Plaintiff did not describe the story to her benefit. She led with passing out drunk... Judge Mathis is the wrong judge to tell that you were passed out!! He almost called her a crackhead!!
I think that was fair judgement, I mean all she did was drive the car. The girl just got scared and agreed to pay for something she didn't damage. The judge is right, first you must be guilty then comes your punishment either in payment or jail time.
The way judge Mathis reacted to Doyle's comment about having done a lot by the age of 20 was really cute. I love the friendship between the 2, u can tell they good old friends. That's hard to come by nowadays.
Your engine blew from pre-existing problems!! Why should she have to pay for another car or engine? What’s wrong with people??! Had you not have been drunk & decided to drive your car. The engine would’ve blown on you too.
a 1999 car - car maintenance. These young people they just drive, drive, drive. i wonder when was the last time the oil was change. Most of all no one was not injure as they was all drunk.
Why was her ex friend aka defendant scott off the hook when she was driving drunk is what I don’t understand. I think she shouldn’t have to pay the engine but at the same time she should not have been getting behind the wheel if they had already agreed that they were all getting a taxi I hate the people want to drive drunk bunch of idiots.
Here's the thing the plaintiff failed to understand your car already had issues. Car engine was going to blow or be replaced whether she drove it or not. Either way you were going to be behind the wheel at some point after the club. That being said you were going to be out of a car. It just so happened when your friend got behind the wheel. You are still responsible because the damage was done prior to her being behind the wheel. She tried it. And a respectable mechanic would of told her that.
@@davontheard61 Wtf ? So if I took your car without permission and totalled it I wouldn't have to pay you for the damage because your car was not in the best condition to begin with ? Thats literally theft, you idiot. Here in Canada where I live, you would go to jail.
ole judge mathis ....issuing out sound verdicts....i agree whole heartedly.....you cant hold anyone responsible for damages for a vehicle that had pre existing problems. esp 18 yrs old. there is no way anyone can tell by just driving another persons vehicle that your car will overheat unless they knew before hand.
I disagree. They agreed to take a taxi so wth..she clearly lied to the judge. Usually he gets mad and starts yelling at the ppl for lying but let her off the Hook smh
@@latonyamosley9475 But they had an agreement prior to them drinking that they wouldn't drive if they were drunk. Age of the vehicle doesn't matter. Def shouldn't have moved that car.
The car would of over heated regardless if they drove it or not that night it just happened to be that night how that her fault she clearly said she passed out how was she going to pay for the cab if she got drunk to the point where she passed out
Just like the Judge said she can’t prove that the cause of the engine blowing up was her fault, she was passed out drunk. Plus she admitted she had car issues anyway , and her friend pulled over to the side of the road, so in this case no her friend don’t owe. Had she got into a wreck then she would owe
@@tynatural4654 The car was almost 20 years old. Even if the owner was driving it, the engine blowing would have been inevitable. The defendant didn't owe her anything, in this particular case.
Ole girl don't need anymore kids if she's not mature enough to understand her car already had issues... Issues with the engine at that. Her friend should not be responsible for fixing her car. Now if the friend wrecked the car then okay but that's not what happened.
because the facts about if she shouldve agreed or not was on the table. The vehicle owner was trying to get over and receive money for something that was out of the other parties hand. Also how could she manage to get 3 people into the car by herself? i believe everyone got into the car willingly and blacked out as the girl was driving. plus this situation happened 2 years ago, why are you just now in court. The car owner most likely needs money and thought this was a easy way.
Fair ruling. That car already had problems and it was old. You don’t create an engine problem in one night. I’m glad the friend wasn’t stuck paying for anything.
I had three young friends do me worse than that we was all drinking in my car . I told them put the empty bottle's in the case what did they do when we arrived at the club in front of the police open the door bottles went everywhere I even had to tell them to run. We got away but never again will I ever hangout with stupid mofo's you pay in the end.
true we all was wrong and I own mine but when you're young you do stupid 💩 but the main thing was I specifically told everyone not to do and they did it anyway so I learned never give a foolish person the power to destroy your life. A true friend would have listened a hater will let you fall on the oops my bad knife.
That girl is trying to blame her because she behind the wheel...weird...thieeeeef ...and the girl agreed to pay back because she has no clue about cars..
That yack ain't nothing to play with...they prolly was drinking it straight too that's why they was all passed out....ol girl driving was just trying to make it to the cut..since everybody went to sleep on her
she had a honda, they are good cars, i bet she drove it without checking the oil. that's what happen to friend, she blew the engine there was no oil in the engine.
Y’all crazy if y’all think she should pay for the girl 1999 car engine blowing up...the car was already fucked yo it had nothing to do with them drinking & driving 😂😂
I don’t like the defendant. It’s funny how people don’t feel bad for certain things. You know, I don’t even feel comfortable when I destroy something of someone’s and they say it’s fine, don’t pay. I feel it got spoilt in my possession so I have to contribute to fixing it. The defendant is low low.
Shawty BIG mad cuz she lost but honestly it was fair. That old ass car was bound to overheat. She might have asked her friend to drive the car but she don’t kno cuz she was too drunk. They should have taken an Uber from the start then there wouldn’t be a question on how they were gettin home.
People should learn to hold their damn liquor when in a public setting. If you're going out with a group, no matter what they say, no one wants to be held responsible for someone else's actions. Designated driver is cool but baby sitting is a whole other situation. Everyone wants to have a good time, but drinking to the point of blacking out is disturbing. Do that shit AT HOME.
Omg!! I never see a person with the same name as me, pronounced the same and spelled the same!! People always pronounce it wrong and I used to think it might be the spelling 😭
Plaintiff is ridiculous! Girl the car was OLD you can NOT expect a person to put down a payment on a new car. Is she out her Mafukkin mind. it just so happen to go out while she was driving it.
if u drive my car w/o my persmission and something happens u are liable. So if she took the car w/o permission wrecked the car but wasn't in the wrong would she then be liable?
It seems like judge Mathis was doing the defendant's work as in giving a defense for her instead of letting her say her own defense. You cant help the defendant win their own case...He petty for that.
In court she said I promised to help her like give her rides and let her use my car. But the email said I told you im going to pay you back. If defendant really felt like she only offered to help she would have stated that in the email. She lied n judge let her go smh
Right, but even though she said she would help. How much should she really be responsible for? Although it's a Honda, it can't run forever, lol! I would never put fault on my friend for something like that. She didn't even wreck the car!
I like that both young ladies are so well-spoken,especially the defendant.They're silly,as we all were at that age,but its always nice to hear people express themselves well.Sidenote-I love how JM speaks of his wife with so much affection.
Smh.. the point was that the defendant did not have permission to drive her car.. she just jumped in the driver seat when everyone was passed out... I feel she should hold some responsibility.
I really thought she would have won because she said the plan was to get a cab, not drive her car and she was intoxicated. How is that not negligence?!
This is why I don’t drive nobody else’s car but mine because you can’t blame her because your engine blew up it’s your responsibility To make sure that your vehicle performs correctly before you have somebody else behind the wheel how the hell she gone sue that girl For a new engine when you knew at some point it was something already wrong with your car and lets just be honest you expect a young Lady that don’t know anything about cars to pull over in the middle of the night and try to see what’s wrong with it hell naw she did right Drive to your house where you feel safe and then see what’s going on. Good job Judge Mathis on how you seen this case.
Oh hell naw it don't matter she shouldn't have touched the girl car without her permission if she didn't know nothing ! Therefore whatever happens while you was driving my car without my damn permission is your fault!
I disagree with the judge on this he should of at least made her pay half they were drunk they shouldnt of been driving at all especially when they had all agreed on a taxi
You ain’t fair judge Mathis. She agree to pay, you should have let her stand a half. Split it in the middle. My grandma always said old bring new. Never agree to anything when you are mad. And never say anything you might regret.
I disagree on this one. She did not give the other girl permission to drive her car. Whether it had a preexisting issue or not, she drove her car without permission. That's essentially stealing.
This was not a fair judgements They Both agreed to go half on a cab then she goes and takes her car without permission and the car was damage with her behind the wheel, also she agreed to paying back. Why agree to pay (2 years later ) if you know you didn’t cause any demages ? Judgement should’ve been for the plaintiff.
People settle way too young. But some people become too picky. I know this girl in her 30s that is determined to find the perfect man. No one is good enough. Reality is that there is no perfect person. My advice is not to settle but look for the perfect person for you.
I think the defendant is just a nice girl who doesn’t like confrontation, otherwise she would’ve bluntly told the plaintiff that she didn’t feel responsible. I’m glad the judge did it for her though.
the fact that the defendant even agreed to pay for the car in the first place is BECAUSE SHE KNEW SHE DAMAGED IT. 🤦🏽♀️ use your context clues mathis .
I'm sorry I don't care what me and my friend goes through I'm never going to publicy bad mouth her. When people do that shit that's how they always felt. That's fake as hell.
B.s. she agreed to split a cab but drive anyway. AND she agreed to repay for the damages. Her word means absolutely nothing. I think the plaintiff should of won
Plaintiff did not describe the story to her benefit. She led with passing out drunk... Judge Mathis is the wrong judge to tell that you were passed out!! He almost called her a crackhead!!
TYB26 😂 right
TYB26 it doesn’t matter the engine doesn’t go after one night of drinking
ahahahahahahahahahah
@@thewise2443 A
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think that was fair judgement, I mean all she did was drive the car. The girl just got scared and agreed to pay for something she didn't damage. The judge is right, first you must be guilty then comes your punishment either in payment or jail time.
The way judge Mathis reacted to Doyle's comment about having done a lot by the age of 20 was really cute. I love the friendship between the 2, u can tell they good old friends. That's hard to come by nowadays.
Your engine blew from pre-existing problems!! Why should she have to pay for another car or engine? What’s wrong with people??! Had you not have been drunk & decided to drive your car. The engine would’ve blown on you too.
Good ruling. Lesson learned Girl Bye ‼️
I'm glad no one was seriously injured
a 1999 car - car maintenance. These young people they just drive, drive, drive. i wonder when was the last time the oil was change. Most of all no one was not injure as they was all drunk.
They think the car does all the maintenance by itself and they just drive it. Stupid girls. Lol 😂
@@isaackid I know right, lol. I knew that she was not going to win after she mentioned the year of the car, lol.
1999 honda "I can go 2-300,000 mile Civic" and it overheated...
That’s why I’m thankful my Gpa taught me what I needed to know. That when I go my first car and there on I knew exactly what I was doing.
blame the parents . this generations parents aren’t teaching them anything or guiding them along the way about *anything* just lazy
They both drunk and the other friends to, maybe next time have a designated driver.
She stated she planned to take a cab
Why was her ex friend aka defendant scott off the hook when she was driving drunk is what I don’t understand. I think she shouldn’t have to pay the engine but at the same time she should not have been getting behind the wheel if they had already agreed that they were all getting a taxi I hate the people want to drive drunk bunch of idiots.
the plaintiff is worse than the defendant. She probably has an alcohol problem she has yet to discover or admit to.
@@mkrkid1 so how were u driven by HER if u were gona cab it... Aint that much drunk in the world
They need to stop drinking.
I hope whoever is reading this have a good week❤️
You too! 😄♥️
You too
Same to you😇
Same 2 you may God continue to bless you and your family baby girl 💙💜❤️🧡💚🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
You too Dabraat! 👌
Here's the thing the plaintiff failed to understand your car already had issues. Car engine was going to blow or be replaced whether she drove it or not. Either way you were going to be behind the wheel at some point after the club. That being said you were going to be out of a car. It just so happened when your friend got behind the wheel. You are still responsible because the damage was done prior to her being behind the wheel. She tried it. And a respectable mechanic would of told her that.
Doyle secretly love the drama 🤣🤣🤣🤣 look at his face between dem
lol, or he comes into work stoned every day and Mathis knows it and lets it go. Doyle admitted he uses weed.
She does not owe her anything.. her car was messed up regardless
She didn't give the friend permission to drive the car though..
@@just_mandie Even if the owner herself drove it, the car was 20 years old, it would have blown out anyway.
@@just_mandie lol it do not matter, thats why people like you need to be educated on law forreal
@@davontheard61 Wtf ? So if I took your car without permission and totalled it I wouldn't have to pay you for the damage because your car was not in the best condition to begin with ? Thats literally theft, you idiot. Here in Canada where I live, you would go to jail.
Soon as I got the notification I just hit play you my man Judge Mathis for real I love and respect you to the fullest
#sinceSept99💪🏿❤💙❤💙
ole judge mathis ....issuing out sound verdicts....i agree whole heartedly.....you cant hold anyone responsible for damages for a vehicle that had pre existing problems. esp 18 yrs old. there is no way anyone can tell by just driving another persons vehicle that your car will overheat unless they knew before hand.
I disagree. They agreed to take a taxi so wth..she clearly lied to the judge. Usually he gets mad and starts yelling at the ppl for lying but let her off the Hook smh
It’s wasn’t a wreck. That car was 18 years old. It was bound to happen
@@latonyamosley9475 But they had an agreement prior to them drinking that they wouldn't drive if they were drunk. Age of the vehicle doesn't matter. Def shouldn't have moved that car.
The car would of over heated regardless if they drove it or not that night it just happened to be that night how that her fault she clearly said she passed out how was she going to pay for the cab if she got drunk to the point where she passed out
Just like the Judge said she can’t prove that the cause of the engine blowing up was her fault, she was passed out drunk. Plus she admitted she had car issues anyway , and her friend pulled over to the side of the road, so in this case no her friend don’t owe. Had she got into a wreck then she would owe
How was she going to put her 2 passed out friends in a cab??
What??! Any other case with evidence of the person saying they will pay you back he usually will grant their claim
In this case she didnt do actual damage to the car so how you going to make someone pay for something that was out of her control
I believe that would've been the case if she got into an accident. Judge got this one right and I disagree with him often
Exactly!!!!!!!
Iriz Cabel it was in her control because she never gave her permission to drive
@@tynatural4654 The car was almost 20 years old. Even if the owner was driving it, the engine blowing would have been inevitable. The defendant didn't owe her anything, in this particular case.
Ole girl don't need anymore kids if she's not mature enough to understand her car already had issues... Issues with the engine at that. Her friend should not be responsible for fixing her car. Now if the friend wrecked the car then okay but that's not what happened.
That was a bullshit judgment... I've seen him give others their judgment will less evidence, with " I'll pay you back" alone
lol this is not a lesson about being drunk. Drunk or not, you cant make someone's car break down. lol
Doyle is so cute!!!
Extremely
Oooo
Why didn't the judge get mad when this girl that was driving the car lied about not agreeing to pay for the car
because the facts about if she shouldve agreed or not was on the table. The vehicle owner was trying to get over and receive money for something that was out of the other parties hand. Also how could she manage to get 3 people into the car by herself? i believe everyone got into the car willingly and blacked out as the girl was driving. plus this situation happened 2 years ago, why are you just now in court. The car owner most likely needs money and thought this was a easy way.
That hen-dawg gets them turnt 🤣
Fair ruling. That car already had problems and it was old. You don’t create an engine problem in one night. I’m glad the friend wasn’t stuck paying for anything.
I had three young friends do me worse than that we was all drinking in my car .
I told them put the empty bottle's in the case what did they do when we arrived at the club in front of the police open the door bottles went everywhere I even had to tell them to run. We got away but never again will I ever hangout with stupid mofo's you pay in the end.
How about not drinking and driving. That's what stupid as hell.🙄
Wait. You allowed that foolishness and y'all were all being foolish. "We was all drinking in my car."
true we all was wrong and I own mine but when you're young you do stupid 💩 but the main thing was I specifically told everyone not to do and they did it anyway so I learned never give a foolish person the power to destroy your life. A true friend would have listened a hater will let you fall on the oops my bad knife.
That girl is trying to blame her because she behind the wheel...weird...thieeeeef ...and the girl agreed to pay back because she has no clue about cars..
One ride does not blow an engine!
The vehicle owner didn't learn anything from what the judge said
The judge was wrong. The defendant agreed to pay because she felt she did something wrong.
How did you get in the car ... DUH 🙄 YOU AND all your friends ... 🤦🏽♀️
Wuz up plantiff..hollar at ya boy.......🌹😎..😁
You ready to be a step dad!? Or is f🤐cking your mission! Lmao
@@deejai1173 I'm ready to be a step daddy😁..do u see that girl?🌹😎..if u know her tell her she need a truck driver in her life..
I think both of them are responsible for being drunk.
If you’re going to drink get an Uber and plan a safe night
She did not have permission to drive. Her fault
We woulda been both woulda been two drunk chicks sleep in the parking lot before I trust someone else driving my whip home... tuhh
They literally planned to all take a cab. I don’t even understand why the other girls car even became apart of the equation. Dead wrong imo.
That yack ain't nothing to play with...they prolly was drinking it straight too that's why they was all passed out....ol girl driving was just trying to make it to the cut..since everybody went to sleep on her
See that’s why I don’t have friends 🎉😂
she had a honda, they are good cars, i bet she drove it without checking the oil. that's what happen to friend, she blew the engine there was no oil in the engine.
Y’all crazy if y’all think she should pay for the girl 1999 car engine blowing up...the car was already fucked yo it had nothing to do with them drinking & driving 😂😂
She is not a real friend ! Glad the case was dismissed
I don’t like the defendant. It’s funny how people don’t feel bad for certain things.
You know, I don’t even feel comfortable when I destroy something of someone’s and they say it’s fine, don’t pay. I feel it got spoilt in my possession so I have to contribute to fixing it. The defendant is low low.
why would you drive if you know you are going out drinking instead of taking a uber or a cab in the first place
Shawty BIG mad cuz she lost but honestly it was fair. That old ass car was bound to overheat. She might have asked her friend to drive the car but she don’t kno cuz she was too drunk. They should have taken an Uber from the start then there wouldn’t be a question on how they were gettin home.
Exactly. Seems they agreed to not take the cab since all 4 ladies were drunk in the car with two in back seat and owner passed out drunk.
People should learn to hold their damn liquor when in a public setting. If you're going out with a group, no matter what they say, no one wants to be held responsible for someone else's actions. Designated driver is cool but baby sitting is a whole other situation. Everyone wants to have a good time, but drinking to the point of blacking out is disturbing. Do that shit AT HOME.
These people try to get over on each other for the dumbest things and end up ruining friendships because of it.
She did not crash your car or get into an accident while driving. Girl make it make sense.
I agree with Judge Mathis ruling! That girl shouldn’t be responsible for a car that had pre-existing issues and plus the car was 18 years old.
Whether she drove the car or the friend drove the engine would have blown either way.
Omg!! I never see a person with the same name as me, pronounced the same and spelled the same!! People always pronounce it wrong and I used to think it might be the spelling 😭
Kookie cat?
Car was already done and she sued her friend to get a new one. Smh.....
I hope they both learned to stay away from alcohol.
Jasmine better admits she likes to drink
Plaintiff is ridiculous! Girl the car was OLD you can NOT expect a person to put down a payment on a new car. Is she out her Mafukkin mind. it just so happen to go out while she was driving it.
if u drive my car w/o my persmission and something happens u are liable. So if she took the car w/o permission wrecked the car but wasn't in the wrong would she then be liable?
It seems like judge Mathis was doing the defendant's work as in giving a defense for her instead of letting her say her own defense. You cant help the defendant win their own case...He petty for that.
Gemini is something else 🤦♀️
Legitimate Bipolars😬
Don’t come for us Gemini’s 😂
Jasmine better admits lol
Both of them are trifling and need to get their acts straight, if they want to get married and have a family someday
Any other time if the Judge sees that someone said they’d pay back, he’d rule that they have to
should've been keeping up with the maintenance; unfortunately, a lot of them don't
In court she said I promised to help her like give her rides and let her use my car. But the email said I told you im going to pay you back. If defendant really felt like she only offered to help she would have stated that in the email. She lied n judge let her go smh
Right, but even though she said she would help. How much should she really be responsible for? Although it's a Honda, it can't run forever, lol! I would never put fault on my friend for something like that. She didn't even wreck the car!
That's why I don't want no friends
Why you call each otherfriend and talk against one another?
I like that both young ladies are so well-spoken,especially the defendant.They're silly,as we all were at that age,but its always nice to hear people express themselves well.Sidenote-I love how JM speaks of his wife with so much affection.
Smh.. the point was that the defendant did not have permission to drive her car.. she just jumped in the driver seat when everyone was passed out... I feel she should hold some responsibility.
Dont drink and drive. It is that simple.
or you can, but you had better hope fate does not catch up to you
Mega mind in the back at 6:34
I really thought she would have won because she said the plan was to get a cab, not drive her car and she was intoxicated. How is that not negligence?!
The girl behind the plaintiff in purple is adorable and looks like an avatar of herself.
The car was a 1999, it was going to die any day just so happened it happen on the day they had been out partying...she owes her nothing
This is why I don’t drive nobody else’s car but mine because you can’t blame her because your engine blew up it’s your responsibility
To make sure that your vehicle performs correctly before you have somebody else behind the wheel how the hell she gone sue that girl
For a new engine when you knew at some point it was something already wrong with your car and lets just be honest you expect a young
Lady that don’t know anything about cars to pull over in the middle of the night and try to see what’s wrong with it hell naw she did right
Drive to your house where you feel safe and then see what’s going on. Good job Judge Mathis on how you seen this case.
Oh hell naw it don't matter she shouldn't have touched the girl car without her permission if she didn't know nothing ! Therefore whatever happens while you was driving my car without my damn permission is your fault!
Most you be drunk to have fun
I disagree with the judge on this he should of at least made her pay half they were drunk they shouldnt of been driving at all especially when they had all agreed on a taxi
You ain’t fair judge Mathis. She agree to pay, you should have let her stand a half.
Split it in the middle.
My grandma always said old bring new. Never agree to anything when you are mad. And never say anything you might regret.
Why? She was not responsible for the damage?
The defendant BETTER not screw up!
I disagree on this one. She did not give the other girl permission to drive her car. Whether it had a preexisting issue or not, she drove her car without permission. That's essentially stealing.
Some ppl logic is mind blowing.
Thank u I needed that
Four drinking Fools .😆
Her bday is may 21st like mines. Idc she won 😂
My 15 year old daughter birthday is May 21 too 👍🏾
This was not a fair judgements They Both agreed to go half on a cab then she goes and takes her car without permission and the car was damage with her behind the wheel, also she agreed to paying back. Why agree to pay (2 years later ) if you know you didn’t cause any demages ? Judgement should’ve been for the plaintiff.
How did she get the keys
People settle way too young. But some people become too picky. I know this girl in her 30s that is determined to find the perfect man. No one is good enough.
Reality is that there is no perfect person.
My advice is not to settle but look for the perfect person for you.
Kinda unfair but okay
Sadly @1:30 is why Mathis is getting divorced.
Hope everything works out for him
I think the defendant is just a nice girl who doesn’t like confrontation, otherwise she would’ve bluntly told the plaintiff that she didn’t feel responsible. I’m glad the judge did it for her though.
Gemini’s are a hot mess
We are not
we Pieces are emotional messes ourselves. We relate via emotion, but it so often costs us in life. To a TERRIBLE extent.
Kiara had bad case. The judge was fair.
She made a threat that is jail time and u won't get your car
Their from my neck of the woods. Lets see how this case goes 💆🏾♀️
Maryland?
THEY"RE
Ran the car hot and blew the motor smh I been there before
Why not meet at one place and split an Uber 4 ways to and from?
the fact that the defendant even agreed to pay for the car in the first place is BECAUSE SHE KNEW SHE DAMAGED IT. 🤦🏽♀️ use your context clues mathis .
Them sum good lookn drunks!
😍
Lady knew dam well her car was F up and then you try to blame it on your friend for a come up
plaintiff may be an alcoholic in denial or one WAITING to happen based up on her statements, making excuses.
I'm sorry I don't care what me and my friend goes through I'm never going to publicy bad mouth her. When people do that shit that's how they always felt. That's fake as hell.
B.s. she agreed to split a cab but drive anyway. AND she agreed to repay for the damages. Her word means absolutely nothing. I think the plaintiff should of won
Jings. Both smokin hot!