Viral ang sagutan ni Sen. Nancy Binay at Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano. Pero higit sa away pulitika, silipin natin ang tunay na isyu sa bagong Senate building.
23B or 21B is still a very expensive Senate building for a country whose people are starving to death. And the would be occupants are the likes of these several Philippine Senators. WTF! 😤😤😤
It is about the Institution, not about the occupants. Nakakahiya naman talaga ang hitsura ng mga government buildings natin. Maski sa Batasan, napaka dungis ng paligid at hindi mukhang government center.
Yes i think masyadong mahal nga pero as explained mahal din kasi renta nila per year kaya ang solution is to have a permanent asset instead of renting.
Arguing about billions in taxpayer's money? How's that building even a priority to begin with sa dami ng dapat pagdalhan ng pondong ginamit dyan. Vanity over many more important infrastructure projects and even housing and food for the masses. 😠
Transparency must be the name of the game. Eh kasi me mga anong expenses kaya ang tinatago nila. Matatalino din kaming nakikinig. Simple lang po. Me budget proposal, me approved budget, POW, etc. tapos me COA to audit. Anong problema? Heistttt...umayos po tayo! Pilipinas kong mahal! Kahit saan na lang me kurapsyon???Tapos me bangayan at walking out pa! Gising na po tayo! Huwag niyong masyadong pagandahin Senate Bldg. niyo! Marami pang bagay mas mahahalaga at need gastusan like health, education, etc...Kaawaan niyo kaming mahihirap.😭😭😭
Really appreciate how Christian tries to stir the conversation about how costly the new Senate building is, but walang masagot na matino si Nancy, aside sa they are spending 400M a year. Was looking forward sana na she can justify the billions but wala. Oh well, "the government you elect is the government you deserve."
Not to mention when she was asked magkano yung budget, kc pagmagpapagawa ka ng bahay you dictate kung how much gusto mo, and she said it's evolving. Ha?
To quote a saying… “Ang bahay mo mn ay bato… kung ang nkatira ấy kwago… , mabuti n ang kubo… n ang nakatira ay tao” Apart from Sen Risa…. All of them were kwagos……!
Disappointed that Nancy kept on deflecting from answering and instead kept on giving political color to the real issue at hand. Walang kalinawan ano ba talaga ang 21B o 23B. Bleeding 400M? From one govt pocket to another.
@21:15 I watched the interview and again, truly brokenhearted and devastated to hear na hindi raw prestigious yung senate hall compared sa iba sabi ni Senator Nancy. Hearing this while knowing na napakaraming pasyente sa public hospitals na nakawheelchair ng ilang araw dahil sa lack of hospital beds, at ilang weeks ngaantay ng schedule for ct scan or mri dhl sa lack of facilities. 23B for a building. There is no way to explain how reasonable that is if you look at the state of health facilities in the country.
It's actually a complex trade-off. But developing strong, effective government institutions is important for a well-functioning society. Robust institutions like the Senate help ensure the rule of law, protect individual rights, and enable the efficient delivery of public services. DepEd still holds the biggest allocated budget in 2023.
Petra Bvngangera also treated ex-Senator JJa-ja-ja-jamby Madrigal in the same manner. He was very ungentlemanly and unstatemanly. I don't like Nancy much either since her family is also tainted with corruption apart from being part of a political dynasty, too. But I can't say whom to hate more esp. upon witnessing the nonchalant Robin who did nothing but happily eat in the midst of his colleagues' verbal tussle.
AKALA MO MALILINIS KUNG MAKA PAG DEFENSA ITONG SI NANCY BINAY. LANTAD NA SA MGA PILIPINO LALO NA SA MGA TAGA MAKATI ANG TALAMAK NA CORRUPTION NG MGA BINAY NA YAN. THE SAD PART IS, PATULOY BINOBOTO NG MGA TAO. MA ABUTAN LANG NG T SHIRT, BARYA, LATA NG SARDINAS AT 1kilo ng bigas, BINENTA NA NG MGA MANGMANG ANG BOTO NILA.
Ang tanong, bkit sa BGC pa??! Why not Antipolo or QC where land prices are way cheaper? At present, they are paying rent to the GSIS. So sa gobyerno rin nman napupunta yng pera. Dapat pna renovate nlng nila.
Malaki talaga ang budget ng magarbong senate building kahit yong tiles lang na ginamit malulula tayo sa presyo ..:habang ang pcg at navy ship ay binubully ng monsters ship ng pirates sa WPS , dahil sobrang liliit at kokonte ang ating mga barko😊😅yong gsis ay pag-aari rin gobyerno ibig sabihin kita rin ng gobyerno..dapat sa batasan nlang gumawa ng senate building dahil ang lupa roon ay pag-aari ng gobyerno 😊common sense 😂 malabong magexplain ni Sen nancy, yan ang senador ng Pilipinas , kawawang Inang Bayan…
Hindi na siguro need magtayo ng senate building ng ganyan kamahal, given that the attitude of some senator are parang nasa palengke lng kung mangatwiran laging may nagmumura. May kumakain at nguya ng nguya sa loob habang yong 2 senator nagbabangayan
WALA NMANG NAKAKAHIYA DON AH , SABI NGA EH KUNG SINO ANG IBINOTO MO YON ANG GUSTO MO AT HANDA KA NA TANGGAPIN KUNG ANO ANG LAMAN O RESULTA NG IUUPO MO , KAYA DESERVE NG PILIPINAS KUNG SINO ANG NAKAPWEST DAHIL SILA ANG IBINOTO , SO KUNG ANO SILA WALANG NAKAKAHIYA ALAM NMAN NATIN NA MGA SURNAME LANG NILA ANG DALA DALA NILA HINDI ANG SARILI NILANG KAKAYAHAN
Gone are the days na kagalang galang, matatalino at may pakinabang ang ating mga senators. All because of Filipinos na di marunong pumili ng mga tamang lider.
NONAMECM5926, THE PEOPLE OF MAKATI, CANNOT FIND ANYONE TO REPRESENT THEM EXCEPT THE BINAYS. TATAY, NANAY AND 3 KIDS!!! NAGPAPATAYAN NA SILA SA POSITION. SO DAHIL GUSTONG MAG SILBE, YOU BINAYS ARE FIGHTING OVER A POSITION, WHY??? GANYAN BA TALAGA KALAHI ANG PERANG MAKUKURAKOT SA MAKATI?? THIS IS THE LEGACY OF THE BINAYS?? TAPOS MGA ANAK NAMAN NINYO SIGURADO ANG SUSUNOD. KUNG MERONG KABETCHING, KABETCHING DIN. WALA NA TALAGANG PAG ASA ANG BAYAN NA ITO!!!!
Si robinhood walang isyu ng kurapsyon, pero yang binay dami ng isyu yan, ultimo kapatid inaaway. Pero yan parin kinampihan nyo, mga tanga ba kayo??? Tanong lang po baka gurgurin nyo ako😂😂😂
A public servant must be respectful and a good role model. Ekis sa mga palamura, bastos sumagot at lalo na sa mga kurakot mahilig sa confidential funds, etc.
Pinaglalaruan lang naman ng mga ito yung pera natin. Why would someone like Robinhood or bato or even these two political dynasties deserves a very expensive building while many Filipino children go to school hungry? Filipinos deserves better.
MISMO! ANG KAILANGAN NG MGA FILIPINOS AY EFFICIENT GOVERNANCE NA MAY IMPACT SA BUHAY NILA.... HINDI KAILANGAN NG BONGGANG BILYONES NA BUILDING NG MGA SENADO KUNG WALA NAMAN NAPAPALA ANG MALILIIT NA MAMAMAYAN SA MGA BATAS NA GINA GAWA NYO JAN SA SENATE AT HINDI NYO NAMAN MA I-SAKA-TUPARAN OR MA "EXECUTE" YUNG BATAS NA MGA GINAGAWA NYO! ILANG BATAS NA BA GINAWA NYO, ANO, MAY NABAGO BA SA BUHAY NG MGA PILIPINO???? MAY NA IMPROVE BA SA ESTADO NG MGA MAMAMAYAN JAN????? UMAYOS BA ANG ARAW ARAW NILANG PAMUMUHAY? GUMANDA BA ANG TRANSPORATSYON? SAHOD NG MGA TAO? DUMAMI BA TRABAHO? KUMONTI NA BA ANG BRAIN DRAIN? NAG IMPROVE BA ANG TALINO NG KABATAAN? O KULELAT PA RIN BA MGA YOUTH NATIN WHEN IT COMES TO LITERACY? DUMAMI BA ANG PABAHAY? O MARAMI PA RIN SQUATTERS? BILYONES PARA SA BUILDINGS? ALAM BA NG GOBYERNO ANG PRIORITIES NA DAPAT GAWIN PARA SA BANSA?
To Sen. Cayetano and Sen. Binay pera naming taumbayan ang pinagaawayan ninyo. There are plenty of reasons why renting is better no. 1 would be the source of money is coming from the national budget and it will go back to the govt via GSIS so nothing is loss. Senate capital outlay for that building that will become useless and depreciate within 20 years and who knows we will become a unicameral by that time. Think about the maintenance cost of that establishment. Sayang lang sana naging business area na lang ito then we get taxes and put more jobs.
Mistake No. 1 by the Senate, binigay sa DPWH ang pag manage ng project ng new senate building. Mistake No. 2, the Senate should have hired in the first place a chief architect who is in charge of the whole plan and who will act in behalf of the senators. Mistake No. 3, this should have been within the parameters of a fixed budget isama na nila ang projected 3 year inflation cost.
It's DPWH kasi that prepares the request for the budget based on cost of building it. 8B was only an estimate, just like when you construct a house may nadagdag na gastos at sa tagal ng construction that spans years, ang cost nyan mag iincrease din. Bastos lang talaga magtanong ung maingay na aso ni Duterte.
Pero dapat bilang client merong owners engineer ang senado, may management team kayo dapat na nagrereview para sa inyo. Para hindi kayo ganyan na nagaakusahan. Simpleng solusyon lang sana kaso napupulitika.
Yung mukha ni Christian habang nagbabato ng numero si Binay, priceless. Nakikita ko thought bubble nya... "Ano ulit yun? Paano naging 23B? Teka, diba marunong akong mag add? Bakit di ko ma-gets... nabubudol ata ako. Tulong???".
ang prestige ng senate ang nagdadala ay mga katangi tanging senador. kung ganito ba naman ang kalidad ng senador na hindi maipaliwanag ng sapat ang budget para sa pagtayo ng gusali, kahit ano pa ang ganda ng gusali nawawala ang saysay dahil sa mababang uri ng senador na binoboto ng taong bayan
Kailangan bang pagandahin iyan kung mga hindi honorables ang senador. May corrupt, pan sarili lang ang tinitignan at pinaglalaban, may mga away na parang hindi mga professional..self-serving....etc. scandalous mga ibang senador. Siguro basta may sarili nalang building ang senate at presentable hindi na ganyan sobrang mahal. Gamitin nalang nila ang pera ng taong bayan para sa pangangailangan ng taong bayan lalo na mahihirap.
Ano ba kayo mga senators sana pagunlad ang gawin ninyo hindi awayan kayo ng ayawan grabe nagaagawan kayo sa power at pera more pera pare pareho kayo pera pera pera yaman yaman
I think Christian's question as to the total cost to construct the senate building was dodged by Nancy Binay. At the very onset, the proposal should have an indicative amount, for purposes of budget approval, including or excluding the lot. To say that the project concept is design and build does not explain it. The review panel should check documentation evidencing approval. This document, unless approved without due scrutiny, should disclose the amount in question. In parting, these two "honorable" senators acted dishonorably during said hearing. Bad example for the youth.
Dapat isapubliko ang lahat ng gastos pr tapos,malinawan ang lhat ,madali lng yn ,d sabihin nyo ung gastos s lupa at gastos s building wag ng pgtalunan sagutin n kasi kung mgkano nga lhat, understood nmn n medyo nadagdagan kasi n stop ung construction dahil s pandemic ,tumaas ang material cost ,,,,,wl ng talo talo sagutin n lng kung mgkano, daming paligoyligoy n binay ,sagutin mo n kasi ,......ang enterview n to ay masakit sa ulo,d nasagot ng tama s tanong , palikoliko,paikot ikot hay naku binay kung lumaki ang gastos e di lumaki kung un b talaga ang nagastos ,ang masama kung pinagkakitaan kawawa nmn ang tax payers laki ng kaltas pero walang magandang bahay, hirap kasi sa pilipinas ang mambabatas s pilipinas ay lahat negosyante
Wala akong naintindihan sa mga paliwanag kung bakit sila nag away. Tayo pa rin kawawa, gumasto nang sobra sobra. Hats off ako kay christian na binuklat sa kahiya hiya sa kanilang demeanor. Wala nang character nawala pa ang intellect.
Christian lagi kita pinapanood pero eto kay binay halata na may malaking priblema diyan sa budget bakit sobrang napakamahal naoanood kuying live hearing takaga di masagot ni binay yong mga number na sila naman gumawa katulad ng land scaping need nila mag paliwanag kasi pera ito jg mga tao lalo n mga nag babayad jg tax
I hope this grandiose expense will not push through. If these senators are really for the country , they should spend it to school buildings and hospitals especially in the low lying areas in the provinces.
Gusto talaga magpa pansin ni Petrang Cayatano. Klaro naman dun sa sagutan nila sa hearing na ayaw makinig ng sinasabi ni Binay na hindi dapat kasali yung cost ng lupa
Wag nyo nlng ituloy yang Senate building e kung ganyan lang din nmn sila mag uusap e anong point ng magandang building. Unahin muna yung quality ng mga Senator. Naninita si Cayetano e building ng Senate yun e diba Senator din siya pag ba chairman siya lang lht? So ibig sabhin kung hindi naging Chairman si Cayetano hindi siya maninita? e from Lacson pa pala yan though estimate lang nmn and sana nga ma delay pa or wag ng ituloy.
Bakit hindi masagot kung bakit lumob ang presyo? Ayoko rin kay Kayatano, pero bakit kasi ang laki ng budget for that building? Grabe naman yang 21B for a building for crooks! Kung nagmahal dahil sa location, bakit hindi nila tinayo sa cheap na lugar. Makakapagdala pa sila ng economic activity.
Kung by phases ang budgeting, so walang contracted project cost as a whole. Dahil by phases yan, ibig sabihin nakabase sa yearly GAA. At yearly ay nagbabago ang material cost. Kaya lomolobo yan.
they should stick to the plan of the total cost. Ang nangyare naiba na ng naiba. Dapat ang pagtitipid ay inuumpusahan ng gobyerno to think na naghihirap ang bansa at walang pondo ang gibyerno
Sana mabasa nila itong mga comments. Nakakahiya itong mga senators na ito. Naturingan pa naman kayong mga taga gawa ng batas at mga kagalang galang na tao. Dapat pa ba kayong irespetong tao. Pare pareho naman ang majority ng senado kung may matino suguro iilan lang. Yong iba tangap ng sweldo, incentives at pakain kain lang at pakuya kuyakoy. Guest mo pala si sen Binay. Ang problema nagpadala siya sa ugali na hindi na ni respeto ang senado. Mahilig magparinig at manghiya. Sana if they have something, should discuss behind camera puede naman sa office nila. O baka naman intentionally na gusto niyang ipahiya si Sen Binay.
thank you mr. esguerra for asking the right questions and trying to get your guest to answer them fully and honestly. i'm neither happy nor satisfied with sen. binay's answers but it's not the host's fault. he can only go so far to squeeze a proper answer out of her. the way sen. binay responded to the questions goes to show how she's either so out of touch, frivolous and shallow or she's not being forthcoming (or both!). i agree that the current senate building is run-down and an embarassment (just like many government buildings), but the cost is too high that one may reasonably suspect a significant amount of padding in the price tag. most importantly, her 'design and build' reason as to why the cost keeps climbing is utter bull$%&t, among other fallacies and gaslights mentioned (ie not inputting the cost of the building when constructing it, etc). ibig sabihin lang ng 'design and build' is that instead of having a separate architect and engineer to design and build a structure, iisang tao or entity lang ang gagawa. it's supposed to be a more cost-efficient way to build kasi pwede i-package yung cost but there are a lot of horror stories about it because there's no checks and balance, and at worst, the person or entity hired to do the project runs away with the money. so the design and build concept has NOTHING to do with the cost climbing. tama si mr. esguerra, if there's an established budget from the get-go that is usually quoted by the architect and engineer based on their experience and expertise, dapat yun na yun. usually may konting padding na dapat yung quotation for contingencies (like 3-5% on top of the contract price) pero kung maayos na architect and engineer ang katrabaho mo, dapat na-foresee na nila ang mga pwedeng mangyari and they won't come crawling back to you asking for more money. labas sa ilong mga sagot ni sen. binay. don't believe it. and don't get me started on sen. cayetano 🤬
Diba siya ung chairman ng committee on ethics nung time na puro grandstand at mura mga senador jan, Tulfo, Padilla, Estrada, Bato, Bong go Tahimik lang sya haha
![ความรักไม่ได้น่ากลัวขนาดนั้น (TRUST ME) - LYKN [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9np-lAtCRpQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![ตีสิบเดย์ [FULL] | ครอบครัวสะท้านทุ่ง "นางบี & อ้ายสติ๊ก"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A1rhYcxxNtA/mqdefault.jpg)
23B or 21B is still a very expensive Senate building for a country whose people are starving to death. And the would be occupants are the likes of these several Philippine Senators. WTF! 😤😤😤
Peter Cayetano is an embarrassment in the Senate. Sanctity in the senate is gone!
Very Trapo a disgrace to his Father's Surname...
Masyado na kayong halata🤑🤑 naghihirap naba kayo at payag kayong maging trolls😅
Opo
he is! i used to adore him pero sya ang trapo at palengkero
WE LIKE CAYETANO.. pag debate or arguments lang naman dahil may EVIDENCES yan parati... magaling na lawyer.
Do the Filipinos want a grandious senate hall where most of the Filipinos are suffering? Sana hospital at school na lang ang pinagkagastusan.
It is about the Institution, not about the occupants. Nakakahiya naman talaga ang hitsura ng mga government buildings natin. Maski sa Batasan, napaka dungis ng paligid at hindi mukhang government center.
Yes i think masyadong mahal nga pero as explained mahal din kasi renta nila per year kaya ang solution is to have a permanent asset instead of renting.
@@yanayoriginals8498lol😂
Yong renta ng Senate sa GSIS kita pa rin ng gobyerno pupunta sa government coffers
Okay lang magbuild Ng Sariling building, Kase pride pa din yan ng bansa. Sana lang di overpriced.
Please vote yung mga May prinsipyo, pinagaralan, disente, masipag at di tamad next election. Big No to nepotism At tamad!!
Mabait kuno para iboto siya. Pag nanalo.. nakaw at inuuna ang pagyaman. WE WILL VOTE FOR NEW NAMES.
si cayetano maraming nasasabi pero oagdating sa ginagawa ng Tsina at role nya sa gentlemens agreement nung sya ay DFA sec ay “no comment”!
Friends with Duterte. Lam mo na. Never kong ibobot yan mga Cayetano. Kahit yung kapatid.
Dynasty vs dynasty for power and money.
sana totoong gising na tayong lahat ng mga filipino... sa mga kayabangan ng ating mga pulitiko... ty
. Si Robinhood wala naman yatang maiintindihan kaya ayun , kain lang ng kain.
Di nahihiya si Robin, Diyos ko kakahiya pag WALA kng alam😢
Baka magsuklay pa yan ng bigote nya
Physically in but mentally out. Nakikain lang KC walang naintindhan o walang pakialam sa usapan .. 😆
Kung baga sa pelikula Props lang si Padilla Sili King😂!
Nagsusuklay nman ng bigote......
Arguing about billions in taxpayer's money? How's that building even a priority to begin with sa dami ng dapat pagdalhan ng pondong ginamit dyan. Vanity over many more important infrastructure projects and even housing and food for the masses. 😠
Transparency must be the name of the game. Eh kasi me mga anong expenses kaya ang tinatago nila. Matatalino din kaming nakikinig. Simple lang po. Me budget proposal, me approved budget, POW, etc. tapos me COA to audit. Anong problema? Heistttt...umayos po tayo! Pilipinas kong mahal! Kahit saan na lang me kurapsyon???Tapos me bangayan at walking out pa! Gising na po tayo! Huwag niyong masyadong pagandahin Senate Bldg. niyo! Marami pang bagay mas mahahalaga at need gastusan like health, education, etc...Kaawaan niyo kaming mahihirap.😭😭😭
Really appreciate how Christian tries to stir the conversation about how costly the new Senate building is, but walang masagot na matino si Nancy, aside sa they are spending 400M a year. Was looking forward sana na she can justify the billions but wala. Oh well, "the government you elect is the government you deserve."
Wala siyang alam. Ako naintindihan ko explanation ni Cayetano.
Not to mention when she was asked magkano yung budget, kc pagmagpapagawa ka ng bahay you dictate kung how much gusto mo, and she said it's evolving. Ha?
To quote a saying…
“Ang bahay mo mn ay bato… kung ang nkatira ấy kwago… , mabuti n ang kubo… n ang nakatira ay tao”
Apart from Sen Risa…. All of them were kwagos……!
Ang kaso, May marangal nga na senate house, e ang mga namamahay kumusta naman? Marangal ba?
Disappointed that Nancy kept on deflecting from answering and instead kept on giving political color to the real issue at hand. Walang kalinawan ano ba talaga ang 21B o 23B. Bleeding 400M? From one govt pocket to another.
That is true. Bka na delay sa la mesa niya ang pag review dahil hindi niya alam paano.
Ano namang inexpect mo kay Nancy na best in fence sitting.
Dapat siguro invite niyo rin sir si former Sen. Ping Lacson to give the Filipino people some background on the issue of Senate bldg budget.
@21:15 I watched the interview and again, truly brokenhearted and devastated to hear na hindi raw prestigious yung senate hall compared sa iba sabi ni Senator Nancy. Hearing this while knowing na napakaraming pasyente sa public hospitals na nakawheelchair ng ilang araw dahil sa lack of hospital beds, at ilang weeks ngaantay ng schedule for ct scan or mri dhl sa lack of facilities. 23B for a building. There is no way to explain how reasonable that is if you look at the state of health facilities in the country.
It's actually a complex trade-off. But developing strong, effective government institutions is important for a well-functioning society. Robust institutions like the Senate help ensure the rule of law, protect individual rights, and enable the efficient delivery of public services. DepEd still holds the biggest allocated budget in 2023.
Petra Bvngangera also treated ex-Senator JJa-ja-ja-jamby Madrigal in the same manner. He was very ungentlemanly and unstatemanly. I don't like Nancy much either since her family is also tainted with corruption apart from being part of a political dynasty, too. But I can't say whom to hate more esp. upon witnessing the nonchalant Robin who did nothing but happily eat in the midst of his colleagues' verbal tussle.
Hahaha kain ng kain walang pakialam sa nangyayare sa kasamahan nya 😂
AKALA MO MALILINIS KUNG MAKA PAG DEFENSA ITONG SI NANCY BINAY.
LANTAD NA SA MGA PILIPINO LALO NA SA MGA TAGA MAKATI ANG
TALAMAK NA
CORRUPTION NG MGA BINAY NA YAN.
THE SAD PART IS,
PATULOY BINOBOTO NG MGA TAO.
MA ABUTAN LANG NG
T SHIRT, BARYA, LATA NG SARDINAS AT 1kilo ng bigas, BINENTA NA NG MGA MANGMANG ANG BOTO NILA.
Kain nlang c robin,wala naman syang maiambag,di nia naintindihan ang topic.
Pero, maganda kung mga dynasty nagbabangayan. High time na tuldokan yan. Yung anti-dynasty bill ikasa na sa House.
BAKA GUSTO NI ALAN MAGING SOUTHEAST ASIAN GAMES ULIT, REMEMBER YON FLAME TOWER NA. MAY. MGA TANONG. SO SIMPLE , PERO PERA NG BAYAN, UTANG NG BAYAN.
Wala na nga makakain Ang taong bayan sobra mahal Ang bagong building.
Bakit ba ayaw bitawan ng mga Binay ang Makati? Meron kaya itinatago at mabubulatlat pag iba na ang umupo?
, MAGPAPATAYAN SA MAKATI IF A BINAY IS UNSEATED. PATI MGA APO NYAN, TATAKBO!!!
Ang tanong, bkit sa BGC pa??! Why not Antipolo or QC where land prices are way cheaper? At present, they are paying rent to the GSIS. So sa gobyerno rin nman napupunta yng pera. Dapat pna renovate nlng nila.
even Binay herself could not even explain it clearly
Yes... So true...
Pa ikot ikot sinasabi.. iniiwas lang sabihin yung kickback nila.. just straight to the pt kung mag kano est budget and actual
KICKBACKS ang dahilan kung bakit lumobo ang gagastusin.
Malaki talaga ang budget ng magarbong senate building kahit yong tiles lang na ginamit malulula tayo sa presyo ..:habang ang pcg at navy ship ay binubully ng monsters ship ng pirates sa WPS , dahil sobrang liliit at kokonte ang ating mga barko😊😅yong gsis ay pag-aari rin gobyerno ibig sabihin kita rin ng gobyerno..dapat sa batasan nlang gumawa ng senate building dahil ang lupa roon ay pag-aari ng gobyerno 😊common sense 😂 malabong magexplain ni Sen nancy, yan ang senador ng Pilipinas , kawawang Inang Bayan…
Hindi na siguro need magtayo ng senate building ng ganyan kamahal, given that the attitude of some senator are parang nasa palengke lng kung mangatwiran laging may nagmumura. May kumakain at nguya ng nguya sa loob habang yong 2 senator nagbabangayan
On point .
❤good evening sir christian,sana sa baranggay nalang Sila nagtalo,nakakahiya talaga 😢😢😢
WALA NMANG NAKAKAHIYA DON AH , SABI NGA EH KUNG SINO ANG IBINOTO MO YON ANG GUSTO MO AT HANDA KA NA TANGGAPIN KUNG ANO ANG LAMAN O RESULTA NG IUUPO MO , KAYA DESERVE NG PILIPINAS KUNG SINO ANG NAKAPWEST DAHIL SILA ANG IBINOTO , SO KUNG ANO SILA WALANG NAKAKAHIYA ALAM NMAN NATIN NA MGA SURNAME LANG NILA ANG DALA DALA NILA HINDI ANG SARILI NILANG KAKAYAHAN
Politicians and Diapers Must Be Changed Often and For The Same Reason.
They're Honorable But Horror-able.
Religious But Corrupt.
Pinag aawayan ang kickback
Okay na sana sakin to si Nancy nung mga nakaraan, kaso halatang di rin honest.
Gone are the days na kagalang galang, matatalino at may pakinabang ang ating mga senators. All because of Filipinos na di marunong pumili ng mga tamang lider.
NONAMECM5926, THE PEOPLE OF MAKATI, CANNOT FIND ANYONE TO REPRESENT THEM EXCEPT THE BINAYS. TATAY, NANAY AND 3 KIDS!!! NAGPAPATAYAN NA SILA SA POSITION. SO DAHIL GUSTONG MAG SILBE, YOU BINAYS ARE FIGHTING OVER A POSITION, WHY??? GANYAN BA TALAGA KALAHI ANG PERANG MAKUKURAKOT SA MAKATI?? THIS IS THE LEGACY OF THE BINAYS?? TAPOS MGA ANAK NAMAN NINYO SIGURADO ANG SUSUNOD. KUNG MERONG KABETCHING, KABETCHING DIN. WALA NA TALAGANG PAG ASA ANG BAYAN NA ITO!!!!
Akala ko gaganda na image ng Senado. Lalo yatang lumala. Si Robinhood wala naman yatang maiintindihan kaya ayun , kain lang ng kain.
Si Robinhood dapat sa TODA lang kumandidato yun.
Korek Buti nlang d cy ngsiklay ng bigote😂😂😂
@@user-qh7mv8np2sHindi yun mananalo unless mangako syang bubuhusan ng personal money nya ang mga projects ng TODA.
Si robinhood walang isyu ng kurapsyon, pero yang binay dami ng isyu yan, ultimo kapatid inaaway. Pero yan parin kinampihan nyo, mga tanga ba kayo??? Tanong lang po baka gurgurin nyo ako😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂🤣✌
Hindi nmn kasi malinaw magpaliwanag itong si Nancy Binay e.
Kasi pinuputol sya ni cayetano
They shouldn’t be called honourable. Both of them are despicable. What a shame😡😡😡
Ms BINAY… hindi mg kakaron ng karangalan ang Senado hanggang tulad ninyo ang andyan… yn ang tutuo….!
BRAVO TO YOU. JULIET.
A public servant must be respectful and a good role model. Ekis sa mga palamura, bastos sumagot at lalo na sa mga kurakot mahilig sa confidential funds, etc.
so frustrated with Alan Peter Cayetano ...both him and Binay are members of their money making clans with vested interest...greed is real !!!
Pinaglalaruan lang naman ng mga ito yung pera natin. Why would someone like Robinhood or bato or even these two political dynasties deserves a very expensive building while many Filipino children go to school hungry? Filipinos deserves better.
MISMO!
ANG KAILANGAN NG MGA FILIPINOS
AY EFFICIENT GOVERNANCE NA
MAY IMPACT SA BUHAY NILA....
HINDI KAILANGAN NG
BONGGANG
BILYONES NA
BUILDING NG MGA
SENADO
KUNG WALA NAMAN NAPAPALA ANG MALILIIT NA MAMAMAYAN SA MGA
BATAS NA GINA GAWA NYO JAN SA SENATE
AT HINDI NYO NAMAN
MA I-SAKA-TUPARAN
OR MA "EXECUTE"
YUNG BATAS NA MGA GINAGAWA NYO!
ILANG BATAS NA BA GINAWA NYO,
ANO,
MAY NABAGO BA SA BUHAY NG MGA PILIPINO????
MAY NA IMPROVE
BA SA ESTADO NG MGA MAMAMAYAN JAN?????
UMAYOS BA ANG
ARAW ARAW NILANG
PAMUMUHAY?
GUMANDA BA ANG
TRANSPORATSYON?
SAHOD NG MGA TAO?
DUMAMI BA TRABAHO?
KUMONTI NA BA ANG BRAIN DRAIN?
NAG IMPROVE BA ANG TALINO NG KABATAAN?
O KULELAT PA RIN BA
MGA YOUTH NATIN WHEN IT COMES TO
LITERACY?
DUMAMI BA ANG PABAHAY?
O MARAMI PA RIN
SQUATTERS?
BILYONES PARA
SA BUILDINGS?
ALAM BA NG GOBYERNO ANG PRIORITIES NA DAPAT GAWIN PARA SA BANSA?
Sa klase ng mga senador meron tayo ngayon, pwede na sila kahit sa barangay hall lang.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
To Sen. Cayetano and Sen. Binay pera naming taumbayan ang pinagaawayan ninyo. There are plenty of reasons why renting is better no. 1 would be the source of money is coming from the national budget and it will go back to the govt via GSIS so nothing is loss. Senate capital outlay for that building that will become useless and depreciate within 20 years and who knows we will become a unicameral by that time. Think about the maintenance cost of that establishment. Sayang lang sana naging business area na lang ito then we get taxes and put more jobs.
Mistake No. 1 by the Senate, binigay sa DPWH ang pag manage ng project ng new senate building. Mistake No. 2, the Senate should have hired in the first place a chief architect who is in charge of the whole plan and who will act in behalf of the senators. Mistake No. 3, this should have been within the parameters of a fixed budget isama na nila ang projected 3 year inflation cost.
Stop na political dynasties. Yan ang nagpapahirap sa bayan.
Disappointed that Christian did not follow through his questions. Nancy did not really shed light on the issue
It's DPWH kasi that prepares the request for the budget based on cost of building it. 8B was only an estimate, just like when you construct a house may nadagdag na gastos at sa tagal ng construction that spans years, ang cost nyan mag iincrease din.
Bastos lang talaga magtanong ung maingay na aso ni Duterte.
Parehong TRAPO…..
Magnanakaw galit sa kapwa magnanakaw. Poor Filipino 😢
Parehas katas ng family political dynasty. 😡🇵🇭🤬
Batang makati ako, la ko pakels bsta nkktanggap nmn parents ko ng benefits ok na😅
@@layza827 how much? In exchange of your principle, or you don’t have it.
@@layza827 pera ng taong bayan …taxes .. Ang n tanggap ng parents mo… hindi pera ng mga BINAY…..!
Grandiose nga bahay ng senate, yung mga nakatira naman, pwehhh
Kung bago ba ang senate building ng pilipinas mag tatalino ba ang mga senatong? Nag tatanong lang po
😂😂😂😂
Pero dapat bilang client merong owners engineer ang senado, may management team kayo dapat na nagrereview para sa inyo. Para hindi kayo ganyan na nagaakusahan. Simpleng solusyon lang sana kaso napupulitika.
Yung mukha ni Christian habang nagbabato ng numero si Binay, priceless. Nakikita ko thought bubble nya... "Ano ulit yun? Paano naging 23B? Teka, diba marunong akong mag add? Bakit di ko ma-gets... nabubudol ata ako. Tulong???".
There's no more PRESTIGE, HONOR, INTEGRITY, and RESPECT in the present SENATE.
Totoo. Siguro ayusin muna nila kunsensya nila bago yung bahay.
Hindi po bagay ang bagong Senate building sa mga senador na isip tungaw.
With a state-of-the-art new Senate Building, how sure are we, that the Occupants are world class.
ang prestige ng senate ang nagdadala ay mga katangi tanging senador.
kung ganito ba naman ang kalidad ng senador na hindi maipaliwanag ng sapat ang budget para sa pagtayo ng gusali, kahit ano pa ang ganda ng gusali nawawala ang saysay dahil sa mababang uri ng senador na binoboto ng taong bayan
Kailangan bang pagandahin iyan kung mga hindi honorables ang senador. May corrupt, pan sarili lang ang tinitignan at pinaglalaban, may mga away na parang hindi mga professional..self-serving....etc. scandalous mga ibang senador. Siguro basta may sarili nalang building ang senate at presentable hindi na ganyan sobrang mahal. Gamitin nalang nila ang pera ng taong bayan para sa pangangailangan ng taong bayan lalo na mahihirap.
Yan ba ang mga "honorable" senators? Nakakahiya kayo!
Ano ba kayo mga senators sana pagunlad ang gawin ninyo hindi awayan kayo ng ayawan grabe nagaagawan kayo sa power at pera more pera pare pareho kayo pera pera pera yaman yaman
how demeaning for Senator Cateyano for even to emphasize it was the senate yet uses expressions unexpected from a senate debate …
600million just for landscaping alone?
Hearing must be done in a civilized manner.... government officials need to learn to put their emotions deep inside their pockets....
I think Christian's question as to the total cost to construct the senate building was dodged by Nancy Binay. At the very onset, the proposal should have an indicative amount, for purposes of budget approval, including or excluding the lot. To say that the project concept is design and build does not explain it. The review panel should check documentation evidencing approval. This document, unless approved without due scrutiny, should disclose the amount in question.
In parting, these two "honorable" senators acted dishonorably during said hearing. Bad example for the youth.
Gone are the days na respectable and talagang magagaling Yung mga Senators natin😌. Ngayon?🙄
Huwag po gamitin ang pera nang bayan sa grandstanding at pag papa-cute🥸Magtrabaho kayo!
Dapat isapubliko ang lahat ng gastos pr tapos,malinawan ang lhat ,madali lng yn ,d sabihin nyo ung gastos s lupa at gastos s building wag ng pgtalunan sagutin n kasi kung mgkano nga lhat, understood nmn n medyo nadagdagan kasi n stop ung construction dahil s pandemic ,tumaas ang material cost ,,,,,wl ng talo talo sagutin n lng kung mgkano, daming paligoyligoy n binay ,sagutin mo n kasi ,......ang enterview n to ay masakit sa ulo,d nasagot ng tama s tanong , palikoliko,paikot ikot hay naku binay kung lumaki ang gastos e di lumaki kung un b talaga ang nagastos ,ang masama kung pinagkakitaan kawawa nmn ang tax payers laki ng kaltas pero walang magandang bahay, hirap kasi sa pilipinas ang mambabatas s pilipinas ay lahat negosyante
Ganyan nakikita ng mga kabataan na ginagawa ng mga Senador...anong VALUES mayroon sila...God bless us all
Pinag a awayan niyo lng Ang mga kickback nyo- Sen. Miriam Defensor Santiago
Kung continuing construction, may "change order" na irerelease ng DPWH sa Senate in case of material cost escalation and labor cost. Let's see this!
Masarap kaya kumain ng libre sa hearing,Lalo na kung hindi ka makaintindi,buti na lang hindi nabulonan.
Wala akong naintindihan sa mga paliwanag kung bakit sila nag away. Tayo pa rin kawawa, gumasto nang sobra sobra. Hats off ako kay christian na binuklat sa kahiya hiya sa kanilang demeanor. Wala nang character nawala pa ang intellect.
Christian lagi kita pinapanood pero eto kay binay halata na may malaking priblema diyan sa budget bakit sobrang napakamahal naoanood kuying live hearing takaga di masagot ni binay yong mga number na sila naman gumawa katulad ng land scaping need nila mag paliwanag kasi pera ito jg mga tao lalo n mga nag babayad jg tax
If there's anything that chiz and alan peter are good at, it's flare. Puro pasiklab lang
D p nya masagot agad, magkano b talaga total budget - i lost interest in siding with her
Problema dito kasi puro hearsay lang ang sinabi ni Nancy. Di ko gusto si Peter pero mukhang may sakit lang din ng loob si Nancy kay Peter.
As skeleton palang un bldg sana may igaganda pa un bldg ng senate . Sana maging environmental friendly din sya.
I hope this grandiose expense will not push through. If these senators are really for the country , they should spend it to school buildings and hospitals especially in the low lying areas in the provinces.
> Sayo Makati - akin ang Taguig!! Revival of old Family Feud!!/
Its about political dynasty and power.
As chair dapat inquisitive and investigative rather than accusatory and grandstanding.
Gusto talaga magpa pansin ni Petrang Cayatano. Klaro naman dun sa sagutan nila sa hearing na ayaw makinig ng sinasabi ni Binay na hindi dapat kasali yung cost ng lupa
Mahiya naman kayo Huy!!!
Halata nga yung galit ni allan sa Makati.. Naku hindi ko ibobito yung kapartido niya kung sakali..😂😂😂😂
Parehas dalawang yan wag na kayo mamili. Ginagawang Family Business yung Gobyerno, mga ganyan di na binoboto mga yan.
Wow! Binay Dynasty narin.... 😔 😟
Wag nyo nlng ituloy yang Senate building e kung ganyan lang din nmn sila mag uusap e anong point ng magandang building.
Unahin muna yung quality ng mga Senator. Naninita si Cayetano e building ng Senate yun e diba Senator din siya pag ba chairman siya lang lht? So ibig sabhin kung hindi naging Chairman si Cayetano hindi siya maninita? e from Lacson pa pala yan though estimate lang nmn and sana nga ma delay pa or wag ng ituloy.
Kng malinis kasi ang intensyon mo dpat hindi k ntatakot n maglabas ng mga hinihingi nila sau..db senator Cayetano
Sir Christian...kumusta ang loans natin sa China...baka nagigisa na rin tayo sa sariling mantika just like some countries debted to them?
Si DUTERTE DAPAT MAG BAYAD NG UTANG NA YAN , SILA DUTERTE NKINABANG EH ..
Bakit hindi masagot kung bakit lumob ang presyo? Ayoko rin kay Kayatano, pero bakit kasi ang laki ng budget for that building? Grabe naman yang 21B for a building for crooks!
Kung nagmahal dahil sa location, bakit hindi nila tinayo sa cheap na lugar. Makakapagdala pa sila ng economic activity.
Korap ksi ang mga na sa gobyerno walang awa sa mga mahihirap na pilipino na nauuto nila tuwing eleksyon😊
What a pity to see these dynastic senators in a debate..ayayayyaya.
Para fair invite senator cayetano ano ang maysabi. Not only Binay
Kung by phases ang budgeting, so walang contracted project cost as a whole. Dahil by phases yan, ibig sabihin nakabase sa yearly GAA. At yearly ay nagbabago ang material cost. Kaya lomolobo yan.
Hindi pa rin napaliwanag ang cost breakdown.
Watching from Milan
they should stick to the plan of the total cost. Ang nangyare naiba na ng naiba. Dapat ang pagtitipid ay inuumpusahan ng gobyerno to think na naghihirap ang bansa at walang pondo ang gibyerno
Sana mabasa nila itong mga comments. Nakakahiya itong mga senators na ito. Naturingan pa naman kayong mga taga gawa ng batas at mga kagalang galang na tao.
Dapat pa ba kayong irespetong tao. Pare pareho naman ang majority ng senado kung may matino suguro iilan lang. Yong iba tangap ng sweldo, incentives at pakain kain lang at pakuya kuyakoy.
Guest mo pala si sen Binay. Ang problema nagpadala siya sa ugali na hindi na ni respeto ang senado. Mahilig magparinig at manghiya. Sana if they have something, should discuss behind camera puede naman sa office nila. O baka naman intentionally na gusto niyang ipahiya si Sen Binay.
Millions…Billions.. for a monument to inanity.
Ok, sige na, 21B na. Pero inupuan mo ng 15 months kaya lumobo ng lumobo. Tama lang ang pagtatanong ni Sen. Cayetano dun sa hearing.
thank you mr. esguerra for asking the right questions and trying to get your guest to answer them fully and honestly. i'm neither happy nor satisfied with sen. binay's answers but it's not the host's fault. he can only go so far to squeeze a proper answer out of her. the way sen. binay responded to the questions goes to show how she's either so out of touch, frivolous and shallow or she's not being forthcoming (or both!).
i agree that the current senate building is run-down and an embarassment (just like many government buildings), but the cost is too high that one may reasonably suspect a significant amount of padding in the price tag.
most importantly, her 'design and build' reason as to why the cost keeps climbing is utter bull$%&t, among other fallacies and gaslights mentioned (ie not inputting the cost of the building when constructing it, etc).
ibig sabihin lang ng 'design and build' is that instead of having a separate architect and engineer to design and build a structure, iisang tao or entity lang ang gagawa. it's supposed to be a more cost-efficient way to build kasi pwede i-package yung cost but there are a lot of horror stories about it because there's no checks and balance, and at worst, the person or entity hired to do the project runs away with the money.
so the design and build concept has NOTHING to do with the cost climbing. tama si mr. esguerra, if there's an established budget from the get-go that is usually quoted by the architect and engineer based on their experience and expertise, dapat yun na yun. usually may konting padding na dapat yung quotation for contingencies (like 3-5% on top of the contract price) pero kung maayos na architect and engineer ang katrabaho mo, dapat na-foresee na nila ang mga pwedeng mangyari and they won't come crawling back to you asking for more money.
labas sa ilong mga sagot ni sen. binay. don't believe it. and don't get me started on sen. cayetano 🤬
Diba siya ung chairman ng committee on ethics nung time na puro grandstand at mura mga senador jan, Tulfo, Padilla, Estrada, Bato, Bong go
Tahimik lang sya haha
pansariling interes lng nman ang propaganda nila.... kase s totoo lng... wla sila pakialam kung mahirap ang karamihan s mga filipinos... di ba...
.bakit ngayun lang tinatanong ni peter si binay? Sana noun pa..anyway its better late than never
Peter Cayetano is the kaldero king! He should remind himself that!!!!
Billion pesos sa senate house ,people’s money ,Ang taong bayan walang makain whahaha……
Only one person should talk at a time.