personally I think unless there's a massive difference in price. I feel most people still lean towards the DJI because of its reputation and support ....
I think that they are identical drones made by DJI under a new name just in case they are band from being sold in the US. That’s what I honestly think. 🤨
@@Matanumi Too many dji drones are shipped to Russia and Ukraine, that's why both US and Chinese govt are urging DJI to stop doing that. And then dji got a shell to keep the business.
Keep up this great work Jack! It sure appears that they are twins. You mentioned that you were geofenced with the Specta. Is there a procedure for unlocking and flight approval from Cotigo?
What is the chance DJI is making this drone?? I wonder if they feel the US banned is coming and this may be their way around it? Up until now nothing has been close to the DJI stability and performance so it has me thinking....
I just watched a vid on 51 Drones about a full PRC drone ban for everyone in the US and the preliminary implementation date of 1/1/2025 was floated in one of the documents shown in the video. If it is implemented, DJI is definitely on the top of the list. Hopefully it won't extend to Autel Robotics and Fimi if it is implemented.
I asked the same thing in the last video and they are not compatible with each other. It makes me wonder why but I think profit is probably the motivator.
Rumor is it's updating via the DJI CDN. The details of the manufacturing and branding may be opaque but the probability is extremely high that it's essentially the same device. You can be sure that DJI would come down like a ton of bricks on anyone randomly selling a clone of the drone, the controller, the app, and even the manual! So, there's a purpose involved, and so-called "white label" devices are not an uncommon marketing strategy in many industries. Since this version apparently doesn't offer the DJI extended support options, it may be aimed primarily at other market segments. I tend to doubt that it's a serious attempt to avoid (theoretical) consumer U.S. bans. The probability of a broad consumer-level ban of these drones being passed and surviving court challenges is very low, and it wouldn't fool regulators anyway.
I agree w/you saying that it's very low probability that DJI would be completely banned. If you look at the bill tracker for (I think it's H.R. 2864), it shows 1% chance.
Is there something about the DJI Air3 that a company would actually clone it to get a pie share or to make the DJI a one to own. Or the DJI Air3 is that popular a drone
DJI Air 3 in this same config: $1399. Specta: $1,199. I'd opt for the DJI but that's just me. This is fun to see this comparo through. It's disappointing the batteries are not interchangeable though.
You can not get them in the same configs. DJI with this remote is flymore only and the Specta has no RC-N2 option. They are the same DJI drone but DJI has locked out accessories like batts and some features with firmware on the Spectas.
Great comparison Jack. It sure looks like they are essentially the same drone. It will be interesting what kind of support is available with Specta. Appreciate you putting this together!
I really appreciate the comparison shots and videos. Thank you for your valuable time to put this together. Unlike the other commentor, I don't care about the insides being the same if the controls work as well or better, and the media is equivalent quality or better . Why would I care about the insides? But looking at the output on these comparison shoots on a T.V. flat screen, I don't think it's bias to say the DJI looks sharper (more accurate). The smaller twigs on the trees were more distinguishable on DJI, but appear as gray mass (blur) on Specta... IMHO.
I'm glad to see that they are basically the same drone for roughly the same price. So basically this is just a "Congress Dodger Air" drone. (One of these DJI shell companies should straight up come out with model numbers that start with CD for congress dodger.) Anyway, it's good to know that we'll have some alternatives when this stupid law passes. I think we just have to get used to the name of the drone company changing with the day of the week. The biggest loss will of course be the replacement plans if you currently pay for those.
Initially couldn’t tell, but eventually DJI, as usual to my eye and preference, seems over contrasted(blues & greens over done), which in turn also darkens the image.
To my eye (40 years amateur/semi-pro photographer) the DJI camera borders on being overexposed in the light and underexposed in the shadows. Your comment about contrast and color balance play out in that regard.
Thank you for taking the time to put the comparison together and have a question on the Geo lock. I occasionally fly in what is considered an Enhanced Warning Zones by DJI. DJI GEO would prompt me at the time of flight to unlock the zone using the same steps as in an Authorization Zone... but I don't require a verified account or an internet connection at the time of my flight. Does Specta give you the same or similar ability to request an unlock? Also, does the Specta require you to setup an account before flying the drone and the ability to upload flights?
In the beginning of the video when you compared drone A & B, I thought drone B was a hair better in video quality. Overall though they are both so close that if Drone A (spectra) was more inexpensive, I would buy it,
i like the look of the air 3 without the name and logo on it. pretty neat. tbh id probably buy one over an air 3. especially with the us gov trying to ban dji drones.
Hi, I love DJI products and own a Mavic 2, I am thinking of upgrading to an Air 3, however now I learn about a similar product the Specta Air and both looks the same!, Are both companies collaborating? Already got an answer from another video and they said No there's no collaboration or affiliation. Can someone confirm? Anyway everyone knows that Chinese love to copy someone else's work in this case, it seems Specta copied DJI, it seems there's no laws which prohibits that in China and no one minds it. Which means it would come down to price. I want the Air 3, but if Specta Air is priced less and is more affordable, I could lean towards the Specta Air.
Wow, this is getting interesting. We went from “no one is even close to DJI”, now we have these duplicates. It doesn’t seem to be a huge difference. 🤔🤔🤔🤔 I have my thoughts on this but I am not sharing yet.
Ok so, thank you for the videos. Having said that, the only way to know for sure is to disassemble them both and see if the inside components are the same. Thats what we all want to see, not more videos on how they fly or record similarly.
@@HalfChrome Excellent! You do realize that yourself and another TH-cam channel have been credited publicly with bringing this possible conspiracy to the public. I have now read two different publications online that specifically name your channel and another. This could be good, but it could also be bad, depending on what happens with this "ban" . Specta could be our only way of recieving Dji level equipment if Dji is actually banned and now it's out there for the government to see. I have mixed feelings on this.
There was no absolute need to carbon copy the dji air 3 as it is. Specta should have designed their drone differently. And how's DJI silent in this matter 🤔
I'm more interested in drone imposed restriction and required interaction with the particular company. I have a DJI Mavic Mini, that I haven't flown yet, because I really don't want an "Account", or a drone that will not take off in an erroneous "restricted", area ...
The shear fact that Specta is offering a package that DJI won't because they get too hung up on marketing ploys is spectacular! Being able to get the drone with a battery and the RC-2 for $1,100 vs a freaking fly-more combo for $1,500+ Maybe this will eventually force DJI to stop the B.S.😅
@Dartheomus Actually no, today was the first I've heard of them and then subsequently visited their website. So they are an American based company that's part of DJI?
If the idea was to avoid DJI embargo, it's not going to work. DJI from China vs Specta from Hong Kong (aka) China🤣. It's the same drone with slight difference firmware.
Same hardware, same software (mostly). Same drone with different names. Gotta wonder what DJI's angle is with this clone. I wonder if we will every know.
Geofencing is the only thing that makes sense; the fact that it still has this makes this offshoot brand kind of worthless. I honestly believe it is created and others will sprout up in response to anti-Chinese drone legislation that’s currently going about. DJI trying to spread itself if in the event they are banned in USA because IF they get banned in USA they dead in the water.
@@HalfChrome this is true. There are other companies popping up, some based in America. Maybe the concern was banning DJI exclusively- so they are spreading / diversifying the brand. In my opinion it really cheapens the DJI brand.
Where did the Specta Air come from? It's the same copied drone from DJI Air 3, But I never heard that the brand of Specta Air before~ This is very funny~
personally I think unless there's a massive difference in price. I feel most people still lean towards the DJI because of its reputation and support ....
Until the US Government bans CCP manufactured drones.
I’ve heard a lot of people saying that this companies had very good drone support similar to DJI
It IS DJI, rebranded to avoid US sanctions.
Its already a pain to get an Air 3S in the USA right now; Specta is 'not DJI'... So it bypasses sanctions.
I think that they are identical drones made by DJI under a new name just in case they are band from being sold in the US. That’s what I honestly think. 🤨
I think DJI knows they would lose some pilots if the Specta didn't have geo fencing. That option would make me cross over the dark side! 😅
It's very likely the same company just a shell corp to avoid any potential ban
@@Matanumi Too many dji drones are shipped to Russia and Ukraine, that's why both US and Chinese govt are urging DJI to stop doing that. And then dji got a shell to keep the business.
@maqfoli_art limits your ability to fly in places you shouldn’t fly
Specta just turned off geo fencing!!!
I stick with DJI. They have a name and care refresh.
If there was a big price difference, maybe, otherwise I choose "better safe than sorry"
Can you swap battaris and can you bind a DJI radio to the Specta
Nope
Could you sync the dji remote with the spectra and vise versus?
Nope
I noticed that drone A has some glitches in the Footage. While dji drone B is smooth as butter.
Keep up this great work Jack! It sure appears that they are twins. You mentioned that you were geofenced with the Specta. Is there a procedure for unlocking and flight approval from Cotigo?
I’m sure it’s the same as DJI. I didn’t try.
That's probably what I'm most curious about.
Hi, what was the cost difference between them?
$100-200
Do you think you can update the Specta...with a dji firmware...it might work...
Nope.
What is the chance DJI is making this drone?? I wonder if they feel the US banned is coming and this may be their way around it?
Up until now nothing has been close to the DJI stability and performance so it has me thinking....
100%
I just watched a vid on 51 Drones about a full PRC drone ban for everyone in the US and the preliminary implementation date of 1/1/2025 was floated in one of the documents shown in the video. If it is implemented, DJI is definitely on the top of the list. Hopefully it won't extend to Autel Robotics and Fimi if it is implemented.
there's a site that says there is a 1% chance of the drone ban bill passing.@@chriswatchingyt
rumor has it that DJI is actually overseeing the production of these and with the possible ban on DJI think they're trying to stay a step ahead of it.
It’s kinda how EXO drones are just rebranded Hubson Drones.
Do the batteries from the specta fit into the DJI Air 3? Just curious
I asked the same thing in the last video and they are not compatible with each other. It makes me wonder why but I think profit is probably the motivator.
They fit but do not work
Hey @halfchrome can you show how to change filter on specta air
Same as DJI air 3.
@ do u know of any replacement batteries I know on amazon it says out of stock is there any other you can recommend
@bugsbunny20878 email Specta. Needs to be Specta battery
Rumor is it's updating via the DJI CDN. The details of the manufacturing and branding may be opaque but the probability is extremely high that it's essentially the same device. You can be sure that DJI would come down like a ton of bricks on anyone randomly selling a clone of the drone, the controller, the app, and even the manual! So, there's a purpose involved, and so-called "white label" devices are not an uncommon marketing strategy in many industries. Since this version apparently doesn't offer the DJI extended support options, it may be aimed primarily at other market segments. I tend to doubt that it's a serious attempt to avoid (theoretical) consumer U.S. bans. The probability of a broad consumer-level ban of these drones being passed and surviving court challenges is very low, and it wouldn't fool regulators anyway.
I agree w/you saying that it's very low probability that DJI would be completely banned. If you look at the bill tracker for (I think it's H.R. 2864), it shows 1% chance.
Does it have an open sdk?
Is there something about the DJI Air3 that a company would actually clone it to get a pie share or to make the DJI a one to own. Or the DJI Air3 is that popular a drone
Does the Specta Air support mapping?
DJI Air 3 in this same config: $1399. Specta: $1,199. I'd opt for the DJI but that's just me. This is fun to see this comparo through. It's disappointing the batteries are not interchangeable though.
You can not get them in the same configs. DJI with this remote is flymore only and the Specta has no RC-N2 option. They are the same DJI drone but DJI has locked out accessories like batts and some features with firmware on the Spectas.
Cheers so much for all your hard work and I like the Specta's camera best it looks like more dynamic range out of the box 😊❤
Awesome videos guys!
Hello,
I couldn't find that drone-specta air on amazon. You have a link I can purchase one. Thanks
Yes. In the video description.
Great comparison Jack. It sure looks like they are essentially the same drone. It will be interesting what kind of support is available with Specta. Appreciate you putting this together!
When you cal Specta customer service it gets transferred to DJI Lol
@@LaszloBagi
That cannot be true
@@AllCentaur Who picks up the phone?
Where are you filming? Such an interesting town
Most of this is carpentersville, IL
Cool, thanks! @@HalfChrome
Saludos el paquete trae el cargador o se debe comprar un cargador dji
Are they same?
IDK but I've a DJI AIR and the SPECTA looks like exactly the same model just without DJI and the name AIR 3 printed on aircraft,
Basically
Well done Jack ! I'm very impressed with the Specta Air. Two areas of concern for me are pricing (under 1K would really help) and support options.
Same.
how tf this not trademark infringement
Because DJI is probably manufacturing both.
Dose it have geo fencing or not.??
Yes
I really appreciate the comparison shots and videos. Thank you for your valuable time to put this together. Unlike the other commentor, I don't care about the insides being the same if the controls work as well or better, and the media is equivalent quality or better . Why would I care about the insides? But looking at the output on these comparison shoots on a T.V. flat screen, I don't think it's bias to say the DJI looks sharper (more accurate). The smaller twigs on the trees were more distinguishable on DJI, but appear as gray mass (blur) on Specta... IMHO.
Whats that music playing in the begining around the 3min Mark? Love that Song but coudnt fint it in rhe notes... Thx in advance keep Up the good Work!
Just found it: The Ones - Jones 😉
Does specta drones have 4glte
No
The spectra company lied saying they don't put geofensing on there drone then
Great comparison, would be nice to see the price difference and the warranties for each drone…
the specta air is $1199 with one Battery and the "RC2" controller.
Gee the government would never be able to work that out! 😂
Thanks for the video 🎉
This reminds me of the comparison between Lexus and Toyota. Same car, different logo
i feel like i like the specta air color science a little better hold up. i wonder how good log footage looks and those kinds of things
I bought the Specta the obstacle avoidance at night is horrible not sure if it’s the the same with the air 3
Yes. OA is visual based. It cannot see in the dark. Same is true if the Air 3
I thought a recent Dji update had removed the "no flight zone" and that the responsibility now fell on the user. Well, at least here in Europe
They removed some, it's actually ongoing on a country by country basis. But e.g. airport NFZ's are still there.
Well the most important question that i have and didn't hear in your video is the Price of both Drone's?
$1199 Specta and $1099 DJI but Specta upgrades the remote.
So more expensive for a clone?
I'm glad to see that they are basically the same drone for roughly the same price. So basically this is just a "Congress Dodger Air" drone. (One of these DJI shell companies should straight up come out with model numbers that start with CD for congress dodger.) Anyway, it's good to know that we'll have some alternatives when this stupid law passes. I think we just have to get used to the name of the drone company changing with the day of the week. The biggest loss will of course be the replacement plans if you currently pay for those.
Initially couldn’t tell, but eventually DJI, as usual to my eye and preference, seems over contrasted(blues & greens over done), which in turn also darkens the image.
To my eye (40 years amateur/semi-pro photographer) the DJI camera borders on being overexposed in the light and underexposed in the shadows. Your comment about contrast and color balance play out in that regard.
Thank you for taking the time to put the comparison together and have a question on the Geo lock. I occasionally fly in what is considered an Enhanced Warning Zones by DJI. DJI GEO would prompt me at the time of flight to unlock the zone using the same steps as in an Authorization Zone... but I don't require a verified account or an internet connection at the time of my flight. Does Specta give you the same or similar ability to request an unlock? Also, does the Specta require you to setup an account before flying the drone and the ability to upload flights?
Not sure. Great questions. Most likely
I unlocked an authorization zone with the Specta Air. It just requires a network connection. I used my phone's hot spot.
In the beginning of the video when you compared drone A & B, I thought drone B was a hair better in video quality. Overall though they are both so close that if Drone A (spectra) was more inexpensive, I would buy it,
i like the look of the air 3 without the name and logo on it. pretty neat. tbh id probably buy one over an air 3. especially with the us gov trying to ban dji drones.
I do like the orange props on the specta lol 😂
Hi, I love DJI products and own a Mavic 2, I am thinking of upgrading to an Air 3, however now I learn about a similar product the Specta Air and both looks the same!, Are both companies collaborating? Already got an answer from another video and they said No there's no collaboration or affiliation. Can someone confirm? Anyway everyone knows that Chinese love to copy someone else's work in this case, it seems Specta copied DJI, it seems there's no laws which prohibits that in China and no one minds it. Which means it would come down to price. I want the Air 3, but if Specta Air is priced less and is more affordable, I could lean towards the Specta Air.
Wow, this is getting interesting. We went from “no one is even close to DJI”, now we have these duplicates. It doesn’t seem to be a huge difference. 🤔🤔🤔🤔
I have my thoughts on this but I am not sharing yet.
Both drones are made by DJI. The insides tell the story. The only difference is in firmware.
Ok so, thank you for the videos. Having said that, the only way to know for sure is to disassemble them both and see if the inside components are the same. Thats what we all want to see, not more videos on how they fly or record similarly.
It’s coming
@@HalfChrome Excellent! You do realize that yourself and another TH-cam channel have been credited publicly with bringing this possible conspiracy to the public. I have now read two different publications online that specifically name your channel and another. This could be good, but it could also be bad, depending on what happens with this "ban" . Specta could be our only way of recieving Dji level equipment if Dji is actually banned and now it's out there for the government to see. I have mixed feelings on this.
He flat out says Chris has fully disassembled both drones to do a side-by-side comparison.
“Video coming soon…”
Thanks Half Chrome !!
faster please :) @@HalfChrome
It’s on my website
April 1st will be upon us soon! D'Oh!
Why does that matter?
Oh the fools....
Yeah well its a real product.... probably to answer the ban as a shell corp
There was no absolute need to carbon copy the dji air 3 as it is. Specta should have designed their drone differently.
And how's DJI silent in this matter 🤔
有区别吗？不就是贴牌的大疆无人机吗？一模一样，可能考虑到某些国家的限制问题，大疆可能默许合作的公司贴牌销售。
I'm more interested in drone imposed restriction and required interaction with the particular company.
I have a DJI Mavic Mini, that I haven't flown yet, because I really don't want an "Account", or a drone that will not take off in an erroneous "restricted", area ...
Just a Drone made in China without the DJI logo .
The shear fact that Specta is offering a package that DJI won't because they get too hung up on marketing ploys is spectacular! Being able to get the drone with a battery and the RC-2 for $1,100 vs a freaking fly-more combo for $1,500+
Maybe this will eventually force DJI to stop the B.S.😅
You realize Specta is a shell company of DJI, right? This is being done to simply be prepared to deal with the incoming DJI ban.
@Dartheomus Actually no, today was the first I've heard of them and then subsequently visited their website.
So they are an American based company that's part of DJI?
@@dmac8207That, or a standalone American company paying DJI for a white label product that they resell.
You never said how long the spectra air battrries lasted
Same as the air 3 batteries
E uma copia quase perfeita!!!
I will always rock with dji. Not supporting knock off.
Obviously the Specta had way better music🤪
LOL
I heard you can’t get extra batteries
How is this legal? Specta copied DJI (which looks to me), 100%. At least the body.
It's all made in the same warehouse
Geofencing has ruined my experience with DJI
Here is my theory: The Spectra has orange propellers, and the DJI does not.
LOL
It tells the drone where it can and can't fly without unlocking it through DJI with FAA clearance.
The specta air is a exact copy of the dji air 3
No price difference ... Pass
clone wars.
🤝
One of DJI's biggest markets is banning the use of their drones, causing them to lose revenue..... what did you exSPECTA them to do? 🤫
lol
so specta is a clone? even the softwre ?
Yes
I think this is just a DJI air 3 rebranded and the logo removed
How the heck can a company make a drone so similar…?
Spectre looks like it ripped everything from DJI down to the controller
If the idea was to avoid DJI embargo, it's not going to work. DJI from China vs Specta from Hong Kong (aka) China🤣. It's the same drone with slight difference firmware.
Same hardware, same software (mostly). Same drone with different names. Gotta wonder what DJI's angle is with this clone. I wonder if we will every know.
The "angle" is to get away from the possible ban
China throwing stuff at a wall and seeing what sticks?
The only reason i could tell the difference between the 2 in the video was because the Air 3 seems to have a better picture in low light.
It’s the same light…
@HalfChrome I'm saying the image looks brighter in spots where there is some darkness, from shadows and such. Maybe that'd just me though 🤷
This is "fun"
DJI batteries don’t work
The images from the DJI Air 3 are better than the Specta Air.
Nah specta air are way better
Who can tell on U Tube.
@bidenisasnake9932 pretty sure no one can tell even off TH-cam 🤣
Geofencing is the only thing that makes sense; the fact that it still has this makes this offshoot brand kind of worthless. I honestly believe it is created and others will sprout up in response to anti-Chinese drone legislation that’s currently going about. DJI trying to spread itself if in the event they are banned in USA because IF they get banned in USA they dead in the water.
But this is a Chinese company also. Based in Hong Kong
@@HalfChrome this is true. There are other companies popping up, some based in America. Maybe the concern was banning DJI exclusively- so they are spreading / diversifying the brand. In my opinion it really cheapens the DJI brand.
That is the way it should be no color editing just the way the drone dies
That Specta is pretty sus...🤔
I think you have a DJI bias. I think you shoot your comparison videos with that bias. Therefore, I don't
trust your opinions.
Fair enough. You don’t have to trust my opinions. You can watch the video and come to your own conclusions.
Well, actually, the only way I would buy this knock off Drone is if DJI was banned in the Usa.
There are the same
If my air 3 is fake I'm gonna 😁🔫
We come here for your opinion. we cannot analyze the pictures and videos like you can .
I think they are basically the same. In nearly every way.
Dji is better. If you dont think so get your eyes checked
It’s the same drone. Neither is better. They are the same.
Seems fake
I thought the same thing.
@HalfChrome is there a link you can purchase this? I haven't be able to find much info on this drone
@travelcanada8817 in the video description. USA only.
Who cares. This is boreing.
Boring
Where did the Specta Air come from? It's the same copied drone from DJI Air 3, But I never heard that the brand of Specta Air before~ This is very funny~
It is odd