Peter crying on : I wish i said i love you just get me tears every time...we know the story, we know the pain...this is more than squeletons of a song...this is blood running on the stage and tears dripping from the soul
Yes, I agree, this is a painfully heavy version of this song, and so personal, together with his latest CDs.....pause.....sigh.....get myself together.... There is something with this song, whatever version: When YOU sing this song (however "good" singer you are) follow that tune together with this words you INEVITABLY travel to places seemingly dominated by pain. and fear. And when the sea of tears is deep enough, you'll find that you can float on salty waters. Thanks Peter. Thanks ElCinghio.
Merci pour cette émouvante version ! Peter nous avait interprété il y a quelques années un "Four Pails" extrait du "Live Tides" en parlant également de son frère avec autant d'émotion ! J'en ai encore les larmes aux yeux... C'est un Grand Homme, et il a bien eu raison de ne pas se compromettre à ce monde commercial et formaté et de rester Authentique...
@InuitAldebaran I couldn't be more agree with you. It was a absolutely spine tingling version, absolutely bones freezing. You can touch the emotional side of the artist who have to be distant -and not completely involved- during the performance as a professionist but.....sometimes old wounds rise up and torn away that dress...leaving on stage a naked and suffering human being.
Peter Hammill, a més de ser un músic excel·lent, és una persona intel·ligent i de molta vàlua humana. La seva trajectòria musical és de les més honestes, intenses i creatives dels darrers cinquanta anys, A way out és una de les grans cançons que ens ha deixat.
@Davemills99 Probably because you don't undestand. And I have no intention to try to explain you why. Just try by yourself. I find very simple to understand why this version is so moving. Maybe you have to dig into your soul with more strenght
Dave, From what I understand Peter has never wanted the fact that the song is about his brother's suicide to be public knowledge. You might consider deleting the above comment (and letting me know, so that I can then delete this)?
Peter crying on : I wish i said i love you just get me tears every time...we know the story, we know the pain...this is more than squeletons of a song...this is blood running on the stage and tears dripping from the soul
Yes.
Man with emotion
Yes, I agree, this is a painfully heavy version of this song, and so personal, together with his latest CDs.....pause.....sigh.....get myself together....
There is something with this song, whatever version: When YOU sing this song (however "good" singer you are) follow that tune together with this words you INEVITABLY travel to places seemingly dominated by pain. and fear.
And when the sea of tears is deep enough,
you'll find that you can float
on salty waters.
Thanks Peter. Thanks ElCinghio.
This is the most beautiful and moving performance of this song I've ever heard...
I'm in tears, too.
Thank you so much for uploading it.
Unbelievable. I'd always known this song held some deep resonance, came from a deep well... The intensity... that's what PJAH has above all.
Fucking fantastic! This is Hammill and shows how honest his music is...
Merci pour cette émouvante version ! Peter nous avait interprété il y a quelques années un "Four Pails" extrait du "Live Tides" en parlant également de son frère avec autant d'émotion ! J'en ai encore les larmes aux yeux... C'est un Grand Homme, et il a bien eu raison de ne pas se compromettre à ce monde commercial et formaté et de rester Authentique...
...I wish I'd said "I love you"
Unbelievable song about suicide I don't know how he could even perfom this ? I would cry every second.
This is the most saddest song ever written.
@InuitAldebaran I couldn't be more agree with you. It was a absolutely spine tingling version, absolutely bones freezing. You can touch the emotional side of the artist who have to be distant -and not completely involved- during the performance as a professionist but.....sometimes old wounds rise up and torn away that dress...leaving on stage a naked and suffering human being.
THAT is gonna live with me a very long time. PH always was the bravest guy I ever heard of in music and it seems nothing has changed. Amazing stuff!
No alcanzan las palabras para abarcar todo lo que es Peter Hammill❤
Que serions nous sans Peter Hammill ?
Moins connaissant en musique.
What an amazing performance!
One of the most intense pieces of music so far...
Grande.
non ho parole.
Ti voglio bene Peter, tanto
i'm off to see him tonight in glasgow ,looking forward to it ...and thanks for posting this amazing song ....
One of my all time favs
Mesmerising
Brutal canción...
when the chords became knifes
I suffered the same loss last Sunday.
A brother's suicide?
@@michevicus2987 fiancee
@@dudleylitz7369 I send you a very warm hug.
So sad every suicide dead is. I lost my wife just over two years ago by ovarian cancer. It was spread liver and lungs too.
This life...
The Artist
as real as it gets
merci la vie peter hammill existe !
Peter Hammill, a més de ser un músic excel·lent, és una persona intel·ligent i de molta vàlua humana. La seva trajectòria musical és de les més honestes, intenses i creatives dels darrers cinquanta anys, A way out és una de les grans cançons que ens ha deixat.
wow, never saw that coming
Ο σπουδαιότερος ερμηνευτής της παγκόσμιας μουσικής σκηνής. Τέλος...................
Demasiado emotivo :')
OUT !!!!!
Out of love for his music.....
And still superbly accurate....
Fuckin real
❤️
I'm so far IN that one
代官山で見たLIVEに近いです
@ml777: you're welcome, was my pleasure ;-)
Could another "I Love You" SAVED You?!?
6:25
@Davemills99 Probably because you don't undestand. And I have no intention to try to explain you why. Just try by yourself. I find very simple to understand why this version is so moving. Maybe you have to dig into your soul with more strenght
to ElCinghio
is that You?
@Davemills99 ok, i get the point. I'm a very limited human being but I'm not going into this kinda flame. So I'll pass it on. Good luck
I'd love to get into his mind but I may end up too far out.
Dave, From what I understand Peter has never wanted the fact that the song is about his brother's suicide to be public knowledge. You might consider deleting the above comment (and letting me know, so that I can then delete this)?
Alice?
Bez komentarza. Co tu dodać? Że łzy mi poleciały? Dla faceta w średnim wieku to przecież wstyd...