This video is an introduction to a productive mindset for reading poetry. If you're looking for some more practical reading skills (and more difficult poetry), check out this video for the next steps: th-cam.com/video/jv6OA3QBRLM/w-d-xo.html
A very good interpretation of what poetry is. Personally, not being any type of an English major, barely passing college requirements for a degree, I thought poetry was to evoke more feelings than experience. Well, unless experience is linked to emotion. I do not know for sure.
First step to enjoying poetry, Get a mental illness, brain injury or illness, then start wearing 1960 style suite jacket and a terrible weird coloured bowtie!
Some constructive criticism, if you are open to it. The introduction is annoyingly long. Consider that if someone is watching the video, they are probably already interested in the topic and go from there. You don't need to assume they don't care about it and try to entice them to actually care about it. With that in mind, the first 1 minute and 44 seconds are totally useless. The problem nowadays is that if you are interested in a topic there are so many options to learn it from, that it can be overwhelming. At least I usually skim through several videos to judge its quality and whether it covers what it claims to cover (i.e. is it click bait?). If you give a long, unnecessary introduction, people who actually want to learn about the topic, can get bored and close the video.
And when the experience is annoying, like, "WHAT depends on the wheelbarrow?" then I don't want to have that experience. Therefore, I don't want to read poetry.
I think the point is that poetry is just a medium of information. Like how reading a novel allows you to imagine the world, reading a poem also allows you to imagine a moment, or an experience, much like the explanation in the video. Art is really only enjoyed out of your own volition, and it's the artist's goal to make you get there. However if you yourself are inclined, you can get to that point without much push from the artist. As for poetry, who cares what the poem means? It's only about what you see in the poem. Maybe the chickens are rabid and the wheelbarrow really is full of your mother or something. As long as you like that interpretation. Convincing others of your interpretation is separate from what you care for it to be.
Understanding Where once rested, a mysterious giant, Amorphous, intimidating form -- Light spread of source and knowledge connected, form melting, into something simple, something pure. @@Pandor18
Rekindled My body, so vibrant What is this I'm feeling Nostalgia, warmth, desire Now I'm finally seeing A once forgotten love In plain sight, a treasure hidden So simple, so wonderful Never overwritten
Did your professor ever explain what's up with the weird breaks in the sentences? Because most of the time there's no rhythm, there's no particular meaning, it's just there seemingly with the sole goal of confusing the reader
But that's like saying pictures give you feelings where pixels fall short. It doesn't make sense! Now if your professor had said "where grammar/syntax/plot falls short" I'd get that.
In high school, I remember wanting so badly to grasp Shakespeare better. And the more I stopped trying to make sense of each word and just let the whole of it paint a picture in my mind, the more I understood what was happening. It’s so counterintuitive-to just let language wash over you and trust yourself to understand on another level. It’s like trying to hold a bubble, which ruins it. You can only watch it shimmer in the air until it’s gone.
I think it helps significantly to *experience* Shakespeare instead of just reading it. Shakespeare didn't intend for anyone to read his plays line by line in a classroom, his intention was for the majority of his audience to see and hear his plays onstage. I've acted in a Shakespeare play, putting it onstage transforms it. You could have never convinced me Macbeth is a great work by making me read it, seeing it is the only way to fully grasp it.
@apollofell3925 yeah I wouldn't give MacBeth the time of the day if I had to read it. But having worked on a stage production in a youth group of children with disabilities, I goy great memories of it as a play. Be it more with making costumes talking about how we could enunciate different lines to make them believable. Shakespeare in school is just killing your brain over dead trees with even deader words on them.
I have a Bachelors of Arts in Creative Writing, took poetry classes, and not once was the genre of poetry been clearly articulated. Always technique, never the purpose. It was always presupposed. I appreciate how clearly you intro-ed this and makes me want to re-export them genre more
Ain't it the way? It is funny how some of the most fundamental things get left out where you'd think they're most needed. I'm really happy to hear this helped!
78 years old and I have just learned tor the 1st time that poetry and literature are not impossible test questions to labor over until you finally have enough days into English class to move onto the next grade. Thank you for introducing me to a whole new world of enjoyment!!
I feel the same way. I’ve always thought that poetry was something (?) to figure out to find clever meaning within. That there were symbolic truths to be understood that if I labored long enough I’d get it. Logical, not an experience to feel. Can’t say my efforts were always successful and left not liking poetry very much. Thank you for a whole new perspective. I’m going back to reread a few. I’m optimistic and by the way I’m 78 years old too.
john green once said on his and his brother’s podcast that poetry is easy to hate when you harbor resentment towards your teacher for telling you that you didn’t ‘get’ the poem because you failed to understand that the wolf howling on the cliff is supposed to be a manifestation of the writers father or something absurd like that
Thank you for this video, it’s really alleviates the anxiety of “getting a poem right.” And, fittingly, the first poem in the Library of Congress poetry collection that you linked is “Introduction to Poetry,” by poet laureate Billy Collins; “I ask them to take a poem and hold it up to the light like a color slide or press an ear against its hive. I say drop a mouse into a poem and watch him probe his way out, or walk inside the poem's room and feel the walls for a light switch. I want them to waterski across the surface of a poem waving at the author's name on the shore. But all they want to do is tie the poem to a chair with rope and torture a confession out of it. They begin beating it with a hose to find out what it really means.”
Because we are taught to analyze poems in school. I don't remember a teacher saying, "Read the poem and just enjoy it." They always ask, "What did the poet mean?" This is a decent question because many poems have some meaning behind them, but it would be nice to be told that some are just pretty poems and that's it. We were preconditioned to solve poems.
This is the best explanation of poetry I have come across up till now. I have been really struggling with understanding what the poet meant but your perspective takes the pressure of “analysing” off. Thanks!
This made my day, so happy to hear this helped you see poetry in a different light. Poetry can be fun--as long as we stop worrying we have to get it "right." Here's to lots of pleasant poetry reading!
A school classroom is possibly the worst place to be introduced to poetry, since it's a context of right and wrong answers. Image been reading my kid poetry at bedtime his while life as just part of a mix of stuff requested and unrequested. Now I'm fully expecting him to disagree with the teacher when he finally gets to that stuff at school
As a Native American who is learning Spanish (the Language of God), I guess the video is decent. Jesus G. Maestro already made videos on poetry and its mechanism. His "Critica de la Razon Literaria" already delved into extensive detail, so I am happy this is spreading.
This is, by far, the best redemptive explanation on reading poetry i have come across the internet. We always discuss it like this during literary workshops. It is great that it is expressed here too, as it helps many appreciate poetry more.
Thanks! And you're right--this is the kind of approach that we always take in the writing workshops I've been a part of, very different (and more fun, I think) than what we encounter in other kinds of English classes
So glad TH-cam randomly recommended this to me. You are an excellent communicator and I particularly love that photograph analogy for poetry. Off to go read some poems now!
As a teen I always appreciated poetry but I never got it, I never understood “why”. You have rekindled a lost joy for poetry that & thank you for that!😁
You just openened up a whole new world for me, thank you so much! I always thought that poetry is "just too difficult for me" and couldn't enjoy it because I thought I would just always miss "the actual meaning". You stopped the poetry gatekeeping for me🥺
Yesss! That's the best possible news--there's a whole wide world of delightful poems just waiting for you to enjoy them. Thanks for taking the time to comment!
Blame pseudo-intellectual gatekeepers like George Steiner and Harold Bloom... then again the anglosphere has been pretty bad in Literature since the protestant reformation. Just compare the ghost stories between "Canterbury Tales" and "Macbeth", the former was almost picaresque and written by one man, while the later was a rational atavism that was spewed by who knows how many dozen anglos.
I have had this opening as a result of this video too. I always thought I was not "learned" enough to really get it. I like what you said about stopping the gatekeeping - exactly right.
Spot on! It's truly unfortunate that the way poetry is generally introduced to kids in school typically involves a painfully tedious exercise in meticulously "decoding" the puzzling symbolism employed and then formulating a conclusion about what it "really means" according to a particular method of analysis or some interpretation deemed to be "correct." If there was ever a way to rob poetry of its myriad enchantments, then methodically dissecting it in such a sterile and formulaic way would be a hard one to beat.
I used this to help introduce my grade 11 class to our unit on poetry in which we are reading the poems of Wallace Stevens. They found it very helpful - especially because they'd (unfortunately) been taught to do the exact opposite of the points you make here. Thanks!
I learned more in 11 minutes than years of language arts classes in high school and college. I think this will help me to not only enjoy poetry more, but also movies, music, and visual arts. Thank you,
I often feel very alone in my love of poetry. I just really enjoy reading all kinds of poems and the images they create in my head that I could never ever imagine on my own. I don’t know anyone else who enjoys them like I do so I’m very excited to have found your channel!!
A poem fan here. I have favorites like "Desirata", and ,,kvæðið um fuglina(translates to the poem about the birds). Icelandic, my native Icelandic is great for poems.
Thank you so much for your take on poetry! While there can definitely be "hidden" meaning in poetry, it's not hidden in the poem, it's hidden within the reader and the poem just brings it to the surface, per my experience. What makes a poem particularly touching is if it stirs up states and emotions you as the reader have experience before, what makes it have "meaning" is when it actually connects the dots between insights you already have, but couldn't put together until you found the key to them, whether in a poem or from anywhere else. So in this sense, what moves me in a poem is when said poem speaks of me and about me, what's moving is the self-reflection and also remembrance of experiences past, or even the making up of experiences I haven't had... I've never been in that scene with red wheelbarrow, yet it has touched me some as you described it! Thanks again :) I stumbled on your video by complete happenstance, but will be looking at others!
I'm autistic and as a child 19th century french poetry was my special interest. I could spend hours reading and memorising poems because I loved the ambiance it created around me. It felt like with a few words the poets could give me emotions to feel and landscapes to contemplate and experiences to ponder. Suffice to say I didn't have me many people to share my love of poetry with. I'm so happy to see more people getting into reading and writing poetry! It's a fun outlet for creativity and there's something so special about keeping a few verses with you that describe a special day, a nice holiday, a beautiful sunset.
I have studied literature up to university level but I have always been trying to decode or unravel the meaning of poems, especially shorter ones, which has often been a frustrating experience and meant that poetry has been my least favourite type of literature. I wish someone had told me this years ago. Hopefully this will give me a new way of reading and appreciating poetry. Thank you Andrew.
Oh my gosh! I feel so much more free to just have “my” experience (whatever that may be) be the “correct” one versus struggling to tease out the what the “right” one is. Also your description of poetry as being a “snapshot” would have been a powerful shift in how I experienced poetry, had I heard that in school. Thank you so much! I’m excited to share this with my partner 🥰
I’m 35 and you’ve given me a newfound appreciation for poetry. I've just read a few that I'd known in the past and it feels wholly different. Thank you so much. I’m about to embark on a journey of experience, a savoring of moments, and I’ll report back sometime later!
When I read, “Oranges” by Gary Soto I was immediately in that moment. I understood the humanity in the poem not by breaking down each word but by simply taking it for what it is. A lovely memory to be treasured.
i love what you said about poems being like a photograph. It makes me think of narritive poems, and in a way, graphic story telling, like a comic strip (just a sequence of drawings (or even photos) telling a story) when you think of joining the pictures of poems together (with an end result in mind of course) than one could write a poem, a narrtive poem in ways that can connect and project an image into your mind in a swifter and pronounced way. It seems to me new possibilities to tell a story. These are things I search for on a daily basis LOL its possibly comparable to that of a reader like a viewer, enjoying a motion picture. Capturing momnts (that again if you combine with thought around it) can create a story in text that can move for readers in ways that a short story, novel, or even film script, and play can't. This is theory, and one that I am enjoying very much atm.
Very cool insights--I have heard fiction writers say that learning poetry made their fiction much better, so I think you're on to something! Poetry is all about bringing readers into a distilled experience--why wouldn't that be beneficial for storytelling too? Cool stuff!
The movie ‘Manchester By The Sea’ is an incredible example of a poetic film… it’s not meant to have a message, but meant to be experienced… it’s not a film you “watch”- it’s a film you feel.
As a published poet, I think this understanding of poetry can greatly challenge poetry writers to create more visual and external poems. Many poets today (including me) focus more on emotional, thoughtful, or opinionated expression instead of visual “experiences” as you put them. I think that this video compels me and (hopefully) all writers to try and write poems with less of an internal emphasis and more of an external one. As you said, this would ideally also motivate writers to care less about arguments or “profound” psychological pieces and, instead, just write about whatever they want. Wonderful video!
Thanks--that's a great way to put it! It's the difference between telling someone to feel sad and telling them about a sad experience that causes them to feel the sadness, and I think it's what's at the heart of the familiar advice to show rather than tell.
That is the single most accurate discussion of how poetry is open to everyone. Whilst you were explaining the “…glazed wheelbarrow “ I was thinking of the ‘gateway’ poem that did exactly the same for me, Walter de la Mare’s The Listeners” This poem opened up a whole world to me that had been shut away and, as I mistakenly thought, only accessible by the ‘academically trained’. You showed what I had thankfully stumbled upon. Fantastic discussion, thank you
Thank you. I am 63 years old and this is the first time I have stopped to understand poetry as a snapshot of someone's experience. I love photography and understand sharing an experience visually but have never connected it this way, so thank you for helping me "visualize" a poet's snapshot-experience via language.
this video is pretty much what got me into writing and reading poetry. i never have felt more seen with your example in highschool and how it felt like it was a riddle to be solved. school never taught me to appreciate art as it was, there was always a lesson to be taught for some dreaded grade. after this video i found love for it again, and even wrote my narrative referencing this video for school!
Loved this video, both as a writer and enjoyer of poems. You bringing up that poetry is about the experience more than any message makes me think of a line by R.A.P. Ferreria in his song CYCLES, talking about artists broadly: "Their job is to invent trophies of experience."
This is the best reason I've heard of for giving poetry a second chance ! Thank you so much ! It IS stressful to always try to figure stuff out ! I just want it to wash over me, not having to analyze it like we did in high school.
That is awesome. I had no idea this is what poetry is. I spend a lot of time pondering on particular past experiences. It would be really cool to capture them in poems to read in the future.
One of my favorite things in poetry is when that experience is not necessarily shared, but can be generated and developed during the reading itself; it's like showing the reader a whole sky and each reader will see different cloud shapes or constellations. Playing with language can provoke really unique sensations and feelings.
Thank you, Andrew. I started writing poetry about a year ago, although I still consider myself a pre-poet. But I just won a poetry competition and I was getting nervous thinking, "do I really even know what poetry IS?" So I appreciated your insights.
Whoa, huge congrats on the win! I'm glad the video helped, but, for what it's worth, I think feeling like you have no clue what you're doing comes with the territory--you're in good company!
Thank you so much for this enlightening video! Poetry has always felt like this mysterious puzzle to me, but your channel has changed my perspective entirely. Your approach of emphasizing the enjoyment of poetry over decoding it is refreshing and liberating. Keep up the fantastic work in demystifying the world of poetry for all of us!
Ahh thanks Andrew for this video! I have really been struggling with this primal feeling of "not getting the poet's views" and it is really stopping me from just enjoying the poem! But now I know how to look forward it and now I'm gonna read a lot of them.
This seems like a great channel, I'm glad TH-cam recommended it. I've always been struggling with enjoying poetry - I love reading, but any stimulation from poetry has mostly eluded me, with "huh, kinda cool" being my best reaction to it. Since I feel like I'm missing out, here's hoping your videos will remedy that, cheers.
TH-cam algorithm found me a gem, today! I've been out of school for nearly a decade and haven't even thought about poetry since then, but this video gave me new appreciation for it.
In highschool, I felt so alienated when we read poetry. Whenever I would tell my classmates, that analysing isn't how it was sopposed to be done, they would just shrug or imply that I'm just not getting it. I'm still not sure why anyone would pretend to enjoy poetry that way, or why we never learned to actually READ poems. I'm lucky to have discovered the joy of writing poetry without any outside influence and thus gain an understanding of how to read it as well. I love your explanation of it being like a photograph. It's like a photograph that gets wider and more vibrant the more you are able to immerse yourself, which makes reading it so rewarding, and writing it encourages you appreciate your surroundings on a deeper level.
So poetry was about visualization, poetry was like a way of making pictures before everyone had access to pictures. The only difference is it allows you to personally experience it, your own interpretation of the scene. It's a bit like how books were a way of telling stories before film. In my opinion something that allows for interpretation will always have more emotional clout, it's yours and you relate to it.
Thank you for giving me permission to just like a poem for the experience and words. I have often been puzzled by the “solving” mentality some people have and thought I might just be missing something.
I love this video. I've always loved reading books, but too scared and intimidated to get into poems. This video has opened my eyes to how awesome poems can be!
Thank you for this. I’ve often been so intimated by poetry that I avoid it and know I’m missing out on a beautiful art form. This helps it seem more approachable indeed.
This is simply incredible. By nature I am analytical and its difficult for me to relax and go with the flow. For the longest, I could not get into it, even though there have been several circumstances of great stress I created my own as an outlet. You simply telling us its meant to communicate an "experience." is so simple and obvious I feel like a goof. Thank you very much.
I cannot thank you enough for this video. You have severely changed and shifted my perspective on poetry as a whole, and deeply resonated with everything said! Before this video, i was a textbook case of, "bad experiences in highschool due to trying to figure it out", reading them as enigmatic and vague puzzles! I never understood, nor was taught, what the point of a poem was, and found them entirely frustrating because I couldnt for the life of me, 'figure any out', reading them for meanings as i did novels and stories. We studied Plath for months and it was a tedious and impenetrable. I think moving forward, i am no longer going to entirely shut poetry out, and attempt see it for what it is! Thank you once again
In my 70-some years, I've slowly come to appreciate poetry, and your explanation articulates my feelings. My favorite poem is Tyger Tyger by William Blake. I love tigers, and if someone were to ask me why, I would show them Blake's poem. It captures the mystery of one of the most beautiful and most dangerous creatures in the world.
Andrew, these are great tips, thank you! 👍🏻 In the past, I have written a couple of poems but unfortunately I lost them when my computer died. Now, I am planning to write new poems as well as recite poems that are not copyrighted for my own TH-cam channel. I look forward to seeing more of your videos on poetry! You just earned a new subscriber, fan, and friend! 😎
I have always said that if I can make someone feel the same way I felt when I wrote the poem, then I have succeeded as a poet. In that sense the poem is like a bank for emotions, accessible to anyone who can read it.
Thank for for taking the time to create and upload this. I have been trying to learn (or figure out) how to read poetry all of my adult life, and the lesson here is a huge leap forward I think.
This is so beautiful and refreshing. So much of my time with poetry has been spent on untangling, and hunting for meaning. Thank you for opening this door.
This is the first explanation of poems that actually make sense for me. I will probably not go to deep into poetry but having it as a skill is very helpful (especially in school). I 've been trying to better my writing skills and even though english isnt my mother tounge the videos on your channel seem to be general enough to be not constricted to only one language. Luckily people like you can teach so many of us through the internet. Thanks :)
I've been falling on hard times right now, and watching this video opened up a whole new world for me that I didn't know I was missing. Something about watching this and hearing your passion for an art often ignored, learning how to enjoy it with the same vigor you have, it quieted my estranged soul, at least it has so far. Thank you.
One of my friends (English major) says this: "writing is to craft the best story using good words. Poetry is to craft the best story using the best words." Another thing he said that really stuck with me is that when you're reviewing a piece you aren't finding the meaning, you're finding your interpretation of the piece. What the author meant is irrelevant, it's about what it means to you.
Although there is some truth to that second passage, it's not ultimately correct. What the author is saying still matters. Interpretation is great when it makes you feel something or creates a feeling, but a poem should know what it wants to say, and the reader has to try to understand what the author wants to say. Like the video says, poetry isn't a riddle. It is a picture.
I like what you’re doing, man. This video is so important, especially in today’s overly fast-paced culture of immediacy. People don’t wanna think about anything for longer than a few seconds. We’ve become very literal and want results instantly (at least in the western world). I think folks would also benefit from learning how to appreciate the ambiguity of more “art house” films. Some are even called “tone poems”and for a reason lol.
Boy, am I glad this video popped up in my TH-cam feed. I've struggled with poetry since middle school, despite being able to find meaning and beauty in others forms of written text, like novels and essays. I thought poets were just pretentious artists who wrote in mysterious ways to make ME feel dumb. Likening a poem to a photograph is such a simple idea, yet I think you might have unlocked a new appreciation for poetry within me. I will pick up one of the dusty poetry collection on my shelf later this week and try and approach them in this new way. Looking forward to it. Thank you again for your video!
First time reading the poem: "it's about a wheelbarrow?" After applying the critical analysis techniques your teacher expects you to use, reading up on William Carlos Williams and the Imagist Movement: "It's about a wheelbarrow."
In my middle school class about this poem, the teacher explicitly told us it was a metaphor for the United States. Red, White, and Blue (water) are the US's flag colors. I didn't really question that as a child, but now I suppose it could also be a poem about France.. Or Russia.. Or Slovakia.. Maybe we shouldn't have been taught poetry that way.
Well done making this video, you're helping a lot of people like me who were instantly turned off to poetry by the mundane classroom meandering of careless, tired teachers. To that I say thank you a thousandfold!
i've been struggling with poetry for years and thanks to your video it finally started to make sense. intuitively while you were reading The Red Wheelbarrow even before your explanation i started immersing myself into this scenery and paid attention at colour contrast. red wheels and white chicken. i enjoyed it as it's a simple yet pleasant combination. so, your approach definitely works. thanks for the video!
Amazing!! I've always found poetry repulsive since the only contact I had with it early on was in school, but i've stumbled upon it with new eyes when trying to compose music and this video helps me appreciate poetry in strictly written form. Thanks!!
I've written poetry on/off for over half of my life by now (That makes me feel old...) but still, with my 13-odd something years of experience in writing it, from freeform to limericks, to haikus or odes, I've always felt that none of mine ever "had" to have a deeper meaning. If what I wrote read the way I wanted it to read, I was happy with the result (Or even if it didn't! I loved hearing people's interpretations). It didn't "need" to be analyzed. It could, but it never "needed" to. I like this video a lot! I appreciate that you've made it, because I think poetry has become misunderstood, with current culture and school especially teaching poetry with a certain bias. Sometimes the curtains are blue simply because the curtains are blue.
Love the video! I'm trying to learn how to write lyrics and its pretty tough, this has been very helpful. Also, I would love to hear you narrate a nature documentary.
Loved the simplicity and the perspective shift! I've recently begun to enjoy poetry - Keats and Mary Oliver are my go to and you've put into words what I had been feeling for a while - poetry is akin to a photograph. Thank you.
I’d like to point out how in a way this approach to poetry feels like a great metaphor for approach to life: yes it’s cool to try to understand and interpret your surroundings, but if we allow this to stop us from just experiencing life in it’s full beauty then we begin to miss out on things.
oh my goodness. i spent years avoiding poetry - i never could "understand" it, so i gave up on ir completely. then i saw this video, thought "huh, why not?", and here i am, almost tearing up at how simple it is. how easy and pleasant and thrilling it may be to share a few moments with an author, to see the world through their eyes. i don't have to "understand" anything more than humanity at its finest, which is the joy to create and then share with other people what we've done. thank you from the bottom of my heart for this video. i'm definitely staying here for more! and i'm so excited to read some poetry now ❤
I completely agree. I only recently started to like poetry out of self-exploration, I've graduated from university now. I wish you had been my English teacher in high school so I would have appreciated this form of art earlier. 😁
This is the best explanation of poetry I’ve ever heard. However, I still cannot find any joy in poetry. That’s ok, I don’t need to and everyone is to their own. It’s like a language I cannot understand
Thanks for this, I was too much into the idea of solving the poems, even if I had to research about it, mainly those harder ones like from Plath which made me feel like I was solving an equation. Even though it's fun sometimes seeing it as sort of an enigma, I can see how one would miss out on a lot more of the essence of the poetry. That idea of a poem being like a photograph is exactly the way I thought about haikus (like a timeless sight of nature), now I'll try to extend that to poetry in general.
Yeah, haikus are really good examples of poems to approach like photos. Come to think of it, they might be what got me started thinking this way in the first place...
This is a revelation to me. I'm not much of a reader and I've always felt a bit intellectually insecure about how opaque poetry seems to me. But your comparison with photography, an art form I can at least pretend to understand, really opened things up. I'm reminded of a quote from some composer, whose name eludes me. I can't even remember the exact wording. But he said something like 'if I could convey what I want to convey in writing, I would not need to compose it in music'. Different art forms are for different things, and I finally have some concept of what poetry is trying to do. Certainly more than I did 20 minutes ago. And that's the beauty of a TH-cam video!!
Literally best explanation of poetry ive seen …throughout the years of me trying to understand poetry ive watched a lot of videos and even took poetry classes and none have said these things before and in the ways that you did thank you so much!!!!!
This did gave me a new perspective towards poems. Now I won't look at it as I used to look at it before. Thanks a lot for igniting my interest in literature. Btw just a suggestion, there are many classic poems (by Shakespeare, Aldous Huxley etc) which are actually difficult to decode. It would be nice if you start making videos explaining them as you explain really well in simple words
When I was younger (around 10-13) and was writing poetry for English class, I remember absolutely loving writing poetry, and always getting commended for everything I wrote. However, growing older, I grew out of love with writing poetry, and found it harder to write poetry that I felt was great. Sure, it was more lexically complex than what I wrote at 10, but it never felt like it had that same impact. I never really understood why until now. I was so caught up in the mire of good grades and subtextual meaning that I never realised why writing poetry was so fun to begin with. It was all about conveying an experience, not about telling a plot, or the overarching metanarrative, it was just the imagery and face value experience. Thank you for reminding me what made writing poetry as a child so fun.
IDK how the algorithms got me here but loved this! What you tried NOT to do and ease folks into reading (and perhaps even writing poetry 😮) is exactly what the English classes do in any country and take the fun out of it! When you introduced the red wheelbarrow I paused the video there even before you said anything and my mind just created an image (as it does with any written piece), perhaps a bit more zoomed in than your’s. It was dwelling a little too much on the red and the glaze of rainwater, clinging droplets and I can understand that due to my obsession with light, water, related imagery and photography. But after all that, my mind wandered a bit into all the work the person put in their farm / garden and having a quiet time… meditative, perhaps in the soft light of dawn or dusk after a short spell of rain, fresh and fragrant earth! I know how much I used my wheelbarrow… one that was way past its glistening days and perhaps was just happy to be still useful! I think the literature folks get fixated a bit too much on the latter. When I was in school I used to wonder how could they say those things about the poem so definitively?! Did the poet make any secret confessions somewhere or annotate elsewhere? Even if they go that route a bit, perhaps they could lead this way… “here’s what I think could’ve been, what do you think?” Perhaps it’s daydreaming into the poet’s day or night, being let in by its imagery.
That's a great response: no disrespect to my colleagues in literature, but I think a less authoritative approach like the one you describe would do wonders
@@WritingwithAndrew Thank you! I also “graduated” to the next level with your other video (which almost felt like jumping from 101 to 401 😅) TBH, It didn’t draw me in right away and wasn’t the kind of poem I’d generally fall in love with but what I appreciated was how you broke it down akin to explaining functions in a piece code (I am not trying to say riddle as it beats the purpose). Just amazing! In the end I could still appreciate several aspects of the poem that you were talking about. I wish I (or your audience) could read all the poems that I love but kinda stuck understanding, with you. 😀 btw, the skull is a great touch adding humor and wit!
I have loved poetry all my life from my maternal grand parents quoting from Burns, down the years. All through school (60years ago) I would be asked, "What did I think of a poem and why did I like it?" I always replied, "Because I disappear when I read it." This was never an acceptable answer. The tutors needed much more re the techniques of construction....A poem is immersive. As you say it is an experience. Best Wishes from Scotland. Jock.
I'm a poet. The poems come from a balance in the soul. A balance between experience and spirit. Poems are a gift. I really appreciate your take on poetry.
i consider myself a casual poetry enjoyer, and have dabbled in writing poetry when i was in school, but this video really opened my eyes about what poetry is about. i love your gentle and kind demeanor, you have such a pleasant personality.
Music has more talent put into it than poetry. You can't make a song out too the poem 'the red wheel barrow" alone. (Or it would be short, and awful. Lyrics alone is not what makes music, and on paper, if it doesn't tell a definitive story, its worthless.
This video is an introduction to a productive mindset for reading poetry. If you're looking for some more practical reading skills (and more difficult poetry), check out this video for the next steps: th-cam.com/video/jv6OA3QBRLM/w-d-xo.html
A very good interpretation of what poetry is. Personally, not being any type of an English major, barely passing college requirements for a degree, I thought poetry was to evoke more feelings than experience. Well, unless experience is linked to emotion. I do not know for sure.
First step to enjoying poetry, Get a mental illness, brain injury or illness, then start wearing 1960 style suite jacket and a terrible weird coloured bowtie!
Some constructive criticism, if you are open to it. The introduction is annoyingly long. Consider that if someone is watching the video, they are probably already interested in the topic and go from there. You don't need to assume they don't care about it and try to entice them to actually care about it. With that in mind, the first 1 minute and 44 seconds are totally useless. The problem nowadays is that if you are interested in a topic there are so many options to learn it from, that it can be overwhelming. At least I usually skim through several videos to judge its quality and whether it covers what it claims to cover (i.e. is it click bait?). If you give a long, unnecessary introduction, people who actually want to learn about the topic, can get bored and close the video.
@@Diego20529 I have had no prior interest in poetry, but this video showed up on my feed, so I checked it out.
@@danquaylesitsspeltpotatoe8307 Are you okay?
"Painting is poetry that's seen rather than felt and poetry is painting that's felt rather than seen."
~Leonardo Da Vinci
"Life isn't a problem to be solved, but a reality to be experienced" -Soren Kierkegaard
And when the experience is annoying, like, "WHAT depends on the wheelbarrow?" then I don't want to have that experience. Therefore, I don't want to read poetry.
@@randomgrinnwell, why do you find it annoying? What turns you off of it
@@randomgrinn Clearly your mother depends on the wheelbarrow. Not many other options to move her around, considering how much she weighs.
Maybe stop reading the wheelbarrow poem. There are others.
I think the point is that poetry is just a medium of information. Like how reading a novel allows you to imagine the world, reading a poem also allows you to imagine a moment, or an experience, much like the explanation in the video.
Art is really only enjoyed out of your own volition, and it's the artist's goal to make you get there. However if you yourself are inclined, you can get to that point without much push from the artist.
As for poetry, who cares what the poem means? It's only about what you see in the poem. Maybe the chickens are rabid and the wheelbarrow really is full of your mother or something. As long as you like that interpretation. Convincing others of your interpretation is separate from what you care for it to be.
I suddenly feel the urge to write a poem about how I feel like I’ve been missing out on poetry
Do it ❤😊
Understanding
Where once rested, a mysterious giant,
Amorphous, intimidating form --
Light spread of source and knowledge connected,
form melting,
into something simple,
something pure.
@@Pandor18
Rekindled
My body, so vibrant
What is this I'm feeling
Nostalgia, warmth, desire
Now I'm finally seeing
A once forgotten love
In plain sight, a treasure hidden
So simple, so wonderful
Never overwritten
@@Tuuubesh0wdamn bro publish that immediately
This is gold 🥇 @@Tuuubesh0w
My poetry professor in university would say that poems give you feelings where words fall short. A shared experience is the perfect way to describe it
I love that explanation--thanks!
Did your professor ever explain what's up with the weird breaks in the sentences? Because most of the time there's no rhythm, there's no particular meaning, it's just there seemingly with the sole goal of confusing the reader
@@helgenlane not all poems are like that though. Personally, I like the ones that rhyme.
But that's like saying pictures give you feelings where pixels fall short. It doesn't make sense! Now if your professor had said "where grammar/syntax/plot falls short" I'd get that.
This literally makes no sense at all. Poems don't use words? Poems are shared experiences? Neither one of those is true.
In high school, I remember wanting so badly to grasp Shakespeare better. And the more I stopped trying to make sense of each word and just let the whole of it paint a picture in my mind, the more I understood what was happening. It’s so counterintuitive-to just let language wash over you and trust yourself to understand on another level. It’s like trying to hold a bubble, which ruins it. You can only watch it shimmer in the air until it’s gone.
Wow, that's a very cool way to put it! Thanks for your insight (I might have to borrow it sometime...)!
Nice metaphor.
I think it helps significantly to *experience* Shakespeare instead of just reading it. Shakespeare didn't intend for anyone to read his plays line by line in a classroom, his intention was for the majority of his audience to see and hear his plays onstage. I've acted in a Shakespeare play, putting it onstage transforms it.
You could have never convinced me Macbeth is a great work by making me read it, seeing it is the only way to fully grasp it.
Very good metaphor indeed. You should write some poetry yourself :)
@apollofell3925 yeah I wouldn't give MacBeth the time of the day if I had to read it. But having worked on a stage production in a youth group of children with disabilities, I goy great memories of it as a play. Be it more with making costumes talking about how we could enunciate different lines to make them believable.
Shakespeare in school is just killing your brain over dead trees with even deader words on them.
I have a Bachelors of Arts in Creative Writing, took poetry classes, and not once was the genre of poetry been clearly articulated. Always technique, never the purpose. It was always presupposed. I appreciate how clearly you intro-ed this and makes me want to re-export them genre more
Ain't it the way? It is funny how some of the most fundamental things get left out where you'd think they're most needed. I'm really happy to hear this helped!
man, that must've been a poopy poetry class then
Bachelor's of Arts and Creative Writing*
I'll have a frappucino with extra cream, thank you
I think this is true of so much education, even math.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
78 years old and I have just learned tor the 1st time that poetry and literature are not impossible test questions to labor over until you finally have enough days into English class to move onto the next grade. Thank you for introducing me to a whole new world of enjoyment!!
You're so very welcome--thanks for commenting!
I feel the same way. I’ve always thought that poetry was something (?) to figure out to find clever meaning within. That there were symbolic truths to be understood that if I labored long enough I’d get it. Logical, not an experience to feel. Can’t say my efforts were always successful and left not liking poetry very much. Thank you for a whole new perspective. I’m going back to reread a few. I’m optimistic and by the way I’m 78 years old too.
Love the explanation...feel a poem about to burst forth!!! Thx for the nudge!! Poetry!! 🖋️ 🗒️
john green once said on his and his brother’s podcast that poetry is easy to hate when you harbor resentment towards your teacher for telling you that you didn’t ‘get’ the poem because you failed to understand that the wolf howling on the cliff is supposed to be a manifestation of the writers father or something absurd like that
Art is a mirror.
It teaches you who you are.
Thank you for this video, it’s really alleviates the anxiety of “getting a poem right.”
And, fittingly, the first poem in the Library of Congress poetry collection that you linked is “Introduction to Poetry,” by poet laureate Billy Collins;
“I ask them to take a poem
and hold it up to the light
like a color slide
or press an ear against its hive.
I say drop a mouse into a poem
and watch him probe his way out,
or walk inside the poem's room
and feel the walls for a light switch.
I want them to waterski
across the surface of a poem
waving at the author's name on the shore.
But all they want to do
is tie the poem to a chair with rope
and torture a confession out of it.
They begin beating it with a hose
to find out what it really means.”
oof i felt this
aNxIeTy over a poem. Hahahah
Because we are taught to analyze poems in school. I don't remember a teacher saying, "Read the poem and just enjoy it." They always ask, "What did the poet mean?" This is a decent question because many poems have some meaning behind them, but it would be nice to be told that some are just pretty poems and that's it. We were preconditioned to solve poems.
This is the best explanation of poetry I have come across up till now. I have been really struggling with understanding what the poet meant but your perspective takes the pressure of “analysing” off. Thanks!
This made my day, so happy to hear this helped you see poetry in a different light. Poetry can be fun--as long as we stop worrying we have to get it "right." Here's to lots of pleasant poetry reading!
Try over standing it sometime. Blessings.
A school classroom is possibly the worst place to be introduced to poetry, since it's a context of right and wrong answers.
Image been reading my kid poetry at bedtime his while life as just part of a mix of stuff requested and unrequested. Now I'm fully expecting him to disagree with the teacher when he finally gets to that stuff at school
As a Native American who is learning Spanish (the Language of God), I guess the video is decent. Jesus G. Maestro already made videos on poetry and its mechanism. His "Critica de la Razon Literaria" already delved into extensive detail, so I am happy this is spreading.
@WritingwithAndrew thank you for this video, I agree with the comment at top
This is, by far, the best redemptive explanation on reading poetry i have come across the internet. We always discuss it like this during literary workshops. It is great that it is expressed here too, as it helps many appreciate poetry more.
Thanks! And you're right--this is the kind of approach that we always take in the writing workshops I've been a part of, very different (and more fun, I think) than what we encounter in other kinds of English classes
So glad TH-cam randomly recommended this to me. You are an excellent communicator and I particularly love that photograph analogy for poetry. Off to go read some poems now!
Thanks a bunch--have a lot of fun!
I really cant hate youtube. This is just what i needed to start my journey.
As a teen I always appreciated poetry but I never got it, I never understood “why”. You have rekindled a lost joy for poetry that & thank you for that!😁
You just openened up a whole new world for me, thank you so much! I always thought that poetry is "just too difficult for me" and couldn't enjoy it because I thought I would just always miss "the actual meaning". You stopped the poetry gatekeeping for me🥺
Yesss! That's the best possible news--there's a whole wide world of delightful poems just waiting for you to enjoy them. Thanks for taking the time to comment!
Blame pseudo-intellectual gatekeepers like George Steiner and Harold Bloom... then again the anglosphere has been pretty bad in Literature since the protestant reformation. Just compare the ghost stories between "Canterbury Tales" and "Macbeth", the former was almost picaresque and written by one man, while the later was a rational atavism that was spewed by who knows how many dozen anglos.
Well, it is more difficult to write.
I have had this opening as a result of this video too. I always thought I was not "learned" enough to really get it. I like what you said about stopping the gatekeeping - exactly right.
txs hermes
Spot on! It's truly unfortunate that the way poetry is generally introduced to kids in school typically involves a painfully tedious exercise in meticulously "decoding" the puzzling symbolism employed and then formulating a conclusion about what it "really means" according to a particular method of analysis or some interpretation deemed to be "correct." If there was ever a way to rob poetry of its myriad enchantments, then methodically dissecting it in such a sterile and formulaic way would be a hard one to beat.
I used this to help introduce my grade 11 class to our unit on poetry in which we are reading the poems of Wallace Stevens. They found it very helpful - especially because they'd (unfortunately) been taught to do the exact opposite of the points you make here. Thanks!
I'm honored! Here's to undoing the fear of poetry!
You sound like a good teacher who gives a damn!
I learned more in 11 minutes than years of language arts classes in high school and college. I think this will help me to not only enjoy poetry more, but also movies, music, and visual arts. Thank you,
That's awesome--thanks!
I often feel very alone in my love of poetry. I just really enjoy reading all kinds of poems and the images they create in my head that I could never ever imagine on my own. I don’t know anyone else who enjoys them like I do so I’m very excited to have found your channel!!
Thanks--I'm glad you did too!
As a poet I agree. Writing a poem is one of the great pleasures of life. Imagine how Frost felt when he wrote Birches. He must have felt great.
Right? Thanks--now I'm going to have to go read Birches!
A poem fan here. I have favorites like "Desirata", and ,,kvæðið um fuglina(translates to the poem about the birds). Icelandic, my native Icelandic is great for poems.
You spelled unemployed wrong
@@d3r4g45 you can have a job and be a poet in your freetime, that's the beauty of being human
@@d3r4g45 spelt
Thank you so much for your take on poetry!
While there can definitely be "hidden" meaning in poetry, it's not hidden in the poem, it's hidden within the reader and the poem just brings it to the surface, per my experience. What makes a poem particularly touching is if it stirs up states and emotions you as the reader have experience before, what makes it have "meaning" is when it actually connects the dots between insights you already have, but couldn't put together until you found the key to them, whether in a poem or from anywhere else.
So in this sense, what moves me in a poem is when said poem speaks of me and about me, what's moving is the self-reflection and also remembrance of experiences past, or even the making up of experiences I haven't had... I've never been in that scene with red wheelbarrow, yet it has touched me some as you described it!
Thanks again :) I stumbled on your video by complete happenstance, but will be looking at others!
I'm autistic and as a child 19th century french poetry was my special interest. I could spend hours reading and memorising poems because I loved the ambiance it created around me. It felt like with a few words the poets could give me emotions to feel and landscapes to contemplate and experiences to ponder. Suffice to say I didn't have me many people to share my love of poetry with.
I'm so happy to see more people getting into reading and writing poetry! It's a fun outlet for creativity and there's something so special about keeping a few verses with you that describe a special day, a nice holiday, a beautiful sunset.
Of course you have to mention you have autism. There's always one of you. Keep it to yourself, you're not special.
I have studied literature up to university level but I have always been trying to decode or unravel the meaning of poems, especially shorter ones, which has often been a frustrating experience and meant that poetry has been my least favourite type of literature. I wish someone had told me this years ago. Hopefully this will give me a new way of reading and appreciating poetry. Thank you Andrew.
You're very welcome!
Oh my gosh! I feel so much more free to just have “my” experience (whatever that may be) be the “correct” one versus struggling to tease out the what the “right” one is.
Also your description of poetry as being a “snapshot” would have been a powerful shift in how I experienced poetry, had I heard that in school.
Thank you so much! I’m excited to share this with my partner 🥰
I’m 35 and you’ve given me a newfound appreciation for poetry. I've just read a few that I'd known in the past and it feels wholly different. Thank you so much. I’m about to embark on a journey of experience, a savoring of moments, and I’ll report back sometime later!
When I read, “Oranges” by Gary Soto I was immediately in that moment. I understood the humanity in the poem not by breaking down each word but by simply taking it for what it is. A lovely memory to be treasured.
i love what you said about poems being like a photograph. It makes me think of narritive poems, and in a way, graphic story telling, like a comic strip (just a sequence of drawings (or even photos) telling a story) when you think of joining the pictures of poems together (with an end result in mind of course) than one could write a poem, a narrtive poem in ways that can connect and project an image into your mind in a swifter and pronounced way. It seems to me new possibilities to tell a story. These are things I search for on a daily basis LOL
its possibly comparable to that of a reader like a viewer, enjoying a motion picture. Capturing momnts (that again if you combine with thought around it) can create a story in text that can move for readers in ways that a short story, novel, or even film script, and play can't. This is theory, and one that I am enjoying very much atm.
Very cool insights--I have heard fiction writers say that learning poetry made their fiction much better, so I think you're on to something! Poetry is all about bringing readers into a distilled experience--why wouldn't that be beneficial for storytelling too? Cool stuff!
The movie ‘Manchester By The Sea’ is an incredible example of a poetic film… it’s not meant to have a message, but meant to be experienced… it’s not a film you “watch”- it’s a film you feel.
The photograph analogy really unlocked a new perspective with such clarity
As a published poet, I think this understanding of poetry can greatly challenge poetry writers to create more visual and external poems. Many poets today (including me) focus more on emotional, thoughtful, or opinionated expression instead of visual “experiences” as you put them. I think that this video compels me and (hopefully) all writers to try and write poems with less of an internal emphasis and more of an external one. As you said, this would ideally also motivate writers to care less about arguments or “profound” psychological pieces and, instead, just write about whatever they want.
Wonderful video!
Thanks--that's a great way to put it! It's the difference between telling someone to feel sad and telling them about a sad experience that causes them to feel the sadness, and I think it's what's at the heart of the familiar advice to show rather than tell.
When i was young i would always write poems whenever a visual experience captivated me
I cant write anymore
But i still have some of the poems
That is the single most accurate discussion of how poetry is open to everyone. Whilst you were explaining the “…glazed wheelbarrow “ I was thinking of the ‘gateway’ poem that did exactly the same for me, Walter de la Mare’s The Listeners” This poem opened up a whole world to me that had been shut away and, as I mistakenly thought, only accessible by the ‘academically trained’. You showed what I had thankfully stumbled upon. Fantastic discussion, thank you
Thank you. I am 63 years old and this is the first time I have stopped to understand poetry as a snapshot of someone's experience. I love photography and understand sharing an experience visually but have never connected it this way, so thank you for helping me "visualize" a poet's snapshot-experience via language.
this video is pretty much what got me into writing and reading poetry. i never have felt more seen with your example in highschool and how it felt like it was a riddle to be solved. school never taught me to appreciate art as it was, there was always a lesson to be taught for some dreaded grade. after this video i found love for it again, and even wrote my narrative referencing this video for school!
That really makes my day--thanks so much for taking the time to share! Keep on writing!
Loved this video, both as a writer and enjoyer of poems. You bringing up that poetry is about the experience more than any message makes me think of a line by R.A.P. Ferreria in his song CYCLES, talking about artists broadly: "Their job is to invent trophies of experience."
That's an awesome line--I'm going to hold onto that one!
Last place I thought I’d find a R.A.P. Ferreria quote but I love that you dropped one. Underappreciated artist.
"Poems aren't riddles, but most of them are a joke." -some wise guy
This is the best reason I've heard of for giving poetry a second chance ! Thank you so much ! It IS stressful to always try to figure stuff out ! I just want it to wash over me, not having to analyze it like we did in high school.
Hooray! Definitely do give it a second chance--and thanks for watching!
@@WritingwithAndrew Your video convinced me! Well done!
I don't know how to explain this, but this guy has the perfect look and voice to talk about reading poetry
That is awesome. I had no idea this is what poetry is. I spend a lot of time pondering on particular past experiences. It would be really cool to capture them in poems to read in the future.
Yes! Go write those poems!
If you catch your voice when reading out loud or to someone that's where the emotion is, enjoy the writing😊
One of my favorite things in poetry is when that experience is not necessarily shared, but can be generated and developed during the reading itself; it's like showing the reader a whole sky and each reader will see different cloud shapes or constellations. Playing with language can provoke really unique sensations and feelings.
Very cool--that's the fun of it for sure!
Thank you, Andrew. I started writing poetry about a year ago, although I still consider myself a pre-poet. But I just won a poetry competition and I was getting nervous thinking, "do I really even know what poetry IS?" So I appreciated your insights.
Whoa, huge congrats on the win! I'm glad the video helped, but, for what it's worth, I think feeling like you have no clue what you're doing comes with the territory--you're in good company!
Thank you so much for this enlightening video! Poetry has always felt like this mysterious puzzle to me, but your channel has changed my perspective entirely. Your approach of emphasizing the enjoyment of poetry over decoding it is refreshing and liberating. Keep up the fantastic work in demystifying the world of poetry for all of us!
Ahh thanks Andrew for this video! I have really been struggling with this primal feeling of "not getting the poet's views" and it is really stopping me from just enjoying the poem! But now I know how to look forward it and now I'm gonna read a lot of them.
Yes--go read all of them!
Ahh, this is the video the TH-cam algorithm has chosen to push now you've past 10k subs! Congrats!
😁 Eagle-eyed as ever! Thanks a whole bunch, truly--it's definitely been getting orders of magnitude more attention this week than it used to.
This seems like a great channel, I'm glad TH-cam recommended it. I've always been struggling with enjoying poetry - I love reading, but any stimulation from poetry has mostly eluded me, with "huh, kinda cool" being my best reaction to it.
Since I feel like I'm missing out, here's hoping your videos will remedy that, cheers.
TH-cam algorithm found me a gem, today! I've been out of school for nearly a decade and haven't even thought about poetry since then, but this video gave me new appreciation for it.
In highschool, I felt so alienated when we read poetry. Whenever I would tell my classmates, that analysing isn't how it was sopposed to be done, they would just shrug or imply that I'm just not getting it. I'm still not sure why anyone would pretend to enjoy poetry that way, or why we never learned to actually READ poems. I'm lucky to have discovered the joy of writing poetry without any outside influence and thus gain an understanding of how to read it as well. I love your explanation of it being like a photograph. It's like a photograph that gets wider and more vibrant the more you are able to immerse yourself, which makes reading it so rewarding, and writing it encourages you appreciate your surroundings on a deeper level.
That's lovely--thank you!
So poetry was about visualization, poetry was like a way of making pictures before everyone had access to pictures. The only difference is it allows you to personally experience it, your own interpretation of the scene. It's a bit like how books were a way of telling stories before film. In my opinion something that allows for interpretation will always have more emotional clout, it's yours and you relate to it.
Thank you for giving me permission to just like a poem for the experience and words. I have often been puzzled by the “solving” mentality some people have and thought I might just be missing something.
I love this video. I've always loved reading books, but too scared and intimidated to get into poems. This video has opened my eyes to how awesome poems can be!
Thank you for this. I’ve often been so intimated by poetry that I avoid it and know I’m missing out on a beautiful art form. This helps it seem more approachable indeed.
Hooray!
Thanks!
Now it's my turn to thank you--truly! 😁
This is simply incredible. By nature I am analytical and its difficult for me to relax and go with the flow. For the longest, I could not get into it, even though there have been several circumstances of great stress I created my own as an outlet. You simply telling us its meant to communicate an "experience." is so simple and obvious I feel like a goof.
Thank you very much.
You're very welcome! Analysis has its place, but it's sometimes nice just to be, to exist
I cannot thank you enough for this video. You have severely changed and shifted my perspective on poetry as a whole, and deeply resonated with everything said! Before this video, i was a textbook case of, "bad experiences in highschool due to trying to figure it out", reading them as enigmatic and vague puzzles! I never understood, nor was taught, what the point of a poem was, and found them entirely frustrating because I couldnt for the life of me, 'figure any out', reading them for meanings as i did novels and stories. We studied Plath for months and it was a tedious and impenetrable. I think moving forward, i am no longer going to entirely shut poetry out, and attempt see it for what it is! Thank you once again
That's awesome to hear it--you're welcome!
In my 70-some years, I've slowly come to appreciate poetry, and your explanation articulates my feelings. My favorite poem is Tyger Tyger by William Blake. I love tigers, and if someone were to ask me why, I would show them Blake's poem. It captures the mystery of one of the most beautiful and most dangerous creatures in the world.
I find myself repeating the first couple lines of that poem every so often, like having a tune stuck in my head
Andrew, these are great tips, thank you! 👍🏻 In the past, I have written a couple of poems but unfortunately I lost them when my computer died. Now, I am planning to write new poems as well as recite poems that are not copyrighted for my own TH-cam channel.
I look forward to seeing more of your videos on poetry! You just earned a new subscriber, fan, and friend! 😎
Amazing. I’ve always hated poetry because I never understood it. This is liberating. I love poems now!
Hooray!
@@WritingwithAndrew It’s never to late to learn and to have the mind opened. This was a gift. Thank you.
You're welcome!
I have always said that if I can make someone feel the same way I felt when I wrote the poem, then I have succeeded as a poet. In that sense the poem is like a bank for emotions, accessible to anyone who can read it.
Thank for for taking the time to create and upload this. I have been trying to learn (or figure out) how to read poetry all of my adult life, and the lesson here is a huge leap forward I think.
You're so welcome--I'm really happy to hear it!
This is so beautiful and refreshing. So much of my time with poetry has been spent on untangling, and hunting for meaning. Thank you for opening this door.
This is the first explanation of poems that actually make sense for me. I will probably not go to deep into poetry but having it as a skill is very helpful (especially in school). I 've been trying to better my writing skills and even though english isnt my mother tounge the videos on your channel seem to be general enough to be not constricted to only one language. Luckily people like you can teach so many of us through the internet. Thanks :)
You're welcome!
I've been falling on hard times right now, and watching this video opened up a whole new world for me that I didn't know I was missing. Something about watching this and hearing your passion for an art often ignored, learning how to enjoy it with the same vigor you have, it quieted my estranged soul, at least it has so far. Thank you.
That makes my day--sorry things have been hard, but thanks for sharing!
Wow, this is a very earnest explanation of poetry that I've never thought of before and makes perfect sense. What a great video, thank you!
One of my friends (English major) says this: "writing is to craft the best story using good words. Poetry is to craft the best story using the best words."
Another thing he said that really stuck with me is that when you're reviewing a piece you aren't finding the meaning, you're finding your interpretation of the piece. What the author meant is irrelevant, it's about what it means to you.
Although there is some truth to that second passage, it's not ultimately correct. What the author is saying still matters. Interpretation is great when it makes you feel something or creates a feeling, but a poem should know what it wants to say, and the reader has to try to understand what the author wants to say.
Like the video says, poetry isn't a riddle. It is a picture.
I like what you’re doing, man. This video is so important, especially in today’s overly fast-paced culture of immediacy. People don’t wanna think about anything for longer than a few seconds. We’ve become very literal and want results instantly (at least in the western world). I think folks would also benefit from learning how to appreciate the ambiguity of more “art house” films. Some are even called “tone poems”and for a reason lol.
Thanks, I appreciate that!
Don't think, feel!
Boy, am I glad this video popped up in my TH-cam feed. I've struggled with poetry since middle school, despite being able to find meaning and beauty in others forms of written text, like novels and essays. I thought poets were just pretentious artists who wrote in mysterious ways to make ME feel dumb. Likening a poem to a photograph is such a simple idea, yet I think you might have unlocked a new appreciation for poetry within me. I will pick up one of the dusty poetry collection on my shelf later this week and try and approach them in this new way. Looking forward to it. Thank you again for your video!
Wow. Just yesterday in school I was going over “the red wheelbarrow” and was so lost at finding a deeper meaning in it. Thank you.
You bet!
First time reading the poem: "it's about a wheelbarrow?"
After applying the critical analysis techniques your teacher expects you to use, reading up on William Carlos Williams and the Imagist Movement: "It's about a wheelbarrow."
In my middle school class about this poem, the teacher explicitly told us it was a metaphor for the United States. Red, White, and Blue (water) are the US's flag colors. I didn't really question that as a child, but now I suppose it could also be a poem about France.. Or Russia.. Or Slovakia.. Maybe we shouldn't have been taught poetry that way.
I pay attention to the important small details sometimes (like most people) that was a great hook/intro. I already liked and subbed lol
lol--thanks!
Well done making this video, you're helping a lot of people like me who were instantly turned off to poetry by the mundane classroom meandering of careless, tired teachers. To that I say thank you a thousandfold!
A thousand thanks in return!
i've been struggling with poetry for years and thanks to your video it finally started to make sense. intuitively while you were reading The Red Wheelbarrow even before your explanation i started immersing myself into this scenery and paid attention at colour contrast. red wheels and white chicken. i enjoyed it as it's a simple yet pleasant combination. so, your approach definitely works. thanks for the video!
That's awesome to hear--thanks!
Amazing!! I've always found poetry repulsive since the only contact I had with it early on was in school, but i've stumbled upon it with new eyes when trying to compose music and this video helps me appreciate poetry in strictly written form. Thanks!!
That's awesome--you're welcome!
I've written poetry on/off for over half of my life by now (That makes me feel old...) but still, with my 13-odd something years of experience in writing it, from freeform to limericks, to haikus or odes, I've always felt that none of mine ever "had" to have a deeper meaning. If what I wrote read the way I wanted it to read, I was happy with the result (Or even if it didn't! I loved hearing people's interpretations). It didn't "need" to be analyzed. It could, but it never "needed" to.
I like this video a lot! I appreciate that you've made it, because I think poetry has become misunderstood, with current culture and school especially teaching poetry with a certain bias.
Sometimes the curtains are blue simply because the curtains are blue.
I'm glad I found this older video. Excellent tips! Thanks for all you do, Andrew.
That's very kind--I'm glad you found it too! Thanks for the support!
Love the video! I'm trying to learn how to write lyrics and its pretty tough, this has been very helpful.
Also, I would love to hear you narrate a nature documentary.
Thanks--that would be a fun gig!
Loved the simplicity and the perspective shift! I've recently begun to enjoy poetry - Keats and Mary Oliver are my go to and you've put into words what I had been feeling for a while - poetry is akin to a photograph. Thank you.
I’d like to point out how in a way this approach to poetry feels like a great metaphor for approach to life: yes it’s cool to try to understand and interpret your surroundings, but if we allow this to stop us from just experiencing life in it’s full beauty then we begin to miss out on things.
You're gettin' it! Thanks for the insight!
oh my goodness. i spent years avoiding poetry - i never could "understand" it, so i gave up on ir completely. then i saw this video, thought "huh, why not?", and here i am, almost tearing up at how simple it is. how easy and pleasant and thrilling it may be to share a few moments with an author, to see the world through their eyes. i don't have to "understand" anything more than humanity at its finest, which is the joy to create and then share with other people what we've done.
thank you from the bottom of my heart for this video. i'm definitely staying here for more! and i'm so excited to read some poetry now ❤
That makes my day--thanks for sharing this. Now go enjoy those poems! 😁
I completely agree. I only recently started to like poetry out of self-exploration, I've graduated from university now. I wish you had been my English teacher in high school so I would have appreciated this form of art earlier. 😁
Thanks! It's never too late--I'm glad you're finding your way back to poetry!
This is the best explanation of poetry I’ve ever heard. However, I still cannot find any joy in poetry. That’s ok, I don’t need to and everyone is to their own. It’s like a language I cannot understand
Thanks for this, I was too much into the idea of solving the poems, even if I had to research about it, mainly those harder ones like from Plath which made me feel like I was solving an equation. Even though it's fun sometimes seeing it as sort of an enigma, I can see how one would miss out on a lot more of the essence of the poetry. That idea of a poem being like a photograph is exactly the way I thought about haikus (like a timeless sight of nature), now I'll try to extend that to poetry in general.
Yeah, haikus are really good examples of poems to approach like photos. Come to think of it, they might be what got me started thinking this way in the first place...
This is a revelation to me. I'm not much of a reader and I've always felt a bit intellectually insecure about how opaque poetry seems to me. But your comparison with photography, an art form I can at least pretend to understand, really opened things up.
I'm reminded of a quote from some composer, whose name eludes me. I can't even remember the exact wording. But he said something like 'if I could convey what I want to convey in writing, I would not need to compose it in music'. Different art forms are for different things, and I finally have some concept of what poetry is trying to do. Certainly more than I did 20 minutes ago. And that's the beauty of a TH-cam video!!
Very cool--thanks for the insight!
Fantastic summary -- thank you --
You bet--thanks!
Your channel is a real treasure! So glad i stumbled across it. Loved your explanation in this video ❤️
Hey, thanks so much--I'm happy you're enjoying it!
Literally best explanation of poetry ive seen …throughout the years of me trying to understand poetry ive watched a lot of videos and even took poetry classes and none have said these things before and in the ways that you did thank you so much!!!!!
I'm really delighted to hear it--thank you!
This did gave me a new perspective towards poems. Now I won't look at it as I used to look at it before.
Thanks a lot for igniting my interest in literature.
Btw just a suggestion, there are many classic poems (by Shakespeare, Aldous Huxley etc) which are actually difficult to decode. It would be nice if you start making videos explaining them as you explain really well in simple words
Thanks for the suggestion--I'll put it on my list!
When I was younger (around 10-13) and was writing poetry for English class, I remember absolutely loving writing poetry, and always getting commended for everything I wrote. However, growing older, I grew out of love with writing poetry, and found it harder to write poetry that I felt was great. Sure, it was more lexically complex than what I wrote at 10, but it never felt like it had that same impact. I never really understood why until now.
I was so caught up in the mire of good grades and subtextual meaning that I never realised why writing poetry was so fun to begin with. It was all about conveying an experience, not about telling a plot, or the overarching metanarrative, it was just the imagery and face value experience. Thank you for reminding me what made writing poetry as a child so fun.
Awesome--you're welcome--thanks for this great reflection!
As the others have commented, this has been extremely helpful. ❤
Hey thanks--I'm always happy to hear a video has helped someone!
this is my favorite "how to read poetry" tutorial ever. thank you so much.
"If this were a photograph what would you be seeing" -- that is pretty much how I view all poetry that I read and write.
Nice--now we just need to get everyone else on board!
IDK how the algorithms got me here but loved this! What you tried NOT to do and ease folks into reading (and perhaps even writing poetry 😮) is exactly what the English classes do in any country and take the fun out of it!
When you introduced the red wheelbarrow I paused the video there even before you said anything and my mind just created an image (as it does with any written piece), perhaps a bit more zoomed in than your’s. It was dwelling a little too much on the red and the glaze of rainwater, clinging droplets and I can understand that due to my obsession with light, water, related imagery and photography. But after all that, my mind wandered a bit into all the work the person put in their farm / garden and having a quiet time… meditative, perhaps in the soft light of dawn or dusk after a short spell of rain, fresh and fragrant earth! I know how much I used my wheelbarrow… one that was way past its glistening days and perhaps was just happy to be still useful!
I think the literature folks get fixated a bit too much on the latter. When I was in school I used to wonder how could they say those things about the poem so definitively?! Did the poet make any secret confessions somewhere or annotate elsewhere? Even if they go that route a bit, perhaps they could lead this way… “here’s what I think could’ve been, what do you think?” Perhaps it’s daydreaming into the poet’s day or night, being let in by its imagery.
That's a great response: no disrespect to my colleagues in literature, but I think a less authoritative approach like the one you describe would do wonders
@@WritingwithAndrew Thank you! I also “graduated” to the next level with your other video (which almost felt like jumping from 101 to 401 😅) TBH, It didn’t draw me in right away and wasn’t the kind of poem I’d generally fall in love with but what I appreciated was how you broke it down akin to explaining functions in a piece code (I am not trying to say riddle as it beats the purpose). Just amazing! In the end I could still appreciate several aspects of the poem that you were talking about. I wish I (or your audience) could read all the poems that I love but kinda stuck understanding, with you. 😀 btw, the skull is a great touch adding humor and wit!
I love your summation of what a poem is. They also invoke emotions and can transport us to the moment. Edit. Love your well tied bow too.
I have loved poetry all my life from my maternal grand parents quoting from Burns, down the years. All through school (60years ago) I would be asked, "What did I think of a poem and why did I like it?" I always replied, "Because I disappear when I read it." This was never an acceptable answer. The tutors needed much more re the techniques of construction....A poem is immersive. As you say it is an experience. Best Wishes from Scotland. Jock.
I'm a poet.
The poems come from a balance in the soul.
A balance between experience and spirit.
Poems are a gift.
I really appreciate your take on poetry.
Poet to poet: thanks for the lovely addition!
You'd love Hegels take on poetry and art in general
Love the selection of Williams’s “Dawn”; what a perfect demonstration. Excellent video!
Thanks!
This is just to say, thank you.
Another Williams classic--you're welcome!
i consider myself a casual poetry enjoyer, and have dabbled in writing poetry when i was in school, but this video really opened my eyes about what poetry is about. i love your gentle and kind demeanor, you have such a pleasant personality.
Thanks for the kind words!
There are people who don't like poems? Do they not know what lyrics are?
Some people don’t like music 🥲
@@Aniyasimone___ . . . that sounds like a worrying disability.
HELPP
Music has more talent put into it than poetry. You can't make a song out too the poem 'the red wheel barrow" alone. (Or it would be short, and awful.
Lyrics alone is not what makes music, and on paper, if it doesn't tell a definitive story, its worthless.
Out of*
This has made the idea of poetry much clearer to me, thank you.
You're welcome!
People think I’m weird writing poetry. Let them.
I’ve never clicked “subscribe” with as much enthusiasm before. What an excellent communicator.
Thanks so much--I really appreciate that!
My english teachers taught and enforced the "deeper meaning" of literary works. It made me hate english class