The only reason is I love this channel is the kind of topics that Niranjan bhai picks ,I want more and more RW groups to discuss this but turns out very few of them are even interested in serious policy conversation like AIM says, anyways good to see something good come out of the land of Bengal.
Bengal eliminated caste discrimination was the greatest lie that current gen of Bengalis believe in. They must be getting very very hurt by this paper.
@@collegestreetkolkata9669 I don't know about much in details about overall WB . As many people as I have seen in Calcutta and Medinipur, no one has such bigotry about caste. The way I see it in my friends from Bihari or Uttar Pradesh. Even in Kolkata some have no problems with Mushlims But if I talk about Marwadi Gujrati people of Kolkata they have even problem with non veg people whatever Hindu or others . Many PGs ( owned by Marwari and Jain's) in Kolkata have so many criteria Non Bengali allowed . So as far as I remember , I faced this language discrimination during finding PG . as a Village person to now a Student in kolkata I never saw in my village that type of casteism even my frnds in village are Santhali but we have no problem of seating, eating etx togather etc .
@@a_oriyup but this is not because of communism ideology suddenly made them saints. It's due to many continuous ongoing movements happened in bengal. 1.Vaishavite movement by Sri Chaitanya mahaprabhu 2. Ramakrishna Paramhansa's teachings 3. Cultural appropriation of Rabindranath Tagores humanism 4. Tantric practices do not adhere to brahminical austerities 5. Brahmo samaj and emergence of bhadrolok -swadhinota andolon - MN Roy estd communism 6. Lastly it became cool to become communists
Bro people who say no casteism in Bengal are saying it in relation to what is considered the epitome of it in Hindi belt and south. Bengal is not some vacuum and also being communist rule does not make you lose your Hindu religion. Brahmoism did more to undo orthodox Hinduism in Bengal which would have kept it more akin to Hindi belt than communist rule. So that would be due to Christian/West/Anglo influence of two centuries, not Marxism. I’m from Brahmin family by surname, our pediatrician growing up was a Dr Mondol. I also have two grand aunts that are married to people whose surname are Das and Mondol respectively, meaning they married in 1960s-70s. Thing is that those uncles also came from historically educated families, despite the surname. I don’t know enough about their roots to know when they became Bhadralok, and yes you are correct about the statistical prevalence that bhadralok is more or less going to equal the historical upper caste, but Bhadralok in itself is a post caste grouping. I recommend maybe you also study and include Brazil in your analysis because maybe Brazil with its narrative of post racial democracy has similarities with Bengal being post caste. That would be better than looking at US where black and white are defined communities.
Is there any theory or article on how we can empower the disenfranchised classes of our state. How can we uplift the situation, especially the women who always get the short end of the stick in this.
The only reason is I love this channel is the kind of topics that Niranjan bhai picks ,I want more and more RW groups to discuss this but turns out very few of them are even interested in serious policy conversation like AIM says, anyways good to see something good come out of the land of Bengal.
🙏🏿
You're on a roll these days
We need a academic paper that clearly outlines the role of Leftist politics in India and caste discrimination.
Chandrachur Ghose's research at FIHCR will probably scratch the surface. But then he comes from a pop-history background and trained in Botany..so..
Bengal eliminated caste discrimination was the greatest lie that current gen of Bengalis believe in. They must be getting very very hurt by this paper.
👀
@@collegestreetkolkata9669 I don't know about much in details about overall WB . As many people as I have seen in Calcutta and Medinipur, no one has such bigotry about caste. The way I see it in my friends from Bihari or Uttar Pradesh.
Even in Kolkata some have no problems with Mushlims But if I talk about Marwadi Gujrati people of Kolkata they have even problem with non veg people whatever Hindu or others . Many PGs ( owned by Marwari and Jain's) in Kolkata have so many criteria Non Bengali allowed .
So as far as I remember , I faced this language discrimination during finding PG . as a Village person to now a Student in kolkata I never saw in my village that type of casteism even my frnds in village are Santhali but we have no problem of seating, eating etx togather etc .
@@a_oriyup but this is not because of communism ideology suddenly made them saints. It's due to many continuous ongoing movements happened in bengal.
1.Vaishavite movement by Sri Chaitanya mahaprabhu
2. Ramakrishna Paramhansa's teachings
3. Cultural appropriation of Rabindranath Tagores humanism
4. Tantric practices do not adhere to brahminical austerities
5. Brahmo samaj and emergence of bhadrolok -swadhinota andolon - MN Roy estd communism
6. Lastly it became cool to become communists
Wonderful work brother keep it up.
Thank you, I will
This is a awesome find
🙏🏿
Bro people who say no casteism in Bengal are saying it in relation to what is considered the epitome of it in Hindi belt and south. Bengal is not some vacuum and also being communist rule does not make you lose your Hindu religion. Brahmoism did more to undo orthodox Hinduism in Bengal which would have kept it more akin to Hindi belt than communist rule. So that would be due to Christian/West/Anglo influence of two centuries, not Marxism. I’m from Brahmin family by surname, our pediatrician growing up was a Dr Mondol. I also have two grand aunts that are married to people whose surname are Das and Mondol respectively, meaning they married in 1960s-70s. Thing is that those uncles also came from historically educated families, despite the surname. I don’t know enough about their roots to know when they became Bhadralok, and yes you are correct about the statistical prevalence that bhadralok is more or less going to equal the historical upper caste, but Bhadralok in itself is a post caste grouping. I recommend maybe you also study and include Brazil in your analysis because maybe Brazil with its narrative of post racial democracy has similarities with Bengal being post caste. That would be better than looking at US where black and white are defined communities.
Is there any theory or article on how we can empower the disenfranchised classes of our state. How can we uplift the situation, especially the women who always get the short end of the stick in this.
Only law n order+free market
Eto energy ashe kotha theke 🔥
🙏🏿
❤
🙏🏿
Can you give me the document?
You can find it in google. Caste and Power: An Ethnography Dayabati Roy eshob likhe search korlei chole ashbe
@@collegestreetkolkata9669 I appreciate it
👌
🙏🏿
Biggest joker 😂😂😂
Who? Dr. Dayabati Roy?
ত joker ট কে ব্যাটে সুনি.!.?
@@collegestreetkolkata9669 tui e to ekta joker..porasona kore video bana
@@collegestreetkolkata9669tui e to joker..porasona kore video Bana.. 2 taka na 5 taka pas bjp theke😂😂😂
@@jyotsnamahato953 TMChawal Ch0r it cellia