Uncle gianni tampak sangat hati2 sekali dlm berbicara krn beliau bukan sedang membandingkan, karena keduanya istimewa 👍, Tapi kalo boleh lebih jauh menangkap pesannya, bahwa bermusic adlh menyampaikan pesan jd tak hanya skill dan perfomance tapi lebih dari semua itu, yaitu harus ada ketulusan dan kedalaman rasa 💗
Lihat senyum nya aja bro.......dia menikmati dan penuh senyum saat Ali ba ta memainkan nya......dan dia tahu mengapa Ali ba ta menyanyikan lagu tersebut......karena ada pesan dari lagu itu , bukan hanya keahlian jungkir balik tapi isi dan petikan gitar menyatu dalam hati dan jiwa, jauh lebih penting dari sekedar keahlian pertunjukan musik
Saya setuju karena memang merupakan dua hal yang berbeda dan Uncle Gianini sebagai orang yg sudah malang melintang di dunia musik tentu punya sudut pandang yg berbeda beliau sudah di next level,
harus ada jiwa rasa dan nyawa yang harus di letakkan pada suatu karya music.Music itu akan lebih berharga bukan sekadar hanya skill dan perfomance tetapi skill jiwa rasa dan nyawa. skill itu ada pada bang Alip
Memang betul dalam bermain gitar bukan cuman tehnik saja, tapi bagaimana mengaplikasikan sebuah lagu menjadi hiburan/tontonan yg enak dinikmati. Karena di situ kah seorang entertain bisa menghibur penonton & penonton pun menikmati alunan musik tsb shg bisa terhanyut oleh alunan musik tsb...God Bless You Uncle🙏🙏🤩😍😍🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
Kedua² nya orang hebat yang mempunyai skill dan bakat. tinggal kita yg menilai dari sudut pandang masing² tapi menurut aku alip lebih dapat diterima karna dapat memberikan efek relex..thanks uncle..
Saya jelas mendapatkan PESAN yang disampaikan oleh Alip bata terhadap lagu aslinya paman Gianni ... Penjelasan paman sangat berarti bagi saya betapa indahnya mendapatkan pesan lagu yg mempunyai jiwa dan seni. 👍👍
Mas Alif bermain dengan hati dan perasaan , mas Alif masuk ke dalam lagu dan music nya , kalau Marcin karena masih muda , maka lebih banyak energi yang keluar untuk bermusik , tidak semua cocok dengan Marcin , tapi Mas Alif bisa cocok untuk siapa saja .. 👍
Tankyou n Gracias to uncle Gianni Bravo Ska sooo muccch...again to reaction very different an other...we love alip-bata n you...for the universal music..enjoyed you life ..still health n Good bless you .uncle Bravooooooo.....
You have a very legitimate opinion/position around the music and what you like. Both are exceptional. Like you say, Marcin is a Virtuoso. In this video, he was really young, 16. I think that he overdid it. He was young and discovering. Already he showed genius in arrangements. I don't know of other teens that can make such full music on a single acoustic instrument. I am much more attracted to his arrangements than his virtuosity. I'm mindblown by his arrangements, the way he transforms a song to make it entirely his own by injecting his craziness. It's the first time I see Alip Bata. His music was really soothing and beautiful. I actually found his version more enjoyable than Marcin's. I'll go check out more of his performances. Thanks!
Old habits die hard, no doubt marcin was young when he played this but in my opinion he still overdid things whenever he plays. I think alip could do whatever marcin is doing but i dont think marcin would be able to do likewise.
@@abdullahjaffar5939 It's not even a question. Alip is better at percussion than Marcin. Alip is better at tapping and fast harmonics. Alip's composition and arrangements are more complicated. Marcin can't play at Alip's speed. Alip is also much younger than Marcin, so he can improve.
@@marekgieniec3253 alip bata its more like skill full harmonic and chill play, the technique its not that hard but the creative is just awesome Same like marcin i just watch his paganini caprice no 5 and it was so awesome all the beat and stuff and the picking style rasgueado he add is just so match with the classical music paganini i love it
Uncle Gianni Bravo ska ,terima kasih dengan sangat bijak dan berhati hati dengan tidak menyinggung satu sama lain nya dalam mengurai perbandingan musik mas Alip dengan yg lain ,..luar biasa unle Gianni ,..mantap ,..Bravo Alipers,..ska .
This guy, Marcin, is just amazing. His arrangements and his perfect performance with all the sentiments him put in every song he plays just amaze me. You can feel his sentiment when he plays. And don't forget that music can be expressed with just the instrument and you can understand the mining. Yes the sing part must exist but in the original one. So you are telling me that you don't lessen to classical or instrumental music? This guy is special, him understand the music in a such beautiful way and i believe that in the future him will create great pieces
Marcin is an excellent guitarist for sure. in this case perhaps his young age made him forget that some songs have the same importance in words as music. ciao
two differents way to play the same notes. two opportunities to listen depent how you feel. Marcin is one of the best actor I have seen, because he plays the guitar, and in the same time make you feel his heart beating as your do just looking at him. He makes love to you with his body, while making his guitar vibrate full of love.
think what uncle Gianni said is even you had so much talented skill of guitar like Marcin but there is no soul in what his song..I think playing guitar even though it is fingerstyle..the guitarist have to put their soul in their guitar and not just good sound and skill..but Alip Ba Ta had it all..good sound..skill and most of all his soul when he playing his guitar that makes the song his own song..
I just realised that Alip is more than talented guitarist. He is an artist. He sent us messages with his music. In his original music, he just say us to keep on spirit in Kopi Pagi, he just say us to be patient in a gloomy pandemic on Pagebluk, and what a culture in Balinesse. Both talented guitarist. One for show. One send us messages. Gracias uncle.
Punya cara dan keahlian ciri masing2 yg berbeda beda diatas langit ada langit , seni itu indah dan keunggulan Alip bata punya cara penyampaian seni yg menyentuh di hati para pendengarnya ...itulah seni yg sesungguhnya
Alip and andrea mempunyai kesamaan dalam music, mereka mempunyai rasa dalam bermusik ini yang membuat kita ga pernah bosan dengarnya, marcin gitaris yang hebat dan atraktif. But music about soul and pure not only skill Bravo uncle gianni and andrea stay save
Both are great guitarists and very talented, nothing to compare. Each has its own characteristics, if you want to hear a more gloomy interpretation, then listen to Alip, but if you want to see an attractive show then Marcin can be an option. Because for me, music is something to listen to, and should be able to touch my soul, without talking skill, technique and other things. Alip and Naudo are two guitar instrumentalists that are my favorites, because they can make music that I can enjoy and touch my heart.
Agree bro. Marcin is great & talented. Marcin is attractive guitarist. Alip is great too. Alip play guitar with soul. I like both of them gives difference atmosphere. Nando is good too. He's play accustic guitar with soul too.
For me as alip fans... we should get the credit to marcin, he is very younger, he always have great performances... full skill and technic... not everyone can do that things hhe... just amazing but once again everyone have their favour of type music including in acoustic guitar... plus point alip in here... he is just bring in easy way to listening like you already mention it with his soul... and always send the original message of this song even if he took in diffrent way... in this case not to apple to apple... probably... for me like as you say uncle... music is "simple" By the way... huge respect uncle for uploading this video... hhe...
@@GianniBravoSka Wew thanks for always... repeat almost all the comment... may i ask one favour uncle... i have one suggestion of one cover alip song it call "Gerimis mengundang - slam" as far as i know... that song it's one of his first song which he first learned how he start to play guitar... probably he should did everything to do a justice to cover this song... Any way thank... before uncle if you fullfill my wish for the future... hhe... It means a lot for me hhe...
Cao Uncle..Alip Ba Ta and Mancin..they are both very amazing.. have their own character.. Alip ba ta is Soft and Mancin is fierce.. salute.. 🙏🙏❤️❤️🇲🇨🇲🇨❤️🇮🇹🇮🇹
Thanks for reaction Uncle Gianni...both of them are brilliant they have different style. Alip is always playing with the heart compare with the others. Keep healthy Uncle...
Both are talented and gifted players. However, Marcin draws me in more. His facial expressions, the way he uses & moves his body….it looks like the guitar is an extension of himself and he plays with such passion. The way he arranges music, the way he plays and the fact that he is only 21 (and much younger in many of his videos….I think 16 in this video) is just mind blowing to me. Alip is wonderful too. His style seems calming & soothing and makes me feel relaxed. Marcin makes me feel alert & alive. Both are great at their own style and I hope they both continue to make and play amazing music!
yes i'm with you, but, Toxicity without words is returned to us in half, choosing it becomes pure exercise in style. this is my thought, thank you ciao
To be honest, you can found many better acoustic musician than Marcin, since he is not the first one who used that technique. I even seen street musician plays better than Marcin. But yet, you'll never seen anyone plays like Alip Ba Ta.
@@mikhail2446 so u mean anyone on the street can fking play paganini caprice no 5 like marcin did? Didnt think so Just dont be so overproud with ur idol talent just because he is from Indonesia then u became overproud I've seen all talents not just on guitar but also on piano and stuff Back then i thought lang lang was the best pianist ever but now im wrong Each person has their own style for example marcin his playing is so on fire In the other side alip bata his playing more like calmful harmonic and stuff
@@MarioJeconiah not like Marcin, but BETTER than Marcin, like I've said. I seen several times in the street with my own eyes, so I don't have to make you believe me (btw I also a musician, I played toxicity thousand times on the stages when I was teenager, so pls don't teach me how to understand music). Also, it's not my fault if you never seen any better street musician than Marcin. One thing you should understand, there's always many great people above great people. Marcin is good, but not the best, still many people above him.
think what uncle Gianni said is even you had so much talented skill of guitar like Marcin but there is no soul in what his song..I think playing guitar even though it is fingerstyle..the guitarist have to put their soul in their guitar and not just good sound and skill..but Alip Ba Ta had it all..good sound..skill and most of all his soul when he playing his guitar that makes the song his own song..
So spot on what you said, papa Gianni. True, both are very skilled on their technic, a virtuoso. Marcin was so very young when interpretating this song, a masterful play, energetic. Alip Ba Ta is on another level. Through Alip we got the message of toxicity, it was a grandeur interpretation, so magical when listening to Alip's version, brought smile to us.
Spot on! The real question is, what makes an artist to be a star? It's not just a talent alone, you need to have a lot more than that to be a star. A lot of talented musicians stuck in their careers because they have no more than their talents alone..
Marcin Patrzałek is already and will always be admired as a phenomenon, as the greatest contemporary virtuoso, such as Paganini, Bethoven, and Chopin. There are tens of thousands of average musicians like Alip Bata. In a dozen or so years, everyone will forget about Alipbata.
Marcin is certainly a virtuoso guitarist, with a great talent. Comparing it to the names you mentioned is absurd. Alip Ba ta is a great artist with a great soul. Time will tell.
@@GianniBravoSka Marcin's brilliant songs are listened to many times and they do not get bored. Alipbata's music is played once, the same cannot be listened to the second time. In fact, even once listening to Alipbata's music is boring.
Uncle Gianni Bravo we are so grateful because you are attentive and concerned to Mas Alip Ba Ta. You are wise when giving reactions. Even when you ve to compare among other guitarists. Anyhow you are straightforward reacting the artists. Thank you Uncle Gianni Bravo.
Both players amazing...👍👍 Both musician are wow...Alif wow to listen and Marcin wow to see...🤩 Alif is clasic dancer and Marcin modern dancer....🤩 Bravo for both...and bravo uncle Giani...🤩
Alicja Bata ładnie gra tak jak wiele innych osób,a ja uwielbiam dynamiczną grę Marcina ,połączoną z jego wielką pasją,talentem i inteligencją.To są dla mnie niesamowite odczucia kiedy słucham jego gry,ile on wkłada w to serca.❤❤
Alip is a magical artist and musician, plays his guitar like a person dancing in meditation, the most prominent technique is in his artificial harmonics, the tone, soul and soothing sound makes you relax like coming from another dimension similar to Oxytron in music healing. 👍👏
@@MrPIEKNYPANin my opinion marcin interpretes the song with anger/madness while alip interpretes with sadness so, it's up to the audience which prefer to be liked.
@@GianniBravoSka Feelings of soul is subjective. He is talking about skills and techniques, (more objective..clearly you can see what takes more work and talent) and you are talking about souls. People have different tastes, although the majority may like certain styles or genres.
Ingat bro ,Alip itu belajar gitar secara otodidak,tidak sekolah musik,sedangkan marcin anda tau sendiri dia murid terbaik di kelasnya,jadi bisa bermain gitar secara otodidak seperti mas alipbata bukankah itu luar biasa,bakat murni yg di berikan tuhan kepadanya, sehingga menjadi virtuoso seperti sekarang ini,mungkin itulah yg membuatnya memiliki penggemar yg fanatik terhadap permainan gitarnya bro,salam alipers ❤️👍
We don't just talk about the skill but the art of music and song... we have to enjoy the music, song and some times the lyric of the song... Thank you uncle Gianni for the good reaction 🙏🙏🙏
To be honest, music is not only about skill and technique, but more about spirit, soul, heart and feeling. They are both great musicians. Greetings from Indonesia and stay healhty uncle Giani 🙏🙏
Byuh byuh mantap uncle.. very nice view.. thanks 👍❤️😘🇮🇩 Almost same with me, as a metalhead, in this case.. sure, both guitarist have great tecnique in playing guitar.. but Alip has more ability to transfer the soul of the song, and for me, this is the most important part in playing an instrument
salam hormat uncle Gianni. tanpa memandang sentimen nasionalisme, tapi bagi saya pribadi "skill" adalah sesuatu dan "soul" adalah sesuatu di atasnya. skill digunakan untuk menghasilkan musik yang lebih memiliki jiwa (dalam hal ini adalah gitar). saya selalu menghormati mereka yang memiliki skill hebat dalam bermusik tetapi selalu rasa saya lebih terpuaskan oleh musik yang memiliki jiwa
Alip ba ta and marcin are both good at playing guitar and they have their own way of covering a song, each has a musical soul and has a unique way of playing guitar, this is a development in guitar playing and will continue to grow over time
Yeah...we are witnessing people who are given advantages by God, all people with special advantages and so are others, that's the greatness of God, thank you uncle you are so wise 🙏🙏🙏🙏
They're both great! You can't compare those two. They both bring something else to the table. That is the beauty of art. There is something for everyone!
I agree, Uncle Gianni Bravo...! music can be enjoyed according to the situation and conditions..where people can enjoy the art. Alip and Marcin are equally talented...👍👍☕🇮🇩
I'm a bit rusty, but with a little effort I can play like Alip (and I'm sure many other does it already). On the other side, I must reincarnate several times in order to be able not to play, but to try to play like Marcin does. We have to admit it: Marcin is a phenomenon, he's one of that people who are only born once in a thousand years.
@@GianniBravoSka, I'm not saying he's not good, but I see him like an ordinary guitar player, nothing special. He's not gifted...that's all! That's just my humble opinion.
@@GianniBravoSka What he said has nothing to do with whether he didn't get what you said or not. It's easier for Marcin to play like Alip, than Alip to play like Marcin. I enjoy more listening to the music that Alip makes than most of the music Marcin makes. However, as much as I listen to Alip more, I acknowledge Marcin as a much better skillful technical guitarist. I would also put skills, techniques, and creativity above preference, taste, and soul, which are subjective. And the video you react is old. Marcin is only 21 years old now.
@@escuadrian2011 Alip makes music that many people like (covers especially), whereas people like Marcin, Luca, Misko and some others prefer to make their own, which is not in the liking of many people in general. Alip also has strong fanbase who will appreciate reactors if they make reactions of him. People confuse favorite as best or better. That's what I think, and I agree with what you said.
@@gratefulyes6282Given that art and technique do not always coincide. I am convinced of Marcin's great talent. I used Toxicity in particular to express a concept that I think is important. When you decide to do a cover you have to respect the artist. There are songs where words are as important as music. Forgetting it does not do justice to the artist of reference. Maybe too young to understand it.
Bagiku skill tinggi ialah dia bs menempatkan sesatu pada tempatnya dan penempatan penempatan itu menjadikan suguhan indah yg musah di fahami mudah dinikmati,saya setuju dg bapa ini,alip tahu kebutuhan jiwa manusia,makanya dia buatlah aransemen cover seperti itu!menurut ku itu bukan hanya skill bermain tinggi tp jg skill kejeniusan dalam bermusik bg ku itulah mas alips,kenapa jelas musik sod itu di buat sedemikian rupa sampai menjadi indah bahkan menurut selera saya itu lbh bs dinikmati secara umum,dan aransement bukan kaleng2 dan dg penunjukan sedikit skill tp pada inti,menurut ku dividio ini mas alip menyampaikam bahwa aku disini menyelipkan skill ku sedikit dn sedemikian rupa tp aku tunjukan tentang sesuatu kejeniusan skill dalam bermusik maka jadilah aransement ini dengan penunjukan skill yg indah dan berbobot
As a music lover, I don't care what kind of music it is, the important thing is to relax and be calm and easy to understand. Complicated or not a piece of music, when we hear it for the first time we will know what song is being played... Many musicians play various types of songs without vocals, but when we play it we don't know what song it is because it is much different from the original song and only briefly just bored.. good music will make us listen to it over and over again because its beauty is heard in the ears, hearts and minds... LOVE 4 UNCLE....🙏
Marcin & Alip are both very talented guitarists. Their techniques maybe at the same level. But, I completely agree with Uncle Gianni, Marcin send great sounds to our ears, while Alip send messages to our hearts. That's the difference between the two of them. Thumbs up for the two virtuosoes 👍 👍 Thank you Uncle Gianni. Stay safe 🙏
alip has always appreciated the guitar according to its nature. It's weird if the guitar is forced to make percussion sounds to the limit. What matters is how to convert the song to guitar playing, not imitating the original sound of the song
Marcin believes that the guitar is not only about taut strings. Therefore the whole instrument of the guitar should be used. so is the house - if someone lives in the house, no one uses only the room, but all the rooms that the house offers - kitchen, bathroom and room
Mksd uncle itu adlh kemampuan mngubah mngaransemen dn mnjadi baru lbh hidup dn tetap pd originalnya adlh kemampuan seniman sesungguhnya..brmaen cepat dn teknik bnyak tp kemampuan utk mnciptakan dn mmbuat perbedaan adalah virtuoso ssugguhnya apa lg mmpu mengiringi lagu aslinya .
both are very talented, regardless of likes and dislikes or taste and perspective of mudic. They have abilities that complement each other in music trend in this digital era. Salute 👍🏾 Happy healthy wealthy, Gianni 🙏🏾
Uncle gianni tampak sangat hati2 sekali dlm berbicara krn beliau bukan sedang membandingkan, karena keduanya istimewa 👍, Tapi kalo boleh lebih jauh menangkap pesannya, bahwa bermusic adlh menyampaikan pesan jd tak hanya skill dan perfomance tapi lebih dari semua itu, yaitu harus ada ketulusan dan kedalaman rasa 💗
Top komentar
Pas banget dengan pemikiranku
Lihat senyum nya aja bro.......dia menikmati dan penuh senyum saat Ali ba ta memainkan nya......dan dia tahu mengapa Ali ba ta menyanyikan lagu tersebut......karena ada pesan dari lagu itu , bukan hanya keahlian jungkir balik tapi isi dan petikan gitar menyatu dalam hati dan jiwa, jauh lebih penting dari sekedar keahlian pertunjukan musik
Saya setuju karena memang merupakan dua hal yang berbeda dan Uncle Gianini sebagai orang yg sudah malang melintang di dunia musik tentu punya sudut pandang yg berbeda beliau sudah di next level,
harus ada jiwa rasa dan nyawa yang harus di letakkan pada suatu karya music.Music itu akan lebih berharga bukan sekadar hanya skill dan perfomance tetapi skill jiwa rasa dan nyawa. skill itu ada pada bang Alip
That's right. 👍
Its not only about the skill ya uncle.. But as you said Pure and heart
Thank you uncle
Bener! 👍👍👍
Ciao vicky, grazie
Artine opo mas vicky...
agree 👍👍kak @vicky himpong
ora mudeng aq himpong...
ngisore di kei traslite lah bro..
mumet mocone....
I love Marcin Patrzalek...
I love Alip Ba Ta...
..............in different ways..😍❤️🤗
Thanks Gianni Bravo Ska for sharply soft reaction..🙏🙏🙏
Grazie, ciao
Yes..in different ways..
Love marcin
Love alip bata
Semua baguss..
Forza Inter😁 from indonesia
Memang betul dalam bermain gitar bukan cuman tehnik saja, tapi bagaimana mengaplikasikan sebuah lagu menjadi hiburan/tontonan yg enak dinikmati. Karena di situ kah seorang entertain bisa menghibur penonton & penonton pun menikmati alunan musik tsb shg bisa terhanyut oleh alunan musik tsb...God Bless You Uncle🙏🙏🤩😍😍🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
It's Marcin for me👍❤
Kedua² nya orang hebat yang mempunyai skill dan bakat. tinggal kita yg menilai dari sudut pandang masing² tapi menurut aku alip lebih dapat diterima karna dapat memberikan efek relex..thanks uncle..
Suara gitar Alibata memiliki rasa dan jiwa...yang dapat memberi ketenangan dan rasa damai...🙏🤗👍❤🇮🇩
Sama2 enak musiknya...
Alip sebagai pengantar tidur dan Marcin untuk membangunkan tidur. 😀😃
Nice, ciao
@@GianniBravoSka mantap 👍😃
Marcin musiknya cocok buat begadang😀klu musik mas alip mantap buat direnungkan sampai tertidur
@@botakubota1521 👍😃
Saya jelas mendapatkan PESAN yang disampaikan oleh Alip bata terhadap lagu aslinya paman Gianni ... Penjelasan paman sangat berarti bagi saya betapa indahnya mendapatkan pesan lagu yg mempunyai jiwa dan seni. 👍👍
OKE master gohet yg penting minum kopi sambil koreksi.alip bata oke.tks
Ini baik saja, ciao
Mas Alif bermain dengan hati dan perasaan , mas Alif masuk ke dalam lagu dan music nya , kalau Marcin karena masih muda , maka lebih banyak energi yang keluar untuk bermusik , tidak semua cocok dengan Marcin , tapi Mas Alif bisa cocok untuk siapa saja .. 👍
Terimakasih telah menyatukan,dua karekter musik yang beda tapi satu tujuan,menuju kekeindahan dalam pemersatu.MANTAP.❤
Marcin is the best. Incredible musical talent. Thank you for your comment. Greetings from Poland 👏🎸
Tankyou n Gracias to uncle Gianni Bravo Ska sooo muccch...again to reaction very different an other...we love alip-bata n you...for the universal music..enjoyed you life ..still health n Good bless you .uncle Bravooooooo.....
You have a very legitimate opinion/position around the music and what you like. Both are exceptional. Like you say, Marcin is a Virtuoso. In this video, he was really young, 16. I think that he overdid it. He was young and discovering. Already he showed genius in arrangements. I don't know of other teens that can make such full music on a single acoustic instrument. I am much more attracted to his arrangements than his virtuosity. I'm mindblown by his arrangements, the way he transforms a song to make it entirely his own by injecting his craziness.
It's the first time I see Alip Bata. His music was really soothing and beautiful. I actually found his version more enjoyable than Marcin's. I'll go check out more of his performances.
Thanks!
Grazie a te, ciao
you will amazed as we amazed
Old habits die hard, no doubt marcin was young when he played this but in my opinion he still overdid things whenever he plays. I think alip could do whatever marcin is doing but i dont think marcin would be able to do likewise.
@@abdullahjaffar5939
It's not even a question.
Alip is better at percussion than Marcin.
Alip is better at tapping and fast harmonics. Alip's composition and arrangements are more complicated.
Marcin can't play at Alip's speed. Alip is also much younger than Marcin, so he can improve.
@@gratefulyes6282 another troll without ears, eyes & brain - alip is perfect but overrated , Marcin is a genius
Marcin: expressive n energetic
Alif: calm n soulful
Both skillful.
Marcin: expessive and energetic
Alif: boring, didnt bring anything new to the song
@@marekgieniec3253 alip bata its more like skill full harmonic and chill play, the technique its not that hard but the creative is just awesome
Same like marcin i just watch his paganini caprice no 5 and it was so awesome all the beat and stuff and the picking style rasgueado he add is just so match with the classical music paganini i love it
I agre Uncle Gianni...the music is not only to play instrumen but also soul and heart...
Sederhana, mdh dmngerti, jg brsaja, wow...
Uncle Gianni Bravo ska ,terima kasih dengan sangat bijak dan berhati hati dengan tidak menyinggung satu sama lain nya dalam mengurai perbandingan musik mas Alip dengan yg lain ,..luar biasa unle Gianni ,..mantap ,..Bravo Alipers,..ska .
Many great guitarists.Alif...Different from the others... Alif bata is an art. The soul.. flows naturally
This guy, Marcin, is just amazing. His arrangements and his perfect performance with all the sentiments him put in every song he plays just amaze me. You can feel his sentiment when he plays. And don't forget that music can be expressed with just the instrument and you can understand the mining.
Yes the sing part must exist but in the original one.
So you are telling me that you don't lessen to classical or instrumental music?
This guy is special, him understand the music in a such beautiful way and i believe that in the future him will create great pieces
Marcin is an excellent guitarist for sure. in this case perhaps his young age made him forget that some songs have the same importance in words as music. ciao
two differents way to play the same notes.
two opportunities to listen depent how you feel.
Marcin is one of the best actor I have seen, because he plays the guitar, and in the same time make you feel his heart beating as your do just looking at him. He makes love to you with his body, while making his guitar vibrate full of love.
think what uncle Gianni said is even you had so much talented skill of guitar like Marcin but there is no soul in what his song..I think playing guitar even though it is fingerstyle..the guitarist have to put their soul in their guitar and not just good sound and skill..but Alip Ba Ta had it all..good sound..skill and most of all his soul when he playing his guitar that makes the song his own song..
I just realised that Alip is more than talented guitarist. He is an artist. He sent us messages with his music. In his original music, he just say us to keep on spirit in Kopi Pagi, he just say us to be patient in a gloomy pandemic on Pagebluk, and what a culture in Balinesse.
Both talented guitarist. One for show. One send us messages.
Gracias uncle.
Love u my uncle. Healty always to you and family..🙏🙏🙏🇮🇩❤
Marcin, kasihanilah gitarmu..
Alip selalu bisa menenangkan kita semua, termasuk gitarnya..
Nice Uncle Gianni Bravo., mantaf..kopi mana kopi ☕
I'm from Indonesia
Thank to uncle for support our Alip
Music is soul 👍💗
Permainan Gitar mas Alip Bata bisa kena hati , jiwa kita bagi pendengar ny se akan masuk dalam petikan gitar mas Alip ba ta 🙏☕😀👍👌
Mantap,,Thanks Uncle,,,🙋👍🙏
Great uncle Gianni🇲🇨🇲🇨👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Thank..Uncle giani bravo..kopi mna kopi..☕👍
Mantap, ciao
Punya cara dan keahlian ciri masing2 yg berbeda beda diatas langit ada langit , seni itu indah dan keunggulan Alip bata punya cara penyampaian seni yg menyentuh di hati para pendengarnya ...itulah seni yg sesungguhnya
B aja, masalah musik tergantung selera
Wkwkwkwkwkwkwk
Harus blajar sama mas Alip..tentang main musik yg menjiwai dan emosional..bravo Ancle giani kopi mna kopi..
permainan alip lebih bisa di terima, lebih masuk ke hati dan menyentuh prasaan, alip the best🇮🇩🇮🇩👍👍 alipers indonesia. 👌thks uncel
Si Alif terlalu membosankan, tidak ekspresif
I agree, Pure, Heart and Soul should be have by the artist. Thank you uncle Gianni. We wish you still healty and doing well. 🇮🇩
Alip and andrea mempunyai kesamaan dalam music, mereka mempunyai rasa dalam bermusik ini yang membuat kita ga pernah bosan dengarnya, marcin gitaris yang hebat dan atraktif. But music about soul and pure not only skill
Bravo uncle gianni and andrea stay save
Kopimanakopi...mantap...kalian semua orang2 hebat dalam hal ihwal musik...tanks. salam alipers
Both are great guitarists and very talented, nothing to compare.
Each has its own characteristics, if you want to hear a more gloomy interpretation, then listen to Alip, but if you want to see an attractive show then Marcin can be an option. Because for me, music is something to listen to, and should be able to touch my soul, without talking skill, technique and other things.
Alip and Naudo are two guitar instrumentalists that are my favorites, because they can make music that I can enjoy and touch my heart.
marcin with young spirit is more rock, but mas Alip can interpret and see a song what other musician did not. i can enjoy Alip interpretation more
Agree bro. Marcin is great & talented. Marcin is attractive guitarist. Alip is great too. Alip play guitar with soul. I like both of them gives difference atmosphere. Nando is good too. He's play accustic guitar with soul too.
True 💝
Jd ceritanya si marcin ngambek ya kagak di react sm uncle ska, wajar dah tu anak msh abege msh labil lu tong
Alip ba ta mantap. uncle Gianni👍
For me as alip fans... we should get the credit to marcin, he is very younger, he always have great performances... full skill and technic... not everyone can do that things hhe... just amazing but once again everyone have their favour of type music including in acoustic guitar... plus point alip in here... he is just bring in easy way to listening like you already mention it with his soul... and always send the original message of this song even if he took in diffrent way... in this case not to apple to apple... probably... for me like as you say uncle... music is "simple"
By the way... huge respect uncle for uploading this video... hhe...
Yes, we will see is yanger and talented, ciao
@@GianniBravoSka Wew thanks for always... repeat almost all the comment... may i ask one favour uncle... i have one suggestion of one cover alip song it call "Gerimis mengundang - slam" as far as i know... that song it's one of his first song which he first learned how he start to play guitar... probably he should did everything to do a justice to cover this song...
Any way thank... before uncle if you fullfill my wish for the future... hhe...
It means a lot for me hhe...
Mantap uncle....... Kopi mana kopi.... Enjoy time
Bisa dipahami mengapa Gianni lbh menyukai music Alip drpd musisi yg lain...sehat selalu bro...🙏🙏
Keduanya mantap...
Salam alipers....
Kopi mana kopi....
Cao Uncle..Alip Ba Ta and Mancin..they are both very amazing.. have their own character.. Alip ba ta is Soft and Mancin is fierce.. salute.. 🙏🙏❤️❤️🇲🇨🇲🇨❤️🇮🇹🇮🇹
Mantap Uncle, Kopi Mana Kopi. Brunei Alipers
Thanks for reaction Uncle Gianni...both of them are brilliant they have different style. Alip is always playing with the heart compare with the others. Keep healthy Uncle...
Mantap uncle... Kopi mana kopi.... 🙏🙏👍👍👍👍
Both are talented and gifted players. However, Marcin draws me in more.
His facial expressions, the way he uses & moves his body….it looks like the guitar is an extension of himself and he plays with such passion.
The way he arranges music, the way he plays and the fact that he is only 21 (and much younger in many of his videos….I think 16 in this video) is just mind blowing to me.
Alip is wonderful too. His style seems calming & soothing and makes me feel relaxed.
Marcin makes me feel alert & alive.
Both are great at their own style and I hope they both continue to make and play amazing music!
yes i'm with you, but, Toxicity without words is returned to us in half, choosing it becomes pure exercise in style. this is my thought, thank you ciao
To be honest, you can found many better acoustic musician than Marcin, since he is not the first one who used that technique. I even seen street musician plays better than Marcin.
But yet, you'll never seen anyone plays like Alip Ba Ta.
@@mikhail2446 so u mean anyone on the street can fking play paganini caprice no 5 like marcin did?
Didnt think so
Just dont be so overproud with ur idol talent just because he is from Indonesia then u became overproud
I've seen all talents not just on guitar but also on piano and stuff
Back then i thought lang lang was the best pianist ever but now im wrong
Each person has their own style for example marcin his playing is so on fire
In the other side alip bata his playing more like calmful harmonic and stuff
@@MarioJeconiah not like Marcin, but BETTER than Marcin, like I've said.
I seen several times in the street with my own eyes, so I don't have to make you believe me (btw I also a musician, I played toxicity thousand times on the stages when I was teenager, so pls don't teach me how to understand music).
Also, it's not my fault if you never seen any better street musician than Marcin.
One thing you should understand, there's always many great people above great people. Marcin is good, but not the best, still many people above him.
think what uncle Gianni said is even you had so much talented skill of guitar like Marcin but there is no soul in what his song..I think playing guitar even though it is fingerstyle..the guitarist have to put their soul in their guitar and not just good sound and skill..but Alip Ba Ta had it all..good sound..skill and most of all his soul when he playing his guitar that makes the song his own song..
Thnk for your reaction..🤞🤞🤞
So spot on what you said, papa Gianni.
True, both are very skilled on their technic, a virtuoso.
Marcin was so very young when interpretating this song, a masterful play, energetic. Alip Ba Ta is on another level. Through Alip we got the message of toxicity, it was a grandeur interpretation, so magical when listening to Alip's version, brought smile to us.
It wasnt Alip interpretation, he just copied the original.
Alip bata mantap
Marcin jg mantap
Penting ngopi 😂
Fantastico..sir.. You always come up with a great point of view... This is not a comaration but a perfect martiege... Alip and marchine. Bravo...
Alip bata paling hadew pokonamah...kopi mana kopi,lur..
No disrespect, but Marcin is on another level, obviously
It depends . In this piece my considerations transcend the simple virtuosic quality.
1000% ...I agree about point view to enjoy music like you, my uncle Giani 👍👍👍.
Marcin mengebu gebu, mr alip bata alus
Spot on! The real question is, what makes an artist to be a star? It's not just a talent alone, you need to have a lot more than that to be a star. A lot of talented musicians stuck in their careers because they have no more than their talents alone..
Talent, work and a great soul, ciao
Alif Ba Ta sangat berisi dalam perasaan.menyentuh hati dan jiwa 🇲🇨
Kalo disambil Ngopi,,, menurut pribadi saya enak didengarkan mas alip,,, tks bro Gianni bravo
Marcin Patrzałek is already and will always be admired as a phenomenon, as the greatest contemporary virtuoso, such as Paganini, Bethoven, and Chopin. There are tens of thousands of average musicians like Alip Bata. In a dozen or so years, everyone will forget about Alipbata.
Marcin is certainly a virtuoso guitarist, with a great talent. Comparing it to the names you mentioned is absurd. Alip Ba ta is a great artist with a great soul. Time will tell.
@@GianniBravoSka Alipbata is a small pond that will dry up, Patrzałek is an endless ocean.
@@GianniBravoSka Marcin's brilliant songs are listened to many times and they do not get bored. Alipbata's music is played once, the same cannot be listened to the second time. In fact, even once listening to Alipbata's music is boring.
@@GianniBravoSka Hundreds of guitarists imitate Marcin, try to play his compositions. I haven't seen anyone imitate Alipbata.
@@krk8303 You are a Marcin fan i respect you. ciao
Uncle Gianni Bravo we are so grateful because you are attentive and concerned to Mas Alip Ba Ta. You are wise when giving reactions. Even when you ve to compare among other guitarists. Anyhow you are straightforward reacting the artists. Thank you Uncle Gianni Bravo.
Ciao
Both players amazing...👍👍
Both musician are wow...Alif wow to listen and Marcin wow to see...🤩
Alif is clasic dancer and Marcin modern dancer....🤩
Bravo for both...and bravo uncle Giani...🤩
Marcin tez gra sonaty ,bardzo ładnie to robi
Intinya dia lebih suka alip...karena alip bermain bukan hanya dgn skil tapi juga dgn hati n penghayatan ❤️❤️
Alicja Bata ładnie gra tak jak wiele innych osób,a ja uwielbiam dynamiczną grę Marcina ,połączoną z jego wielką pasją,talentem i inteligencją.To są dla mnie niesamowite odczucia kiedy słucham jego gry,ile on wkłada w to serca.❤❤
Tak diragukan..paman banyak pengalaman musik....lidah bisa bohong..tapi masalah hati..gakkan bisa bohong..mantap...sehat slalu paman...
Alip is a magical artist and musician, plays his guitar like a person dancing in meditation, the most prominent technique is in his artificial harmonics, the tone, soul and soothing sound makes you relax like coming from another dimension similar to Oxytron in music healing. 👍👏
......and Marcin playing guitar like a wild horse running from a lion.....
Alip is boring and not impresive.
Marcin kurang jauh maen nya lur
@@MrPIEKNYPANin my opinion marcin interpretes the song with anger/madness while alip interpretes with sadness so, it's up to the audience which prefer to be liked.
Good that you support local peuple. Ali ba ta is a very good local player, marcin as every great artist is going his own path, unwalked before him :)
There are many guitarists who can play like Alip Bata and better but there is none who can play like Marcin. He is an absolute genius.
Maybe you dont understand what i said, ciao
@@GianniBravoSka
Feelings of soul is subjective.
He is talking about skills and techniques, (more objective..clearly you can see what takes more work and talent) and you are talking about souls. People have different tastes, although the majority may like certain styles or genres.
Ingat bro ,Alip itu belajar gitar secara otodidak,tidak sekolah musik,sedangkan marcin anda tau sendiri dia murid terbaik di kelasnya,jadi bisa bermain gitar secara otodidak seperti mas alipbata bukankah itu luar biasa,bakat murni yg di berikan tuhan kepadanya, sehingga menjadi virtuoso seperti sekarang ini,mungkin itulah yg membuatnya memiliki penggemar yg fanatik terhadap permainan gitarnya bro,salam alipers ❤️👍
@@GianniBravoSkaNo he understood very well. Marcin would play as Alip within 5 minutes but vice versa would take ages. 🤣🤣🤣
Saya penggemar Alip dan jg anda menyukai Alip... sebagai hormat saya kepada anda saya Subscriber cannel anda.salam hormat saya dari Indonesia.
We don't just talk about the skill but the art of music and song... we have to enjoy the music, song and some times the lyric of the song... Thank you uncle Gianni for the good reaction 🙏🙏🙏
Good job uncle. Tq by Alipers Indonesia. Mantap. Kopi mana Kopi.
To be honest, music is not only about skill and technique, but more about spirit, soul, heart and feeling. They are both great musicians. Greetings from Indonesia and stay healhty uncle Giani 🙏🙏
So you admit that Marcin have better technic.
Looking on the soul is just personal biast.
Yg pingin tenang dan terhanyut ya psti Alip..klu yg lincah dan atraktif ya yg muda sii..sama" hebat..cmn beda selera dan cara penyampaian aja😊
Tentu saja, tetapi ada lagu yang harus dihormati jika memiliki kata-kata penting, halo
Byuh byuh mantap uncle.. very nice view.. thanks 👍❤️😘🇮🇩
Almost same with me, as a metalhead, in this case.. sure, both guitarist have great tecnique in playing guitar.. but Alip has more ability to transfer the soul of the song, and for me, this is the most important part in playing an instrument
Luar biasa om Gianni.., video reaksinya langsung ditanggapi oleh mas Alif ba ta sendiri..👍👍👍
Bravo uncle 👍👍👍
Thanks paman giovani reaksi nya luar biasa 👍🙏🙏
Thanks uncle. Alipers love you ❤️❤️❤️
Hadir, mari kita nikmat kopi di hari ini ☕
salam hormat uncle Gianni. tanpa memandang sentimen nasionalisme, tapi bagi saya pribadi "skill" adalah sesuatu dan "soul" adalah sesuatu di atasnya. skill digunakan untuk menghasilkan musik yang lebih memiliki jiwa (dalam hal ini adalah gitar). saya selalu menghormati mereka yang memiliki skill hebat dalam bermusik tetapi selalu rasa saya lebih terpuaskan oleh musik yang memiliki jiwa
me too, ciao
It's fenomenal music with fingerstyle. Thank's for Mr Giani Bravo react
Alip ba ta and marcin are both good at playing guitar and they have their own way of covering a song, each has a musical soul and has a unique way of playing guitar, this is a development in guitar playing and will continue to grow over time
Alipers Indonesia 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩 hadir
Yeah...we are witnessing people who are given advantages by God, all people with special advantages and so are others, that's the greatness of God, thank you uncle you are so wise 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Grazie, ciao
Thanks uncle giani. 💖💖💖💖💖💖ngopi mantaps
They're both great! You can't compare those two. They both bring something else to the table. That is the beauty of art. There is something for everyone!
I respect your opinion, ciao
Good job uncle ❤️😍👍 lanjutken
I agree, Uncle Gianni Bravo...! music can be enjoyed according to the situation and conditions..where people can enjoy the art. Alip and Marcin are equally talented...👍👍☕🇮🇩
Thank you uncle Gianni...i m very very apreciate. God bleas you.
I'm a bit rusty, but with a little effort I can play like Alip (and I'm sure many other does it already). On the other side, I must reincarnate several times in order to be able not to play, but to try to play like Marcin does. We have to admit it: Marcin is a phenomenon, he's one of that people who are only born once in a thousand years.
Maybe, but you honestly didn't get what I said in the video. Congratulations if you play like Alip Ba ta
@@GianniBravoSka, I'm not saying he's not good, but I see him like an ordinary guitar player, nothing special. He's not gifted...that's all!
That's just my humble opinion.
@@GianniBravoSka
What he said has nothing to do with whether he didn't get what you said or not.
It's easier for Marcin to play like Alip, than Alip to play like Marcin.
I enjoy more listening to the music that Alip makes than most of the music Marcin makes.
However, as much as I listen to Alip more, I acknowledge Marcin as a much better skillful technical guitarist.
I would also put skills, techniques, and creativity above preference, taste, and soul, which are subjective.
And the video you react is old. Marcin is only 21 years old now.
@@escuadrian2011
Alip makes music that many people like (covers especially), whereas people like Marcin, Luca, Misko and some others prefer to make their own, which is not in the liking of many people in general.
Alip also has strong fanbase who will appreciate reactors if they make reactions of him.
People confuse favorite as best or better.
That's what I think, and I agree with what you said.
@@gratefulyes6282Given that art and technique do not always coincide. I am convinced of Marcin's great talent. I used Toxicity in particular to express a concept that I think is important. When you decide to do a cover you have to respect the artist. There are songs where words are as important as music. Forgetting it does not do justice to the artist of reference. Maybe too young to understand it.
Terima Uncle semoga Uncle sehat selalu.
Bagiku skill tinggi ialah dia bs menempatkan sesatu pada tempatnya dan penempatan penempatan itu menjadikan suguhan indah yg musah di fahami mudah dinikmati,saya setuju dg bapa ini,alip tahu kebutuhan jiwa manusia,makanya dia buatlah aransemen cover seperti itu!menurut ku itu bukan hanya skill bermain tinggi tp jg skill kejeniusan dalam bermusik bg ku itulah mas alips,kenapa jelas musik sod itu di buat sedemikian rupa sampai menjadi indah bahkan menurut selera saya itu lbh bs dinikmati secara umum,dan aransement bukan kaleng2 dan dg penunjukan sedikit skill tp pada inti,menurut ku dividio ini mas alip menyampaikam bahwa aku disini menyelipkan skill ku sedikit dn sedemikian rupa tp aku tunjukan tentang sesuatu kejeniusan skill dalam bermusik maka jadilah aransement ini dengan penunjukan skill yg indah dan berbobot
Thans, nice comment, ciao
Terima kasih Uncle Gianni reaksinya.....sangat dalam dan luar biasa MANTAP👍👍👍KOPI MANA KOPI
Salam sehat selalu untuk Unccle Gianni
Mantap. ciao
As a music lover, I don't care what kind of music it is, the important thing is to relax and be calm and easy to understand. Complicated or not a piece of music, when we hear it for the first time we will know what song is being played... Many musicians play various types of songs without vocals, but when we play it we don't know what song it is because it is much different from the original song and only briefly just bored.. good music will make us listen to it over and over again because its beauty is heard in the ears, hearts and minds...
LOVE 4 UNCLE....🙏
Grazie, ciao
Couldn't agree more...👌
Amazing uncle Bravo.. thank you so much ❤️❤️🇮🇩🇮🇩🙏
Marcin & Alip are both very talented guitarists. Their techniques maybe at the same level.
But, I completely agree with Uncle Gianni, Marcin send great sounds to our ears, while Alip send messages to our hearts. That's the difference between the two of them.
Thumbs up for the two virtuosoes 👍 👍
Thank you Uncle Gianni. Stay safe 🙏
halo uncle , nice to see you again 🙏🙏
alip has always appreciated the guitar according to its nature. It's weird if the guitar is forced to make percussion sounds to the limit. What matters is how to convert the song to guitar playing, not imitating the original sound of the song
Marcin believes that the guitar is not only about taut strings.
Therefore the whole instrument of the guitar should be used.
so is the house - if someone lives in the house, no one uses only the room, but all the rooms that the house offers - kitchen, bathroom and room
Mksd uncle itu adlh kemampuan mngubah mngaransemen dn mnjadi baru lbh hidup dn tetap pd originalnya adlh kemampuan seniman sesungguhnya..brmaen cepat dn teknik bnyak tp kemampuan utk mnciptakan dn mmbuat perbedaan adalah virtuoso ssugguhnya apa lg mmpu mengiringi lagu aslinya .
Toxicity without words is a simple exercise in style, thats all. ciao
both are very talented, regardless of likes and dislikes or taste and perspective of mudic. They have abilities that complement each other in music trend in this digital era.
Salute 👍🏾
Happy healthy wealthy, Gianni 🙏🏾
Grazie, ciao
Straigh to the point... Very-very deep reaction again... thanks Uncle Giani...
👍👍👍❤❤❤
Bagus sekali 👍