Part 2 of the Talk with J. Sai Deepak| India, Bharat and Pakistan
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- In Part 2 of our discussion with J. Sai Deepak we talk about the reforms by Raja Ram Mohan Roy. The Interactions between Hinduism, Islam and Christianity, how they operate as belief systems and where exactly lie in the problems and solutions? Also we ask him about his views on Uniform Civil code and why J. Sai Deepak opposes it? The idea of Pakistan, it's origins.All this and much more with India's Best Selling Author. The link for Episode 1 of this topic ⬇️
• In Conversation with J...
#jsaideepak #india #indiathisweek
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @indiathisweekbyamanak...
I actually cried listening to the facts, almost felt like I was cheated about my history, J Sai Deepak Sir Thank you so much.
Yes we were cheated Monica,
Absolutely .. 👍 but sadly Hindus have not learned anything .. we r doing the same mistakes
Along with Sai Deepak, I want to specially praise Aamna and Khalid for showing and continuing the courage that have and are able to put forward. Such wholesome discussions and respecting each other's views are the true ethos of Bharat 🙏🙏
What makes Amna smile in between. Especially where she should very hurt.
was going to comment the same!!!
@@the_0_man absolutely….spot On…both are asking pertinent questions and elicit reply from JSD ….another brilliant guy…
34:25 - you are standing out because you are outstanding- you both are micro-minority of Muslim community- Amazing Words Sai - you amaze me with your intelligence every time .
whats the third person name Khalid said ?
I didn't get the name :(
@@hrishichauhan2813
Zeba Zoariah.
She is a legend.
@@Michaelvarghesee : REALLY ? WHATS SO LEGENDARY ABOUT HER NOW EXACTLY !??😑😒
@@rexxbailey2764
If you have ever followed her Research work which she had published in two-three forums with respect to subjects like Semiconductors and Green Energy ,one would admit that she has an amazing intellect.
@@Michaelvarghesee baap re kya legend hai Nobel puruskar to mila hi hoga. 🤣
Fucking brilliant episode... The hosts and the guest both were blunt and honest. They didn't pamper each other out of courtesy. We need this type of free and open discussion.
Taj Mahal banane k baad hath kaat diye 😂 Deepak Sai is product of WhatsApp university
@@bharatkapoor4062 "The story about Shah Jehan ordering the amputation of 40,000 hands has entered folklore. Even though no contemporary account confirms this incident, the fact that it is still widely believed is proof of the unchecked power wielded by the Mughals, as well as by other monarchs of that period. The Taj took some two decades to complete at the cost of a fortune. But obviously, emperors were not held to account, and even if the legend of 40,000 hands chopped off had been true, nobody could have questioned Shah Jehan" - said Irfan Husain, a Pakistani, writing in the Pakistani newspaper, 'Dawn'.
@@kalapipaasi5977 that particular story is usually taken to describe the inestimable beauty of the Taj, rather than just the brutality of the muslims; the latter was etched in stone for most Hindus prior to Gandhi's whitewashing. The story was also probably code speech for the likelihood that muslims stole the Taj (in sharia, the hands of the thief are chopped off).
Pakistanis/converts usually don't realize how ridiculous they look when they identify with invaders who brutally persecuted their ancestors. It is not Hindus who are the losers" - they defended themselves valiantly and maintained their culture.
@@bharatkapoor4062 OK then post your sources to disprove. You can't accuse someone of being incorrect, put a laughing emoji and think people will believe you over an accomplished lawyer and academic. Your name is unfortunate for two reasons- your surname which shows you're a Punjabi Hindu and your first name which is of course the name for our land. Both don't suit you based on the immaturity with which you tried to refute the claim, lackluster really.
@@panjabipandit Punjabi hu ya dalit hu kya farak padta h desh ka sar garv se tb ucha hota h jb modi bolta h ladki ki safety aur jail se repist ko reles krta h
My parents worship gram devta and kul devta but I did not know the context, Thank you for explaining this,,
I wish I could articulate my thoughts as well as JS Deepak sir does. Man is a national treasure
Sai is blunt, no holds barred. Aamna and Khalid are courageous and gracious to hear him out. Bravo, great podcast
What a exciting conversation to wake up to! Each conversation with Sai is an intense education season.
Taj Mahal banane k baad hath kaat diye 😂 Deepak Sai is product of WhatsApp university
@@bharatkapoor4062 He's a graduate of IIT KGP
@@rawadosa90210 to kya WhatsApp university bolega
@@bharatkapoor4062 I'm just wondering which college you went to if you can insult one of the best universities of India. But anyway, judging on your troll-like activity on this video, I feel it's pointless to engage in any conversation with you.
@@rawadosa90210 haath ktwa diye they check kr WhatsApp university wali harkte h uski
Thank God Sai Deepak made the meaning of आस्तिक and नास्तिक clear. Most people use these words as synonyms for "theist" and "atheist". The correct words for "theist" and "atheist" are सेश्वर and अनीश्वर
Timestamp please
@@jellalfernandes1309 21:49 "If you subscribe to the āstika philosophy, तो वेदों को final माना जाएगा"
Correct antonym for सेश्वर is निरीश्वर.
@@हर्षवान् oh yes! स - with; निः - without. अनिश्वर would mean non-god. Thank you for the correction.
0:38
Amazing Point Amana 👌🙏🔥.
I can totally relate to this .
This is what people like me and many others faced
( Like many of my Indo Abrahamic best friends, Eurocentric Hindu Atheists/Agnostics) who had no clue about the Historiography of Bharath,the Theology,World View etc..thanks to the Macaulyean Education system.
I had to dedicate 9 months to learn the Hindu Civilizational literature and boy it was an amazing Revelationary Journey....
🙏 🇮🇳✨
She merely blamed Hindus…yeah agree it was a groundbreaking comment 🙄
I think this hindu victimhood is stupid. Fix problems in hinduism and get out if this stupid victimhood mentality.
@@musicworship4520
Is it wrong to blame Society regardless of their Religious Identities?
Watch Kushal Mehra's The Charvaka Podcast wherein he clearly explains the Root Cause of these issues.
If you don't have the balls to handle Postive healthy Criticism,you will never know the exact source of the problem.
Hindu Society in India needs to
Re-develop the same Intellectual Kshatriya,Shathrubodham and the Geopolitical Knowledge to understand the Onslaught befalling in Bharath and implement the Vishnu Guptha Chanakya's Arthashasthra's policy.
They will have to teach the next generation to not be Woke and fall into the Westphalia's Abrahamic narratives .
@@musicworship4520 : LOLS 😆😆😂😂😂😂
Truth missiles🚀🚀🚀
Excellent straight forward answers
My brain got electrocuted
Thank you Aamna and Khalid
Thank you J .Sai ..my mentor🙏🙏🙏
Taj Mahal banane k baad hath kaat diye 😂 Deepak Sai is product of WhatsApp university
@@bharatkapoor4062 go no further than read your Sharia or Fatwa ee alamgiri to find proof.if that’s WA university material. End of story.
“Satyamev Jayate” 🙏
J sai Deepak sir is just a marvelous
Speaker with such a vast knowledge.
LOL, ITS NOT VAST, ITS OBVIOUS KNOWLEDGE WHICH WAS ALREADY PRESENT IN FRONT OF EVERYONE WHICH YOU OBVIOUSLY DIDN'T CARE TO SEE NOR CARE NOW DID YOU ? 😑
Great conversation, great because two Muslims patiently listening to the point of view of a Hindu without yelling at him😊. Reading the second book of Sai on kindle, so far it's quite good.
That's because there's mutual respect. J Sai Deepak can even carry a conversation with people who don't respect him like Owaisi and Tharoor. It's because he's a secure Hindu. He knows what he knows and isn't swayed by who yells at him and tries to divert his attention and tell him he's wrong. That's what we all need to strive for. Get educated on dharma, get educated on what the history of our people has been and how both the Islamic and Christian coloniser has worked to destroy us and only then can you carry a conversation with someone with as much grace and intelligence as seen here. It also takes a proper upbringing to be able to listen to someone who speaks against your faith or at the very least brings out certain truths against Islam and as a Muslim being raised with class and intelligence to patiently listen and then formulate a response. That's another skill lacking in this country as evidenced by any Indian news channel possible that hosts debates.
I like the fact that sai is straightforward about his position(s) and is not afraid to voice his views....this is how conversations should be structured ...I hope he is back on the show to have more conversations with both Khalid amd Amana.
He’s taken “satyamev jatate” to heart. Imagine if only 5% Hs were that serious about it. It’d change the world.
I came here because it is J Sai Deepak - who impresses as usual.
Would like to commend Aamna and Khalid for their attitude and efforts regarding some of the sensitive issues.
I learn so much today about umbrella of Hindu Darma and application on the Hindus ,
You are genius Sai .
Best wishes.
I can listen to J Sai Deepak for the whole day. He is so scintillating. Plus lots of respect for both the hosts, its not easy to listen to Sai's direct answers
Amazing discussion. Really liked the questions Khalid and Aamna asked. They all helped in setting the tone and direction of the dialogue
I wish everyone reads Dr. SL Bhairappa's epoch 'Aavarana'. This novel has been translated into Hindi too and tells the story of impact of muslims rule on hindus.
Best of Luck Sai, for your second book. Much needed. Well done guys for a great conversation 😉
Jai Sai 🙏 you are sent by our Paramatma I believe 🙏 ❤️ I stand by you and have the same feeling 🕉
Because j Sai deepak sir know almost all the traditions and is a practitioner he could explain it so simply and nicely than others.
Even if it is harsh, the ideas of Deepak are eventually gonna be good and safe for Moderate Muslims who love this nation and its civilization.
its a misnomer dude. plz there is no such thing as moderate muslims. they will become muslims eventually.
Salutations to J SAI DEEPAK. Aptly describe Hinduism and concept of Dharma. God bless.
Sai is a master ⚔️
Always a pleasure to soak in his teachings, so clear & precise!
Huge admiration and appreciation to Ammna and Khalid.....question and answers were tough, conversation mind opening.
This is called intellectual.hats of to j Sai Deepak
Amazing, Sai does not mince his words or feelings .Wish we all Hindus become so vocal or least unite behind him.
i congratulate all the three panelist . truth discussed realistically as it is in ground reality. God bless you guys .jai Hind
Maza aa gaya....i can listen this conversation whole day....
J Sai Deepak is Straightforward and blunt.
19:09.... the five groups of Vishwakarma, Ironsmith, coppersmith, goldsmith, carpenter and shilpi undergo upnayan ceremony and wear the janeu.
J Sai you are circulating energy in this lifeless society. amina and khalid you are two beautiful people, wish our minorities were like you.. 🌹
J Sai Deepak is so eloquent and intelligent. He is a great orator with immense clarity of thought. I wish more people listened to him.
A fantastic discourse Mr Sai Deepak. As a consequence of your discussion with Mr. Khalid Baig and Amina Begum (both parts) I am today placing an order for both your books ( India, Bharat & Pakistan) with Amazon. Bravo, indeed.
Brilliant session ! when you start scrolling down the comments , You automatically notice the religion of the viewers . Khaled and Aamna have not been able to interest viewers from their own community ! Best of luck to them in changing that
how many even Hindus watch this? how many Hindus even support ex-muxlim movement? I respect Amna and khalid but they will never be able to convince Ixlamist as ixlam need more time to reform so we should support ex-muxlim movement.
Exactly.
Thanks you both for having Sai here for us. Sai rocks
It takes a lot of open mind and guts to have such an open discussion. Hats off to both the hosts and guest.
Brilliant discussion
Absolutely brilliant , Sai Deepak.
First , please accept my congratulations.
To the point , my worry was , who would tell the world what my thinking for my motherland , my cultural roots , and here you are echoing my thoughts for myself , my family , my community and my country.
I pray that your National pride spreads like fire .
And yes , I am in possession of "" India that is Bharat""
There is so much clarity in what you say Sai . Every conversation teaches something new. Thank you so much 🙏
It's always a great pleasure listening to J Sai Deepak. His thought process is very clear and inspiring. Thank you Sai ji.
Absolutely marvellous conversation ❤❤
Thanks
Would love to see Rajiv Malhotra interviewed by Khalid and Amina.
Excellent suggestion. Also Sanjay Dixit.
That's what I see when constitution says freedom of speech and expression. Kudos to the both of the hosts, you have may outmost respect🙏🙏🙏🙏
Very good podcast, it did clear alot of concepts👏
Really good to see moderate muslims... World will become much better place with these kind of muslims.
dude, moderate muslims is a misnomer. they all will become jihadi once in majority
Both sessions Part 1& Part 2 have been excellent, deep thoughts, meaningful questions and powerful replies by Sai Ji. Great salute to the organisers and both panelists for contributing to very healthy discussion.
some divine force is working through sai deepak
This is my first time on ur channel and the video was recommended to me by TH-cam because it is featuring JSD and it's an absolute pleasure to hear him on any day but the way the conversation has happened both of u were also very graceful and should be praised for.I'm a subscriber now.
Amazing conversation 👌 all of you 👏👏👏
In crude language..... yeh sabki waat laga deta hai... i am elder in age but i bow to you as you are inspiring people logically ...
I agree with J. Sai Deepak on points of accommodation, Dharma and Bharat. Need open discussion of Amana and J. Sai Deepak on UCC please.
Wonderful discussion!
Very relevant questions and excellent knowledge based responses.
Pp: Ms. Aamna seems so enamoured by Sai's discourse. 🙂
Best conversation in this channel till now.
Mr Sai u r great ... we needed u so much to articulate our thoughts so well.
21:14
This is how below Dharmathva Panth / Sampraday branched out independantly and yet is connected to Hindu Dharshanas :-
1) Sikhi
2) Buddha
3) Jaina
4) Mimansa
5) Charvaka
6) Nirvana Sanhemisee
(Nagaland + Mizo + Arunachali region )
Yes yes saare indian culture ka part hai 😍😊☺️🙂❤️🥰💪😘
@@mayankindian3750
No doubt from me.
But there is a big Left Wing Majority in India who won't accept or read books.
Kyuki 8-9 mahina lagthae ye sab read karne ke liye.
Kaun ithna Mehnath karega? 😆
@@Michaelvarghesee wo isliye kyuki India jyadatar ussr or left liberals so called ki goad me tha abhi tak jab tk aapne economic liberalisation nahi kiya tha or India ne jyadatar me bolunga islamic extremism or left wing extremism jhela hai maowad ke roop me ☺️😊 isliye hamare yha ke jo leftist hai they aren't rational they are also dogmatic they are not rarional people ☺️😊🥰 because ronald reagan ne bola tha democracies ko nuksan leftist hi karenge aage jaake 😊☺️
Here for sai. I love his clearity of thought and crisp oratory skills. No one can come near his skills. Wonderful intellect !
Wow this is a great discussion
One of the best episodes
Very brave of Amna and Khalid to host JSD.
This is a new avatar of Sai, so calm and gentle and conveying the essence with light.
Amana and Khalid, you both were amazing hosts, keep it up! JSD as usual was brilliant. Overall, loved the episode!
Great discussion.
Sai's explanation of Dharma is very beautiful.
Dharma is righteousness in action. So true!
Thanks Khalid and Amana for inviting Sai... Undoubtedly he a master orator with ferocious knowledge and logic...but hats off to your guts and gallantry to host him and allow such a candid discussion...well done guys and thus i subscribed...
19:10 exactly exactly... I'm from Bihar and I totally agree!!
Very good questions
heartfelt appreciation to Amina and Khalid, for their initiative. Sai deepak for his unwieldy expression. Superb. Best wishes and blessings to all the three panelists. Jai Hind. Jai Bharath.
Lovely discussion..JSD is brilliant as usual. Kudos to Aamna and Khalid for asking brilliant questions and bring this discussion for all Indians to think and ponder and decide their future.
salute for the hosts. 🙏
साई जी ने हमेसा की तरह हर प्रश्न का सटीक जवाब दिया 🙏 जब भी साई जी को सुनो ज्ञान और जिज्ञासा के नए द्वार खुल जाते है ।
This episode made me hooked, i learnt a lot.
Thank-you Amna and khalid
What an episode of great dialog and right wordings. One may not agree to each other's view point but can leave understanding the other's perspective and broaden one's horizon.
In these times of TRP journalism, this really stands out due to the host and the guest.
Great going and thanks for bringing it up!!
Thank you Amina and Khalid 🙏🏼🙏🏼
Thank u Sai . More strength and power to u , wishing good thinks in the future.
Sai Deepak is too good !!
🇮🇳 Bhārat --- her's is a history of profoundness and 'unprecedented but redressable' adversity .
Thanks a lot Amana ji and Khalid 🙏
This was a wonderful discussion.Respectvfor all three in the discussion.The Muslim brother n sister in this discussion have been wonderful n patient listener.They must know that we want peace n respect n understanding.Sai has been at best very straight forward most people shy off.Better to be honest not intending to put down anyone else.
Wonderful podcast and excellent questions raised and tackled by amana and khalid 👏
Thank you for this podcast. Very excited and happy to see J Sai Deepak being interviewed by this channel. I resonate with with this ending thought we need to continue having a civil dialogue followed by action and learn to coexist.
great discussion j Deepak sai sir
At the time of birth of Sai Deepak, There was a Mania going around South of India - Shirdi Sai and many children were named after Sai. Sai became the name of children in many households. Then came Satya Sai. Even now, many households in South of India name their children with Sai in it. This mania happened with Sharukh's - Rahul name in a smaller scale. Every new generation in Hinduism comes and washes away the old rigidity and morphs the customs and practices more in sync with current generations needs. This happened in Christianity but it doesn't happen in Islam and that is the problem.
Brilliant,brilliant!
Sorry to say this Amina, I found you as a host moving casually around the house and the phone shaking all the time while the guest was speaking was very unprofessiona and distracting while such a gem of a conversation was taking place. I hope you take this feedback of mine positively. I love your podcast, please keep up the good work.
Even the other host went on hold for sometime which is why the profile picture popped up. Well, they still remain muslims and carry Arabic names after atleast partially knowing what their origin is. This much civility itself is unexpected.
Taj Mahal banane k baad hath kaat diye 😂 Deepak Sai is product of WhatsApp university
@@anitha6249 you are just casting aspersions and judging them wrong and assuming you are an admirer of sai deepak I am sure he wont agree with you. Both of them are wonderful people, you should realise what it takes for people who are born as Muslims to actually do what these two are doing!
@@aravindurstruly One can either be a human or the follower of 'peaceful' religion. Prove otherwise and I shall change my opinion. Sai Deepak is a crystal clear man, although a practical man. He knows what is what.
@@bharatkapoor4062 Tu whatsapp university ka student hai.
Itni choti baat tuzhe bata nahi thi
Sai Deepak is brutally honest and does not beat about the bush.
You both are a great listener, learning the art of listening from you guys... Wish we had millions of muslims like you wish they were majority from muslim community..
i like this sai deepak
This is one of the underrated channel I have came across👍🏻
Very well explained Sai Deepak 👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏
Thank you, Amana and Khalid.
Jai shree ram... great episode
Sai is just Awesome
Listening sai is Divine 🙏🙏
Excellent! Excellent! Excellent!
Fuck.. shit.. I am sorry for the language but awesome discussion.. loved it to the core.. thanks Amana n Khalid for such a open discussion.. thanks J Sai Deepak.. total respect for all 3 of you..THANKS
JSD🔥
I am from West Bengal here Muslim population already crossed 35%. If in next 30 years it reaches 45% then another Kashmir like situation on the card.
bengali elite is obsessed with hindu-muslim unity culture.
Both part of video was good with compelling insights. 🙏🙏
J Sai Deepak sir ❣
Sai Sir, thanks so much for giving voice to the feelings of so...many hindus😭🙏🏽🌺who have these deep inner feelings but are not able to articulate it the way you are chiseling it without doubt🙏🏽💗🙏🏽 yes we need our places of worship all 40,000( 27th minute)🙏🏽
Thanks you for this, only if there were more conversations like this. Blunt, uncomfortable yet necessary and brilliant