Ukraine is Collapsing and NATO Will Fall Apart | Col. Larry Wilkerson
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 พ.ค. 2024
- Col. (ret.) Lawrence Wilkerson's last positions in government were as Secretary of State Colin Powell's Chief of Staff (2002-05), Associate Director of the State Department's Policy Planning staff under the directorship of Ambassador Richard N. Haass, and member of that staff responsible for East Asia and the Pacific, political-military and legislative affairs (2001-02).
-
Before serving at the State Department, Wilkerson served 31 years in the U.S. Army. During that time, he was a member of the faculty of the U.S. Naval War College (1987 to 1989), Special Assistant to General Powell when he was Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff (1989-93), and Director and Deputy Director of the U.S. Marine Corps War College at Quantico, Virginia (1993-97). Wilkerson retired in 1997 and began work as an advisor to General Powell. He has also taught national security affairs at the George Washington University.
I'm British and absolutely sickened that we funded az-ov N4zis in Ukraine. It's time to leave NATO like we left the EU
I think nato will fall apart exactly for the reason you say. Nato never had a problem with aligning with nazis and terrorists. Nato that is the covet military extension of usa. Never been a defence alliance its bullshit. Lies and deceit, but what on earth you expect from usa anyway? It just ceases to be credible. The whole world knows it now.
You never left the Communist EU. Havent you noticed it yet?
You can't leave because Britain is the real nato itself via America .
@@thomastumasang2770we need to take back our people's power from our corrupt elites whether they be in the UK, USA or Israel. They do not serve British people's interests.
Absolutely. Vote Reform UK.
Biden is a temporary employee. No point in discussing him. The problem is the political class.
The problem are the Employers of the political class.
The political class are mere employees.
the Devil in the White House is a Knight of Malta.
his most crucial loyalty.
he is a demented fossiel
Not the real owners, the Oligarchy?
I don't believe for a minute that Biden is anything other than a manipulated puppet and a figurehead for those who actually DO run America.
NATO needs to be disbanded
Putin's invasion of Ukraine has caused Finland and Sweden to join NATO. It's not going to be disbanded.
It’s going to implode
It will happen
You wish 🙂
If disband,russia would have easier target…😂
Impossible…
Ukraine and Israel has highlighted the true US intentions to the world. Imperialism and military states must never prevail. Excellent discussion 😊👍
So far France; Japan and Germany didn’t succeed in this lifestyle
If Imerialism and militry states must not prevail than Russia is truly doomed...
Indeed.
If imperialism and military states never prevail, this will be bad news for Russia. 🤔
The stupid Taiwanese politicians better take note .
I the late 80's a Soviet journalist was invited to the US for a visit. After some time host asked the guests what he thought of the US. He was expecting to hear praise of freedom but rather shocked when the guest said: "We didn't expect so much propaganda in the US." BUT, the host argued: "Don't you have more propaganda in the Soviet Union?"
Yes - the guest replied - but nobody believes it.
Our propaganda IS the best..!🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲 We have top tier professionals working in public partnerships(fas.cism) 🏴🏴🏴- hand in glove- in order to deliver a product in a manner that is all encompassing. 5th gen cogni.tive warfare was developed by OTAN and it's roots are N@z! +Leftist nati.onal socia.list in nature. But wait , Here is the insidious part ... Ever since Obama's 2012 NDAA and the Smith Munt Act that legalized said propaganda, it has been turned up to 11. It's a fundamental part of Total.itaria.ns playbook.
Brilliant sums the whole west up and the US is the west.
It is starting to improve in the west, buy many people still don't get it.
[redacted]
The ministry of truth would like to apologize for this commenter. The last remark was memory holed due to: Malinformation: correct information, the sharing of which is censored because it disrupts a narrative it exposes as incorrect.
Our apologies for a inconvenience/ cognitive dissonance incurred .
Regards,
Winston
Records dept
1984-2024
Our propaganda IS the best..! We have top tier professionals working in public partnerships(fas.cism) - hand in glove- in order to deliver a product in a manner that is all encompassing. 5th gen cognitive warfare was developed by OTAN and it's roots are N@z! +Leftist nati.onal socia.list in nature. But wait , Here is the insidious part ... Ever since Ob.a.ma's 2012 N.D.AA and the S.mith M.unt Act that legalized said propaganda, it has been turned up to 11. It's a fundamental part of Total.itaria.ns playbook.
You have one of the best programs. Keep up the good work. You and your guests are much appreciated.
Sure, both Nima, and colonel Wilkerson are the best, ❤❤
Ukraine will not survive
😆😆😆😆 desperate mantra
@@jacekboczarski6698You are delusional. Ukraine is already a romp state. It will get worse!
may not....
@@LesFauves-ko9pg that goes for you, too. Be careful.
@@jacekboczarski6698it breaks my heart to see how stupid Polish government is. Do you want to be the next Ukraine? USA will use you too the same way. And who will be blamed? Your government volunteered to host nukes against Russia. Are you insane? Remember, usa exploited the ignorance and hatred of ukrainians towards Russia. They yielded. Do you like what happened to ukraine? Do you want Poland to be next? I see your government is heading the same way. Do you think Poland can beat Russia? Because lets face it this is in your head, right? I can assure you USA will be happy to sell you weapons while you die on the battlefield. I can guarantee it will be a great deal for them. Will it be a great deal for Poland? Thats all usa is interested in.
When Putin is the only one who is showing Patience/restraint in this Dangerous Situation,that Speaks Volumes as to how Pathetically Incompetent our US Government has become.
Yes, you are a 100% correct . Thank you
...and what a brilliant statesman Putin is especially in contrast to the incompetence of the leadership of the entire collective West.
Well said.Iam from Greece and the usa fallen rapidly in peoples mind.Most of them they dont want to hear even the name usa or nato.Are equal to criminal gang!!!
Playing the long game, Ukraine, then Europe, then Korean then Taiwan. What is it the protesters often shout “The west is a woman to be ridden”
@@meloneypullen8746 Yes!!
💯💯 % correct!!
It's not just N Korea that that's not interested in US any more. It's more than half the world just moving on & leaving US Europe in the past
Yep and they are not coming back if Biden does not get reelected. There is no fixing this. We are gonna be the lepers of the world and side into worse than third world status
Ironically that probably has to happen for populations now captive under western governments to be free. Hegemoney is a curse.
4/5 of world don't trust anything coming from US and few their slaves( West).US is 5 percentage of world population.China,India,Russia,global south
Greetings from Australia 🇦🇺 Nima, I found this podcast between you and Col. Wilkerson a very good one. 👍
An Apt comment from another :
On December 8, 1967, Senator J. William Fulbright gave a speech on the floor of the Senate. The subject was the Vietnam War.
The prior month, on November 17, LBJ held a press conference in which he said, amongst other things, the following regarding the governments attitude towards dissent IRT the war in SE Asia:
"We don't stop the publication of any papers. We don't fine anyone for something they say....."
Fulbright in his Senate remarks responded with the following:
"I should like to make it clear that I am not the slightest bit grateful to the administration for my freedom of speech. That freedom is an inalienable right which the American people reserved to themselves when they established a constitutional government. It is not the people's freedom which is a gift from their Government, but the Government's authority which is a gift from the people, a retractable trust to be discharged at their pleasure. When the Government abstains from suppressing dissent, it is doing nothing more than complying with one of the explicit conditions of its constitutional trust. That is not a thing for which gratitude is owed."
It is inconceivable that ANY member of the Congress would be capable of saying anything even remotely like this today!
No need for free speech when we have got CIA propaganda apparatus. The majority do not understand what " free " means anymore.
I appreciate your reposting my work from Caitlin Johnstone's substack. We will never again see someone with Fulbright's intellectual gifts representing the people in Congress.
@edlindgren4114
Thank you very much for illuminating us with that crucial work. The opposite of Fulbright scholars are running amok in the Halls of Power ; if I may, the "Emptydim" blockheads.
God help us all.
Wonderful comment. Thanks a bunch. Do most Americans yet understand that they do not have a constitution anymore because it is ignored by the government?
@@edlindgren4114people of character like Fulbright, are needed now in these crisis and end of democracy in the West
Nima you should run for President in Brazil I see you growing as a visionary leader month on month, you are an amazing person.
Doesn’t one has to be born in Brazil to run for president?
Why would it want such a job?
@@terrylovesenegal why not?
Larry,people like you are keeping me in trust that there is some clear and sane mind in US
Thank you for bringing Mr Larry to us!
We appreciate all of your hard work Nima🙏🏻
When has he targeted Hamas, he tells the civilians to go to one place and then bombed them there, why would this be any different?
Welcome to genocidal world of Pissreal and its murderer in chief/Benzion Mileikowsky .
Because people want to live, they take a chance since there’s no choice. Sisi could help but he’s,,,a wimp.
@@HerrDirleWanger1 If they leave they will never get their lands back.
@KhairulFadzlyAKarim Because they want to kill them anyway.
Nato falling apart...... Happy face
From NATO to NAPO. North Atlantic Pirates Organization..
It's still NATO by all account; North Atlantic Terrorist Organization.
LOL, I’m in stitches ❤
naFo.
Fucking pirates indeed....I was shocked they never went away. But Shit from China arrives postage free. I just can't send anything to Florida, it might cost me an eye.
Mr. Wilkerson, Syria has called on Russia to bring in troops. Syria is occupied illegally by the USA. That's a huge difference as far as what you said about the relationship between the two armies in Syria.
Finally some common sense talk
"common sense talk". Im not so sure. Especially when this guest keeps mentioning "climate change". He loses credibility.
Can we all do something for the ordinary people's interest - to live their lives to the ripe old age, seeing the birth of their great-great grandchildren?
Probably a good idea if you put that question directly to Benzion Mileikowsky of Pissreal ?
Great analysis gents.
Thank you Nima.
Respect Col. 👍
The Colonel and I are of the same generation. He and I both, I believe, have a very crystal clear view of the dire consequences of a failure to step back from the brink.
My young adult kids don’t have a clue about these dangers. I don’t know what to tell them.
USA lost Vietnam war 10 years and 20 years in Afghanistan lost
et n'ont jamais payé pour leurs dégâts. Il faut détruire .....
They don't fight wars to win.
"The goal is NOT to win these wars. The goal is to use the wars to wash money out of the tax bases of the United States and out of the tax bases of European countries and back into the hands of a transnational security elite. That is the goal. To have ENDLESS wars, NOT SUCCESSFUL wars."
~ Julian Assange - Stop the War
Interview - 8 October 2011
Two things, it doesn’t really matter since none of them have put one foot in the US and the second is nth Vietnam ended up,paying for the war.
And MILLIONS KIA.. mostly civilians. It's absolutely shameful. 😪
@@stepheneurosailor1623Interesting perspective, it explains all the printing. Poor Julian, it explains what's happening to him too.
One of his best interviews.
I don't always agree with Wilkerson but he always talks about the most important issues in an intelligent way
Macron is no Charles De Gaulle!
The American conscious moving toward isolationism…
Dragging Europe with them.
Towards non-interventionism, not isolation.
Russian president has the highest level of support from his people.
Israeli people want Israel's government's resignation. What is Netanyahu doing wrong?
simple: he doesn't care about grooming Israel's reputation the way his predecessors did, or rather, he cares more about staying out of jail
Israel’s people don’t want their governments resignation. You have false information
The US leadership has no diplomatic compass, absolutely no cultural sensitivity and are considered rather stupid globally (from what I read) Thank you, Nima, and Colonel Wilkerson for an excellent and edifying discussion
Nima, thank you for your great work, truly professional and great guests.
And you even have the actual date on the screen, amazing !
the book 1984, will never happen, God has already chosen a side ,its not the West
1984 is already here, and apparently Russia is the only surviving refuge from it.
I blame the Globalist goblins.. every country should put its citizens first and make no permanent alliance with another blindly. Nationalism has been demonized by the globalist camp and that paradigm need to be flipped. The end goal of world or now regiona/factional l Total.itar.ian govt rule is the 1984 scenario we are fighting against in the west from within
@@genestone4951 its about the collective "waste", 1984 has nothing to do with the rest of the world
I think the Colonel underestimates the insanity of Netanyahu.
Maybe he doesn't want to be called anti.....
The good Colonel Wilkerson scares me to death... because everything he says is spot on target. I don't know how humanity is going to survive the next 30 years without a nuclear war- and if one happens, I don't know how we'll survive it at all.
This is the worst stage. Later, the West will accept that it can no longer push everyone around.
30 years? If only. Try 30 weeks.
Morning Nima one of my favorite guests
Presumably you didn't hear his utter racism towards China.
@@earthlingthings Like what ?
Somebody is realizing their country isn’t as important as they thought they were. No bully lasts for ever, eventually the bully grows up or moves away. I hope we’ll grow up.
Thank you for letting these people come to your channel. They bring years of experience and knowledge with them and shed some light on this very difficult situation that my country has gotten itself into.
A sensible and well thought out analysis on all things geo politics,by Larry Wilkerson. Well done to Nima for having this gentleman on your show.👏👏👍👍
From what I've read, China accomplished its limited political goals against the Vietnamese, and withdrew once they did so. Yes, the war only lasted a month, and Vietnam gave them a bloody nose... but... the CHinese war against India only lasted a month as well, and China is clearly seen as the victor of that war: China accomplished its limited political goals in Inida and then promptly withdrew.
The lesson I take from this is not that the Vietnamese kicked China's butt, but that China does not initiate long protracted wars. Instead, China initiates short wars with achievable objectives, achieves those objectives, and then withdraws.
P.S. The American perspective on the war may be shaped by wounded pride. How many Americans would like to believe that China fought a small-but-successful war against Vietnam after Vietnam kicked the US' asses?
Yes, Ch1na did. Although it was a pyrric victory for Ch1na, they still indeed won, and it was a limited incursion anyhow, anyways. They sent in ONLY 4 Group Armies, out of their massive armed forces (and ZERO airpower committed, for most part).
It's not true that the Vietnamese had beaten the Chinese when the Chinese crossed the Vietnamese border to punish them for the Cambodian invasion. The Vietnamese attacked the Chinese when they withdrew their artilleries and forces back to China and that's venerable time when you are moving back. Get that right.
True. Also, Ch1na committed nowhere NEAR the forces they easily could have, to that. It was merely a limited incursion, and also with next to no airpower used, either, by Ch1na
Confused about your comment: "venerable time" or "vulnerable time"?
The story I heard at the time was that the Vietnamese were feeling frisky and did some border incursions. The Chinese swatted them to show them how to be polite. Don't know what is true.
Thanks Nima & Mr Wilkerson
Once again, Larry's analysis is brilliant. Nima, thank you for such well-constructed dialogues that are uniquely interesting and informative.
THIS GUY
IS
PROVIDING
THE
CLEARIST
INSIGHTS
ON
CURRENT
AMERICAN
FOREIGN
POLICY
THAT I
HAVE
HEARD IN A
LONG TIME.
I
A
G
R
E
E
*Col. Larry Wilkerson is truly a wise, educated, and proven experienced man. Your views and opinions are highly appreciated! Thank you, sir!* 🇺🇸🫡
Another great interview from Larry
Very informative giving unbiased point view
They have as of about 10 minutes ago starting a Color Revolution in Georgia
A new front against Russia?
This is how the US government work.
One would think Russia will squash this quickly.
It is young people in Georgia starting "the revolution". They just prefer to live in Western country than Russian mir. The old have a different perspective, they long for soviet times.
They will fail, but will be trying again and again.
Have you seen the West. Ursula Von Der Leyen, Borrel, Stoltenberg, Macron, Scholz.
Who wants to be ruled by these people? Who wants turn away from their traditional family values society to live in their crazy LGBTQ, woke vision of a world.
As long as US NGO's (NED, USAID) are given free reign in any country, guaranteed, there will be dissent and 'color revolutions' brewing.
Greetings from Australia
Thank you Gentlemen.❤
Thank you Gentlemen. Thoroughly enjoyed the show. Cheers.
yet another excellent dialog. Thanks again.
What's funny is you have to know this beings in power are insane beings ,
How could you not know that
Can't believe I've missed this channel, now signed up. Col Wilkerson was class. People like Wilkerson and Douglas MacGregor should have a big say in government policy, instead, they are silenced.
5 Eyes falling...
Thank you professor Alkhorshid and Col Wilkerson #best channel
Thank you for this comprehensive and thoughtful analysis and prognosis. With gratitude.
Excellent discussion...thank you.
Nima and Col. Wilkerson 👍
From Germany ❤
I agree💯
Thanks for such a great interview...always great people. And you always make good questions and know how to listen. Complicated times...
God protect us.
Nima asks excellent questions. A civil engineer presently demonstrating that Dialogue Works. Bravo good human! And Larry Wilkerson is amazing...
It's not a mistake it's all deliberate
People on the left bank of the Dnieper River have always sided with Russia, whereas those on the right bank side with the West, so the Dnieper River would be a natural border between two potential Ukrainian states.
Good to see you Wilkerson!
The debate isn't happening in Washington now. It happened in Davos 20 years ago, and soon after, GWBush announced Ukraine would join NATO.
Amazing🤓
You didn’t believe it would be this dangerous voting for such social lightweights
Voting?
Voting theater 🎭 🎭 🎭 bread and circus @@brutallyremastered4255
If you are talking about voting for Biden, I was telling people the entire time he was campaigning that he’s the poster boy for our failure of foreign policies for decades. He was going to be just a continuation of Obama and Bush. I never even thought he would be this much of a war monger or anywhere near as bad in foreign policy as he had been. I did not think Biden would be as completely incompetent as he is.
Heavy censorship on this channel. I've said the same thing elsewhere and it stayed up.🧐🤔
Kafkaesque Trial here .. YT gives you a notification for a thread u commented on but your comment has been deleted
You are doing God’s work Nima. Many of us appreciate it greatly. Please keep it up!! 🙏
Thanks for this great program. The Col. is an excellent guest with wide ranging knowledge relevant to today's clashes.
When I learned what we did & have been doing to Iran for refusing to accept Israel I now understand how important it is we stop spending 1.5T on the empire abroad that does nothing for US the investors & only makes us the poorest rich country w no real legitimacy only brute force
Prof Marandi is the one to interview on this matter
Thank u to Larry & ur channel as always
You look wonderful at 80 Col. Wilkerson and you make so much sense. Thank you Nima as usual for being an amazing intelligent host.
The icecream lover will go to nursing home in the end of this year. He will leave the mess for any one inheriteds after him
Or Biden wins re-election and we get to add war with China to his failures
Larry Wilkinson is one of the best
True!
col. Larry, I salute you.
🇳🇿⚖️🇵🇱as a western trained lawyer, I say the "rules based order" is a blatant legal joke and a misnomer or hypocorism (adult baby talk). There is NO substitute to the International Law.😂
I think after what’s happening in Gaza is going to create another global organization similar to the UN but with actual teeth, enforcement capacity and the western powers will not be part of it. This will probably take a 2-3 decades to make it happen though.
Great analysis from the Colonel.
Thank you, gentlemen! 🙏🏻💪🙏🏻
How can we expect national defense without a nation? Lloyd Austin and CQ Brown are in it for themselves. Everyone in DC is a self serving individual.
Superb content...
Great interview .interesting points about China. I wish more americans could hear
"What do you get for pretending the danger's not real?"
Fantastic discussion hosted by my Dear Nima and stunning analyses by Colonel Larry. Thank you so much ❤😍🙏🏾
No NATO No WAR !!
Great stream Thankyou 👍
I would find it hilariously funny if China and Russia would both announce that they are going to support both Hamas and Hezbollah against Israel in the exact same way the US and EU are supporting Ukraine. See how Israel responds to that.
Are Russian generals going to teach a course at West Point
Not that trusting. Nor should they be.
You called someone a dirty name and you asked them for help…good luck with that! You started the mess and you deal with it!
Thank you Larry and Nima 💖
The UK does not have a written constitution.
when challenged, apologists say there are instead a series of treaties and documents which function as a de facto constitution, apparently oblivious to the idea that any sitting parliament in Westminster can repeal, replace, adjust or override any one of those documents in a single term, which has in fact happened several times
@@BrennanYoung Oh yes.
The EU don't have a constitution, written or otherwise. Not even a passport. But hey ! They got a printing press and a Central Bank.
Samuel F. B. Morse knew why the US hierarchy does serve the wims of Georgetown University.
Larry's king
excellent interview thanks ❤
North Vietnam army was hard core during Vietnam war
Thank You for your sensibility and expertise. God Bless your input
"I know how they cheat... ¡Hell! I helped them cheat!" Larry is incredible!
Thank you. Best wishes.
Let's get a real Diplomat from China up in there. Apparently, America does not have any.
You may discuss ice cream flavors only with Joe Biden the old clown 😂😂😂😂his the best joke president 😂
Thank you gentlemen for this brilliant analysis.
Thanks for sharing and surfacing the truth. 👏👍
The title gives great hope❤
Rutte has a super talent to desintegrate anything he is close too. Should he be near…it will collapse even faster than the other clowns will..CHRISTUS VINCIT
RUTTE 😆😆😆
He wants to be either the EU, or NATO leader. He should take both 😀