No offense but G1 isn't played very cleanly. Elite Spellbinder has to take Collective Brutality I think to not allow him Brutality+Reanimation that turn. Taking Atraxa when there is redundancy in terms of fatties is bad imo. On the other hand once Atraxa got taken Profane should've gotten persist as enchantmenthate is expected out of a naya deck and the -1/-1 counter is irrelevant.
No offense but G1 isn't played very cleanly. Elite Spellbinder has to take Collective Brutality I think to not allow him Brutality+Reanimation that turn. Taking Atraxa when there is redundancy in terms of fatties is bad imo. On the other hand once Atraxa got taken Profane should've gotten persist as enchantmenthate is expected out of a naya deck and the -1/-1 counter is irrelevant.
Without knowing the players' thought processes, about 10 hours of tournament Magic had been played before this match. :-)