I am just an old man from a much different world of music and when I like paticular music well, who they sound like has no need to compare. I really like all of Noctura's music. Their music is DEEP
Mandy and Kris show real talent, this genre needs more from their songbook! Comparisons to other artists is a great compliment I believe! Please go forth and create. We so need more of this.
this sounds like young fallen era amy lee. Amy's voice has matured and doesn't sound like this anymore. outstanding music though. sad this band didn't get far more traction
lol at first i thought "why is my evanescence playlist playing? amazing voice. something between amy and her sister, who has a weaker but also nice voice.
@eggEgg23 Actually... Within Temptation was the first band in this genre... Evanescence came after... And then now Noctura is here... It's just the cycle of music... There's a band that starts a genre or sub-genre... There's people who like it... And then there's more bands that go to that genre and give it their own unique taste... Until obviously no one recognizes who the original starter is...
@SubarusXangel No it's not. The singer is Mandy Suiter. Amy Lee is under contract to create three albums under the band name Evanescence. Anywhere But Home and Origin have no been counted because one is a live album and the other is a demo. Amy still has one more album to go before she is allowed to leave.
@EVANESCENCEROCKSLIFE Anywhere But Home isn't a studio album :P It's a live on tour DVD. An album is a whole album of new songs :) Their albums are Fallen and The Open Door and Anywhere But Home is their DVD.
Her voice is pretty much the same as Amy's. However, she has a different vibrato, which is something Amy almost never uses. Also, her voice might be slightly higher in tone. I guess we can't avoid the comparisson, but at least they've done something good using the elements Evanescence brought in the modern music era. All in all, great band! Waiting for the album. Hope more bands like this turn up in the future.
@helxig correct! u are true fan of evanescence, by the way maybe u think it sound like amy lee, for me they have some same technique to control voice that make it sound alike... :) cheer for u and for all
Oh wow. No matter what anyone says, this girls voice is very similar to Amy Lee's in some parts. Its very good though and i may have to look into this band further.
@adr14ntr Oh the Symphonic-like genre... Less an official genre, and more like a musical style... Using Choir and orchestral sound bytes basically... Within Temptation was the first band to publicly do it, being that Evanescence was private (very few knew they existed) until their first public release of Fallen.
@iamJuicey Okay, I agree they do sound like Evanescence, but you don't need to insult anybody just because they don't think so. Noctura is still an awesome band either way.
what? shut up! you know what? you're all jealous! because mandy has such a wonderful voice... no one has the power to choose how their voice is gonna sound like! it's HER voice okay! i looove amy, but c'mon, they're two great singers, but totally differents. Too bad that Noctura is an USA band, cause if it was in my country, i would like to promote and help them to get a record contract. Stop judging, and simply enjoy music.
Ok, just want to say I FREAKING LOVE THIS BAND! I looked them up on Amazon, and their album Surrender The Sun doesn't have this song on it, and same with some others I found like Caged. Are these songs just singles they released?
@EVANESCENCEROCKSLIFE WHOA WHOA WHOA way wrong!!! Three ex members of Evanescence formed a new band with Carly Smithson from American Idol as their singer and started a COMPLETELY NEW band named we are the fallen. Amy is still in Evanescence with new members and they are in studio recording a new Evanescence album now. WATF and Evanescence are two seperate bands. Evanescence never died, Amy is still in it. And this chick doesn't sound that much like Amy, similar but not enough to say it IS her.
@ghostcatinmirror They didn't 'copy' as in plagiarizing. It is the same genre. Mandy wrote the song, not Amy or any one affliated with Evanescence. So what if Evanescence inspires her? It's still her music that was created by her. The lyrics are different from Evanescence's. So lets all play nice. If you don't like the music, you don't have to listen. I still love Evanescence and listen to it all the time, yet I love Noctura just as much.
If you just listen quick, it sounds like Amy. But at the begining of this song, u can tell she has a higher voice than Amy does. BUT I LOVE BOTH BANDS SOOO MUCH!
What the?! Have you ever heard about Therion? Investigate before speaking, Therion used choir and orchestral sound way before Within Temptation even existed
@EVANESCENCEROCKSLIFE I meant that I hear similarities :P Other people are like she sounds EXACTLY like Amy Lee, so I said she sounds almost like her. I should've said similar to.
She pretty much sounds like the Soprano version on Amy Lee. Or, maybe she just sounds younger and more fragile and that Amy. Idk. When I first saw this, I thought it was going to be some gay artist trying to sound like her like WIN, but nope. She's good. Good job(:
Some say this group sound like evanescence...for me the concept is same but to sound not, she has pretty voice but not same with amy...maybe technique of singing is almost similar....i simply recognize the different..both both band are awesome...
They haven't done a live show because they only have two members. Duh. Not everybody needs to have an album out or do live shows to be great. Let art be what it is; self expression.
@Reylan84 She doesn't sound like Amy really. She doesn't sing like Amy...and there music isn't even that similar in terms of how it's written. And We Are the Fallen are JUST as much Evanescence as Amy Lee is. I love Amy Lee and admire her work, but she isn't Evanescence really - not the 2003 era.
beast and noone actually has a higher voice than amy lee. she has the 4th largest vocal range in the world buddy boy. keep up on your fanbase. she probably can't hit the notes amy lee can hit but hey i give her her props she's good
![“อ.เบียร์ คนตื่นธรรม” มาตามคำเรียกร้อง แหกศาสตร์ฮวงจุ้ย เตือนสติอย่างมงาย | แฉ 7 พ.ย. 67 [1/3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5fc4S3xBNfc/mqdefault.jpg)
This reminds me SO much of old Evanescence. It sounds like it could be a song off of Origin.
I absolutely love it. 🖤
Noctura, Evanescence and We Are The Fallen are all great bands with similar sounds, each one is equally as great as the other.
2021 and im still here
While we don't mind people bashing us (it happens), we do kinda have a problem with people bashing our fans. *block*
if they broke up such talent gone to waste, who care's if they sound like someone else, Mandy has such an amazing voice
I miss you guys.
I just can't get over how awesome this band is
seriously giving me chills
I am just an old man from a much different world of music and when I like paticular music well, who they sound like has no need to compare. I really like all of Noctura's
music. Their music is DEEP
Mandy and Kris show real talent, this genre needs more from their songbook! Comparisons to other artists is a great compliment I believe!
Please go forth and create. We so need more of this.
this sounds like young fallen era amy lee. Amy's voice has matured and doesn't sound like this anymore. outstanding music though. sad this band didn't get far more traction
When she sings "between the light of day," it sounds exactly like "the pain that grips you" from Understanding.
lol at first i thought "why is my evanescence playlist playing?
amazing voice. something between amy and her sister, who has a weaker but also nice voice.
Love this band... Not only are they excellent at what they do, but they are awesome cool down to earth people. You rock Mandy!
Only found out about this band tonight. Simply amazing!
❤ woah cool song
Wow nice song the singer is so talented, love her voice.
dang shes really good! i love her voice...kinda like a fragile version of amy lee! i love it!
❤️
I love the sound of Noctura and I turn up the radio when their songs come on X103. I don't know why people would be dissin' on y'all...
first time i listen to this song, i put in on repeat until i could get all the lyric...
Just amaaaazing! I instantly loved
The instrumental part reminds me of Imaginary
heard their song dont save me on the radio the other day. loved it. but i like this one even more
Am I the only one that thinks the lead vocals from Noctura, Halestorm, Evanescence, and We are the fallen should do a song together?
@eggEgg23 Actually... Within Temptation was the first band in this genre... Evanescence came after... And then now Noctura is here... It's just the cycle of music... There's a band that starts a genre or sub-genre... There's people who like it... And then there's more bands that go to that genre and give it their own unique taste... Until obviously no one recognizes who the original starter is...
@SubarusXangel No it's not.
The singer is Mandy Suiter.
Amy Lee is under contract to create three albums under the band name Evanescence.
Anywhere But Home and Origin have no been counted because one is a live album and the other is a demo.
Amy still has one more album to go before she is allowed to leave.
good stuff. I'm glad yall hooked up
wtf. When she started singing, I NEARLY thought she said 'The pain that grips you'
OMG :S
Loriiii :D I like her as well.. she has a song called Suffocation which ROCKS!!
@EVANESCENCEROCKSLIFE Anywhere But Home isn't a studio album :P It's a live on tour DVD. An album is a whole album of new songs :) Their albums are Fallen and The Open Door and Anywhere But Home is their DVD.
wow this band is awesome ;)
This is a combination of everything epic with epic sauce on top :)
Wow, this song is so good! It's so cool how her and Amy sound so alike :O
Mandy Suiter
cool....... i like it
Wow! Nice!
@dbananaO its actually a goth font.
d2 has also a simple goth font
I like it because it is thinking music for me
awesome!!!!
sooo true!!!!!!!!!!
Her voice is pretty much the same as Amy's.
However, she has a different vibrato, which is something Amy almost never uses.
Also, her voice might be slightly higher in tone.
I guess we can't avoid the comparisson, but at least they've done something good using the elements Evanescence brought in the modern music era.
All in all, great band! Waiting for the album.
Hope more bands like this turn up in the future.
@eggEgg23 True, but even tho the inspiration was evanescence, they make the music their own, and all three bands are equally as amazing
well done
This is Evanescence!
I agree
@foreverdead1248 that's because amy lee is the lead singer of this band. she left evanescence
@Lucylex1 It's not Amy.
The singer's name is Mandy Suiter
I like her because we havn,t too many famous band like evanescence tajra epika within temptation we are the fallen I want more.
Noctura's debut album is going to be called Surrender the Sun.
@helxig
correct! u are true fan of evanescence, by the way maybe u think it sound like amy lee, for me they have some same technique to control voice that make it sound alike... :) cheer for u and for all
yes, his love is like amy lee, nice song =)
Oh wow. No matter what anyone says, this girls voice is very similar to Amy Lee's in some parts. Its very good though and i may have to look into this band further.
@tlo9879: Great. But... who is Carly Smithson? Noctura's singer is Mandy Suiter. Are you on the right page?
it kind of sounds like the bridge to bring me to life.......towards the end
@adr14ntr Oh the Symphonic-like genre... Less an official genre, and more like a musical style... Using Choir and orchestral sound bytes basically... Within Temptation was the first band to publicly do it, being that Evanescence was private (very few knew they existed) until their first public release of Fallen.
@iamJuicey Okay, I agree they do sound like Evanescence, but you don't need to insult anybody just because they don't think so. Noctura is still an awesome band either way.
oh my god wooow this is impossible i've always thought that amy's voice was so unique
what? shut up!
you know what?
you're all jealous!
because mandy has such a wonderful voice...
no one has the power to choose how their voice is gonna sound like!
it's HER voice okay!
i looove amy, but c'mon, they're two great singers, but totally differents.
Too bad that Noctura is an USA band, cause if it was in my country, i would like to promote and help them to get a record contract.
Stop judging, and simply enjoy music.
I wish next Evanescence would be like this
I wish too...
Ok, just want to say I FREAKING LOVE THIS BAND! I looked them up on Amazon, and their album Surrender The Sun doesn't have this song on it, and same with some others I found like Caged. Are these songs just singles they released?
It's sounds like understanding D: "My love for you still grows" ♪ but a litlle faster ._.
@EVANESCENCEROCKSLIFE WHOA WHOA WHOA way wrong!!! Three ex members of Evanescence formed a new band with Carly Smithson from American Idol as their singer and started a COMPLETELY NEW band named we are the fallen. Amy is still in Evanescence with new members and they are in studio recording a new Evanescence album now. WATF and Evanescence are two seperate bands. Evanescence never died, Amy is still in it. And this chick doesn't sound that much like Amy, similar but not enough to say it IS her.
Love the song, but she sounds nearly identical to Amy.
But that just means she's an amazing singer too :D
Yes, maybe amy lee has the 4th largest vocal range KNOWN... but think of all those people who can sing but aren't famous yet.
Noctura rules!
@ghostcatinmirror
They didn't 'copy' as in plagiarizing. It is the same genre. Mandy wrote the song, not Amy or any one affliated with Evanescence. So what if Evanescence inspires her? It's still her music that was created by her. The lyrics are different from Evanescence's. So lets all play nice. If you don't like the music, you don't have to listen. I still love Evanescence and listen to it all the time, yet I love Noctura just as much.
@Reylan84 No... after listening carefully for a min or so, you can easily tell this aint Amy. She have her own unique voice.
im pretty sure this was her band before evanescence
never mind lmao spoke too soon
I like this song!!!!!!!!!!!!!Very Evanescence-esque
whos WIN stand for
@foreverdead1248 I read somewhere that this is amy singing
does anyone have the lyrics to this??
Amazing song!!
If you just listen quick, it sounds like Amy. But at the begining of this song, u can tell she has a higher voice than Amy does. BUT I LOVE BOTH BANDS SOOO MUCH!
id love to collaborate with you. we would sound great together
WT was the first band in what genre??
where the piano begins it sounds a lot like the Origin version of "Imaginary" (by... evanescence. not hating, just observing)
@meentagranizadaa2
yeah i think same way, they are diff but both r go0d!
What the?! Have you ever heard about Therion? Investigate before speaking, Therion used choir and orchestral sound way before Within Temptation even existed
Someone needs to post a video of this with lyrics! Not Evanescence, but they're great anyway!
please make vidio :P
Hey, who sings? howcome it sounds so alike to Amy lee....it's so evanescence.....O.O...i like it but im confused...
Sounds like Evanescence!! Nevermind, this is really good!
@EVANESCENCEROCKSLIFE I meant that I hear similarities :P Other people are like she sounds EXACTLY like Amy Lee, so I said she sounds almost like her. I should've said similar to.
this looks like a mashup to understanding and imaginary tottaly like evanescence
not bad.
lol at the Diablo 2 Font/
La voz es tan parecida a la de Amy Lee *o*
They sound so much like evanescence... I like them though ♥
She pretty much sounds like the Soprano version on Amy Lee.
Or, maybe she just sounds younger and more fragile and that Amy.
Idk.
When I first saw this, I thought it was going to be some gay artist trying to sound like her like WIN, but nope. She's good.
Good job(:
@lmfaoATyerface2369 LOL!. Each singer has its own style and yes Amy is good as hell.. but wtf? a ranking system?
Some say this group sound like evanescence...for me the concept is same but to sound not, she has pretty voice but not same with amy...maybe technique of singing is almost similar....i simply recognize the different..both both band are awesome...
@iLOVEChihuahuas123 jajaja good coment LOL!
ahh u gotta love off-brand evanescence...xD
Sounds like a mix of We Are The Fallen and Evanescence
Are you amy lee evanescence's siblings?
Wow it sounds a ton like Evanescence
@EVANESCENCEROCKSLIFE Sorry :P Just clearing the air in case someone read that and spread it.
it truly sounds like Amy Lee...
Realmente soa como se fosse a Amy Lee cantando.
A banda é boa, mas precisa de algum diferencial.
They haven't done a live show because they only have two members.
Duh. Not everybody needs to have an album out or do live shows to be great.
Let art be what it is; self expression.
She sounds a lot like Amy
actuly fyi amy lee copyed othe syph power meatl bands its not copying its a genra so no one stoll from anyone.
sorry for the miss spellings
Better than bieber
@Reylan84 She doesn't sound like Amy really. She doesn't sing like Amy...and there music isn't even that similar in terms of how it's written. And We Are the Fallen are JUST as much Evanescence as Amy Lee is. I love Amy Lee and admire her work, but she isn't Evanescence really - not the 2003 era.
beast and noone actually has a higher voice than amy lee. she has the 4th largest vocal range in the world buddy boy. keep up on your fanbase. she probably can't hit the notes amy lee can hit but hey i give her her props she's good