Glad AP didn't get Fired. I am willing to give him another season. All the Divas are out and we could build this team up. I like our young players. Lets add and keep the same offense. I like Scott Turner and his dad. Lots of experience there.
I was NEVER with Tom Telesco neither. Then he got rid of JJ and brought in Minshew. Then idc what nobody says, whoever CUT THE CHECKS, is doing the hiring. AP wanted Kingsbury, Kubiak and i forget the other dude. We end up with Getsy. Telesco had a great draft however he had a HORRIBLE Free Agency. QB room worst in league. RB room after not paying J.J, WORST in the league. Oline after draft n free agency, 1 of the worst. Telesco took the offense that got JMD fired and made it WORSE. Why does he get a pass? AP supposed to compete with the AFC West with that offensive personnel? We have to be realistic. I didnt even bring up the injuries! Far as the press conference, read between the lines. AP is not going to throw anyone SPECIFICALLY under the bus. He KNOWS we need a QB and OC. He didnt want Scott Turner, Getsy did. Hopefully we can get Kubiak and whoever cuts the checks. Does not let him out of the building like Kingsbury last year.
i agree the Free Agency was tough. But Getsy, QB coach, and OL coach were trash… Pretty sure they had a say about the OL free agents… But what he did with the DL is really good. In the end, offense wins games and gets you to the playoffs. The defense is needed from there…
We need to keep AP him because from beginning of the season we lost Josh Jacob's, 5 games later we lost Davante Adams, Wilkins got hurt, Koonce & Epps, Max, all hurt. Plus we didn't draft a QB. He deserves more than one year
AP was set up to fail. Take it how you like, but i think he will have more say so. Coupon Tom made that decision to start bugger minshew after pay 15 mill for that dude to just have him sit.
People are mad at staying the course? To me that’s ridiculous. Expecting a first year coach to be perfect. He made horrible decisions early on no doubt. I saw him improve through the season and trying to make best of a bad situation. Plus if he’s not the guy other top coaches will know they won’t have one year to get it done. RN4L🏴☠️☠️🏴☠️
The defense was decent; I believe 15th overall in the league. 2nd youngest team in the league. If AP is back it is what it is. Needs: QB, RB, LG, LB, S. Draft well, resign our own key FAs, get a more than competent O.C., keep the defensive coaching staff in place if possible. This team is not that far away. How about bringing in Justin Fields and drafting Dart in the 2nd round. Take the Big WR from Arizona at 6.
His body language says it all , you can see in his eyes. He will have one more year. We seen it today he knows there is no way he will get this team to the Super Bowl in 25… Holes s only chance is if he can get to the playoffs this is his only chance.
I don't understand the hate for Graham. Ton of injuries, an offense that doesn't help the defense at all, and they were still a middle of the pack defense.
I'm happy we are keeping AP, this group of men we have are going to grow together with some damn continuity!! We have some pieces and need to draft some more pieces. Dan Campbell sucked ass too until they drafted and traded for a QB. So y'all need to stop crying!
Just because he’s staying doesn’t guarantee he will get an extension in the future. Every coach has to improve if they don’t they get replaced. The biggest issue is Coach only got a two year deal and they blew the OC hire now he’s heading into a lame duck season and doesn’t even have a DC under contract with his OC allegedly having an option to go to UNC.
@quentinhood5827 He just ain't a good coach,we have been irrelevant since 2002 minus 1 year ,this year proved he can't make the rite decisions on many levels
There's just alot of uncertainty with AP. AP knows it himself. At times i feel as if its just a body at HC. I mean my man isn't calling any plays on either side of the ball. If he's here next year i hope he gets his guys in free agency and the draft and lets see what he can do. Best of luck!
21 years and 12 head coaches but Graph and others want to make a coaching change. How do you build continuity if you're changing coaches. Sean Peyton missed the playoffs his first two years and then built what he wanted and now they are in the playoffs. Raiders fans use to be some of the smartest but losing has made a lot of us have a not so smart mindset.
What’s crazy is when ppl get real comfortable they sound like T Hill.. there was a lot of things that went into the failure of the season. Wishy washy FANDOM! Do you think they haven’t had a plan b4 the last game win/lose or draw. Many folks blame TT for Minshew!! Now what?
I think TT is here to stay. I think a lot of things AP was saying was cap and fluff for the public and didn’t want to say anything negative about anyone but behind closed doors he and TT understands what needs to be done.
Damn bro you really gave me the finger?? All I was saying is that WE including myself don’t k ow shit about how the raiders are working to put shit together! not just you! Damn bruh can’t even disagree with you before you get all in ur feelings smh
Raiders biggest problem is trying to sell us stuff always listening to the fans and content creators. Listening to players. Hasnt worked out for 20 years. Hopefully telesco has a backbone and understands listening to fools will be his downfall.
How does he sell us fans on it? Ez. Millions of raids fans willing to keep buying tickets & merchandise. He gives more authority to AP then fires him next year of he crashes. If he wins 9 games next year and the season ends with players trying harder than it starts- he stays for 2026.
What if Telasco playing chess either AP figures it out and gets an extension or another tough year and we get our qb next draft in a much stronger class #rnfl
If u ain't gone support him...BOUNCE. stop cryin and complaining. Ap don't care about you sensitive af fake weekly fans. Cant none of yall even touch a football or field so fall back and let the pros work. Couch GMs and coaches don't matter
The revolving coaching door is BS, Pure BS, Jim Harbaugh walked in the Chargers with a new everything and turned it around fast.. So don't tell me that it's a problem.. The Right Coaching is a bigger problem than having a wrong guy in there.. I agree with Graph on that
Your not gonna do very well playing with 2 backup qbs. And all the best players on defense and offense on the injured reserve. There was a few coaching mistakes and a few referee terrible calls that might have gotten us maybe an extra 2 or 3 wins but that's it!
Man not sure how to feel about AP, I always been team AP but he's done a lot of questionable things this season, if he remains coach I wldnt be surprised if he's fired halfway through next season🫠
Where was the animosity towards McDoucheBag after year 1? He was a clearly terrible hire and never deserved the job after our playoff appearance. He ruined the culture we built in 2021 and actually pissed off our entire fan base and ROSTER! I’m not an AP advocate but the hate towards him and not allowing him to build after 1 year is kinda wild to me.
Looks like they will do the typical Raiders thing and Keep AP... Raiders are like the Trump Office.. total S Show..I like when he says he never changes lol, Folks if you can't change, you can't adapt and grow, in anything in life.. same as those who never admits they are ever wrong..
Mark Davis has been riding Al’s coattails and didn’t learn a damn thing from his dad. Keeping a coach that wasn’t even competitive in any game this season and lost ten in a row is a huge mistake!! He was out coached every week besides the Saints coach who is getting fired and a Jags team that mailed it in. AP didn’t even know Sincere and AOC should have been the starters from the jump, hearing that press conference is like nails on a chalkboard with terrible in game management
@ you thinking that vanilla offense with no running game that struggled to score 17 points in four quarters was competitive? I actually have watched a few games or two in person for 24 years at the O.Co and that display this season was not creative or cultural building. Look around the NFL and see how other teams HC’s have their teams prepared week in and week out, when the season was over mid October I knew they were in trouble..
@ 👍. Check out the one score game stat, I had no idea there’s was one but at one point during the season the Raiders still would have had only 3 wins in one score games. It’s tough to watch a HC with training wheels being able to almost keep his job. RN4L
First we need to stop wit this almighty Sean Payton stuff he only beat us twice last season let’s not forget how many time we whooped up on them the past six seasons since we was in OAKLAND
Enjoying the AP haters crashout... don't change ur tone ur sellouts for not supporting our coach and the bad hand he was dealt. Coupon Tom ur on the clock ⏰️ 😂
0-6 in the division for the first time since 2006, and lost 10 straight for the first time since 2014, and this is the guy you delusional fans want to keep? Why? What has he shown that says he deserves another shot? Like, seriously, somebody give me one good thing he showcased as a coach. This is a results league, and his results suck.Hell, Josh McDanies had more wins for crying out loud, and we got his azz outta here way faster. I like AP as a guy, but he's not ready to be an HC in the NFL.
This and Sanjit best Raider content. Straight to business, and Raiders Football TALK. Not ads, no click bait and watching guys chugging beers for money. Lol smh
Raiders have a bunch of good YT creators. But Tape Don’t Lie is probably my fave… they don’t over react and they don’t make excuses for coaching, personnel or players
@@belchmelchagree Raiders have alot of good content creators. Haven't checked out alot of the new ones though but I'll definitely check out tape don't lie. 👍
All these so called fans need to find a new team. You all sure as hell ain't no GMs and most are dumb as hell. Firing coaches every year will keep any talent from coming here. You have to have an identity and stability to succeed in the Not For Long. Mahomes doesn't grow on trees, this draft is horrible for QBs.
Couldn't say it better. I wasn't gonna be surprised if he was fired. But these "fans" and " content" creators think they run the team and to a degree they have for the last few years.
Glad we didnt tank for the 1st. The NFL does not tank look what the Pat's did yesterday. Our GM and other management will figure out what to do with the draft and free agency.
Preach Graph... AP is not that guy, Every time I hear AP talk he sounds like a used car salesman selling some BS. The proof is in the putting, not the talk. After an embarrassing 4-13 season there should be no excuses. That's on the Head Coach, he's supposed to lead and find a way to win, don't give excuses about hurt players and QB, other teams deal with the same shit.
If patrick Graham is leaving he needs to hurry up and make a decision while we may still have a shot at Robert saleh or rex Ryan as defensive coordinator
What’s crazy is when ppl get real comfortable they sound like T Hill.. there was a lot of things that went into the failure of the season. Wishy washy FANDOM! Do you think they haven’t had a plan b4 the last game win/lose or draw. Many folks blame TT for Minshew!! Now what?
You look like you wanted to cry as AP went on. AP is here to stay and a lot of us fans are here for it. RRAAIIIDDEEERRRSSSS
💪🏽 definitely!
………
@@GraphkRaider 😭😭😂😂 Damn we was wrong
RAIDERS!!!!!!!☠️
Bpa in the 1st - Dart in the second or 3rd
Get Dart in the 2nd and Jaden Higgins if he is there in the 3rd. Deone Walker at DT in the 4th
I thought Tom Brady said something about not thinking rookie QB’s should start right away. So AOC would still go into next season as the starter.
Glad AP didn't get Fired. I am willing to give him another season. All the Divas are out and we could build this team up. I like our young players. Lets add and keep the same offense. I like Scott Turner and his dad. Lots of experience there.
We can’t stay the course. It’s F insane
Graph face listing to AP...🤣
We need to draft RB Henderson out of Ohio State 😎
Absolutely Yes and Jack Campbell
I was NEVER with Tom Telesco neither. Then he got rid of JJ and brought in Minshew. Then idc what nobody says, whoever CUT THE CHECKS, is doing the hiring. AP wanted Kingsbury, Kubiak and i forget the other dude. We end up with Getsy. Telesco had a great draft however he had a HORRIBLE Free Agency. QB room worst in league. RB room after not paying J.J, WORST in the league. Oline after draft n free agency, 1 of the worst. Telesco took the offense that got JMD fired and made it WORSE. Why does he get a pass? AP supposed to compete with the AFC West with that offensive personnel? We have to be realistic. I didnt even bring up the injuries!
Far as the press conference, read between the lines. AP is not going to throw anyone SPECIFICALLY under the bus. He KNOWS we need a QB and OC. He didnt want Scott Turner, Getsy did. Hopefully we can get Kubiak and whoever cuts the checks. Does not let him out of the building like Kingsbury last year.
i agree the Free Agency was tough. But Getsy, QB coach, and OL coach were trash… Pretty sure they had a say about the OL free agents…
But what he did with the DL is really good.
In the end, offense wins games and gets you to the playoffs. The defense is needed from there…
We need to keep AP him because from beginning of the season we lost Josh Jacob's, 5 games later we lost Davante Adams, Wilkins got hurt, Koonce & Epps, Max, all hurt. Plus we didn't draft a QB. He deserves more than one year
@@MrHfolsome I thought Jacobs was in Green Bay? My mistake I thought it was a dream
We didn't lose Devante Adams. Adams witnessed the incompetence and wanted out.
@@rickl2633 …and *HE ASKED TO BE TRADED TO A MORE INCOMPETENT TEAM.* 😆🤔 What does that tell you…? 🤭
Anyone thinking Tom Telesco should pick our coach is wrong
We are on the books to pay three coaches next year. Didn’t make sense to pay a forth
What 3 coaches are we paying?
The spanos family sounds like they didn’t want no one in control but them nasty work
Well FUCK, I DONT THINK HE CAN DO ANY WORSE!!
AP was set up to fail. Take it how you like, but i think he will have more say so. Coupon Tom made that decision to start bugger minshew after pay 15 mill for that dude to just have him sit.
Ninjas be actin like 304s..changing up in they feelings cuz they don't get they way...AP here haters. U don't like it jump ship
Tom signed on knowing AP was coach, and Tom hired a bunch of bad coaches not just Staley
AP has a say in those coaches. Telesco wasn’t there when they let their OL coach go to NYG.
Justin fields looks like the only qb option for the raiders in 2025
Team Tank.You were wrong all along. AP is here to stay another season.
………
People are mad at staying the course? To me that’s ridiculous. Expecting a first year coach to be perfect. He made horrible decisions early on no doubt. I saw him improve through the season and trying to make best of a bad situation. Plus if he’s not the guy other top coaches will know they won’t have one year to get it done. RN4L🏴☠️☠️🏴☠️
The defense was decent; I believe 15th overall in the league. 2nd youngest team in the league. If AP is back it is what it is. Needs: QB, RB, LG, LB, S. Draft well, resign our own key FAs, get a more than competent O.C., keep the defensive coaching staff in place if possible. This team is not that far away. How about bringing in Justin Fields and drafting Dart in the 2nd round. Take the Big WR from Arizona at 6.
Tha GM wouldn’t fire a coach and expose himself this early. It’s all about insurance
His body language says it all , you can see in his eyes. He will have one more year. We seen it today he knows there is no way he will get this team to the Super Bowl in 25… Holes s only chance is if he can get to the playoffs this is his only chance.
Just got fired
Turners are staying I think
Deone Walker out of Kentucky would be a solid pick if he is available in the 3rd or 4th round.
I don't understand the hate for Graham. Ton of injuries, an offense that doesn't help the defense at all, and they were still a middle of the pack defense.
I'm happy we are keeping AP, this group of men we have are going to grow together with some damn continuity!! We have some pieces and need to draft some more pieces. Dan Campbell sucked ass too until they drafted and traded for a QB. So y'all need to stop crying!
AP isn't even closely qualified to go against the big dawgs in our division, we need to start over
Me to
@kamelsekhon519 uh he beat a big dawg last year and a big dawg this year so what you saying
Just because he’s staying doesn’t guarantee he will get an extension in the future. Every coach has to improve if they don’t they get replaced. The biggest issue is Coach only got a two year deal and they blew the OC hire now he’s heading into a lame duck season and doesn’t even have a DC under contract with his OC allegedly having an option to go to UNC.
@quentinhood5827 He just ain't a good coach,we have been irrelevant since 2002 minus 1 year ,this year proved he can't make the rite decisions on many levels
AP was taking shots at Telesco saying he wish he went with his gut
There's just alot of uncertainty with AP. AP knows it himself. At times i feel as if its just a body at HC. I mean my man isn't calling any plays on either side of the ball. If he's here next year i hope he gets his guys in free agency and the draft and lets see what he can do. Best of luck!
It’s only one year never know wat can happen next year
21 years and 12 head coaches but Graph and others want to make a coaching change. How do you build continuity if you're changing coaches. Sean Peyton missed the playoffs his first two years and then built what he wanted and now they are in the playoffs. Raiders fans use to be some of the smartest but losing has made a lot of us have a not so smart mindset.
What’s crazy is when ppl get real comfortable they sound like T Hill..
there was a lot of things that went into the failure of the season. Wishy washy FANDOM! Do you think they haven’t had a plan b4 the last game win/lose or draw. Many folks blame TT for Minshew!! Now what?
I know the AP Haters are mad Lol 😂
………
I think TT is here to stay. I think a lot of things AP was saying was cap and fluff for the public and didn’t want to say anything negative about anyone but behind closed doors he and TT understands what needs to be done.
Damn bro you really gave me the finger?? All I was saying is that WE including myself don’t k ow shit about how the raiders are working to put shit together! not just you! Damn bruh can’t even disagree with you before you get all in ur feelings smh
Yeah Watson reaggravated his Achilles injury
Raiders biggest problem is trying to sell us stuff always listening to the fans and content creators. Listening to players. Hasnt worked out for 20 years. Hopefully telesco has a backbone and understands listening to fools will be his downfall.
Drew Aller is special
Hopefully 🙏 he’s gone thank you for trying out but we have too move on
AP will do better next season
😂😂😂 don’t hold your breath
………
Graph just don't like ap...he shaking his head in disgust but u hate on him for content smh
………
You AP haters act like we had starting caliber playmakers all year. Down playing the wins like we weren’t playing backups too smh crazy
………
@ Gotta hand it to Mark, he always finds a way to make us fans look like idiots. Another rebuild year incoming. It’s exhausting.
Graph, Gruden’s team went to the playoffs with a Special teams coach it was set up so well. That’s why we say Gruden over AP!
How does he sell us fans on it?
Ez. Millions of raids fans willing to keep buying tickets & merchandise.
He gives more authority to AP then fires him next year of he crashes. If he wins 9 games next year and the season ends with players trying harder than it starts- he stays for 2026.
What if Telasco playing chess either AP figures it out and gets an extension or another tough year and we get our qb next draft in a much stronger class #rnfl
I like Trevor etienne
If u ain't gone support him...BOUNCE. stop cryin and complaining. Ap don't care about you sensitive af fake weekly fans. Cant none of yall even touch a football or field so fall back and let the pros work. Couch GMs and coaches don't matter
………
Going 0 & 6 in a Division is a fireable reason to can AP! RN4L 🔥 ☠️ 🏈 🤬 🔥
The revolving coaching door is BS, Pure BS, Jim Harbaugh walked in the Chargers with a new everything and turned it around fast.. So don't tell me that it's a problem.. The Right Coaching is a bigger problem than having a wrong guy in there.. I agree with Graph on that
Caleb Williams being called a bust but he had similar stats as Jayden Daniels just not the W's.
Coaching matters
@spaceghostfarrt yes sir
Your not gonna do very well playing with 2 backup qbs. And all the best players on defense and offense on the injured reserve. There was a few coaching mistakes and a few referee terrible calls that might have gotten us maybe an extra 2 or 3 wins but that's it!
How about Doug Pederson as O.C. and Robert Saleh as D.C. Now if AP shit the bed Doug Pederson moves in.
Kliff Kingsbury, Pete Carroll
Naw I don’t think Tommy T but I think it was more twords Luke Getsy
I need to know why PG has to go I really need to know
Sorry dox but I ain’t hear him say he wanted Gardner that’s a reach
Fire A P
Our Raiders never do the right thing. Man we are Doomed.
Man not sure how to feel about AP, I always been team AP but he's done a lot of questionable things this season, if he remains coach I wldnt be surprised if he's fired halfway through next season🫠
Where was the animosity towards McDoucheBag after year 1? He was a clearly terrible hire and never deserved the job after our playoff appearance. He ruined the culture we built in 2021 and actually pissed off our entire fan base and ROSTER! I’m not an AP advocate but the hate towards him and not allowing him to build after 1 year is kinda wild to me.
WTF!! PIERCE IS NOT GETTING FIRED...
🤦🏻♂️
………
Gruden is a cult of personality
You guys are deep diving into next yrs draft way too much. You guys ain’t nfl
Coaches. Let it go, move on,and find another job!
NFL credentialed and do this for an actual living. God bless your heart tho 🙏🏼
Looks like they will do the typical Raiders thing and Keep AP... Raiders are like the Trump Office.. total S Show..I like when he says he never changes lol, Folks if you can't change, you can't adapt and grow, in anything in life.. same as those who never admits they are ever wrong..
Go lakers 😎
Are we bringing back the SoulTrain Line at practice next season also. Commitment to Excellence!🏴☠️
This is a Joke!
Mark Davis has been riding Al’s coattails and didn’t learn a damn thing from his dad. Keeping a coach that wasn’t even competitive in any game this season and lost ten in a row is a huge mistake!! He was out coached every week besides the Saints coach who is getting fired and a Jags team that mailed it in. AP didn’t even know Sincere and AOC should have been the starters from the jump, hearing that press conference is like nails on a chalkboard with terrible in game management
Not competitive in any game? Ok champ
@ you thinking that vanilla offense with no running game that struggled to score 17 points in four quarters was competitive? I actually have watched a few games or two in person for 24 years at the O.Co and that display this season was not creative or cultural building. Look around the NFL and see how other teams HC’s have their teams prepared week in and week out, when the season was over mid October I knew they were in trouble..
@@oaklandfan5262 you said not competitive in any game.
@ 👍. Check out the one score game stat, I had no idea there’s was one but at one point during the season the Raiders still would have had only 3 wins in one score games. It’s tough to watch a HC with training wheels being able to almost keep his job. RN4L
I'm with you Graph, shaking my head bro.
First we need to stop wit this almighty Sean Payton stuff he only beat us twice last season let’s not forget how many time we whooped up on them the past six seasons since we was in OAKLAND
His analysis of AOC is just proof
RAIDERRUDY48 HERE...LOVE THIS CONTENT
Enjoying the AP haters crashout... don't change ur tone ur sellouts for not supporting our coach and the bad hand he was dealt. Coupon Tom ur on the clock ⏰️ 😂
………
Graph, is the only content creator that has said let Telesco cook on his own. I think AP asked the Raiders for this exit press conference.
Yo
0-6 in the division for the first time since 2006, and lost 10 straight for the first time since 2014, and this is the guy you delusional fans want to keep? Why? What has he shown that says he deserves another shot? Like, seriously, somebody give me one good thing he showcased as a coach. This is a results league, and his results suck.Hell, Josh McDanies had more wins for crying out loud, and we got his azz outta here way faster. I like AP as a guy, but he's not ready to be an HC in the NFL.
I remember that dox bro was pissed 😂 but you right give up the keys
This and Sanjit best Raider content. Straight to business, and Raiders Football TALK. Not ads, no click bait and watching guys chugging beers for money. Lol smh
Raiders have a bunch of good YT creators. But Tape Don’t Lie is probably my fave… they don’t over react and they don’t make excuses for coaching, personnel or players
@@belchmelchagree Raiders have alot of good content creators. Haven't checked out alot of the new ones though but I'll definitely check out tape don't lie. 👍
All these so called fans need to find a new team. You all sure as hell ain't no GMs and most are dumb as hell. Firing coaches every year will keep any talent from coming here. You have to have an identity and stability to succeed in the Not For Long. Mahomes doesn't grow on trees, this draft is horrible for QBs.
Couldn't say it better. I wasn't gonna be surprised if he was fired. But these "fans" and " content" creators think they run the team and to a degree they have for the last few years.
So what was the reason we got Tom Brady ?this clown show is staying the same. Disgusting 🤮
I missed where Brady said keep AP or fire AP.
If Brady can get Mike G to be the new HC- he might.
Otherwise Brady is all about stability in coaches.
Awwww yeah, AP is back and Shadeur is coming ..maybe Saleh comes in..?
Glad we didnt tank for the 1st. The NFL does not tank look what the Pat's did yesterday. Our GM and other management will figure out what to do with the draft and free agency.
Definitely get rid of Graham and being in Saleh
Get ready for Will Johnson
I still say we are drafting Shedeur .
I'm not into AP! How I feel is an offensive coordinator headcoach is better than a defensive guy RN4L🔥☠️🏈🤬🔥
What do you think about Russel ?
Preach Graph... AP is not that guy, Every time I hear AP talk he sounds like a used car salesman selling some BS. The proof is in the putting, not the talk. After an embarrassing 4-13 season there should be no excuses. That's on the Head Coach, he's supposed to lead and find a way to win, don't give excuses about hurt players and QB, other teams deal with the same shit.
Dumb.
If AP stays it going to be the same clown show next season . Us raiders fans are doomed 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Tommy T ain’t gotta bet nothing if he ain’t got the keys
All AP did was spew excuses.same ol crap.
AP is not pointing fingers and is taking responsibility, allowing outside influence effect is judgment.
If patrick Graham is leaving he needs to hurry up and make a decision while we may still have a shot at Robert saleh or rex Ryan as defensive coordinator
I think mark davis is trying to buy time and save alittle money after having to pay off jon gruden and josh ( the worst coach ever) mcdonut!
I still say we are drafting Shedeur .
What’s crazy is when ppl get real comfortable they sound like T Hill..
there was a lot of things that went into the failure of the season. Wishy washy FANDOM! Do you think they haven’t had a plan b4 the last game win/lose or draw. Many folks blame TT for Minshew!! Now what?
Umm...what ?