They ABSOLUTELY ARE RESPONSIBLE for ensuring that the upstairs neighbors are not disturbing the place or else they cannot use it as an AirBnb. PERIOD. They could have easily notified the upstairs people in advance.
They paid $5300?!? And, the defendants are fighting over repairs to a fridge that they promised to reimburse? Also, one of the beds was missing and I am certain they knew about the construction. What a nightmare, I would be so angry.
And? Even if they knew about it. They have no right to anything someone does on their property. The landlords here did NOTHING wrong in regards to the noise and shit.
@@lookinatyoulookinatme1600 my sister's family and my family, so we split the cost, usually spend a week there every year, but we haven't gone since the pandemic
Even if it's not their property they knew there was construction going on and should've notified her. Who would knowingly go on vacation and spend that amount of money on a rental unit to listen to construction. They did this lady so wrong and it's going to come back to bite them in the butt.
@@xfga4531 Who said anything about controlling construction? They can't control construction but they can definitely control how they treat people. If you're renting out vacation property and there is construction going on you have a duty to inform your renter. Allow them to decide if they want to come. Don't withhold information that could ruin someone's vacation that they're paying good money for. The fact that the defendants knew the entire history about the people that were doing the construction let's me know they had some type of window of time to inform the plaintiffs. They could've even offered a discount. There's no possible way the defendants we're renting out that property and didn't know especially since they had to make sure it was cleaned, prepped, etc. If you want to retain someone's business while also building your business this would NOT be the way to do it.
THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT I SAID...I WON'T RENT A HOUSE FOR "PEACEFUL ENJOYMENT" IF THERE'S GOING TO BE A FULL CONSTRUCTION GOING ON EARLY AND OFTEN!!!J.J. WAS WRONG ON THIS ONE 😂
I work out there. It usually is pretty quiet and before construction begins, everyone on the block gets written notice - well in advance. They knew about it and they're playing ignorant in court. Foul of them not to warn her.
I kind of disagree... these people are renting out their unit (making a profit). If that unit is unbearable to stay in due to construction (even if they didn't control the construction schedule), the person paying should have some sort of recompense. Especially if paying $5.5k for a week.
But they did not notify the owners of the noise issue, they assumed it was a lost cause, so chose not to allow owners to resolve it & then sued for compensation over it.....that's a bad faith argument & a money grab.
Completely agree. You can't sell a luxury stay with construction going on upstairs. Should have been told it was going to happen and if they want to cancel. Definetely owed something back.
@@chazixon5913 so if the city is doing construction on the street the owners are responsible? Of course not. If they were staying at a resort and the resort is doing construction on the premises then of course the resort should be. Not the case here.
What if the landlords knew that there was ongoing loud intermittent construction upstairs that summer and chose not to inform their tenants? I believe that would be false advertising/breech of contract and worthy of a partial reimbursement.
The defendants are scammers! They have balls renting it for 5300& For one week… that’s UNBELIEVABLE!!!! I can rent a cottage here for 2000$ for a whole month and ZERO NOISE … This woman deserved money back 1000%.
I have a condo that I rent by the week in popular tourist destination. If something occurs that causes a real disturbance for the guests, (even if beyond my control and not part of my condo) I give a full refund. It doesn’t happen often, but it’s my responsibility to deal with other owners if a problem is coming from their unit. It’s certainly not the responsibility of the paying guest who has no idea any disturbance will happen! JJ is off base on this one.
Why are they renting out their house if they have no control over the top unit??? Legally they aren't responsible for the Construction Noise because they have no control over it but that's why they shouldn't be renting their unit in the first place because $5300 is a lot of money to have no control over noise. I would be mad at hell paying you all that money and have to hear all that noise overhead every day of my vacation. ..👀
I think it's a duplex, in which case each apartment (or floor) was probably independently owned and not part of a complex or association. LOTS of those in Ocean City.
I’m from South Jersey. My aunt has owned units and now a home in Ocean City for 20 some years. I know tons of people who rent, and several who own and rent in Ocean City. Until this video, I have never encountered a single person who would pay $5300 for a week in a first floor of a duplex for NINE PEOPLE that’s marketed with the word “SHABBY” in the ad. My mind is blown.
I would have got a refund, why would she rent something for 5500 and there was going to be construction going on. I would have immediately gotten a refund .
Defendants should not be held responsible for the construction noise, but plaintiff should be able to have peaceful enjoyment of the premises. Plaintiff should have gotten money back and defendants should sue the owner of the other unit
They must have knew about it and they definitely have the contact number of people who own condo above them in case of emergency. They knew if they will tell the lady know she will probably cancel the stay
I don't aggree with JJ on this one.. if you are hosting holiday makers they should have done everything possible to ennsure they had a peaceful stay by working with the owners above or cancelling the stay
If the rental was east of Philadelphia then we can assume she was not far from West Philadelphia and I’d like to assume that is where the defendants were born and raised. It would be simple to assume when they were young on the playground is where they spent most of their days . Sometimes they would be chilling out , sometimes maxing out and others relaxing out and at least once playing B-ball outside of the school . Sorry , I had to .
This sounds unfair though. If you are renting out a place, especially for just a week, surely you are responsible for asking your neighbour to not do construction for that week.
They can ask all they want. The upstairs owners are under no obligation to not do the construction they might feel they need to start based on thier schedules just because the downstairs owners decided to AirBnB it.
So what if the people rented their bottom property out consistently for months at a time? Are the owners above not allowed to do construction on their property until other people say otherwise okay otherwise?
So when can construction be done. The other week? Suppose the air BNB is always fully booked then you expect the owners to tell the neighbors to never have construction?
Y'all, I have a problem..... I'M ADDICTED TO WATCHING JUDGE JUDY!!! I CAN'T STOP MYSELF, I JUST LOVE HER SO MUCH!!!
Same 😭🥰
Me too!
Me too
I share the same addiction 💃
Me three 😭😭😭😭😭
Peaceful vacation? In Jersey??? That was her first mistake… 😂😂😂
Aye!!!!
Lmao ikr
You're not kidding. That's the LAST place I'd go.
They ABSOLUTELY ARE RESPONSIBLE for ensuring that the upstairs neighbors are not disturbing the place or else they cannot use it as an AirBnb. PERIOD. They could have easily notified the upstairs people in advance.
They paid $5300?!? And, the defendants are fighting over repairs to a fridge that they promised to reimburse? Also, one of the beds was missing and I am certain they knew about the construction. What a nightmare, I would be so angry.
Agree
$5300 for 9 people!!! That's a very fair price to rent in OC, NJ
And? Even if they knew about it. They have no right to anything someone does on their property. The landlords here did NOTHING wrong in regards to the noise and shit.
@@julietteoscaralphanovember2223 Yes it really is for that area
@@lookinatyoulookinatme1600 my sister's family and my family, so we split the cost, usually spend a week there every year, but we haven't gone since the pandemic
That home’s interior doesn’t even look very impressive. There’s no way I’d pay $771 a night!
Even if it's not their property they knew there was construction going on and should've notified her. Who would knowingly go on vacation and spend that amount of money on a rental unit to listen to construction. They did this lady so wrong and it's going to come back to bite them in the butt.
They can’t control construction
@@xfga4531 Who said anything about controlling construction? They can't control construction but they can definitely control how they treat people.
If you're renting out vacation property and there is construction going on you have a duty to inform your renter. Allow them to decide if they want to come. Don't withhold information that could ruin someone's vacation that they're paying good money for.
The fact that the defendants knew the entire history about the people that were doing the construction let's me know they had some type of window of time to inform the plaintiffs. They could've even offered a discount. There's no possible way the defendants we're renting out that property and didn't know especially since they had to make sure it was cleaned, prepped, etc.
If you want to retain someone's business while also building your business this would NOT be the way to do it.
THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT I SAID...I WON'T RENT A HOUSE FOR "PEACEFUL ENJOYMENT" IF THERE'S GOING TO BE A FULL CONSTRUCTION GOING ON EARLY AND OFTEN!!!J.J. WAS WRONG ON THIS ONE 😂
When was it established that the landlords knew the construction was taking place?
@@Chalk89 When they admitted it.
$5300 for a week?! WTF!?
I work out there. It usually is pretty quiet and before construction begins, everyone on the block gets written notice - well in advance. They knew about it and they're playing ignorant in court. Foul of them not to warn her.
Thank you....I don't even live out there but I've visited enough to know how it works in that area. That's how I know they're lying.
I kind of disagree... these people are renting out their unit (making a profit). If that unit is unbearable to stay in due to construction (even if they didn't control the construction schedule), the person paying should have some sort of recompense. Especially if paying $5.5k for a week.
But they did not notify the owners of the noise issue, they assumed it was a lost cause, so chose not to allow owners to resolve it & then sued for compensation over it.....that's a bad faith argument & a money grab.
Completely agree. You can't sell a luxury stay with construction going on upstairs. Should have been told it was going to happen and if they want to cancel. Definetely owed something back.
They're not responsible for noise made by a third party off of their property.
@@chazixon5913 yup. This isn't a 99$ Motel 6
@@chazixon5913 so if the city is doing construction on the street the owners are responsible? Of course not. If they were staying at a resort and the resort is doing construction on the premises then of course the resort should be. Not the case here.
My daily dose of Judge Judy🔥
I can’t get enough of her either!! She’s the best!! ❤️💕❤️💕❤️💕
Courage to confront.
Me too! Lol
Me too!!😉
Same here
What if the landlords knew that there was ongoing loud intermittent construction upstairs that summer and chose not to inform their tenants? I believe that would be false advertising/breech of contract and worthy of a partial reimbursement.
The defendants are scammers! They have balls renting it for 5300&
For one week… that’s UNBELIEVABLE!!!! I can rent a cottage here for 2000$ for a whole month and ZERO NOISE …
This woman deserved money back 1000%.
Jersey shore is super expensive to live🎉🎉🎉 5300$ is reasonable
$5500 for a 1 week stay in an Ocean city Nj apartment ? Yea that’s a HARD NO THANK YOU!!!!
Not sure where 9 people could stay for less. Hotels are generally 200ish per night for single room
Lots of places lol that’s definitely not worth it new jersey dirty asf !
@@badazzbarbiePOV I'm taking an educated guess that you've never been to Ocean City, NJ. Definitely not dirty.
And for an ad describing it as “shabby chic”?????? No ma’am.
I have a condo that I rent by the week in popular tourist destination. If something occurs that causes a real disturbance for the guests, (even if beyond my control and not part of my condo) I give a full refund. It doesn’t happen often, but it’s my responsibility to deal with other owners if a problem is coming from their unit. It’s certainly not the responsibility of the paying guest who has no idea any disturbance will happen!
JJ is off base on this one.
Thats great but legally she's right
The first word of the advertisement is literally “Shabby” I can’t even. 😂
I wish the management of the apartment I live in now had been so honest 6 years ago. *I would've moved in here and kept on looking!*
Yayyyy on a Saturday I’m too excited 🥰🥰🥰
I was surprised too
Most refreshing plaintiff EVER!
5,300 for ONE week? No thank you! lol
A person needs to be loaded money wise just to rent a beach home
That’s normal in New Jersey
@@jerzygurl609 especially in beach towns. Even the smaller homes cost millions of dollars
@@ShadowGirl1126 not really rented one in myrtle beach way cleaner than dirty azz jersey
That's why some Americans prefer to take vacations in my country. The dollar is worth much more abroad.🤷♂️
so the hosts had no responsibility to make sure the stay would be uninterrupted?
liking these weekends JJ videos 👀
did the landlords notify in advance the tenant that there was a possibility of construction happening? sounds like they know that it could happen.
Why are they renting out their house if they have no control over the top unit??? Legally they aren't responsible for the Construction Noise because they have no control over it but that's why they shouldn't be renting their unit in the first place because $5300 is a lot of money to have no control over noise. I would be mad at hell paying you all that money and have to hear all that noise overhead every day of my vacation. ..👀
Today, I had the urge to scream at someone just the day I’m having, turned on JJ and I feel like I got it all out, listening to her yell at ppl! 👍🤣
She has my dream job ... yelling at stupid people lol
This is a condo? There’s no way there wasn’t notice sent to everyone else about construction.
I think it's a duplex, in which case each apartment (or floor) was probably independently owned and not part of a complex or association. LOTS of those in Ocean City.
On a SATURDAY?!!!!! 😭🥹 I love you guys.
I would have been upset too if they were doing construction above me while I was on vacation
$771 for a NIGHT?!?!?! They were out of their FING MINDS.
$5300 a week? Y’all got it like that? Damn.
😂LOL
@@nyotauhura5646 hahahahaha I don’t even make that a month!
@@jazmynbrown6820 I know Me neither!
I’m from South Jersey. My aunt has owned units and now a home in Ocean City for 20 some years. I know tons of people who rent, and several who own and rent in Ocean City. Until this video, I have never encountered a single person who would pay $5300 for a week in a first floor of a duplex for NINE PEOPLE that’s marketed with the word “SHABBY” in the ad. My mind is blown.
We need to form a support group. LOL.
I would have got a refund, why would she rent something for 5500 and there was going to be construction going on. I would have immediately gotten a refund .
Officer Byrd is always nice to listen to
$5300 for a rental, a duplex? Jeez, that's a rip-off.
What on a Saturday?? Let’s go!
2:19 dude looks INSANELY creepy right here idk
Summer is when beach homes (in associations) are allowed to do construction.
They should have notified you the guests of the possibility of construction. Yeah, you aren't in control of it but it's going to cost you in reviews
JJ is crazy: how can they rent her a property with ongoing construction.. they had to know
the title tho 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Judy Judy Judy Judy Judy
Defendants should not be held responsible for the construction noise, but plaintiff should be able to have peaceful enjoyment of the premises. Plaintiff should have gotten money back and defendants should sue the owner of the other unit
They must have knew about it and they definitely have the contact number of people who own condo above them in case of emergency. They knew if they will tell the lady know she will probably cancel the stay
my GOD she looks like Judith Light (whos the boss mom)
Anyone else hear the kids giggling @ 0:57
Totally agree. Judge Judy is the wisest woman living. Wish she ran the country 😅
I have the same problem
IF THEY NEW THERE WAS A FULL CONSTRUCTION HAPPENING BUT DIDN'T NOTIFY A SHORT TIME RENTER WHO WANTS A PEACEFUL VACATION...SHE'S DUE GET MONEY BACK IJS
Yikes! $771 per night with a minimum stay of 7 nights??? That's $5,400 per week!
I understand that..BUT 🤯🤯🤯
Thats Felicity Huffman!
Need part 2
Relax they just posted this I'm sure 2 will come soon
@@beth1188 Exactly... patience all you JJ addicts! 🙂
It was posted over 30 minutes ago.
Whats gross is they were paid 5000 for that week.
The girl behind the defendants 🥰
Plaintiff looking like Lynette from desperate housewives
Duplex is side by side, double is up and down
5300 to go to New Jersey ?
man to have rent around $800
771 a night WOW
😳😳😳😳😳
Okay? And what about him?
She looks like the blonde actress from desperate housewives 😊
I don't aggree with JJ on this one.. if you are hosting holiday makers they should have done everything possible to ennsure they had a peaceful stay by working with the owners above or cancelling the stay
If the rental was east of Philadelphia then we can assume she was not far from West Philadelphia and I’d like to assume that is where the defendants were born and raised. It would be simple to assume when they were young on the playground is where they spent most of their days . Sometimes they would be chilling out , sometimes maxing out and others relaxing out and at least once playing B-ball outside of the school .
Sorry , I had to .
Should get all her money back 🤨💵
I ask you, Would you rent from these two?
5300 DOLLARS FOR A WEEK!!!!!!!!!!!! WHAT DA FFFFFFFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Give that guy a cane and he's House.
This sounds unfair though. If you are renting out a place, especially for just a week, surely you are responsible for asking your neighbour to not do construction for that week.
No. It’s not your property to tell someone to stop doing something.
It would be polite but no you are not responsible…
They can ask all they want. The upstairs owners are under no obligation to not do the construction they might feel they need to start based on thier schedules just because the downstairs owners decided to AirBnB it.
So what if the people rented their bottom property out consistently for months at a time? Are the owners above not allowed to do construction on their property until other people say otherwise okay otherwise?
So when can construction be done. The other week? Suppose the air BNB is always fully booked then you expect the owners to tell the neighbors to never have construction?
The hair on these people my gosh....no hairdressers in Jersey?
👀
Male defendant has an alcohol issue
They use people to get repairs
😅
_Shabby Chic?_ That doesn't sound good.
You are beautiful
R.KELLY IS THE GREATEST OF ALL TIME ‼️‼️‼️
TRUMP/JUDY 2024
She doesn't support Trump. She has common sense.
Why should Judge Judy go to jail in 2024?
Nah, I'd rather see Judy rip Trump a new asshole in 2024 =)
How do you watch someone like Judge Judy and think for a millisecond that she would team up with a moron like trump
@@Vibrinspiration Or feminism! Common sense!
I just broke up with a 200 pounder from jersey a few days ago.