The beauty of their bond is that it transcends a label. No matter what angle you may see it from, nothing changes the fact that it’s a connection between souls, a relationship of spirits, showcasing the core meaning of love itself.
I don't know about people seriously arguing about a relationship between Sam and Frodo. It's just fun because there are so many Instances in the film showing the depth of their love for each other, whatever kind of love. I think you're taking things to seriously. It's just a joke imo. Anyway, ever heard of the kinsey scale. It's not impossible there is a spark of erotic love in addition to the agape and storge.
@@ElroyMF1 I also don't know many people who actually think there's something there, but to be honest, I think it's at least a valid debate to be had here. Obviously none of the subtext is intentional, neither by Tolkien nor by Jackson, but that doesn't really matter all that much in my opinion. I honestly don't know why many people are that opposed to the thought (well no, I do know, some don't want the Hobbits to be gay because they like the Hobbits but aren't comfortable with gayness). They clearly love each other deeply, and considering all we know about the Hobbit's society, I don't think Sam and Frodo would have the language to express any big gay feelings, or the freedom to show them. I think it's a completely valid reading of the story. It works very well, nothing contradicts it (because Sam can obviously be bisexual and like both Frodo and Rosie, no problem at all). But even if it wasn't, if they said "no homo" after every single hug and slept with every woman they met on the way - I could still totally ship them. There's a difference between a romantic bond you WANT to be there (a ship, that's always possible) and one you think IS there. (So basically exactly what you said, just with more words :D)
@@kaydenblack3178 Dunno--curiosity, perhaps. Sometimes people can edit a film in such a way to make a compelling music video about a relationship. And this was one of them.
I dont even really like Taylor Swift but this is just so perfectly edited that it legit made me cry in while I was at work. I am so mentally unstable about them. I love this so frickin much.
Literally! Look at the ending. “You cannot always be torn in two..” why would Frodo say that if Sam wasn’t in love with him as well as Rosie? It’s like the end of Casablanca. Like Ingrid Bergman, Sam has to accept that he must choose the partner who can give him his best life (Rosie) over his soulmate (Frodo).
This vid is just too funny and cute. Just wish the scenes with Rosie weren't included. No hate to her, but I personally feel her getting married to Sam was forced
I hate the 40 so theories i have heard about a gay relatonship of Frodo and Sam! There are two ways I look at it. Scratch it cause Sam obviously isn't when he is shy of Rosie and then marries her. Frodo even smiles at a couple female characters! If you think Gay, what about Merry and Pippin. I've seen them two together more than anyone! When Frodo and Sam leave the Shire...who runs into them? Merry and Pippin. When Borimir is dying, lets see...who gets kidnapped together...Merry and Pippin! Finally, the third film. Pippin sees death around him. Then reunites with Merry! (Sure Frodo and Sam are many miles away from them!) But what about Eowyn, Aragorn and the dwarf Gimil? They are in the same battle with them! But the main focus Again is...Merry and Pippin! I rest my case!
aren't pippin and merry first cousins? anyway, bisexual people exist, but no one thinks sam and frodo were intended to be gay in the books or movies. we all know they weren't. but it's normal for gay people to project into characters that have such and intense and caring relationship with each other. any interpretation is valid, even outside of what the authors intended.
@@corruption8639 lmao i don't even try to understand the straights anymore xd "gaspp how dare you suggest that gay people are rappresented in this moviee? :oo"
@@bubbleous9994 so now gay people are the ones projecting? Lol Straights want everything to be straight, even when it's totally gay, they just refuse to see it. Cause heterosexuality is the canon thing, always.. You can eventually make up something gay but that's not real amirite?
Tbh i love Sam and frodos relationship both as a romance and as a friendship, either is amazing
I totally agree with u.
The beauty of their bond is that it transcends a label. No matter what angle you may see it from, nothing changes the fact that it’s a connection between souls, a relationship of spirits, showcasing the core meaning of love itself.
You put that beautifully 💚@@12classics39
Samwise has a wife named Rosie cotton
Belate happy 10 years to this national treasure
"We keep quiet, 'cause we're dead if they knew" With the Nazgûl I can't 😂
why am i laughing and crying at the same time
Frodo looking at samwise after he gets married looked so genuine im sksksks
Me the moment I heard this song start to play; YOU DIDN'T 😭
I love these two so freaking much and this took the cake 🤍
Oh my goodness this was hilarious! XD I love it so much! Too perfect!
They love each other so much hh i'm gonna cry-
Also it's funny how well the lyrics fit with the scenes, i'm laughing so hardd
This is perfect💓
Oh Mr. Frodo
I usually can't stand the argument that Sam and Frodo might like each other in that way, but.....DANG IT, this was too GOOD!!
I don't know about people seriously arguing about a relationship between Sam and Frodo. It's just fun because there are so many Instances in the film showing the depth of their love for each other, whatever kind of love. I think you're taking things to seriously. It's just a joke imo.
Anyway, ever heard of the kinsey scale. It's not impossible there is a spark of erotic love in addition to the agape and storge.
@@ElroyMF1 I also don't know many people who actually think there's something there, but to be honest, I think it's at least a valid debate to be had here. Obviously none of the subtext is intentional, neither by Tolkien nor by Jackson, but that doesn't really matter all that much in my opinion.
I honestly don't know why many people are that opposed to the thought (well no, I do know, some don't want the Hobbits to be gay because they like the Hobbits but aren't comfortable with gayness). They clearly love each other deeply, and considering all we know about the Hobbit's society, I don't think Sam and Frodo would have the language to express any big gay feelings, or the freedom to show them.
I think it's a completely valid reading of the story. It works very well, nothing contradicts it (because Sam can obviously be bisexual and like both Frodo and Rosie, no problem at all). But even if it wasn't, if they said "no homo" after every single hug and slept with every woman they met on the way - I could still totally ship them.
There's a difference between a romantic bond you WANT to be there (a ship, that's always possible) and one you think IS there.
(So basically exactly what you said, just with more words :D)
Lmao, if you hate the ship how did you end up here?
@@kaydenblack3178 Dunno--curiosity, perhaps. Sometimes people can edit a film in such a way to make a compelling music video about a relationship. And this was one of them.
@@WishfulThinkingArt yeah, this amv is very well done :)
I’m crying 🥲 one of my favorite parts of this is that it implies a fatherly bond between Frodo and Gandalf
I dont even really like Taylor Swift but this is just so perfectly edited that it legit made me cry in while I was at work. I am so mentally unstable about them. I love this so frickin much.
You made my year a decade ago tysm ❤❤🥺💖💖
Beautiful film, beautiful song = The Perfect Music Video :D
Finding this years too late but I smashed that like button when Sam was on the straight stair and it said about the staircase I'm CACKLING xD
It made cry so heart warming and beautiful
Very well done, I love it!
i love this ship SAM X FRODO IN MY HEARTH
It's a lot more like that in the books actually. The way they express love is so romantic in the book
Literally! Look at the ending. “You cannot always be torn in two..” why would Frodo say that if Sam wasn’t in love with him as well as Rosie? It’s like the end of Casablanca. Like Ingrid Bergman, Sam has to accept that he must choose the partner who can give him his best life (Rosie) over his soulmate (Frodo).
I wonder Elija wood watches this kind of vids
and what would he think of this when he does lol
Beautiful 💗 definitely deserves more views 👏
haha my favorite part is frodo's face under the tree
You are a genius. This video is great.
Only just discovered this - amazing haha!
So fantastic🥰💖💖
STAY AWAY FROM JULIET
Thank you.
And my daddy said : BAaaAarGh
gains
this song is so carefree as if it was made specially for hobbits ))
i so love this video it so cute and sweet
oh sam
Que linda amistad 😍
I applaud you.
The moment taylors song started playing i laughed i dunno why
Sam Bagains
Aight. I got some movies to watch...peace ✌
heads up this vid's about to spike in views
Fantasticks movie 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
Nice Job, how long did it take you to make it.
We gay people love this ship. uwu
I ship it
who can I make friends with?)
This vid is just too funny and cute. Just wish the scenes with Rosie weren't included. No hate to her, but I personally feel her getting married to Sam was forced
que tonterias escriben en ves de decir que esta cancion es hermosa
tf
I hate the 40 so theories i have heard about a gay relatonship of Frodo and Sam! There are two ways I look at it. Scratch it cause Sam obviously isn't when he is shy of Rosie and then marries her. Frodo even smiles at a couple female characters! If you think Gay, what about Merry and Pippin. I've seen them two together more than anyone! When Frodo and Sam leave the Shire...who runs into them? Merry and Pippin. When Borimir is dying, lets see...who gets kidnapped together...Merry and Pippin! Finally, the third film. Pippin sees death around him. Then reunites with Merry! (Sure Frodo and Sam are many miles away from them!) But what about Eowyn, Aragorn and the dwarf Gimil? They are in the same battle with them! But the main focus Again is...Merry and Pippin! I rest my case!
aren't pippin and merry first cousins?
anyway, bisexual people exist, but no one thinks sam and frodo were intended to be gay in the books or movies. we all know they weren't. but it's normal for gay people to project into characters that have such and intense and caring relationship with each other. any interpretation is valid, even outside of what the authors intended.
why did u spend real hours making a case for straightness 👁👄👁
Pippin and Merry do not live in Alabama
@@corruption8639 lmao i don't even try to understand the straights anymore xd "gaspp how dare you suggest that gay people are rappresented in this moviee? :oo"
@@bubbleous9994 so now gay people are the ones projecting? Lol
Straights want everything to be straight, even when it's totally gay, they just refuse to see it. Cause heterosexuality is the canon thing, always.. You can eventually make up something gay but that's not real amirite?