Rosè for sure, but not than Karina. While Karina gets messy, and Giselle has better approach, her mix is too light to be a Higher Weak to average (^D+) bcz of her light mix, she tends to get shallow, and her Bb4's quality it's not enough to be higher than a High Weak to average (D+), so while she's better than for example IVE's Liz (that presents similar issues but it's Mid/High Weak to average) she has yet to improve to get at Karina's level or to Low average tier. Still impressive for a sub vocalist and rapper
![[BAEMON NEWS 7] NEW ALBUM COMING IN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wtVeAPimOyo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[단독샷캠4K] 에스파 'Whiplash' 단독샷 별도녹화│aespa ONE TAKE STAGE│@SBS Inkigayo 241027](/img/n.gif)
She has such a lovely voice, I wish SM let her vocals shine more
Giselle is going to be taemin in the future
Gigi has such a gorgeous and elegant vocals
Yeh, and 99% of these moments are just quick phrase (50% of them discovered through fancall), SM rather let Giselle shine with her voice!!!!
What's the highest note that Giselle hit till now? If only she had more lines, I think she could sing better than what she's been singing so far
c#5 in girls i guess?
A5 in black mamba one of the background vocals
A5 in black mamba
I think now it's D#5 in Live My Life
queen ❤
Can you do a video of winter in this new concert i head she support c#5 in salty and sweet..please do a video about winter in this concert ❄️
I just wish her support was fuller like Karina’s
Her support is fuller than karinas
@@이런-아 more like lighter* lol
It's just her tone
@@이런-아 No, she's lighter
@@yujikari that's her tone
is she better than both karina and rosè
Yes
Yess
Giselle >Karina> Rose actually
Rosè for sure, but not than Karina. While Karina gets messy, and Giselle has better approach, her mix is too light to be a Higher Weak to average (^D+) bcz of her light mix, she tends to get shallow, and her Bb4's quality it's not enough to be higher than a High Weak to average (D+), so while she's better than for example IVE's Liz (that presents similar issues but it's Mid/High Weak to average) she has yet to improve to get at Karina's level or to Low average tier. Still impressive for a sub vocalist and rapper
@@keonheehe interesting i see the majority place her higher bc she’s not as throaty and seems to have a better sense of support