Plants Talk. Can We Understand?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 มิ.ย. 2023
- When plants are experiencing stress, they make noise. Can we understand what they're saying? Scientists at Tel Aviv University built soundproofed acoustic boxes with ultrasonic microphones - and used machine learning to understand what they heard. Like Dr. Doolittle, but for plants!
If you like optimistic science videos, you'll love this video that uncovers the truth about psychedelics: • The Truth About Psyche...
And if you want to support optimistic science and tech content, the best thing you can do is subscribe :)
#shorts #tech #plants #science #technology
“Sir how was your salad”
“We had a good conversation”
Yooooo, the xbox photo
😂
😂😂😂
I remember that one
One time I was on 🍄 and I had a whole conversation with a salad and developed intimate feelings towards the salad. My friend then ate the salad and I began to cry.
That gives a whole new meaning to „Tell it to the trees“
So plants have feelings. Tell that to vegans. 😂
😂😂😂
Speaking trees are common tho' in vietnam during US invasion😂
Just so you know, the sounds aren't a form of communication but instead a by-product of other processes.
The way this was presented seems the same as saying that cracking your fingers is your knuckles trying to talk, even though the sound has no function.
Hahaha wait..is that the saying? Isn't it "tell it to the bees?" If you were being clever and it's gone straight over my head, I am so very sorry. If so, very punny!
Imagine walking home from vacation and hearing your indoor plants say "he's in the Garage, quick hide in the closet"
That's ridiculous. I always let my plants know when and where I'm going on vacation lol
At some point in time, having a conversation with a plant Ain't gonna be strange anymore
"NO NOTE, CAR GONE? YOU COULD HAVE DIED YOU COULD HAVE BEEN SEEN."
“Where have you bean?” 😅
@@Ranma_Saotomebwahahahhahah
Damn…I always forget to water my plants, they’re probably screaming their asses off
Good thing we cant hear them with our ears😂
Nah. In 200 years. They’ll call it abuse and punishable with jail time.
Can you imagine the veggies scream when get to the pot or talk to each other in the salad bowl? Yaks
@@popociciWould they still scream when detached from the main plant?
*plants make sounds*
vegans: sweating profusely
More plants are eaten by farmed animals than we could eat directly so there’s still less plants killed on a vegan diet.
actually no, I think this is astounding :))
Nope
Plants screaming from pain
@@orangentagedon't care that they get stressed and make noise ?
“Hello. My name is Inigo Montomato. You ate my father. Prepare to die”
- a Tomato probably 🙃
😂😂😂😊
probably not a tomato since being eaten is part of their reproduction process
@@jasondads9509 *well who says that they’ve come to terms with it though? Just cause it’s natural doesn’t mean they have to like it or that they don’t want to avenge their parents that have been eaten*
*Getting eaten by predators is natural too, but if I was getting mauled and eaten by a bear I'm sure I'd have a thing or two to say about how utterly displeased I was with the situation😂*
@@Anarkitty420 for some reason i thought that a tomato of a tomato is the actual tomato fruit. If we are talking the tomato plant being the father, that makes makes more sense
My name is tomato Marston. You knew my father
“These… are the cries of the carrots.”
Maynard James Keenan is God.
As an avid and passionate gardener, this video short is especially interesting. I’ve imagined my plants sing as we commune together. It’s a beautiful relationship!🌱🌿💚
"Pass the nutrients bro."
-A starving plant, probably
That's definitely something a potted plant would say. They refer to them as The Groundless.
They should name this tech Lorax, because it speaks for the trees.
The trees gonna be shocked when they hear that someone has been speaking for them.
10/10 idea
but to convince them you would have to make it an acronym
or maybe loraks to avoid issues
@@SpikeyBagel Yeah, I heard from somewhere that Dr. Seuss (or his estates) is a bit lawsuit-happy.
Reminds me of a tales of the unexpected episode!!
My plants listening to me singing as loudly as possible when I'm home alone 👁️🌿👁️
Fu¢k the other comments, this is the most real one lmao.
bro 💀
My plants are probably screaming in pain from my singing lmao
@@BisexualCatWithPizzano wonder mines die so often...
Music helps plants grow so you are helping them lol
Farmer gets a call:
Tomato: hey man, give me a sip
Now what will vegans say plant life matters so we eat soil now😂
This is so cool. Things like this remind me how limited our human experience is. Other organisms can sense and communicate things in ways we could never think of. Reality is so much bigger than our own perception.
"I am the lorax, I speak for the trees"
why they speaking vietnamesse?
"Plants can feel distressed, and pain"
The vegan teacher:" PLANTS DONT FEEL PAIN"
😅
After a while time,we dont also plant(vegetable and fruit))))))
plants dont speak...
vegan teacher: "ok. time for russian roulette."
plants : "no! wait, i will tell you everything..."
vegan teacher: ohh, so cute noises...
plants: *ticks morse code asking for independence and ammendment rights.*
Ok,pls shut up
@@relaxedambience9804 "pls,shut up"this?
That Vegan Teacher punching air rn 💀
She has something to say
@@RMCF22xhello I am jasmine masters and I have something to say
She now hunting air to eat 😂
Most of our crops go to feeding animals for meat consumption so no the vegans would still be better off.
And I'm not even vegan, just logical
I don't think you understood the video.
Plants are truly amazing organisms!
Right? And there are heartless vegans hurting and killing plants for food. Shameless.
@@tcsnowdream9975 people who eat animals consume waaaay more plants.
@@tcsnowdream9975 80% of crops grown for agricultural purposes is fed to the animals you eat.
You know the sound is just air bubbles forming and bursting in the plant's vascular system in a process called cavitation. It's not communication or intentional. It's like burping when you've eaten too much or drank a fizzy drink.
@@veganaktivistenSo? We don't care...as simple as that. We are not going around questioning morality of the people based on their food choices!
I love this - there’s so much about the world we don’t yet understand, and we forget that our ability to see and hear is fairly limited compared to the full spectrums of sound and light.
Nothing cooler than hearing a tree screem for its life as it gets cut down😊
As someone who didn't grow up in a place where woodcutters are a fetish, that's horrifying n sad. If we did hear it, there will be a lot of us who will become like Bishnoi people
@@lemon4087 how are woodcutters a fetish
@@lemon4087what have you been smoking?
Scp worker? Confirmed?
There was story like this by Roald Dahl called "The Sound Machine"
I love being taught the language of tomatoes by Natalie Portman.
Like Natalie Portman and Jennifer Garner put together lol
I thought of Keira Knightley before all of those beautiful women you mentioned. I do not disagree though.
All of these comments are equally accurate 😂
I’m wheezing 😭
A young Julia Roberts has just entered the room
It's important to note that these sounds are simply from the drought popping bubbles in the plants veins. So this is not evidence of plants being sentient, it's a basic physical reaction more akin to the bubbles in your fizzy drink popping.
Never let the truth get in the way of a good joke.
I sincerely hope that is true.
I'm vegan and thought I was doing no harm and was having a melt down until I read your comment.
Thank you for reassuring me. My anxiety attack has no dissipated.
Phew !!
@@silver-fd3cvYou’re still doing harm. It’s impossible for anyone to live without causing some level of harm. Even if plants are sentient, more of them are grown to feed livestock animals anyway, so there would be no reason to have a meltdown if we discovered plants are sentient.
I love how she not only tells us about cool stuff, but she also explains why it matters and the effects it could have!
PETA’s about to lose their mind
BWAHAHHAHA
I thought the same thing. 😂
They're gonna eat rocks and mud from now on.
More plants are eaten by farmed animals than we could eat directly so there’s still less plants killed on a vegan diet.
@@vgreens22a living creature that reacts to paint pain doesn't feel it... got it 👍
I mean, it makes sense that if you have cellulose-based cell walls, there would be tiny sounds produced when your cells begin to shrink due to fluid loss & conservation efforts by the plants. They also shut down photosynthesis when the conditions aren't right, like in full sun. Things make sounds. Cellulose amplifies sound (think wood instruments, but super duper tiny).
Yeah, I'm sure a piece of fire wood drying in the sun also makes tiny sounds.
yeah whats weird is my glass screamed when i dropped it the other day, before it shattered, i guess it was in pain
@Ali80076 It was warning the other glassware in the vicinity upon facing death- what a champ !
Indeed.
But it’s still nice to get absolute confirmation.
What I’m interested in is how plants react to sounds.
Being half deaf all my life. You most definitely can feel sounds without hearing them.
Or take an extreme example like being at a convert, by the stereo, you’ll feel the bassZ
I assume everyone feels sounds like I do. But they’re just less accustomed to it.
After getting into gardening, figuring out for some plants I grew inside I needed to use a fan to help thicken and strengthen them.
I just wonder if the physical aspect of sound dies anything for cellular growth, or reaction.
I mean. We know for humans physical touch from another person sends our brains to go crazy. Infants regularly die from lack of positive physical interaction, even if they’re fed and medicated.
Also. It’s wild how far humanity has come. As most anytime in human history, if you went around claiming plants made sounds, you’d be called crazy, potentially burned or executed.
Plants most definitely communicate, make decisions and react. Not in the same way humans do.
But from Venus flytraps being able to “count” and have a “short term memory” of 15-30 seconds.
( the same tooth has to be touched 3 times inside a window for it to close.)
I have to imagine getting a concrete understanding, and adapting how we think may help understand more.
By plants making decisions, I mean if you have a vine, if you water only one side, or you water near it, it’ll reach towards that direction over time.
Similarly, if you keep untangling it, and trimming certain parts over the course of years you won’t have to keep trimming those same spots, or untangling it.
Or say, if you have one plant that needs a lot of sunlight and others not so much.
One will stay under the one that needs the sun consistently. Without you needing to interact too much.
The crazy part about this, is that when you plant these together like this, it’s incredibly uncommon for them to actually strangle each other to death.
So I am using the terms “learning”, “ making decisions” incredibly loosely.
With the confirmation that we can grow some plants in moon soil, it’s pretty exciting to see where Botany is going to go.
If people start doing experiments like - Trying to grow something in a vacuum, that you put pure oxygen and other gases into.
( to try to simulate Mars/Stations)
Bonsai is the most fascinating. As, you can intentionally keep trees and plants insanely small that still can bare regular sized fruit.
But the crazy part is, that if you remove their restraints, and start giving them the normal amount of water & nutrients.
A Bonsai that’s been small for decades will grow to its full size.
Meaning again, for space exploration/multi planetary development.
Bonsai will be highly effective I imagine.
Seeds are just too inconsistent, as are sprouts.
Where as Bonsai, even if the tree if left alone is supposed to be 15-45ft. But you keep it at 1-5. It’s so much more stable, and there’s just not much of a risk.
I went on a crazy ass rant, got pretty off topic.
This video just got me thinking again.
Apologies!
The tomatoes sounds like it is typing on an apple keyboard on an iPhone while the volume is turned up 😂
That reminds me of the story "The Sound Machine" by Roald Dahl. It enumerates the idea of making such a machine which can hear the sounds made by plants. You can go for it, it's good. 😊
Dude I was reminded of the same story!
"The Secret Life of Plants"
Sir Jagadish Chandra Bose
finally someone quoting the legend.
Jagadish
@@sayakmaity4106 thank you, for the correct spelling😎☕
Ye i was why is saying that scientist recently found while Bise showed it much earlier
is a book?
Peta: Starve, my children.
@@USA_UNITED1776 are you high? They do feel emotion the same way. Every animal we eat does. Saying they don't have a purpose is just like saying you and me don't. They're all in a delicate balance that keeps everything from collapsing. We didn't choose the animals we eat bc they "have no emotion." Which they do btw. We chose them because they're easy to farm, and yield high rewards. Now i have no problem with me eating them, but i won't deny that they have emotion and have just as much of a purpose as you and me. Also multiple studies have shows that plants show some sort of conscience, can hear, and respond accordingly to how they are physically and verbally treated. They also show hints of emotion.
@@USA_UNITED1776 That just seems like a convenient list of the animals it's not socially acceptable to eat in english speaking countries. I'm sure if you met a cow or a pig or a chicken and got to know them you'd find them just as complex and emotive as any dog. Cows have cow friends, they bond with their children and cry out when they're taken away, they play, they're curious and friendly.
@@skylark6167 I literally live on a farm with cows, chickens, and pigs. One of our calfs got trampled to death by its mother, cows are dumb animals that understand nothing. Also I dont live in an english speaking country, I live in Italy. Also I've literally seen chickens eat their chicks, and one of our pigs snuck in to our cellar and ate some pig carcass. They're idiots, evil, and non sentient creatures, and I will continue to eat them, and so will the entire glorious nation of Italy, GLORIA A ITALIA!
@@skylark6167 cows cry out when their kids are taken away, yes, that doesnt make them sentient. That's an instinctive reaction, their bond with their kids is purely instinctive and for survival purposes, and the kids dont have that bond, read my response to gaymeister.
@@USA_UNITED1776 Is this coming from a religious perspective perchance? Because that's not the conclusion of a majority of biologists, zoologists, philosophers and lawyers.
I love your channel! When I was a little girl I looked at trees and wondered how do they do that? At 61, I still look at trees and wonder how they do all that. The more I learn the more I am in awe of what they can do.
"If trees could scream, would we still be so cavalier about cutting them down? We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason!" - Jack Handy, _Deep Thoughts_
Perfect Logic... I can't stand people who never shut up.. 🤣
No good reason.. that we can discern.
LOL most animals scream yet we butcher them by the trillions each year.
Depp Thoughts was one of my favourite SNL skits during that time period, for me that cast was the best with hilarious writing
@@discursionexactly. People suddenly grow a conscience when it's about plants and they can diss vegans for that
Finally, someone can hear my screams…
I love how she doesn’t personify them like everyone else “plants are screaming” vs plants make noises and they are different if they need water 😂
Objective observation is so appreciated
Tel Aviv uni is so much more different and diverse than any other university. As an Israeli who has been there, this is wild.
Acacia trees in some areas of Africa send out a chemical signal when being eaten, especially by elephants. The plants nearby and downwind increase a bitter chemical in their leaves to become more unpalatable.
Not just unpalatable, they can become poisonous
Source?
not just acacia plants. there are others.
@@arazatliyev6564google?
@@arazatliyev6564Africa.
If I remember correctly, the smell of a freshly mowed lawn is the equivalent of grass screaming for help
So yeah this makes sense
That's probably why they made lawn mowers so loud so we couldn't hear it😅 jk
@@mandielou so we couldn't hear the smell?
@@roywempor8395 ................................the screaming..............................................................................................................................................................................................
It's a simple chemical reaction. A plant is not conscious in any way and has no ability to feel or experience anything at all, unlike humans and other animals.
J.D. Bose a famous indian biologist already kinda proved that plants feel pain or other stimuli. And in revent times its been seen that trees help each other during stress times. And now this. It just shows how complicated the biology is
Ive seen this before in an old doco years back. It touched on frequencuee in nature and how they non human world communicate with one another and also when happy, sad etc.
I need some experiemental artist to sample these soundsNOW😭
We need an entire arca album where each song samples a different plant
@@cvntyextraterrestrial333 i would no joke sell a kidney to hear that actually happen, and it better contain a collab with Aphex Twin
The salad remix album
Veggie Tales remix.
@@bodyofhope😂😂😂
I watched a video on how plants and trees do this and the guy was like, "So are they talking? Or are they just forcing air through their stems to produce noise?"
It's like... That's literally how we talk though lol.
Sure, but when we talk it's a deliberate decision made by an *extremely* complex central nervous system. Plants don't have a nervous system of any kind, and there's no evidence that plants are capable of anything more than simple chemical responses to external stimuli.
The question should be is it “intentional” or is it just a side effect of less water changing acoustics? Like no shit a different makeup will sound differently.
@@therealdrag0 Idk how you'd propose to measure intentionality but the point of my comment was that he was trying to delineate, when his alternative to talking is just a description of how we talk, and that's amusing.
I read that as “planets” and got very excited
I love plants I always talk to them give them high fives and hugs❤
We had a story named 'sound machine' in 11th standard and it was about a scientist making a machine that could hear the pain plants had when they are cut,i guess we are near achieving it...man science is wild
Glad I'm not the only one remembering this story. It's by Roald Dahl, published in 1949!
I’m fine. I’m a Level 5 Vegan. I don’t eat anything that casts a shadow.
So you eat light?
@@regicideinaction2839no dude he eats people's souls
Great 👍 in a month there will be one less of you
👍🤣🤣🤣🤣@@regicideinaction2839
@@TheByrd nailed it.
I read an article about plants communicating with each other & responding to the environment & stimuli in the ‘80’s. I’m glad that there’s continued research that’s ongoing because it’s really interesting.
Great. Plants scream in pain and stress. That’s so comforting.
Vegans:
Peta’s gonna be livid if they see this
Now "plants communicate" might be true, but "plants are capable of suffering" is wholly unscientific. There's widespread support for the idea that mammals and birds (at a minimum) have a subjective experience of the world, same as you or I. Plants however do not, they are no more capable of emotion or experience than your phone, "crying out" for a charger.
@@skylark6167ok
@skylark6167 So just because we don't understand, that means it doesn't exist!
I mean, we learn every day more and more about the complexity of the natural world.
Plants communicate with each other! They "talk" about their environment, and have vast networks of communication, aided by fungi- an entire different kingdom of creatures!
With all this that we don't know, you sound bananas to try and say "only animals that are like me feel, everything else is illegitimate ".
@@sarar.1932Plants don't have nervous systems or brains. All of this 'communication' is automatic local chemical responses to external stimuli, we have found literally nothing that suggests that plants have consciousness of any kind.
Claiming that plants feel pain just to dunk on vegans is very silly.
@@skylark6167 isn't that line of thought is the very reason alien invasion is such a wild topic? plan still feel pain the way lobster or crab does. not like our pain.
It’s the equivalent to our stomach growling.
Amazing analogy!
It’s like in A Wind in the Door when Calvin talks about a science project he did
Things make sounds as their physical structure shifts. I don't find this surprising at all. It's great that we are beginning to understand this, but not surprising.
But is that what the study said, though? Are the sounds signal or are the sounds signs?
@@tannerhuxtable6118neither. I dislike how this information was presented. The sounds aren't a form of communication. The sounds are a byproduct of the structure and functions of the plant changing.
It's like pretending that cracking your neck means that your neck is trying to communicate with you by speaking to you in neck-cracking sounds.
@@RedstonerD you're describing signal. All signs are communicated through or interpreted from signal.
@@RedstonerD Well I mean, it was a study. They had a control group so see if being cut/eaten/dehydrated actually made the plants make more sound. This short doesn’t exactly say whether or not they did, or whether or not the sound was a because of plant growth or plants’ responses to external forces. So yeah the information in this short wasn’t that great.
10 years later: Plants might be able to build spears and hunt elk more efficiently than humans.
There was an interesting experiment made in the 1960s demonstrating that if you pinch a tomato and pinch a person they both have the same needle reaction on an electronic sensor.
I have known this since I was a kid. That plant are able to respond to stimuli. Even if some one was to do them harm, a plants reaction was detected through a lie detector machine attached to it.
as a vegan,i was left speechless
What are you gonna do now??? Plants can talk, when you pick a fruit or vegetable, they make sound, will you stop eating them????😂😂😂😂😂
@@cherryblossomsandwisteria855 im just kidding. im a vegiterian ....i eat egg everyday
@@unknown_person_777 It's good for your health 👍🏻
I eat meat once a week
@@cherryblossomsandwisteria855your flexatarin then. People who eat pretty much like a vegetarian but have meat a couple times a week
This is awesome. Imagine watering your crops because they asked for it 😮
Farmers know how much to water their crops and sprinkler systems water all the plants the same amount at the same time, so nah this will never happen.
@@dikhed1983 Nah. Farmer which I know only water if someone from his workers tell him that plants need water or when dirt is like stone also he has so many leaks, because of damaged water hoses.
So either he could buy some humidity/water sensors or something like this, also plants often have many many varieties, and they are often very different, so those sound would make it way easier.
@@MAST My parents have sprinkler systems in the greenhouses (which are set to a timer) and the fields, and they are a small business so I think your friend's case is pretty unusual.
Also, it's easier to just water the plants every day at the same time (and have different systems for different plant varieties) than listen to a monitor that says the plants are "distressed". That kind of thing would require really expensive equipment also, while a sprinkler system and forethought is bare minimum.
@@dikhed1983 It's depend on how big greenhouses and fields are, the farmer I talk about have 1 greenshouses field and 2 normal fields of strawberries and 1 field of grain, 1 pears, 2-4 apples.
He has manual water system, so you know lazy etc. also many of them damaged and he didn't even noticed water on ground path between strawberries instead of where plants are etc.
If you have a small business or u just plant for yourself, then maybe you have time and money, but when it became medium business and moving fields digging, puting/removing pipes, hoes, plastic foil, straw, things break, things take time etc.
Probably businesses like 5+ fields same plant would be employing experts and would invest in water system etc.
And then maybe newer businesses or run by young farmers.
Water me plant daddy i’m thirsty 💦
The elephant in the room:
You
Are
Gorgeous.
And
Intelligent.
Which makes it a pleasure to listen.
Thank you for putting your talents into science's service.
I'm an Indigenous American from Arizona from the Hopi tribe. We've been practicing dry farming for over +1000 years and in our cultural practices, our fathers and uncles teach us that when you go down to the fields you have to talk and sing to your crops. The outside world laughs at us, but we learned that it encourages them to grow without rain because we dont believe in irrigating our fields we rely solely on rain to water our fields. Hopis live in a very dry desert with little rain, and no lakes around for miles, so we developed a religion that heavily relies on moisture & singing to your corn. We're taught to sing to our crops as if a mother is singing to her newborn baby. We're taught to treat them with respect and care for them as we would our own children so that way they will grow & help feed us to keep our people going. So I'm glad to see that we're not just crazy hippies & that we were right haha
That tomato is spitting! Someone get them a record deal asap
I love studies like these! It helps prove what some cultures already know. Plants are living creatures that react and communicate. Some studies have shown they can react in a way that resembles fear when they have been purposefully injured.
Scientist Mr.Bose was first person to prove that plants communicate and has feelings. His invention has helped wireless communication
Ironically vegetarians believe eating plants is killing free.
I bet I know exactly what that student was doing when they thought "Hey, you know, I wonder if plants can, like... *talk*?"
This is the most amazing thing I’ve seen and heard. It proves plants feel stress and pain. Amazing
No. It proves they respond to external and internal stimuli. Not that they "feel" pain.
@@corytinsley You could make the same argument about humans too.
@@honewhetstone1732 Not at all. Pain has a definition. You know that right?
@@corytinsley Stress due to dehydration or cutting of stems or other harm inflicted to the plant causes a reaction that can be recorded. What separates that from harm or injury to humans that classifies as pain? You can be in pain and not react, the ability to react doesn’t define pain.
@@honewhetstone1732 You literally proved my point with your last sentence. "the ability to react doesn’t define pain.". But earlier you claimed them reacting was proof they felt pain. So you really are just that stupid. Also, what separated it is the feeling of discomfort caused by that harm or injury. We feel pain because our brain detects something is wrong and tells us it hurts. Plants would need a similar mechanism that you would need to prove exists. And proof isn't, "see plant move, duurrrr. plant make sound".
this could make a pretty straightforward plant chat script to a tweet - eg I'm thirsty, or im growing. etc..
Indian scientist J C Bose sir had already proved that plants have feelings ❤
How do vegetarians can still eat plants
There was a scientist that used a lie detector to monitor things and plants would basically scream when damaged randomly, but showed no problem when told what was about to happen. This is why I like to thank them for their sacrifice and that I'm grateful that they are going to nourish me. I don't currently grow food, but when I do, I plan on doing this practice then. I'm vegetarian and I don't see this the same way as eating animals.
us plant parents are gonna have a mental breakdown when we now know our plants literally cry and make a fuss when we don't water them
It's not 'talking' it's growing, or shrinking. It's the sound of cell division, with the pops being when it reaches a full nodule size, so the structure shifts, like tectonic plates.
I thought about that too but she said that the scientists, that most likely did think about this too, have control plants, that arent stressed or need water or whatever. So if plants would just naturally make these sounds all the time just by growing, the control plants would do it even more than the others, because they have enough water and everything they need
@@melinaalba63 It's precisely because of that, that it's inaudible. When you harm a plant, or make it suffer, by drying it out, or overwatering it, or cutting it, bending it, breaking off branches... What you get, is a rapid response as compared to the more gradual movement you'd otherwise see. Like tectonic plates, they dont cause a tsunami every second, instead, it only happens when there's large, sudden change. Like when a plant has to spew out juices to seal off a broken stem, or redistribute moisture to preserve it's life during a dry spell. These movements happen far more rapidly and as a result, it's a more granular movement. Granularity can be heard as pops. All life operates in different frames of time, for instance, a lifetime for a human vs the lifetime of a cat or dog. So too, do these things, when it needs to respond quick, or to unforeseen events, it's respond of die for the plant, that rapid movement takes them from their more gradual timeframe into 1 that we can measure with our equipment. If one were to strap a child to a table in a comatose state and feed them via a drip, you'd be able to hear bones grow too, if you were listening in the right timeframe. We hear between 20 and 20kHz, these noises from the plants are over the span of weeks, which means 1/1000th of a Hz.
But that’s the thing, it kind of is “talking” because plants sometimes send these vibrations/sometimes releasing chemicals and other plants react to them accordingly (like increasing bitterness in their leaves when an animal starts chewing on one plant to make themselves gross to eat)
They also share water when young plants aren’t getting enough water or nutrients
Plants really are fascinating
@@ianvisser7899 @gloop7458 Especially if other plants respond I feel like it can be seen as a Form of communication. Maybe the sounds only come from the plant helping itself and I don't think it is possible to say any final thing about this because we need to research that way more still, but just a while ago I have also read that plants "hear" (or sense the waves sounds make) and can grow towards water for example. So obviously there seems to be way more to plants than we thought and just the possibility of them Perhaps communicating in some way seems really interesting. And it seems like the scientists working on this aren't entirely sure if its really only growing sounds, because if they thought that they wouldn't research it and noone would pay for it. So I get that your explanation is a possible one but I just don't think that the scientists wouldn't have factored that in.
The QUOTE is
“BEING IN TUNED TO YOUR SURROUNDING “
Everything Above,Upon ,Below
Has a connection we as adults a lot of times loose that connection. ❤
Didn't know tomato was chill like that yo!
If this could be further explored we might be able reach on the path of having our own “groot”!!
predictive maintenance using sound for plants! that is wild
Tomato was probably clappin ass and we're like... "Wooow, listen to this"
Plant: "Save me from this miserable lifeee"
Farmer: "You got it"
Suddenly the vegetarian community is questioning their existence
Plants are also sentient beings. Vegans are sweaty.
@@cyrilleleb.8563 They aren't tho
@@cyrilleleb.8563 no they're not. did you dropout of high school?
@@Manvir. And you can't even press play on this video. Did you drop out of kindergarten?
@@cyrilleleb.8563 do you know what sentience means? plants don't have nervous systems so they don't feel pain like humans and animals. they are not conscious; I could say the same about you. go back to middle school. hating on vegans doesn't make you a good or cool person even though it makes you feel like it.
Yeah I love listening to my food before I eat it!
Wow, this is amazing. Both in terms of how fascinating it is that plants can ""talk"", and in terms of how useful that will probably be in farming, imagine if a plant can literally tell you what it needs
I was already afraid of plants and this add so much more to it
Bruh
ah, in my country :) making all of us really proud :)
Roald Dahl was a bit ahead of his time with the Sound Machine
Searching for such comment...
isc kids💪
Plant: “Listen Linda listen…”
Birds doing that dawn chorus help plants do their morning routine. I’m sketchy about the detail, but that’s a thing.
Finally, the answer to "if a tree falls and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?"
I guess the soccer parents aren't the only ones screaming at the game-
I don’t get it
Love the “we have so much left to learn” comments at the end of these videos it’s the proper perspective to have to new discovery, it’s optimistic and realistic to look beyond the horizon instead of just congratulating science for having arrived at a new destination which is how discoveries are usually presented, Carl Sagan would be proud!
FINALLY THE TREES SCREAM!!!
YO THIS TOMATO GOT BEATS FR 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🎙🎙
the tomato plant fr experiencing American school ambiance
This has been known for years, we have the technology to capture it finally.
that tomato plant sounds like atlanta at night
Roald Dahl proudly looking at us from heaven
I was searching for such a comment
Keep seeing you on the FYP! Love to hear these tech stories!
Plants can communicate! That lovely scent of Fresh Cut Grass is the sound of grass screaming a warning to nearby grass to draw their nutrients down into the roots.
Vegan teacher “plants don’t feel pain🗣️”
People proving her wrong💯
That Vegan Teacher better watch out, now she can’t be saying plants don’t feel nothing and can’t speak 👁️U👁️ ✨🌱
Vegan: “BUT ITS NOT FLUFFY AND CUTE SO IT DOES NOT COUNT!”
Your channel is excellent! Positive and informative and entertaining...
I am from India and in our culture we worship plants and trees.
I really think you should learn about an Indian scientist named Jagadish Chandra Bose.
Lot of cultures worship plants and trees. Well they are just living beings like rest of us. Not divine
The kind of tech I need to keep my house plants alive 😭
THE TREE IS SCREAMING!!!!!!!!!!
-dr [REDACTED]