hai,
Koyi QURAN-O-HADEES Se SABIT Kar Kay Dikhawoo😏
QURAN-O-HADEES Ka FAISILAH Hai:-👇👇👇
Kissi Bhi Cheiz Kay NA-JAAYIZ Honay Kay Liyae QURAN-O-HADEES Ki DALEEL Hona ZAROORI Hai
(Yani Jisko QURAN-O-HADEES Ne
NA-JAAYIZ Nahi Kaha,Woh Karna JAAYIZ Hai)👌👌👌
Lahaza,Jab QURAN-O-HADEES Ne
EID-MILAD-UN-NABIﷺ MANANA
NA-JAAYIZ Nahi Kaha,Ab Jo Bhi
EID-MILAD-UN-NABIﷺ MANANA
NA-JAAYIZ Kahay Ga,To Samijh Lijiyae,
Woh SHATAAN Hai,
Kyun Ki QURAN-O-HADEES Kay Khilaaf SHATAAN Hi Bool Sakhta Hai 📌📌📌
I was wondering the same thing about celebrating the prophet's birthday 'salatu as salaam' and brother Uthman Farooq answered the question quite clearly! Thank you so much.
What is so hard to understand. If you want to "celebrate" mawlid with just salawat and dzikr, Rasulullah SAW told us to do that and practice his sunnah every day. Not sanction it to a specific day. And the main teachings of the Prophet SAW has always been to worship Allah SWT, not finding obscure opinions to celebrate his birthday. You want to send peace and blessings to the prophet and his family, do it everyday as the Prophet taught us, along side every other ibadat that is waajib.
Yes but i believe its about intentions too. Allahu alim
@ where did the Prophet (pbuh) or any of his companions set a specific day just for the intention to celebrate himself or anyone else? And for what?
Notice how before asking about his bid'ah, he tried to embarrass Sheikh by asking him a very specific and fringe question about grammar to try and undermine his knowledge.
This is something more and more common with the students of Ahlul bid'ah, and why we as students of knowledge must really strive to have strong Arabic and Quran and Usool as well as Aqeedah and fiqh
Ameen. 100% I clocked that straight away.
I’m not sure akhi. It seemed he came to ask the 1 question and was almost ready to leave. This act of mawlid must be ingrained in him since childhood and he knows he can’t leave it or he loses all his family this is usually the case.
don't assume bad things, and things you have no knowledge of brother.
Wow what a refutation Masha ALLAH.
I am from a city in the subcontinent where grave worship is rampant especially amongst the illiterate masses. When you try to reason with them they get emotional. The caller in this video is not too different from them. May Allah guide us all to the way of Quran, Sunnah and the Salaf.
Wallahi you don't even realize the crazy thing you just said, delete it. You just compared worshipers, with people who praise The Messager of Allah.
@@hamidaqueue5973 you are crazy. What he said is true.
So you'll eat haram and then praising prophet pbuh and think it's okay? Use brain aqq.
@hamidaqueue5973 ever heard the term "bid'ah" ? Is not something to take lightly. It leads to hell.
@@UnchainedSlaveJahil, Mawlid was validate by scholars and has proof in the Qur'An and Sunnah
Yes these grave worshippers go to graves and ask the dead to bless them amd forgive them..
Don forget to do dhikr today bros
Even chatGPT doesn't find this "nuanced" because this is what it answered me with :
" The origins and observance of Mawlid developed over several centuries within Islamic culture and history.
Early Islamic Period
During the Prophet Muhammad's lifetime and the era of the early caliphs, the Prophet's birthday was not celebrated as a formal event. The emphasis in early Islam was on following the Prophet’s teachings and practicing his Sunnah (traditions).
Development of Mawlid in the Islamic Timeline
Fatimid Dynasty (10th-12th Century CE): The origins of formal Mawlid celebrations trace back to the Fatimids, a Shia dynasty ruling Egypt and parts of North Africa. They were the first to introduce public celebrations marking significant Islamic dates, including the birth of the Prophet Muhammad. However, their intent was partly political, as they aimed to strengthen their rule by encouraging public gatherings.
Sunni Muslim Adoption (12th-13th Century CE): The celebration of Mawlid spread into Sunni communities, particularly in Egypt and Syria, where it took on a more widespread and devotional nature. The festival was embraced by the Ayyubid dynasty, especially under Sultan al-Malik al-Muẓaffar of Irbil (in modern-day Iraq). He is often credited with organizing grand Mawlid celebrations, with festivities that included sermons, poetry, and feasting."
My humble conclusion is that celebrating 'Al Mawlid' comes from a Fatimid Shia practice that has sadly infiltrated sunni Muslims lives. But we must always go back to the roots of our deen since if the Prophet P.B.U.H himself didn't tell the sahabah to celebrate, than who are we to make these judgements and continue a wrong Shia-based practice?
May Allah swt make it easy for all of us and bless Shaykh Uthman for his hard work.
They just can't seem to accept the fact u can't celebrate mawlid even with proof and then wants to refute it..such arrogance Allah guide him
Celebrate anything is halal but not mawlid then this just Wahabi ideology not Islam.
@@thethickandthinBetter than your deoband and Barelvi garbage. Trash.
what a disrespectful kid
backbiting akhi, becarefull with your good deeds
@hamidaqueue5973 that's not backbiting, we are watching a video where the brother got a bit rude interrupting the sheikh, he commented on the video pointing out that the brother is disrespectful, that does not amount to backbiting but inshallah your intentions are pure as are mine. ALLAH knows best. Salam
@@aj1608 backbiting its saying about your brother in islam when he is not here what he would NOT* like to hear, he did that
@@hamidaqueue5973he is telling fact and you are the idiot one we are using social media how can he stand with us 🤡
@@hamidaqueue5973 that isn’t backbiting lol
notice how he said 'sheikh', then quickly changed to 'brother'?
Subhanallah!
But the fact that's when someone is disrespecting the ulemas and make them as little child who have not read all the proof from what mawlid can be not halal, its a sign of great jahiliya to says that's they have no knowledge of that. So the brother sees that instantly and change his mind about what he thinks about brother uthman...
@@hamidaqueue5973jaahil, there are only two eids, if this celebration was valid show it from islamic literature.
@@UnchainedSlave akhi they have write about why they thinks its halal its not because you are jahil about it that's means there is not proff
@@UnchainedSlave follow your passion
I don’t like these sneaky type of muslims. Well played shaykh
Anytime someone wants to be blurred in the frame, we know what time it is.
my country need this kind of dawah.
the bidah is very strong here.
one of the bigest muslim population country
My Sheikh Uthman is almost always on point with his Evidences Ma'Sha'Allah Alhumdullilah Allahu-Akbar. Jazakallah Khair Ustad for ahutting down the Bidati people
I will definitely share this video inshallah ❤
Someone should ask this guy why not pray 5 rakats for Maghrib, it's ibaadat still right?
Great point!
I have seen a mawlid celebration in a masjid where fard salah was delayed and shortened so that the congregation can have more time singing nasheeds. I try to avoid going to that masjid if possible where they made every ibadat seem so difficult, except obligatory salah which they speed though. They even have lengthy dua's after every adzan and iqamah before salah, when I am already pressed for time as I have to go to work immediately after.
Later scholars if they oppose salaf we prefer the salaf. Mawlid came from Obaidi fatimid shia sect. They used to celebrate mawlid of ashab al qisa i.e. Hassan, Hussain, Ali, Fatima and nabi A.S.
Its not like that that islamic science works... Get knowledge akhi !!
@@hamidaqueue5973Then show mawlid from Quran, Hadith, Seerah, early taarique or from practices of tabiyeen and salafi.
U are questioner indeed. Shaitain is playing with u
These innovators are so stubborn that they cannot give up their bid'ah..
It is the innovators who say that the prophet fasted on his birthday. Meanwhile, they are the ones who eat on this day.
Allah and his angels send durood and Salaam on the prophet pbuh, o you who believe you too send durood and Salaam on the prophet pbuh. Allah swt most High most Merciful has clearly stated this in the holy quran, now Allah swt has not stated how much one should read nor when one should read so if one does read and send salutations durood and Salaam on the best of creation as ordered In the holy quran how on earth can this milk shaikh say that you would be punished fir something Allah swt and his angels do, These wahabi shaykhs don't realise on the day of judgement when we all run to the prophet pbuh to intercede for us do they really think by saying you will be punished for something Allah swt has ordered us to do in the quran and does himself is a direct violation of Allah's laws and commands. So brothers take heed these guys may look all knowledgeable but so is shaytaan he has a tight grip on the wahabi World, they claim to love the prophet but deny him in the same breath, Allah swt loves the prophet pbuh so much so that he told us how many obligatory prayers we should read and put a number on it told us how many months are in a year told us how many times we do tawaf during the holy seasons even told us the number of sunnah fard or nawafil to read see numbers in all types of his own worship are mentioned but when it comes to sending durood and Salaam he Allah swt never limited it to a specific number, rather it's limitless in its origin, can one imagine how many durood and salaam Allah and his angels send. Do dont be fooled b these not do learned shaykhs who try to bypass the prophet pbuh however will run to him on the day of judgement themselves
Salam alaikum wa rehmat Allah
You roasted him.....
Allah give him and me and all hidayat
Greetings from Copenhagen Denmark ❤
The guy is obviously trying to close his eye to the truth ..i was also doing maulid beforr but it took me years to idnetify and realise the truth that it was bidya and i had to swallow my pride and stop because loving your prophet and followung gods guidance is better than inventing things on your own which are not in the religion
الحمدلله على الإتباع وعدم الإبتداع
It's always the soft spoken ones that are some of the most deceptive!
I'm American and a convert
I've been in Egypt for 10 years
I've seen dancing and a lot of Haram stuff.
This guy isn't being honest
Mashallah Shaikh for the beautiful clarification. I love you for the sake of Allah brother. ❤❤❤❤❤
may Allah guide the deviants
Guide them to *God Logic* podcasts are just Shia vs Sunni vs Sufi……
There should be no division amongst true believers
@@leolionroarrrrrrr5509
*1 Corinthians 11:19*
his favourite word is Nuance
Alhamdulillah the last few evidences absolute clarity! Just to add as far as I remember there is a narration of Abdullah ibn umar cursing ones who elongate the adhaan, thus proving even a nuance of change in this religion is destruction
I just love it when sheik explains thingd and bring evidence from quran again
You have done your job by making it very clear to him. Only those who want to follow ASSUNNAH will abide by it.
اللهم اجعلنا من المتبعين ولا تجعلنا من المبتدعين
In malaysia and indonesia, maulid celebrated with dancing and entertainment that not related to prophet saw, this is exactly what christians doing during christmas celebration.
My question to ahlul bidah is if you celebrate mawlid to express the love for Muhammad pbuh. Why don't you celebrate mahram like the shia to express the love for ahlul bayt?
Because it doesn't has proof from the qur'an and the sunnah, and the ulemas doesn't says that's halal. Simple man.
Mawlid doesn't have any proof either@@hamidaqueue5973
@@hamidaqueue5973 where did you get proof to celebrate mawlid on 12 rabiul awal?🤣
@@mdshahadat-o3z look the witings from Ibn Tamiyya, Ibn Hajar, An-Nawawi, Ibn Al-Jawzi, Abu Shama, and As-Souyouti
@@hamidaqueue5973 bro Their opinion is not proof.when i said proof i meant quran or hadith.
Show me if prophet Muhammad pbuh or any sahaba or anyone from 4 imam or bukhari,muslim (ra) any mujtahid from 1st 3 century celebrated mawlid...
I may not agree with Shaykh Uthman on everything but this caller is very disrespectful! To try and catch someone out on Arabic grammar is very very snidey! It shows that he was trying to have a "GOTCHA" moment with Shaykh Uthman. Not only that he said he studies in Egypt. So why isn't he asking his lecturers at uni about this?
He starts the call by saying he has a Masala that no one can answer and he's struggling to find and answer. Here's me thinking it's going to be a serious question 😂 It ends up being an Arabic grammar test to try and catch the Shaykh out. Wallahi what an insincere brother.
I mean if you're studying in Egypt and you can't find an answer to these questions you should go back home bro
@@MrGee2468 exactly!!! Found him so disrespectful
@SlaveofAllahhh totally agree people like that brother are pretty disgusting but Allah exposes them and their character while they don't even realize it bc of their arrogance.....
And what do u disagree with Sheikh Uthman on?
Assalamu Alikum. Unfortunately sounds like most Christian’s you debate with. They put up a wall and don’t want to listen with an open heart. May Allah guide us all. Ameen
Sheikh Sulayman ar Ruhayli حفظه الله said: "Ask him (i.e innovator), did the Messenger of Allah ﷺ leave off something of the religion and did not do it nor clarify it? If he says yes, then he has disbelieved. If he says no, then he has established proof against himself."
For those uninitiated in Islam :
In Islam we have 3 aspects : Al-Islam (=Fiqh which is Jurisprudence), Al-Imen (=Aqidah which is Belief) and Al-Ihsan (=Spirituality) (See the hadith of "Gabriel" in Sahih Muslim)
The Ulemas (scholars of Islam) diverged among those 3 aspect so the ijmah (which is the consensus) of the Ulemas (scholars) conclude to a divergence accepted, as a result ALL muslims that FOLLOW ANY OF those MADHAHIBS (Schools of Thoughts) are in the right path (Ahl Sunnah which is the people who follow the tradition of the Prophet Muhammed Peace be upon Him)
1-Fiqh = 4 Madhab, Maliki, Shaffi, Hanbali and Hanafi
2-Aqidah = 3 Madhab, Ash'ari, Maturidi and Athari
3-Ihsan = 2 Madhab, Sufi and Not Sufi
For example :
Imam An-Nawawi was :
Fiqh : Madhab Shaffi
Aqidah : Madhab Ash'ari
Ihsan : Sufi
Imam Ibn Tamiyyah was :
Fiqh : Madhab Hanbali
Aqidah : Madhab Athari
Ihsan : Not Sufi
Imam Ibn Ashir was :
Fiqh : Madhab Maliki
Aqidah : Madhab Ash'ari
Ihsan : Sufi
Imam Abu al-Layth al-Samarqandi was :
Fiqh : Madhab Hanafite
Aqidah : Madhab Maturidi
Ihsan : Sufi
...
ATTENTION :
*The sahabas (the companions) and the tabi'ins (the followers of the companions) and taba'tabi'ins (the followers of the followers of the companions) did not thinks over that (schools of Aqidah) because they were mutashabih (ambiguous) which is accept the verse or the hadith as it is and do not says anythings more. They do not said of for example that's the Face of Allah is attribute or NOT of Allah. But when many ideologies like the Greck philosophy in Palestine & Lebanon & Egypt, the Latin philosophy in Spain, the Hindu philosophy in Inde the Christian philosophy in Egypt and the Zoroastrian philosophy in Perse begin to rise and bring a lot of muslims to misguidance and kufr.
BY NECESSITY, the muslims scholars had to give answers to those questions wich concern in the majority about qadr (destiny), free-will and attributes, and as a result the Ummah and the Ijmah among the scholars conclude to 3 schools of thoughts which are all FROM the SUNNAH : Asharis, Maturidi and Atharis
*The sahabas and the tabi'ins and taba'tab'ins did not thinks over that (schools of Fiqh) because they were a little bit, and they had not to do that., so each Ulemas makes their own opinions and basically their own madhab, so the people lived by that, but because of the deviant thoughts that's were going on the muslim world and the increase of the muslim community BY NECESSITY, the muslims scholars had to make madhab which Ulemas can now give interpretation and fix opinion based on holy principe wich as known today as the 4 madhahibs : Maliki, Shaffi, Hanbali and Hanafi
*Many people now are ignorant and do not fully understand what Sufism is. Sufism represents above all a path towards the greatest degrees of piety, in this path several components are developed such as: asceticism, trust in Allah, renunciation of the soul, fear of Allah etc... And some write and describe their ideas in order to reach these components, understand them and apply them while others prefer to focus only on a personal path so everyone must develop "alone" (without necessarily writing methodological texts to achieve it). Today unfortunately many deviate from the path of the sunnah, and call themselves Sufis while they are not, those people are not considered Sufis in the same way as the elders like An-Nawawi or Al-Ghazali , they are just deviants and follow their passions.
*The 4 legal schools, the 3 theological schools agree on 90 to 95% of the religion, they diverge on very external points, such as for example for the legal schools the position of the hands in prayer, or the one who eats or drinks during Ramadan without doing it on purpose must make up for his fast or not, etc... And the same for theological schools they differ on certain things about the attributes of Allah etc... For Sufis and non-Sufis, they just differ on how to achieve the highest degree of piety.
*Throughout Islamic history, there has never been war or bloodshed over attending school. There were only debates between scholars but otherwise Muslims lived peacefully with these differences and were tolerant.
*Any Muslim who are Muqqalid (wich is not being a scholar) has to follow ONE madhab in each aspect that's he wants, but it is preferable that he follows the most majority school in his country for practical reasons , and he cannot pick and choose. And for Muslim who are Mujtahid (which is being a scholar) he can choose between the madhahibs because he has the knowledge to go in dept to the argument of each madhab and being sincere in those research and the science.
*Now in the last 200 years a movement in Saudi Arabi born and says that now its not correct and we should only follow what we says (the ulemas of Saudi Arabia) and then it began to born the wahabi sect who deviates from the salafs (the ancient scholars) and the right path, they are in picking opinion from all the schools (in fiqh, in aqidah in ihsan) and pick what they want to impose in the muslim community, they take the overwhelming majority of their opinions from the schools: Fiqh: Madhab Hanbali, Aqidah: Madhab Athari, Ihsan: Not Sufi, and as the hadith says they are like the khawarij (extremists) :
The Prophet of Islam (peace and blessings be upon him) had said after blessing all the regions except the Najd plateau: “From the Najd will rise the horn of Satan” [Reported in the Sahih al-Bukhârî: Hadîth 558 (p 108) the book of prayer for obtaining rain in “the summary of the sahih al-bukhârî” Volume I, by Imam Zein Ed-Dine Ahmed ibn Abdul-Latif A -Zoubaidi.]
The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) had said: there will come out of Najd people who only understand the exterior of the Qur'An, the meaning of the Qur'An does not reach their hearts.....This is to allude to the Khawârijthe followers of the followers of the companions
[Reported by Al-Bukhari in his chapter on lost sects]
أعاذنا الله من البدع في ديننا الجميل
They have no problem doing what which was not commanded in the Quran and which is not shown in Hadith yet have no problem doing what is forbidden by the Quran and Hadith like taking a mortgage/loan & paying interest/ribah/sood
The sahaba sacrificed there life for the prophet and you telling me they would not do this
Also they were perfections we need this not.
These people are cowards. Like be confident about what you believe
From where you got this video akhi ?
I want to see full session
In India, Shias and different groups of Muslims coming out to streets on Miladunnabi blocking roads and playing songs like gangsters. This is exactly how the Hindus celebrate their festivals. May Allah SWT guide us all. Ameen
اللهم صل وسلم وبارك على سيدنا محمد وآله
Skip to 4:30
Subhan Allah ❤️
Can someone send the link of the Video the sheikh talked about , for the references
The most clear cut evidence against it is that we’re not 100% sure when the prophet was born. If it was a big thing then it wouldn’t been a discussion as to when the prophet was born. 🤷🏽♂️
Haqq....🎤 ( drops mic)
Emotions need to take the back seat to facts. Our deen is clear all praise to Allah. In the prophet we have the greatest of guides peace and blessings upon him. We don't need more, there is no more to add to a perfect guidance.
May Allah guide the brother its clear he is putting forth a great effort to learn, may Allah sorround him with those who will put him on a straight path and the way of the salaf, the way of the Prophet peace and blessings upon him.
Allah guide the wobblie brothers
When desires show up, following the prophet SAW disappears.
People are asking big questions but dont even have tarbiyyah
Question: shaykh asrar Rashid from Birmingham, uk has been asking you for a debate or a dialogue. Why have you been avoiding, says a lot.
He was beaten silly in debate with andul rehman and sheik usman well above his level
@@shahidhussain9176 brother that’s like saying khabib lost to McGregor. Only in your imagination
@@MM-bu9ir
I seen the debate brother myself barelvi / Sufi lost badly
@@shahidhussain9176ye I saw the khabib fight, khabib lost badly. In my head.
@@MM-bu9ir
Keep saying that you yourself as Conor in this version was definitely Asrhad 😂
Any seeing this go and see the debate Abdul Rehman v Arshad rashid simple as that
حَدَّثَنَا أَحْمَدُ بْنُ عَمْرِو بْنِ السَّرْحِ قَالَ: أَخْبَرَنَا ابْنُ وَهْبٍ، عَنْ عَمْرِو بْنِ الْحَارِثِ، أَنَّ دَرَّاجًا أَبَا السَّمْحِ حَدَّثَهُ، عَنْ أَبِي الْهَيْثَمِ، عَنْ أَبِي سَعِيدٍ الْخُدْرِيِّ، قَالَ: خَرَجَ مُعَاوِيَةُ عَلَى حَلْقَةٍ فِي الْمَسْجِدِ، فَقَالَ: مَا أَجْلَسَكُمْ؟ قَالُوا: جَلَسْنَا نَذْكُرُ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ، قَالَ: آللَّهِ مَا أَجْلَسَكُمْ إِلَّا ذَاكَ؟ قَالُوا: وَاللَّهِ مَا أَجْلَسَنَا إِلَّا ذَاكَ، قَالَ: أَمَا إِنِّي لَمْ أَسْتَحْلِفْكُمْ تُهْمَةً لَكُمْ، وَمَا كَانَ أَحَدٌ بِمَنْزِلَتِهِ مِنْ رَسُولِ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ أَقَلَّ عَنْهُ حَدِيثًا مِنِّي، وَإِنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ خَرَجَ عَلَى حَلْقَةٍ مِنْ أَصْحَابِهِ، فَقَالَ: مَا أَجْلَسَكُمْ؟ قَالُوا: جَلَسْنَا نَذْكُرُ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ، وَنَحْمَدُهُ عَلَى مَا هَدَانَا لِلْإِسْلَامِ، وَمَنَّ بِهِ عَلَيْنَا، قَالَ: آللَّهِ مَا أَجْلَسَكُمْ إِلَّا ذَاكَ؟ قَالُوا: وَاللَّهِ مَا أَجْلَسَنَا إِلَّا ذَاكَ، قَالَ: أَمَا إِنِّي لَمْ أَسْتَحْلِفْكُمْ تُهْمَةً لَكُمْ، وَلَكِنَّهُ أَتَانِي جِبْرِيلُ، فَأَخْبَرَنِي أَنَّ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ يُبَاهِي بِكُمُ الْمَلَائِكَةَ
- Sunan an-Nasai 5428
What happens in Mawlid gatherings
May Allah allow us to rejoice the birth of the Prophet ﷺ
This guy says you will be punished for reading durood whilst Allah swt innallaha wa malaikitahu ya saluna alan nabi ya ayu halaazena amanu Sallu alayhi wa salimu taslima. This guy should refute what the Saudi leaders are doing if he's a real shaykh and not refute sending durood on the prophet
May ALLAH guide people of bidah
Me pretending to understand all the words used in the first few minutes 🗿🗿(i understood only the english ones)
Same😂
Mawlid is jaiz and great. There is nothing problem in pointing out a date. We dont have a problem with people not attending mawlid, but there is a standard. If its haram tell us how specifying a date is haram.
Again, specifying a date is not wrong. Get me a hadith on that
Let people celebrate whatever they want. Chill out.
Apparently , Isa was born in the summer.
What part of mawlid goes againts sunnah or sharia
Celebrating the birthday part, which originally comes from the shia
The celebration wting of the birthday part is not from Sunnah.
I live in a village in Pakistan where there is sufi environment. Insha'Allah soon I will make hijrah.
Jahil, you will leave your family and the great muslim country of Pakistan to go like IDK in the UK maybe ?
Where is full video 😢
this is it
wouldnt milaadun nubuwaah be a more important event
Let both party meet in the day of judgement to know if this tradition of mawleed is right or wrong in Allah's eyes
Whomever Allah guides, no one can lead him astray. Whomever Allah sends astray, no one can guide him. The truest word is the Book of Allah, and the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The evilest matters in religion are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation, every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.”
The mere mention of 'Mawlid' triggers these lot lol
Bidah should trigger any Muslim that want to follow the sunnah
Muslim's should have the best of manners.
17:40
What if people are gathering and remembering him in a way that is displeasing to Allah. There are certainly some forms of worship that are displeasing to Allah, such as adding or omitting rakats from fard salah. So who can then try and say that all worship is good worship? Truly a boy of his desires
Interrupting whilst the Shaykh is relating a Hadith is rude.
If i hold gatheri g of dhikr and remembrance of holy prophet pbhu tomorrow maybenot many people would come as oppose to the specific date on which he was born that is the state of todays people where as sahaba would come everyday to see tha face of the beloved and learn about him
💪🏽💪🏽
18:40 WHAT'S THIS HADITH
oh ignorant people sahabas had the blessed destiny to see and be with the beloved 24/7 but all we have are these gatherings which should be held in our hearts everyday we cannot even fathom how drenched the sahabas were in love with the prophet khalid bin walid stiched the prophets hair in his turban did that mean he understood more than khulaafa rashidun no
Seriously I don't understand people who wants to do mawlid
Why dont the Bidati people start making Azan on Eid prayer and Janaza prayer too since Azan is a vig blessing.
We ONLY DO and DONT what the Prophet SAID from Evidences. Not an inch out of the ⭕
We dont worship scholars or their decisnt OPINIONs, in fact some scholars will be the first to enter hell. We only follow our Prophet with Evidences.
Ibn taymiya can be proofed even kafir about what he says about Allah sitting on throne
This kid has such poor manners and is stubborn. May Allaah swt guide him to the sunnah and away from the ashari sufi innovators.
Okay I have a question when does it become an innovation does it become an innovation when you do it specifically on the 12th what about if somebody attends gatherings of commemoration throughout the entire year like every single Thursday or every single Friday when does it specifically become a biddah because of celebrating the birthday what is believed to be the best day is an innovation and there should be no problem with having gatherings of commemoration during the week for example not necessarily doing rabbi a awal
Both of them are not doing a proper job here. One holds a very extreme view on Sufism, and the other one is unbecoming.
Brother Uthman Farooq is a Talib with incredible Knowledge but he is NOT a Shaikh yet. May Allah SWT bless our Dawah brethren with an abundance of khair in duniya and akhira Ameen Ya Rabb ❤
Am from nigerian amd honestly i can tell you with fact and evidence maulid here is even like a party ..honestly it terrible to see it
Undercover Sufi ? Quit trying to click bait and slander ASTARGHFIRULLAH
❤
May Allah guide all the sufis.
Celebration of mawlid is neither part of faith or religion.
It is clearly bidah. Youll not die nor will you be questioned if you don't celebrate it.
Don't waste time and money on this unfruitful act.
Don't make a door for fitnah.
Don't try to overperform Prophet pbuh.
Trash who have yet to perfect salah should shut it and keep quiet. No grave worshipping either.
Note to do well and don't act oversmart.period.
Emotional and lacking knowledge. His family probably do this and he can't handle the facts. Smh
I don’t agree with the Moulana
Why you gonna ask the question if you gonna not have an open mind to any answers
Nasheed? Bro is talking like nasheed is something that includes in islam ans get rewards in islam
can asnyone explaine to me why these type of videos have a person inserting a video of themselfes into video literally adding zero value to it but in fact taking away from it.
Wobblie meaning wahabi. Uthman talks without ilm on this topic