Ameer Mukhtar Saqafi say motalliq SUNNI aur SHIAH ka Ikhtelaf ??? (By Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ต.ค. 2016
- A Video Clip from 157-Mas'alah [ A Special & Critical 100-Q & A Session (Duration : 4-Hours & 43-Min) recorded on SUNDAY, 23-Oct-2016 (21-Moharram-ul-Haram 1438 Hijri) at Qur'an-o-Sunnat Research Academy Jhelum City, Punjab PAKISTAN ]. Link of Complete Video : • 157-a-Mas'alah (Part-1...
#Ameer_Mukhtar_Saqafi #Sunni_Shiah_ka_Ikhtelaf
SUNNI & SHIAH kay IKHTELAF peh Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza ki 63-ILMI-o-Tahqeeqi MAJLIS (16-May-2019) : th-cam.com/video/dQr6FwQ2znI/w-d-xo.html
Sorry engineer sahib ic baray me apka knowledge zero hei ya phir AP haqeeqat chupa rhe..
Apko Al e Zubair k baray me bhi video bnanani chahyie ...
Me Shia hn or apko bht pasand krti hn..mre husband sunni hein mgr apki videos ki waja se unko bht knowledge Mila hei...
Me ne apko calls bhi ki jo apka numbr facebook pe hei...mgr sab off😑
I hope AP muje reply Karen gy will wait
میں مختار ثقفی کے پاس اس کے محل میں گیا، تو اس نے کہا: جبرائیل ابھی ابھی میرے پاس سے گئے ہیں ۱؎، اس وقت اس کی گردن اڑا دینے سے صرف اس حدیث نے مجھے باز رکھا جو میں نے سلیمان بن صرد رضی اللہ عنہ سے سنی تھی کہ نبی اکرم صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: جب کوئی شخص تم سے جان کی امان میں ہو تو اسے قتل نہ کرو، تو اسی بات نے مجھے اس کو قتل کرنے سے روکا ۔
Sunnan ibn e maja 2689 .
Ali bhai ap hadith btaty hn .is mamly mai chupyn na .or aesi kitni hadith hn jis mai ye biyan hai ...
اگر وہ حدیث نہ ہوتی جو میں نے عمرو بن حمق خزاعی رضی اللہ عنہ سے سنی ہے تو میں مختار ثقفی کے سر اور جسم کے درمیان چلتا، میں نے عمرو بن حمق خزاعی رضی اللہ عنہ کو کہتے سنا کہ رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: جس نے کسی کو جان کی امان دی، پھر اس کو قتل کر دیا تو قیامت کے دن دغا بازی کا جھنڈا اٹھائے ہوئے ہو گا .
Sunnan ibn e maja 2688
رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: ”بنو ثقیف میں ایک جھوٹا اور ہلاک کرنے والا ہو گا“۔ امام ترمذی کہتے ہیں: کہا جاتا ہے کذاب اور جھوٹے سے مراد مختار بن ابی عبید ثقفی اور ہلاک کرنے والا سے مراد حجاج بن یوسف ہے ۱؎۔
Jam e trimazi 2220
Hazrat mukhtar was real hero......
Indeed
Bashuk
Tum koi yazeedi sayed hay
Mukhtar valli video to.mene v dekhi hai us me to vo muslmano ke hero hee lg rhe hai jis ne alli ke katilo ka bdla liya
U
Ameer Mukhtar e saqfi was a great man..
Nabuwat ka dawa bhi kr dy tha is ne pta hona chaiye apko
@@shariqhussain6974 kahan pa likha hai
Mukhtar e Thaqafi R.A was awarded Nishan-e-Liaquat by Moula Ali A.S wheb he was just 13 years old and said " This Child will be ointment ( Marhum)for the pain of Ahley Bait A.S"
Nice joke shia khod sa bana laitay aisi nakli rawayat
@@aladdinyt8064 Sadly!
Kharijites Are Also here.
haters of Ali yet again CAlling Ali's words And a Letter for Mukhtar Fake
@@aladdinyt8064 tum ho hi jahil tumhe to ale rasool se hub nhi tum to kafir ho sorry boy.....ab to youtube pr sb koch Fazal bhai jan ab search krlo shaame Ghareeban mein kya kya hota hai.......
@@aladdinyt8064 behas naa krein nhi to bht bura hoga ja keh diya meine.
@@aladdinyt8064 jaa Allah tujhe bughse Ali mein jlai ga aur jb jb tere sath bura hoga tujhe mera ye comment yaad aye ga...beraghrk hojaye...tumhara
Jis bandey se imam Sajjad(a) razi the us se Allah b razi hogaya....
Syed W Abbas bashak jnb bashak
Sada salamat rovo
Ameen
Syed W Abbas beshak bhai
Bhai ap sb is shaks k bolny pe mt jayen ye kadiyani hai lanti shimar ki pairvi krne wala youtube pe hi bol skta hai kbi munazra krna pRha to jang e khandak waly jese bhagy thy ye b bhagyga
bushamar
Salam ho ap janabe Mukhtar,haq Ada kr diya apne khoone Hussain ka badla lekr,ye h asli ishqe Hussain vale
Mohtarma aap kab Haq ada karengi without hijaab photo dp pr lagai hain aap
Malik Ashtar Mukhtar ne pakad liya har katile husain
Daawa ali ka ek bhi jhoota nahi huwa...
Meri Behan, Bohat achi baat hai kay aap Ali Bhai ko sun rahi hain, Kindly and Please, watch Ali Bhai on Hijab and respectfully I would implore you to have a modest profile pic. May Allah be pleased with all of us, Ameen.
Allah ke wali Hazrat maula Ali a s ne ye peshan goi pehle hi kar di thi ke hazrat mukhtar hussain a s ke katilo se badla lege
Kash ke musalmano ko ye bat samajh ajaye ke mere nabi ne kaha me shehre ilm hu aur Ali uska darwaza h a s
MY DEAR MUSLIMS, PLEASE STOP ARGUING ABOUT WHO HE IS. WE SHOULD BE PROUD OF WHAT HE HAS DONE. HE WILL BE REMEMBERED THROUGH OUT OUR GENERATIONS UNTIL THE DAY OF JUDGEMENT.
WELL DONE MAKHTAR!!
Is tarha to ghulam Hussain qadiyani ko bhi apna hero man lo phr wo bhi to Islam ki us wqt sub see zaida knowledge rakhne Wala tha
@@fahadahmad4381 he is not talking about muhtar knowledge he talking about muhtar has taken Hussain a.s revenge. That's why he will be remembered.
@@fahadahmad4381 lpc😊😊😂
@@fahadahmad4381 is trha to amar ibn e abdy wod b ap ka hero ho ga or saad ibn abi waqas b yaqeenan hero ho ga ap ka
@@jabbarhaiderDo not disrespect Saad ibn Abi Waqqas. Even though he left Imam Ali but later he apologized in front of Imam Hassan and Marwan poisoned him just because he was supporting Imam Hassan.
I am shia, mukhtar saqafi (ra) wo shakshiyat hai jinhone un logo ko wasile jahanum kiya, jin logo ne karbala me Imam Husain (as) ko Qatl kiya tha ya unke qatl me involve the, Mukhtar (ra) ne qatilane karbala ka intiqam liya tha... Shirme maloon jaise tamam jahannumiyo ko jahanum pahuchaya tha...
Ameer mukhtar was lion , a true lover of maula ali He killed all killer of imam Hussain. He also helped imam hasan mujtaba. He was follower of imam sajjad and muhammad hanfia. May allah bless him in jannah.
Yes..he was a lion
brother mukhtar ra is the real hero and allah give him jannat
janab e mukhtar saqafi zinadabad
Paendabaad
Zindabad
Salam ho is shaks pr Allah mukhtar ko janat me Alla maqamat ata farmae
BILKUL ZINDABAD
Zindabaad 🙌
Ali a.s ki mohabbat har kisi ko naseeb ni.....🙂🙂
Right
1:04
Hamein to naseeb hy pr tum shion ko nhi hy
Mukhtar Saqfi pe salaam beshumar.. Mola Panjtaan Paak apko jannat mein alla maqam aata farmein
Bhai as ma to koi shak nahi
Ameen
Ameen
No one messes with mukhtar he was great muslim king and i love him
Mukhtar saqfi sy jalny walo py lanat be shumar ....40 part hain dheko or samjo .....
rehman ali dekhe howe han hazrat mukhtaar zindabad or mukhtaar wo shaks h jis ne imam hussain ka badla liya tha or mukhtar ussi jagha pr shaheed huwa tha jis jagha pr imam ali a.s shaheed huwe thae
Rehmat Ali are bhai imam Hussain ki part kis aayenge bataoge
Rehmat Ali yesh it was mukhtar nama
He is a great man
Maine dekhe hai Sare part 4 bar
Vo haq par the hamesha rahe
Unko badnam karne ki chal thi zubairiyo ki
Unko katl karwa diya unki zoja ko bhi 😔
right mene dekhe he. mukhtaar nama episode he
Mukhtar BHT acha th imam Hussain a.s kha bdla lia
Imam Hussain as key badla abhi tak baqi hain jo kehta hai imam mehdi as keh ana sey pehla sufyani khoroj karte hai
Lanat Ho Khuda ki Un Yazidoyon pr Jo Mukhtar R.A ko bura bhala kahein.
Asad Ali bhai sahi kah rehe ho
mukhtar r.a zindabad
syed shan Shia the mukhtar
Bhala bale khae bhai bora khene walo pe lanat
Mera mola ali ka chne wala mukhtar unke bura bhala na kaha kro bhi😭
Bhai jo Abu Talib A.S. K baray mai ye aqeeda rkhen K aap musalman nai hoay thay wo Mukhtar ko kazzab hi bolen gai
Mukhtar was lion and took revenge from yazedes we as a Muslim admire him about his exceptional qualities of leadership and skills..
The GREAT mukhtaar saqhafi........hum un k paon ki matti b nhi ho sakty....
اللہ پاک حضرت مختار ثقفی رضی اللہ تعالی عنہ کے درجات بلند فرمائے
🚩 Ameen 🚩
امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین امین ثمہ امین
mukhtar thaqafi was a great man
mukhtar saqfi par hum Qurban ,,,,,
Salam ho ap par janabe mukhtar,or lanat ho yazidiyo pr dushmanane ahlaibait pr
Mohtarma Aap kab Haq ada karengi without hijaab photo dp pr lagai hain aap
Ali bhai ap ka musalman ummat py bohat ehsan hay Allah ap ko apny hifzo eman main rakhay aameen ya rabul Aalameen🌴🦋🌴🦋🌴🦋
Salam ho janab e mukhtar par humhara labbaik ya Hussain Ali un wali ullah
I think every person has some negative and positive habits.
With all of these habits Mukhtar is a good man.He is the son of a brave companion of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
Let me know about Abu Abaida bin Jarrah and Abu Abaida saqfi.
One of them was leader of Islamic Army during Hazrat Umar khilafat
Mukhtar was really a great person in Islamic history who rules over the hearts of Muslims ever and foreever
Mukhtar saqfi sy jalny walon py lanat be shumar
Amarah Kazmi beshumaar.
Amarah Kazmi tū
beshumar
Be Shumaar.Be Shumaar
Amarah Kazmi beshak lanat hy magr lanat un pe bi 1000 lanat jo Hazrat umer farooq ra ko na many hazrat abu bakkar ko na many or usman ko na many wo kafir us pe lanat beshumar agr apko mere coment p ghusa aya hu to ap mujy khi pe lanat dka day hazraat ali nay dali hu in pe ya in nay un pe dali ho Ya mujy yh dkha do k kha likha hy k mjy in 3 se nafrt thi ali pak n kha likha agr ap mjy ye sabit krdo me shia huajao ga ....Kasm se
A
MashaAllah.
I love you Ali bhai.👍💐👍💐👍💐
AMEER MUKHTAR SAQFI (ra) PAR ALLAH KI REHMAT HO.
Ali bhai ap ka muslman ummat pe bohat ahsan hai Allah ap ko apne hifzo eiman me rakh Ameen ya rabolle Alamein. 🌴🦋🌴🦋🌴🦋
مختار ثقفی کو اللّٰہ تعالیٰ جنت الفردوس میں اعلیٰ مقام عطا فرمائے آمین یا رب العالمین
Jitne bhi dushmanane ahlebait a.s the wo sunniyo ki nazar me razi allah hy waha re bhole sunni
Sahi kha mazlum bhi r.a qatil bhi r.a
Hazrat mukhtar e saqafi ka nam ijjat se lo yazeedi yo ko jahannam bheza hai isi insaan ne
Azeem Sayyed huseniyt zendabad yazidyt murdabad nasly Yazid pr LANAT beshumar Dushmanany ahlybet pr LANAT beshumar AHLY khabis murdabad Wahabi murdabad
Labyk ya husain
Azeem Sayyed
Bhai us Kha
Izzat se naam lenge Janabe muktar ka Ye Sab to rasool ki apne jaise Khate hai
Ali Hussain Alamdari pehli baat to jis tarha sare sunni halala ya misyaar ya jina nahi karte usi tarha sare shia mutta ya jina nahi karte lekin tum logo ke bare bare maulwi jinki bari bari dari hoti hai woh Allah ki qasam kha kha kar shiyo par bohtaan lagate hai
Ali Hussain Alamdari jitna bura shia mazhab ko bura tum log bata te ho mimbare Rasool s.a.w par baith kar itna bura ye mazhab hota to Allah ki qasam shiyat chorke musalmaan ka ko e aur firke me chala jata
Ali Hussain Alamdari tum hari ma ko me bhi galat bol sakta hu lekin nahi boluga kyo ki ma ma hoti hai chahe kisi mazhab ki ho
I saw this clip in 2017... That led me to watch Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza more and more... Now my views changed... Love You Engineer sb (Alhamdulilah)
When Hazrat Ameer Mukhtaar was just 13 years old Mola e Kainat Ali Murtaza ع gave him the title of Nishan e Liaquat and said He will be the ointment for the pain of our Ahlebait..
Thank you so much for clearly stating that Sunni s ct hold nothing against Hazrat Mokhtar Al-thaqafi, atleast not in writing. HE IS A HERO FOR ALL! much respect and appreciation for your work! May Allah reward you for your great work towards uniting the two sects and clearing up old propagandas 👍🏼
It is just propaganda of then government officials to make him look bad. By Allah he was a great man. He will always remain all and every Muslim hero and beloved. It does not matter what sect. Respect to you and Muslims. Sometimes I feel that with atrocities and harm afflicted to Hazrat imam Hussain R.A I wish I was never born and never heard of it. My Final say is SHIA, SUNNI and all sects of Muslims as long as they don't commit shirk and Takfeer on each other are brothers, brothers, brothers and are united in fundemantel believe Hazrat Mukhtar was Martyred and was momin. And Insha Allah will be granted Jannatil Firdous. Amen ya Rabil Alameen
Fawad Ahmed kea bat h boss jeety raho.Allah slamat rakhy.
Fawad Ahmed InshaAllah Amen
Fawad Ahmed true bro
Mukhtar saqafi haramzada
🙂
العجل یا وارث خون حسین علیہ السلام امام حسین علیہ السلام کے خون کا بدلہ لینے والے کو لاکھوں سلام
I love mukhtar
mad lipz mukhtar saqfi salm ap pe ali haq haq
Izat se naam lo hazrat Mukhtar Saqafi rz ka
Wo ek sher dil the aur qatile hussain ko
Chon chon ke mout ke ghat utara
NABI pak s.a.w.w or ahly baiet a.s py lakhon or karooron darood o salaam....💚🌟🌹❣
Na main wahabi Na main babi main hoon Muslim ilmi kitabi.📚📙📘📗🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
حضرت علی نے ارشاد فرمایا ہے کہ حضرت رسول کریم فرمایا کرتے تھے: سنو یہ میرے نور نظر حسن اور حُسین امت کے ہاتھوں قتل کیے جائیں گے پر خدا ایک شخص کو پیدا کرے گا جو آپنی شمشیر آبدار سے ( قاتلان اہلبیت ) کو کیفر کردار تک پہنچا کردم لے گا وہ بنی ثقیف کا چشم و چراغ ہوگا اور اُس کا نام مختار ہوگا۔ “ نورالابصارص ۱۴ جلاءاالعیون ص ۲۲۷ بجارالانور ص۳۹۸ جلد ۱”
Ahmad Reza k یہ وہ بغرت ہیں جو آپنی امان کے قتل کا جشن مناتے ہیں
م جناب علی بن حسین بن علی بن ابی طالب سے متعلق ملتا ہے کہ وہ مختار پر لعنت بھیجتے تھے اور فرماتے تھے کہ اس نے ہم پر اور خدا پر بہتان باندھا ہے جو یہ کہتا ہے کہ اس پر وحی نازل ہوتی ہے۔ جناب جعفر صادق سے روایت ہے کہ سیدنا علیؓ اور حسن و حسینؓ روز قیامت جہنم کے کنارے تشریف لے جائینگے اور مختار کو جہنم میں دیکھیں گے۔ (رجال کشی تحت الترجمۃ مختار ثقفی)
Nadaan Dil
رجال کشی کوئی حدیث کی کتاب تو نہیں
Zaheer Abbass bhai such ye he ke mukhtar e saqafi kuch mutanaza shakhsiyat hain clear kehna mushkil hai
@@saeedmohammad7500 yay dekhna parega kay kon si riwayat sahi hn aur kon si zaeef hn phir faisla kiya ja sakta h
Shia sunni bhai bhai .......!
Final
Lakhun Slam Junab Mukhtar Saqwi Pr🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Allah pak ali bhai ko lambi umar or sahat wali zindgi day....amieen....👍🌹❣
Hazrat Ali A.s k Chahne wale pe jan Qurban hai!!
Mukhtar saqfi ❤️❤️❤️
HAZRAT ABU ISHAQ MUKHTIYAR BIN ABU UBAIDA SAQAFI
Hazrat Mukhtar al saqafi par laankho salaam❤️
سبحان الله حق بات پر اللہ کی رحمت ہو آپ پر ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mukhtar saqafi was a great aashiq e aale rasool
I love mukhtar saqafi
Mukhtar saqfi Jo bi thaa usne haq ki jung jeeti 🌹🌹salaam ho mukhtar saqfi per
Mukhtar saqfi ne mola imam Hussain ke katilo ka bdla
Hm muslalmano ke dil ko Rahat milti hai
ye log jalte hai janabe mukhtar se qatilane hussain a.s ko dhoond kar mara inlog ke ajdad ko
Labbaik ya hussain a.s
Labbaik ya mukhtar
Mukhtr is grate tabi
Salaam ho salaam ho lakho salaam mukhtar radiallahu ta ala par
Koi shuk nhi h ke hazrat mukhtar ne hum sb musalmano ke dilo ko boht sukun pohnchaya imam Hussain ke qatilon se bdla lekar magr fr baad Mei unhone bhi shahadat payi😭😭😭...shyd Allah ko yahi manzur tha ke wo bhi karbala walon Mei shamil hojaye
bilkul
Mukhtar zainda bad.yazeed ki owald per unlimited lanant
Mukhtar zindabad
Khuda ki kasam dor e hazir ja agar koi tasdeek shuda or ilam e islam ko theek tareeqy se amm awam tak ponchany wala insan agr koi hai to wo engineer ali mirza sahab hain, ALHAMDULILLA ab mera kisi b bidat phelany waly firky se koi talooq nahi, or mai barga e illahi mai yehi dua krta hun k mere pehly k gunaah maaf kry mera ALLAH ameen
I love Amir Mukhtar Sakfi
Dekho bhai in umar abo bkr usman ki koi qabr nhi magar mola ali ali the un ki nasl or olad pori duniya me zinda he or mavia lanti bhrriakoi nishan nhi kainat ki har she ne mola saeyadushuhada pe ghiria kia
kausar abbas oh jhaal insan fitna mat dal r shram kr jin ko to bura bol raha hai unk rozy Mubarik Nabi pak k kadmo pa hai r Nabi k kadmo pa wo he jta hai jisy Allah pak baje tm jaso ki oqat ni k unk rozy pa jao shram kro fitna ma dalo....
Back Benche tu jahil tera baap wo 3no rasool e khuda k phleo s gainb ho kr jahnum mai dafan ho gye .jis s bibi zehra sa naraz us khuda or rasool b naraaz .....
Binte saad
@@stayhappy8943 abe zahil agar vo galat hote to khalifa to hajarat ali.r.a.bhi bane the. Kya vo unki qabare dur nahi karvate ???
@@vahoraanisipca3c584Yani aap kehna chah rhe ho ke Imam Ali unki qabar ko khudwate aur kahin aur banwa dete. Ajeeb jahilana baat kardi. Baghair kisi ehm wajah ke qabar ko khodna khud qabar ki behurmati hai aur gunah hai. Tou aap chah rhe ho ke Imam Ali faltu main gunah karte
Mukhtar saqfi ek nek dil aur islam pe qurban hone wala aur qatilane husain ko mitti me milane wala h
Janab e Mukhtar Saqafi r.a k Baray mei ye Riwayat bhi hai k Jab Aap r.a Choty thy to Mola Ali a.s aap ko Apni Gaud mei Bitha kr Pyaar frmaya krty thy. 💖💖 Jis ne b (Nawuzubillah) Khudayi ya Nabuwat ka Ghuta dawa kia To Allah ne us ka Naam o Nishaan Mitta dia magar Janab e Mukhtar Saqafi r.a k HAQ pr hony keliye bas yahi Daleel Kafi hai k Aaj Muntaqeem e Aale Muhammad saww Ka Roza Iraq mei Bosa Gah e Aam o Khaas hain or wahan Azaan ki Awaaz Goonjati Hai.💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
Question ap lectures me bol chuke hn Abdullah bin umer ko umaiya wall ne shaheed krdiya th ye pls concept clear kr den
MashAllah LABIAK ya Hussain as
❤
MashaAllah molana sahab apne hmare hmra dill thanda krdeya mukhtar ki haqeqat bata kr
HAZRAT MUKHTAR.A.S....IS A GREAT leader Labaik ya mukhtar
Allah ki rehmat ho janab ameer mukhtar pe.
Mukhtar e thaqfi is real Hero of every Shia 😍😍😍
Isnai dawa e nabuwat bhi kia thaa
Mirza ghulam Ahmed qadiyani bhi tra hero hai right?
A
Mashallah.
I love you Ali bhai. 👍💐👍💐👍💐
Ali bhai.
Legta Hy sawal kerny waloon ko zeyada Islam ki malumat nahi Hy.
insha'Allah aesi baateen to ham ne apni buchpun me parhi hoi hy.aor ham per Allah paak ka Ahsan Hy.
Khuda aap ko salamat rakhy.ameen
Kya mujhe koi hazrat umar as ki movie ki link dega
Can anyone help me about Mukhtar nama urdu series story review??
Hazrat Mukhtar zinda bad I love u .waqi app muhib al rasool ka dil tanday key
Engineer Sahab inko ye b kehdo jinkay buzargon ko Ameer Mukhtar ne wasil e Jahanam kia tha unhon ne hi isko kazab likhwaya tha
Ameer Mukhtar ki fazeliyat toh khud Nabi kareem saww ne Batai thi
Us sab ka hawala b moujood hai
Baki jo aap hamaisha haqq ki baat karte hai uspe salam ❤️❤️ huge respect for uh
Ameer mukhtar saqafi ke darjat buland hon aamin
Jo bhi yha Hussain ❤️ ka zawar bn gya Hur bn gya koi koi Mukhtaar bn gya
Hazrat Janab.e.Ameer Mukhtar Saqfi Zindabad..💕
wah kahan tah itna piyara insan ALLAH LAMBI ZINDAGI ATA FARMAYA MUHAMMAD ALI MIRZA SAHAB KO
Thanks Ali bhai effort for Islam.
Salam hu ya amir Mukhtar per
For blind followers
Or Mirza ky leye
References
1. Sahi Muslim Shara (Imam Nawawi RA vol 7 page 176
2 .Sun Qubra Al Behke vol 3 173
3. Kitab-ul-Salat Hadees no 5301
4. Tabaqat al mudaleseen page no 55
5. Fatawa Ilmiya Vol 2 page no 149
6. Tareekh Ibn Kaseer Vol 8 page no 1262-1266. Mukhtar Thaqafi Detail Halat
7. Jilal ul Ayoon (Shia Alim Mulla Bakir Majlasi) Page 286
8. Tafseer Ibn Kaseer Vol 2 page 108
9. Tafseer-e-Qurtabi Vol 4 page 104
10. Musnad Ahmad vol 2 page 22 Hadees 1909 Hazart Ibn Abbas RA
11. Musnad Ahmad Vol 10 page 319 Hadees 22293
12. Al Mujam Al-Kabir Vol 3 page 323, 324 Hadees 4984
13. Kitab-ul-Siqqat Vol 4 page 386 Sister Mukhtar Thaqafi Dawa Nabuwat ( ManQan tu Mola Ali RA ky Ravi)
14. Tareekh Ibn Kaseer Vol 8 page 1262-1265 Detail
Al Isaba Fi Tamyiz Sahaba Vol 6
15. Jilal-ul-Ayoon Vol 2 page 291 (Shia Alim) Imam Zain-ul-Abideen (RA) About Mukhtar Thaqafi dawa Nabuwat.
Tabari, in vol.2, p.503 has recorded the story from Abdul Rahman Bin Abu Bakr as follows:
"When Khalid's army reached Botah, he sent a group of soldiers, under the command of Zerar Bin Azwar, to attack Malik's tribe overnight. Abu Qatada, a member of that army said later, ‘When we took Malik's tribe by surprise overnight we frightened them. They put their amour on hurriedly, and declared that they were Muslims. Our commander asked them why they were armed, and they asked him the same question. We asked them to put down their arms, if they were Muslims, and they did so. We then said our prayers, and they did likewise."
Ibn Abilhadid in his book says, "When they relinquished their arms, the soldiers handcuffed them, and took them to Khalid."
In Kanzul Ommal, vol.3, p.132 and in Ya‘qoubi, vol.2, p.110, the above story is recorded as follows: "Malik Bin Nowaira with his wife came to Khalid. Khalid on seeing the lady fell in love with her, and said to her husband, ‘You shall never return home, by God, I will kill you."
In Kanzul Ommal, vol.3, p.132, is written that Khalid accused Malik of heresy, which Malik denied and both Abdullah Bin ‘Omar and Abu Qatada interposed on his be- half. But Khalid ordered Zerar Bin Azwar to behead him. Then Khalid took his wife Umm Tamim and slept with her.
In Abdulfada, page 158 and in Alwafayat it is recorded Abdullah Bin ‘Omar talked unsuccessfully to Khalid concerning Malik, and Malik pleaded to be sent to Abu Bakr for his decision. Khalid said, "God will not forgive me, if I forgive you," and he ordered Zerar to behead him. Malik looked at his wife saying, "You are the cause of my being killed." Khalid said, "God has caused your death because of your heresy." Malik said, "By God I am a Muslim and my faith is Islam." But Khalid ordered Zerar to behead him.
It is recorded in al-Esaba, vol.3, p.337 that Thabet Bin Qasim has written in al-Dalael that Khalid fell in love with Malik's wife at first sight, as she was very beautiful. Malik said to his wife, "You have killed me."
It is also written in al-Esaba that Zubair Bin Bakkar recorded from Bin Shahab that Khalid ordered Malik's head to be used as fuel for the cooking fire. But before the fire reached the skin of Malik's head, the food was cooked, Malik had abundant hair. Khalid, that very night, married the wife of the murdered Malik.
Tabari has recorded from Ibn Abibakr that Khalid made an excuse to Abu Bakr saying that Malik had said to him, "I do not think that your companion (The Prophet) has said this and that." Khalid had replied, "Was not he (The Prophet) your companion?" and he had ordered him to be beheaded and all the men who were with Malik, to be beheaded also.
When the news came to ‘Omar he discussed it with Abu Bakr saying, "The enemy of God has killed a Muslim and, like and animal, has immediately molested his wife."
Khalid returned home, then went to the Mosque wearing a robe marked with rust from his armor, and a feather in his helmet like a Muslim soldier. He passed ‘Omar who furiously rushed at him, pulling the feather from his helmet saying, "Like a hypocrite you have killed a Muslim, and like an animal rushed at his wife, by God I will stone you to death. That is what you deserve."
Khalid kept quite thinking that Caliph Abu Bakr would also say that he was guilty. But when Khalid reported his successful expedition and confessed his mistake, Abu Bakr forgave him. On his 'way back from seeing the Caliph, Khalid passed ‘Omar again and shouted at him. " O son of Umm Shamlah - now tell me that which you wanted to say." ‘Omar understood that Abu Bakr had forgiven Khalid, and he left the Mosque and went home quietly.
This is the end of Khalid and Malik's story according to authentic sources. But Saif has told that story in seven events, each one complementary to the other, and Tabari has recorded it with the events of the year eleven Hijri as follows:-
Abu Namir Sa‘di has composed the following poems:- Do the horsemen who attacked us at night, know that we will never see the morning bright? Khalid had to get rid of Malik obviously, To possess the woman whom he loved previously, Khalid had not the will power to shun his desires, And to avoid the sin, he had not the piety required. In the morning of the night that poor husband vanished, his wife in Khalid's hand.
It is written in Esaba that Minhal saw the headless corpse of Malik and covered it.
That was the story of Malik. Let us now find out what was the reactions of the government towards its General.
Ya‘qoubi has recorded that Abu Qatada reported the event to the Caliph Abu Bakr and said, “By God I will never go anywhere under Khalid's command. He has killed Malik, although he was a Muslim.”
Tabari recorded from Ibn Abibakr that Abu Qatada swore that he would never fight under Khalid. Yaqubi has recorded that ‘Omar Bin Khattab said to Abu Bakr, “ O successor of the Prophet of God, Khalid fell in love with Malik's wife, and on the same day killed Malik who was a Muslim." Abu Bakr wrote to Khalid for an explanation, and Khalid came to Abu Bakr saying, “ O successor of the Prophet of God, in killing Malik I made a rightful decision, but I also made a mistake."
Motammim Bin Nowaira, brother of Malik, composed a number of poems lamenting the murder of his brother. He went to Medina and joined in the congregational prayers lead by Abu Bakr. After the prayer Motammim leaned back on his bow, and addressing Abu Bakr he recited:-
O Bin Azwar, you threw the body of a noble man on the floor, Whilst the gentle morning breeze was caressing our door. You deceived him using the name of the Almighty God.
But faithful Malik had always honored his word. Abulfada has recorded that when the news of Malik reached Abu Bakr and ‘Omar, ‘Omar said to Abu Bakr, "Khalid has undoubtedly committed adultery; you should have him stoned." Abu Bakr replied, "I will not do that." ‘Omar then said that Khalid had murdered a Muslim, and therefore should be sentenced to death. Abu Bakr said that Khalid had carried out his duties and he understood them - but he had also made a mistake. ‘Omar asked Abu Bakr to dismiss Khalid. But Abu Bakr said, "I will never sheath the sword which God has taken from its scabbard."
Tabari has recorded from Ibn Abibakr that Khalid made an excuse to Abu Bakr saying that Malik had said to him, "I do not think that your companion (The Prophet) has said this and that." Khalid had replied, "Was not he (The Prophet) your companion?" and he had ordered him to be beheaded and all the men who were with Malik, to be beheaded also.
When the news came to ‘Omar he discussed it with Abu Bakr saying, "The enemy of God has killed a Muslim and, like and animal, has immediately molested his wife."
Khalid returned home, then went to the Mosque wearing a robe marked with rust from his armor, and a feather in his helmet like a Muslim soldier. He passed ‘Omar who furiously rushed at him, pulling the feather from his helmet saying, "Like a hypocrite you have killed a Muslim, and like an animal rushed at his wife, by God I will stone you to death. That is what you deserve."
Khalid kept quite thinking that Caliph Abu Bakr would also say that he was guilty. But when Khalid reported his successful expedition and confessed his mistake, Abu Bakr forgave him. On his 'way back from seeing the Caliph, Khalid passed ‘Omar again and shouted at him. " O son of Umm Shamlah - now tell me that which you wanted to say." ‘Omar understood that Abu Bakr had forgiven Khalid, and he left the Mosque and went home quietly.
This is the end of Khalid and Malik's story according to authentic sources.
ab bolo beta tariqh tabari ke anusar tu abke khalid bin waleed rapist nikle.
aur jin kitabun ke apne hawale diye hain uper phir unme apke sahaba ke bare me aise aise batein likhein hai phir wo bhe mano na.
baqir majlis ne tu behrul anwar me tareef bhe kiwi hai ab bol .
istarah tu phir apke sahih bhukari me. umer ka hazrat fatima(sa) ke ghar jalane ka pura waqiya hai wo bhejun phir mein
Hazrat mukhtar jaise log real shia the ...maula hme mukhatar jaisa takwa or parhezgaari ata kare...
Tirmizi 2220
عبداللہ بن عمر رضی الله عنہما کہتے ہیں کہ رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: ”بنو ثقیف میں ایک جھوٹا اور ہلاک کرنے والا ہو گا“۔ امام ترمذی کہتے ہیں: کہا جاتا ہے کذاب اور جھوٹے سے مراد مختار بن ابی عبید ثقفی اور ہلاک کرنے والا سے مراد حجاج بن یوسف ہے ۱؎۔
Mukhtar Al saqafi the real hero of Muslims . He was the one to take revenge of imam hussain a.s
Momneen ka peer hai Mukhtar saqfi a.s jis ne main QURBAN jaon Ameer Mukhtar a.s pr mola ke har dushmano ko Chun Chun kr Jahanum raseed kia ❤
Is Abu obaidah ibn jarrah and abu obaida saqafi alaimosalam
The same?
Subhan Allah
علی بھائی ماشااللہ بہت خوب۔ علی بھائی جب امام زین العابدین نے کہ دیا کہ مختار نے ہمارے دل ٹھنڈے کر دے تو پھر اس ہستی پہ تنقید کرنے کا کیا سوال بنتا ھے۔ ھم تو سلام پیش کرتے ہیں مختار ثقفی کی شجائت پہ
ALLAH ap ko salamat rakeh ur ap ko hamesha sach bolney ki tofeeq ur marfatey al e rasool inayat frmaey.... JAZAKALLAH ALLAH ap ky dil ko AL-RASOOL ki marfat sy bhr dy ta k ap hr baat sach keh sakain...
Mukhtar Saqfi.... Aik bahadur sahabi.... Salam ho ap per
aapne konsi siart ka name diya jisme hathi ke niche kuchl kar shid krdiya
Umar series
مختار ثقفی کے خلاف وہ لوگ ھے جس کے اباواجداد کو اس مجاھد حسینی نے کیفر کردار تک پھنچایا تھا۔سلام ھو مختار پر
Ameer Mukhtar is a real hero and role model for shia muslims we love ameer Mukhtar who was true shia of imam Ali A.S
Always say his name with respect never disrespect the man mukhtar he is the one who took revenge of imam hussain as
Mery dil k bohot Qareeb hain janab e HAZRAT MUKHTAR E SAQAFI . HE was a LION . Massab bin zubai tjh py lanat hu jo tuny un k hath kat kay keelon sy shehr k darvazy py lga diye.O hathiyoon ko ghirany waly SHAIR k BAITY AP py ALLAH ki rehmat ho.😭😭
Salam ho mukhtar ko Aapne Hussain ka badlalya khuda Aap vala kre
Muktar mera hero took a revenge of moulas enemy's may God bless him heaven. I see he may be sitting near the feet of mera moula ali (s a )