The Newshour Debate: Subramanian Swamy Vs Gandhis - Full Debate (26th June 2014)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 มิ.ย. 2014
- Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels
The NewsHour Debate : goo.gl/LfNgFF
ET Now : goo.gl/5XreUq
Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
Social Media Links :-
Twitter - goo.gl/FzJIpz
Congress President Sonia Gandhi, and son Rahul Gandhi were summoned as accused by a local court for alleged cheating and misappropriation of funds in acquiring ownership of the now-defunct daily National Herald. Holding that complainant BJP leader Subramanian Swamy has established a prima facie case of cheating, misappropriation of funds and criminal breach of trust against the accused, Metropolitan Magistrate Gomati Manocha issued summons also issued summons AICC Treasurer Moti Lal Vohra, General Secretary Oscar Fernandes, and Suman Dubey and Sam Pitroda, besides the Gandhis, to appear before the court on August 7. All of them are directors of Young Indian Ltd (YI), a company that was incorporated in 2010 and which took over the "debt" of Associated Journals Ltd (AJL), the publisher of National Herald. Swamy had accused Sonia and Rahul Gandhi and others of conspiring to cheat and misappropriate funds by just paying Rs.50 lakh by which YI obtained the right to recover Rs. 90.25 crore which the AJL had owed to the Congress party. He alleged that in the present scenario over Rs. 2,000 worth of assets also got transferred to YI, whose 76 percent of shareholding vests with Sonia and Rahul Gandhi and the remaining shareholding of 24 percent vests with the other accused. "Complainant has established a prima facie case against the accused under section 403 (dishonest misappropriation of property, 406 (criminal breach of trust) and 420 (cheating) read with section 120B (criminal conspiracy) of IPC. "Hence, let the accused Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, Moti Lal Vohra, Oscar Fernandes, Suman Dubey and Sam Pitroda be summoned for August 7, 2014. Let the Young Indian be summoned through it's authorised representative for the same date," said Manocha. Reacting to the development, Congress spokesman and a senior lawyer Abhishek Manu Singhvi said the party will respond "vigorously" to the allegations made by Swamy. "Dr. Swamy is known for his personal, motivated campaign against the Congress and you can take it that as and when we receive the papers and take the full legal advice a very vigorous response will be filed in respect of this completely false and motivated complaint.
"Issuance of process over a stale complaint made a year ago is not something to be excited about. Let's seek comprehensive legal advice and you will see how all allegations are legally demolished," Singhvi said. The court, in its order, said, "From the complaint and the evidence led so far, it appears that YI was in fact created as a sham or a cloak to convert public money to personal use or as a special purpose vehicle for acquiring control over Rs. 2000 crores worth of assets of The Associated Journals Ltd.(AJL). "Since all the accused persons have allegedly acted in consortium with each other to achieve the said nefarious design, there are sufficient grounds for proceeding against all of them," the court said. It said the accused Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, Moti Lal Vohra, Oscar Fernandes were the office bearers and trustees of the funds of the Congress party and the funds of the party were not the personal property of the accused. "The funds entrusted to them by the party were to be utilised to advance the purposes for which the Congress party was formed. "These funds could not have been advanced in the form of an interest-free loan to AJL, as no provisions exists in the Representation of the People Acts or the constitution of the party permitting grant of any such loan to a company engaged in commercial activities," the court said. "The accused, prima facie appears to have committed criminal breach of trust on the existing share holders of AJL as well as against the company," it added. The court further said that the accused appeared to have cheated the state exchequer as well by claiming tax exemption by showcasing the objective the donations, etc. were sought by the Congress from the people and diverting those funds to commercial purposes.
In a debate moderated by TIMES NOW's Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami, panelists -- Subramanian Swamy, Sr. Leader BJP; Prof R Vaidyanathan, Professor, IIM Bangalore; Mahesh Jethmalani, Advocate; Randeep Singh Surjewala, Spokesperosn, Congress; Rahul Narvekar, Spokesperson & MLC, NCP; Kumar Ketkar, Senior Journalist -- discuss whether after loss of power at the centre, the summons will dent the Congress image.
Long Live Sbramanian Swamy. God gives you all his protection and long life to serve India.
+ha-ram-linga chaddiutarsingh app chutiye ho...
+Raj D Ye linga chutia nahi pakka madarchod hai
Subramaniam Swamy is epic!! He delivers his statement and just sits there and laughs for 40 minutes at the others making a fool out of themselves
🔑
U know u r in trouble when Dr. Swamy has that smile on his face...god save the Gandhi's and hope the court gives them a long and hard punishment.
his smile is infectious
I wish if the court couriers the aliens to their Native Land.
Oh yeah
THE ONE MAN ARMY - the Great Dr. SWAMY
Dear Arnab,
Consider this as a personal letter direct to you.
In Future we don't want to see Surjawala in your debate show or wherever, as his facts and his way of sarcasm to everybody who's there in the debate and also to us(viewers) is so much annoying and waste of time.
I hope anybody in this world dont want to waste time esply in a debate of a National Tv.
So kindly please dont make this mistake ever in your channel and this mistake of bringing Surjawala is very much regretful.
Last but not the least MR Surjawala, Thank you so much for exposing yourself.
You Sincerely
Viewers of Newshour debate
Arnab if we Tax evade what Punishment in India the same
Punishment apply Rahul Gandhi
And Sonia Gandhi,Surjewala they
Are so Congress Cemcha these
Is not today since sixty years
Tax Evades A to Z Gutala tell
Them pay Taxes are put him Jail
This is why we need more Subramanian Swamys in our country. He may have a massive ego, he may have his prejudices, but the man is adept at legally cornering big wigs like no other person in the country.
Love you Mr. Swamy... For fighting for the betterment of India... You are the second father of our nation... No country had to go through 2 freedom struggles!!! We need to break-free from this tyranny too
Kudos to Dr. swami.
You have done a great job.
look at Swamy's smile, a big big grin.
This is a look of satisfaction when you win after fighting for decades.
Love how Swamy sits there laughing like Naradar who's deeds are done for good, even if it might seem like poking.
Wow, what expose's he has brought out. First 2G and now this.
This khujliwala should have been thrown out. Also why doesnt anyone comment about the other Congress spokeperson who runs away in the middle? Hmm...
Other congress spokesperson is another demented sycophant of gandhis . Kumar Ketkar is a salaried congress person who is paid to defend misdeeds of gandhis.
thiruvetti
Hats off to Subramania swamy and M Jethmalani for bringing these cases out..Without these people india will be fooled without even someoone noticing it..
swami is such a badass ♡ just love him
ban that cong media spokesperson.... he doesn't listen...only speaks nonsense.... a disgust for a debate
+Bikash Padhi
surjhewaala = bhosdiwaala
+Bikash Padhi surjewala the Congress spokesman has a verbal diarrhea and keeps blabbering like a trained parrot.
+Rohan Joshua ....RANDI-p Surjewala is a seasoned LIAR at par with ZERO LOSS SIBAL and CHIDAMBRUM......
Sadguru Prerna If its about Lying, No one can beat 'Feku-The Real Bluff-master'. But for one reason, even I am a Fan of Feku,
*Banda Apne Hi Bhakton Ki Leta Hai...Wo Bhi Kehke...*
Romi Buzz ...Americans often say FAKE IT UNTIL YOU MAKE IT !....
If Kumar Ketkar does not have any facts why he participated in this show at first place...everybody in Maharashtra knows that he is a congressi first and then a journalist..
Same for narvekar
Subrahmanyam Swamy, you are a genius!
INC spokesperson reminds one of a HMV vinyl record. Never stops.
Swamy called Surjewala a DEMENTED FOOL ...GO AND HAVE YOUR BRAINS CHECKED ........ hahahahahahahahaha .... love you swamiji ...
Sanjay Jha is heaps better and that's saying something. Obnoxious filibustering.
Congress representatives always disturb the debates by shouting and not allowing others to talk. Arnab Goswami is inept as a host of a debate. He should disable the microphone of anyone who disturb others. Gandhi, Nehru family should be arrested and put in jail without any trial.
+Govind Deshmukh i agree
I would have mounted a rocket in Mr surjewalas backside and sent him outside this solar system. this man is so much annoying and irritating.
Arnab should put off Surjee's mic when other members are talking
Agreed Dr Swami that MF Sujewala is Fu888n demented and lots more.
In entire panel only Swamy was found happy laughing till end, he is confident of what he does is right,only genius can do it.
Surjewala successfully diverted the debate and Arnab didn't do anything.
Next time Arnab use the MUTE button.
Kumar Ketkar exposed himself as the most illogical person on the panel no wonder he is the stooge of the congress. If he does not know the facts as he claims in the beginning he should have quietly declined the invitation to participate in the debate saying that he is not knowledgeable on the subject.
Hats off to subramanya swamy for digging out the truth. After all subramanya swamy is subramanya swamy. Great.
when you vomit.. its Congress party..
+truth is always painful ...and when you get Diarrhea, what comes out is BJP.
Romi Buzz some one got pain in ASS
+truth is always painful hahaha what a slap
i want to vomit on romi buzz
+truth is always painful Off course Man Because Bhakt(s) got a Diarrhea and So your Ass will hurt.
+Jitendra Bhosale Slapped!...Who?
Fuddu Bhakts, As usual....
This guy battamizwala is annoying as hell...just keeps shouting the same song over and over again without giving a chance for others to talk.
Arnab should come up with a mute button to press once the guest is done with his allowed amount of time on air so that he can go on with other guests and not waste time on just one idiot.
He should have a mute button for himself too as nowadays he talks for 99.9% of time.
MUTE THE FU@KING BA@STARD OF CON PARTY....
arnab cannot press mute button like ManDmohan singh cuz mute button hold by sonia nehru...
if he press, he will going to loose all bribes from congress,...
Ankit Patel
Here is someone who can outshout Abrnab and turn into a helpless spectator !!! Rajdeep Surjewala !!!
This was the funniest Newshour Debate !!!
MY god, Surjewala can talk rubbish for hours on end
True man, he is just trying to waste the time, and not reach at any conclusion.
This Surjiwala should be banned from future debates as he continues to speak nonsense
You can do better, Arnab. Disallow such ridiculous rants by spokespeople.
I would like to remind mr surjewala that though mr arnab is loyal to 10 janpat but we indians are not fools what are u talking about vendetta every time what vendetta 2000 crore of public money is looted and u say it vendetta shame on u shame on ur nationalism shame on u for defending chors shame shame
Love You Dr.Swamy.
Proud of him. He is from my State TAMIL NADU
@@ramkumarkantha9143 Naanum tamil dhaan :)
@@multicast100 sooper bro.. Vanakkam
both are going to jail.well done swamiji.he is real anti corruption yodha not like someone who wears a AAM admi and does press conferences and does nothing.long live swamiji and let's make congress mukht Bharat
KHANGRESS MUKT BHARAT..
There is only one Subramaniaswamy who has talent and guts to expose all corruption activities of bloody Cong
hatsoff to Dr. Swamy
Hats off to Swamy ji...please save India.
Don't know if anyone noticed that...Whenever swamiji speaks sabjiwala starts interrupting him...I think italy madam and buddhu have directed him to do so
Yes it is a fit case for prosecution of Mrs Gandhi and her son.Hats up to Sri Subramanian swamy to bring such cases of high profiled persons to the court of law. I admire you for this excellent job .
arnab: why u r so biased and will not let the defendants speak and keep on butting and let the viewers listen the complete debate. you never butt in when subramaniam swami or any of bjp members were speaking. this is a total biased debate on your part. tks.
arnab only interviened when surjewala was making personal arguments, when arnab had already mentioned that the debate would be about specifics.There was no problem with arnab in this debate. he tried to do a good job.
***** Ek surjewaala jhela nahi jaa raha
ek aur paida ho gaya.
what a shameful language and how Arnab you can allow this?? very shameful.
BEcause that surjee wala speaks like a mother fucker.. see his arguments. or rather his crap.. u will know...unless u cut him he will keep on shitting from his stinking mouth
Just watch how cool is Dr. Subramanyam swamy.
Mr. Swami was not interrupted because he was straight on facts.... not like congress spoke persons who just made allegations.
Arnab why cannot you invite the gandhis to your newshour and prove there innocence. I wish mr.swamy all the best. I want to see a true justice.
Sateesh B gandhis have no daring to speak as they are looting india
Frustration comes out of Surjewala. No one can now save the accused. Lagg gayi inki to !!
Honestly, i preferred the Aap Ki Adaalat episode with Dr Swami.... atleast he spoke about the issue there.. The highlight of this show was the Dr saying "You are Demented"
I died laughing!
Surjiwala reminding Mahesh Jetmalani to follow the speaking etiquette, but how this fellow forgot the same while speaking about Subramaniam Swami, first he should learn how to speak others. And about the case entire nation knows that how the crores of money goes into Gandhis Family account. Firstly they steal the money, and to cover the loop holes they use some of that money to these courtiers like Surjiwala. But still our people will support the Ghandis, this will not change until the mindset of the common person is educated well by leaders like Swami. No doubt Swami is doing a phenomenal job.
Must watch
Mr. Arnav, it is shocking to watch such debate conducted by you and totally ruined by this congressman without forwarding a single fact and u just watching and watching and whole hour is destroyed.
Arnab, please get control of the board to turn off mic
wow.................
arnab u conduct the debate quite good.i liked it
lol! did swamy really call surjewala a demented fool! :P :D ROFL!!
brave soul! Hats off! :)
Congress representative ..wow such a wonderful arguement..questioning Locus Standi ...three cheers to the awesome thought process. No wonder you have such great leaders unmatched to anyone in this world. btw there are law books where you could gain more knowledge on locus standi...:)
You are being sarcastic
It's 2022 yet this debate is so fresh
arnab please turn the speakers off if u want to control and conduct debate without interference.
sujyabala become wordless and started becoming humble
Don't you have a mute button at Hand for those who pester.
Please have some Decorum, while conducting debates,Mr. Arnab.
only swamy ji is behaving like a sincere student
I want to see Dr.Swamy as India’s finance minister or at least HRD, wondering why our Dear PM Modi didn’t utilize him so far. Having full faith in PM Modi to let him use in most effective way. The reason of my vote to PM Modi is Dr.Swamy & I know PM Modi will respect that. He is certainly the most intelligent & honest person in BJP…………
Continuing even after asking to listen ,is the usual trick of culprits.
Most uncivilized debate. The anchor has no control what so ever. The anchor could should be able to cut off the mike when the participant don't listen.
Swamy deserves Bharat Ratna
swaMI real heroo
sir, pl persue this in puplic interest,.y.f. s.j.patel ahmedabad.
Love it from 33:33 ...awesome
Hahahha reverse uno card
surjewala!! please don't invite him nexr time
Dear Arnab, Could you please silent idiots like surjewala who has no basic civic sense of allowing others to speak.
If this Rajit surgevalla can out shout in the debate why not he shout in a court the same way? He seem to b a a perfect doormat of the Gandhis
स्वामीजी नमस्कार,डिबेट में सभी को सुन पाना बहुत मुश्किल हो रहा था.
Arnab , if you can't control such a demented persons like surjewala then you better don't call into debate ever again otherwise people might think you are a demented person too...its really frustrating to see that lunatic surjewala noising like a broken gramophone record trying to disturb the entire debate.
Its 2022. What is the status of this case
The moderator should have the ability to mute those who have exhausted their allotted times. Filibusters, mindless rants, and ad hominem attacks should not be allowed on debates like this with limited time.
Itz amazing how swamy ji laughs!
Swamiji always smiling...
Eagerly waiting for "is swami a good or a bad man" debate
Swamy always rocks...
No body interrupted Surjewala but he is interrupting everybody
Why Rahul or Sonia is not called for this news hour discussion?
Sujraawala should not be invited in any future debates on any television channel , As neither he will answer any question properly nor he will stop his mouth when he is insulted again and again
Why doesnt Arnab's Channel provide him with a fucking mute button on panelists who talk out of turn???
We need more Swamy’s and Arnabs in the country
swami listens everyone very carefully.
No sane person can be a congress member. Sachin Pilot is an exception, and that too due to family tradition.
Hats off to subhramanyam swami.....this was really required for someone to move ahead and do this act..
This conversation is actually like i driving a bike without a helmet and when caught by the traffic police..try to get rid by making complement "WHY DONT YOU CATCH ALL THOSE OTHERS DRIVING WITHOUT HELMET" hahaha thats shit ...this concludes you are guilty...
Swamy , the Great & True Leader..
It was obvious even before the start of the 'debate', that someone who does not have a leg to stand on, will try to disrupt and talk over everyone else. This is an old tactic employed in this show. All you need to do is lower the volume of his mic so he cant talk over everyone else. Don't subject your viewers to this torture. I hardly ever watch this show now because of all this cacophony.
लिगली मूव्हमेंट बाय डाॅ.साहब ,धिस ईज हीज अंडर पर्सनल राईट.
If knowledgeable person like with guts to call a spade a spade ,to book the culprits irrespective on indiscriminately of any person
The microphone must be controlled by Mr Aranab.
Please Times Now, ban Mr Randeep Singh Surjewala forever from your shows. He is so irritating, cunning corrupt etc etc
It is the practice of Congress to train their media spokesperson to obstruct the debate with their own one way communication to rob the precious time. There are fault lines on the part of TV channel to conduct the show with the application of best possible electronic technologies. Raghu Rama Rao, Kakinada
In 2021 and this case hasn't seen its logical end yet...
we as indian its time now to be free from " Gandhi slavery".......
The Mainos have systematically plundered and exported the ancient treasures of India, especially temple sculptures of Tamil Nadu, Andhra, Orissa and Madhya Pradesh, Mughal paintings and precious gems in Indian Museums, all protected and banned from export under the Antiquities and Art Treasures Act, 1972. The CBI had in 1993 registered cases on such illegal exports from a Chennai Suburb to an identified person in Italy (see enclosed document). Alitalia and Air India flights were used to send unchecked crates after after crates misusing the SPG cover first to Italy for display in shops owned by her family e.g.Etnica in Rivolta or Ganpati in Orbassano [see enclosed photo and calling card], and after creating an ownership on paper, getting the contraband auctioned by Sotheebys and Christies, the London auctioneers. Fred Watson’s Sothebys-An Inside Story [Random House, 1998] gives some clues on such a racket.
Yogesh Saxena true bhai
poker faced Randeep Singh Surjewala... spit on him and he just smiles...
Soorji does not want the others to be heard!
Swamy is epic!oh god!!lol...
Well done Mr SWAMI, you are the great person to raise voice against GANDHI family. They have washed away the country and now if someone raise voice then congress speak persons saving congress and GANDHI. Still congress never change after big defeat in India. Next election all states election would be ruined opposition (congress).